Chapter 10 of 25

Anabel Proffitt and Jacquie Church Young

Anabel Proffitt and Jacquie Church Young

Anabel Proffitt and Jacquie Church Young

Grace arrived at a summer leadership academy not sure what to expect. Though she came to us with wounds from her past, she had gifts in abundance. She also seemed torn between the desire to fit in and be accepted by her surrounding culture — a culture that is often individualistic, materialistic, and narcissistic — and her growing recognition that she was a unique individual whose very giftedness set her apart. She quickly found that our community celebrated her gifts. Early in our time together, Grace surprised herself and the entire group by volunteering to preach a sermon. In it, she testified about what it means to feel renewed by God’s grace, and she boldly addressed some of the issues and challenges facing young people today, including cutting, depression, and chronic anxiety. Listen to her honest, insightful words:

I have spent enough hours in silence and meditation to know my relationship with God very well, and it has changed over time. Dare I say, through my hard struggles with anxiety and depression, through my past with self-­harm and toxic friendships, and through each moment of pain, it has been renewed? It seems like a radical idea that all of that was part of my renewal — to me at least. Renewal is about resting and recharging, right? It is, but it’s more than that. Jesus says that he will give rest to the weary and heavy-­laden, but he doesn’t mention what it takes to get those weary followers to him. He doesn’t have to because it doesn’t matter. He doesn’t care what kind of burden and suffering has brought you to him, since what matters is that you’re there. All the hurt that breaks you down and brings you to your knees leaves you in a great place to start praying. Renewal is the gentle hand that picks you up at your lowest and pours the Holy Spirit into you, filling you with God’s grace and making you new in the best of ways. That is a definition I can stand by.

Grace’s powerful words struck a chord with her peers. After she preached, students stood in line to talk to her about her story and to share in her pain and joy, and then to share their own stories with her. They spent the evening conversing about grace and renewal in Christ, and about the trust and courage required to share our faith and stories. Together, they wondered how they might do this back in their own churches and schools.

What kind of community opens up space for a young person to speak with this level of honesty about her own suffering and the role of faith in transforming it? What kind of community allows other youth to receive and connect to such a story? How do we nurture young people’s gifts, help them interpret their experience in the context of the Christian story of God’s radical grace in Jesus Christ, and encourage them to testify to that experience?

The High School Theology Programs have taught us that effective formation of young Christian leaders immerses them experientially within the story and vision of the Christian community. In our experience, it takes an “incarnational” community to nurture the gifts of young people like Grace and to help them to share their unique gifts with the world — a community that invites young people to live within and powerfully enact the vision and story of Christian faith. In many ways, community in the HSTPs operates less as a pedagogy than as a learning “accelerator,” providing the nourishing matrix in which every other Christian practice becomes meaningful, and therefore formative and revelatory, as young people come to recognize these practices as means of grace that open them to one another and to Christ. In this chapter, we assert that Christian community can serve as a catalyst — perhaps even a catechist — for faith formation by incarnating the gospel in the lives of young people.

It is not enough to simply teach about Christian community, because Christian community must be lived out experientially. It must be incarnated. In order to do this, a community must: (1) root itself in the theological claim that community is a reality created by God in Christ, (2) view truth and learning in incarnational, relational terms, (3) engage in ritual practices that live out community as a gift of God, and (4) commit to collegial forms of learning and develop mechanisms for nurturing leaders who have arisen from the community, who can embody all of these practices for the next group of participants.

Be Who You Already Are in Christ:

Christian Community as Created by God

One of the challenges to authentic sharing in Christian community is the consumer-­capitalist view of life, an upward climb toward power and economic attainment. Our progress in this way of life is marked by ever-­increasing adherence to a normative (and expensive) lifestyle. To make progress, we learn to choose the right clothes, drink the right energy drink, drive the right car, impress the right people, attract the right mate (or playmate), and create envy among our peers. Informed by a democratic spirit, this vision claims that anyone can get ahead, but at the same time it creates a society in which some get ahead, while others are left behind to serve the more successful. Even those who do get ahead are never allowed to feel that they have arrived. Nothing is ever enough. Unable to achieve the airbrushed perfection we have come to identify with the happy life, we cannot allow ourselves to admit failings, depend openly on others, or rest.

