Postscript: Reflecting on MethodYouth Ministry as Practical Theology
KENDA CREASY DEAN
If Christianity be not altogether restless eschatology, there remains in it no relationship whatever with Christ.
KARL BARTH
f course, I was expecting a children's movie. Like countless other families who lined tip for Pixar's 2009 animated feature Up, Kevin and I had brought our children (okay, they were sixteen and twenty-one, but still), and armed with popcorn, the four of its settled in for another feel-good Pixaradventure.
If you've seen Up, you know what happened next. Ten minutes in, we were blowing our noses into our butter-stained napkins, weeping for balloon-man Carl as his beloved Ellie slips from the surly bonds of earth. In mere moments, we had witnessed their long and happy marriage's simple joys and bitter disappointments. Suddenly we shared Carl's desperation, anticipating life without Ellie. We hated those smarmy developers who wanted to bulldoze his hone. Our hearts sank when anxiety seized Carl and he whacked a construction worker with his cane. We seethed at the injustice of the court ruling, and despised the laughable aides sent from the Shady Oaks Retirement Village to fetch him. But above all, we ached for Carl's remorse about never taking Ellie to South America, a promise that he forgot to keep until it was too late. At the movie's ten-minute mark, regret weighs heavily on Carl. "Now what do I do, Ellie?" he sadly asks, leafing through her childhood scrapbook. He can feel-we can feel-his past, his identity, slipping away.
Then he gets an idea.
Spoiler alert: Carl does go to South America, escaping his pursuers by ascending into the heavens-thanks to thousands of helium balloons that lift his house, and his spirits, sky-high. Like all fairy tales, Up takes place in a secondary, enchanted universe. Dogs talk and children befriend exotic birds and an old man pulls his past behind him in the form of a floating house. Yet J. R. R. Tolkieu insisted that fantasy stories must tell the truth.' Because fantasy stories take place in a universe where latent human anxieties are given concrete shapes, these anxieties can be symbolically confronted and conquered. We do children no favors, child therapist Bruno Bettelheim famously argued, by domesticating the evil characters in fairy tales, since confronting and vanquishing evil is necessary to a child's sense of mastery in the world.2
THE GOSPEL AS A TRUE STORY
Tolkieu maintained that "myths were the best way of conveying truths which would otherwise be inexpressible."3 Picking up on this theme, Frederick Buechner insists that fairy tales teach us to enter the strange, alternate universe of the gospel on its own terns, so that the death-confounding truth of Christ can reach through the story into our anxious world.' Like fairy tales, the gospel communicates truth-beyond-words. The gospel is so universal, so profound, so vital for addressing the deep-seated anxieties of being human, that it defies easy explanation. Yet this does not make it untrue; on the contrary, the deepest truths we know-love, grace, forgiveness, redemption-do not "make sense" by human standards. Love goes beyond all reason, grace goes further than justice, forgiveness willingly suffers for another, resurrection turns death into life. Taken together, these mysteries ground Christian hope. They are signs of the future God has created us for; they point to what the kingdom of God is likes-which means that if we preachers tell God's story without its counterintuitive, eschatological promises, we do not tell the truth.
And therein lies the problem. In a church increasingly concerned with self-preservation, telling the truth gets harder and harder to do. Eschatology-the study of God's ultimate purposes for humankind-functions as the church's doctrine of hope, but it gets less attention in most churches than Flag Day, save for obligatory references to heaven at funerals.6 The link between Christian eschatology and hope is all but forgotten, mostly because (1) we avoid the subject altogether, (2) we dehydrate eschatology to mean God's judgment on the last days (which inevitably winds up looking hopeful for some, and decidedly less hopeful for others), or (3) we convert Christian hope into optimism or cheap cheeriness (making the church look preposterously far removed from real human pain). And no one is more likely to "call us out" on these exclusionary, cheesy interpretations of the gospel than the teenagers, who are the first to accuse Christians of being out-of-touch with the real world because our heads are up in the clouds.
THE PROBLEM WITH LOOKING UP: ASCENSION DEFICIT DISORDER
Anxious people, uncertain about their futures, have always scanned the skies for hope, expecting to find answers in the heavens. Sailors navigated by the stars; wise men interpreted the alignment of the planets; ancient people worshiped the sun. Even among contemporary Christians, the answer always seems to be "up":
"Lord, I lift your name on
"God will raise you up on eagle's wings ..."
