Fred Edie
Students in the Lilly High School Theology Programs worship together — a lot. It is not always pretty; as one thoughtful alumna and present staff member of Emory’s Youth Theology Initiative explains, worship planning was always “very fraught”:
There was lots of conflict. But it was really important conflict to work through, because it gets to issues of theological — I mean you do theological reflection — you think about ethics, you think about race, you think about class, and do we use gender inclusive language or not? And all of it comes out in worship, whether it’s in worship planning or in who is speaking in worship, like, what does worship look like?
Her conclusion was one echoed by many HSTP students, staff, and alumni: “Worship is, I think, the most important pedagogical space at YTI.”
This is true also of the program I know best — Duke’s Youth Academy for Christian Formation (DYA) — where worship occurs daily and orients its curriculum. Perhaps this is because the vast majority of High School Theology Program students are publicly, avowedly Christian, and worship is a zone of great passion, often planned and led by young people themselves. Like a bunch of conferencing Methodist preachers, when the call to worship comes and with it the hymned interrogative — “And are we yet alive?” — HSTP students respond in a hundred different ways with a joyous, and even deafening, doxological “YES!” In my own experience, it is impossible to worship with these students and not be filled with wonder and hope.
At the same time, all is not perfect in Youth Doxology Land, even at the High School Theology Programs. One night during communal worship at DYA, a guest preacher called students to the altar to be saved by Jesus. (He either missed the memo about our students or did not believe it.) For five excruciating minutes nobody moved from his or her seat despite the preacher’s exhortations. And why should they? Our students were not there to meet Jesus for the first time; they were there to learn how to follow him more faithfully. The tension finally broke when Nelson trooped forward from the back of the chapel. In a prayer, our preacher praised Nelson and God and himself while vaguely threatening the rest of us. Confused, I approached Nelson afterwards, saying lamely, “Welcome to the Body of Christ, Nelson.” He replied, “Thanks, dude, but you know I’m already Christian. I felt bad for the guy, and we were all dying in there, so I took one for the team.”
Nelson and other young people are alert to youth ministry’s efforts to repeatedly cast them in a repetitious liturgical version of the film Groundhog Day. They resent being infantilized by adults who do not trust their capacity to be faithful or who fail to recognize their desire to grow in grace. This friction also indirectly raises the question of what constitutes authentic Christian worship, especially where youth are concerned, and how worship feeds into the vocational discernment that lies at the heart of the HSTPs. The common assumption of many congregations is that they must attract Nelson and his Christian peers with “worship lite,” a caffeinated mix of beach balls and boom boxes all designed to orchestrate a certain religious experience, rather than invite them to feast on the deep and lasting nourishment of Word and Sacrament. The truth is that even devoted youth — the Nelsons of the church — often feel alienated or marginalized by the consumerist liturgical fare that is too readily served on Sunday mornings to teenagers. To these youth, “worship lite” feels cheesy, and Word and Sacrament can sound like old-people speak for “dull.” Habituated to the Big Buzz, even devoted youth — like their less devoted peers — often fail to comprehend the subtle transformational mysteries of grace unplugged (if, in fact, that is even being offered).
I believe the church is poised to reclaim worship of the triune God as a critical zone of formation for young Christian leaders. If, as I will claim later, we lead from who we are, then the church must look to Christian worship’s capacity to shape faithful imaginations as the deep wellspring from which faithful leadership (and all discipleship) flows. In the early church, of course, worship was the only formal context for catechesis available. Yet today, reclaiming worship’s power to shape the imaginations of young Christian leaders presents a complex challenge. On the one hand, young people like Nelson with callings to Christian leadership are especially in need of the “continuing conversion” that worship can catalyze. On the other hand, this transformative encounter with the Holy is short-circuited when worship seems superficial and abstract, too disconnected from worshippers’ own lives to inspire their participation. In order for worship to enact its potential to inspire the “continual conversion” of young people like Nelson (and indeed, of the entire church), we must help youth become “fluent” in worship — which means providing settings, like the High School Theology Programs, where worship is spoken.
The liturgical literacy I imagine has several marks. Youth should recognize authentic worship when they see it, and, equally important, when they see it being distorted. They should learn how to plan worship, participate in it or, when called upon, lead it artfully; and they should be equipped to use their imaginative capacities to taste and see the goodness of God’s self-giving love through it. Fostering such liturgical literacy first requires repeated opportunities for youth to participate in the breadth and depth of the church’s historic worshipping traditions. It also calls for intentionally cultivating a faithful imagination that can function at several levels in relation to worship. Finally, it entails inviting young people’s improvisations upon the church’s traditions so that they can call those traditions their own.
