Kenda Creasy Dean and Christy Lang Hearlson
Kenda Creasy Dean and Christy Lang Hearlson
You did not choose me, remember. I chose you.
Jesus (John 15:16, paraphrase)
If you were on your way to work in Washington, DC on January 12, 2007 — and if your route happened to take you through the L’Enfant Plaza subway station at 7:51 a.m. — you might have noticed a young man in jeans and a baseball cap playing a violin. L’Enfant Plaza is the nerve center of the federal government’s morning commute. The young man’s violin case was open, welcoming the occasional dollar tossed inside by the various species of government workers who scuttled by. Some had children in tow on their way to day care. Everyone was in a hurry. The young man played for forty-three minutes.
During that time, several things happened. The young man played six classical pieces, netting $52.17 (one woman threw in a twenty). The videotape shows 1,097 people passing by, but only six stopped to listen for a few minutes. Children craned their necks to watch, but parents scooted them away without pausing. No one realized that the young man was playing a three-hundred-year-old, $3.5 million Stradivarius, or that he played Bach’s “Chaconne,” considered one of the most difficult pieces ever written for the violin. And, with the exception of the woman donating the $20 (she recognized him from a concert), no one knew that the musician was world-famous violinist Joshua Bell, who had soloed with the world’s most celebrated orchestras, performed an Oscar-winning soundtrack, and appeared on Sesame Street and Late Night with Conan O’Brien — all before turning thirty-nine.
The Washington Post called the subway concert “art without a frame,” an experiment to see if people would recognize a musical feast prepared by an artistic genius if it was right under their noses. Turns out, they didn’t.
High School Theology Programs: Feasts of Hope
This book pays attention to another experiment — “theological education without a frame,” perhaps — that has continued, mostly unnoticed, for nearly two decades. The Lilly Endowment Initiative “Theological Programs for High School Youth” constitutes North American theological education’s most ambitious pedagogical experiment in fifty years. Distressed by congregational youth ministries’ failure to seriously engage teenagers theologically, the Lilly Endowment’s Religion Division enlisted teams of theological educators and youth ministers to imagine a kind of theological education for teenagers considering Christian leadership. To that end, High School Theology Programs (HSTPs) spent the better part of two decades testing various pedagogical cocktails that would “help teenagers fall in love with theology” and inspire, challenge, and shape the next generation of Christian leaders for the church and for the world.
The practices these programs use to prepare young Christian leaders are striking both for the ways they echo formal theological education and for their unapologetic departures from it. Very few of these programs claim that forming future clergy is their primary aim, yet some research suggests that an astonishing one in four HSTP alumni have graduated from, are currently enrolled in, or plan to attend seminary — and another 28 percent say they “are considering” attending seminary. Yet of those who “pass by” High School Theology Programs each summer (and many do this literally, since most of them take place on seminary campuses), very few church leaders have taken note of how likely these students are to want theological training, how often they credit these programs with awakening their sense of calling, or how transformative practicing vocational discernment in community is for both young people and the church, as young people come to think of vocation as discerning the church’s calling in the world, and not just their own.
We believe that approaching vocational discernment as a social practice is a distinctive theological contribution of High School Theology Programs, challenging individualized notions of vocation in ways that include, but go beyond, identifying where young people’s deepest passions intersect with the world’s greatest needs. A different metaphor began to inform our discussion about the vocational ecologies of these programs, brought to mind by Isak Dinesen’s famous short story “Babette’s Feast.” Babette — an enigmatic maid who, as a young woman, had been a celebrated chef in Paris — makes her way to a Norwegian village where she serves two sisters, members of an austere Christian sect, for many years. Day in and day out, she prepares the plain fare they have shown her how to cook. But when Babette wins the lottery, she asks permission to make the sisters and their guests a real French meal. The food is divine; the guests warm to the wine and to each other. Old rifts are healed and old loves are confessed, and the sharp line dividing spiritual from other appetites melts in the joy of the meal. Surprised to learn that Babette will not return to France with her winnings, the sisters are aghast to learn the reason why: she has gladly spent every penny on them, offering the feast.
Like Babette’s gift that awakened joy throughout the village, Lilly’s decision to invest in the vocational formation of young people felt like “winning the lottery” to many scholars and practitioners interested in adolescent faith formation. Forty-seven teams of academics and youth ministers, located in seminaries across North America, were given license to prepare a vocational feast for people whose joy they longed to awaken: young people, and especially teenagers who showed promise for theological leadership.
Spiritually Interested Teenagers: Hungry for More
Megan LeCluyse and Emily Chudy are two young Presbyterian (USA) pastors who met at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary’s Summer Youth Institute (SYI) in 2003. Megan called herself a “band kid” from Arizona; Emily was a Philadelphia athlete. Like most teenagers in High School Theology Programs, Megan and Emily did not come to faith or have a conversion experience at the Summer Youth Institute. Their faith had already been significantly formed through committed, church-going families and attentive churches, to the point that others began to notice and name their gifts for Christian leadership. Yet Emily and Megan recall being excited about being with other teenagers who also wanted to “go deeper” in their faith, and who were also trying to discern whether God was calling them to ministry. As Megan and Emily put it, “For us, [SYI] was the first time we felt ‘normal.’ ”
For two weeks at Pittsburgh’s Summer Youth Institute, Emily and Megan drank in a typical HSTP experience. They studied under seminary professors, engaged in serious Bible study, learned to preach, serve, and worship together, and — in their words — were “simply nerdy teenagers living in community.” In a study of their fellow SYI alumni ten years later, they write,
[SYI] was the first time we felt . . . that our call to ministry at a young age and a desire to academically engage our faith did not make us different from our peers. Our experience was both fun and formative. . . . As we went through seminary, we realized we were not only very close friends . . . but colleagues in ministry who care very deeply about the future of the PCUSA and its ministry to young people.
Emily and Megan say their journey into ministry was decisively influenced by their participation in the Summer Youth Institute, which amounted to (in their words) “an AP course” in Christian community and theological reflection, enabling them to unapologetically profess their religious interests and articulate their desire to serve Christ.
Their words were echoed in many of the interviews our research team conducted; over and over, we heard young people say they finally felt that they had found their tribe in the program they attended, that they were being taken seriously for the first time as religious beings and theological thinkers, or that they wished their home churches provided similar challenge and depth in exploring faith. As it turns out, spiritually interested teenagers must confront two ironies in North American culture. The first is that — despite the fact that 40 percent of American teenagers attend religious youth groups for an extended period of time, and three out of four self-identify as Christians — most North American young people do not share Megan and Emily’s depth of spiritual interest, in spite of the fact that theological and existential concerns are very much on adolescents’ minds as a matter of their place in the lifecycle. Three out of five millennials say religion does not matter much to them. Most young people who call themselves Christians describe their faith in terms that the 2004 National Study of Youth and Religion dubbed “moralistic therapeutic deism,” a bland, superficial religiosity that helps people be nice and feel good about themselves, but otherwise keeps God in the background.
