David Horn
Everyone knew his name in school. You had to know Devin because he seemed to be everywhere: star football player, good student, homecoming king. He was popular, and he knew it. I was surprised that he showed up at our four-week summer Compass program. I had heard through the grapevine that the only reason he applied was because of some heavy-handed pressure from his parents, but this happened to be a year when we needed all the candidates we could get, so we admitted him. For the first several days of the program, Devin’s body language made it quite clear that he had absolutely no interest in anything we were doing. But then something changed.
Fast-forward ten years: Devin is about to commit the rest of his life to serving the poorest of the poor in Jakarta, Indonesia. He recently came home for his wedding after serving two years at a remote missions agency in North Africa. In Devin’s words, the four-week journey he took with us in our Compass program was “the turning point of my life and the springboard into a future that I hope will glorify God in everything and will be completely motivated by the love of Christ.” What happened to initiate this dramatic change? Devin had undergone pilgrimage.
Explicitly or implicitly, every High School Theology Program invites youth on pilgrimage, a journey that dislodges them from “home” — physically, theologically, existentially — and sends them forth on a shared journey toward God. Youth leave home for a week or more to go to camp with a group of strangers, or they journey together across geographical, cultural, and linguistic boundaries. In their journeys, the physical displacement of moving from here to there instigates a spiritual displacement as young people find themselves moving from who they were before the experience to a new arrangement of faith and identity.
As a pilgrimage, Compass intentionally disrupts established patterns of thought and habits of life by immersing teenagers in not one, but three disorienting experiences: a week in the wilderness, followed by a week of studying theology together on campus, followed by a week of cross-cultural mission work outside the United States. Afterward, these young pilgrims return to their home congregations to conduct a three-year ministry project with a dedicated mentor. As with all pilgrimages, Compass thrusts young people into liminal space — an experience of dangling in between the familiar and the unknown — with a community of equals. Because Compass is explicitly organized around this spiritual practice of liminal space, the program illustrates how the theme of pilgrimage can be translated theologically and pedagogically for youth.
In this chapter, I will show that pilgrimage in various forms is a potent source of Christian formation for young people — and has potential to inform how we do theological education — if undertaken in a theologically reflective community and for the sake of a larger, lifelong pilgrimage. I will first explore the theological significance of pilgrimage, and then describe the way our High School Theology Program at Gordon-Conwell Seminary utilizes the practice of pilgrimage pedagogically. Finally, I will mention a few ways in which the practice of pilgrimage might inform congregational ministry and theological education.
“From Here to There”: Pilgrimage as a
Practice of Christian Formation
The idea of pilgrimage is a well-traveled theme in Christian spirituality. Whether on the road to Emmaus, the road to Damascas, or the desert road where Philip meets the Ethiopian eunuch, the biblical witness often presents the road as a place of unexpected divine encounters. In Scripture, getting from here to there is an experience brimming with theological meaning. Paul suggests that Adam’s unintended, unhappy journey from the Garden to the briar patch is imprinted on every human being’s life journey. Abram and Sarai uprooted their life in Haran and journey to a new place, receiving new names and identities along the way. Jacob dreamed of angels and wrestled with a divine stranger while exiled. Ruth and Naomi learned covenant faithfulness as traveling refugees. The Hebrew people received God’s discipline and provision as they wandered, becoming a covenant people in transit. Jesus’ pilgrimage with the Twelve led to his death and resurrection and laid the path to our own redemption. The disciples’ journey from cringing fear to Spirit-filled courage set in motion a church called by Christ to go into the world in his name. When God’s people step out on the road, we expect something to happen.
This expectation became deeply embedded in the practices, literature, and culture of the church, and indeed of Western culture, in which we witness characters journey spiritually and physically. Saucy medieval characters set off together one April in Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales, and we know they will have adventures. Christian makes his way toward the heavenly city in Pilgrim’s Progress, learning to trust God on the way. Frodo travels from the Shire to Mordor and discovers the power of small acts of faithfulness. Harry Angstrom journeys through the cultural landscape of middle class suburbia in John Updike’s Rabbit, Run coming to terms with his own fears. We follow these characters as they go from here to there in their lives. We sense destiny drawing their steps, and we know their journey may lead to inner change. This is pilgrimage: the intentional “going from here to there” in life, whether externally or internally, from where we are now to where we hope to go.
