Andrew Brubacher Kaethler
Kristi participated in !Explore, the High School Theology Program at Anabaptist Mennonite Biblical Seminary, in 2005. Kristi is from a small town in rural southern Ontario, near Lake Huron. The people of her church are not particularly progressive or highly educated, but they are honest, hardworking people who want to do well by their children. Kristi was deeply involved in this congregation. While her church affirmed her, it did not push her to expand her world. Being adventurous, she took the risk of exploring the wider world of her denomination and theological tradition. Her parents facilitated her participation in denominational youth events, which afforded Kristi additional leadership opportunities within the Mennonite church. She credits the adults in her church and denomination with trusting her with leadership early on and for believing that when youth are given the opportunity, they rise to the challenge.
!Explore allowed Kristi to expand her world and to witness the diversity of the Mennonite church. Even though her hometown is only five hours, three hundred miles (500 km), and one international border away from Elkhart, Indiana (where Anabaptist Mennonite Biblical Seminary is located), spending eighteen days with Mennonite youth from across Canada and the USA, including African American and Hispanic Mennonites, launched her on a journey that would carry her much farther than the three hundred miles that brought her to !Explore.
At !Explore, Kristi encountered a context and structure for living into her questions of faith, and for discovering new sets of questions evoked by her encounters with other youth. Finding new questions, rather than new answers to old questions, energized her. Also exciting were the new vocabularies she learned that deepened and enriched her faith: the vocabularies of biblical theology, of ritual in worship, of service, and of other Mennonite groups, including African American Mennonites and Mennonites from Western Canada. Within the structure of this High School Theology Program, Kristi found a community in which to test her new vocabularies, and to explore what they meant for her own faith, identity, and emerging sense of vocation.
In this way, !Explore introduced Kristi to the joys of theological reflection, an activity that can (and should!) permeate our days as Christians. Kristi later reflected that she wished she had received fewer devotionals for youth about abstinence from sex and drugs, which was not her scene as a teenager, and instead had been invited into more conversations about Christian education of children and outreach to the community, where her emerging interests and passions lay. Like Kristi, many participants articulate that the most exciting thing about the program is meeting other young people who want to talk about God and the church!
Kristi grew in her identity as a follower of Jesus at !Explore. Theological conversations challenged her to build upon the foundation her congregation had provided. She commented that she had “always taken Jesus seriously,” but hearing other youth articulate their faith gave her new terminology and new categories for understanding her faith. The fact that others listened to her theological questions and wanted her to contribute to theological conversations introduced her to the notion that to be a Christian is to be a theologian — to think deeply about God and God’s call in our lives, individually and collectively; to reflect on the centrality of community in worship, fellowship, and service; and to contemplate the normativity of Jesus’ life of healing and suffering for Christians today. In !Explore, these topics were discussed not only in formal class settings where professors and adult leaders guided the conversations, but also in informal settings between students at the dinner table or while driving to a learning site. Kristi met people who lived by a common purpose, and people who dedicated their whole lives — not just a weekend or night of the week — to service and reconciliation in Christ’s name. These encounters expanded Kristi’s horizon of what a fruitful Christian life could look like.
Disruptive Continuity: The Vocational Rhythm
of Formation and Transformation
!Explore prompted Kristi to grow as a leader. It clarified her understanding of the work of a pastor, and it highlighted and expanded her repertoire of leadership gifts. Most importantly, this HSTP prompted questions about places where the work of a pastor and her own leadership gifts converged. In the years following !Explore, Kristi continued to teach Sunday school in her home congregation. She expanded the contexts in which she accepted leadership, becoming involved with chapel services while at university. While her congregation did not actively encourage women to consider the pastorate, they did encourage Kristi. After graduating from college, the campus chaplain encouraged Kristi to consider an interim youth pastor position, which precipitated an agonizing process of discernment. The short-term, part-time position did not scare her; rather, for the first time she identified patterns and themes in her life coalescing around pastoral ministry, and sensed she was on the verge of taking a big step toward claiming a particular identity and vocation. Kristi took a deep breath and jumped in. Today, Kristi is a “permanent” youth pastor in another Mennonite church in southern Ontario, with male and female pastoral mentors who empower her and help her solidify an identity as a young pastor. Kristi notes that beginning this long-term position forced her to confront new aspects of her identity and calling, even as it built on her prior leadership experience.
