Chapter 12 of 25

Katherine M. Douglass

Katherine M. Douglass

Katherine M. Douglass

Joyce had never heard of a High School Theology Program before her interim pastor brought one to her attention. Joyce grew up in the small town of Lowland, Indiana, in the northwest corner of the state. In her teens, she was feeling a call to ministry, but she had never seen a woman pastor lead worship or offer pastoral care — that is, until she encountered the new interim pastor at her church. In the three months this pastor had been serving Joyce’s church, she had become a mentor to Joyce. One day, the pastor handed Joyce a pamphlet for the Summer Seminary Sampler, the High School Theology Program at Trinity Lutheran Seminary — a program the pastor herself had just heard about — and said, “I think this is something you need to do.” Joyce recalls,

I was also invited to another leadership program later in the summer, and I wanted to go to both, but for both it required the congregation support me in some way. Either the pastor had to recommend that I go or financial aid was needed. So she looked at the congregation and said, “I think that Joyce would be really good for both of these opportunities,” and within a matter of three weeks, they not only had the money to pay for both camps, but they had spending money for me and gas money for my parents, and it was just incredible the amount of support I got. So I said, “Okay, I guess this is something that I am supposed to do.” I came to Trinity and fell in love with it.

In the advocacy of her interim pastor and congregation, Joyce found her leadership potential named, called forth, and supported in powerful ways. Joyce not only went to the Summer Seminary Sampler; she also later attended Trinity Lutheran for seminary. The Summer Seminary Sampler was so formative for Joyce that she decided to volunteer as a leader with the program for several years after her involvement as a teenager. Joyce’s decision to enter ministry emerged from an inner sense of call that was reinforced from multiple directions: it was first affirmed, named, and supported by the minister at her church, then by her congregation, and then by the High School Theology Program at Trinity. And Joyce is not alone.

Our research team heard Joyce’s call story, in one form or another, many times at each of the thirteen youth theology programs where we conducted interviews. Regardless of the nature of the High School Theology Program, having a pastor “tap” young people for these programs and having a home congregation support, commission, and/or “send them out” with the congregation’s blessing were powerful experiences by which many teenagers begin to discern a vocational path pointing toward Christian leadership. When they arrived at a High School Theology Program, they found their still-­unarticulated gifts for ministry affirmed, advocated for, and encouraged. A large percentage of these young people returned home thinking of themselves as passionate Christian leaders, eager to participate in the mission of God.

By “mission of God,” I have in mind theologian Darrell Guder’s conception of the missio Dei, which involves the sense of being sent out from life in Christian community into the world to be a witness to Jesus Christ through one’s daily life. Teenagers in the HSTPs participate in the mission of God as they worship, pray, and build community together, as they feed the hungry, glean alongside the poor, share afternoons with adults who have disabilities, and engage in faith conversations with Muslim and Jewish youth. They learn to listen for the direction of the Holy Spirit, to recognize and subvert evil powers, to restore justice, and to embrace others. Such acts of reconciliation and restoration anticipate the Kingdom of God.

For many youth, participating in a High School Theology Program gave them a first glimpse of what a vocation in pastoral ministry, service, or justice might be like. We heard stories of countless HSTP alumni for whom this was true. Many now serve churches in various forms of pastoral ministry. One became a lawyer working on behalf of immigrants; another started an organic farm providing healthy food for the poor; yet another worked as a counselor for families with children with disabilities. Certainly, countless people who are not Christians work in such jobs, but HSTP alumni enter these vocations with the expressed belief that their work contributes to God’s work in the world — and they name this conviction in startling numbers. They view their discipleship — their particular role in bringing about healing, reconciliation, and justice — as an answer to God’s call. This is their purpose, their vocation.

Before they can respond, however, young people — like Moses before the burning bush (Exod. 3) — must become convinced that they are called and capable of such ministries. For many, this means developing radically new identities as they begin to think of themselves as being healed, gifted, and sent into the world as bearers of God’s healing, justice, and reconciliation. For others, it means building on an inner sense of call and gaining confidence in what God can do with their abilities and vocation. After hundreds of hours of interviews and site visits, our research team concluded that one reason HSTPs are so effective at forming engaged and effective Christian leaders is that they commission and name young people as both called and sent by God and by the church, while providing significant space in which young people can reflect on and build a sense of Christian identity around this calling.

High School Theology Programs play a unique role in the practice of naming that happens as part of the Christian life. Their distinctive contribution is their ability to create intentional communities of naming, discerning, and reflecting upon young people’s giftedness in light of God’s mission in the world. Every HSTP continually challenges youth to reflect on how their particular gifts can contribute to the Christian community and to God’s work in the world. While the face-­to-­face aspect of these intentional communities tends to last for two to four weeks, some programs continue the intentional relationships online, by phone, and through alumni reunions years into the future. The extended opportunity to observe young people in person — undistracted by students’ prior social identities — gives program directors and mentors the opportunity to explicitly notice and name teenagers’ gifts and graces, bolstered by the knowledge that the congregations who sent them have already noticed and named the good work God has already begun in these young people’s lives (Phil. 1:6). For these directors and mentors, naming is a part of the theological and pedagogical formation of the next generation of Christian leaders.

