Chapter 21 of 25

Kenda Creasy Dean

Kenda Creasy Dean

Kenda Creasy Dean

If you want to build a ship, don’t drum up people to collect wood and don’t assign tasks and work, but rather teach them to long for the endless immensity of the sea.

Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, Citadelle (1948)

If Branch Rickey had been a theological educator, he would have been intensely interested in High School Theology Programs. We now think of Rickey as a Harrison Ford creation from the movie 42. But W. Branch Rickey, the ardently Methodist (W. stood for “Wesley”) baseball manager who in 1945 signed Jackie Robinson to the Brooklyn Dodgers, changed modern baseball. Signing Robinson may have been the most revolutionary thing Rickey did, but he also invented batting cages, pitching machines, and batting helmets, was the first to track player statistics, and — always a sucker for young talent — was the first manager in baseball history to develop a farm team. Rickey had coached college baseball at Allegheny College and Ohio Wesleyan University when his own playing career tanked, and he knew that a ball club was only as good as the depth of its young talent. So he invented the farm team system, a strategy designed to deepen the pool of young players who could step into professional-­level baseball, ready to play. By aligning Minor League clubs with Major League franchises like the St. Louis Cardinals and the Brooklyn Dodgers, Rickey could corral and refine young, passionate players for his teams’ futures.

The farm system allowed Rickey to create baseball dynasties. As other teams began copying Rickey’s methods, it became obvious that ball clubs with farm systems did far better than clubs without them. Today, every Major League team has a farm system, a set of affiliated lower-­level teams that invest in promising young players by giving them experience, practice, and highly invested teammates while grooming them to become Major League players.

Farm teams do not cultivate talent; they cultivate readiness. Talent is assumed in every player who plays on a farm team; these players already know baseball and have a sense of what their particular abilities — already noticed and named by others — contribute. The point of the farm team is to groom young players with noticeable potential and an unquenchable passion for the game for the moment when their particular gifts and passions are called for by the Major League parent team. Playing for a farm team gives players already hooked on baseball access to coaches, training, and practical experience, as well as a community of similarly impassioned teammates who understand what it means to feel like baseball is a calling.

The Minor Leagues of Church Leadership

Just as Minor League baseball existed before Rickey co-­opted it as a training ground for the Majors, “farm systems” for theological leadership existed long before the Lilly Endowment gathered youth ministers and professors teaching youth ministry to invent High School Theology Programs. For several generations, confirmation programs, church camps, volunteer corps, and denominational youth leadership organizations all gave spiritually curious teenagers opportunities to deepen their affinity for the church and to cultivate a readiness for Christian leadership. These programs were seldom teenagers’ first introduction to faith; for the most part, teenagers who entered these programs had already been exposed to Christianity at home or in a local congregation, and consequently they already had a rudimentary faith vocabulary and, sometimes, deep theological curiosity. Often, their potential for Christian leadership had already been noticed. Done well, these youth programs served — and still serve — as greenhouses for vocational readiness. Done poorly, they served — and still serve — as colossal wasted opportunities.

Take church camp, for example. Wayne Meisel, Director of the Center for Faith and Service at McCormick Theological Seminary, describes Christian camps as “the minor leagues for church membership and leadership” because these camps inspire, identify, and train young people as church leaders. Thousands of young people find Christian community more palpable — and their gifts more utilized — in the course of summer camp than in their congregations or youth groups, and for these young people, camp becomes “the new church.” Meisel’s assessment is borne out by a 2013 Presbyterian Church (USA) survey reporting that 43 percent of PCUSA pastors say their most significant “spiritual experience” happened at a camp, retreat, or conference (compared to about one-­fourth of their parishioners, who were more likely to have significant spiritual experiences in congregations). More than three out of four church leaders, both lay and ordained, identified camps as either “important” or “very important” for developing Christian young adults as leaders, even declaring their “highest priority” to be providing camp scholarships to new members (a statement that seems to reflect more hope than action, given Presbyterian camps’ recent difficulties in garnering dollars and participants).

Another oft-­cited training ground for Christian leadership are denominational volunteer corps. Catholics are among those making use of such ministries for leadership formation; a 2013 survey of alumni from Catholic volunteer service organizations called “volunteering for a year of service in a faith-­based volunteer service organization . . . a next step in a young adult’s [vocational] discernment process.” The study found that volunteer service years both attract those already interested in ministry (77 percent considered ordained ministry or religious life prior to participating in a volunteer service year) and serve as important contexts for ongoing vocational discernment (nearly half continued to discern a call to religious vocation during volunteer service years). Twice as many Catholic women and more than ten times as many Catholic men seek ordination, attend seminary, or serve in church leadership roles after a volunteer service year than those without this experience.

While youth ministries like camps and service corps have long sought to deepen young people’s faith — and while the vocational influence of such programs can be profound — this formation is also sporadic. It is more often the result of a fortuitous combination of volunteer leaders than a coordinated curricular effort, suggesting that church leaders are either unaware of these ministries’ genius for encouraging vocational discernment, or are uncertain why it matters. Whether these experiences are substantive, intentional, abundant, or compelling enough to create deep pools rather than puddles of young talent is unclear. Nor is it clear whether the “Major Leagues” of Christian vocational formation — congregations, denominations, and theological schools — are prepared to make room for this young talent when it appears.

High School Theology Programs build on existing youth ministry programs but add both intentionality and curricular support to the task of vocational discernment. Most youth leave the womb of a High School Theology Program thinking of themselves as leaders in their congregations and communities, and they re-­enter their home congregations with high expectations for contributing there (as we saw in chapter 6, the degree to which churches welcome these contributions varies widely).