"When I fall down, he lifts inc up ..."
"We will meet him in the air, and then we will be like him ..."
"Everybody's gonna have a wonderful time up there, glory hallelujah ..."
We are not the first anxious culture in history, of course. In the days and weeks following the resurrection, Jesus taught the disciples about the kingdom of God, promised them the power of the Holy Spirit and commissioned them to be his witnesses to the ends of the earth. All the disciples could say in response was, Are we there yet? "Lord, is this the time when you will restore the kingdom to Israel?" they asked (Acts 1:6). Lord, does the kingdom of God lean you are finally going to give us what we've been waiting for? Is this the time when all our faithfulness and hard work finally pays off? Is this the time we finally get the church we want? Lord, are we there yet?
Jesus parries: no, and yes. The future belongs to God, but in the nieantinie, there is work to be done; God's good news is for all people, but not everyone knows that God's reign has begun to unfold-that "the kingdom of God is at hand." This is where the church conies in:
It is not for you to know the times or periods that the Father has set by his own authority. But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you; and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, in all Judea and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth. (Acts 1:7-8)
And with that, Jesus "was lifted up, and a cloud took him out of their sight" as the disciples stood there gaping, gazing up at the heavens, watching him go. Suddenly two men in white robes appeared, and reminded them to stop gawking and trust the future Christ had promised them: "Men of Galilee, why do you stand looking up toward heaven? This Jesus, who has been taken up from you into heaven, will come in the same way as you saw him go into heaved" (Acts 1:11). In other words, "You already know what the future holds. So you can stop worrying, and concentrate on the here and now."
File this under troublesome texts for contemporary Christians. To the ancient Greeks, Jesus' ascent into the clouds would have confirmed his lordship over creation-but to us, it reads more like the floaty exit of Glinda, the good witch in The Wizard of Oz. Throughout the centuries, artists have playfully depicted Acts 1:1-11 by portraying the disciples watching Jesus' feet disappear into a cloud. No wonder twenty-firstcentury churches suffer from what we might call ascension deficit disorder' (A.D.D.), a tendency to act as though the future God has promised in Jesus Christ is a fairy tale, which shrivels our ability to practice hope. When we don't believe that Christ's promise to secure the future is true, we live as people fearful for our own prospects, protecting ourselves instead of allowing the Holy Spirit to use us as Christ's witnesses. A.D.D. is the reason churches get distracted so easily from the work Jesus commissioned us for: to be his witnesses throughout the earth. Instead, we are stymied and stressed, straining to make sense of the future's cloudy uncertainty. Like Carl (and like the disciples in Acts) we feel lost and alone, missing the implications of the angels' words: Christ is separated from us, but he is not finished with us yet.
If ascension deficit disorder stunts the church's ability to practice hope, maybe the cure lies in developing an eschatological imagination: the ability to envision the counterintuitive world God intends, and to live into the fact that this world has already started to unfold. Commenting on the "dystopia"-the sense that things are not as they should be-of global culture, British theologian Ann Morisy says pointedly: "Christians confronted by dystopian perspectives can no longer just proclaim or assert the persistence of hope; rather, if confidence in hope is to grow, then hope has to be demonstrated."8 Churches with eschatological imaginations do not merely cling to hope; they enact it, because the kingdom of God is not just up ahead. The kingdom of God is at hand.