The bold claim of this chapter is that the process of naming (and renaming) forms persons to participate in the mission of God as Christian leaders in the church and in the world. To unfold that argument, we will first explore some theoretical and theological claims regarding the power of language and naming as it creates reality and identity. Next, by placing the biblical narrative of the renaming of Abraham and Sarah beside concrete practices of the High School Theology Programs, we can see the theological and pedagogical power of naming for Christian identity. Finally, we will consider how adults (especially congregational leaders), congregations, and theological education can offer potential leaders the gift of naming, and what this suggests for the work of Christian formation.

A Predecessor and a Princess: Theological and

Theoretical Perspectives on Naming

God’s people have long known the power of naming. At the ripe old age of ninety-­nine, after a lifetime of seeking to live in covenant with God, Abram was approached by God to form a covenant. The Lord said to Abram,

“I will make my covenant between me and you, and I will make you exceedingly numerous.” Then Abram fell on his face; and God said to him, “As for me, this is my covenant with you: You shall be the ancestor of a multitude of nations. No longer shall your name be Abram, but your name shall be Abraham; for I have made you the ancestor of a multitude of nations.” (Gen. 17:2-4)

In the ancient world, as in some communities today, “a new name signifies a new phase in the life of its bearer.” Taken alone, “Abram” means father, but because the Hebrew word for “multitude” sounds similar to the name Abraham, the suffix expands the meaning to “father of multitudes.” God had promised Abram many descendants (Gen. 12), prompting Abram to imagine and attempt to actualize the divine promise through his own efforts. The turning point came when God renamed Abram, confirming the earlier promise, changing Abram’s identity and instantiating a new reality for him to grow into. God’s promised future becomes a part of who Abraham is. Likewise, Abram’s wife Sarai experienced a name change that altered her life and her identity:

God said to Abraham, as for Sarai your wife, you shall not call her Sarai, but Sarah shall be her name. I will bless her, and moreover I will give you a son by her. I will bless her, and she shall give rise to nations; kings of peoples shall come from her. (Gen. 17:15-16)

The name Sarah, meaning “princess,” linked Sarah to the royal lineage that she would produce. In short, Abraham and Sarah entered a new phase of life when God changed their names.

In changing Sarai and Abram’s names, God did not cancel their old identities. Rather, their change in identity fulfilled and expanded upon what they had long hoped for. Abram and Sarai had lived with an inner sense that God was calling them to be parents; they had longed for a child and had gone to great lengths to accomplish this by their own devising. Their changed names did not cancel their desires and striving, but instead indicated a shift in their identity, powerfully altering the trajectory of their lives from desperate attempts to bear children toward a future of fecundity based in God’s power. God’s changing of their names was both a promise and a symbol that a new reality was unfolding.

Of course, Abraham and Sarah are not alone in receiving new names and new identities. Throughout the Hebrew and Christian Scriptures, we see evidence of transformed identities in name changes: Jacob/Israel, Hoshea/Joshua, Hadassah/Esther, Naomi/Mara, Simon/Peter, and Saul/Paul. In Judeo-­Christian history names matter, and the practice of naming wields and bestows power. The practice of naming prods particular ways of imagining and living life in accordance with a name, especially a name that connotes a particular relationship with God. Names convey promises. They instigate new realities.

Both modern sociologists and contemporary theologians echo these ancient intuitions. In their classic work, The Social Construction of Reality, sociologists Peter Berger and Thomas Luckmann argue that identity is formed by society, specifically through the names that society gives to its children: “The child learns that he is what he is called.” Berger and Luckmann argue that language is the medium that transmits reality (and society) to an individual. In their words, “language constitutes both the most important content and the most important instrument of socialization.” In addition to emphasizing the power of language to form identity, they also argue that language is the principle vehicle by which individuals can change reality.

Our research of the High School Theology Programs underscores these sociological insights. Naming — both an activity in which youth are named and an activity in which youth are given opportunities to name — powerfully forms and transforms teenagers’ self-­understandings and their understanding of the world. As Berger and Luckmann explain, putting experience into language shapes the world and our shared sense of reality. When the church invites youth to name the reality of their experience — as well as God’s activity in the world — using the language, symbols, and images of Christian tradition, they do not simply participate in a mental exercise. They exert force on society that, quite literally, shapes the world.