The schools our young people attend are set up on similar models of success. Students — at least those in contexts stable enough to look ahead — are encouraged to study hard, ace the tests, and get ahead in order to attend the selective college of their choice. In more affluent communities, young people’s schedules are packed with activities — many of which cost a great deal of money — that will look good on their college applications, though they often miss time with families as a result. Individual young people who do not fit the desired mold because of their look, learning style, gender identity, or lack of financial and personal resources are left behind, while whole communities of youth in poor neighborhoods may despair when they realize that the touted lifestyle is forever evading their grasp.

Underlying this cultural ethos, educator William Myers wrote, is a view of community as a pyramid, one that requires a ladder of success. In his book Theological Themes of Youth Ministry, Myers noted that Christian community offers a more excellent way: community as a circle. The parameters of the community we create, said Myers, should be determined by the vision of the circle of koinonia, rather than the pyramid of success. In this circle, everyone has a place at the table that Christ has set, and we discover that we are implicated in each other’s lives. The circle model honors the practice of hearing one another into speech, rather than seeking to get ahead through competition and one-­upmanship. It is a circle of hospitality.

Such hospitality, theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer once wrote, does not arise out of our own efforts, but out of God’s gracious action in Jesus Christ. In Life Together, Bonhoeffer explains that Christian community is not an ideal that we must work to realize. Rather, it is a reality created by God in Christ in which we may participate. Because community is a reality already created by Christ, we do not need to be ideal people before we can be in community, nor are we permitted to demand that others fit our ideal — or that which our culture labels as ideal — before we enter into relationship with them. Rather, in Christian community, we set others free to be what they are in Christ, and we honor “the true image they bear as Christ’s own.” In Christian community, our relationships are not about gaining control or demanding achievement: “Because Christ has long since acted decisively for my brother (sic) before I could begin to act, I must leave him his freedom to be Christ’s; I must meet him only as the person that he already is in Christ’s eyes.”

The encounter with a Christian community that lived out this conviction set Grace free to share her deep and tender testimony with her peers. Her experience of being met as the person that she already was in Christ’s eyes gave her the courage to speak her truth for the first time to others. While her home faith community had taught her the concept that Christ had acted for her, Grace experienced this truth incarnated in her youth theology program. She was then able to extend God’s grace to her peers, meeting them also only as the people that they already were in Christ’s eyes. This is the sort of relationship that springs from real, lived, incarnational community.

All of the High School Theology Programs testify to the power of community to transform lives. Recognizing that young people’s lives “are ruled and ordered by ‘law,’ ” in the words of one program director, many youth name their experience in these programs as their first real experience of grace and mercy, how the HSTP community lives (in community), works (in accountability), and plays (in radical inclusion and affirmation). In all learning environments characterized by relationships of forgiveness and acceptance, students thrive in both the discovery of their own deeper selves, and their relationship to God. One youth commented, “I found a place where I was heard, where I was seen, and where all my kooky weird stuff was not only accepted, but welcomed, encouraged and loved.” Another young person commented, “The best feeling I can think of is that this is a place that has no shame and you don’t have to be ashamed to say anything,” while yet another confessed, “I feel like [the leaders] create a safe environment for us, and that we can open our minds up to anything and they are not going to laugh at something.” These testimonies are clear. Christian tradition is not a set of dead doctrines, but rather the taproot of incarnational, grace-­saturated communities of authenticity. Teenagers need such communities in order to bloom into who they already are in Christ, and it is urgent that we make space for such communities to grow.

Living the Truth Together:

Christian Community and Relational Truth

Approaching Christian community as a circle allows room for significant, holistic pedagogies to develop. Hearkening back to the Reformation catechisms, Protestants tend to think of catechesis as a cognitive exercise, as learners are asked to understand, accept, or memorize a body of knowledge that a group of churches have labeled the truth about God or the world. While the High School Theology Programs — as every chapter in this book attests — encourage deep intellectual engagement of theology as a “non-­negotiable” component in adolescent faith formation, identifying intellectual knowledge too closely with “truth” misses a central implication of the incarnation: namely, that the truth of God is a person with whom we have relationship (John 14:6). In To Know as We Are Known, educator Parker Palmer writes, “In Christian tradition, truth is not a concept that works, but an incarnation that lives.” This theological conviction about living truth, Palmer notes, has implications for our view of reality in general: “Truth is not a statement about reality [out there] but a living relationship between ourselves and the world.” Even more radically, he claims, “Truth is between us.” In other words, for Christians, relationality is at the heart of the search for truth. We cannot exempt ourselves from implication in one another’s lives. In the words of Archbishop Desmond Tutu, we live in the reality of ubuntu: “My humanity is caught up, is inextricably bound up, in yours.” I am, because you are. To live in this reality is to live in truth.

