Chapter 13 of 25

Christy Lang Hearlson

Christy Lang Hearlson

Christy Lang Hearlson

In Martin Gardner’s 1973 novel, The Flight of Peter Fromm, a young man leaves his Pentecostal church and devout family to enroll at the University of Chicago Divinity School, where he hopes to change the school’s secular ethos with his religious fervor. Instead, theological education slowly corrodes his convictions and creates a widening break in his identity that can only be crossed at great psychological and spiritual peril. In a key scene, Peter returns home, where his mother begs him to pray. Knowing what she expects, he prays in tongues. Yet praying in tongues is a practice Peter no longer believes in, and his dishonest performance pitches him into despair that leads to the brink of madness.

A more recent novel by Barbara Kingsolver, Flight Behavior, opens with the central character hiking up a mountainside toward an adulterous tryst. Dellarobia is stopped short by a vision of orange flame that does not burn the forest. Filled with awe and an overwhelming sense of vocation, she runs back home. When scientists arrive to study the phenomenon, they invite Dellarobia to work with them, and she becomes a translator between the scientists and her poor small-­town community. Although her liminality is sometimes acutely painful, Dellarobia works hard to integrate her learning into her life, achieving a level of knowledge and freedom she had not imagined.

Peter and Dellarobia represent two ends of a spectrum. On the one hand, an experience of separation from home and of education can lead to inward chaos and permanent dislocation. On the other, such experiences can lend new perspective and courage for daily life, as well as skills for translating between different communities. What makes the difference between these two? This question is acute for theological education, which often removes learners geographically from home, and invites students to undertake spiritual, intellectual journeys. This question is equally acute for the High School Theology Programs, since learners leave home in order to be immersed in a new community and formed in new ways — and then return home again. In some cases, learners skillfully reintegrate into their families and churches with a sense of vocation as Christian leaders. In other cases, youth simply cannot match up the seams of their home life with their experience in their youth theology program. What makes the difference?

In this chapter, I will seek to answer that question by first offering theological and psychological perspectives on the experiences of separation and return, drawing especially on the research of Jeffrey A. Kottler, who has explored factors that prompt lasting personal change. I will then turn to data collected by the research team of the High School Theology Program Seminar, which suggest that when teenagers return to their home contexts after a High School Theology Program, they are met by one of four basic orientations: partnership, substitution, transformation, and/or opposition. After describing and assessing each of these approaches as they relate to separation and integration, I will recommend two in particular and briefly suggest how they might inform theological education and congregational ministry with youth. What seems clear is that the catechetical impact of deeply formative vocational experiences like High School Theology Programs does not end with the car ride home. The homecoming itself may be decisive in a young person’s ability to claim his or her vocational identity.

“Go from Your Country and Your Kindred”:

Separation and Transformation

In ancient agricultural communities in which most people stayed put, wandering was weird behavior, but the Bible is full of stories of people who went out from their “country and kindred.” Adam and Eve, Abram and Sarai, Hagar, Ishmael, Jacob, Joseph, Moses, the Hebrew people, Naomi and Ruth, Esther, Jonah, Mary and Joseph, Jesus, Peter, James, John, Paul, Onesimus, Priscilla and Aquila — they were exiles, sojourners, nomads, escape artists, wanderers, migrants, emigrants, refugees, and missionaries.

Away from the familiar, safe, and civilized, they met God. In the wilderness, the angel of the Lord gave Hagar a covenantal promise, and she in turn named God. Jacob dreamed of God’s promise and wrestled God’s angel. Joseph discovered God’s faithfulness in the midst of enslavement. The Hebrew people experienced God’s discipline and provision in the wilderness. Jonah had it out with God on the outskirts of Nineveh. Elizabeth and Mary felt divine life dawning when Mary traveled to see her cousin. Angels attended Jesus in the wilderness, the disciples saw God heal and teach in Jesus, and Paul heard the risen Christ speak to him. When people leave home, the biblical narrative suggests, holy things happen. Wrenched out of the quotidian, people encounter a wild God, the God of elsewhere and everywhere, and they can never be the same.