Because language, by definition, names our reality, it is not theologically neutral. Rather, to name a thing is to exert power: naming asserts the truth of an object or a phenomenon. It identifies God’s movement in the self and the world. This power, of course, carries both risks and potential. Feminist theologians are among those helping us sort out the possibilities and challenges that language poses for identity formation. Theologian Sallie McFague writes:

First, feminists generally agree that whoever names the world owns the world. . . . The feminist critique of religious language is an extremely sophisticated one, for it is based on a recognition of the fundamental importance of language to human existence. With Ludwig Wittgenstein, feminists would say, “The limits of one’s language are the limits of one’s world,” and with Martin Heidegger, “Language is the house of being.” We do not so much use language as we are used by it. Since we are all born into a world which is already linguistic, in which the naming has already taken place, we only own our world to the extent that the naming that has occurred is our naming.

Here McFague uses the phrase “our naming” ambiguously to include both being named and the activity of naming. She claims that persons are only a part of a world insofar as they participate in the “naming” activities of that world: “New naming, changes in language, are . . . no minor matters, for if one believes that language and ‘world’ are coterminous, then changes in the one will involve changes in the other, and such changes are often revolutionary.” The thrust of McFague’s argument is a critique of the limits of the patriarchal language for God, but her insight has been widely applied by HSTPs for the broader purpose of identity formation in adolescents.

Yet Christian theology also challenges a simple constructivist view of reality in which language becomes the ultimate and defining force in the world. Distinguishing between human “reality” and ultimate “Reality,” Christians maintain that while language does construct human reality, exerting real and shaping pressures and forces on individuals and their identity, God’s Reality is beyond the limits of language. Human language always falls short of describing God, and cannot fully capture what God is doing in the world. Because God exists beyond human language, naming God does not control or create God. Nor does naming young people — important as it is — ultimately determine them or the world in which they live. Rather, naming proclaims God’s intentions for the world and for us, providing us with what theologian Howard Thurman calls “a crown” that we grow into as we participate in God’s transformation of all creation.

Thus, the naming practices at work within the High School Theology Programs use language in ways that disrupt and reframe the disfiguring reality in which youth have lived, instead opening up perspectives on the divine Reality that defines the world according to the mission of God. HSTPs use naming practices to help youth see the world as a mysterious place where God gives sight to the blind, heals the sick, and brings justice where corruption has reigned — in other words, to help youth hear God’s Reality as different from the world of labels they have been given. In these practices of renaming, young people hear themselves named by God as called, capable, powerful, whole, and beloved.

These theoretical and theological reflections help us see that words and names are not neutral; they are theologically loaded. Names have meaning, give power, and confer identity. They have the power to create, destroy, heal, and open new possibilities. As God changed Abram and Sarai’s identities by giving each a new name, so young people experience the Holy Spirit’s power through the High School Theology Programs’ use of naming and renaming as formative practices.

Practices of Naming and Renaming

The HSTPs are especially attuned to this nominative work of the Spirit, using intentional naming practices both explicitly and implicitly. A mentor or leader might say to a teenager: “I see this gift in you; do you sense it as well?” Or peers may reflect back to one another: “This is the you that I see.” Or, naming can occur as youth are given the space and opportunity to say, “This is who I am, and this is what I believe.” Naming might involve actually receiving a new name, but it also can simply involve hearing a gift or potential identified and called forth. In all these ways, the High School Theology Programs model intentional uses of naming to form young people’s identities, and to commission them to participate in God’s mission in the world. In our research, four practices of naming and renaming appeared prominently in most HSTPs:

1. Commissioning: “I Think You Should Try This”

Joyce felt an inner sense of call to ministry, but only when her pastor identified her gifts in a personal and public way, and when her congregation confirmed those gifts with their emotional and financial support, did she find the courage to take concrete steps toward exploring her call. These acts of support “commissioned” Joyce in the sense that they entrusted her with a kind of authority for the task of Christian leadership. Recognizing the powerful influence of adult mentors in the lives of young people, most High School Theology Programs require an adult or several adults to formally recommend a young person for participation. Program directors emphasize that the recommendation process is not designed to screen for only “the best and the brightest” students (in reality, in the HSTPs — as in most summer programs for adolescents — availability determines a large percentage of program enrollments); nor is the process primarily intended to ensure participants’ readiness for the program (despite program directors’ hopes that this would be the case). Above all, the nomination process is designed to assure the participant that someone else has noticed in them gifts for the ministry of Christian leadership. Often, the person who formally recommends a young person is the same person who had originally brought the program to the teenager’s attention. Although a few young people stumbled across the HSTPs themselves, the vast majority attended after a parent, teacher, youth leader, pastor, or congregation member articulated their gifts, and after their congregation formally or informally commissioned them.