Such an approach to faith formation requires both practice and reflection, but it does more than help young people more clearly understand, or more confidently participate in, worship. To assert the formative power of worship is to say that, in the act or performance of worship, young people actually experience God meeting them, and can name ways in which they have been identified as God’s own. In worship, God joins youth to God’s saving work in the world, and truly empowers them for that vocation. Sometimes youth recognize this divine encounter spontaneously, as did seventeen-year-old Amanda from Gordon-Conwell’s Compass program:
We climbed White Face Mountain, which is 4,786 feet high, and when we reached 4,786, we all just started screaming, um, you know, “Glory, glory, glory!” . . . We sang almost all the way up the mountain and down, because we were not only just so worn out and had to take our minds off [how tired we were] — but also because of what was around us, God’s creation. We just couldn’t help it, just bursting into song.
More often, however, youth in the High School Theology Programs told us about encountering God through the liturgical practices of their communities, especially when those practices were framed in a new way. At St. John’s Youth in Theology and Ministry Program, sixteen-year-old Justin recalled:
Last year one of the biggest things for me was the morning worship and all the songs we would sing, and how [singing] can be used as a prayer, and just [be] a way to praise God too. And that’s what I really found. I think I’m closest to God when I’m singing and doing those worship songs. That’s my favorite way of prayer.
Seventeen-year-old Rachel, from Candler’s Youth Theology Initiative, remembered a recent worship service that involved her body in new ways as a time of divine encounter: “The most recent [time I experienced God at YTI] was yesterday. Yesterday was my exploratory course on . . . bodies and disability, and [worship] was very different . . . because we got to experience God through our senses, like sight, smell, touch. It was a very humbling experience.”
As these youth attest, when Christian worship invites grateful praise of God, confession of sin, passing the peace, baptismal washing from pretense, and Eucharistic communion, it both envisions and actually practices a Christian ethic. Liturgy is performed, but it is not pretend. Instead, worship embodies a way of life that Christians must lead. When we invite young people into faithful performances of worship, we invite them to encounter the triune God, and to participate in a way of life that reflects this encounter.
My account here reflects on the experiences of teenagers like Amanda, Justin, and Rachel by making three interrelated moves. First, I review wisdom from Scripture and the church of antiquity, as well as share contemporary theological insight, to affirm worship’s power to form and transform followers of Jesus. I also take soundings from Christian tradition to provide a set of norms (or at least rules of thumb) for discerning authentic Christian worship as it forms young people. Second, I suggest some reasons worship is formative and transformative, and I argue that it engages and operates on different levels of what I will describe as “faithful imagination.” Finally, I attempt to show how, through imaginatively engaged worship performances, young Christians may find both their identity and vocation in Christ deepened, including vocations for leadership in the church.
The Transformational Nature of Authentic Worship and Formation
Whatever else Christians are called to do, worship is always first among them. If we confess that God has created the entire cosmos out of a surplus of love, that Jesus Christ is redeeming and bringing new life to this same cosmos that was formerly subjected to sin and death, and that the Holy Spirit inspires and empowers creation’s journey to the fullness of God’s reign — if we confess all this, then worship is always the church’s primary calling. What more fitting response could there be than praise and gratitude for God’s good work? As the Westminster Shorter Catechism famously proclaims, humanity’s chief end is to “glorify God and enjoy [God] forever.” In this “work of the people” (the meaning of the word liturgy in the original Greek), worshippers join the ongoing prayer of Jesus and all the saints in unceasing praise.
Christian worship is first and foremost directed toward God; it is inspired by God and is offered to God. It is not first about human beings, not about re-charging our spiritual batteries, not about discovering identity and living into vocations, not even about cultivating faithful leadership for the next generation. It is for the glorification of God for God’s own sake. And yet, the Christian triune God is always paying it forward. God receives our offerings of praise (though they amount to a pittance in relation to who God is and the gifts God provides) then serendipitously returns them to God’s people as the sustaining food of faithfulness. Even though worship is for God, worshippers may receive from it the vision and power to live into Christ’s new creation. Worship does not just symbolize transformation; through worship, God forms and transforms us into new creations who do what we were made to do: glorify God.
The idea that liturgical action could actually form or transform worshippers, rather than simply mimic or recall such a transformation, is a conviction as old as the faith itself. Paul, for example, notes in his letter to the Romans that persons are not baptized “because” Jesus was baptized, nor were they baptized in mere “imitation” of Jesus. Instead they are baptized into Jesus; specifically, according to Paul, into Jesus’ death and resurrection hope (Rom. 6). Similarly, Augustine, the fourth-century bishop of Hippo, contemplates the transforming grace of Holy Communion (or “Eucharist,” as he calls it) by imaginatively inverting the logic of eating. While normally we would expect the food we eat to become part of our own bodies, for Augustine, to partake of Eucharist is to be incorporated ever more deeply into Christ’s body. To borrow from Tertullian, bishop of Carthage in the early third century, worship is the setting where Christians are “made.” Historian Thomas Finn affirms this connection by noting that, for the earliest Christians, theology was the result of “symbols deeply lived.” God’s gifts of transforming grace flowed through human participation in ritual symbols (word, table, font, chrism, fire, patterns of time) to “make” God’s people.