High School Theology Programs differ from farm teams in two important respects, however. First, unlike the minor leagues, High School Theology Programs do not view themselves as preparatory holding tanks for future players. High School Theology Program leaders are steadfast in their insistence that young people are the church of right now and not just tomorrow: every HSTP impresses on teenagers that the church requires their leadership immediately, and that youth, not their managers, decide that they are ready to enter the game. Second, unlike farm teams that prepare players for baseball’s established roles, High School Theology Program leaders encourage switch-­hitting and experimentation; the roles their alumni will play in the church are unknown, and “hacking” the system is encouraged.

Now What?

What theological educators learn about vocational formation from this conversation depends significantly on how we choose to use the findings in this book. You could read these pages in a number of ways: as a handbook, as an indictment, or as a mirror. These vantage points are useful in different ways.

A Handbook: Field Guide for Better Pedagogy

The obvious way to use this book is as a pedagogical resource. High School Theology Programs serve as proving grounds for experiential, embodied, personally invested, and communal learning as effective means for handing on living arts like Christian discipleship, where social modeling and existential openness are as critical to learning as understanding content.

What could this mean for untangling some of the wicked problems facing theological education? What would it look like, for instance, if theological content were used — unapologetically — to evoke experiences of liminality, competence, holy struggle, and belonging because these experiences are so closely aligned with vocational transformation? Would church leaders lead differently if seminaries were cultures of mentoring, or if preparing for ministry required immersion in pilgrimages, intentional disruption, service, and the arts? How would divinity schools change if the theological curriculum openly addressed, not only students who have answered a “call,” but students who are still wondering if they have one?

Of course, many theological educators already attend to these nuances. Take, for example, the growing commitment to culturally responsive pedagogies — a top priority for North American educators seeking to address increasingly diverse students. Educators committed to culturally-­reponsive teaching use the liminality and struggle inherent in encountering cultural others a pedagogical opportunities, not as problems to be solved. Still, institutions change habits far more slowly than individual educators. If we use this study primarily as a pedagogical resource, we will find that the High School Theology Programs mostly reinforce what we already know about education. For the most part, teachers already know the value of the pedagogies used by HSTPs. We simply fail to use them in graduate school, for both personal and institutional reasons.

Without pedagogical intentionality, educational institutions do not shape students’ attention; they consume it. We confuse exposure with learning, and send our students off to spin the data we dispense into wisdom they can use. We now have nearly two decades of evidence from HSTPs affirming what postmodern educators take for granted: we are shaped by our experience as well as by the people who experience the world alongside us; our bodies, and our communities, store knowledge; authenticity begets authenticity; preparing young people to lead healthy, life-­giving Christian communities requires experience in such communities; plunging teenagers into communities of leadership practices tends to cause them to think of themselves as leaders. We did not need High School Theology Programs to know these things. So the real question HSTPs awaken in educators is not “What must we do?” to make vocational formation more effective, but rather “Why aren’t we doing it?”

An Indictment: Evidence of Problems in North American Youth Ministry

You could easily interpret our research on High School Theology Programs as an indictment of the goals, practices, and outcomes of North America’s dominant “fellowship” models of youth ministry. High School Theology Programs emerged from the Lilly Endowment’s dissatisfaction with the kind of vocational formation taking place (or not) in North American congregations through existing youth ministry programs. This was especially true for spiritually interested teenagers, for whom ministry based primarily on teenagers’ social needs left them theologically malnourished and vocationally unchallenged.

Thanks to research of the last decade, we now know that this form of youth ministry not only failed to deepen the faith of spiritually interested teenagers; it did little to deepen the faith of anyone. Intuitively, teenagers recognized the impotence of our good intentions, shrugging their way through confirmation, Sunday school, youth group, and other formative practices while taking advantage of youth ministry’s social networks. Most teenagers do not view their experience in youth ministry negatively; they are glad for the role these activities play in their lives, and grateful for the connections they make with peers and adults. In a society where alienation often has tragic consequences for teenagers, this is no small matter. Nonetheless, teenagers frequently graduate from their congregational youth ministries with little to show in terms of theological formation, and are relatively untouched vocationally.

One of the comments we heard most frequently from teenagers we interviewed was their profound appreciation for “being taken seriously” in High School Theology Programs. As we saw in chapter 2, the experience of “being taken seriously” comes in many forms: being assigned challenging theological readings, being taught by “real” seminary professors, being challenged to work with people very different from themselves, being genuinely “heard” by caring adults, being given responsibilities and leadership tasks that seemed beyond their capacities, only to be encouraged and cheered when they succeeded. Many youth contrasted the HSTP’s seriousness of purpose and permission to speak plainly with experiences they had had elsewhere in youth ministry, where both purpose and permission were in short supply.

If we were to view High School Theology Programs as an implicit critique of North America’s dominant forms of youth ministry, we would find little resistance from most youth ministers, who recoil from being cast as purveyors of “juvenile” (i.e., immature) faith. The “juvenilization” thesis in youth ministry — namely, that youth ministry is responsible for originating a kind of shallow, immature Christianity that has spread like pinkeye through adult congregations — is wrong (research overwhelmingly suggests that teenagers learn their faith from adults, not vice versa), but the view is compelling and widespread. Equating youth ministry with immaturity, in faith formation or anything else, causes even those who want to do ministry with teenagers to eschew the title “youth minister,” especially if they want to be taken seriously by theological educators and graduate schools.

The irony is that “fellowship models” of youth ministry were instituted, not to entertain teenagers socially, but to give them leadership experience they would presumably use in their future as active adult church members. Youth groups have been standard fare in American churches since Christian Endeavor swept the United States and Canada in the late nineteenth century, but these youth “societies” were youth-­directed, and intended as training grounds for church leadership skills. Young people were expected to show up and speak up, and Christian Endeavor mobilized many vocal young people as spokespersons for the social gospel movement and for leadership in Christian Endeavor itself. Even in the 1940s, when fellowship groups replaced youth societies, these groups cultivated young leaders for the ecumenical church and the broader society. Fellowship groups reflected postwar America’s faith in institutions, as well as the ecumenical movement’s optimism in the power of Christians gathering together, and taught young people ecclesial governance and ways to mobilize groups for social change — which they did, especially around racial equality, two decades before adults in their denominations followed suit.