Even when these scriptural or literary travelers wander in ignorance of what lies around the next bend, we know they are heading somewhere, geographically and spiritually. They travel purposefully toward a destination, even when it lies far off on a hazy horizon. As theologian Doris Donnelly writes,
To be a pilgrim is to assume a new and risky identity, surrendering all that clutters one’s life so that God takes center stage. To be a pilgrim is to live within the Paschal Mystery of holding on and letting go, over and over again. The investment is total, severe, and uncompromising.
Pilgrims are attuned to the inward as well as the outward journey, opening themselves to the possibility of transformation as they move toward a sacred destination, surrounded by a community of fellow pilgrims. Existentially and physically, pilgrimage is costly — an “interiorization of the via crucis, the way of the cross,” says Donnelly — and, as Devin discovered, it is filled with “unplanned, unbidden, and for the most part unwelcome” change and conversion along the way. Yet pilgrims willingly incur these costs in order to gain greater spiritual riches. If the mystic traveler Thomas Merton is right, when we are “jerked clean out of the habitual, half-tied vision of things,” we gain new insights into the ordinary courses of our lives.
Capturing this potential for conversion and transformation, the High School Theology Programs invite young people to leave their habitual patterns and set out together in the deep, well-traveled ruts of Christian pilgrimage. For example, the Beyond Belief program at Lutheran School of Theology helps high school youth move “beyond belief” to faith in action through an urban immersion week of service in Chicago. Queen’s University’s Future Quest program offers a two-week summer program that begins with classes and service field trips in their community and ends with an eco-spirituality canoe trip at the Frontenac Provincial Park. Tabor College’s Ministry Quest program focuses on vocational calling through a program that spans the entire year, starting with a five-day retreat called “Charting Your Course,” and ending with a retreat called “Setting Your Sail.” The Youth Theology Institute at Candler School of Theology sends their youth on what they call “pilgrimages” to different religious communities, exploring ways in which these diverse religious traditions work for social justice. At the Duke Youth Academy, youth travel around Durham on “Pilgrimages of Pain and Hope,” in which they listen to stories about the city and wrestle with issues of class, race, gender, and oppression. Varied as these programs are, they all insist that a shared physical journey with young people can evoke a journey of the soul, especially when understood in light of Christ’s own journey to the cross.
Translating Pilgrimage: A Snapshot of the Compass Program
The motif of pilgrimage defines the Compass program. The central goal of our program is to stop youth in their tracks and invite them to step out of the normal patterns of their lives and enter into a constructed pilgrimage so that they can more fully understand the larger pilgrimage of the Christian life when they return home. Compass emphasizes the practice of intentional, reflective pilgrimage because young people are all on a journey, whether they know it or not. They travel well-worn paths from their schools to their churches to their sports fields. Their schedules are crammed full of activities as they float from one event to the next with little opportunity for thoughtful transition. Plugged in to their media devices, they face constant distraction. On any given day they are confronted with far more information than they can absorb, and they struggle to pick out a vocational path. Given this cultural menu, young people can be entertained and distracted to death, losing sight of their own goals and passions and failing to notice either the God who is calling them or the fellow travelers God puts beside them.
With this picture of a typical young sojourner in mind, the Compass program invites about thirty young people every summer to remove themselves from the normal distractions of their day-to-day journeys in order to undertake pilgrimage. We call our program Real Ministry Immersion (RMI): real because we seek authenticity, ministry because we focus on vocational calling, and immersion because participants enter totally into several learning environments. The core of the RMI program is made up of three interconnected pilgrimages, or “Expeditions”: the Wilderness Expedition, the classroom Theological Expedition, and the cross-cultural Service Expedition, which run in sequence with minimal transition. The three experiences of wilderness, classroom, and cross-cultural service provide diverse pedagogical opportunities for us to engage our students in pilgrimage. Teaching in each of these settings is designed to be both catechetical and dialogical. A fourth “Expedition” at home follows this intense three-week experience.
The Wilderness Expedition
The first Expedition requires youth to face challenges in the Adirondack Mountains for ten days. They rappel down a mountain, bushwhack through uncharted woods, deal with harsh weather, experience a one-day “solo,” and endure a final eight-mile run, all while striving to relate meaningfully to a community of equally uncomfortable tent dwellers. Throughout, they commit to “challenge by choice,” and the arduous wilderness journey comes to represent the challenges of Christian life.