To simplify massively, the church’s task of “faith making” in worship changed course dramatically in the second millennium. The emphasis shifted from bodily, affective, and experiential faith to ideational faith. Now the path to salvation required getting your Christian facts straight. Indeed, despite its etymological root, the meaning of orthodoxy also shifted from “right worship” to “right belief.” As a result, the context for making faith moved from the sanctuary to the school. By knowing the truth, it was thought, people could then go live it (an assumption that rather quickly proved unreliable). Noting Augustine’s insight that human beings are disposed to worship what they love, contemporary philosopher James K. A. Smith observes young people enrolled in Christian schools and colleges who are nevertheless engaged in “cultural liturgies” of conspicuous consumption at the mall, or a melding of rituals drawn from entertainment media, military power, and the sports industry. Smith contends that these cultural liturgies shape young peoples’ desires just as powerfully as Christian liturgy once did, forming young people’s identities around what they love.
Likewise, Katherine Turpin has exposed consumerism as the dominant but inadequate faith system of Western young people today. Turpin notes that young people worship at the cathedrals of shopping malls and engage in liturgies and therapies of consumption. Like Smith, Turpin rejects the idea that young people simply need to be trained to think “better.” The problem, she argues, is that a young person may become cognitively aware of the evils of rampant consumerism but not have the desire to change. Turpin thus calls for a “conversion” of imagination, desire, and will, which take place as young people engage with communities that offer countercultural practices of work, fellowship, and worship.
Just how do we distinguish “authentic” Christian worship from false, damaging, or impoverished worship? At the risk of setting off another century of internecine strife, I plunge in. In the midst of its doxology, worship should proclaim and perform the truth about God so far as we know it from the witness of Scripture and tradition of the church (including liturgical tradition). By implication, worship should also proclaim and perform the truth about human beings, including the struggles and insights arising out of our efforts to live faithfully before God. Christian worship should not be directed toward a god fashioned out of our navel fuzz, but to the living triune God. The God of Christian Scripture is a storied God whom we know through the saving history of covenant with Israel; through the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus reconciling us to God’s covenantal intent; and through the Spirit’s continuing redemption in the church and world.
As Gordon Lathrop suggests, worship is therefore most likely to enact the truth of God’s revelation and the truth about humanity through structured “juxtapositions” of one liturgical “holy thing” to another. For example, Lathrop suggests that the juxtaposition of Word with Table is pivotal to liturgical authenticity. Placed in creative tension, these holy things mutually interpret one another. Further, in their juxtaposition with one another, holy things are also juxtaposed to the life of the assembly of faith. Through this structured tension, holy things and the community of the faithful are “broken open,” enabling new revelatory insight to pour forth. For Lathrop, juxtaposition preserves an essential hermeneutical (and pedagogical) humility. Juxtapositions create paradoxical truth. They ensure that we praise the God we worship as incarnate while also acknowledging God’s transcendence. They remind us that we are at once sinfully rebellious yet are being made holy by God. They enable us to sense God’s reign as at once here now and yet not complete. Additional normative juxtapositions in worship include placing doxology alongside lament and beseeching, placing (baptismal) bathing beside teaching, and so on. Without these juxtapositions, Christian worship risks either claiming too much or professing too little about God.
Worship and Faithful Imagination
The deeply transformative and theologically significant effects of worship flow in part from the ways in which liturgical participation both instills and requires practices of faithful imagination. Faithful imagination is more than a knack for innovation or creative flair; it serves as an interpretive matrix in which communal and personal memory shape desire or passion, bending toward hope for the future. Something like Spinoza’s conatus, imagination funds the human drive not only to be but also to be well, to flourish.
Christians engage a faithful imagination at different levels and for different tasks. On one level, worship can train worshippers’ embodied imaginations by working through and forming dispositions. This way of imagining is transacted and ultimately inscribed in and through habitual gestures of the body and affections of the heart. On another level, worship invites reflective imagination. Through ritual-symbolic-linguistic expansion and associative linking, Christian young people discover that worship contains previously unfathomable gifts that respond to their previously unfathomable wounds, blessings, and hopes. Of course, like all human capacities, imagination is subject to sinful distortion. Hence imagination, too, must find its proper telos in the Word made flesh, and worship is a critical zone for doing that. Thus, at a third level, worship helps shape a critical faithful imagination, as young people worship in ways that operate as creative responses to critical reflection about worship itself. In short, imagination is not simply key to assist young persons in discerning what makes their worship Christian; it also enables them to conceive how their present circumstances, and perhaps their worship, are not yet all that God intends. Besides prompting youth to see what is not yet, faithful imagination fuels young peoples’ dreams to join with God in building God’s kingdom.