You’ll notice a rhythm in Kristi’s life that first became evident in her summer at Anabaptist Mennonite Biblical Seminary. Past experiences of faith are recognized and honored, while surprising encounters with God, self, and others give her new frameworks for thinking about faith, and launching her discipleship in new directions, as the cycle starts anew. Although !Explore was clearly a key step in the process by which Kristi became a young pastor, it did not effect a seismic about-face in her young faith, identity, or vocational aspirations. Yet that is what makes her story interesting: her journey demonstrates how the development of faith, identity, and vocation depend on both formation and transformation, two concepts that tend to be bifurcated and treated as binary options in leadership development and in ecclesial ecology.
Rather than standing opposed, formation and transformation wind through Kristi’s story in a cyclical, symbiotic relationship. She was formed in her ordinary congregation through slow-paced, enduring practices and faithful adult companions, and this formation helped her open up to God’s extraordinary transformation in intense experiences at !Explore. In turn, Kristi engaged in ongoing faith, identity, and vocational formation at university. This process of inquiry and development continues for Kristi even now. “I preached a lot this summer,” Kristi said recently. “I don’t like it when I have to preach so often. Like, really, who am I to preach the Word of God to all these people?” We can answer: she is a servant of God, formed by God through her community, transformed by God alongside her community, and ultimately, blessed by God and her community. She is still on a journey — a pilgrimage, as chapter 10 of this volume describes it — marked by a recurring cycle of formation, transformation, and blessing.
Imagining Kristi’s story as a journey provides us two rich metaphors for formation and transformation: home and pilgrimage. Kristi’s story illustrates that Christian pilgrimage begins at home. Having a home to depart from, physically and metaphorically, is the necessary prerequisite for the journey. Home and pilgrimage illustrate that formation and transformation are complementary, not competitive, elements of the development of faith, identity, and vocation. Formation occurs at home, in the family or home congregation, but during experiences of pilgrimage we become especially receptive to the inbreaking, transformative work of God and the Holy Spirit.
This chapter will argue that both formation and transformation are essential for growing in faith, developing identity, and discerning vocation. Formation provides stability by underscoring the foundations of faith, while transformation occurs when encounters with truth disrupt our cultural assumptions and invite a reorientation toward the good news of the gospel and the Kingdom of God. This chapter offers a theological account of the disruptive nature of encountering truth, as well as a pedagogical account of the necessity of disorientation and disequilibrium. I will suggest that disruption and disorientation are not ends in themselves but rather are opportunities to displace cultural assumptions with commitments oriented around the good news and the Kingdom of God. Finally, I will suggest how we might incorporate pedagogies of disruption and reorientation into the church, home, and school — wherever Christian leadership takes root.
Holy Confusion: The Theological and
Pedagogical Importance of Decentering
Formation is a process of centering. Transformation is a process of recentering. In between centering and recentering is the necessary stage of decentering. Pilgrimage allows us to leave the familiarity of home to explore new geographical, social, and existential places, creating a liminal space for cognitive, emotional, and spiritual discovery. The point of disruption and deformation, to be clear, is not simply to introduce chaos. The purpose is to unmoor comfortable, assumed, handed-down perspectives and to create a space into which God’s inbreaking truth may be recognized in new ways.
Jesus engaged in a kind of centering, decentering, and recentering, as a number of prominent biblical examples demonstrate. He left his home in Galilee and, after being baptized by John, he journeyed into the desert to be decentered and recentered before facing temptations by Satan (Matt. 4:1-11). Similarly, Jesus regularly engaged in practices of withdrawal and return, culminating in his retreat to the Garden of Gethsemane where he decentered and recentered his ministry before his arrest and crucifixion (Matt. 26:36-46). This decentering and recentering allowed Jesus to confront his divine identity and embrace the truth about God’s love and desire for humanity and for all of creation.
Getting All Turned Around: Truth and Decentering
Truth is always disruptive. The New Testament word for the disruptive nature of truth is metanoia, meaning a change of mind, heart, and behavior. It is the process of turning — not merely a turning from, motivated by guilt or shame, but a turning toward, drawn forward by the light of truth. Metanoia is the process of truth telling and healing that Jesus himself often initiated in those whom he encountered. The center of Jesus’ teaching ministry was characterized by the call to metanoia (Luke 15:7), illustrated for his listeners and followers though numerous parables.