This first pilgrimage is not merely geographical and physical. Students also grapple with specific spiritual disciplines: daily journaling, prayer, Bible reading, and small-group reflection. These “habits of the heart” are often new to young people and are not always easy, but like the external challenge of climbing a mountain, these disciplines help youth explore, record, and reflect on the spiritual and emotional pilgrimage that accompanies their physical journey.
The Classroom Expedition
The second Expedition is no less daunting than the wilderness trek. The tools of theological reflection in the classroom replace hiking boots and mosquito netting. Over eight days, our youth confront six theological and philosophical questions: (1) Why do bad things happen to good people? (2) How can a two-thousand-year-old book be relevant in the twenty-first century? (3) In a highly pluralistic world, can we really say that Jesus is the only way? (4) Does the Church really matter . . . really? (5) How is one to live “in” the world but not “of” the world? (6) And, given the complexities of life, how do we know the will of God for our lives? Adult leaders encourage youth to consider how these questions inform and shape their everyday lives, and together they imagine how their answers to these questions can direct their steps in life. Although the second Expedition takes place in a classroom, it is no less a journey than the first, as young people move from here to there intellectually and spiritually. Together they travel with other thinkers in the Christian tradition, often ending in a different place than they began.
The Cross-Cultural Expedition
Finally, the one-month program ends with a cross-cultural immersion where young people participate in a service project that addresses the needs of a community very different from their own, including places in Mexico, Costa Rica, and Nicaragua. In this Expedition, youth are fully immersed in the complexities of daily living in a context foreign to them, even as they serve. Living with host families, they must negotiate unfamiliar or uncomfortable living conditions, and they constantly encounter new language, customs, and food. Coming up against the apparent strangeness of another context, they spend considerable time discussing with one another and their adult leaders how their home cultures have shaped their perspectives.
A fourth Expedition extends for three years after the “Real Ministry Immersion” month. Each young person returns home to his or her church with an assigned mentor from the congregation who continues to walk with this teenager as a fellow pilgrim on the journey, as well as an advocate and interpreter for this young person in the home church. Each mentor relationship is sealed with a covenant that binds these fellow pilgrims together for the next three years, both relationally and in terms of a ministry obligation that we ask of each youth. These mentors are encouraged to participate in the last days of our three-week Compass journey, and we orient them to the journey their mentee has experienced. In this way, the intense experience of a pilgrimage away from home flows directly into a pilgrimage at home.
Pilgrimage and Pedagogy
These four Expeditions — three at Compass, and one after youth return home — break young people away from their usual paths in order to walk a road that may be quite new to them, but which follows deep ruts carved by spiritual pilgrims before them. The idea that travel can provoke change is, of course, nothing new. Many schools, denominations, and churches already offer travel opportunities for young people, and the mission trip is a staple of youth ministry. Recently I was on a plane traveling to the Dominican Republic and found myself surrounded by three large clumps of matching t-shirts, each signifying a different church’s good intentions for their youth. To these churches, I would reaffirm that these journeys can be powerful, but they can also be deceptive. Left unexamined, well-intended pilgrimages can easily become tourist holidays.
Doris Donnelly distinguishes between the pilgrim and the tourist, explaining that spiritual pilgrims leave home intentionally seeking to invest themselves in both the journey and the destination for the sake of inward transformation. Not so for the tourist. Tourists are interested in arriving, with as little personal cost and commitment as possible, and are far more interested in themselves than in establishing meaningful relationships with their fellow travelers. To take young people on pilgrimage, and not on a tourist holiday, therefore requires intentionality, attentiveness to both the context and theological structure of the experience, and a great deal of preparation by leaders in both the sending and receiving communities.
Over the years, Compass and other High School Theology Programs have learned crucial lessons about how to help young people become pilgrims rather than tourists. At Compass, we have found certain pedagogical approaches to be effective in establishing a community of fellow pilgrims who journey together. These include teaching through an experiential learning cycle that includes theological reflection, establishing highly structured environments, creating disorienting dilemmas, delaying gratification to heighten longing, cultivating interdependent community, and assisting young pilgrims in their return home.