In a culture where blasé spirituality is the norm, Megan and Emily’s intense interest in theological questions and commitment to Christian service sound out of place. Yet Megan and Emily were not, in fact, weird in their interest in theology. Although American teenagers who say faith matters to them (even when it takes a backseat to other activities) are a minority, they are a significant minority. A full 37 percent of American teenagers describe themselves as “strong” in their faith, and 8 percent are described by the National Study of Youth and Religion as “highly devoted.” Ironically, these “highly devoted” young people are the very teenagers that North American youth ministry is most likely to overlook.
This, then, is the second irony facing teenagers like Megan and Emily: congregational youth ministries are not designed for spiritually interested youth to grow in their faith — maybe because we think the Megans and Emilies in our churches are “already won.” Congregational and community youth ministries, hoping to cast a wide net, tend to cater to moralistic therapeutic deists (a case can be made that some North American churches actually help youth become moralistic therapeutic deists). As a rule, contemporary “fellowship” models of youth ministry do not challenge young people like Megan or Emily. To be clear, church leaders appreciate these teenagers (we are not shy about employing their gifts or exploiting their reliability), but the fellowship aims of most congregational youth ministries cause youth leaders to default to programs that are designed to attract a wide array of teenagers, or that we hope will whet the spiritual appetites of the uninterested.
Meanwhile, one of the most disturbing trends facing theological education in the early twenty-first century is the fact that Christian young people who want to make a difference do not seem to think the church is the best place to do it. As one youth minister told me, explaining his decision to become an artist instead of attending seminary, “I feel like I have to choose between my creativity and the church.” Spiritually interested teenagers — young people hungry for theologically substantive conversation about faith and identity — are more likely to find congregations to be places that affirm them rather than challenge them. As Chris Hughes, co-founder of the United Methodist Foundation of Faith Formation, remarked about confirmation (arguably the most common congregational vocational discernment practice): “In most churches, spiritually interested teens emerge in spite of confirmation, not because of it.”
Why Now?
Congregations’ tendency to underinvest in spiritually interested teenagers was in fact the predicament that motivated the Lilly Endowment’s Religion Division to fund High School Theology Programs. By the 1990s, the Endowment’s own reports were forthright about the gifts — and limitations — of church youth fellowship programs. The reports were especially critical of these programs’ effectiveness in helping youth intellectually engage Christian thought and practice:
Many congregational and denominational youth fellowship programs nurture young people in the Christian faith and establish personal relationships with other Christians. They do not always provide adequate opportunities for youth to explore and examine critically the long and rich tradition of Christian thought and practice.
Noting that the “networks and systems needed to identify and recruit talented young people into the vocation of Christian ministry are not strong enough at this time,” theological educators like Craig Dykstra, then the vice president of Lilly’s Religion Division, saw a clear need for helping young people see Christian leadership as a viable expression of their gifts and dreams. Sensing urgency, Lilly elected to bypass incentivizing congregational reform and went straight to theological schools, gambling that if seminaries developed teenage Christian leaders, it would solve two problems at once: (1) talented youth would consider ministry as a desirable vocational option; and (2) future church leaders would be formed who — a generation hence — would reform congregations’ ailing approaches to faith formation.
With these young leaders in mind, the Lilly Endowment began funding teams of theological educators and youth ministers to “(1) stimulate and nurture an excitement about theological learning and inquiry, and (2) identify and encourage a new generation of young Christians to consider vocations in Christian ministry.” High School Theology Program directors vigorously deny accusations that their programs cater only to the “best and the brightest” young Christians. (Overheard from one program director: “What does that even mean?”) Instead, they describe their participants in terms of readiness, referring to an openness to vocational exploration expressed by teenagers once their gifts for leadership have been recognized, named, and affirmed by others.
Given free rein to develop their own recipes for adolescent vocational formation, these teams created a sumptuous array of offerings that immerse young people in communities organized around Christian practices of vocational discernment. No two curricular designs, schedules, staffing patterns, organizational partnerships, theological emphases, or signature themes and practices (liturgy, peacemaking, mentoring, hope-building, etc.) are alike. What unites all of them is a profound confidence in teenagers’ capacities for theological leadership, and a commitment to giving young people concrete opportunities to practice this leadership. Each program cultivates adolescents’ ability to wrestle with thorny theological problems, giving teenagers confidence in their theological agency while they encounter myriad ways in which people live their lives for God. Motivated by research in civic education that shows a predictive relationship between early leadership opportunities and adult civic engagement, each High School Theology Program provides teenagers with countless opportunities to “try on” various mantles of Christian leadership in the context of a deeply intentional, if briefly constituted, community of faith. The ability to practice theological leadership in these communities is key. As one group of theological educators working with HSTPs pointed out,
“Falling in love with theology” is not what motivates kids to think about ministry. . . . They respond best to a sense of agency and a sense that they can bring about greater justice. At the same time, they need help in growing theologically and developing skills for service.
Almost twenty years and twenty thousand alumni later, the data speak for themselves. Overwhelmingly, HSTP alumni view their professional lives as expressions of Christian discipleship. According to Barbara Wheeler’s study of HSTP alumni, in addition to the one in four who are attending or finished with seminary, and the 28 percent who say they are considering formal theological education,
These outcomes suggest that it is not only possible to challenge teenagers with rigorous theological reflection and meaningful opportunities for ministry and service, but that doing so helps teenagers imagine vocational futures that otherwise would go unnoticed.
Top Chefs and Mother Sauces
This book is the fruit of a two-year project in which HSTP directors were asked to describe the theological emphases and pedagogical practices of their programs, and — along with a team of practical theologians in Christian education and formation — discern what these programs might teach those of us concerned with educating future church leaders. This book is intended to evoke more than prescribe; the chapters that follow are more invested than objective, more anecdotal than analytical. For eighteen months we convened this group, while a research team made up of PhD students combed through the archives of every seminary-based HSTP that has been funded. This research team also conducted thirteen site visits to programs “in progress” in the summer of 2012, interviewed teenagers, staff, and program directors, and sifted through various theological and pedagogical analyses written about the forty-seven current programs.
Stepping into the High School Theology Program universe felt a little like stepping into a Food Network show in progress. We peeked in on forty-seven “top chefs” in youth ministry who had been given access to “risk capital” and what amounts to a pedagogical carte blanche by the Lilly Endowment; what we observed was part genius and part chaos. Along with committed teams of young adult staff, seminary professors, youth ministers, community members, and high school participants themselves, these program directors created energetic test kitchens where teenagers could experiment with different aspects of spiritual and vocational formation. Through remarkably diverse settings and curricula, they helped youth unapologetically claim and articulate faith, discern how to serve Christ with their work and with their lives, and see themselves as church shapers rather than church shoppers.