2. Titles: “This Is Who You Truly Are”

Another way naming functions at the High School Theology Programs is by bestowing on teenagers specific titles that reframe their self-­understandings in relationship to God and the world. Berger and Luckmann’s insistence that “the child learns that he is what he is called” rings especially true here. The Duke Youth Academy offers a case in point. At the DYA, adults challenge youth to consider how they are renamed in their baptism as one who belongs to Christ and — to paraphrase Martin Luther — as people called to be “christs” for others, i.e., people whose lives truly reflect Jesus Christ in the world. They are reminded that in baptism they are claimed by Christ and that they become one with Christ in their resurrection out of the waters of death. DYA emphasizes that young people’s new identity in baptism is God-­given and therefore more authentic than any humanly given identity or name. It negates the pejorative and painful identities youth have taken on in the past; it gives them a renewed value, and it sets them on a path of participating in the mission of God. This theologically rooted naming calls young people who they already are (Christ’s), as well as who they are becoming (christs).

Baptismal theology is not the only source of nominative pedagogies in the HSTPs. Some programs employ educational philosophies that seek to honor learners by calling them to live up to high expectations, and to recognize the value of young people’s contributions to the church. At Candler School of Theology’s Youth Theological Initiative, youth are called “scholars” rather than “students,” “participants,” or “youth,” insisting that young people are called to become “public theologians” who identify injustice in the world and act to address it. Adult leaders at YTI report that the nomenclature of “scholars” and “public theologians” helps youth imagine themselves as practical theologians engaged in the crucial tasks of theology, and not as immature learners.

As the first youth theology program, YTI has influenced other programs. Huron University College recently adopted the language of “scholars” for teenage participants in the Ask & Imagine program; director Judy Steers reflected that this change in nomenclature immediately raised youth’s expectations for themselves and made them more invested participants in ways that were profoundly positive. Chelle Huth, the program director at Theological Education with Youth, affiliated with Lutheran Theological Seminary in Philadelphia, explained their program’s decision to call young people “scholars” in order to create a contrast between CrossRoad and young people’s usual experience in congregations:

One of the key reasons that we call them scholars, because they aren’t kids — well, they are kids, but we want them to understand that we honor them in a different way, in a way that they aren’t used to being honored in an institution whose main foci are to teach faith and to teach people to teach faith, and to worship in faithful ways. And so to honor them by calling them scholars, I think, helps set a different tone.

Tonya Burton, program director at the Perkins Youth School of Theology, points out that the naming practices of her program are intended to call forth latent potential in their youth participants and make them aware of who they already are and can become. She explains,

I come here . . . every year highlighting that [youth] are young leaders right off the bat. They may not know that, but we call them young scholars for a reason: to instill those callings [to be practical theologians] already through affirmations, and then [to give] them responsibilities that we deem are characteristics of leaders.

Like Abraham and Sarah, these young people experience renaming as both a promise of what they will be and as an actual inauguration of that new reality. They are already leaders; they are already theologians; they are already scholars; they already belong to Christ — and adults respond to them accordingly. Yet they are also becoming leaders, theologians, scholars, and mature Christians, living into the promise that has been opened by the new names they have received.

3. Naming Particular Gifts and Callings: “I See This Gift in You”

A High School Theology Program tends to operate as an equal opportunity labeler: the same honorific language is used for each teenager in the program who is asked to take on certain tasks before his or her peers. All participants are called to ponder their faith, reflect in community, love God, serve neighbors, seek justice, and act as servant leaders or public theologians. Yet young people have differing gifts, and are called to different kinds of ministries — so the HSTPs also use language that names and reframes specific gifts and callings. Some programs, such as Youth Theological Initiative at Candler and Compass at Gordon-­Conwell, explicitly challenge mentors and leaders to look for gifts in young people and find opportunities to tell young people what they see. A few programs design their entire curricula around the task of ferreting out and cultivating gifted new leaders for the church.

Most programs give youth opportunities to hone particular gifts for ministry. CrossRoad, for example, gives youth an opportunity to preach a five-­minute sermon. After preaching, each preacher receives feedback from the group. When a teenager possesses a natural talent for preaching, the professor, mentors, and the program director take time during the week to affirm this gift explicitly, saying things like: “Wow, you really have a gift for preaching. I wonder if you have any opportunities to preach at home. Perhaps preaching might be a gift God has given you.” Some youth may never have considered talent in public communication to be a God-­given gift, explicitly valued by faith communities. Hearing this gift named (and many others) allows young people to begin to see their particular gifts as having a divine origin, becoming a way in which God has equipped them to serve Christ in the church and in the broader culture.

4. Youth as Namers: “This Is Who I Might Be,

and This Is the World as I Know It”

The power of hearing oneself named as capable, gifted, and beloved cannot be overstated, but that power is amplified when young people have the necessary agency and creative space to name these emerging identities for themselves. As teenagers intentionally reflect on these new aspects of their identities, when they are allowed to ask questions about who they have been, who they are, and who they might become, they begin to own the vocations that others have noticed. Some of these opportunities for self-­reflection come through formal practices and processes. The Interdenominational Theological Consortium’s Youth Hope-­Builders Academy in Atlanta works mostly with African American youth, and aims to build their confidence while strengthening their connections to their families and home churches. The first activity in the summer program each year asks youth to look up the meaning or story of their given names. The goal is to help participants feel solidly grounded in an inherited identity from which they can confidently move forward into the future, even as they experience Christ’s transformation of that identity. The adult mentors at YHBA agree that throughout this process, as teenagers uncover affirming stories about their parents’ dreams for them, they gain a sense of pride in their personal stories. This is particularly significant for those who have stories of distress, and had not previously thought of themselves as having a “goodly heritage” (Psalm 16:6).