Outward and Inward Journeys: Teaching through Experience
In each of our Expeditions, we approach the theological realities embedded in our practices from an experiential perspective. Reflecting on the motives of pilgrimage, Doris Donnelly notes that sometimes it is important to pack an overnight bag and to ready our cars “in order to make an outward journey which responds to an interior quest.” Since many youth are already on an interior quest, we provide a way for them to embark on the outward journey that accompanies that quest. But just as the outward journey responds to the internal quest, we have also seen the outward journey motivate an internal quest, dismantling assumptions, raising new questions, and altering perspectives. The outward and inward are inextricably linked.
Although we use selected texts — theological reading is a critical part of Compass — the heart of our program involves a distinctly experiential approach to pilgrimage. This experiential approach plays out dramatically in the Wilderness Expedition as our youth backpack through a marsh, and in the Cross-Cultural Expedition as they journey to another country. But even in the Theology Expedition, we work to challenge our youth experientially through concrete, practical teaching. That being said, experiences do not just speak for themselves. Human beings interpret their experiences in a context; that is what makes experiences meaningful. Young people arrive with their own previous contexts that inform their interpretation of the pilgrimage experience, and we value those contexts. At the same time, we wish to help young people form a more distinctly Christian lens for understanding their lives and the world. For this reason, we surround all we do with purposeful theological reflection and provide language and categories to help them process their experiences. In effect, we set them up to interpret their experiences theologically, without providing all the answers.
Following David Kolb’s Experiential Learning Model, we guide our pilgrims through a path of understanding that flows from anticipation to experience to reflection. Before an experience, we intentionally ask and anticipate questions that they might encounter on their journey. If they will be on a high ropes course that day, for example, we might reflect for the group on the theological significance of what it means to live with success or failure. Afterward, we carefully debrief the theological implications of what they have just experienced, and we develop a narrative of that experience together. Or after a day spent visiting churches of different traditions in inner city Boston, we ask youth to reflect on how those churches may differ contextually from their own, and how those differences are an expression of the Kingdom of God. This pattern of Anticipate-Experience-Reflect occurs on multiple levels — individually, in small groups, and in large group settings.
Trusting the Itinerary: Teaching through Structure
In contrast to the unreflective way in which many youth are accustomed to living, Compass intentionally places youth in structured environments that require them to reflect purposefully about how and why they got “from here to there.” Despite our experiential approach, this pilgrimage is no Jack Kerouac road trip, with the wind in our faces and an open-ended horizon. While HSTPs vary in their philosophies about the educational value of structured time (some emphasize its importance, while others stress the value of permitting young people to decide how, where, and with whom they will spend their time), for one month young people at Compass follow a carefully planned “road map.” Although this map is not explicitly discussed with our young pilgrims, it quickly becomes clear that every aspect of the pilgrimage is designed to have meaning.
Toward that end, each day is structured in ways that define the purposes of the day. Every moment is accounted for from the time youth get up in the morning to the time they go to bed. Each day begins with what we call “Compass Time,” when young people are invited to exercise certain faith disciplines such as Bible study, prayer, and journaling. Each day’s corporate activities begin and end in worship, and the day’s learning events conclude in a small reflection group called “Table Talk,” where youth can process the day together in an assigned small group. We view these as sacred moments that youth must pass through in their daily pilgrimage with God.
At Compass, each day is also defined by specific theological emphases. As they start the day with a time alone for reflection and journaling, youth are introduced to specific theological foci: What does it mean to be called to live a life of commitment? What is the role of wonder, or radical servanthood, or community, or holiness, in our faith? The chosen theme then recurs throughout the day, and youth have opportunities for experience of and theological reflection on that theme. For example, as youth embark on a solo day in which they will be required to live for twenty-four hours alone with a piece of canvas, their Bibles, and their own uncluttered thoughts, we ask them to consider what it means to live lives filled with simple wonder and surprise. At the end of the twenty-four hours, they debrief their experience in small groups and again reflect on the theme of wonder.
Getting Lost to Be Found: Teaching through Disorientation
Like many High School Theology Programs, the Compass experience is designed to be dissonant, even disruptive, for youth. Sometimes getting from here to there involves living “betwixt and between,” to use Victor Turner’s description of liminal space, as the disorientation of the “in-betweenness” of life dislodges our unexamined assumptions. Adult educators interested in transformative education call an experience that launches a process of cognitive dismantling and reconstruction the “disorienting dilemma.” At Compass, practices of disorientation are grounded in the assumption that the transformed life is a disrupted life, and that change for the good requires exercising one’s entire being — mind, body, will, spirit, emotions. Further, a life transformed by God is not always easy; instead, it involves the full breadth of human experience, from difficult, uncertain, and even painful moments to joyful, affirming, and celebratory ones.