Yet the fellowship era also reflected America’s emerging youth culture, which promoted age stratification and replaced community organizations and institutions as teenagers’ primary source of tribal identity. As age-­segregation became normative in churches as well as in the culture at large, youth spent less time with adults they admired and less time in intergenerational communities eavesdropping on the experience of other generations. Instead of entering adulthood first as de facto “apprentices” to elders they admired, North American teenagers increasingly began raising each other, causing journalist Patricia Hersch to conclude in 1999 that North American teenagers were, in fact, “a tribe apart.”

Amidst these shifts, youth groups’ original purpose of being training grounds for Christian leadership shifted, too. As churches felt their credibility erode among teenagers, the field of youth ministry became more concerned with the vocation of the youth pastor than the vocation of the teenager. Youth groups became another node in peer culture, a redundant place for teenagers to hang out with friends and with caring adults. Presumably what set youth fellowship groups apart from countless competing activities and social networks was the fact that youth groups gave teenagers peers who shared their faith. Where this was true, it was generally significant. The problem was that it was less often true than we thought. Just because teenagers came to church did not mean they could distinguish Christian faith from the “moralistic therapeutic deist” culture at large. In fact, by the mid-­twentieth century, churches had become extremely effective vehicles for socializing young people into a bland, homogenized Christendom, from which moralistic therapeutic deism sprang.

Most youth ministers would be grateful for High School Theology Programs’ critique of what youth “fellowships” have become (after all, youth ministers helped design HSTPs as a way to offer a form of vocational formation not currently available in most yourth groups). HSTPs directly challenge the bland religiosity that dominates North American culture, and explicitly counter the “juvenile” stereotype associated with adolescents. By treating teenagers as young adults, as “scholars,” as leaders — and by expecting a level of maturity and reflexivity seldom expected of adolescents — HSTPs give teenagers an experience of legitimacy associated with adulthood. This is a status young people crave, in churches as elsewhere; recall the young woman we met in chapter 1, pleading at the Catholic Theological Union: “Whatever you do, please don’t give us the Fisher-­Price version of theology!” By focusing on spiritually interested young people, High School Theology Programs unapologetically address the mostly convinced, but they also affirm — in a boots-­on-­the-­ground, lives-­are-­at-­stake kind of way — these teenagers’ hope that Christianity actually matters, that living one’s faith makes a decisive difference in the world, and that the God of Abraham, Moses, and Mary has bigger plans than Sunday night youth group.

A Mirror: Why Do We Do What We Do?

A third way to use this study of the vocational pedagogies used by High School Theology Programs is as a mirror we can hold up to churches, denominations, and theological schools to help us think critically about our current systems of Christian leadership formation, as we ask how well those systems prepare young leaders for the twenty-­first-­century church. In particular, this book suggests four reflections that are worth thinking about:

1. What is seminary for?

If you happened to be a seminarian at the Renk Theological College in South Sudan, you would be studying for the salvation business in very literal ways. In South Sudan, first semester seminarians are not introduced to theology, church history, youth ministry, preaching, or pastoral care. Instead, the first four classes required of every student at Renk Theological College are biblical Greek, biblical Hebrew, agriculture, and public health. The first semester curriculum at Renk is indicative of the purpose of seminary in South Sudan. Students come to seminary primarily to save lives — physically and existentially — which is why their seminary education begins with the growing and healing arts: the care of the soul (biblical Greek, biblical Hebrew) and the care of the community (agriculture, public health).

On the whole, seminaries in North America are far more directed towards saving churches than saving lives. A good deal of time is devoted to dispensing information that we want pastors to have, and to teaching students how to think in the disciplined ways that we want pastors to think. Biblical, historical, theological, philosophical, and practical studies infuse North American theological education; “saving lives” is something best left to Jesus, or so we say. Meanwhile, the assumptions governing our seminary curricula (for example, that students come to seminary to prepare to lead churches) do not always match the assumptions of students (who may be in seminary to discern whether they are called to ministry in the first place).

At the same time, some seminary leaders argue that the MDiv degree — once a standard requirement for ordination — now functions more like an MBA: beneficial, but optional. Ironically, this shift is taking place at a time when the ecology of Christian formation has collapsed; many churchgoers cannot articulate the difference between following Jesus and working for Google (official slogan: “Don’t be evil”). The upshot is that seminaries often now face new responsibilities in providing basic Christian education for their students whose own religious formation is quite sketchy, and who may one day have responsibility for discipling others.

In an educational climate where the life-­giving arts have been siphoned off to medical schools and social work; justice has become the terrain of law schools; the art of community-­building is given to engineers, educators, and social planners; and changing the world belongs to social entrepreneurs — seminary education is fishing for purpose. As we mentioned in chapter 1, one trend facing theological education in the early twenty-­first century is the fact that Christian young people who want to make a difference often do not seem to think the church is the best place to do it. High School Theology Programs offer young people a way of thinking about theological education as a route to multiple vocations that represent Christ in the world — and they go a long way toward putting ministry on young people’s vocational radars. Theological education becomes a way to do more than save churches; it becomes a way to join in God’s work to save lives, in multiple ways.

2. Should theological education be a post-­undergraduate degree?

The word “seminary” means “seedbed” — suggesting a slow, nurturing environment for a growing, living organism as it takes root. The clarion call from Auburn Theological Seminary’s 2013 research on seminary students is that intentional, long-­term nurturing environments matter enormously for vocational discernment, since “seminarians don’t come from nowhere.” Barbara Wheeler explains,

None of the interviewees and, from what we can tell from the survey data, very few students in the total population wander into seminary out of curiosity or are snatched by us from a wholly secular culture. Almost all seminary students have been embedded in religious communities, involved in religious institutions, and exposed to religious role models for a long time, usually since birth.