The Bible, of course, is not the only place where we witness separation from home as a time of transformation. Therapist and educator Jeffrey Kottler has spent his professional career studying experiences that catalyze personal change, particularly geographic travel, as well as the factors that sustain such change afterward. Kottler suggests that people who set out on a geographical journey often already have a mindset ripe for change, but once they leave home, they also experience insulation from the usual influences of their lives, which sets them free to move in new directions and experiment with different identities.

Such disconnection from established networks of relationships is potent because our relationships are tremendously accurate predictors of our attitudes and behaviors. In Connected: The Surprising Power of Our Social Networks and How They Shape Our Lives, Nicholas Christakis and James Fowler show how the web of relationships in which we are embedded shapes our lives and pervasively affects — sometimes dictates — our emotional states, romantic lives, financial welfare, health, addictions, and religious and political views. It should not be surprising, then, that geographic journeys that separate learners from established social networks impact their thoughts, emotions, and behavior.

In addition to removing the traveler from relational networks, separation from home also introduces disorientation, which Kottler argues incites change:

More often than not, the most powerful and dramatic changes took place during a time when someone felt lost or literally was lost. . . . It is interesting to consider that it is often when you are most uncomfortable, most out your element, most confused and anxious, that the real action begins. You are forced to rely on resources that you never knew you had. You are required to solve problems in new ways. And often what you learned from these crises has helped you ever since.

In addition to fostering such flexibility, resourcefulness, and proactive behavior, travel heightens our senses, sometimes inducing an altered psychological state. This strong emotional arousal, Kottler explains, sparks transformation, since it creates a clear memory and prompts action.

Drawing on the potential of travel to instigate change, the High School Theology Programs enable young people to “get lost” through a variety of practices, many of which David Horn describes in his chapter on pilgrimage in this volume. Most notably, the programs physically remove young people from their home churches and families for a time of intentional growth, take away devices that connect young people to their routines and social networks, and transport them to new places and experiences. Many youth whom we interviewed expressed that their program gave them space to reflect on their lives as they would not have done had they stayed put. They also said their program challenged their assumptions, showed them new perspectives, opened up vocational possibilities, helped them make their faith their own, and gave them skills and courage for living out and talking about their faith. Their comments suggest that practices of separation allow for the development of critical distance, freedom to try out new identities, and the opportunity to personalize learning.

“Go Home to Your Friends”:

Possibilities and Problems of Reintegration

When people meet God on the road, their encounter with holiness often sends them back home changed and ready to effect change. Psalm 126 describes those who go out carrying seeds for sowing and come home singing songs of joy, bearing sheaves. When God’s people go away from home, they come home bearing gifts — new songs to sing, new joy to share, new food to sustain themselves and their neighbors. But a sojourner’s return does not guarantee a community’s welcome. When the wild God of elsewhere sends us home to the here and now, reintegration is never simple.

Jacob finally returned home to the brother he had defrauded, but he came in fear for his life and was shocked by Esau’s graciousness. Naomi returned home accompanied by a faithful daughter-­in-­law who would bless the whole family line, yet she was also a vulnerable widow who had to maneuver her way back into society. After the burning bush, Moses feared that the Hebrew people would scoff at him, and he needed his brother Aaron to partner with him. When Jesus returned to Galilee from the wilderness and preached in his hometown synagogue, his community tried to throw him off a cliff. We do not know what happened to the Gerasene demoniac whom Jesus instructed to go home and tell his friends what the Lord had done for him, but he must surely have faced surprise and skepticism. Return does not guarantee integration. How then can we equip those who return home to tell their stories, sing their songs, spread their joy, and feed others with the food they have gathered? How can we welcome youth who come home changed, helping them integrate what they have learned into the rest of their lives?

The task is not simple — there is no magic formula — and the challenges are real. In our research on the HSTPs, three challenges to reintegration predominated. The first challenge is the tendency for youth to take the path of least resistance and to jump into old ruts at home. Director Andy Brubacher Kaethler tells of a mother who remarked to him with some anxiety that her daughter had come home changed from her program. Her daughter had become committed to discipleship to Christ, zealous about ethics, questioning of consumerism — all disquieting behavior. But then, the mother reported with relief, soccer season began, and her daughter was “back to normal.”

