Chapter 17 of 20

15 Ascension Deficit Disorder Youth Ministry as a Laboratory for Hope

15 Ascension Deficit Disorder Youth Ministry as a Laboratory for Hope

ANDREW ROOT

y wife and I boarded the train just after midnight, sad to leave behind the breathless beauty of Venice (and the Italian ice cream sandwiches, of which I had already consumed a half dozen). We were on our way to Nice in the south of France for another adventure on twenty dollars a day. My wife had won a fellowship our final year of seminary, so we chose to stretch the funds to their extreme by traveling the world. (Yes, we chose to enter the stream of global tourism ourselves!)

Hauling our backpacks through the narrow aisles of the train, we found our way to our sleeper car and swung the door open to meet another young couple, also backpackers, from Montreal. After sharing a few travel stories they asked its what we did back home. We explained that we had just finished seminary and that my wife was preparing to be a pastor and I was going to be an academic theologian. "Cool," they said in their perfect English with overtones of a French accent. It was the kind of "cool" that said, "That's surprising and a little weird; I have nothing else to say, soooo ... cool." After a minute of silence the young woman, realizing that we had hours remaining together, said, "I was kicked out of confirmation when I was in school. The leader thought I asked too many disturbing questions so they asked inc to leave." Though I don't often think of the perfect thing to say until after a conversation, this was one of those occasions when it came to me in the moment. I responded, "That's too bad, because the best theologians ask the most disturbing questions." She just smiled and we were on to another conversation.

THE STRUGGLE OF CONFIRMATION

When we finally went to bed that night I lay in my sleeping bag as southern Europe raced past the window and thought of the last confirmation class I had taught. I remembered being frustrated by what felt like bipolar meetings with my ninth-grade small group. They never seemed to want to talk about the lesson or faith, preferring instead to rehash school gossip or simply make fun of each other until it was impossible to find our way back to the lesson at hand. But at least a few times a year (and this is where it got bipolar), the conversation would turn from gossip and mayhem and popcorn-throwing to the deepest and most difficult questions. One minute I would be fighting to get them to talk about anything having to do with what I supposed was our reason for being together, and throwing out comments like, "So in reading this Bible passage, what jumps out to you?" Then the next minute I'd suddenly be cornered with something like, "So if God is so powerful and loving, why every minute are children in poor countries dying? And why did my mom's friend who just had a baby get leukemia?" This back and forth made my head spin; what was I doing? I felt like half the time I was taskmaster teacher and the other half I was bumbling defender of the faith, feeling unprepared or inadequate to address these significant questions (and I was a seminary student at the time). So what was I doing as a confirmation leader? Was Ito be a teacher, a defender, a mixture of both?

The truth is, when it conies to preparing adults to be confirmation teachers and mentors for students, we often don't know what they are supposed to be doing-which of course means that if we, the paid youth workers, don't know, then surely the volunteer has no clue. Usually, the volunteer is given a packet of lessons and told to get through them, as well as help kids write faith statements and memorize Bible verses. "And of course," they're told, "while you're doing all this essential stuff, stuff that determines whether or not they can be confirmed at all, don't forget to build deep relationships with them." But these goals-passing on the essentials of the Christian faith and tradition to young people while also being in deep relationship with them-seem to conflict.

DOUBT AS OUR CURRICULUM

Maybe this conflicted way of being a confirmation leader is not the best approach; perhaps there is another way. Often we see the confirmation leader as the one responsible for getting kids to know and appropriate the tradition through deep relationship. But what if the objective of the confirmation teacher was not to work to pass on anything but was rather to be a partner and companion in doubt? What if, instead of depending on lessons bought from publishing houses, we used our very doubts as the curriculum for passing on the faith? Or to say it another way, what if the best way to actually pass on the faith was not through lessons, certainty and knowledge, but through doubt? What if the confirmation teacher was a convincer and co-doubter with adolescents? What if confirmation wasn't about appropriating a tradition but about exploring doubt, placing it on the table and fiercely seeking understanding through it?