The vocational pedagogies of these “top chefs” were less new than freshly interpreted in specific contexts, which gave them a boldness — and, it must be said, a hopefulness — that was as irresistible to adults as to teenagers. At the heart of their pedagogical frameworks was a collection of powerful practices: practices of community building, decentering and disruption, worship, spiritual companionship, holy conversation, theological reflection, pilgrimage, and experiential learning. These pedagogies function as the “mother sauces,” so to speak, of vocational discernment. Just as French cooking utilizes four or five “mother sauces” that make possible nearly every dish in the French palette, vocational pedagogies lie at the root of every effort of High School Theology Programs to help teenagers recognize God’s movement in their lives. The theory was simple: once teenagers learned the basic ingredients of vocational discernment, they could combine those ingredients in endlessly creative ways to cobble together a future as a Christian leader.
High School Theology Programs are not the only de facto laboratories for adolescents pursuing church leadership, of course. Church camps, retreat programs, volunteer service corps, denominational youth councils, and confirmation programs all can be viewed, with some accuracy, as feeder systems for future Christian leaders as well. When utilized intentionally, vocational pedagogies turn out disproportionate numbers of future pastors from many venues, partly because they cultivate experiences that are positively correlated with young people’s likelihood to attend seminary: communities of faithful peers, agency in shaping those communities, primary leadership experience, “disruptive experiences” like leaving home and encountering difference, as well as access to effective Christian leaders who take youth seriously as theologians (an oft-cited virtue of HSTPs). They treat youth ministry as an occasion to challenge and deepen adolescents’ call to discipleship, rather than use youth ministry as a net to capture teenagers before they escape. In short, they give students opportunities to see “ministry done well, and at close range,” which, as Barbara Wheeler observes, is normally a prerequisite for a young person’s interest in seminary.
Vocation: What It Is, What It Isn’t
High School Theology Programs were formed in part to make Christian leadership an imaginable possibility for young people who might not otherwise consider it, and to prompt those already leaning in that direction to “try on” the identity of a Christian leader. Despite Lilly’s stated objective for HSTPs to help teenagers “fall in love with theology,” by itself this was not enough. Youth needed to make the connection between their love for theology and the church as a place where lovers of theology put their insights about Christ into action.
Thus, while it was crucial for HSTPs to help teenagers “fall in love with theology” and discern their individual gifts for leadership, a communal understanding of vocation gave teenagers a reason to introduce practices of vocational discernment to others. The language that Lilly most often used to describe their mission was the cultivation of Christian leaders through a process of vocational discernment. A key component of this leadership was helping the gathered community discern its collective gifts, and determine how God might use those gifts to reflect Christ in particular contexts.
Thinking about Christian vocation as God’s call to communities, and not just to individuals, is part of the DNA of every High School Theology Program we studied and profoundly influences the way HSTP alumni understand pastoral ministry. Instead of viewing pastoral leadership as a church office or service profession, these teenagers tend to view Christian leaders as catalysts, community developers, shepherds, and bridge-builders — people who mobilize others to enact the gospel in their contexts — as well as serve as prophets, priests, and servants. While all High School Theology Programs use the language of vocation and discernment to describe their work, let us take a moment to scrutinize these terms, especially since HSTPs use them in distinctly communal ways.
The Early Church and Vocation
The early church understood vocation primarily in terms of discipleship. Every Christian’s vocation is to bear the image of God, to follow Christ — a life made possible by unceasing prayer and purity (usually equated with chastity or virginity). However, since most believers could not abandon their daily toil to literally pursue a life of unceasing prayer (and most had no wish for chastity or virginity), “vocation” came to mean one’s call from God to live as a religious “professional” (i.e., a monk, nun, virgin, or priest) — people who lived holy lives on behalf of others. Thus, “vocation” had a dual meaning from very early on: it referred both to Christ’s call to all believers to follow him, and it referred to people whose full-time work was set apart to strive for a kind of holiness that would reflect Christ’s likeness in intentional, intensified ways as representatives of the church.
By the Middle Ages, vocation had become closely identified with the work of a vowed class of religious people. After the schism in 1054, Western churches continued this trajectory with vigor. For medieval Catholics, vocation referred almost exclusively to a specific calling to holy orders; priests, monks, nuns, and various holy people were said to have a special calling, a vocation. By living simply in community, and by adopting ascetic practices aimed at eliminating all distractions from God, these “religious” could focus their attention on holiness, often viewed as an almost literal imitation of Christ’s suffering and self-giving love.
In the East, vocation was less of a specialized profession. The Eastern church had religious professionals too, but “transfiguration was the central paradigm for understanding humanity’s vocation.” Eastern Christians believed all believers were called to theosis, to become partakers in the divine nature. The goal of Christian life is future union with God, and — in contrast to the Roman Catholic Church — was less focused on the sin of the past. The Orthodox considered sin a serious but temporary malady that hurts us, but does not destroy God’s image in us. In other words, sin was less a matter of disobedience and guilt than a failure to follow the path to theosis — the vocation of all human beings.
Vocation in the Reformation
The sixteenth-century Protestant Reformers radically expanded the idea of calling or vocation, but maintained its association with human work. Martin Luther, for example, believed that all Christians are of the “spiritual estate,” though they may have different roles or belong to different classes of society. Luther believed in both an internal and an external calling. Internally, all Christians are called to the gospel faith. Externally, we are called to certain roles in particular “estates” or social classes. In other words, Luther did not think it possible for someone not to be called; the ordinary roles of life, he insisted, were divine callings.
While Luther’s view of vocation elevated the work of ordinary life to a higher status, making the active (versus contemplative) life of ordinary Christians a part of God’s plan for society, this also had the effect of identifying people’s vocations with the work dictated by the social class they were born into, reinforcing common assumptions that one’s social class could not be improved. Although Luther’s views on social mobility are debated, his view that all work, in any station of life, should be joyfully dedicated to God failed to recognize the oppressive nature of work for the poor, and often seemed to sanction dehumanizing work imposed upon the poor by those in power.
In many respects, John Calvin was in agreement with Luther. Calvin also associated calling with ordinary roles and work. Like Luther, Calvin used “calling” to refer to the fact that all people, regardless of their station in life, were called to salvation and to following Christ. And, like Luther, Calvin also used “calling” to refer to a person’s work. A person of any social class could serve God and neighbor, and, as Calvin stressed, this truth elevated mundane responsibilities. For Calvin, vocation has the potential to transform how we feel about our work since, by being useful to other people, we are ultimately doing something God had asked us to do. Calvin had a more flexible view of the social order than Luther, recognizing that people sometimes had to change professions in a changing economic landscape. For Calvin, one’s utility and activity within one’s social class mattered more than remaining a part of that class, which made “the whole tenor of callings . . . more aggressive and busy.”
The gift that Luther and Calvin offer Christians today is a view of vocation that celebrates the fact that every Christian is called by God, allowing ordinary work to be consecrated as holy, something one does for the good of others and in service to God. Unfortunately, as many theologians have noted, the Reformers’ identification of vocation with work also poses serious problems, leading to an array of perspectives on vocation among contemporary theologians (especially Protestants).