Embodied Imagination: “It’s Awesome, Dude”
Faithful imagining is first of all bodily and affective before it is reflective or critical. The philosopher Paul Connerton contends that persons and societies carry their most important truths at the bodily level. Oddly, we human beings often experience the bodily dimensions of ourselves as tribal regions about which we know little, if we notice them at all, and over which we exert scant control. Hence, without reflection, we may not notice how worship is working in these regions, disposing us to see, feel, and act in certain ways — an obliviousness that often leads us to underestimate worship’s formative potential. Nevertheless, like Nathaniel Hawthorne’s contemplative who spends a lifetime gazing at the Great Stone Face, through their worship Christians may find themselves growing in resemblance to that which they admire. Repeated thoughts, feelings, and behaviors strengthen synaptic connections between neurons in the brain, automating them in the process. Habits free the conscious mind for other tasks. Yet these habits also come to characterize persons. The ways in which youth typically greet or ignore others, respond to opportunities or crises, assume bodily postures, or even feel about themselves internally all become functions of habit. Such habits provide youth with a reliable (if not always positive) sense of who they are. The repetitions of worship, therefore, and the habits they instill are integral to forming young Christians who experience themselves as God’s beloved, and who are capable of loving God and neighbor as a result.
Such formation of dispositions occurs not only through repeated bodily practice, but also through stories retold, recalled, and lived. Pastoral theologian David Hogue has suggested that liturgy’s formative capacity is related to its own and to the storied nature of human beings. Drawing upon neuroscience, Hogue suggests that persons naturally store their memories in narrative form. He notes that these stories of the past become associated in our memories with emotions evoked in the midst of those experiences. Christian worship operates in the realm of regularly rehearsed declarative memories (God’s story of salvation) and, equally important, repeatedly evoked emotions appropriate to this story (gratitude, compassion, and hope, for example). Worship thus may become an occasion for healing people’s memories of wounding stories through the graced reimagination and reinterpretation of them in the liturgy.
Experiencing worship as lived story, then, can lead to healing and hope, and even inspire a sense of awe. Awe is more than a feeling or emotion. To be awed is to be moved to one’s depths by the profundity of personal encounter with the God of the universe, but also to experience God’s offer of relationship with the divine. Emotional memory can make our declarative memories seem as if the events they capture are happening again in the present. For example, recalling one’s near drowning as a child can feel as if one is drowning all over again, just as remembering one’s first day at a new school or reliving one’s first kiss can cause the heart to race. Similarly, singing the story of Jesus’ resurrection (“Jesus Christ is risen today . . .”) activates the emotional memory system, conveying power as we experience this stupendous event happening again in the here and now of the assembly’s worship, where we are witnesses! In this understanding, teenagers’ full-on declaration — “It’s awesome, dude!” — is more than adolescent slang; for Hogue, this performed anamnesis is the means by which worshippers’ stories of brokenness may be “re-written” in relation to the story of salvation. Critically, according to Hogue, when this re-narration occurs at the level of bodily practice, it transforms emotional resonances of memory even more than it shapes conscious or self-reflective awareness. Performed, bodily anamnesis is a dispositional imagining; it forms dispositions and affections.
Reflective Imagination: An Invitation to Wonder
Faithful imagination begins bodily and affectively, but it does not end there. Faithful imagination consists also of reflective, mindful attention that evokes young people’s poetic and artistic sensibilities in response to the stories and symbols of Christian faith. Reflective imagination employs a form of reason that cultivates deepened awareness of God’s graced self-revelation through worship. Yet because it remains imagination, this faithful, reflective attentiveness does not intend to rope, brand, and corral Holy Mystery. Instead, it invites young people who learn to employ a reflective imagination to connect more profoundly with the elements of worship themselves, to recognize the relationship of these elements to one another, and to discern the connections between worship and worshippers’ lives.
At the Duke Youth Academy, the formation of the reflective imagination resembles catechesis. This form of catechesis is anything but mind-numbing memorization of faith facts. Its aim is deepened delight and praise. It proceeds by way of invitation to “wonder” at the ritual symbols of Christian worship. It assumes that these symbols bear a great surplus of meaning and that their polyvalence may “speak” more expansively of the life of God and to young people’s lives — if they acquire the eyes to see. In addition to wondering about meanings, those engaged in imaginative reflection upon holy things may work through associations as well. Youth are invited to associate ritual symbols with the biblical stories of salvation and with the emerging stories of their own lives. Indeed, reflecting on the layers of meaning within these symbols reveals something of the depths of God, and further opens worshippers to wonder and awe.