Then the responsibility of confirmation teachers is not to know the tradition in an airtight way, something few to no volunteers can sign off on, but only to be open enough with young people to explore their own doubts as they explore the young peoples'. What energy a small group could have if, for three years or three weeks, they sought to express the depth of their unbelief, working to share it with each other and God! The confirmation teacher then is no longer taskmaster teacher or skilled apologist with defense for all adolescent questions but rather captain of the company of companion doubters. And confirmation would then be the time for students to ask their most disturbing questions about God, self and world and have those questions placed on the table as the group's shared curriculum.

You may be starting to get nervous with my statements (I have to admit that my own stomach is quivering a little as I write this). But our shared nervousness has more to do with misunderstandings than with reality. We wrongly think that doubt is a Trojan horse which, if allowed to penetrate the fortress of our person, will release an army that will undercut our faith and lead its far away from God. And though we may not admit it, we fear that if we allow kids to doubt (even more, if we encourage it!) then they will discover that our faith is only a house of cards that cannot stand up to the winds of their inquisitions. I think this is because we wrongly assume that faith is only faith if it has been immunized from doubt. Yet doubt is not antithetical to faith; doubt is the call to faith. Doubt is the origin of faith, as we saw in part one.

BACK TO THE VIA NEGATIVA

As we discussed in chapter seven, the theologians of the early Reformation sought to do theology by discussing the negative or the opposite (the via negativa). They believed that it was only by examining the opposite that we could be freed from seeing our common theological language as just that: common, like meaningless phrases plastered on greeting cards that now have no meaning at all. We get back the rich (earth-shaking) meaning by thinking of these realities together in light of their opposite. So, for example, when Paul says that discipleship is encompassed in faith, hope and love, these are not just nice flowery words perfect for church mission statements and Christian college insignias. Rather, in light of their opposites, they are radical assertions. We are to love others in opposition to the will to dominate them. We are to hope in opposition to immediacy. And we are to have faith in opposition to certainty. The call to faith, then, is the call to avoid the temptation of certainty; it is certainty-not doubt-that destroys faith.

Right here is where we usually go wrong with confirmation. Christianity has nothing to do with certainty, and confirmation is not the ritual of claiming that you will, with all certainty, believe the tradition and theology of the church. No, Christianity is about living in opposition to certainty; it is about faith in the midst of doubt. Indeed, Christianity has no room for certainty, for certainty lives by the law of self-protection; its own rightness keeps it from hope and, most importantly (the greatest of these, Paul says), from love. Certainty demands its rightness in the now, even if it means hurting or hating others to maintain its integrity.

Doubt then is not our enemy but our great friend. For it keeps its from the most unchristian of things: assuming that we possess certainty, that we need not think about our faith or love our neighbors, and worse, that we need not search for God, for we know this God certainly. Faith that has become certain is no longer (by definition) faith; it has become idolatry, where we no longer seek out a living personal God but make this God into a frozen idol. The truth, then, is that there can be no relationship at all when it is based on certainty. I cannot really love my friend and embrace the fullness of his being if I assume I know him with certainty, if in being with him I keep saying, "I know you; that's not what you think. I don't need to hear you, see you or learn from you. I know you certainly. You cannot change." Faith is about trust. And for trust to be trust, it must always live with doubt. So I say, let its doubt! Let its make confirmation the place of shared doubt. For it is only when we welcome doubt that we are really people who are about faith seeking understanding (which the church father Anselm called its to be).

BACK TO CONFIRMATION

The confirmation leader, then, would be committing to affirm that the Christian tradition has something to say to our questions and our deep doubt, something worth exploring, rather than committing to know the tradition perfectly or even accept it fully. It is not important that they have the answers; they only need the willingness to seek God through doubt. This, of course, takes some bravery-much more bravery than going through a lesson handout. But it is a bravery that is borne in the person of the leader. When the group is built around shared doubt, it is constructed around the core of shared humanity. Through doubt the leader is moved to share not simply knowledge or adult wisdom with an adolescent but his or her very person, his or her sufferings and longings. A confirmation small group built on the sharing of doubt embraces the mutual openness of relationship. It is a group of place-sharing.