For example, womanist theologian Joan Martin points out that the Reformers failed to take seriously the potential of economic stratification to exploit workers, or “the incipient danger of theologizing, mystifying, and romanticizing all forms of work as theologically and morally ‘good.’ ” Martin concludes,
By upholding an unambiguously positive notion of work as vocation without criticizing the social relations of the changing political economy, the Protestant tradition was left with no theological or moral recourse for challenging exploitative work.
Like Martin, Reformed theologian Miroslav Volf also rejects the idea that “virtually every type of work can be a vocation, no matter how dehumanizing it might be (provided that in doing the work one does not transgress the commandments of God).” If work and vocation are simply equated, the doctrine of vocation can be abused, functioning to “ennoble dehumanizing work.” Volf agrees with Martin: this “vocational understanding of work provides no resources to foster . . . change.” In today’s market, where people must hold down several jobs at the same time or switch jobs in order to survive, the early modern perspective of Luther is untenable.
For Volf, a theology of work must be rooted in both the doctrine of creation, which evokes reflection on the world and social order as they already are, and also in eschatological hope, which evokes reflection on the world and social order in light of Christ’s redemption. Fueled by hope that God’s Spirit is even now changing the world and will ultimately bring about a reign of justice, peace, and love, Christians must use the gifts the Spirit has given them to cooperate with God in transforming the world. Because of his concerns about equating vocation with work, Volf replaces the language of vocation with charisms — gifts — as a way to describe what Christians are meant to be and do in the world.
Lutheran theologian Douglas J. Schuurman paints a more positive portrait of the Reformers’ approach to vocation, and as a result is hesitant to separate vocation and work. Like Calvin, Schuurman believes that vocation has potential to infuse life with meaning, integrating “all spheres and relations of human life into a religious vision of love and service to God and neighbor.” Schuurman maintains that vocation is “neighbor-centered, theocentric, and preferential” toward those we are called to care for by virtue of our family and community relationships — and as a result “rules out triumphalism, cynicism, and moral paralysis,” providing grounds to resist unjust social realities. To prevent abusing the doctrine of vocation, Schuurman provides some “hedges”: (1) Always keep in mind that our most encompassing “call,” or “vocation,” is to serve God and the common good; (2) Make love our guide; if a so-called vocation is harming people, it is not a vocation; (3) Shalom — divine peace and justice for all — must give form and structure to our view of vocation; (4) In a “good but fallen world,” exercise discernment in searching out and fulfilling our vocations.
Combustible Communities: Vocation as a Social Practice
These views illustrate both the importance and complexity of vocation in Christian history, in contemporary society, and in High School Theology Programs. HSTPs resist equating vocation to holy orders, avoid reducing teenagers’ “callings” to their employment or “day jobs,” and reject identifying vocation with dehumanizing work. Even in the few programs that unapologetically identified their primary objective as forming future clergy, the HSTPs we studied were united in reminding young people that God calls all Christians to reflect Christ in the work they do in the world — and that the work God calls us to do is sometimes (but not always) work for which we are paid.
At the same time, High School Theology Programs add an additional dimension to the conversation about vocation and discernment. Historically, both Protestant and Catholic discussions of vocation focus heavily on individuals — people’s work, their jobs, their station in life. Martin, Volf, and Schuurman are all concerned about social context, but treat vocation essentially as something that happens for individuals in those contexts. Absent from these theological expositions is an explicit discussion of how the whole church is called; nor is there a recognition of vocational discernment as a social practice — an adventure, even — that the church undertakes together, as a body.
High School Theology Programs, on the other hand, explicitly approach vocational discernment as a communal, creative process. We will explore the relationship between creativity and calling in chapter 2. For now, we can simply note that doing vocational discernment with teenagers in High School Theology Programs raises a fresh set of questions around vocation. What if, in addition to focusing on vocation as an individual calling, we began to understand vocation as something Christ calls the whole church to discern as a community? What if vocational discernment involves more than an internal psychological process that helps individual Christians figure out how to use their gifts and time? What if discerning vocation became an ongoing practice of the whole congregation in relationship to its community? What if vocation were like fire, less a material object than a visible, tangible expression of an ongoing social process that brings many “combustible” elements together to reflect the fire of the Holy Spirit?
Teenagers in High School Theology Programs wrestle with questions like these in both explicit and implicit ways. The pedagogical practices discussed in this volume come together around this point: they are practices of communities, and not just individuals, that lead to collective as well as individual discernment and action in an attempt to participate in Christ’s transformation of the world.
Combustible Theological Education
What seems clear in light of this research — and we would argue, in light of Christian tradition itself — is that, however spontaneous it may appear at the time, discerning one’s call to serve Christ is the result of a combustible vocational ecology, not any single variable. Not terribly long ago, “formative ecologies” were a taken-for-granted aspect of Christian formation. Networks of social institutions like families, congregations, community organizations, campus ministries, and Christian colleges all played a part in helping young people come to know themselves as religious beings, called by God to serve Christ in the world. Today, these formative ecologies have largely eroded, leaving young people drawn toward theological study and Christian leadership with very mixed levels of preparation and vocational awareness when they arrive at seminary (if, in fact, they arrive at seminary at all). Mounting research points to the de facto abandonment of religious education even in churches (and even the most intentional family or congregation struggles to convey religious identity in an hour or two a week of formal religious instruction). In short, while families and congregations are the best incubators we know for mature faith, they do not always do it well, and they cannot do it alone.
In this milieu, the effect of participating in something like a High School Theology Program becomes much more pronounced. Consider three of the ways in which the vocational ecologies of these programs have already contributed to the next-generation church:
1. High School Theology Programs are yielding talented and committed young leaders for Christian communities.
Young people who pursue religious vocations, particularly as clergy, are increasingly rare in North America. Given the superficial faith claimed by so many American teenagers, it is not surprising that many drift away from faith communities altogether by young adulthood. One-third of young Americans between eighteen and twenty-five are religiously unaffiliated. They are not atheist or agnostic; they are “nothing in particular.”
Against this backdrop, the vocational trajectories of more than twenty thousand HSTP alumni are striking. Even though roughly half do not pursue formal theological education (at least within the first decade of completing a High School Theology Program), forming a body of committed young congregants who are accustomed to engaging their faith deeply is no small thing. And, although the HSTPs pose serious questions to the church’s dominant forms of theological education, they also serve as extraordinary feeder systems for formal theological education. Not only are youth who have participated in a High School Theology Program more likely to attend seminary; they come to seminary with an excellent set of theological tools. In contrast to many of their classmates, HSTP alumni are not only deeply formed in faith; they are acquainted with basic exegetical strategies, the discipline of theological reading, an appreciation for hermeneutics and contextual analysis, and they have already experienced a range of the historic practices of Christian tradition that aim for discerning the Holy Spirit’s activity in their lives and in the world. Significantly, as several chapters in this book illustrate, they have also learned how to share life with people who sit at vastly different places on the ecclesial spectrum.