Other opportunities for youth to reflect on their own identity — to name or rename themselves — tend to arise naturally when youth can explore, test, and refine their gifts in a discerning community that provides a welcoming space as well as peers and mentors with whom they can “try on” their identity in Christ, to see how it fits. A number of youth, for example, told us that coming to a High School Theology Program caused them to ask themselves, “All of these people think of themselves as having gifts for leadership as a Christian in the world or in the church. Do I have these gifts, too?”

A certain freedom seems to accompany the ability to name one’s own identity. One female participant traced her changing career trajectory to her two-­summer experience at CrossRoad: “If you remember, last year, I said I was definitely going to be a minister, but now I’m not sure. I am really feeling called to something else . . . ” Her program, like many others, provided her the safe structure in which she could try on and take off the names and identities that her parents, friends, ministers, and peers had given her, so she could consider which “name” most authentically described her inner sense of the Holy Spirit’s call.

Frequently, the space provided at the HSTPs for naming oneself allowed youth to claim an identity they would have been reluctant to admit prior to the program. A number of teenagers told us about the anxiety they experienced when claiming their religious faith at home or in school. Being immersed in a practicing, reflective community of faithful peers appears to encourage and normalize the expression of faith commitments. In the safety of these programs, populated by similarly religious peers, young people can practice Christian language without judgment, gaining confidence in their ability to articulate their faith identities. They gain the courage to say, “This is who I am. I am a person of faith.”

Sometimes articulating a sense of one’s religious self has the effect of making other identity statements possible as well. Lancaster Theological Seminary’s Leadership Now program focuses on building a diverse, welcoming community, and youth frequently declare other identities in the context of faith: “This is who I am. I am a person of faith, and I am gay.” Quite unexpectedly, leaders noticed that summer after summer Leadership Now seemed to provide a context where youth gain courage to discuss sexual identity, surprised to learn that two labels — “gay” and “person of faith” — need not be mutually exclusive. Leadership Now’s program director Megan Malick observes that the safety of intentional Christian community seems to give teenagers permission to share dimensions of their lives that they have not shared elsewhere. In the holding environment of a safe social space away from home, teenagers feel free to take risks with their emerging identities, even entrusting these communities with information they had formerly held in private.

Effects of Pedagogies of Nomination

The pedagogies of nomination that occur in the High School Theology Programs form missional faith in a variety of powerful ways. When youth are named, renamed, or given opportunities to name, they participate in revolutionary and transformative practices that change them, and that change the world in which they live. In the HSTPs, naming had many benefits, including (1) opening vocational possibilities; (2) bringing about healing and reconciliation; (3) raising young people’s awareness about their relationship with God; and (4) strengthening relationships with pastors and congregations.

Naming Opens Vocational Possibilities

In a society in which young people are constantly asked, “What do you want to be when you grow up?” — but are seldom made aware that their adult vocation can be a way of living out their Christian faith — naming practices provide crucial opportunities for youth to try on the identity of a Christian leader in the presence of peers and invested adults. Other youth experience High School Theology Programs as a chance to explore vocational possibilities apart from pastoral ministry that nonetheless flow from their faith commitments. For example, most programs introduce young people to Christian adults from an array of professions who explicitly connect their faith to their chosen vocational trajectory. Youth at Lancaster’s Summer Seminary Sampler go so far as to job-­shadow adults who do not work in churches, but who still view their jobs as “callings”; days prior to our on-­site interviews, a conversation with a local funeral director had profoundly moved the teenagers we talked to. Meeting people from various walks of life who articulate faith as a springboard for their work as public defenders, city planners, homeless advocates, physicians, and so on prompts teenagers to imagine how they too might connect their lifework and their identities as disciples of Jesus Christ.

Naming Fosters Healing and Reconciliation

One frequent side effect of practices of naming and renaming is deep healing and relational reconciliation. Names have power to create, but they also have power to destroy, as the current climate of bullying makes bitingly clear. The nominative practices of HSTPs seem to disrupt these patterns in two ways. First, painful labels — instigated by others but repeated and internalized by young people themselves — are challenged by new names drawn from Christian tradition and the experience of Christian community. Instead of “You don’t belong,” youth hear: “You belong to God. You belong here.” Instead of “You’re not good at much,” they hear: “You are uniquely gifted, and we value what you bring.”