At one time, such imaginative catechesis was a constitutive practice for forming persons in Christian faith. Rich expansions and improvisations on symbols are everywhere in the Bible and the early tradition. Paul associates Jesus with Israel’s Passover Lamb. Matthew portrays him as the new Moses. Everywhere in Scripture older images are recast and re-associated to speak something new. For example, 1 Peter 3:20-21 claims that the story of Noah’s ark “prefigures” baptism into Christ. This process of expansion and association continues in figural readings of the Scriptures. With breathtaking artistic genius, Ephrem (a fourth-century Syriac bishop) reflects that from whatever angle he gazes upon the prismatic oil of chrism, the multifaceted Christ “looks out at me from it.” Indeed, reflection upon these ritual symbols was not only catechetically effective; it was theologically generative, giving rise to new understandings of God and the Christian life.
We live in a different world at present, in which standardized tests celebrate teenagers’ linear reason at the expense of other intelligences, and churches and denominations become known for wrangling over points of doctrinal orthodoxy rather than for the richness of their stories and symbols. We ought not be surprised when youth perceive ritual symbols as flat or even dead — water is clear; fire is hot; bread is flour mixed with water heated by fire; wine is flavored water that gives you a buzz — and then come to regard such symbols as pointless. They have never been invited to “speak” the Christian liturgical language at its depths.
Critical Imagination: How Might It Be Otherwise?
Faithful imagination also moves toward a critical moment in which we discern whether our offerings to God are faithful — a critical insight that can then move us toward action and activism. Earlier I described ways in which worship may be assessed for authenticity, including attention to juxtaposition. We are called by our baptism to discern such authenticity, for the baptismal waters scrub away both pretense and unworthiness with equal effect. As Paul suggests to the Galatians, baptism constitutes Christians into a new form of community wherein old markers of status are relativized if not erased. In place of slave or free comes a shared, unified identity in Christ. Does our worship enact baptismal unity or reassert former status hierarchies? Does our holy meal express the paradox of hospitality — all are welcome yet all remain beggars at Christ’s table — or are some left hungry?
Ultimately, these questions also invite a wider imaginative critique of the liturgies undertaken by Christians beyond the sanctuary. Where exactly is our community involved in the baptismal work of erasing hierarchies of power and in reconciling, unifying, justice-seeking ministry? Where are we meeting the hungers (actual and metaphorical) of the world? In this way, not only is imagination key to detecting authenticity in worship; it evokes visions of how things may be otherwise, in worship and in the world. Faithful imagination is a key that helps young people begin to see as God sees, and therefore to get involved in what God is doing.
Pedagogies of Worship and Awe:
Keys to Cultivating Faithful Imagination
If, as the introduction to this book suggests, imagination is key to the formation of future church leaders (and to creating a kind of church that young people want to lead in the first place), then the ability to shape a faithful imagination is “Job One” for catechists, church leaders, and theological educators alike. The High School Theology Programs are energetic laboratories for faithful imagination, and worship has unrivaled pedagogical power for forming the Christian imagination. To be clear, HSTPs do not emphasize worship in order to provide youth with an effective pedagogical exercise; we worship together, as all Christians worship together, in order to come into the presence of God, to remember who we are and to respond to Christ’s call to serve him in the world. Yet in the process of worshipping God together, we find our imaginations changing. We see one another a little more as Christ sees us. We desire a little more honestly what Christ desires. So what are the aspects of worship that, as we perform them, can become pedagogical opportunities as well, especially as they help young people begin to imagine themselves as people called to Christian discipleship and leadership? I will conclude with a few of the ways the Duke Youth Academy, and some other HSTPs, have turned to worship as a resource for shaping young people’s faithful imaginations.
Across the board, High School Theology Programs make worship a place where bodies, as well as minds and emotions, are welcome. Most programs start by simply reminding students of this fact, teaching varieties of gestures for worship that may or may not feel familiar. Students at the Duke Youth Academy, for example, learn to raise hands in praise, extend them in supplication, process into a worship space, perform simple dance steps, chant Psalms, genuflect, bow, pass the peace (we use a “hug and release” method), sing the Prayer of Great Thanksgiving, and receive the elements of Holy Communion. They repeat these gestures daily in worship for two weeks. Adult staff then build on these gestures in their teaching. For example, one artist, a theologically trained biblical storyteller, instructs students in how to embody and inhabit the Scriptures they read in the assembly. Visual artists show how to contemplate iconic images, and musicians teach multiple musical forms.
We are not alone in emphasizing gesture in worship, of course. Students attending St. Meinrad’s One Bread One Cup program are trained as lay Eucharistic ministers in their tradition. In addition to the theological dimensions of becoming a Eucharistic minister, students also learn the gestures of this ministry — where and how to stand, bow, genuflect, or kneel, when to tender what to the celebrant, and how to offer the host hospitably and with expectant joy to communicants.