In other words, if the seed of Christian vocation is not planted early, it is very unlikely to spontaneously sprout at age twenty-­one. Despite numerous factors that appear significant in shaping a young person’s decision to attend seminary, Wheeler contends that nothing replaces the long, slow nurture of faith by families and congregations.

This should not surprise us. Go back to Joshua Bell’s unexpected concert in the subway station, described in chapter 1. Here’s how Gene Weingarten, writing in The Washington Post, described people’s reactions that morning:

There was no ethnic or demographic pattern to distinguish the people who stayed to watch Bell, or the ones who gave money, from that vast majority who hurried on past, unheeding. Whites, blacks and Asians, young and old, men and women, were represented in all three groups. But the behavior of one demographic remained absolutely consistent. Every single time a child walked past, he or she tried to stop and watch. And every single time, a parent scooted the kid away. (italics mine)

Weingarten reminds us of the poet Billy Collins’ joke that all babies are born with an innate knowledge of poetry, because, according to Collins, the mother’s heart beats in iambic meter. But then, Collins said, “Life slowly starts to choke the poetry out of us.” Weingarten wonders if maybe that is true of music, too.

Their suspicions are justified; studies show a sharp decline in creativity in children once they start school, with the most significant decline occurring between kindergarten and third grade. In 1991, Harvard child psychiatrist Robert Coles’ landmark research on young children and spirituality reported, with some awe, that after scores of conversations with children, even those whose parents were atheists and had never attended a religious service initiated conversations about God. Coles concluded that theological thinking comes naturally to children as they try to make sense of their world — at least, it seems, until they get old enough to care what people think.

If calling is a creative practice of communities, then the church benefits by engaging younger people in vocational discernment. Maybe the “blue ocean” of theological formation is not found in developing more creative forms of graduate theological education, but in creating more opportunities for children and youth to participate in high-­touch ecologies of vocational discernment, capitalizing on certain “critical periods” for vocational formation — periods of spiritual readiness (or at least openness) that seem especially conducive to entertaining the idea of a “call.” Adolescence and emerging adulthood seem to be two such periods. As we saw in chapter 12, young adult staff members and mentors in High School Theology Programs seem to find the vocational practices intended for high school students significant in helping them discern their own vocational trajectories. These young staff members are able to respond to vocational formation in part because they are building on prior scaffolding supplied by earlier periods of religious formation.

One possibility for seminaries to consider may be offering theological education in stages, rather than save it for graduate school. To seriously consider “staging” vocational formation will require graduate theological schools to make hard choices about deploying funds and leadership. Are we willing to divert funds into programs (like High School Theology Programs) that may or may not pay off in terms of later enrollment? Is engaging children and youth in communities of vocational practices what is needed to pique young people’s desire for graduate theological education, once they are old enough to attend? Should seminaries become actively engaged in supporting congregational practices of vocational discernment with young people? Some stages of formation may require new investments for theological schools (like High School Theology Programs), but some may simply be a matter of helping congregations re-­tool practices already familiar and dear to them.

Confirmation, for instance, is a kind of vocational discernment process, at least theologically speaking. Recasting confirmation as a way to help teenagers begin to discern a call to both Christian discipleship and Christian leadership starts with a congregation, which names young people’s gifts, and then confirms this vocation by letting youth use those gifts for ministry. But this approach requires congregations, pastors, and youth ministers to rid ourselves of perfunctory versions of confirmation, allowing it to become an occasion for experiences of liminality, competence, deep belonging, and holy struggle, and for honing their leadership through service, witness, and stewardship.

3. Is the schooling model for theological education

the best model we have?

Among the most explicit aims of High School Theology Programs is to help teenagers “fall in love with theology.” Mastering theology is not the objective; loving theology is — making the goal of HSTPs the formation of desires as well as the formation of vocation. Many theological educators would hope for something similar among their own students, as well. We know the limits of academic theology: while seminary does an admirable job exposing future church leaders to the foundations of Christian theology and introduces them to certain habits of mind that we want Christian leaders to exhibit, it is less clear how degree programs, graded curriculum, academic calendars, and for-­credit courses help students fall in love with “the study of God.”

The point is not to rid ourselves of academic programs or denigrate theological scholarship. Both of these are critical for a new generation of intellectually engaged, theologically disciplined church leaders. High School Theology Programs draw significantly on these resources. But scores of theologically interested HSTP alumni challenge the assumption that schooling models of theological education are the only effective vehicles for teaching and inspiring theological leadership. HSTP alumni frequently describe discovering a “lifelong love for theology” during their High School Theology Programs that made them look for ways to continue being part of theological conversations as they entered college and beyond. Wheeler’s research underscores the importance of both informal and formal educational experiences in young people’s vocational formation. For example, the influence of religious formation in school settings, especially colleges, is a factor in encouraging young people to attend seminary — though it is less clear whether this influence stems from religious coursework or from participating in a subculture that makes room for theological conversations about vocation.

Wheeler also reminds us that early and sustained religious formation through a family and congregation remain the most important tools for vocational formation that we know. Role models in faith leadership, the presence of a faithful peer group, and participation in formative micro-­cultures like church camps, religious “niche” cultures, and/or parachurch youth ministries all have measurable impacts on young people’s likelihood to attend seminary. Among other things, these experiences seem to give students tools that help them frame disruptive experiences in light of a religious tradition. As Wheeler notes, “Almost all seminary students have been embedded in religious communities, involved in religious institutions, and exposed to religious role models for a long time, usually since birth.” Of course, there is nothing stopping formal theological education from providing analogous experiences. The problem is that for a young person to wait until seminary to discover religious role models, faithful peer groups, disruptive existential experiences, and so on means it is highly unlikely that he or she will go to seminary at all.