ESCHATOLOGY: THE CHURCH'S ANSWER TO ANXIETY
Nothing rattles a bunch of postmodern, educated, rational Christians quite like talking about the ascension of Jesus. A good deal of our dazed posture toward the ascension story comes from our mainstream allergy to eschatology; surely this isn't a story we are meant to take seriously? Yet eschatology is the church's answer to anxiety, and it is one of Christianity's most practical doctrines. Our vision for the future affects our present choices far more directly than, say, asking "What would Jesus do?" Take the Celts, for example: their vivid sense of God's presence in everyday life gave Christianity "a less imperial feel" than many of its counterparts, which partly accounts for Celtic Christianity's appeal to postmodern young people.9 The Celts constantly celebrated the interwoven relationship between heaven and earth; indeed, believing that the world is perforated by "thin places"-sites where heaven and earth comingle-Celts viewed their future with God as woven into their daily life on earth.'°
It's safe to say that most American youth lack the Celts' pragmatic eschatology. Mention "future with God" to most of them, and the afterlife pops up-a subject youth find too distant to be relevant, and the rest of its would just rather avoid. Belief in heaven is growing among Americans (tip almost 10 percent from a decade ago, to 81 percent), while the number of hellbelievers has remained fairly steady (around 70 percent)." More than four out of five (85 percent) think they'll go to heaven. 12 And yet, while the majority of young people believe in an afterlife, few consider it "a life-driver," according to sociologist Christian Smith. In general, young people's religious beliefs amount to abstract agreements, not priorities they organize their lives around, or that guide them as they set their life's goals.13
Our reluctance to claim a significant role for eschatology in mainstream Christianity is also due to our persistent misunderstandings about what it is. Eschatology is neither a way to predict the future nor a doctrine about heaven and hell. Rather, eschatology simply means that we know how the story ends-God wins. And because God has bound Godself to humanity in Jesus Christ, if God wins, we will too. Knowing the "end of the story" therefore funds Christian hope, and it profoundly affects the way we live now. If we no longer need to worry about the future, we can let go of our survival anxiety. This allows us to live life as it unfolds, one play at a time, without worrying about the score or about running out of time.
Let's try this analogy. Remember the last time you TiVoed a football game and accidentally found out the final score before you had a chance to watch it? Knowing the final score (for better or worse) drains the suspense from the game-suspense that makes gladiator sports entertaining. But if knowing the score in advance makes for boring viewing, it also makes for lower blood pressure and better human relations. When we know how the game ends, we don't sweat the individual plays, even the ones we lose. Life is no longer a gladiator sport. We can approach our teammates and our opponents as who they really are, not just as the positions they play. And we can relax a little, since we know a fumble will not cost us our futures. In a similar way, a sturdy eschatology makes the Christian community an "unanxious presence" in the world because we are not obsessed with life's final score. Instead of functioning as a spiritual weathervane, eschatology enables its to read the "signs of our times" in light of an ending God has already written.
ANXIETY IN AMERICAN TEENAGERS: A BARRIER TO CHRISTIAN MATURITY
Unfortunately, young people absorb most of their anxiety from us-and ill an era of economic recession, things are likely to get worse before they get better. Youth tend to deal with anxiety the way they deal with many of the traits they get from their parents: through denial. Yet denying the anxiety of the surrounding culture may not prepare them to function ill it.14 With marriage and parenthood receding farther into the future, the first few years after college are often given to "funemployment"-voluntary, transitional jobs that one can easily quit in favor of something else that is more entertaining.`5 However, with unprecedented high expectations for both salary and fulfillment, disdain for work that does not suit their personal needs or lifestyle, and a looming, extended period of national joblessness, American eighteen-year-olds to twentysomethings, according to economist Heidi Shierholz, need to brace themselves for "a big national experiment on stress." 16
Hope offers an important cushion in stressful circumstances, and its prevalence in religious teenagers is one reason the National Study of Youth and Religion concluded that highly devoted young people are "doing much better" in life, on any number of variables, than their peers. 17 Research consistently finds dramatic differences in the levels of hope expressed by highly devoted teenagers compared to their peers." But even Christian teenagers often have a very simplistic grasp of what hope means, and few relate it to Christian teaching. Take, for example, these hopeful statements gleaned from Christian teenagers in the National Study of Youth and Religion (2004):
"The future's gonna be great, I know it!"
"I just know God won't let me down."
"I hope that there's something after [death].... That's pretty much all. I just hope it's okay, that I don't have to go to hell."
It is unlikely that such simplistic views of hope can be sustained until graduation, much less through a lifetime.
What makes Christian hope different from facile optimism and cheerful determination is its ability to stare down anxiety, the sublimated fear of our own demise. If Christ has secured our future, then this anxiety is superfluous-but in an eschatologically challenged church, anxiety often gets the upper hand. In 1586, the Carmelite priest John of the Cross penned the church's most famous manual on spiritual anxiety, The Dark Night of the Soul. But the roots of Christian anxiety reach back for centuries; remember, even in Acts, the disciples fretted over Israel's survival: "Lord, is this the time when you will restore the kingdom to Israel?" (Acts 1:6). We hear ourselves in their concern: Lord, is this the time you're going to fix the church, and make it powerful again, the way it was back when the old pastor was here? Back when 150 teenagers showed up for youth group every week? Back when people cared about church? Back when the people who came to church were like me?