In the parable of the Prodigal Son, the son has a change of mind, heart, and behavior toward his father, spurred by his hedonistic excursion and subsequent desperation (Luke 15:11-32). In a later parable in the same section, Jesus confronts his listeners with an unsettling truth about how wealth distracts from the way of the Kingdom of God (Luke 18:18-30). Zacchaeus also responds affirmatively to the disruptive truth of God, changing his perspective and making things right with those he had cheated or oppressed (Luke 19:1-10).
Such encounters suggest that truth, in the New Testament view, is not best understood as a “thing,” a possession, an idea, abstract concept, or a disembodied principle. It is, rather, an “event.” Admittedly, it is possible to observe truth passively, but to do so misses both the transformative power of truth and the full impact of God’s communication with us. According to the witness of Scripture, God confronts us with truth. God presents truth in such a way that it needs to be encountered and wrestled with. Truth, when fully encountered, moves us, from one place and perspective to another. It is a disruptive event because it then forces us to reorganize our view of God, of humanity, and of the world, and it prompts us to relocate ourselves in relation to each of these.
John Caputo compellingly articulates this understanding of the disruptive nature of “truth as event.” Caputo revisits Charles Sheldon’s century-old question, “What Would Jesus Do?” Although this question has become a thoroughly domesticated and commodified cliché through the WWJD movement of the 1990s and early 2000s, Caputo claims this question was originally posed by Sheldon to disrupt the Christian’s assumed and complacent view of things, especially social realities. When we are content with the “same” and with the familiar, Jesus, according to Sheldon, introduces us the “other,” to the poor and to those who are on the social periphery. By encountering the other, we are reminded that the good news of the gospel is always “good news for the other,” not just for me, and while the gospel’s truth may be disruptive, it is never “imposed coercively.” Truth, then, is not a gift we can give ourselves; truth is the disruptive gift of the encounter with the other.
This is why holding tightly to assumptions or preconceived conceptions of people, places, or situations can stymie us from fully encountering the disruptive nature of truth. In the first place, unchallenged assumptions simply prevent us from seeing disconnects between old perspectives and new ones. Moreover, we become fearful of the domino effect: What if accepting this new truth affects other perspectives, values, and behaviors we hold dear?
The Art of Truth-Telling: Recentering in the
High School Theology Programs
These assumptions that we hold dear, but seldom acknowledge or seriously question, fall under the rubric of culture. In order to encounter the truth event of the gospel, we all need to be able to acknowledge and name the cultural assumptions by which we live. Many High School Theology Programs are transformative because they introduce youth, implicitly or explicitly, to cultural hermeneutics — the process of reading and interpreting culture, similar to the way biblical hermeneutics is the process of reading and interpreting the Bible. It is appropriate that Christians read and use the Bible to affirm and critique culture, but, as the African theologian Musimbi Kanyoro contends, without a critical awareness of how culture shapes our assumptions, and without the independent skill of being able to read culture, Christians are prone to respond to culture in quasi-Christian ways. Either we read the Bible as a blind confirmation of culture — including its destructive and harmful aspects, like material consumption, militarism, or nationalism — or we categorically reject culture, associating it predominantly with sin or with secularization.
What elements of culture need to be named? From what cultural assumptions might young Christians need to be dislodged? Before we can be recentered in the gospel, we need to read culture in a way that disentangles the good news of Jesus as presented in Scripture from pseudo-gospels and ideologies of individualism, consumption, and entitlement. These three “malaises of modernity,” identified by philosopher Charles Taylor, are instructive. The first malaise, individualism, highlights the “disenchanted” nature of the modern world. Modern social, political, and economic orders allow little space for the divine presence, which means that humanity is no longer routinely viewed as part of a divinely ordained, created, cosmic order. The second malaise — the widespread employment of instrumental reason — considers solutions to economic, social, and political problems mostly on a “cost-benefit” calculus. Money and “efficiency” are prioritized over human lives and meaning-making tasks, reducing human identity to that of a consumer, instead of recognizing the complexity of persons being consumers and producers, family members, global citizens, stewards of creation, fellow creatures, etc.