High School Theology Programs remind us that formal theological education is one way — but not the only way — to form Christian leaders. Desperation has its advantages; dwindling congregations and the loss of young leadership have forced experimentation on the part of both seminaries and denominations, even where ordination is concerned. The upshot has been an increasing number of intriguing (if embryonic) experiments around new models of leadership formation. Promising experiments are multiplying. The Anglican mission pioneer program in the United Kingdom offers a multi-­tiered, multiple platform delivery system for theological education for lay and ordained leaders. The Center for Youth Ministry Training “flipped” the ratio of classroom and congregational experience for master’s degree students in youth ministry. Post-­seminary residencies in mentoring congregations, such as the Lilly Pastoral Residency Program, rely on learning communities that work with, but go beyond, traditional MDiv education. These communities tend to include networks of mutual accountability, relational authority through mentoring and coaching, apprenticeship learning and immersion experiences that work in concert with more traditional educational delivery systems. These hybrid programs challenge the compartmentalized “university approach” as the only, or best, approach to formal theological education.

4. Are “best practices stupid”?

So suggests the misleading (but marketable) title of business innovation consultant Steve Shapiro’s 2011 book. Shapiro reminds us that “best practice” models are beneficial for some goals, but tend to work against innovation. Given the fact that most pedagogical studies in theological education (including this one) tend to favor “best practices” approaches, caution is merited. Many of Shapiro’s forty principles of innovation are useful for theological educators, but here are three that help us work within the limits of “best practices” approaches while working toward innovation in theological education:

1. Asking for ideas is a bad idea. In the era of crowdsourcing, asking for ideas is an excellent way to harvest the collective intelligence of the masses. The problem for innovation is simply that “the masses” tend to be very, very conventional. Despite our dissatisfaction with current conditions, most of us will still opt to perpetuate the familiar, with minor alterations, rather than leap into an entirely new paradigm. In short, Shapiro reminds us, if we need lots of ideas — and buy-­in from lots of different people — then seeking input from multiple sectors is a good strategy. However, if we need new ideas, then innovation research is astonishingly consistent: seek the input of outliers (say, for instance, teenagers.)

2. Best practices help solve identical problems. Shapiro’s advice here is straightforward: if you have a problem to solve that everyone else has to solve, too, in reasonably similar contexts, then best practices are the way to go. This is why collecting data on vocational pedagogy is beneficial; most formal systems of theological formation, from summer camps to divinity schools, struggle with similar issues: decreased enrollment, reduced donor bases, and insufficient numbers of young leaders to reverse the aging trends of most North American congregations. To the extent that North American churches still reflect middle class values if not a middle class demographic, best practices may well help us. On the other hand, if a problem emerges that is specific to a particular context, leadership style, or needs of a community — or if our hope is to address a new context or demographic — then our best hope lies in innovation, not in best practices.

3. Simplification is the best innovation. One of the most consistently successful forms of innovation is simplification. Think about Apple’s design strategy, or the hundreds of “life-­hacking” websites that show easier and more efficient ways to make a grilled cheese or invent new uses for Ikea furniture. In a complicated world, the most influential innovation may involve taking away a variable rather than adding a new one.

Sometimes the “best practice” in theological formation, the one that yields a sense of peace and improves our sightlines to Jesus, is the practice of moving things out of the way — what Christian mystics called purgation. Purgative practices were considered the first steps toward one’s true vocation, union with God. Given the “busyness bubble” that has captured North American culture — the saturation point for the number of activities, opportunities, and responsibilities we can take on, or that young people can — practices of purgation are enjoying a small renaissance. As I write this, for example, Marie Kondo’s book The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up: The Japanese Art of Decluttering and Organizing has spent fifty-four weeks on the New York Times best-sellers list. “Mindfulness” is in the news; Time calls mindfulness a “revolution,” the Huffington Post heralded 2014 as a “year of mindful living,” and marketers have identified “mindfulness” as one of the ten trends shaping the world. Young people are among those ardently pursuing less. Interest in life/work balance, intentional food practices, economic and ecological sustainability, and other “slowing” practices run high among millennials, many of whom watched the busyness bubble bury their parents, usually metaphorically (sadly, not always).

Churches, denominations, and theological schools — captured in the busyness bubble like everyone else — are having mindfulness revolutions of their own. Renewed interest in spiritual practices like walking the labyrinth, silent retreats, and Sabbath-­keeping, as well as a renaissance in simple living, sustainability, and local sourcing among young adults, all point to purgative practices that contribute to young people’s vocational decisions. The teenagers in our interviews were reliably fascinated, and inspired, by practices like Sabbath-­keeping, silence, and fasting and by those who undertook them.

Often, churches’ first reaction to secular social trends is to create parallel ministries that capture these innovations in ways that are more explicitly Christian. Yet true innovation may involve a simpler — and likely more gracious — approach. An emergent skill of Christian leadership seems to be the ability to forge community partnerships, allowing churches to come alongside secular organizations to work for “the common good,” together. In this scenario, churches act as supportive partners, making no apology for our faith while recognizing that God’s work in the world is not limited to activities we call “ministry.” Christians would be hard pressed not to see the Holy Spirit at work in secular efforts like Café Momentum in Dallas, founded by a young chef who sold his four-­star restaurant to teach teenagers coming out of prison how to cook; or in the P.R.E.P. program (“Patience, Responsibility, Empathy, and Partnership”) that teaches compassion and responsibility to incarcerated teenagers by hiring them to train shelter dogs. Watsi was founded by a Peace Corps volunteer to crowdsource medical funding for people in developing countries; New Jersey teenager Maggie Doyne, hiking through the Himalayas on a gap year in 2006, came home and invested $5000 of her babysitting money to work with local Nepalese to build the Kopila Valley Children’s Home and School, where Maggie and her staff now teach and care for more than 300 children. These social innovations are not ministries, yet Christians would see in their work evidence of God’s grace afoot in the world — making the church’s support an important gesture of hospitality.