One of the most frequent themes in the Hebrew and Christian scriptures is the anxiety of the people of God, and with it God's repeated efforts to quell this anxiety. Angels appear, and their first words are "Fear not." Jesus urges his followers not to worry, to take their cues from the lilies of the field (Mt 6:28). Again and again Israel is encouraged to step back and wait upon the Lord. In the ascension text, two Ines (we assume them to be angels) admonish the disciples to stop looking for Jesus in the clouds and assure them of his return.
Today we know that anxiety works against hope for social and biological reasons as well. New York Times columnist Kate Zernike dubbed the young people coming of age during the "Great Recession" of 2008-2009 as Generation OMG ("OhMyGod!" for the uninitiated). Zernike cites sociologist Glen Elder's 1974 study, "Children of the Great Depression," in order to compare Generation OMG with those who grew up between 1929 and 1931. In Elder's study, both older (ten and older) and younger (ages two to nine) children internalized adults' anxiety, but the effects of this anxiety differed. Older youth, who had developed a capacity for formal reasoning but were not yet saddled with adult responsibilities, translated their anxiety into resourcefulness. They learned how to survive, make do and solve problems; they grew into resilient adults who were extremely family-centered. However, younger children did not fare as well. Their need for parental care and attention coincided with the worst years of the Depression. They reniember feeling bewildered and alone as children, and lacked confidence and direction through high school and beyond.19
The verdict is out on whether the "Great Recession" will last long enough to evoke similar responses among today's adolescents (my money is on "no"). But what we do know is that, at any level, the brain's wiring makes its more self-centered when we feel threatened. As Ann Morisy writes, In the anxious atmosphere of dismal times, generosity of spirit shrinks and the primitive inclination to pursue self-interest increasingly dominates."20 During the Depression, adversity caused people to pamper teenagers less and depend on them more, which gave youth confidence in their ability to overcome hardship. Today's teenagers, however (with the exception of the very poor), have been protected from real responsibility, and are the products of highly structured childhoods. As a cohort, they act more like the young children in Elder's studies of the Great Depression, dependent on external structures to the point that they grow anxious without them.
In fact, despite their reputation as a generation quick to volunteer and support community causes, research shows that millennial youth actually seldom do either one." Are they an insensitive generation, or has the survival switch been activated in their brains? When we are concerned about survival, we do not think about our neighbors, our communities or important issues in the world. We do not think about Christ, or why he matters. In anxious times, the caretaking hormone, oxytocin, kicks in, motivating its to circle the wagons to protect our own. Our sense of entitlement (or selfishness, if you prefer) goes into overdrive, not because we are greedy but because we are scared, which winds tip influencing our spirituality as well as our savings accounts. In anxious times we cannot take risks, so we cannot grow, which makes spiritual maturity-in fact, any form of maturitydifficult to come by. We cling to what we know, because our entire organism is focused on self-preservation.
ANXIETY IN AMERICAN CHURCHES: A BARRIER TO CHRISTIAN HOPE
Here is the interesting part: systems, also, grow anxious-which means churches can show the same symptoms as individuals. Most American churches are trapped in a rhetoric of decline, and each loss seems to threaten our existence. This is the kind of scenario that sends our brains into survival mode. The creative, problem-solving parts of our brains step aside, so our reflexes take over. Take, for instance, churches' responses to the growing research that identifies emerging adults-young people between the ages of eighteen and thirty-as the least religious cohort in America, and strikingly absent from congregations. Sociologist Robert Wuthnow argues that churches (and American institutions in general) have abandoned this age group, who must consequently make the most important decisions of their lives-decisions with long-lasting consequences about love, work and ideology-without the benefit of traditions or elders to guide them.22 Living apart from their families, schools, churches and other established structures for community, emerging adults are left to guide one another as best they can.