The third malaise, ironically, is the loss of social freedom as people lose control over the narrowing strictures of politics, economics, and technology. Living “against the grain” is increasingly difficult. People feel alienated from the public sphere. While Taylor celebrates the emergence of the modern “self,” he laments its disconnect from social, epistemological, and political contexts. As a philosopher, Taylor argues that the self is not an autonomous self, but is always a self-in-social-context — a position Christians cannot help but recognize as a theological claim.
High School Theology Programs give youth language and tools for analyzing the human condition, and equally important, a community that does such analysis together. The themes of individualism, consumption, and entitlement are common themes addressed in these programs as youth subject them to prophetic critique. Chelle Huth, the Project Director of the Theological Education with Youth (TEY) program at Lutheran Theological Seminary, Gettysburg, articulates the importance of language, tools, and community like this:
[TEY invites youth into] a deeper understanding of being Christ’s, of being a child of God, to ask how do I live with that identity every single day. . . . The language we use is the contract language of the covenant. . . . [We ask,] “how do we live as people of the covenant?” Because God loves us, therefore I will feed the hungry, I will meet the needs of my neighbor, and I will sit with those who are the other. And so we use a lot of covenant language in TEY, and the response of the [youth] scholars has been that it has given them a clearer understanding of what it means to be a baptized child of God, [a fuller understanding] than any confirmation program that they have ever been in in any congregational setting. So, by giving them that deeper understanding and answering their questions, it is adding to the foundations that have already been placed by families or congregations. . . . We are just adding more foundational pieces to it so that their foundation is stronger and broader and deeper.
An alumnus (and eventually counselor) from Candler School of Theology’s Youth Theological Initiative (YTI), reflects on the way YTI worked to provide youth with language, tools, and a community in which they could analyze entitlement, race, and class in America without silencing those who actually experience injustice:
The private school white kids are the ones who are more likely (or, ironically, maybe not) to have vocabularies about privilege and structures of injustice. [Privileged youth] are able to theorize these things in ways that [less privileged youth] scholars who have been going to underfunded inner city schools have the experience to analyze. The youth from underfunded schools are certainly able to analyze structures of injustice, but maybe not with a sense of safety that the dominant group has.
As these reflections suggest, the HSTPs intentionally set out to help young people analyze culture in ways that encounter truth and, consequently, reveal God’s intentions for their lives in new ways. These programs are not simply working against culture; rather, they are operating from an alternative center that is distinct from the foci of the dominant cultural ethos. Countering the dominant culture’s focus on individualism and entitlement, YTI encourages youth to think about Christian theology’s emphasis on liberation, diversity, and solidarity. Challenging the dominant cultural center of consumption, TEY focuses on the biblical and historic Christian concept of covenant.
Pedagogies of Decentering: The Spiritual Benefits of Disequilibrium
For many youth, the learning that occurs in the relatively short time span of a High School Theology Program is both formative and transformative. For some, the experience is immediately and radically transformative; for others, like Kristi, it is more like a tsunami wave forming far from shore, intensifying over time as it approaches land. Either way, an important step in the pedagogical process is disembedding young people from their accustomed perspectives by creating experiences of disequilibrium through which teenagers encounter the other and are confronted with the event of truth. Such encounters and confrontations can disrupt a young person’s existing identity, schema of the world, and vocational aspirations. They pose a disorienting dilemma, to use the terminology of transformative learning theory, creating psychological, intellectual, and moral disequilibrium through constructed experiences that disrupt, sometime gently and sometimes more vigorously, inherited and familiar identity, convictions, and set of behaviors.
Disequilibrium is neither an end in itself, nor simply an educational strategy — for many young people experience chronic disorienting dilemmas in the course of their daily lives long before arriving at a High School Theology Program. The point is not simply to be disruptive. The purpose is to prompt and precipitate affective, cognitive, and effective reorganization and reorientation, with the help of an intentional reflective process and a community of support that can “hold” the young person in the state of disequilibrium as new insights emerge. The purpose is to create space in which the Holy Spirit’s inbreaking can be discerned more readily, and in which the Word of God, the good news that is truly good for all humanity and truly new for our time, can be encountered.