Through the three Expeditions at Compass, young people confront multiple disorienting dilemmas that throw them off balance or require them to find footing on uneven ground. They feel the ground literally drop away from under their feet on a high ropes course or a slippery mountainside. They live in close proximity to other youth they had never met before Compass, hearing others’ perspectives and trying to articulate their own as they grapple with thorny questions. They are startled to discover that not everyone thinks or believes as they do, and they may feel a kind of spiritual eyestrain as they peer through the new theological lenses their professors hold up. Having established a cohesive community with one another, they then travel to another country and take up residence in diverse households that operate by new rules, and that eat, speak, joke, and worship in unfamiliar ways. The Expeditions are disorienting and disruptive, often uncomfortable, and because of that, they drive learning. One young woman drew a larger lesson about life from her experience of difficulty at Compass:
When people ask me about Compass, and I know that they really wanted to know about what happened, I tell them that Compass wasn’t always easy, but it was so very good. The good things in life aren’t always easy. There were times during Compass when I was tired, hungry, pushed really hard, or really wanted my family, but those times helped to strengthen me. After going through Compass I know that I can push myself and that through God I can succeed. . . . So yes, Compass was not always easy, but it was wonderful and most definitely worth it.
One particularly provocative practice of disruption used at Compass and several other HSTPs is a “technology Sabbath.” Given the dominance of texting, Facebook, Twitter, smartphones, computer games, and other technologies in young people’s lives, living without them is deeply disorienting for most youth, and panic-inducing for some. Four whole weeks without a text to a friend? Four weeks without checking status updates or watching what is trending? How will they ever catch up when they return home? While the technology Sabbath is meant to maximize face time in community, it has the effect of heightening awareness of the way certain technologies distract and cause distance even as they purport to inform and connect people. Young people return home with a different, more nuanced and critical relationship to their phones and computers. They lose an old path in order to find a new one.
We ground these disorienting practices in larger biblical and theological themes. The incarnation embodies the notion that struggle and even suffering are at the center of the salvation story. Furthermore, the virtue of perseverance persists throughout the biblical account, from Genesis to Revelation. Whole epistles were written to encourage churches experiencing persecution. James, for example, encourages his readers: “Consider it pure joy whenever you face trials of many kinds because you know that the testing of your faith develops perseverance. Let perseverance finish its work so that you may be mature and complete, not lacking anything” (James 1:2-4, NIV).
So rather than suggesting that faith helps the believer to avoid life’s ambiguities and struggles, we assume that a life of faith is lived in the midst of life’s uncertainties and incongruities. If the human condition always involves confusion, unfulfilled dreams, and disappointment, and Scripture acknowledges the same, young people should not be surprised that struggle is part of the life of faith. Purposefully situating moments of disruption in controlled settings with concurrent opportunities for theological reflection stimulates spiritual reflection and becomes the occasion for spiritual transformation. Again and again, participants say that practices of intentional disorientation — getting lost on purpose — are the aspects of our program most likely to set them on a new path. One young man from the streets of Boston declared after returning from a sweaty, bug-ridden expedition in the Adirondacks: “I will never do that again. But I wouldn’t trade that experience for the world.”
Longing for the Far Country: Teaching through Delayed Gratification
Pilgrimage literature plays on a sense of longing: longing for glory, gold, adventure, meaning, freedom, the heavenly city, or even home. C. S. Lewis, whose work so often reflects a sense of longing, uses the German word Sehnsucht to describe what he understands as a primitive impulse lodged deep within the human heart, a yearning or craving that can hardly be put into words, but that nevertheless motivates everything we say and do. Using pilgrimage language, Lewis speaks of Sehnsucht as a “desire for our own far-off country.” Unfortunately, in a contemporary culture of instant gratification, many young people have lost touch with a sense of longing, instead trying to satisfy deep personal and spiritual cravings with material goods and instant experiences.