A Glimpse of the Future of Youth Ministry —

and Theological Education

Despite the mystery surrounding the kind of workforce the next generation church requires, and the kind of theological preparation that workforce will need, perhaps we can assume some basics as we imagine vocational formation for next generation Christian leaders:

  • De-­professionalization. Professional models of church leadership that dominated North American church life throughout the twentieth century are increasingly unsustainable, nor do they capture the radical nature of discipleship. As a result, young people seeking organic forms of community tend to gravitate toward a more seamless integration of church and mission. This integration gives fresh energy to new church starts, tentmaking ministries, nonprofit work, and hybrid ministries that serve congregations and communities simultaneously, often through mutually beneficial entrepreneurial enterprises.
  • Early stage theological education. Deep vocational formation — including formation in the Christian story itself — must remain the primary task of theological education, but this task need not be limited to seminary education. Intentional programs of vocational discernment, including confirmation programs, church camps, service corps, and programs like HSTPs can form a constellation of experiences that expand vocational formation to include early adolescence through early adulthood. These programs will have maximal impact when they offer young people tools for intellectual theological reflection while simultaneously immersing them in a community trying to imitate Christ in real time.
  • Expanded leadership skills. As we have suggested, theological education must include new leadership skills, since next generation church leaders will move more fluidly between established Christian institutions and spontaneous communities that emerge around common needs. In the futture, Christian life will be less associated with “church activities” than with communitties of human flourishing. As a result, Christian leaders’ toolkits will increasingly need skills such as:
    • Community development. Churches — lacking substantial denominational support enjoyed by twentieth century churches — will increasingly partner with other community organizations with sympathetic missions to mobilize community change.
    • Missional entrepreneurship. Since traditional funding models are no longer sufficient to support most churches, mission will become more local, more entrepreneurial, and more integrated into the economic lives of both global and immediate neighbors.
    • Hacking. The ability to devise practical shortcuts through existing structures that make them more useful will be prized as next generation church leaders hack their way through a thicket of habits and bureaucracies that no longer speak to the North American church’s cultural location.
  • Missional communities. As youth ministry moves away from youth fellowship models, young people longing for community are finding it in missional communities. Among the important changes this signals is a movement away from creating ministries for young people to participate in, toward supporting young people in ministries that they themselves create — a significant step toward the vocational formation of spiritually motivated teenagers.
  • Life-­long vocational discernment. Vocational discernment is increasingly a life-­cycle concern, not just an age-­level concern, especially in the first third of life. As churches learn to recognize and leverage certain “critical periods” for vocational discernment (especially late adolescence/early adulthood), ministry and work apprenticeships will become more common as forms of ministry with young people.
  • Early leadership experience. Early leadership experience begets adult leadership. Young people who are participants — not spectators — in Christian leadership, and who have received primary experiences of service, witness, and stewardship (accompanied by theological reflection on these experiences) are the most likely to emerge as Christian leaders.
  • Building ecologies of discernment. Ecologies of vocational discernment attend to two layers of practices:
    • “Baseline” vocational practices that cultivate safe space for vocational exploration, such as creating intentional Christian communities, developing networks of mentors, seizing “naming and commissioning” opportunities, and making space for young people who want to use those newly developed leadership skills in the context of their “back home” faith communities.
    • Exploratory practices that frame vocational discernment as an adolescent adventure, especially by creating and leveraging experiences of liminality, competence, deep belonging, and holy struggle. Pedagogies that decenter teenagers and/or give them practice in theological reflection, worship, pilgrimage, service, leadership, and the arts seem especially evocative for vocational exploration.
  • None of these paths to vocational discernment will happen by accident, of course. High School Theology Programs offer one hedge against ecclesial uncertainty by intentionally encouraging youth to experiment with the theological tools of Christian tradition as they hammer out forms of discipleship that authentically represent Christ to their generation. HSTPs encourage youth to imagine what bearing witness to Christ in the twenty-­first century requires, and they give youth a social laboratory in which to test out this witness.

    While the Lilly Endowment’s original vision for HSTPs was to create feeder systems — farm teams, if you will — for future clergy and church workers (by any measure, HSTPs have succeeded admirably in this regard), it is clear that these programs’ alumni are also participating in a significant ecclesial shift. While HSTP participants pursue vocations of church leadership in disproportionate numbers, they also universally view other kinds of work as discipleship as well, blurring the lines between sacred and secular callings, complexifying what constitutes “ministry” in the first place. In their hands, church leadership will undoubtedly be the task of teachers, doctors, nonprofit leaders, stay-­at-­home parents, entrepreneurs, and engineers, as well as professional church workers — who may or may not find their pastoral niches in the established roles of the church. As theological educators lament the murky future of a changing church, High School Theology Programs view this ambiguity as an opportunity. As teenagers reinterpret Christian witness for their moment in history, they reinterpret the church itself.

    Mystagogical Farm Teams

    High School Theology Program directors insist that the pedagogical strategies they employ are neither new nor unique; they are merely faithful ways of helping teenagers recognize, discern, and enact their callings as Christian disciples. Using what he calls a “mystagogical” approach to teaching that “respects the experience of the person we’re speaking to,” St. Meinrad’s program director Godfrey Mullen insists that diving into teenagers’ experience head-­first with them is a profoundly incarnational move — and that in fact, this kind of formation has created what amounts to farm teams of Christian leadership for centuries. Describing his teaching method as “fourth century mystagogical preaching,” Mullen says:

    You can’t speak the language that youth don’t understand and expect them to understand what you’re saying. . . . Mystagogical preaching [says]: experience Scripture and some new demand on my life. People are like, “That is a brilliant way to teach!” It is, and that’s why it’s endured for 1600 years. It’s not because I dreamt it up one day.