A second challenge is that youth go home to face others’ apathy toward the ideas and practices they have become passionate about. Staff and directors told stories of youth who returned home and tried to convince their youth ministers to talk more about the sacraments, their congregations to address homelessness, or their friends to care about where they buy their clothes — and their efforts fell flat. Their home communities could not relate to their newfound passion and did not join in their work, so their gifts went neglected. Discouraging experiences like this led some youth and alumni to say that their High School Theology Program “ruined” them for churches that go about business as usual.

Third, youth sometimes face others’ active resistance. One alumna of the Youth Theology Initiative at Candler School of Theology was changed by learning about systemic social injustice. Yet her new theological and political opinions wreaked havoc in her relationship with her father. Near tears, she said, “My dad called me ‘you damn liberal’ more than he called me by name for a whole year.” While many youth meet a friendly welcome, others cannot overcome the apathy or resistance they encounter and respond by giving up on their vision, seeking a new congregation, or simply leaving church altogether.

Jeffrey Kottler’s research on factors that make personal change likely to endure resonate with these stories. He names five factors, two of which relate to the initial learning experience, and three that relate to the learner and the learner’s community. First, if the experience of learning involved strong emotional arousal, and second, if learning occurred in multiple modalities, especially in active, experiential learning, then it is more likely to prompt lasting change. Third, for change to endure, the change cannot simply be imposed or superficially experimented with; it must be internalized or personalized. Fourth, the learner needs a community that supports the change. Finally, change persists when learners’ interest and commitment are sustained over time, which requires overcoming frustration, obstacles, and distraction.

The High School Theology Programs generally do an excellent job of supplying the first two factors in Kottler’s list. As participants experience intense community, thoughtful worship, and demanding service and academic learning, they are aroused emotionally. They also engage in experiential, active learning, worshipping in unfamiliar traditions, leading their own worship services, planning and carrying out projects, talking with homeless people, visiting civil rights memorials, backpacking in the wilderness, or praying alongside monks. Youth widely agreed that such active learning experiences changed them. The last three factors — internalized learning, supportive community, and commitment over time — are harder for High School Theology Programs to control, but as we will see, some programs employ practices that make these results more likely.

Preparing Youth to Return: Four Orientations

The Princeton Theological Seminary team found that the High School Theology Programs oriented themselves in four different ways in relation to participants’ home contexts, and that the orientations they chose appeared to affect how they went about preparing young people to return home. The four basic approaches are partnership, substitution-­compensation, transformation, and opposition. While some programs were nearly ideal types, others showed a mix of attitudes.

An Ecology of Faith Formation: A Partnership Approach

Some programs strongly emphasize the positive, interdependent partnership between their program and the home church or family. Directors and staff of these programs refer to a total “ecology” of faith formation, or to an “intergenerational village” that seeks to help young people understand themselves as belonging to the Christian faith or to a particular Christian tradition. They see themselves as playing a distinctive role in this ecology — whether it be helping certain youth explore theological questions, training youth to be leaders, or helping youth grow spiritually, ethically, and relationally. Drawing on the resources that seminaries offer, they offer an intense experience away from home that churches and families cannot give, while still depending on families and churches for recruitment of youth, prayer and moral support, and financial and human resources. Some such programs are specifically geared toward building enthusiasm about ministry vocations or church leadership, and others aim toward “denominational branding,” helping youth understand and commit to their denomination.

The practices associated with this partnership orientation reveal a high level of trust between the program leadership and church leaders. Programs that fit this approach actively recruit youth from churches or parishes, requiring sponsorship or recommendation by a pastor or church leader. In some cases, pastors, priests, or bishops have sent cohorts of youth year after year, welcoming them back to significant positions of leadership or to ongoing projects. The programs in turn show that they value participants’ home contexts and denominational identities, depicting youth as heirs of rich theological or cultural traditions. For example, the Youth Hope-­Builders Academy asks youth to explore the origin of their name and what it reveals about their parents’ hopes for them, and then connect their name to their identity as African American Christians. Likewise, through theological reflection and liturgical practice, the various Roman Catholic programs teach youth to participate meaningfully in Catholic Mass, and the Duke Youth Academy focuses on helping participants appreciate the significance of baptism and communion as practices that mark almost all Christian communities.