But young people yearn for more. Pay close attention to the conversations of young people, and you will see their longings rise to the surface. At Compass, we work to help our young pilgrims understand and reclaim a place for deep longing. We create space characterized by restraint, and sometimes by deprivation, as in the case of the technology Sabbath. We put youth in situations in which something is withheld, in which what they crave is not immediately accessible. They want — but do not immediately find — comfort in a rain-soaked forest, facile answers to difficult questions, or easy communication with someone who speaks another language. These situations lead to frustration, but they also lead to growth. In the middle of the Adirondack Mountains, one participant reflected:
The thing is to be here now. So you don’t get caught up with what is going on at home. [The Compass leaders] want you to be here with God and with your peers. So they take away all of our, like, any sense of time that we have. They take away our watches. . . . So you go with the flow. . . . It also helps you trust God more because you don’t really know what you’re doing.
Placed in a situation of deprivation and delayed gratification, this young woman found herself with an opportunity to alter what she yearned for, from something immediate to something far deeper and ultimately more fulfilling.
This “living in the now” is deeply eschatological. Placing youth in situations where things are not easily or immediately resolved, in which they dangle “betwixt and between,” causes youth to rethink what they crave. They learn to live with anticipation, to have a sense of expectation, to distinguish hope from entitlement. By heightening their sense of expectation, we point youth toward God’s Kingdom — a kingdom that calls us to live in the now, even as we long for and journey toward a far-off country.
Traveling Together: Teaching in Community
Pilgrimage is deeply communal. Few pilgrims travel alone, and even those who do rely on the hospitality of those they meet along the way. At Compass, we seek to build authentic community both as an end in itself and as a reflection of the theological reality that we are brothers and sisters in Christ. When we compare the depth of students’ relationships at the end of Compass with the relationships cobbled together at the beginning of the program, we always stand back in awe. What a difference thirty days of living together in community makes! Youth arrive every summer as complete strangers to one another. You can see it in their eyes. Most of their focus is peripheral as they mentally compare themselves with those around them. By the end of the three-week program, they are deeply committed and vulnerable brothers and sisters in Christ. They have moved from being strangers to fellow pilgrims. How does this happen?
We have learned that the best way to nurture deep relationships in community is to foster interdependence. A colleague who directs another wilderness program describes the cultural safety net around affluent Western people as like “living between two mattresses.” There are certainly many wonderful things that can be said about living in a well-padded, highly institutionalized, and affluent society. But one of the unintended casualties is a distorted view of dependency. We — at least those of us in middle to upper-middle class society — have become under-dependent on one another. Our well-padded life styles allow us the illusion of independence and rob us of a sense of needing one another. It is difficult to remain a Christian community if we are robbed of authentic dependency on one another — and, by extension, on Christ.
Compass is designed to intentionally develop healthy dependency — or interdependence — among our youth. In fact, we have found interdependence key to developing authentic community. Each of our Expeditions challenges young people to depend upon one another as if their lives depended upon it. In many ways, their lives really do depend on it, whether when rappelling down a mountain or trusting each other as practice for trusting in Christ. In the Wilderness Expedition especially, small groups are put in situations of physical interdependence. To climb over the mountain may require that the strongest of the group repack his or her bag to add some weight from the backpack of the weakest, teaching both the stronger and the weaker about the nature of Christian community. In the Teaching Expedition, the more informed student must learn to make a theological point in a way that builds up, rather than belittles, his or her less informed classmates, since honest conversations bloom best without competition. The Cross-Cultural Expedition has for the past two years involved designing and creating pieces of public art as gifts for the people of a small village in Nicaragua. To make something long lasting and beautiful has required small groups to depend upon each member’s particular creative gifts, and the cooperation of the whole, to create a common project. Through such concrete experiences of interdependence, community becomes more than an abstract concept for Compass participants. They first embody community out of necessity — and then out of love.
The pilgrim communities that cohere at Compass persist after the Expeditions end. Indeed, for several years at Compass, the “problem” of persistent community kept rearing its head. Thirty or forty Compass alumni, some traveling great distances, would spontaneously show up at the end of our current program and want to participate. We groused that their presence intruded upon the final days of the current cohort’s experience — that is, until we realized what their presence meant. Their arrival signaled that we had been developing a community of faith unlike any that many of these young people had ever experienced. Many of them discovered for the first time that they were not alone in their faith journeys. When we realized this truth, we embraced our “problem” and welcomed alumni, whose yearly visits have since become a legacy of Compass. They continually remind us of the fact that when pilgrimage is undertaken in an interdependent community that shares struggles and celebrations, the relationships that result are long lasting.