The HSTPs capitalize on numerous “disorientations” that young people confront in the course of these programs. One type is simply geographical disorientation: being transplanted from a familiar environment to an unfamiliar environment. By itself, geographical disorientation does not necessarily cause disequilibrium, but it is frequently a correlate to other unfamiliar experiences. Another type of disorientation is ethical or moral disorientation, where some previously held conviction or behavior is challenged and juxtapositions emerge that beg to be resolved. A third type is worldview or cultural disorientation, in which a disorienting dilemma prompts whole-scale questioning of previously held cultural schemas. This can result from the accumulation of smaller dilemmas and disequilibria, or from major ones that are urgent and command deep attention.
Transformative learning theory emphasizes the roles that both educators and learners play in disequilibria. The educator actively and carefully cultivates an environment in which transformative learning can occur. Unsurprisingly, a strong correlation exists between students who experience healthy disequilibrium in HSTPs, and those who claim strengthened identity, greater vocational clarity, and renewed faith as a result of these experiences. Occasionally participants encounter a disorienting dilemma that is overwhelming, perhaps because it is unintentionally presented or is presented recklessly. Such moments underscore the fact that disequilibrium is not good in itself, and requires adult leaders who are sensitive to each individual participant so as to ultimately facilitate reorientation.
Take, for example, the students from Hellenic College’s CrossRoad program, one of the sites where our researchers spent time with teenagers during the summer of 2012. As part of the CrossRoad program, teenagers spent a day with a homeless community in Boston, an experience that one counselor said was designed to help youth “go deep” and “grasp on to something real.” By all accounts, the experience was jolting for the participants because it placed them in unfamiliar geographic, economic, and social contexts. Buying food for a homeless person was only initially difficult. What was an ongoing source of discomfort, however, was figuring out what to say to a homeless person, or how to respond to her or his story. When one homeless person rejected their help, youth were left feeling “shocked and confused.” The physical, interpersonal, and cultural disequilibrium came as a result of teenagers trying to befriend and care for people in the very short term, while at the same time realizing that there are long-term roots to problems of homelessness, and also long-term processes needed to affect change. As the counselor put it, youth found it “heart-wrenching” to think about where a homeless person might get his or her next meal — but even more heart-wrenching to wonder when they might have their next conversation with someone who cares.
In Sunday School, the counselor noted, these youth did not really have to wrestle with vocation, but here, on the street, questions about their own faith, identity, and vocation were suddenly paramount. Young people were forced to align the stories of homeless people with their own stories, and with “stories of the Bible, [where] you learn that God loves everybody.” One student, Cindy, reflected that the immersion experience was a way to “refocus” and to “practice the love that we are taught.” John, another participant, observed how the experience challenged approaches to service that have their roots in consumer culture: “[Helping others] is not something you do to make yourself feel better, because that’s not what serving is. You serve to care for someone, not to make yourself feel better.” When young people realize that homelessness does not exist so that middle-class teenagers can consume another “experience,” they are forced to rethink their own faith, identity, and vocation, reconsidering the good news of the gospel as good news for all, including the homeless men and women they met on their immersion day.
In the end, the test for disequilibrium’s usefulness in vocational formation is not only that High School Theology Programs create space for reworking identity, faith, and practice, but also that they create the conditions for youth to be introduced to the other and to the event of truth. In other words, disorientation is not merely a psychosocial phenomenon prompting youth to a new developmental stage. It is also a theological phenomenon in which God is given the opportunity to speak a new truth into the life of a young person. The disorientation that HSTPs cultivate is not disruptive for the sake of being disruptive, but this disorientation instead strives to be directive. By directing youth into encounters with God in the other, the HSTPs position youth to struggle with concepts of justice, forgiveness, or grace, and to rely on certain sources, such as Scripture, Christian narrative, and the Holy Spirit, as they reorient their own lives toward Christ.
Call Me Weird: Nurturing an Ec-centric Faith
Singer/songwriter and Scripture evangelist Bryan Moyer Suderman writes, “When you learn to follow Jesus you will act a little strange. People stop and take a look.” These lyrics capture the truth that, when Christians follow Jesus as if Jesus is truly Lord of all areas of our lives, we look odd from the perspective of broader culture. Re-aligning their faith, identity, and vocational aspirations with the good news of Jesus is a countercultural act for young people. To begin imagining life “in sync” with the good news of Jesus Christ, but significantly “out of sync” with the dominant culture, requires a skillful sense of cultural hermeneutics, and the ability to identify, name, and analyze contemporary Western cultural values from the perspective of Christian faith. Experiencing life with a community of youth and adults for a short period of time — typically ten to thirty days — affords participants the opportunity to learn, test, and practice a new language of prophetic witness and cultural critique. This countercultural language is not at all anti-cultural. It is countercultural, and the difference between these deserves explanation.