Barbara Wheeler acknowledges the obvious point — students attracted to HSTPs tend to be those already anchored in church life — so perhaps they would have pursued religious vocations anyway. Yet teenagers’ interest in ministry, while noticeable to others, is often vague and unarticulated in youth themselves — at least until they encounter a situation where Christian vocation is openly discussed. One program director recalled a student named James who recently contacted him for a reference to seminary, a decade after completing St. John’s University’s Youth, Theology, and Ministry (YTM) program. James wrote: “YTM was by far the most life-changing experience of my life. I think that it was the experience at YTM that made me first consider a career in something theology-related, then possibly the priesthood.” Wheeler’s interviews also underscored the experience of James, Emily, and Megan: “Several interviewees described their experiences in these high school programs as the defining moment in their decision-making about ministry.”
Wheeler invites us to speculate about what theological school enrollment figures might look like apart from the presence of High School Theology Program alumni in seminary classrooms over the past decade. Did the unexpected dip in the average age of seminarians, which had climbed steadily from 31.4 in 1989 to 34.4 in 1999 — and then unexpectedly dropped from 1999 to 2009 — in any way correspond to the presence of young HSTP alumni? Clearly many cultural factors are at play here. Yet with theological schools competing for a dwindling pool of well-prepared students, the vocational interest of HSTP alumni in theological leadership is difficult to ignore.
What we can say with some confidence is that participating in an intentional community that values and teaches theological reflection and spiritual practices, and offers myriad opportunities for leadership goes a long way toward convincing teenagers that they have gifts for leading a faithful life, and for leading others as disciples and change-makers in the church and world. For some youth, participating in a High School Theology Program awakens a call to Christian ministry; and for others, it ignites a life of committed, often passionate discipleship in other sectors. For teenagers and staff alike, being part of a High School Theology Program seems to significantly shape expectations for what the church should look like in their lifetimes, and heightens their determination to make this kind of church a reality.
2. High school theology programs stretch ecclesial imaginations — not just intellects and behaviors.
One of the most refreshing contributions of High School Theology Programs is that they allow us to witness the construction of a new church, rather than the deconstruction of an old one. These programs function as creative studios that both reimagine the way churches prepare leaders and catalyze more missional ways of thinking about the church altogether. HSTP directors share the conviction that Christian leaders need “traditioned” imaginations that anchor their expectations for the church and its leaders in the church’s teachings, texts, and traditions — but that also yields a nimble holy wisdom that guides discipleship in the fluid here-and-now. One program director compared this gift to the pivot foot in basketball: the player plants one foot on the court so the other foot can turn, enabling her to see what’s going on elsewhere on the court as she prepares to throw the ball.
A traditioned imagination starts with a deep affection for the texts and traditions of Christian faith, an explicit aim of High School Theology Programs. Aware that formal theological education often asks students to deconstruct theological traditions that they understand only at very rudimentary levels, each HSTP starts by plunging teenagers into a thicket of formative texts and practices. Quality of instruction matters; teenagers notice (and comment on) the difference it makes to be guided by an adult who, in the words of one program director, “has more than a fourth grade theological education.” Challenge also matters. During a focus group conducted by the Catholic Theological Union’s Peacebuilding Initiative, one teenager pleaded: “Whatever you do, please don’t give us the Fisher-Price version of theology.” She went on to explain that what excites teenagers about spending a week at the Peacebuilding Initiative is the chance to get “undiluted theology, theology rich and complex enough to be engaged on different levels allowing a bright young person to formulate ideas about God and the church.”
At the same time, the HSTPs’ objective of holy wisdom directly confronts “schooling” models of theological formation, where intellectual mastery, critical deconstruction, and technical proficiency are the primary goods on display. A great deal of pedagogical emphasis in HSTPs is placed on dehabituating teenagers from their accustomed vocational mindsets by inviting them to sample a feast of spiritual practices, to meet people living lives of radical discipleship, and to reflect with adult leaders who help them imagine what such discipleship might look like for them. The strategy invites comparisons to the early catechumenate, as new catechumens were apprenticed to seasoned Christians for learning the life of faith. Not only do such apprenticeships expand adolescents’ view of Christian faith; they expand the number of ways young people consider taking part in it.
3. High School Theology Programs suggest new forms of theological education.
As Masters of Divinity programs shrink and enrollment in formal programs of theological education declines, judicatories, seminaries, and others concerned with preparing future church leaders are being forced to ask whether our dominant models of theological education are the most effective ones we have. We can no longer assume that students attend seminary in order to prepare for callings they have already discerned. Increasingly, students come to seminary to discern a call to ministry, lacking other communities to either confirm or disconfirm a call to Christian leadership. HSTPs serve a crucial “research and development” role for theological education in this context, giving seminary students, faculty, youth ministers, and scholars new ways to think about the way we help young leaders respond to God’s call to Christian service — and whether our task is primarily to imbue them with knowledge or ignite them with hope.
Vocational pedagogies help create leaders and communities with ecclesial agility: the ability to bend toward God in a rapidly changing church, the ability to help communities pivot quickly in shifting cultural sands. As HSTP faculty learn to teach teenagers through High School Theology Programs’ broad teaching repertoires, their approach to teaching MDiv and MA students shifts as well. Meanwhile, the young adult staff of High School Theology Programs (frequently master’s and PhD students in theology) test-drive their own emerging pedagogical identities, influencing the kind of classrooms they will one day create.
Calling All Cooks: This Book Is for You
As you can see, this book is of interest to youth workers, but they are not the ones most likely to be changed by its contents. We are confident that the practices discussed here will broaden youth leaders’ own vocational pedagogies, and our hunch is that they need no convincing to experiment with the practices named here. As a species, youth leaders are less risk averse than professors; nor do they have the weight of academic tradition or assessment criteria to consider when they choose curriculum. In fact, I have yet to meet a group of youth leaders who cannot reel off the list of practices described in this book, with one exception, as what they would do had Lilly given them money to expand the vocational imaginations of the teenagers they know. (The one practice youth workers often miss, by the way, is “theological reflection,” which as we shall see is HSTPs’ stock-in-trade — and is profoundly appreciated by teenagers.)
Thus, in addition to creative youth workers, we hope courageous theological educators will also take up this book, sample the pedagogical feast these programs lay out, and let the practices and concepts described here transform their own thinking and teaching. Such transformation has already happened for many who have participated in the HSTPs as designated teachers. In chapter 12, Elizabeth Corrie argues that those most dramatically affected by HSTPs’ vocational pedagogies are the young adult counselors who staff them. In chapter 13, Brent Strawn describes how seminary faculty who teach in these programs learn to experiment, adapt their teaching methods, and gain practice explaining theological concepts in terms that are connected to the world of adolescents — all of which inevitably transform the way they teach seminarians as well.
Finally, we hope those who care about the formation of the next generation of Christian leaders — judicatory leaders, seminary presidents and administrators, curriculum designers, nonprofit executives, public theologians, and congregational leaders — will pay attention to the discussion in the pages that follow. High School Theology Programs till the soil, not just for next-generation church leaders, but also for the next-generation church. The nature of that church depends largely on what its future leaders think communities that follow Jesus should look like. In a culture where the majority of North American young people give the church very little thought, those of us who care about the church’s future should listen closely to the young people who do.