One of the ways the Youth Hope Builders Academy forms embodied worshipful imaginations is through dance. I witnessed a group composed of current students and alumni from YHBA perform a dance that evoked the “ring shout,” a practice dating back to antebellum slavery. Costumed in flowing gingham dresses and kerchiefs, the girls (all African American) moved in circles, clapping and stamping their feet, then lifting their arms in praise. The ring shout was a uniquely African American practice of worship, fueling their resistance and resilience in the face of slavery. The girls executed the dance flawlessly and with great artistry, and the congregation was powerfully moved by their performance. I do not doubt that this dance and the saving memories it bears are now inscribed in these young dancers’ bodies. They carry these stories of slavery, resistance, and the hope of God’s deliverance in their flesh and blood.
In my more despairing moments, I sometimes question whether DYA makes any lasting difference in forming the Christian lives of students. At annual reunions, however, I am always awed to witness the community enter bodily into Holy Communion. The prescribed bidding is offered: “Lift up your hearts!” Even after an interim of months or years, the assembly’s response is immediate and sung with great relish: “We lift them up to the Lord!” The liturgy continues. Students look around and smile, perhaps like me, “re-membering” the power of these gestures. They have learned Holy Communion “by heart,” and in their performance of it they witness to its power to elevate their own hearts.
Forming Reflective Imagination
As Brent Strawn notes in chapter 13 of this volume, no one is born speaking a language. Yet young people must learn the Christian liturgical language if it is to be meaningful. Anyone who has taken a high school foreign language class knows that dogmatic, authoritarian, or rationalistic pedagogies do not result in language acquisition. On the contrary, Christian tradition prompts us to recover the insight of artists and their ways of imaginative expansion and association if young people are to be moved and empowered in worship. We might follow St. Ephrem’s lead regarding chrism, for example, as he links it to healings, royal anointings, and the gift of Spirit power, then further spins out its connotative resonance by considering its composition (olives) and by connecting the leaves of the olive tree to Jesus’ triumphal entry into Jerusalem, and its limbs to his crucifixion. All this Ephrem gets from riffing on chrism!
Alternately, a few minutes of guided brainstorming around the significance of water easily yields a dozen or more ways water impacts human life. Young people may use this list to discover how the baptismal waters suggest a wide range of possible meanings, including water as primal source of all life and water as threat to life’s existence, plus power, transport, transformation, and mixing together (as in community). These soundings provide young people the resources to imagine Christian baptism as a wondrously consequential event in their lives, and one with continuing consequence. The same exercise may be employed with bread, wine, fire, and other symbols of the liturgy — or with the gestures of worship, mentioned above. A bowed head, for example, might signal either holy fear or humiliation, depending on the context, while a broken loaf can mean wounding or sharing.
In addition to exploring symbols and gestures, DYA instructors also explore biblical stories and literature with youth, as well as liturgical figurative speech, including metaphor. Obviously, the point of metaphor in reference to God is not to name God with flattening (and domesticating) certitude. Perceiving and using metaphor makes possible the linking and interlacing of biblical stories with personal stories. Anne Wimberly, director of Youth Hope-Builders Academy, advocates a pedagogy of the African American church that links stories on three levels: personal stories to biblical stories to stories of African American Christian exemplars. The point is to develop students’ capacities to imagine, by sharing stories of struggles and hopes, that they are living in continuity with the stories of their forebears and, ultimately, with the Story of the God who hears and responds to the cries of oppressed peoples.
Forming Imagination in Relation to Critical Reflection
Like dispositional and reflective imagining, critical reflection can also be cultivated and formed. At DYA, as at many of the High School Theology Programs, young people work with mentors to take responsibility for planning, leading (to the extent that various faith traditions permit), and reflecting upon worship. This is a higher order pedagogical task requiring the imaginative connection of a number of variables. At DYA, the opportunity to help lead worship is the point where students’ still squeaky new theologies of liturgy collide with their aesthetical preferences and the habitually embodied worshipping practices they have brought with them from home. It is never dull and sometimes explosive! Although students must operate within certain traditioned parameters (we use a Word and Table pattern under the umbrella of the Baptismal Covenant, plus a lectionary of sorts, as well as daily theological themes keyed to the lectionary), they nevertheless find themselves contending over the content and performance of worship, as well as how these factors most faithfully enact the truth of their lives before God within the DYA community. Is worship marking Christ’s passion really the time for Elrod to solo “Shine Jesus Shine” on his tuba, even if he did truck it all the way from Tuscaloosa? Does Jenna’s desire to blow bubbles from behind the altar appropriately signify God’s forgiveness for sin and our reconciliation to God and neighbor? These scenarios — actual ones — may fall a bit on the wacky side, but they illustrate well the complexities of interpretation and imagination required for faithful worship to take flesh.