Encountering new languages and ideas can be discomforting or annoying. When that which we encounter calls us to live differently, it can feel dangerous. Challenging dominant cultural language, ideas, and lifestyles must have a purpose beyond being discomforting or threatening. Being countercultural is not simply a matter of doing the opposite of what dominant culture does. It is not primarily reactive. Rather, as Christians, a countercultural way of life means naming and practicing the central commitments to which Jesus calls us as disciples. It is about having encountered truth, and integrating the resulting new language, new ideas, and new forms of life into our daily life. When the central commitments of culture (individualism, consumption, and entitlement) do not align with the truth of Jesus Christ, followers of Jesus can be appropriately and positively described as being ec-centric: off-center, from the standpoint of dominant culture, but other-centered or Jesus-centered from the standpoint of a gospel-shaped people. Eccentric Christians will think, look, and act a little strange because they have been displaced from assumed cultural norms and centered on God and the other.
The “strangeness” that High School Theology Programs evoke is illustrated by Isabella and JoAnn, two recent !Explore alumna. Isabella discovered biblical and theological insights that enlivened her prayer life and deepened her care for creation. After the summer program, where she and three other participants learned the Lord’s Prayer in Greek and (with the help of a New Testament professor) translated the Greek into English for themselves, she pushed her family and friends to new levels of attentiveness to prayer, encouraged them to begin buying locally, and to step up their commitment to recycling.
After returning home from !Explore, JoAnn became frustrated by the shallowness of theological conversation in her Christian high school. She began challenging her friends and classmates to take conversations about faith deeper. Undoubtedly, some of the strangeness of the HSTPs’ formation wears off when youth return to the distractions — sports, clubs, lessons, etc. — that adults use to keep teenagers busy and fragmented. These activities are not necessarily bad in themselves, of course, but they often assume a commanding presence in our lives and divert our attention from God. What JoAnn found astonishing was that her encounter with the other, with God, and with truth through !Explore did have a long-term impact on her faith, identity, and vocation, allowing her to press for more mature discussion about faith with her peers, even after the novelty of the HSTP wore off.
Both Rooted and Odd: Learning from Disequilibrium
High School Theology Programs can typically name their central commitments. These central commitments are often relatively consistent with the denomination(s) or constituencies to which they are affiliated. But these programs are also able to risk more than typical congregational youth ministry programs. By practicing ec-centricity, they can pose difficult questions to both the dominant culture, and sometimes to the church itself. For example, Youth Theological Initiative (YTI) at Candler School of Theology, affiliated with United Methodism, creates space for youth to ask questions about sexual orientation and the value of other religions. The Compass program at Gordon-Conwell, an evangelical seminary, challenges youth to ask critical questions about the role technology plays in our lives, while Huron College’s Ask & Imagine program encourages participants to ask provocative questions about tradition and exclusion in Holy Communion.
!Explore, a program of the Mennonite church, also espouses commitments central to Anabaptists: (1) making Jesus the center of our faith, (2) making community the center of our lives, and (3) making reconciliation the center of our work. Yet these commitments are incommensurate with individualism, consumption, and entitlement, all dominant Western cultural values that even many Mennonites embrace. With foci that at times differ from and challenge their cultural context, and sometimes that differ from and challenge their denominations or constituencies, HSTPs may help re-enliven the denominational vision among young people who attend them.
This has a big payoff. Leadership development programs abound in North America. Developing leaders for tomorrow is among the aims of schools, businesses, and extracurricular activities — not to mention churches, seminaries, and denominations. While High School Theology Programs must surely be counted among the groups nurturing leadership, what is unique about these programs is that they are intentional about developing Christian leaders: leaders who are vocationally compelled by the good news of Christ and who acknowledge a calling to use their gifts for ends other than economic gain or social prestige. Theological reflection on the disruptive event of truth, and pedagogical reflection on disorientation and disequilibrium, demonstrate the importance of forming Christians who are not just disoriented from the dominant values of the wider culture, but who are also reoriented toward the emerging Kingdom of God, in which all of creation has been reconciled with the Creator.