A partnership orientation also leads to intentional, ongoing communication with the home context before, during, and after the program. Besides asking for recommendations from the home church, certain programs assign a mentor at home to partner with the participant upon return, providing guidance, accountability, and encouragement. Other programs ask an adult from home to attend the program with youth from their church, or they offer training and information to home churches to help them welcome youth back. Stressing the critical role parents play in faith formation, some programs seek to aid parents in understanding and affirming their children’s learning, so they provide websites and blogs where youth can update parents and post pictures, and they print out and deliver parents’ emails to youth. Some programs afford yet more contact, setting aside time daily for youth to call their families.

Guided by the innovating vision of Dr. Anne Wimberly, the Youth Hope-­Builders program goes even further, treating parents and families as an integral part of their program. They invite parents and families to attend opening and closing ceremonies and to formally release and then receive back their children. Parents and families are also invited to attend two talent shows, an all-­day family recreation day, and subsequent reunions. This remarkable program has recently begun operating within three different congregations, seeking to strengthen partnerships even further. Wimberly points out that participants in her programs are often alienated from their parents or families (they are already separated in many ways, even if they are living at home), so the program seeks to repair this breach through intentional time spent as families, and through teaching practices of communication.

The strengths of a partnership model are many. Since programs oriented this way draw on the resources of other institutions, they do not have to be or do everything for participants, but can focus on what they do best. Since they build trust over time with churches and families and show themselves an ally to them, they may have an easier time raising financial support and becoming self-­sustaining. They also set youth up to feel a sense of belonging to a church, denomination, or religious tradition, making for a more seamless transition between the program and the home. Further, since programs with this orientation are motivated to work for healthy connections to home communities, they invest time in finding adults who can offer mentorship not only at the program, but also in home contexts, thus increasing the likelihood that youth will return to a supportive community. As Kottler notes, such a supportive community can help sustain change because it offers help and accountability.

A partnership approach is most vulnerable where it is most dependent. Since it depends on families and churches as partners, it suffers when churches and families do not take responsibility for their role in the ecology of faith formation. Even with efforts to connect with home contexts, programs cannot always overcome the apathy, resistance, or abuse some young people meet at home. Further, when programs maximize continuity between home and the program, they may neglect the psychological benefits of separation from the home context, which include opportunities to individuate and to personalize one’s learning, rather than uncritically assuming the beliefs, practices, and worldview of the home context. Despite these weaknesses, a partnership approach appears to be one of the more successful at preparing young people to return to their communities as gift-­bearers, rather than as strangers or enemies.

“Going Deeper”: A Substitution or Compensation Approach

In contrast to programs that see themselves as part of a larger ecology of faith formation, certain programs function as substitutes for or alternatives to the church or family, either as a short-­term “home away from home” or a stand-­alone experience of an ideal church community. While this is sometimes the case simply because programs want to offer youth a fulsome experience of faith formation in community, it is more frequently an attempt to compensate for the failures of family and church. Those failures can be quite real, with some youth reporting fractured or abusive families, churches in crisis, and youth programs that do not take young people’s questions or leadership seriously. For some participants, their program becomes the first place they have encountered life-­giving Christian community that deals with conflict constructively, honors their hard questions, and equips them for leadership.

In this substitution approach, the dominant theme is not continuity, but contrast between the program and the home context. Such contrast is often construed in terms of depth. Staff talked about wanting to give youth opportunities for deep conversation, penetrating exploration, and profound communion that are unavailable at home, and they faulted youth groups that serve up manic entertainment and facile answers, as well as distracted, busy, and ill-­equipped parents and a culture of instant gratification and distraction. This is not to say that these staff had no sympathy for the challenges youth ministers and parents face, but that they had learned they could not rely on churches and families as dependable partners in faith formation, and so needed to supply youth with a whole experience of education, worship, and community.

Many youth also used depth language in interviews, expressing gratitude for the chance to “go deeper” in theological exploration and in community, and contrasting their High School Theology Program with boring or authoritarian teaching and shallow relationships at home. A few youth suggested that their youth leaders and parents were more interested in telling them what to believe than in engaging them in conversation around hard questions. Yet youth were not entirely negative about their churches and families. No youth blamed their youth pastors for lack of depth and admitted their church leaders tried to get real conversations going, but to little effect. They attributed such failures to the fact that church youth ministries involve less intense, less frequent time together and include a greater range of ages and commitment levels.