Taste Tests
High School Theology Programs emerged in response to inadequate systems of vocational formation in congregations and youth ministries, but they point to a larger issue facing the church. Namely, HSTPs reveal churches’ tendency to underestimate the power of “communities of discernment” in spiritually interested teenagers’ vocational trajectories — just as we underestimate their capacities as theological leaders generally. The truth is that teenagers are capable of far more disciplined theological reflection, far holier lives, and far more courageous leadership than most adults assume or practice.
That, of course, is the risk: forming young people into capable theologians and Christian leaders puts those of us already wearing those mantles — who perhaps have grown sloppy or tired or cynical over the years — on notice. As Carol Lytch observed in the first review of HSTPs in 2006, “With knowledgeable theologians and exemplary pastors in their midst, youth [immersed in the study of Scripture and liturgy] ask difficult questions about the dissonance they live with as Christ-centered people in a humanistic, consumerist, and secular world.” For these young people, who have neither written off the church nor ruled out the possibility of divine guidance, figuring out how to be a church that authentically follows Jesus matters, to the point that many of them are willing to forego other professional opportunities to invest their lives doing exactly that.
Here is a map of the road ahead. Part One, “A More Excellent Way: Vocational Discernment as a Practice of Christian Community,” suggests some of the implications of these pedagogical practices for theological education as a whole. Our basic thesis is that vocational discernment includes but cannot be reduced to helping teenagers “name their passions” or inventory their gifts to see which ones intersect with the world’s groaning needs. Instead, “a more excellent way” — to paraphrase Paul — is to challenge teenagers to a complex, creative adventure that takes place when faith communities become ecologies of discernment, as churches receive and nourish teenagers’ questions of identity and purpose.
Part Two, “More Than a Job Fair: Creating Cultures of Vocational Discernment,” explores some of the anchor practices that prepare congregations to become cultures of vocational discernment. These practices — community formation, spiritual mentoring, the naming and receiving of gifts — cultivate “good soil” for teenagers to discover God’s hope for the world and for them, and the gifts they have been given for contributing to a divine purpose. In chapter 3, Anabel Proffitt and Jacquie Church Young testify to the power of intentional Christian community to transform young people’s lives, describing Christian community’s “accelerator effect” in Christian formation. In chapter 4, Anne Streaty Wimberly describes spiritual companionship as a mutual process of doing theology, as holy conversation becomes a practice through which young people lay claim to both the Christian story and to their own stories as children of God.
Katherine Douglass and Christy Lang Hearlson, in chapters 5 and 6, look closely at congregations’ practices of naming and receiving young people’s gifts for ministry, before and after High School Theology Programs. Douglass reminds us that vocational formation in HSTPs starts before teenagers arrive, since they must be nominated by their pastor or another adult leader to attend. For many youth, this nomination is their first realization that others see in them the potential for spiritual leadership. Hearlson makes an equally powerful case for the influence of homecomings. Churches handle teenagers’ homecomings from HSTPs in vastly different (and sometimes indifferent) ways. Hearlson insists on the teachable moment of return, as teenagers from High School Theology Programs (or any “away from home” form of youth ministry, for that matter) are recognized as bringing something special to their home faith communities from their pilgrimages, which in turn helps youth integrate a newfound sense of divine purpose into their daily lives.
Part Three, “More Than a Summer Camp: Adventures in Vocational Pedagogies,” shows how young people are spurred toward vocational discernment through pedagogies of challenge and disruption, rather than by merely being safely entertained. Safety and trust are undeniably the preconditions for vocational exploration; growth happens when teenagers experience God’s call as an adventure that takes them beyond their comfort zones. In chapter 7, Andrew Brubacher Kaethler describes how decentering pedagogies help youth unmask culturally bound, self-centered interpretations of Christian faith. Likewise, Jeff Kaster describes HSTPs’ shared emphasis on theological reflection in chapter 8. Calling theological reflection the “fuel” for a long-term life of discipleship, Kaster argues that it is young people’s communal, intellectual engagement with Scripture and doctrine — often overlooked by congregational youth ministries — that makes faith durable over the long haul.
Underscoring the importance of immersive practices, in chapter 9 Fred Edie describes young people’s need to move from ideational faith to a more bodily, affective, and experiential form of Christian witness, especially through practices of worship that engage Christian tradition bodily, reflectively, and critically. David Horn takes up the other side of the equation in chapter 10. Noting that every High School Theology Program is a spiritual pilgrimage for young people (i.e., teenagers leave home and travel toward Christ on a common road with fellow pilgrims), he introduces one program that uses the practice of pilgrimage as an experiential way to understand the internal journey of faith. Experiential pedagogies are also the focus of chapter 11, as Judy Steers presents a theological case for playfulness, the arts, leadership and service as practices of vocational formation.
Finally, in Part Four, “More Than Teenagers: Vocational Discernment of Program Staff, Faculty, and Theological Institutions,” we take a look at other populations who benefit from participating in High School Theology Programs. Chapter 12 points to Elizabeth Corrie’s research from the Youth Theology Initiative (the original High School Theology Program at Candler School of Theology), which reveals how profoundly young adult counselors’ own callings, leadership styles, and understandings of ministry are shaped by participating in HSTPs. Corrie suggests that young adulthood may be a kind of “critical period” for forming Christian leaders as vocational discernment converges with other life course concerns. In chapter 13, Brent Strawn — speaking from his own experience as a professor in HSTPs — argues that these programs transform the pedagogies of seminary faculty as well, since teaching teenagers emboldens them try new methods that influence their seminary teaching as well. Finally, in chapter 14 we conclude by speculating on the kind of leadership — and the kind of church — that might ensue if theological education took its pedagogical cues from a bunch of teenagers trying to figure out how to participate in the mission of God.
Coming Out of Our Shells:
Learning about Leadership from Lobsters
If playing Bach in the subway will not make us notice innovative genius happening right under our noses, let’s try a different metaphor — lobsters. Here is the gist: lobsters never stop growing. But because they are crustaceans, in order to keep growing, they must shed their shells from time to time. This is the most vulnerable point in a lobster’s life — but since a too-tight shell impedes growth, if a lobster does not shed its shell sporadically, it will die. So every so often, a lobster ingests extra water to bloat itself and loosen its outer shell. Then it turns itself inside out, even pulling its giant claws back through tiny openings at the base of the claw casing, wriggling out of the shell it has outgrown. At one point in the process, it must pop its eyes out of their sockets to get free from the shell, rendering the lobster almost blind during the transformation process. When the lobster finally extracts itself from the old shell, it is utterly soft and defenseless as it waits for the new shell to harden. If it is going to get eaten by a predator, now is the time that is most likely to happen.