When institutions are preoccupied with survival, they can scarcely think about nurturing the next generation. Ephibephobia-the fear of teenagers-sets in. Rhonda van Dyke Colby, dean of religious life at Shenandoah University, has employed Murray Bowen's classic theory of anxiety to analyze millennial young people, but she might as well be talking about churches.23 In a state of heightened anxiety, Bowen says, we can't access our entire brains. Our reptilian, survival brain takes over, and instinctively we choose to fight, flee, freeze or protect. The good thing about the reptilian brain is that it is quick-but this speed comes at the expense of the thinking brain's accuracy and compassion.24 When survival is at stake, there is no time for deliberation or empathy.
Carry this logic over to anxious churches. In anxious churches, our survival skills are on high alert. If your congregation is in survival mode, people are thinking of ways to fight, flee, freeze or protect. They have difficulty reflecting and thinking critically. They lose the ability to perceive humor or paradox. With the exception of protecting their own children, they can't think creatively about young people or newcomers, or anyone else who is not currently part of the congregational system. Those others are intruders, and the church needs to conserve their energy to survive.
Yet young people are notoriously slow to abandon hope. In fact, the age group least likely to develop a generalized anxiety disorder are those between the ages of fifteen and twenty-four.25 Young people tend to view hope as an ethic, an action as well as an attitude, which serves as a powerful antidote to dystopia. In 2007, Jonathan Reed, a twenty-year-old film studies major at Georgia State University, won second place (and a place in YouTube history) in the American Association of Retired People's "U@50" video competition, in which filmmakers under thirty are invited to describe their lives at age fifty. His video, in which a palindromic poem (a poem that can be read backward or forward) scrolls onscreen, is a manifesto of youthful hope. To date it has received nearly fifteen million hits on YouTube and has inspired dozens of imitations. For the full effect, watch the film version,26 but here are the words:
Lost Generation
by Jonathan Reed
HOMESTEAD ACRES: AN ESCHATOLOGICAL NEIGHBORHOOD
This is the kind of eschatological imagination that enabled saints like St. Francis and Clare, and leaders like Martin Luther and Martin Luther King, to learn to imagine the world as God intended it, and to lean into this vision as it began to unfold. But it's an imagination anyone can develop, even if we are not saints or reformers. I grew tip in an intentional conlnlunity-but the surprising thing is that I was forty years old before I knew that. (In Ohio, if you are tip to any good, the worst thing you can do is tell people about it. That might look like bragging, and in the Midwest, bragging conies pretty close to being a mortal sin.) As a result, I had no idea that my neighborhood was any different than any other neighborhood in town. I obviously knew that the Mitchells next door were African American, and that two doors down lived the Lees, and that there were some mixed-race families on the block. It was a fact of life in our neighborhood that people were forever borrowing tools from one another, plowing each other's driveways, mowing each other's lawns. I thought this was how neighborhoods worked.
What my parents never told my sister or inc was that Homestead Acres was established in the 1960s by a handful of people who had committed to living together as an interracial community. It wasn't until my dad diedand my mom moved because she remarried a guy down the street-that I learned that the tools in our garage did not all belong to its. Most of the tools and the tractors in Homestead Acres were communally owned. When I read an article in the paper celebrating the fortieth anniversary of the Homestead Acres "experiment," I suddenly realized why so many people in our neighborhood had built their own homes, and why we had a community pond for fishing and swimming. I had assumed that my neighbors built their homes because they were thrifty, and because they were gifted craftsmen and women. I thought we fished and swam in a pond because it was wholesome entertainment. The reality was that, in the 1960s, many contractors refused to build in Homestead Acres because of its interracial stance, and in some parts of the country, pools remained closed to blacks.
In retrospect, I wish my parents had mentioned some of this along the way. On the other hand, if they had, would growing up in Homestead Acres have seemed as natural, as non-anxious? The people of Homestead Acres (many of whole were churchgoing Christians) simply lived as though the reign of God were already unfolding on earth-and if not everywhere on earth, then at least in one tiny corner of Delaware, Ohio.