In this substitution approach, family language abounds: youth say (and are told) that they are brothers and sisters in Christ; mentors are referred to as older siblings, aunts, or uncles; directors and pastors are called or treated as surrogate parents, and the group engages in regular “family times.” Youth also comment that they see their group as their new family, whom they will depend on when they return home. As this new family or mini-­congregation develops its own rituals, worship patterns, prayers, and rules of engagement, youth express a deep sense of belonging. Yet unlike the previous approach, in which youth feel they belong to a larger faith tradition or community, they feel they belong to a smaller community that lives what they perceive to be a more authentic expression of the Christian life than they see at home.

While almost all the programs offer youth a bracing experience of deep theological exploration, exposing youth to new theological concepts and vocabulary, programs that take a substitution or compensation approach are more likely to urge youth to try on ideas and practices that are unfamiliar to or at odds with their home context. In this way, they encourage them to individuate from their received faith and to claim faith as their own. If the partnership orientation pictures youth as heirs of a rich theological tradition, this approach pictures youth as courageous miners or divers who go deep in search of treasure.

Since programs that take this approach do not entirely trust that a supportive church and family awaits participants, they approach reintegration by seeking to extend the program’s community. They emphasize the power of social media groups, regular reunions, and ongoing contact between alumni and staff to keep the community going, and they stress to youth the importance of finding others at home who also want to go deep. They may also encourage youth to start their own groups at home modeled on their experience of ideal family and church.

The strengths of this approach are that youth are excited by the emotional intensity of belonging to their new “family,” by the closeness and freshness of personalized worship practices, and by deep theological exploration. In Kottler’s terms, they claim their learning as their own, they are alerted to the fact that they will face obstacles at home, and they are encouraged to seek supportive community. Yet since this approach does not stress partnerships with churches and families, it risks sending youth home without advocates or mentors to guide them and offer accountability. In addition, this approach sometimes encourages youth to identify a short-­term, intense experience with authentic community or church but neglects to admit the special resources and planning required to pull off such a program (including seminary-­trained mentors and seasoned theological teachers with doctorates) — resources that are often simply not available in home contexts. When youth start to believe that their home contexts should replicate exactly the ideal they have experienced while away, they risk becoming judges and critics rather than gift-­bearers.

“You Can Change the World”: A Transformational Approach

A third approach sees youth as change agents who can transform their church or family by offering leadership in their congregations and by “catechizing their families,” in the words of one director. Like the previous pattern, this approach is realistic about churches and families and also stresses deep community life and theological exploration. Yet this approach wants to harness young people’s zeal and dissatisfaction for the sake of change. In this pattern, youth are reformers and prophets who bring a balance of good news and wise judgment to share with their youth groups, congregations, and families. The goal is that they will remain committed to their churches and families, while developing critical distance and skills for effecting change.

Programs with a transformation approach try to offer youth a distinctive experience of Christian discipleship, encourage them to discern what aspects of it might enrich or transform their home context, and equip them with skills for making change happen. They train them by giving youth opportunities to plan, lead, and debrief events, thus raising their competency and confidence as leaders. They ask youth to envision themselves returning home to live out what they have learned. They practice role-­playing around certain challenges or temptations youth will face and invite youth to write documents describing the change they seek, draft action plans, research organizations that can serve as resources, and name possible allies and mentors at home. They also bring alumni to speak with current participants about the challenges they faced — as well as victories won — at home.

This approach, when done well, can be quite effective at supporting the process of separation and reintegration. By modeling a different way of life and granting young people a prophetic identity, they help them separate and individuate from the home context. By teaching skills for effecting change at home, they help youth internalize learning and sustain their interest and commitment over the long term — two of the factors Kottler names as contributing to enduring change. In this approach, youth are given maximum opportunity to integrate what they have learned into their daily lives.