Leaders whose faith is shaped by Jesus, whose identity is shaped by a community of believers, and whose vocation is aligned with the Kingdom of reconciliation, have the capacity — by facilitating encounters with truth that decenter and recenter young people — to create communities that not only anticipate the Kingdom, but that proleptically embody that future for all of humanity. The High School Theology Programs model ways in which churches, denominations, seminaries, camps and conferences, and others committed to the formation of Christian leaders can create holy disequilibrium through geographical, moral, and cultural dislocation. The ultimate goal, however, is reorientation in a renewed commitment to the good news, revealed in the life and teaching of Jesus Christ.
The call in this chapter is to recognize that formation and transformation are both essential for encountering Jesus Christ. These two poles provide the launch-points for growing in faith, developing identity, and discerning vocation. For traditions that historically have emphasized formation, the call from High School Theology Programs is to acknowledge the importance of Damascus Road experiences (Acts 9:1-9) and facilitate transformation through disruptive encounters, even if these encounters lead to truth-telling about the complacency of Christian traditions. For traditions that historically have emphasized transformation, the call is to consciously value and facilitate formation. These Emmaus Road experiences (Luke 24:13-35) generally embody the slow processes and steady practices whose foundations embolden youth to venture forth and risk meeting God in the face of the other. The double action of formation and transformation are processes as natural as breathing in and breathing out; one is necessary for the other.
. In this volume, my colleagues David Horn, Christy Lang Hearlson, and Brent Strawn discuss this rhythm in different ways. Horn stresses the importance of the journey in preparing us for God’s inbreaking transformation in High School Theology Programs; Hearlson describes the necessary rhythm of “leaving” and “returning” in these programs; and Strawn emphasizes the priority of scriptural catechesis (formation) preceding biblical critique in these programs.
. This view of truth is similar to Judy Steers’ understanding of encounter, presented in chapter 11 of this volume.
. John D. Caputo, What Would Jesus Deconstruct? The Good News of Postmodernism for the Church (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2007), pp. 27-30.
. Cf. John Howard Yoder, “Meaning After Babble: With Jeffrey Stout Beyond Relativism,” Journal of Religious Ethics 24, no. 1 (Spring 1996): 135; “On Not Being Ashamed of the Gospel: Particularity, Pluralism, and Validation,” Faith and Philosophy 93, no. 3 (July 1992): 292.
. Musimbi Kanyoro makes this point convincingly when she reflects on a return to her native Kenya and engaging in Bible studies with women in her home village. She observes that without the lens of a critical awareness of cultural assumptions, the women of her village inadvertently use Scripture to condone customs harmful to girls and women instead of speaking truth to them and challenging them. See Musimbi R. A. Kanyoro, Introducing Feminist Cultural Hermeneutics: An African Perspective (Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim, 2002).
. This is not an exclusive list, but an attempt to name the dominant social, economic, and political narratives that characterize late modern Western Liberalism.
. Charles Taylor, The Malaise of Modernity (Toronto: Anansi Press, 1992), pp. 2-10. Taylor is not an antimodernist. He seeks a nuanced analysis of modernity, embracing valuable aspects of modern life, and Taylor would not want to jettison, most notably, the modern understanding of the “self.”
. Chelle Huth, “Reflections,” Theological Education with Youth, Lutheran Theological Seminary (Gettysburg, PA), unpublished paper, High School Theology Leadership Consultation, Indianapolis, IN, February 23-25, 2012.
. Jack Mezirow, “Transformation Theory of Adult Learning,” in In Defense of the Lifeworld, ed. M. R. Welton (New York: SUNY Press, 1995), p. 50; also see Mezirow, Transformative Dimensions of Adult Learning (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1991), pp. 93-96 and Fostering Critical Reflection in Adulthood (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1991), p. 168. Although Mezirow’s work focuses on adult learning, the concepts of the disorienting dilemma and disequilibrium are relevant and applicable to adolescent learning as well.
. Bryan Moyer Suderman, “When You Learn to Follow Jesus (You Will Act a Little Strange),” God’s Love Is for Everybody: Songs for Small and Tall, Toronto: SmallTall Music, 2002, compact disc.
. Palmer Becker, Harold Stauffer Bender, and James R. Krabill, What Is an Anabaptist Christian? (Elkhart, IN: Mennonite Mission Network, 2008).