If truth is at its core relational, then the search for truth must take place within relationships in which young people come to see the world through others’ eyes, and support each other’s expanding horizons. In an incarnational community, learners become accountable for one another’s learning. Palmer expresses such accountability in terms of obedience. Obedience, he elaborates, “does not mean slavish, mechanical adherence to whatever one hears; it means making a personal response that acknowledges that one is in troth with the speaker and with the words he or she speaks.” Palmer develops this image in terms of betrothal — in Old English, the act of pledging one’s troth (faithfulness or truth) to another: “To know in truth is to become betrothed, to engage the known with one’s whole self, an engagement one enters with attentiveness, care and goodwill.”

This kind of “betrothed” learning requires young people to submit to others’ needs, but it also returns them to themselves with greater insight. As one male student noted, “You’ve got to stop thinking of self, and you’ve got to start thinking of others, and I feel as if now I’ve become more aware of others, and that’s actually helped me to become more aware of myself.” This young man went on to say how participating in an HSTP helped him appreciate the importance of accountability as a sign of “the beloved community.”

Accountability in the Christian life can be quite demanding of youth who want to fit in and enjoy peaceful relationships. As one teenager remembered about his HSTP experience: “The hardest part was holding each other accountable. The moment someone saw one person not doing what they were supposed to do, we didn’t want to go tell the mentors what they were doing.” Fear of being a “snitch” made it difficult to confront behavior that was counterproductive to their community. Yet one of the important lessons many youth learn is that healthy conflict or honest confrontation can nurture life-­giving community. As this young man learned, holding each other accountable to the norms they had established together strengthened individuals and the whole community.

“Betrothed” and pledged to one another in this way, teenagers in HSTPs openly aim to live incarnationally. As they do so, the programs become spaces where young people speak honestly about their suffering and their faith, and respond to one another in kind. Unlike communities in which truth is viewed only as a body of knowledge that youth must master or consume — where teenagers’ understanding of themselves and their world is of secondary importance to intellectual apprehension — the embodied truth of incarnational communities offer youth a view of reality as integrated whole, demanding their participation and not merely their assent. In the absence of such mutual, accountable relationships, learners are less likely to drop their self-­protective armor and share their inmost thoughts and feelings, and they are less inclined to listen attentively to the struggles of others. When learning is embedded in a relational matrix of faithful accountability to the image of Christ, the community itself becomes a catechist, opening youth to learning experiences that reveal Christ’s grace and mercy and that catalyze deep searching, honest sharing, and personal transformation. Immersed in a community of betrothal, teenagers “try out” the person God has already made them to be.

Catalytic Structures: Ritual Practices

that Live Out Community as a Gift of God

Christian community does not happen in the abstract. It is always made up of concrete relationships, particular contexts, and specific practices that enact grace and mercy in our life together, including worship, prayer, confession, communion, work, study, and play. In contrast to youth groups or church education programs where young people interact with peers and adults for an hour or two at a time, the HSTPs have the advantage of sustained collegial contact. Living together for a prolonged period or maintaining contact with one another throughout the year alongside mentors and congregation members creates the possibility for more three-­dimensional relationships, as youth have time to become “real” with one another without defaulting to the social roles they are accustomed to playing in school or church.

High School Theology Programs take full advantage of this sustained contact. They employ a number of “catalytic structures” that pave the way for transformation by embedding these practices in significant relationships of vulnerability, challenge, and care. Among the countless ways HSTPs intentionally form such relationships among teenagers, three catalytic structures are prominent in every program: small covenant groups, collegial learning cohorts, and peer and adult mentoring.