You can see why this story was told in a book on ecclesiology. Churches, denominations, and theological schools are in the process of shedding our shells, too. In many cases, we have become so bloated that our structures can no longer support us, and we can feel our shells loosening. Yet we are still mid-transformation, blind to what God has in store for us, uncertain about which direction to go, and we are going to be vulnerable and awkward for a while until our new forms firm up. But if we do not go through the process of shedding our too-tight structures, we will die.
Maybe God created crustaceans who do this by instinct because no explanation could convince a self-respecting lobster that extracting itself from its shell was either possible or wise — any more than any new birth seems possible or wise. Thank heavens we do not have to persuade a baby-in-utero that the journey down the birth canal is thinkable, or convince her as a dependent newborn that this vulnerability is the route to maturity. Such irrationality is what made the incarnation a stumbling block to many. A God who assumed human form, capable of being born and capable of dying, was impossible for the ancient world to imagine, and it certainly did not seem like a wise strategy for saving Israel from its enemies. Yet God’s vulnerability in Jesus Christ is precisely what saved Israel, and us, from the enemy of death — and the church’s current vulnerability may be precisely what God is using to save the church from dying as well. If the North American church is currently experiencing contractions, it is because every new birth requires it.
For those of us committed to forming a new generation of Christian leaders, this scenario means that theological educators and church leaders must not only teach vocational discernment; we must practice it ourselves. Theological education is changing too, and as we grow into our calling to form people who long to participate in God’s transformation of the world, many of our structures are as bloated and blind and vulnerable as any molting lobster. One thing we can be sure of: we will not find our way alone. Like all Christian communities, theological education has a vocation as well. Part of our mission, whether we form people for ministry in formal or informal ways, includes discerning the ecologies that best prepare leaders for the church — not for the church we are, but for the church we are becoming.
Of course, no one (least of all young people) knows what that church will look like or the kind of leaders it will need a generation from now. This makes the quest for Christian vocation less of a holy obligation or an individual career decision than a grand adventure undertaken by God’s people, a communal exploration that tests and recombines elements of a vocational journey until it begins to take shape. Multiple ingredients for vocational formation are laid before teenagers in High School Theology Programs, and each new practice expands the palette as new forms of faithfulness come into view. As Elizabeth Corrie, director of Candler’s Youth Theology Initiative, put it: “Youth [in High School Theology Programs] get a foretaste of the Kingdom — and once you taste it, then you know what you’re hungry for.” As we visit these programs in the chapters ahead, we will see how they help young people taste their possible futures as Christian leaders, and see that the Lord is good (Psalm 34:8).
. Gene Weingarten, “Pearls before Breakfast,” The Washington Post (April 8, 2007), http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/04/04/AR2007040401721.html (accessed July 8, 2014).
. North American theological education’s investment in continuing education in the 1960s and 1970s was a comparable experiment in theological pedagogy. The American system of continuing education — arguably the largest pedagogical experiment in North American theological education in the twentieth century — had its roots in adult educational programs at Cooper Union in New York and San Francisco Public Schools in the 1850s, but did not become widespread until the 1960s and 1970s.
. Lilly funded some programs as “pilots” prior to 1998.
. Barbara Wheeler, “On Our Way: A Study of Students’ Paths to Seminary,” unpublished report of survey data submitted to the Lilly Endowment (August 2013), p. 46.
. We are paraphrasing Frederick Buechner’s famous definition of vocation in Wishful Thinking: A Theological ABC (New York: Harper and Row, 1973), p. 95.
. Isak Dinesen, “Babette’s Feast,” Anecdotes of Destiny (New York: Random House, 1958), pp. 23-70. The story is available online at https://www2.bc.edu/~taylor/babette.html (accessed November 28, 2014).
. In addition to these programs, Lilly also experimented with some HSTPs in other contexts.
. Emily Chudy and Megan LeCluyse, “Promises to Keep: The Importance of Communities of Faith on the Faith Development of Adolescents and Emerging Adults,” unpublished MDiv/MA thesis (Princeton, NJ: Princeton Theological Seminary, 2012), pp. iii-iv.
. The data are based on samples from the United States. Christian Smith with Melinda Lundquist Denton, Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), p. 69. The vocational pedagogy most effective at countering such apathy and superficiality is the long, slow nurture of faith, through families and congregations, that models and practices discipleship as a lifelong pursuit. Families and congregations that offer this degree of intentional religious formation are increasingly rare — but they do exist, and to powerful effect.
. Cf. Smith with Denton, Soul Searching; Christian Smith with Patricia Snell, Souls in Transition: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of Emerging Adults (New York: Oxford University Press, 2009). For consistent findings about spiritually disinclined young adults, see Pew Report, “Nones on the Rise,” Pew Forum for Religion and Public Life, October 9, 2012, http://www.pewforum.org/Unaffiliated/nones-on-the-rise.aspx.
. Alison Pond et al., “Religion among the Millennials,” Religion and Public Life Project/Pew Research (February 17, 2010), http://www.pewforum.org/2010/02/17/religion-among-the-millennials/ (accessed July 10, 2014); also, Smith with Denton, Soul Searching, p. 110.
. I have been among those making this case; see K. C. Dean, Almost Christian: What the Faith of Our Teenagers Is Telling the American Church (New York: Oxford University Press), 2010.
. Chris Hughes, Foundation for Christian Formation (Winston-Salem, NC), personal interview, August 3, 2014.
. Lilly Endowment Request for Proposals (1998), cited by Carol Lytch, “Summary Report I: Strategic Advances in Theological Education: Theological Programs for High School Youth, 1999-2004,” Theological Education 42 (2006): 3. Research on youth groups suggests that attending worship may be a stronger indicator than youth group participation of young people’s connection to church, moral frameworks, and comfort with adults, though youth groups do produce positive outcomes, especially for older youth (who are more likely to say that church is a place they can think). Youth groups’ contribution to faith formation seems to be indirect at best. See Patricia Snell, “What Difference Does Youth Group Make? A Longitudinal Analysis of Religious Youth Group Participation Outcomes,” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 48 (2009): 572-87.
. Lytch, “Summary Report I,” p. 3.
. Lytch, “Summary Report I,” p. 4.
. Cf. Christian Smith’s influential research through the longitudinal National Study of Youth and Religion (especially Soul Searching, with Melinda Denton; Souls in Transition, with Patricia Snell). Also note the Pew Report, “Nones on the Rise,” 2012.
. The first HSTPs were explicitly patterned off the “Governors’ Schools” that aimed to foster civic engagement in high school students. Peers and voluntary associations seem to have a disproportionate socializing effect on later political participation, compared to parents and schools. Cf. Ellen Quintelier, “Engaging Adolescents in Politics: The Longitudinal Effect of Political Socialization Agents,” Youth and Society 47 (January 2015): 51-69; also James Youniss, Jeffrey A. McLellan, and Miranda Yates, “What We Know about Engendering Civic Identity,” The American Behavioral Scientist 40 (March/April 1997): 620.
. Lytch, “Summary Report I,” p. 33.
. Wheeler, “On Our Way,” p. 46.