Coming Full Circle: Teaching toward the Return Home
Every pilgrimage has a destination — but this is a less simple statement than it seems. On the one hand, every pilgrimage is circular: our young people’s journeys begin and end in their families, schools, and home churches. Sharon Daloz Parks cautions that the current religious culture tends to have “overvalued the journey at the expense of home.” Parks reminds us that, in contrast to immigrants who leave their homeland behind, pilgrims return home; their pilgrimages are not designed to be ends in themselves. Compass uses pilgrimage to prepare youth to return to families and churches with stories about the blessings of the journey.
Yet for some, going home is the hardest part of their pilgrimage. Some return to church communities and families who will never understand or help sustain the pilgrimage of faith young people have just experienced. For others, the challenges are subtler. They return home to familiar territory where they pick up their lives where they left off, complete with all their former distractions: technologies and schedules, old relationships, tired habits. For some, unfortunately, the Compass journey soon becomes an afterthought.
Indeed, the Compass journey is in some ways designed so that our youth never do go home again. Our hope is that in their return, they are far more theologically reflective than before, more intentional about their use of time and technology, more willing to be transformed by disruption and disorientation, more open to the true and hope-filled longings of their heart, and more dependent upon the Christian community around them. Our hope is that they become lifelong pilgrims. Our hope is that in Compass, they will have received gifts for the longer pilgrimage, so that as they move “from here to there” in their lives after the program, they will do so in ways far more theologically rich than they did before their pilgrimage with us.
Specifically, we believe we give participants three gifts for the lifelong journey of faith. First, we give young people certain “habits of the heart” to sustain them along the way. We realize that one month is not enough time to set these habits in stone, but for many, a daily ritual involving the disciplines of prayer, journaling, silence, individual and corporate inductive Bible study, theological study and reflection, and new perspectives on worship and community sets them on a road that makes returning to these practices more likely throughout their lives. We trust that the new patterns of thought shaped by theological reflection in the midst of the real live experiences of Compass will serve as a basis for deeper reflection as they journey onward.
A second gift youth receive at Compass is a profound memory of God’s faithfulness that both informs and sustains their faith in the future. A powerful little story in the fourth chapter of Joshua illustrates the importance of memory as a pedagogical tool. After God divides the waters of the Jordan River so the people of God may enter into the Promised Land, God commands the people to deposit twelve large stones in the river. The stones are “to serve as a sign” among the Israelites, “a memorial to the people of Israel forever” of God’s faithfulness. Faith is built upon memories of God’s faithfulness encountered on the journey. For most alumni of High School Theology Programs, their experience in these programs becomes a faith-building memory, a “memorial” on which youth can look back as a source of strength for the future.
The Compass program gives youth a third gift in sending them off with a mentor and a task. Emphasizing that God calls them to follow and serve in their home communities, we match them with adults who will serve as resources and fellow pilgrims over the next three years. This relationship and the task that youth focus on with their mentor cannot be underestimated; without them, even the powerful experiences of the Expeditions can simply devolve into tourist holidays with a religious flavor. By expecting youth to return home as confident servant leaders who can engage in theological and personal reflection with their mentor, we help them to continue as pilgrims who seek God, rather than as tourists who simply recall a fun trip.
Lessons for Forming Disciples
What might all this mean for those charged with forming young people into disciples who see themselves as part of God’s pilgrim people? What might it mean for theological education? First, and most simply, we should not underestimate the potential of a physical journey to launch the inner journey of faith. Richard Niebuhr says that we acquire ourselves not in abiding only, but also in moving. In an era in which “going away to seminary” is becoming a rarer phenomenon and in which more people are training for ministry in home contexts, we must still consider ways in which people can engage in pilgrimage of body, mind, and heart. Something about the act of travel, of being displaced and “homeless,” even briefly, provides tremendous opportunities for growth and personal transformation. This “ruptured” time, says Fredrick Ruf in his book, Bewildered Travel, is nothing short of sacred.