Participants in other HSTPs echo these sentiments about the complexity of the task. As the high school theology alumna quoted at the beginning of this chapter suggests, conflict is common as students who take responsibility for worship find their assumptions about worship clashing with the worship expectations, not to mention cultural and theological expectations, held by their new friends. Teenagers must use what they are learning in order to get something done together. They seek the best words, the most resonant gestures, and the proper aesthetic key. Using the tradition, they nevertheless seek to reimagine and improvise upon it, so that it speaks to their reality. They brainstorm, and they argue. With gentle prompting from mentors, they involve themselves in a process of critical imagination toward deepened faithfulness of expression.
Liturgy planned must then be performed. Students dance, sing, read, tell, dramatize, pray, play, share, and symbolize to the glory of the Holy Trinity. Sometimes lacking professional polish, student leaders more than offset their inexperience with passion. They have become invested in this work and are seeking to offer their very best to God. Other worshipping members of the community participate in these offerings equally as wholeheartedly because they sense that these expressions evoke the truth about their lives in this community.
Afterward, worship leaders reflect upon the entire experience. What went well or poorly? What was difficult or easy? Where did they sense the worship perform the truth about God and the truth about themselves? What new insights came through the process? Where were they surprised? Where did they encounter Holy Mystery? Here is a small sampling, from DYA and other HSTPs, of their reactions:
As a result of these programs, students glimpse the depths of Christian worship, and are better able to articulate its plurality of meanings and intent. They become more fluent speakers and interpreters of Christian language. They also more clearly understand the worshipping traditions of the church, and improvise on them, bending these traditions toward their own contexts and cultural idioms. Further, they have expanded their repertoire of means to enter God’s presence beyond the use of subwoofers and laser lights; they are more susceptible to wonder and, therefore, more willing to participate in the Spirit’s graced transformative work. They learn to evaluate worship’s authenticity beyond personal preference. Finally, they see in worship very real (not pretend) patterns of Christian living.
Christian Worship, Identity, Leadership
It is obvious from the students’ reflections above that when young people perform and reflect upon Christian worship, it does more than help them “act more like Christians.” Worship becomes generative for their Christian identity, their sense of inner coherence, their claim to belong to a people — to God’s people. Erik Erikson has taught us that identity formation is a primary developmental task for adolescents. Emergent capacities for self-reflection cause youth to wonder about themselves. They ask, “Who am I in light of who I and others say I am?” Christian worship provides a rich context for asking and answering that question. One HSTP alumnus commented that he now recognizes how his baptism made him “another dad” to the children in his home congregation. Indeed, a significant number of HSTP alumni return home to serve as Sunday school teachers, confirmation mentors, and directors of children’s choirs or dance groups.
Yet forming a Christian identity is not just about deeper self-appraisal and self-construction — that is, my ability to make sense of how to answer the question, “Who am I?” Christian identity is deeply tied to the uniquely performative nature of worship and the knowing that resides in the bodies that perform it. This makes identity less a function of who we say we are and more the result of whom or what we worship. Hence worship itself, as much as what worshippers can say about it or how they make sense of their lives in relation to it, remains key to Christians’ identity formation. Speaking theologically, identity comes to young Christians as a gift from God through their ongoing practices of worshipping that very same God.
What, finally, does worship-formed identity have to do with forming Christian leaders? I offer a story shared with me by Alaina Kleinbeck, Duke Youth Academy’s program director, in the effort to answer this question. DYA is intentionally ecumenical, drawing students ranging from the starchiest of Episcopalians to the happiest of Pentecostals. At a worship service early in the 2012 program, sixteen-year-old Aaron noticed Peter — an exuberant charismatic who was moving in response to the preacher and the music — “behaving disrespectfully” (in Aaron’s words). Aaron crossed the chapel aisle in the middle of the service and told Peter to chill. Peter was confused, embarrassed, and offended. He was worshipping as he’d always worshipped.
A week later, at the close of a day in which DYA focused on the call to reconciliation, Aaron responded to the communal confession of sin in worship and the pastoral gesture of pardon by crossing the aisle once more to seek out Peter. This time, however, he confessed his sin for judging Peter previously and for embarrassing him. Aaron begged Peter’s forgiveness (which was granted), and sought to be reconciled with him through the exchange of Christ’s peace (long hug, eventual release).