    Mullens is referring to the early catechumenate’s practice of offering intentional instruction to newly baptized Christians. In the early church, this instruction explored the “mysteries” of faith (i.e., sacraments) that these new Christians had already experienced, but did not yet deeply understand. The order mattered: the experience of God’s mystery preceded human instruction about that mystery.

    High School Theology Programs approach theological formation similarly, holding up the adolescent’s prior experience of God’s call as a mystery of faith that should be explored more fully. Like farm team players in baseball, most young people in HSTPs already long for a way to participate in the church leadership game, and they long to be with others who share their passion for the spiritual life. They are hungry for coaches and guidance. But they are still rookie players — neophytes, in the catechetical language — baptized into faith without fully recognizing what God is up to in their lives. High School Theology Programs set out to explore this mystery in ways reminiscent of the early church, bringing together new disciples to understand the litourgia — the “work of the people” — as they participate in this work themselves.

    By focusing on teenagers’ informed participation in the practices of Christian community — and by giving them a team to practice with, rather than merely instructing them about these practices — young people begin to exercise agency as people of faith. Teenagers recognize that their theological agency is intensified by their experiences in High School Theology Programs. Many students we talked to openly wondered what it would be like to go back to “real life” in their churches and schools, now that they had tasted theological reflection with equally interested others, and now that they thought of themselves as potential leaders in the Christian community. They wondered whether the church as they know it has room for them, or whether God might best use their leadership elsewhere.

    We will see.

    . Cf. “1942: Home Grown Champions,” This Great Game (2014), http://www.thisgreatgame.com/1942-­baseball-­history.html (accessed August 8, 2014).

    . Wayne Meisel, “Where Faith Still Thrives: Summer Camps and the Future of the Church,” The Huffington Post (May 23, 2014), http://www.huffingtonpost.com/wayne-­meisel/where-­faith-­still-­thrives_b_5379846.html (accessed August 9, 2014).

    . PCUSA Camps and Conference Ministries, “Spiritual Growth Experiences and Church Retreats,” The Presbyterian Panel (May 2012), http://www.pcusa.org/site_media/media/uploads/research/pdfs/may_2012_panel_report_camps_and_conference_centers,pdf.pdf (accessed August 9, 2014).

    . Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate, “Special Report: Nurturing Vocations to Religious Life and Priesthood: The Impact of a Volunteer Service Year,” Spring 2014 (Washington, DC: Georgetown University), p. 6, http://cara.georgetown.edu/Publications/NurturingVocations.pdf (accessed August 9, 2014). It should be noted that the Catholic use of the term “vocation” to mean specifically ordained or lay ecclesial service is more restrictive than the definition used by HSTPs.

    . The effect continues after the service year. Controlling for gender in Catholic volunteer alumni, 7% of women have “very seriously” considered a religious vocation, compared to 2% of never married Catholic women in general. Among men, 19% of alumni have “very seriously” considered a religious vocation, compared to 3% of never married Catholic men. See Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate, “Special Report.” Protestants report similar effects, though research connecting volunteer service and vocation in these programs is scarce. One exception is Life Together, an Episcopalian intentional community network in Boston, serving young people in the Episcopal Service Corps; the Rev. Arrington Chambliss, Executive Director. See http://www.lifetogethercommunity.org/contact-­us (accessed July 31, 2012).

    . By 2020, whites in the Unted States will be the statistical minority; in 2012, the U.S. Census showed more non-­whites were born in the United States than whites. In March 2014, Gallup estimated 54% of Americans between the ages of 18-29 were non-­Hispanic white, compared to 71% in 1995, the first year Gallup measured Hispanic ethnicity. See Jeffrey Jones, “Young Americans’ Affinity for Democratic Party Has Grown,” Gallup Politics (March 28, 2014), http://www.gallup.com/poll/168125/young-­americans-­affinity-­democratic-­party-­grown.aspx (accessed August 21, 2014). On culturally responsive teaching, see Anthony Kudjo Donkor, “Higher Education and Culturally Responsive Teaching: A Way Forward,” Journal of Multiculturalism in Education 7 (December 2011), http://www.wtamu.edu/webres/File/Journals/MCJ/Volume%207-1/Anthony%20K%20Donkor.pdf (accessed August 21, 2014). The vocational pedagogies described in this book readily align with the relational, experiential, and embodied teaching methods associated with culturally-­responsive educational practices.

    . See Christian Smith with Melinda Lundquist Denton, Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), and Christian Smith with Patricia Snell, Souls in Transition: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of Emerging Adults (New York: Oxford University Press, 2009).

    . Patricia Snell, “What Difference Does Youth Group Make? A Longitudinal Analysis of Religious Youth Group Participation and Religious Life Outcomes,” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 48, no. 3 (2009): 572-87.

    . See Thomas Bergler, The Juvenilization of American Christianity (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2012). My critique of this thesis may be found in K. C. Dean, “Pointing the Finger in the Wrong Direction: Thomas Bergler’s The Juvenilization of American Christianity,” Theology Today 70 (April 2013): 79-81; and, in more detail, in K. C. Dean, “Beyond Truthiness: How the ‘Juvenilization Thesis’ in Youth Ministry Is Both Wrong and Right,” Immerse (Fall 2012): 11-16.

    . Cf. Sara Little, Our Church — A Fellowship (New York: Friendship Press, 1951) and, almost fifty years later, her 1998 lecture at Princeton Theological Seminary, “Youth Ministry: Historical Reflections Near the End of the Twentieth Century” (Princeton, NJ: Princeton Lectures on Youth, Church and Culture, 1998), http://www2.ptsem.edu/uploadedFiles/IYM/YCCL/Little-­Youth.pdf (accessed July 23, 2014).