Yet the transformation approach has two major risks. First, it risks using young people as pawns in a colonizing scheme that disregards the integrity of the traditions from which youth come. Young people come from contexts that have their own unique cultures, traditions, theologies, and attitudes. While some of these patterns may be broken or corrupt, others simply differ from the dominant culture or theology of the High School Theology Program. In challenging young people to change their home contexts, HSTPs must be extremely careful not to hold up their program as the only viable pattern of Christian community or to impose ideological norms on young people. When programs impose norms on youth who will go home as change agents, they risk making them into insensitive colonizers, rather than equipping them as indigenous leaders who translate between traditions and cultures.

A second risk is that youth will try to transform their church or family without help from guiding adults who can interpret the theological and historical underpinnings of the practices youth encounter at home. For example, a girl from a church that does not ordain women might learn to preach at her program, youth from a praise-­band church might embrace Taizé music, and a young man from a conservative congregation might befriend gay and lesbian mentors or youth. When such youth go home, they may be enthusiastic about transforming congregational practices and attitudes, but they might not see that those practices and attitudes are the visible tip of vast submerged icebergs. When they crash into the bulk of deep tradition, they need adult partners to help them understand what is happening and decide what to do next, or they may quickly find themselves out of their depth.

“Stand Strong”: An Oppositional Approach

A final stance is more adversarial and is often the result of significant frustration with home contexts that have failed young people or rejected their leadership. No program we studied takes this approach alone; rather, certain programs occasionally depart from one of the other approaches and become openly oppositional to the family and church. For example, in various interviews, staff and alumni from different theological traditions lamented that the church has bought into a larger corrupt culture and forsaken a countercultural gospel, and that it is failing young people by infantilizing them, offering them poor substitutes for substantive education and formation, and refusing to heed their voices. Some churches and denominations, they explained, appear to be totally resistant to the change that High School Theology Programs represent, leaving the program no choice but to take an oppositional stance. Staff also described the role some parents play in keeping youth groups too safe and entertainment-­oriented, worried about church programs that become subservient to such parents, and told of parents who were angered by how the program shifted their child’s political or theological views or vocational hopes away from their own. Though youth were less likely to speak so critically, they occasionally expressed frustration with the rigidity, shallowness, or intellectual apathy they perceived at home.

If in the transformational approach youth were reformers and prophets, now they are separatists, puritans, and pioneers, bravely striking out from a corrupt church. In their program they learn to own a faith that may be quite different from what they learned at home, to engage in conflict honestly and unflinchingly, to act courageously when no one else agrees with them, and to seek faithful people outside their families or congregations.

This stance obviously affects communications between home and the program. Some staff, aware that their program’s theological or ethical convictions conflict with what participants’ churches and parents may espouse, stress the importance of being radically transparent with parents and church leaders, while others take the opposite tack, expressly not advertising in advance the more controversial topics youth will encounter. Since in this view parents, churches, and church leadership are not usually allies, they also do not make obvious recruitment partners, nor are they abundant sources of mentors. Instead, mentors in these programs tend to be critical of churches and families. From this perspective, the task of integration is more about integrating what one has learned into one’s life, but not about reintegrating into church or family — for in that way lie frustration and backsliding.

The oppositional approach has real merit, given the fact that certain churches and families really do resist change, reject young people’s leadership, or abuse their vulnerability. It is not naïve about the frustrations youth may face at home and can offer sympathy and support to youth who suffer rejection by their home context. But this stance risks becoming harshly puritanical, judgmental, or cynical. It does not give credit to those churches and families who are doing an excellent job with their youth (and these are often churches and families who have raised youth who want to attend a High School Theology Program to begin with!) or who have good intentions. Further, like the substitution and transformation approaches, this stance can unfairly hold home contexts to the standard of an intense experience away from home that has access to tremendous resources. If youth buy into that ideal vision, they can become disillusioned with families and congregations, where the tasks of daily living and mundane administrative matters demand attention, and where the journey of faith is walked at a slower pace. Finally, because an oppositional stance tends to be frustrated with compromise, it rules out the potential of partnering with “good-­enough” mentors and institutions at home. The risk is that these programs will send young people home without adult advocates or partners, setting youth up for frustration.