The HSTPs overtly challenge the social hierarchies and divisions teenagers have absorbed from media culture and the high school social order (“jocks,” “preps,” “geeks,” “goths,” etc.), disrupting this naming system with rituals of welcome and by offering liminal space where traditional stereotypes can disintegrate. Candler’s Youth Theological Initiative, for example, directly confronts the unjust naming structures of young people’s social worlds in their opening worship service, adapting Galatians 3:28 to proclaim to youth that in Christ, “there is no longer Jew nor Greek, Jock nor Geek.” Likewise, Jessica Driesenga, program director of Calvin Seminary’s Facing Your Future program, relates how one small group that she led, composed of five boys from the program, became a case study for reconciliation across the usual social dividing lines:

One of the guys was one of those tan, very athletic . . . you could tell he was one of the popular kids at the school. He was quarterback of the football team; he was doing well in high school. Then we had another guy who had the long, dark shaggy hair and wore what you might call “Emo” clothing. You could tell that he was not going to be quarterback in high school, and he was not going to be a part of the popular crowd. He had expressed in our group a lot of the loneliness and isolation that he felt and . . . those feelings of not being worthy in his high school because he didn’t have a ton of friends. And I remember the last day him coming to the quarterback in tears because they were friends, and he had never had someone that was in that [popular] group treat him like he mattered.

Such reconciling experiences help youth glimpse what a life beyond labels could look like, as they reimagine their relationships, identities, and values “back home.”

Naming practices also help to heal deeply fractured self-­understandings as well. Ken explained how Hellenic’s CrossRoad program was one place where he was able to share his divided sense of self due to being adopted, and how vulnerable this made him feel. He described how this inward division made him feel defensive, lashing out at those who made fun of him. By naming this pain — and by worshipping with a community of peers who included, welcomed, and loved him — Ken used the faith practices of the Eastern Orthodox tradition to move toward healing, re-­narrating his experience as an adopted child, forgiving those who had hurt him, and imagining how he might help others who feel like outsiders.

Naming Raises Awareness about One’s Relationship to God

As young people hear themselves named through Scripture and Christian tradition in new, theologically rich ways, they arrive at more than just a clearer sense of self. They arrive at a clearer understanding of God and of their own spiritual longings. Naming our innate desire to be in relationship with God is a practice important to every Christian by helping us realign our priorities to become more closely connected to the One who made us. The ongoing National Study of Youth and Religion identified youth’s tendency to think of God as a distant, helpful therapist rather than an active, sometimes disruptive, agent working in their lives. By contrast, youth in the High School Theology Programs are continually asked about what God is doing in their lives, and are expected to give an account of this experience — out loud — or at least pose questions about it in response. Hearing others name their perceptions of God’s activity in their lives (i.e., “I think God is calling me to this” or “I believe the Holy Spirit has given me this gift”) is a way of practicing a vocabulary of faith. Such conversations help youth gain facility with theological language that allows them to notice ways in which the Holy Spirit is at work within and through them.

Naming Strengthens Young People’s Relationships

with Clergy and Congregations

Paraphrasing Erik Erikson, Kenda Creasy Dean writes in Practicing Passion that adult guarantors (Erikson’s own phrase) are “representatives of the adult world who embody worthy ideologies, and who respond to the adolescent’s plea to be recognized as more than he seems to be, with unique potentials needed by the world.” According to Erikson, youth need adults present in their lives as models for what a life (including a Christian life) can look like, and also to provide solid claims against which youth can press. Unfortunately, as Dean claims, few youth have adults who are “there” for them, let alone present and invested in their lives in a role where they could be recognized as “more than [they] seem to be” and as someone with “unique potentials needed by the world.”

The High School Theology Programs swim upstream of this current by providing numerous adults, in multiple roles, who are explicitly commissioned to “be there” for youth, and to draw attention to God’s presence in young people’s lives by naming young people’s God-­given abilities and inclinations. These mentors also invite youth to talk about the way they perceive divine presence and direction. Practices of nomination help adults turn the spotlight of Christian vocation away from themselves toward the young people they love as they help them to recognize, just as their biblical forebears helped young people to recognize, that God loves the unlikely candidate for leadership. The Bible is full of stories about God’s startling renaming of young people who, until the intervention of a divinely appointed messenger, saw themselves only as shepherds (David) or virgins (Mary). In each of these “renaming” stories, God first names young people as leaders and then equips them for the purpose to which they have been called.

While the professionalization of youth ministry since the 1980s has certainly had more benefits than drawbacks, the tendency to import leadership standards from corporate culture has also reinforced the tendency to see youth ministry as a distinctive “department” in the church. The nomination and recruitment processes encouraged by High School Theology Programs blur easy compartmentalization, and strengthen young people’s desire to connect with their pastors and congregations — and vice versa. The challenge of looking within their congregations for young people with interests or gifts for ministry gave ministers a formal “excuse” to talk with teenagers, not merely asking how their soccer team did in yesterday’s tournament, but to actually see and name their gifts for the mission of God. As Joyce’s story demonstrates, to feel noticed by a spiritual leader has a powerful effect on teenagers’ sense of belonging to and purpose in a faith community. In a culture where youth are graded, scored, weighed, timed, and measured on a weekly basis in school and extracurricular activities, the effect of being noticed by an adult who is attentive to gifts of the Spirit is paramount.