Aaron’s gesture illustrates the power of Christian worship to shape faithful imaginations, and young people’s identities as Christian leaders. God not only transforms us through water, word, and song in worship; God also transforms us through each other. In relationship to others, we are a more fully doxological community, more certain of our identity in Christ, and more clear about our vocation as disciples. Over nearly two weeks of living intentionally in community and practicing daily worship, as well as daily reflection upon worship, Aaron came to know and appreciate Peter and to recognize his own liturgical parochialism. After a day with special emphasis on Christ’s reconciling work, Aaron sensed himself caught up in God’s present work of reconciliation within the liturgy itself. Awed, Aaron did not so much decide as he felt himself moved by the power of the Spirit to confess his sin to Peter and to seek reconciliation. That he did not choose to seek forgiveness over Facebook or privately during the daily snack break suggests that, in Aaron’s deepening faithful imagination, worship was the obvious context for this gesture. It offered Aaron a real, not a pretend, way of being in the world, a source of concentrated Spirit power that called forth his best self — which, not coincidentally, was the self God was calling him to be in the first place: a reconciled child of God, his true vocation.
. This “worship as curriculum” approach is shared with other programs, including those at St. Meinrad, Notre Dame, Lutheran Theological at Gettysburg, Hellenic, and others. Of these, a number (including DYA) approach vocational discernment from the perspective of the sacrament of baptism out of their conviction that baptism is a source of Christian identity and vocation.
. I’m borrowing the phrase from the Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults (RCIA) Rite of Calling the Candidates to Continuing Conversion, #446-449. Cf. RCIA: Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical, 1990), p. 263.
. Augustine of Hippo, Sermons 227, 228b, 229a, and 272 (http://david.heitzman.net/sermons227-229a.html, accessed October 7, 2013). The biblical text for Augustine’s reflection is John 6, including v. 51, “I am the living bread that came down from heaven. Whoever eats of this bread will live forever; and the bread that I will give for the life of the world is my flesh.”
. Quoted in Maxwell E. Johnson, The Rites of Christian Initiation: Their Evolution and Interpretation (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical, 2007), p. xix.
. Thomas M. Finn, Early Christian Baptism and the Catechumenate: West and East Syria (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical, 1992), p. 5.
. According to James K. A. Smith, the foundations of Christian schooling in America lie in the determination to transmit a Christian worldview to students. See James K. A. Smith, Desiring the Kingdom: Worship, Worldview, and Cultural Formation (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2009), pp. 17-18.
. Smith, Desiring, pp. 19-27.
. Katherine Turpin, Branded: Adolescents Converting from Consumer Faith (Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim, 2006).
. Don Saliers puts it this way: “Christian liturgy transforms and empowers when the vulnerability of human pathos is met by the ethos of God’s vulnerability in word and sacrament.” Saliers defines pathos as “the human suffering of the world. Human emotions and passions, despite vast differences, provide access to what is counted real,” and the divine ethos as “the characteristic manner in which liturgy is a self-giving of God to us, the encounter whereby grace and glory find human form.” Worship as Theology: Foretaste of Glory Divine (Nashville, TN: Abingdon, 1994), p. 22.
. Gordon W. Lathrop, Holy Things: A Liturgical Theology (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress, 1998), p. 24.
. Pieces of this section are excerpted from Fred Edie, “Liturgy and Faith Formation: Reimagining a Partnership for the Sake of Youth” in Liturgy 29 (2014): 33-44.
. Conatus is a seventeenth-century metaphysical category used to describe a being’s will to live, or innate inclination to continue to exist and enhance itself. Spinoza understood conatus as a “striving” to persevere. For an expanded definition, see Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/spinoza-psychological/ (accessed October 8, 2013). The view of conatus discussed here in relationship to imagination is developed in Thomas H. Groome, Sharing Faith: A Comprehensive Approach to Religious Education and Pastoral Ministry: The Way of Shared Praxis (Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock, 1999), pp. 28-29.
. Paul Connerton, How Societies Remember (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989).
. David A. Hogue, Remembering the Future, Imagining the Past: Story, Ritual, and the Human Brain (Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock, 2003), see especially chapter 2.
. Hogue, Remembering the Future, see chapters 3 and 4.
. See Anabel Proffitt, “The Importance of Wonder in Educational Ministry,” Religious Education 93, no. 1 (Winter 1998): 102-13.
. I take my cues here from Jerome W. Berryman, Godly Play: An Imaginative Approach to Christian Education (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 1991) and from Kieran Egan, Imagination in Teaching and Learning (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992).
. Thomas M. Finn, Early Christian Baptism and the Catechumenate: West and East Syria (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical, 1992), p. 155. For the full range of Ephrem’s insights into chrism, see all of hymn seven.
. See Brent Strawn’s chapter in this volume for more on inviting young people to learn to speak the language of faith. In his case, he is concerned with the capacity of the Old Testament and the Bible as a whole to form human persons in a way of life.
. See Anne S. Wimberly, Soul Stories: African American Christian Education (Nashville, TN: Abingdon, 2011).
. See E. Byron Anderson, Worship and Christian Identity: Practicing Ourselves (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical, 2003).
. The names of youth have been changed.