This means that a good confirmation teacher is not necessarily someone who knows every answer. It is, rather, someone who can create an environment where people feel safe enough to speak their deepest doubts into the life of the group-to speak these doubts and then seek God in them. In other words, the job of the confirmation leader is to invite doubts to be spilled without fear of shock or dehumanizing judgment by others. And the goal is to make doubt shared, and therefore part of a community. When our doubts are shared by others we not only find ourselves squarely in relationship with others but we also discover that our doubts do not alienate us. Rather, they invite us to keep searching, to keep seeking for God with those others. In this we discover that when we cannot believe, others believe for its, and that faith is not a possession or achievement, it is a gift from God.

Thus, confirmation is not the end of a road or a final exam but the welcome and continued encouragement to keep seeking God. Indeed, the lifeblood of faith seeking understanding is confronting and sharing our doubts with others. If confirmation teachers are co-doubters, conveners of the community of doubt, then they are able to do the two things we often ask of them, the two things that often thrust them into an uncomfortable conundrum: they are able to be in deep relationship with young people and, in so doing, explore the tradition deeply.

If relationships are built on mutual identification while respecting the other's difference and otherness, then exploring each other's doubts serves as a road to deep connection through mutual exploration (what more can we want?). Our doubts are usually deeply woven around our being. We doubt, for example, because we have heard that Jesus brings peace, but we have only known the chaos of a drunken father. We've heard that Jesus brings wholeness, but we have only known the emptiness of being out of work. As co-doubters, the small group becomes a deeply woven relational community of shared suffering. But because it has been built around doubt instead of certainty, it is at the same time a group that seeks God, that seeks understanding in the midst of the world's, the tradition's and their own inconsistency. In shared doubt the broken searching of our shared lives leads its into seeking God by asking, Who is this God who joins us in our suffering, who comes near in our doubts? Who is this living God who calls us into relationship, who loves its so that our very unbelief and our willingness to proclaim our doubt, like the father in Mark 9-"I believe; help my unbelief!"-become the invitation to trust, and therefore to have faith in the God made known in Jesus Christ?

I wonder what our sleeper-car companion would have said had she been in a confirmation class that did not kick her out for asking disturbing questions but made her (and the many other unspoken) doubts the curriculum for their time together. My hunch is that she would have said something like this:

Cool. I went to confirmation. It was one of the most interesting times of my life. I fell in love with those people. We talked about so many crazy, fun and heartbreaking things. I really saw the depth of the Christian life; I tasted it and even now I find myself still searching, always asking big questions, always wondering what God is tip to, who I am and what people are dealing with. It was one of the most interesting experiences I've ever had-I discovered life is worth living and God is worth loving.

DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION EXERCISE

Simulation
This simulation is designed to give you the chance to experience what it might be like to do confirmation or some kind of catechesis around doubt.' Therefore, the exercise will work best with people who have led or will be leading some kind of educational dimension within the church with young people.
Break up into groups of three. You will do this simulation in these groups, but you will report back to the full group at the end of the session to share your insight and thoughts.
Background to Simulation
You are three teachers who are coteaching a Wednesday night confirmation small group (eight kids). Due to your busy schedules (something common for volunteers) you only see the class on the week you teach (i.e., every third week).
Situation
Last week you all received an email from students in the small group. Amanda, it seems, has made the rest of the group uncomfortable with her questions. According to the email, the probing and doubt-filled questions she asks disrupt the time and make the others uneasy. All three of you have experienced the depth of these questions, but because you each see the group only every third week, you were unaware of their extent. The kid who sent the email mentions over and over that Amanda is dangerous and that they have to deal with so many people who challenge their beliefs at school that they shouldn't have to deal with this at church.
Your Task
The three of you have now gotten together to figure out what to do. How do you deal with the group's anxiety and Amanda's questions? How do you handle it in a way that honors not only each member's person, but also the objectives of the small group? How can this be an opportunity to shift the group's focus to thinking deeply about their faith? Take your time together to address these questions but also to sketch out strategies of action: ways to keep Amanda's questions from dominating as well as ways to help the other kids open themselves to think deeply and critically about their faith. Sketch out an outline for at least one small group time. Then prepare to report your thoughts back to the rest of the group.

↑ Back to top

↑