    . Patricia Hersch, A Tribe Apart (New York: Ballantine Books, 1999).

    . The “wholesome” activities that overwhelm middle class youth continue to more or less bypass other teenagers, rich and poor alike. Wealthy teenagers do not need the social networks made possible by involvement in such activities, and poor teenagers cannot afford to miss work to belong to them — or lack other assets (transportation, parent approval, freedom from responsibility) that make extracurricular participation possible.

    . L. Gregory Jones, “Learning Curve,” The Christian Century (May 18, 2010), http://www.christiancentury.org/article/2010-05/learning-­curve (accessed August 22, 2014).

    . L. Gregory Jones, “Pastors by Degree: Evolution of a Vocation,” The Christian Century (December 15, 2009), http://www.christiancentury.org/article/2009-12/pastors-­degree (accessed August 22, 2014).

    . Quote is from Barbara Wheeler’s “Pathways to Seminary” address at a Lilly Endowment meeting for High School Theology Program directors and senior executives at program schools (Barbara G. Wheeler, “Pathways to Seminary: Where the Best Students Come From,” speech, January 22, 2014). The address summarized findings of the Auburn Theological Seminary research reported by Barbara G. Wheeler, “On Our Way: A Study of Students’ Paths to Seminary,” unpublished report of survey data submitted to the Lilly Endowment (August 2013), http://www.auburnseminary.org/religion-­and-­research (accessed August 24, 2014).

    . Gene Weingarten, “Pearls before Breakfast,” The Washington Post (April 8, 2007), http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-­dyn/content/article/2007/04/04/AR2007040401721.html (accessed August 24, 2014).

    . Cf. Kyung Hee Kim, “The Creativity Crisis: The Decrease in Creative Thinking Scores on the Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking,” Creativity Research Journal 23 (2011): 285-95. Sir Ken Robinson’s 2006 TED talk, “How Schools Kill Creativity” (the most-­viewed TED talk of all time), develops this thesis in detail. See http://www.ted.com/talks/ken_robinson_says_schools_kill_creativity (accessed August 24, 2014).

    . Robert Coles, The Spiritual Life of Children (New York: Mariner, 1991), pp. xiii, xvii.

    . Wheeler, “On Our Way”: 7.

    . For instance, Chris Hughes’ confirmation program, the Foundation for Christian Formation (http://www.fcfconfirm.net), and in more detail, Chris Hughes, Consecration 3x3 - A Disciple Making Sequence: Profession of Faith, Confirmation, and Commissioning: Testing Our Assumptions and Improving Our Process of Adolescent Disciple Making (Pneumanaut Publishing, 2012).

    . Wheeler, “Pathways to Seminary,” p. 3.

    . Stephen M. Shapiro, Best Practices Are Stupid: 40 Ways to Out-­Innovate the Competition (London: Portfolio, 2011).

    . Larry Keeley et al., Ten Types of Innovation: The Discipline of Building Breakthroughs (Hoboken, NJ: Wiley, 2013).

    . Greg Mckeown, “Why We Humblebrag about Being Busy,” Harvard Business Review Magazine (June 2014), http://blogs.hbr.org/2014/06/why-­we-­humblebrag-­about-­being-­busy/ (accessed August 29, 2014); Marie Kondo, The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up: The Japanese Art of Decluttering and Organizing (Emeryville, CA: Ten Speed, 2014).

    . “10 Trends That Will Shape the World in 2014 and Beyond,” JWT Worldwide (December 4, 2013), http://www.jwt.com/blog/consumer_insights/10-­trends-­that-­will-­shape-­our-­world-­in-2014-­and-­beyond/ (accessed August 26, 2014). The Huffington Post also predicted 2014 as “the year of mindful living.” See Carolyn Gregoire, “Why 2014 Will Be the Year of Mindful Living,” The Huffington Post (January 2, 2014), http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/01/02/will-2014-­be-­the-­year-­of-_0_n_4523975.html (accessed August 26, 2014). Time referred to “mindfulness” as a “revolution”; see Kate Pickert, “The Mindful Revolution,” Time (January 23, 2014), http://time.com/1556/the-­mindful-­revolution/ (accessed August 26, 2014).

    . See cafemomentum.org; https://watsi.org/; Christina Rosales, “Dallas County Juvenile Offender Program Teaches Leadership, Commitment with Shelter Dog Training,” Dallas Morning News (August 6, 2011), http://www.dallasnews.com/news/community-­news/dallas/headlines/20110806-­dallas-­county-­juvenile-­offender-­program-­teaches-­leadership-­commitment-­with-­shelter-­dog-­training.ece; Maggie Doyne, “Why the Human Family Can Do Better,” Do Lectures 2010, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-­Xv9h5nBls (accessed August 27, 2014).

    . It should be noted that catechesis was accomplished through preaching in the early church; preaching in this sense is a form of pedagogy. See Craig Alan Satterlee, Ambrose of Milan’s Method of Mystagogical Preaching (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical, 2002), p. 1.

    . In the latter stages of catechetical instruction, participating in the shared life of the Christian community was believed to have catechetical power. Cf. Satterlee, Ambrose of Milan, p. 6.

    . We could say that High School Theology Programs are to local church youth programs what studying in France is to high school French class. French class introduces a subject, and teaches its necessary grammar and rudimentary structures — scaffolding that allows limited access to a culture that would otherwise remain out of reach. But actually going to France gives the French language life and force; experiencing French culture firsthand makes speaking French personally and contextually relevant. Speaking French daily, like exercising a muscle, makes it stronger, more flexible, and more useful. Attending an HSTP, like going to France, builds upon local congregations’ catechetical instruction by translating technical understandings of Christ’s call into a robust and personal claim on teenagers’ lives. Thanks to researcher Katie Douglass for making this connection.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