. At the time this project was conceived, Christopher Coble was a program director at Lilly Endowment Inc., with chief oversight of the HSTPs. He has since become the vice president for religion of the Endowment. The Lilly Endowment — funded primarily by Eli Lilly and Company (the inventors of Prozac) — has optimistically funded most of the youth ministry research conducted in the United States since the 1990s.
. Seminar members included eight academic Christian educators, all of whom either serve as, or work with, HSTP directors at their schools; four practical theologians teaching in American seminaries; and a seven-member research team comprised mostly of doctoral students in discipleship formation at Princeton Theological Seminary. Seminar participants are listed in appendix B.
. One member of the research team — an MDiv student who was hired for the project because, at the time of this study, he had completed a PhD course in empirical research methods and was actively applying to PhD programs — was so impressed by the HSTPs he visited that he pulled his PhD applications and looked for youth ministry jobs instead. (Upon his return from interviewing participants in two programs, he declared: “I want to do that!”) He currently serves as a youth pastor in Washington, DC.
. Barbara Wheeler, “Pathways to Seminary,” unpublished lecture reporting Auburn Seminary research on seminarians (Indianapolis, IN: Lilly Endowment), January 23, 2014.
. Barbara Wheeler, “Pathways to Seminary,” In Trust (Autumn 2013): 7.
. Donald Fairbairn, Eastern Orthodoxy through Western Eyes (Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 2002), p. 70.
. Fairbairn, Eastern Orthodoxy, p. 74.
. Paul Marshall explains that Luther broke with tradition when he translated Sirach 11:20-1 (“Stand by your agreement and attend to it, and grow old in your work”) and 1 Corinthians 7:20 (“Let each of you remain in the condition in which you were called”) by using Beruf for work or calling. There were other German words available to Luther — Werk and Arbeit — but he chose the term traditionally used to describe the calling of someone who took on a clerical position. See Paul A. Marshall, A Kind of Life Imposed on Man: Vocation and Social Order from Tyndale to Locke (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1996).
. Karl Barth read Luther as being against changing stations in life (Church Dogmatics III. 4, “The Doctrine of Creation,” ed. G. W. Bromiley and T. F. Torrance, trans. A. T. Mackay et al. [Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1961], p. 646. This is a contested point; cf. Gilbert Meilaender, Friendship: A Study in Theological Ethics (Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 1981), pp. 86-103 and Working: Its Meaning and Its Limits (Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 2000), pp. 1-24.
. Marshall, A Kind of Life Imposed on Man, p. 26.
. Post–Vatican II Catholicism adopted a broader view of vocation than the medieval or neoscholastic interpretation of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, which linked vocation to certain ecclesiastical positions, though contemporary Catholics still commonly identify the term (if not the theology) of “vocation” with religious orders. The Catholic HSTPs we studied used the word both as a term meaning discernment of a path that follows Christ and as a synonym for being a priest, nun, or monk. See Edward P. Hahnenberg, Awakening Vocation: A Theology of Christian Call (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 2010), pp. xi-xviii.
. Joan M. Martin, “Between Vocation and Work,” in Feminist and Womanist Essays in Reformed Dogmatics, ed. Amy Plantinga Pauw and Serene Jones (Lousiville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 2006), pp. 180-81.
. Miroslav Volf, Work in the Spirit: Toward a Theology of Work (Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock, 2001), p. 107.
. Volf, Work in the Spirit, p. 108.
. Volf, Work in the Spirit, pp. 108-9.
. Volf, Work in the Spirit, pp. 98-99.
. Douglas J. Schuurman, Vocation: Discerning Our Callings in Life (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004), p. 86.
. Schuurman, Vocation, p. 90.
. On the congregational abandonment of the religious formation of young people, see Charles R. Foster, From Generation to Generation (Eugene, OR: Cascade, 2012), p. 77.
. Wheeler observes that the degree of interest in theology and church life that HSTP alumni maintain is impressive especially because most of the respondents came from mainline Protestant, Roman Catholic, or Orthodox programs — “religious sectors that have a hard time holding on to their young people these days” (Wheeler, “On Our Way,” 46). Whether or not young people remain within the religious traditions of their HSTP experience is unclear. Chudy and LeCluyse’s senior thesis research of alumni from Pittsburgh’s Summer Youth Institute (a Presbyterian Church USA program) found that, while SYA alumni still attend worship as frequently as they did in high school, 25% have switched to other denominations, mostly conservative evangelical churches, that often reflect their involvement in parachurch campus ministries in college. See Chudy and LeCluyse, “Promises to Keep,” pp. 50, 58.
. “Religion among the Millennials,” Pew Research Religion and Public Life Project (February 17, 2010), http://www.pewforum.org/2010/02/17/religion-among-the-millennials/ (accessed August 9, 2013). Sociologist Josh Packard is now augmenting this research with studies on the “rise of the dones” — religiously unaffiliated believers (Church Refugees, [Loveland, CO: Group, 2015]). Also see Smith with Snell, Souls in Transition.
. Cited by Lytch, “Summary Report I,” p. 34.
. Wheeler, “On Our Way,” p. 46.
. From 1999 to 2009 the average age of seminarians in the U.S. dropped from 34.4 to 32. If HSTPs had a role in these trends, it was indirect. Other possible (and related) explanations include the increase in twenty-somethings in the general population, young people’s increasing interest in more “altruistic” jobs, and the increase in schools’ financial resources being targeted at younger students — such as investing in youth theology programs. G. Jeffrey MacDonald, “More Young Adults Going into Ministry,” USA Today (August 9, 2010), http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/religion/2010-08-09-youngseminarians09_ST_N.htm (accessed August 30, 2013).
. I am borrowing Greg Jones’ use of “traditioning” as a verb. See L. Gregory Jones, “Traditioned Innovation,” Faith and Leadership (January 20, 2009), http://www.faithandleadership.com/content/traditioned-innovation (accessed July 25, 2014).
. Andrew Brubacher Kaethler, private conversation, High School Theology Seminar Writer’s Retreat (August 30, 2013).
. Cited by Lytch, “Summary Report I,” p. 26.
. Cited by Lytch, “Summary Report I,” p. 26; see footnote 44.
. Cf. Barbara Wheeler and Anthony T. Ruger, “Sobering Figures Point to Overall Enrollment Decline,” In Trust (Spring 2013): 5-11, http://www.intrust.org/Portals/39/docs/IT413wheeler.pdf (accessed July 29, 2014).
. Lytch, “Summary Report I,” p. 10.
. It is no coincidence that I learned about lobsters from a book on ecclesiology. See Paul Sparks et al., The New Parish: How Neighborhood Churches Are Transforming Mission, Discipleship, and Community (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2014).
. Cf. Ivan Schwab, Evolution’s Witness: How Eyes Evolved (New York: Oxford University Press, 2012), p. 59.
. Elizabeth Corrie, director, Youth Theology Initiative (Candler School of Theology), HSTP seminar discussion (August 22, 2013).