BECOMING A YOUTHFUL CHURCH
Without attention to the ascension, our imagination as a church grows small and hard. The kingdom of God becomes a platitude instead of a concrete hope we are called to enact. Yet Christians "are called not just to have hope but to perform or enact hope, here and now."27 Eschatology does not predict the future; it frees its from anxiety about the future, because in Christ, the future is secure. Christ has removed our human time limits by binding our future to his, freeing its to worry less and laugh more. We can stop looking up, and start looking around. As Studs Terkel, the American oral historian, put it, "Hope has never trickled down. It has always sprung up."28
This is where youth itself becomes instructive. Theologian Jurgen Moltmann points out that what makes us "young" is not our age. What makes youth youth is its wide-open sense of possibility, the confidence that death is not on the horizon, the exhilarating assumption that the future is wide open and filled with limitless potential. For Christians, this sense of wideopen possibility, the confidence that death poses no threat, that the future is a gift-this is Christ's promise to all Christians, not just the young ones. In other words, everyone whose future is bound to Jesus Christ is a youth. In Jesus Christ, the church is inherently youthful-because in Jesus Christ, we are unfettered by death. We are apostles of possibility, with a wide-open future in God. We are participants in the kingdom of God, world without end, not just someday, but now. In Moltmann's words, "It is not that the future belongs to the young.... The future makes us you11g."29
Moltmann describes how, in August 2002, Pope John Paul II-eightytwo years old, ill and in great pain-visited his hometown of Cracow. He was greeted by cheers of "You are young! You are young!" The pope smiled and denied it, but the crowd was right.30 For Christians, what makes its young is not age, but hope:
LOOKING UP: MINISTRY'S OCCUPATIONAL HAZARD
The eschatological message of Pixar is that things are looking "Up." It is true that the image of "looking up" is a powerful one in Scripture as well; as the psalmist sings, "I lift up my eyes to the hills-from where will my help come? My help comes from the LORD, who made heaven and earth" (Ps 121:1-2). But straining to see God's future can never be a permanent posture for Christians. Before long, we begin to feel a crick in the neck. It is easy to convince ourselves that, if we just look hard enough, pray hard enough, stay true enough, some answer from heaven will appear-maybe in the form of a new volunteer, maybe in the form of a pastor, maybe in the form of a youth minister. If we just persevere long enough, though, God will send somebody from on high to fix things down here.
But if that were all there were to the gospel, we would be a stiff-necked people. It is understandable that the disciples became anxious at the ascension, when the Jesus they had gotten used to disappeared from sight. And it is understandable that our churches, in a world where God's involvement is often hidden from our sight, and at a time when all we can see of the future is fog, become anxious too. Yet the ascension story reminds its to stop fretting about what lies ahead, and to live as though what Jesus promised is true: the kingdom of God is not up there. The kingdom of God is at hand.
ADVENT: LIVING LIKE PREGNANT PEOPLE
We serve an anxious church, in an anxious culture, that cultivates anxious teenagers, and if we marinate in this anxiety long enough, we become anxious church leaders too. But what if we stopped feeding the beast? What if we began to live as people who believe what we preach-that Jesus is Lord, that his life, death and resurrection binds our futures with his, and that the kingdom of God is at hand? What if our job is not to convince young people that Jesus wins, but to live as though he already has? What if the church were less of an ad agency for Jesus and more a community that embodies the world as God intends it to be? What if youth ministry were a laboratory for developing eschatological imaginations-a place for imagining and embodying God's intentions for the world?
The Christian community has a model for developing such an imagination in an unlikely place: Advent. Some theologians are disillusioned with Advent, put off by the season's cheesy optimism marketed by advertisers through outlets like Hallmark and Hasbro. Yet Advent is a season of hope, and is well-suited for nurturing Christian eschatology. In fact, a case can be made that twenty-first-century Christians are living in one prolonged season of Advent; Advent is the season the contemporary church is in.
Why? Because Advent is a season of pregnancy-a season of expectation, of course, but also a season of waiting, and anxiety, and pain, and risk. New life is coming, but it's not here yet, and our job is to get ready. There is no cheap hope in pregnancy. You can't pass it off as though it doesn't change you, or as if suffering isn't involved. Moreover, with great hope conies the risk of great disappointment, for new life is fragile. It often struggles, and sometimes it emerges in ways we don't expect, or wouldn't wish for. But in new life there is also joy, and as Pau1 reminded the Thessalonians, joy in the church is a sign of the Lord's coming: "For what is our hope or joy or crown of boasting before our Lord Jesus at his coming? Is it not you?" (1 Thess 2:19).