Covenant Groups: Going Deep Together

One of the concrete practices many of these programs share is the formation of covenant groups — small groups bound by formal or informal, mutually agreed upon practices of faithfulness and care. In such groups, young people have opportunities to engage in deep conversations and to get to know a few people well.

Covenant groups are critical to the building of community. In several HSTPs, each time covenant groups gather, youth spend time talking about their experiences of the day, debriefing concerns, and telling stories of their lives. Some programs choose to focus these covenant group times around a single question per meeting — what one program refers to as “candle questions.” After the initial business of the gathering, a group leader lights a candle and asks a question based on the group’s experiences that day, explaining that the lighting of the candle both welcomes Christ into their midst, establishes the setting as sacred ground, and casts teenagers’ perception of their conversation as sacred speech. As the program director notes, “Each voice is held as equally important in the covenant group, and we make it clear that we value their thoughts and ideas.” After everyone has had a chance to answer the candle question, the group time ends with prayer.

The questions these groups discuss are intentionally wide-­ranging, designed to elicit self-­discovery and vocational curiosity, as well as to allow space for the basic conversations that accompany community life. Typical conversations might range from gifts that youth bring to their community, the ways Christ’s presence has been discerned during the day, questions about theodicy or how youth are called to respond to the needs of others — as well as “How do I put up with my roommate?” and “How do I worship with people who believe such vastly different things?” All covenant groups work to preserve high levels of trust among participants, and a certain openness to the direction of conversation. While probe questions are often determined beforehand, the discussions they generate are not. There is no canned curriculum handed down from a denominational office or independent publisher. Instead, questions emerge from the life of the group as young people respond to the day by exploring hopes and dreams, questions about faith and God’s action in the world, and vexing problems about the human condition that have surfaced through program activities.

Conversation practices that create safe space for vulnerability, and that give youth a sense of God’s presence in relationships, have a “legitimizing effect” on other aspects of the program curriculum. One young person explained it this way:

Once you feel more comfortable with yourself, you become more comfortable with others and you can interact more truly and more maturely. I’ve had these thoughts before, but I realize them on a much deeper and higher level than before because I’m like legit living in intentional community, and I’ve never really [had] this kind of experience.

Another teenager noted that her covenant group helped her to “build up relationships, develop trust, and look for Christ in each other.” The trust engendered by covenant groups spills over into other forms of learning by setting a collegial tone that invites learners to risk their ideas in the educational arena. As one youth explained, building relationships in covenant group gives teenagers the confidence to “bounce ideas off each other in a bigger discussion.” Smiling, she added: “We’re all lame and we all just kind of [act] lame together, so it’s okay to be weird.”

Collegial Learning Practices: I Respect You

Christian communities that take their cues from a theology of the incarnation value how Christ is already at work in each learner. Because we are a circle and not a pyramid, and because we trust that truth emerges between us, a spirit of respect and collegiality is paramount. This spirit begins in taking young people’s capacities seriously; they are not offered a “theology lite” curriculum, but are asked to wrestle with material used in college and master’s level classrooms and are taught by professors and experts in their fields. Further, adults and youth are expected to show mutual respect for one another. In effect, everyone becomes a teacher and a learner, fellow travelers on the way to more faithful discipleship.

An incarnational theology of learning-­in-­community dovetails with what theorist Dwayne Huebner identifies as an “ethical value framework,” in which education is viewed as encounter between persons. Curriculum designed in the ethical value framework introduces students to subject matter not only as “bodies of principles, concepts, generalizations, and syntax to be learned,” but as “patterned forms of response-­in-­the-­world, which carry with them the possibilities of the emergence of novelty and newness.” Such an approach helps learners “find new ways to partake of the world, and [they] become more aware of what [they] can become and what [human beings] can become.” This, in turn, “increases their response-­ability in the world and thus aids in the creation and re-­creation of the world.” But, Huebner notes, such an effect only occurs when educators themselves recognize that they “participate in a human situation of mutual influence,” and when they “accept their ability to promise and to forgive.”