Such ruptured time can serve as a testing ground for young people and seminarians alike, as they reexamine their assumptions about life and God and discern anew their life plans and sense of self. Such testing makes a difference in vocation. In Auburn Theological Seminary’s study of best seminarians, a time of “testing” proved to be a necessary crucible for many seminarians’ call to ministry. Yet we seldom leave sufficient room for such testing. Many of the youth we work with at Compass have been made to assume that failure is not part of a good pilgrimage, and that human effort should only lead to success. When youth experience the “betwixt and between” of challenging pilgrimages within a supportive community, they find safe places to test their assumptions, their courage, and their sense of call.
Providing such safe places for testing is also becoming an increasingly important role for theological institutions, as fewer seminarians arrive well formed in faith practices or knowledgeable about their own faith traditions. What might happen if more theological educators imagined and treated their students as pilgrims, remembering the ambiguity and disorientation such an identity brings with it, and providing challenge, support, and community as the necessary context of pilgrimage? More specifically, what might happen if theological schools expected all students to undertake concrete experiences of pilgrimage during their studies, as a way to help them counter the lure of immediate gratification, or to grapple with the realities of disorientation and disruption in ministry? Such pilgrimages might take the form of border-crossing immersion experiences, semesters spent at other theological institutions, a year away from classes doing full-time ministry, or service and mission expeditions with other students — all accompanied by theological reflection. These pilgrimages could make a difference not only for students but also for theological institutions if schools were receptive to the lessons their student-pilgrims learned, affirming students’ journeys and providing a forum for them to share their experiences.
Such affirmation of pilgrimage matters deeply not only for seminarians, but also for young people. Our experience at Compass is proof positive that youth think deeply and passionately about theology, yet these youth are seldom treated in their home congregations as capable pilgrims on a spiritual journey. The church actually has an advantage over programs like Compass, since pilgrimages become much more meaningful when they are publicly honored and shared by the broader faith community. Congregations have the capacity to publically confirm youth as pilgrims setting out on a journey and affirm them afterward in the presence of the congregation. Doing so not only shows young people that adults care about the changes going on in their lives, but that the church considers those changes sacred. As young people embark on journeys of faith, the church can celebrate with them, reminding young people and the whole church that to be God’s people is to be a pilgrim people, traveling onward in hope, seeking the far country together.
. See Victor and Edith Turner, Image and Pilgrimage in Christian Culture (New York: Columbia University Press, 1978), p. 6.
. Doris Donnelly, “Pilgrims and Tourists: Conflicting Metaphors for the Christian Journey to God,” Spirituality Today 44 (Spring 1992): 20, http://www.spiritualitytoday.org/spir2day/92441donnelly.html (accessed October 22, 2013).
. Donnelly, “Pilgrims”: 20.
. Richard R. Niebuhr, “Pilgrims and Pioneers,” Parabola 9, no. 3 (August 1984): 12.
. Donnelly, “Pilgrims and Tourists”: 20-21.
. Donnelly, “Pilgrims and Tourists”: 20.
. Victor Turner, “Betwixt and Between: The Liminal Period in Rites de Passage,” in The Forest of Symbols (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1967).
. Cf. Jack Mezirow, Transformative Dimensions of Adult Learning (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1991). While the “disorienting dilemma” is commonly associated with adult education, its power is not lost on teenagers.
. C. S. Lewis, Preface to The Pilgrim’s Regress: An Allegorical Apology for Christianity Reason and Romanticism (London: Geoffrey Bles, 1956), p. 10.
. Victor Turner speaks of the forming of community within liminal space as communitas and describes it as a community much like I am describing here, as shared fellowship, spontaneity, and warmth fostered by a common pilgrimage that breeds a sense of equality and harmony. See Victor and Edith Turner, Image and Pilgrimage.
. Sharon Daloz Parks, “Home and Pilgrimage: Deep Rhythms in the Adolescent Soul,” in Growing Up Postmodern: Imitating Christ in the Age of ‘Whatever,’ Princeton Theological Seminary Institute for Youth Ministry (Princeton, NJ: Princeton Theological Seminary, 1999), p. 55.
. Niebuhr, “Pilgrims and Pioneers”: 8-10.
. Frederick J. Ruf, Bewildered Travel: The Sacred Quest for Confusion (Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 2007), p. 74.
. Barbara Wheeler et al., “Pathways to Seminary: Where the Best Students Come From,” In Trust (Autumn 2013): 7-8, http://www.intrust.org/Portals/39/docs/IT_Autumn2013-Wheeler.pdf (accessed November 28, 2013).