Interestingly, practices of nomination were not only helpful on the “front end” of the HSTPs. Many youth described feeling a tension between their “before” and “after” identities — the person they thought they were “before” the program and the person they felt like they had become by the time they returned home. Naming on the part of pastors and congregations plays a pivotal role in helping teenagers to integrate their high school theology “selves” with life after the program. As Christy Lang Hearlson writes in this volume, young people experience the return home in many ways, depending largely on the degree to which home congregations embrace the participant’s new self-­awareness about faith. Nominative practices proved to be significant for young people before, during, and after a High School Theology Program. A congregation’s naming and commissioning of the newly empowered young leader at the conclusion of these programs proved to be exceptionally powerful, especially as churches deployed them for the church’s ministry.

For the majority of the youth we interviewed, the time spent at a theology program was not merely formative — it was transformative. While nearly all High School Theology Program participants identify as Christians before leaving home, many if not most return with a renewed, refreshed, and invigorated understanding of what “being Christian” means — and what they might personally contribute to the church as a result. Thanks to the nominative practices of the HSTPs, these teenagers’ invigorated understandings of their callings often include concrete plans rooted in their named gifts. Countless learning activities in the context of an HSTP — sermon writing, interfaith conversation, theological discussion, or just talking with roommates or mentors into the wee hours of the morning — were calculated to contribute to new understandings of teenagers’ relationships to God and the church.

The Role of Congregations in Naming

The task of Christian communities on behalf of young people — in addition to protecting and empowering them — is to help them discern and name their gifts, and to commission them to use those gifts to serve God and others. We saw how one minister identified Joyce’s emerging sense of call, and how her congregation — in three weeks’ time — informally commissioned her by financially supporting her attendance at not one, but two leadership camps. Some programs take congregational practices of nomination even further, requiring congregations to work with young people on a ministry project at the conclusion of the program, or involving congregants as mentors with young people in between sessions of a multi-­year high school theology experience. At Gordon-­Conwell’s Compass program teenagers may participate only if their congregation nominates them; there is no application process. While program director David Horn says that this has many advantages — including solidifying a teenager’s a sense of call and identity as a leader — there are also unique challenges. As a result, some of the time at Compass is spent inviting young people to question their call, and discern whether their gifts really are for leadership in Christian ministry or elsewhere.

Congregational support and affirmation are key elements in practices of naming that are crucial to High School Theology Program participants. While HSTPs provide liminal space for healing, reconciliation, and identity formation, congregations remain the contexts in which young people must recalibrate their “camp highs” for the day-­to-­day work of Christian ministry. Teenagers quickly learn that the graced existence of a theology program, in which service, worship, reflection, study, and fellowship are orchestrated to flow into and out of one another seamlessly, is not replicable in the week in, week out rhythm of congregational life. It is entirely realistic, however, for congregations and parents to participate in this graced existence by listening to youth narrate their transformative experiences, inviting them into leadership roles within the congregation, and sending and receiving youth through practices of nomination, commissioning, and receiving.

Insights for Theological Education and Leadership Formation

For those committed to forming future Christian leaders for the church and beyond, helping young people discern, name, and nurture their gifts for ministry — long before they need a job — is a critical concern. Seminary education, of course, is graduate education, not catechetical instruction. Nowhere is this more obvious than in seminary intake systems, which rely somewhat on practices of nomination but much more decisively on formal applications, test scores, and undergraduate preparation. Yet the importance of seminaries, divinity schools, and theological institutions becoming organically involved in helping young people name their gifts for ministry before graduate school is, as we have seen, one of the chief benefits of sponsoring a High School Theology Program.

Similarly, the “exit strategies” that accompany seminary graduation are frequently an overlooked but formative element in young people’s call stories. Unlike HSTPs, where teenagers return to congregations that often purposefully utilize these homecomings as opportunities for leadership formation, seminaries and divinity schools typically graduate people into the unknown, and hope that things turn out well. As this project makes clear, a more successful formula for establishing young people’s identities as Christian leaders would make practices of naming and commissioning an intentional part of the curriculum. Theological formation must include intellectual as well as moral discipline, but nominative practices — before, during, and after seminary — serve as a “third rail” to guide missional formation by planting, cultivating, and reinforcing young people’s understandings of their identities as participants in the mission of God.