In classrooms and facilitated learning activities, HSTPs encourage educators to self-­reflectively treat their students as co-­learners, a practice that teenagers soon adopt for themselves. Youth repeatedly comment with surprise and appreciation at being shown respect in these settings. Being asked their opinions, being treated with dignity, being appreciated for their intellectual and theological competence, being challenged to lead in various ways and not only to “receive” the benefits their program offers — all of this bolsters confidence, invites questions that might otherwise have been swallowed, and allows space for half-­formed ideas to be articulated on the way to deeper understanding. One youth commented, “They make us feel very welcomed. We can ask any questions that we want, because they’re willing to answer it in their way. And [it’s] not just that they’re willing to answer it. They want our opinion on it, too.” This student also appreciated the way adult teachers asked him clarifying questions and invited his own responses and opinions. Rather than shutting learners down, he appreciated teachers who responded with comments like, “Yeah, I understand where you’re coming from.”

One group interview conducted by our research team centered on teenagers’ appreciation for the respect adults showed them in their High School Theology Programs. One young woman reflected, “Sometimes when you’re in your teens, I feel like you’re in between the kid and the adult and you’re not really sure where you fit. Some people still treat you like a kid, but here we’re like full-­on adults. They bring that out of you, bring the adult out of you. They make you think.” Another participant agreed, grateful for the quality of instruction the HSTP offered: “Yeah. Cause you can only learn so much from your church and, like, here we actually have PhD students.” The first commentator nodded: “Not only for the fact of PhD students, but you learn from other people based on . . . other questions they’ll bring up in class, and even the PhD students will be like, ‘Wow.’ ”

The excitement evident in this exchange stems from the young person’s first taste of respect as a mature contributor in a theological community. A common theme in our interviews was young people’s amazement at being treated as fellow theologians, co-­journeyers with authority figures in an educational enclave. This respectful collegiality quickly informs youth’s interactions with one another as well, as they become peer mentors in various learning cohorts. In our program at Lancaster Theological Seminary, we have found that those with previous experience as students in the program serve as excellent, and essential, peer mentors — not only because they help create a collegial culture, but also because they help sustain the incarnational Christian community that serves as the foundation for every other learning activity.

Adults show respect for youth in order to honor them as individuals, but also in order to model a way of becoming a mutual, beloved community that reflects Jesus Christ. High School Theology Programs strive to include young people from diverse racial and ethnic backgrounds, social class, gender identities, theologies, and developmental stages. In some programs, this diversity is deliberately cultivated; in others, diversity is simply a by-­product of the cultural moment in which we live. Either way, difference always risks conflict, and often leads to divisions within a community.

Amidst such diversity, adopting collegial learning practices can be difficult, even for adult leaders. As Beth Corrie, director of the Youth Theology Initiative at Candler School of Theology (a program that approaches diversity quite intentionally), explains, the importance of adult mentors who model a reconciling and boundary-­crossing collegiality is crucial:

You know, [as a staff member], you have to keep reaching out to people that you don’t even agree with. You . . . can’t just keep plopping down next to the kids that you already get along with; you can’t keep plopping down with the staff people that you already know really well.

She adds: “We [adult mentors and teachers] have to be very intentional about constantly showing a different way of being. You’ve got to go sit down and eat with somebody that you know is going to be an awkward conversation, but you have to do it anyway.”

Peer Mentors: Let’s Walk Together

When an incarnational community comes into being, its culture begins to take on a life of its own. The community that is a circle, when it is healthy and vital, soon morphs into an expanding spiral, opening out into the world and renewing itself by drawing others in. Participants in the High School Theology Programs form communities in which their gifts are valued and their voices honored, and they then return to their churches and — if all goes well — they begin to help build up that type of community in the church. Some youth then come back to their programs-­of-­origin as peer mentors, or later as adult mentors, and they bring new friends with them. Grace, whose story began this chapter, learned to trust the community she experienced through the encouragement of peer mentors and adults who modeled a community of trust for her. As an adult mentor, she is now a model for others of how to live in a community of betrothal — a community whose truth is found in relationship with Christ and with one another. And so the story will repeat. The circle turns into an expanding spiral, in which the community teaches youth how to be community by being in community.