Advent helps its reframe the anxiety facing the contemporary American church. Yes, our numbers are declining. Yes, our forms are shifting. Yes, Christian communities continue to hemorrhage their youth. Yes, our leadership is in crisis. All of this is true. But what if decline is not a bad thing? What if decline may save the church? If, as a church, we have veered into anxious self-centeredness or therapeutic individualism, maybe what we're seeing in our current ecclesial condition is a market correction. Contractions may not be bad; in fact, contractions are necessary to new birth. What's more, when we feel these contractions, we know that new life is on the way.31
Youth ministers can be midwives for such a time as this. Our ministries serve as signs of God's wide-open future, enacted by young people simply because they are young. If the church has involuntarily entered a new season of Advent, then evoking an eschatological imagination in the faith community is necessary. The church must learn to live like people who are "expecting." We must learn to live like pregnant people. That means several things:
1. Wait. The most obvious thing you do when you're pregnant is wait. As Advent people, we wait, and while we wait, we nourish the vision for the kingdom of God that Christ has planted in us.
Waiting is not doing nothing. During this period of waiting, we are bathing this embryo of new life, this church about to be reborn, in prenatal care. We must tend our own souls so that the Word of God has good soil to grow in. Prenatal care doesn't always feel holy or beautiful; sometimes the vitamins are hard to swallow, and the ultrasound gel is squishy and gross. But just because we cannot see Jesus at work during this incubation period does not mean that he is not multiplying life within us. So we keep hope alive, even when God is invisible to us. We remember the rabbi in Auschwitz who, day in and day out, wailed at God's absence in the death camps. Yet every Friday at sundown, the wailing stopped. The rabbi would say: "Now we must light the candles. It is time to pray."
2. Name our anxieties. New life is scary. There be dragons here-dragons of doubt, disillusionment, uncertainty. So it is even more important that we tell the story of Christ during Advent, mostly because we need to hear it ourselves, as do the young people in our care. As Jacques Ellul put it, we do not need a theology of hope. We need hope.32
Naming our ecclesial anxieties also means telling the Christian story without rationalizing it or apologizing for it, and certainly without shying away from the parts that bother its. Christian history is filled with advice for addressing the dragons of spiritual anxiety, but none of it advises avoiding them. In 1738, a young John Wesley, already an Anglican priest but in the throes of spiritual doubt, asked his friend, Moravian leader Peter Bohler, whether he should cease preaching, given the depth of his anxiety. "By no means," Bohler said. "But what can I preach?" agonized Wesley-to which Bohler famously replied: "Preach faith till you have it, and then because you have it you will preach faith."33 In the face of anxiety, we're to tell the Christian story anyway, until we believe it.
3. Paint the nursery. Eventually, pregnant people must make room for the new life that is coming, and must brace themselves for the way this new life impinges on their existing reality. In other words, we have to paint the nursery. At some point, the new life Christ promises us must stop being an intellectual possibility and start being an actualized one. We must start enacting God's hope in the world, even if there are times, maybe many, when we will be disappointed, and when we will disappoint ourselves.
A lot of people go into youth ministry-and I count myself among them-partly because we love teenagers, and partly because youth ministry is one of the few places we see real hope for ecclesial change. People who work with teenagers are an irrationally hopeful breed, and because youth ministry serves as the "research and development" arm of the church, it is a place that both generates and test-drives new forms of church life in today's culture. The questions youth ministers wrestle with today will very soon be questions the entire church must answer-questions like:
• What does relational ministry look like in a world of ubiquitous connection?
• What is the difference between "pastoring" someone and "friending" them?
• What makes small, face-to-face Christian communities matter, when teenagers are already networked online with thousands of friends who already share their most intimate hopes, dreams and fears?
• Can the church offer a richer slice of reality than a virtual one, a taste of COlllnlunion beyond Communlty?34
When the church does start asking these kinds of questions, the go-to people in the Christian community will be those who work with teenagers.
IMAGINEERING THE KINGDOM OF GOD: LESSONS FROM IMPROV EVERYWHERE
There are many metaphors that describe the role of the youth minister in a pregnant church. We are ecclesial lab technicians, vocational "test rats," maybe even pastoral "crash dummies"-pick your image-as we learn, trial-and-error, to represent Christ in a world that young people will not let its avoid. Perhaps a more apt description comes from Disney: youth ministers serve as the Christian community's "imagineers." It is our job, to the best of our ability, to imagine the world the way God imagines it. It is our job, to the best of our ability, to treat young people as the people God made them to be instead of as the people they have become. It is our job, to the best of our ability, to live alongside young people as though we believe what we preach-as though the kingdom of God, strange as it sounds, really is at hand.