Perhaps pedagogies of naming matter even more for church “systems” (congregations, regional judicatories, denominations) of leadership formation, since these practices cultivate vocational attentiveness for those who do — and don’t — view their calls in relationship to formal theological education. In 1998, when the Virginia Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church “renewed efforts to strategically focus on encouraging vocational discernment among young people,” conference leaders set out to identify and cultivate future clergy and lay leadership by integrating pedagogies of naming into every aspect of the conference’s age-­level ministries. At middle high camps and conferences, teenagers heard their gifts for spiritual leadership named and encouraged, and they were given multiple opportunities for primary leadership. Conference youth ministry personnel tracked these young people into high school, inviting them to discernment programs and leadership summits. In college, conference leaders requested these young people as volunteers at youth events and employed them as camp and conference staff. Those who attended seminary were also tracked; upon graduation, young pastors were commissioned and placed in peer groups with a mentor who attended closely to the needs of young clergy, helping them discern their future vocational trajectories. It is no surprise that the Virginia Annual Conference has the highest percentage of young clergy in the denomination, and generally boasts an extremely committed corps of lay and ordained young leaders — some of whom were first identified fourteen years ago, at a middle high camp.

The nominative practices of the High School Theology Programs create bridges that connect young people in congregations with broader, more formal systems of leadership formation. They reassure youth of God’s confidence in them by demonstrating the church’s support and confidence in their leadership. By helping teenagers discern their gifts, explore their calls, reconstruct their fractured identities, and name God’s activity in the world, the HSTPs’ pedagogies of naming are powerful vehicles for constructing adolescent faith identities. What’s in a name? When it comes to engaging young people in the mission of God, a great deal.

. Darrell L. Guder and Lois Barrett, Missional Church: A Vision for the Sending of the Church in North America (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1998), pp. 3-5.

. Gen. 17:15-16, Walter J. Harrelson, The New Interpreter’s Study Bible (Nashville, TN: Abingdon), p. 35.

. Peter L. Berger and Thomas Luckmann, The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge (Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1967), p. 132.

. Berger and Luckmann, Social Construction, p. 133.

. Berger and Luckmann, Social Construction, p. 133.

. Sallie McFague, Metaphorical Theology: Models of God in Religious Language (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1982), pp. 8-9.

. McFague, Metaphorical Theology, p. 9.

. Howard Thurman, Jesus and the Disinherited (Boston: Beacon Press, 1976), p. 106.

. In Martin Luther’s treatise The Freedom of a Christian (1520), Luther wrote: “(A)s our heavenly Father has in Christ freely come to our aid, we also ought to help our neighbor through our body and its works, and each one should become as it were a Christ to the other that we may be Christs to one another and Christ may be the same in all, that is, that we may be truly Christians.” Available at http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/mod/luther-­freedomchristian.asp (accessed October 18, 2013).

. Personal conversation, Judy Steers, High School Theology Program Seminar #3 (February 5, 2013), Princeton, NJ.

. Paraphrasing Eric H. Erikson, Insight and Responsibility: Lectures on the Ethical Implications of Psychoanalytic Insight (New York: Norton, 1964), p. 125. Kenda Creasy Dean, Practicing Passion: Youth and the Quest for a Passionate Church (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004), p. 77.

. Dean, Practicing Passion, p. 125.

. Practical theologians tend to resist such compartmentalization, and a growing body of literature encourages churches to re-­imagine excellent youth ministry as the healthy integration of youth deeper into the life of the church. This perspective has gained currency especially since the 1990s, as youth ministry has become more closely aligned with practical theology. Cf. David Ng, Youth in the Community of Disciples (Valley Forge, PA: Judson Press, 1984); Roland Martinson, Effective Youth Ministry (Minneapolis, MN: Augsburg, 1988); Mark DeVries, Family-­Based Youth Ministry (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 1994); Kenda Creasy Dean and Ron Foster, The Godbearing Life: The Art of Soul-­Tending for Youth Ministry (Nashville, TN: Upper Room, 1998); Joyce Mercer, Welcoming Children: A Practical Theology of Childhood (St. Louis: Chalice, 2005); Katherine Turpin, Branded (St. Louis: Chalice, 2006); Andrew Root, Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2007); Brian Mahan, Michael Warren, and David White, Awakening Youth Discipleship (Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock, 2008); Amy Jacober, The Adolescent Journey (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2011); also, Root and Dean’s summary of this shift, The Theological Turn in Youth Ministry (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2011).

. Beth Downs, cited in “Virginia Conference Fares Pretty Well in Latest Clergy Age Report,” Virginia United Methodist Advocate (2012), http://www.vaumc.org/page.aspx?pid=2423 (accessed October 20, 2013). Data are available from the Lewis Center for Church Leadership, Washington, DC, http://www.churchleadership.com/clergyage/um_clergy_age_trends13.html (accessed January 20, 2014). This number reflects all categories of clergy recognized by the United Methodist Church (elders, deacons, and local pastors age thirty-­five and under). The process for recruiting young clergy was explained to Kenda Creasy Dean by Beth Downs and Rhonda van Dyke Colby, personal conversation, Virginia Conference Ministers Convocation, Blackstone Retreat and Conference Center, Blackstone, VA, January 20, 2009.

↑ Back to top

↑