While this self-­renewing process can (and often does) occur through informal social influence, as Anne Wimberly points out in chapter 4, many HSTPs have formalized the process by recruiting and training peer mentors. The effort to train peer mentors developed out of the shared conviction that the best way to help churches and pastors empower young people for leadership is to give them substantive leadership roles and experience in their programs. As one director, whose program explicitly cultivates youth leadership for future program years, told our research team: “The benefit we didn’t know would come with this — and that has become the most important way that we establish our community — is that the young people experience youth leadership and safe community themselves during the academy.”

They come back as peer mentors, and they immediately begin to establish that type of living that they have valued. . . . They show and exhibit and model safe and intentional communities of theological diversity and questioning. So when the new students arrive at the academy, the peer mentors welcome them into this new, yet similar variant of our already existing community. [As a result], they gently nudge, teach and mostly model exactly what we hope the community will be.

Despite this self-­renewing effect, creating communities anew each year is still a challenge. Communities are living, breathing, evolving entities, and they must revisit and renegotiate community norms at each annual gathering. In fact, one sign that these programs serve as active expressions of incarnational community is their fluidity; even when new adult and peer mentors have imbibed the spirit of “safe and intentional community for theological diversity and questioning,” participants’ unique personalities and social locations create changes in how the community is constituted. As Bonhoeffer notes, relationships within the Christian community mean we must treat one another “only as the person that he [or she] already is in Christ’s eyes,” which calls for every person’s active participation in setting the community’s expectations. Honesty before God and one another is a precious gift that must be incarnated over and over again. When Grace returns to her church, and then again to her program as a peer mentor, her transformed life will be a gift to a new group of young persons, who will, in turn, offer others the good news that because “Christ has long since acted decisively for [us]” we are free to be who we are in Christ.

Committing to Collegial Education

for Christian Leadership Formation

For Christians, the truth of Christ is embodied in relationship, which means that Christian community grounds every other incarnational practice of the church. Indeed, divorced from this sort of community, pedagogies that seek to form Christian leaders are unintelligible. Grace’s story points to the transformative power of the caring community of mutual support and accountability youth experience in the High School Theology Programs. Christ’s mercy and grace, encountered through these relationships, had agency in forming Grace into someone capable of embodying mercy and grace for others.

The community-­centered, holistic pedagogies of HSTPs are suggestive for theological formation generally. In these programs, community is more than a “context” in which learning takes place; community is a learning space with pedagogical agency, which calls the whole self to engage ideas and practices for the sake of spiritual and vocational formation. As Bonhoeffer insisted, Christian community sets young people free to be who they are in Christ, and to experience what it means to bear their true image as Christ’s own. If next-­generation churches are actually to become life-­shaping, incarnational communities, then those who lead them must learn to engage a community’s life-­shaping, incarnational power.

The HSTPs testify to a community’s catechetical role in several ways. First, they remind us that the community we have is the one we must work with — it is already the gift given to us by God in Christ. It is tempting, for example, to imagine community as a by-­product of our work as theological educators, rather than as a living, incarnational space where Christ meets our students. We protest that our institutions do not contain the right people, or have to deal with all the wrong people. Yet if it is true that God places us in community and calls us to see Christ at work in the midst of that particular set of relationships, we cannot approach Christian community as an imposed “ideal,” accomplished by recruiting better members, exiling annoying ones, and shaping up the members we have, all of which undermines our own conviction that Christ is already present in our institutional communities. This does not mean that we should not work toward more faithful, more connected, more vital communities. But it does mean that the first step in acknowledging our communities’ formative potential is to help one another look for Christ’s presence in the midst of existing relationships, as we grow together into a beloved community.

Second, those of us who teach Christian leaders must have the courage and the freedom to employ holistic, relational pedagogies that allow our students (and ourselves) to experience — not just analyze — God’s truth in community. The Christ-­created koinonia has discursive, personal, and interpersonal expressions, and a primary experience of grace and mercy touches all of these. While acquiring intellectual knowledge about the church’s texts and traditions is necessary for church leaders, countless spiritual leaders, from Luther to Wesley to Mother Teresa, have attested to the fact that this knowledge is not transformative until it takes on an event quality. For many learners, that event — the experience of a God who “happens” — happens in the context of conversation and relationship.