Lessons for Theological Education and Congregations

High School Theology Programs have much to teach theological education and congregations about effective ministry with young people. All four of the approaches — partnership, substitution-­compensation, transformation, and opposition — seek to honor young people’s needs and concerns, foster spiritual and personal maturity, and give them skills for navigating life, exploring theology, and offering leadership. In all HSTPs, youth are central to the ministry of the church and can provide leadership and vision now and in the future. In contrast to popular culture depictions of youth as shallow consumers, wild animals, or vulnerable victims, HSTPs treat youth as beloved heirs of a rich tradition, members of a close community, capable explorers who can go deep, powerful prophets and reformers who can change their world, and social critics and activists who act courageously. For all their differences, these perspectives can fuel the imagination of congregations who struggle to hang on to youth past confirmation, form youth as disciples, or send youth out as leaders.

While all four approaches have merit, two of these orientations appear to be more helpful for the task of reintegration — the partnership and the transformation approaches. The substitution-­compensation approach responds to real crises in the home and the church, but it too easily leaves youth without a supportive everyday community that can help sustain their work, and since it tends to be focused on the experience of ideal community, it does not usually teach critical skills for effecting change. Moreover, although the opposition approach is sometimes justified and can form dedicated activists and pioneers, it precludes the option of reintegrating into a home community, leaving youth vulnerable to loneliness and defeat. The partnership approach, on the other hand, fully expects from the beginning that youth will return to their communities, so it maximizes those communities as resources even as it offers them information and training. At its best, this holistic approach gives young people freedom to explore while also showing them the way back home, and it provides for mentoring relationships with caring adults. The transformation approach takes into account the crises and problems that give rise to the substitution and opposition patterns, but it does so in a more proactive, positive way that seeks a balance of criticism and commitment. At its best, this approach not only builds up young people’s courage and confidence but also gives them skills to interpret culture, propose change, and lead transforming movements — all skills needed by leadership of the church in the twenty-­first century.

As theological institutions seek to form church and community leaders, they might take lessons from the partnership and transformation approaches. Today an increasing number of theological students come from independent, non-­denominational churches without processes that intentionally bridge the experience of the home context and seminary. Theological schools can choose to claim that this bridging activity is someone else’s responsibility (the student’s or the home church), or they can seek ways to partner with churches and community groups, making explicit the expectation that students will use their schooling to bless and transform congregations and communities.

One intriguing possibility comes from Andover Newton Theological School, which is preparing to pilot a cooperative MDiv degree program. Designed to eliminate seminary student debt and foster church connections, the five-­year program offers students the opportunity to apprentice to a seasoned pastor while serving in a congregation through their whole seminary career. Students in this program receive academic credit for the work they do in church, build relationships in a congregational setting, and engage in action and reflection in an ecclesial community they come to know well. They learn skills for transforming communities even as they participate in them as committed pastors. As experiments like the one at Andover Newton proceed, they can look forward to receiving capable, prophetic students who have been formed by High School Theology Programs, students who already know that when they journey to encounter the God of elsewhere, they return to share what they have learned, singing new songs of joy, carrying sheaves of grain.

. Martin Gardner, The Flight of Peter Fromm (New York: Prometheus Books, 1994).

. Barbara Kingsolver, Flight Behavior (New York: Harper, 2012).

. Jeffrey Kottler, Travel That Can Change Your Life: How to Create a Transformative Experience (San Francisco: Jossey-­Bass, 1997) and Making Changes Last (New York: Routledge, 2001), p. 130.

. Nicholas A. Christakis and James H. Fowler, Connected: The Surprising Power of Our Social Networks and How They Shape Our Lives — How Your Friends’ Friends’ Friends Affect Everything You Feel, Think, and Do (New York: Back Bay Books, 2009).

. Kottler, “Change: What Really Makes a Difference?” Psychology Today, December 8, 2010, http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/helping-­yourself-­helping-­others/201012/making-­changes-­last (accessed November 27, 2013).

. See especially David Horn’s chapter in this volume: “Prepare Me for a Worthy Adventure: Pedagogies of Pilgrimage in the Compass Program of Gordon-­Conwell Theological Seminary.”

. Kottler, “Change: What Really Makes a Difference?”

. These categories bear a strong resemblance to the taxonomy H. Richard Niebuhr offers in his Christ and Culture (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1951), though they were created without his work in mind.

↑ Back to top

↑