This is why it is not enough for Christians to have hope; we must enact hope, in every corner of the earth, in every crevice of human life. Pope Benedict XIV makes the case eloquently:
The Christian message was not only "informative" but "performative." That means: The Gospel is not merely a communication of things that can be known-it is one that makes things happen and is life-changing. The dark door of time, of the future, has been thrown open. The one who has hope lives differently; the one who hopes has been granted the gift of a new life."
In truth, what drove this point home for me was not a church, but a group of young adults whose sole purpose is to give people, in their words, "the story of a lifetime." Improv Everywhere is a New York-based improvisation troupe that invites ordinary people into "missions" that enact a reality that does not yet exist-until the actors insert a small but noticeable change into a present situation.36 One of their most famous stunts involved two hundred "agents" (volunteers) who entered Grand Central Station and simultaneously "froze" on cue. For schedule-crazed New Yorkers, the stunt was a humorous, disorienting masterpiece. After a few moments the agents "unfroze" and everyone went about business as usual.
I became acquainted with Improv Everywhere by accident. A friend sent Inc a YouTube clip of a free wedding reception, thrown for a random couple as they exited a courthouse ill New York City.37 "Do you want a free wedding reception?" a man, dressed for church, asked the couple-and the bride said, "Sure." The man escorted the couple to a park across the street where a tent was waiting with bridesmaids and groomsmen, in full regalia, along with a wedding cake, a dance floor, a band, guests and even presents. As the bride and groom laughed, danced and cut the cake, the change in their expressions-from skeptical curiosity to unbridled joy and appreciation-was unmistakable. "What church does this?" I wondered, anxious to discover the community that had come up with such an incredible ministry.
Then I learned that the wedding reception was not the ministry of a church, but a "mission" (their word, not mine) sponsored by Improv Everywhere. I was crestfallen ... and a little angry. Why hadn't a church thought of doing that? Why were we Christians leaving mission to young people who just want "to see what would happen" if they introduce extravagant hope into ordinary human situations? Why wasn't it the church giving people "the story of a lifetime"? The young people in Improv Everywhere, of course, gave no thought to participating in God's reign; they would not recognize the parallels between my job and theirs. And yet they too were on a mission of hope-and it occurred to me that they might be better at fulfilling their mission than I am at fulfilling mine.
THE BEST GAME EVER
Full, of course, goes a long way toward dissipating anxiety, and working with teenagers offers ample opportunities for playfulness. Yet without the gospel to inform such play, Christian hope goes unproclaimed, and in some cases it is clearly absent (Improv Everywhere's "pantless subway ride" conies to mind). Yet Improv Everywhere has captured something that churches have forgotten: the ability to enter a situation assuming that there is a different game to be played in human time than the one that is scripted. My favorite Improv Everywhere mission is called "The Best Game Ever," in which several dozen agents infiltrate a Little League game, unannounced, and treat it like the World Series. The "fans" cheer for each player by name, wave team posters, dress like mascots and broadcast plays on a JumboTron. Even the Goodyear Blimp ("Go Mudcats!") makes an appearance, coming out of the clouds over the game. At first, players and parents greet the hoopla with disbelief, but soon the boys are thinking of themselves as champions. I am willing to wager that the kingdom of God is like that: every player feels like a champion, because this is how God views each and every one of us.
Jesus calls its to be a youthful church, not because we are young but because we are his. Nothing is more important for a youthful church than developing an eschatological imagination, which allows its to wait with confidence, to name our anxieties without fear, and to make room for new life and new possibilities as Christ works, unseen, to usher its into an utnknown future. Young people's sense of open-ended possibility, their candid rejection of the fear of death, remind its that youthfulness is built into Christian eschatology. It is not age that makes its young. The future makes its young, and the future belongs to Christ. Fear not.
• DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE
Hat Full of Quotes
Choose quotes within the reading that you find interesting or challenging-ideas that get you thinking-and come to the discussion with one or two of these quotes typed out.38
When you all arrive, place your quotes in a hat. Then break up into small groups. Each group should choose two or three quotes out of the hat. Allow these quotes to become the starting point of discussion.