Young people attending seminary after a High School Theology Program (or who have had similar experiences that successfully translate theological information into experience) will have high expectations for formative conversation in the theological classroom. They will be disappointed by faculty who sacrifice dialogue for “getting through the material,” and by institutions that confuse data transmission with teaching, or that adopt the wholly false assumption that integrative, communally based pedagogies employing conversation, imagination, personal engagement, and embodiment are substandard intellectual practices. The HSTPs confront this misunderstanding directly, and challenge it with scores of theologically nuanced program alumni.

Third, High School Theology Programs’ emphasis on intense community as a learning vehicle challenges those of us in theological education to reconsider the schooling model that structures most contemporary higher education. Echoing the industrial age that gave rise to so-­called schooling models of education, schools were designed for efficiency of production (presumably, of knowledge), not for community formation, relational integrity, or conformity to Christ. In the schooling model, community is a by-­product of the educational production process, not a formative educational element. Yet dividing learning communities into temporary units (think semester-­long courses, credit hours, etc.) can make community more difficult than, say, time-­intensive retreats or residential, short-­term courses that students share while living together. The HSTPs, unencumbered by an educational “mold” into which their curricula must fit, offer educators an extraordinary window into what theological formation might look like that utilizes some aspects of the schooling model, but is not constrained by it.

Finally, the community-­based learning models of the HSTPs call us to pay close attention to the motivation learners experience when their teachers show them respect and take their ideas seriously. As Katherine Douglass and Brent Strawn each point out in this book, even the subtler practices of the HSTPs — like intentionally addressing learners as “scholars” rather than as “students” — help the programs demonstrate the Christian community’s ability to decouple status from roles. While the roles participants play in these programs are clear (program director, adult staff, peer mentors, participants, and so on), persons in each role share identical status: they are children of God. Just as the early Christian community recognized that, in Christ, there was “neither Jew nor Greek” and accorded equal status to slave and free, the HSTPs employ practices that communicate status as God-­given, in equal measure, to every human being. By cultivating mutual respect between youth and adults, these programs demonstrate the enormous positive effect that mutual respect plays in human motivation. Creating supportive communities where learning is viewed as a relationship of mutual accountability, undertaken by partners on a shared journey — even when one partner is more familiar with the terrain than the other — turns out to be a highly effective way to motivate learning, as well as a way to encounter the truth of Christ.

The reason is simple. Community, that matrix of relationships of support and care in which we live exposed to God and to one another without fear, frees us to become who God created us to be. It is where, as Howard Thurman wrote, we find the relationships we long for “in which it is no longer needful for us to pretend anything.” Christian community catechizes us through the freedom of Christ, a role fully recognized by teenagers like Grace. What transformed Grace into a bearer of Christ’s love and mercy was not her exposure to theology or her understanding of Christian tradition. What empowered Grace, and what empowers other young people in High School Theology Programs — is the presence of a community through which Christ takes human form, accepting young people fully so they no longer need to pretend to be anything but the wildly promising human beings God made them to be.

. William Myers, Theological Themes of Youth Ministry (New York: Pilgrim, 1987), pp. 5-7.

. Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Life Together (London: SCM, 1960), p. 20.

. Bonhoeffer, Life Together, p. 92.

. Parker Palmer, To Know as We Are Known: A Spirituality of Education (San Francisco: HarperCollins, 1993), p. 14.

. Palmer, To Know as We Are Known, p. 35.

. Palmer, To Know as We Are Known, p. 55.

. Desmond Tutu, No Future without Forgiveness: A Personal Overview of South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission (New York: Doubleday, 1999), p. 31.

. Palmer, To Know as We Are Known, p. 31.

. Dwayne Huebner, “Curricular Language and Classroom Meanings,” in Curriculum Theorizing: The Reconceptualists, ed. William Pinar, (San Pablo, CA: McCutcheon, 1975), p. 223.

. Huebner, “Curricular Language,” p. 227.

. Huebner, “Curricular Language,” p. 231.

. Huebner, “Curricular Language,” p. 231.

. Huebner, “Curricular Language,” p. 229.

. Beth Corrie (director, Youth Theological Initiative, Candler School of Theology), interviewed by Christy Lang Hearlson, July 2012.

. See chapter 6 in this volume, where Christy Lang Hearlson describes various ways in which programs engage youth’s process of separation from and reintegration into home communities.

. Bonhoeffer, Life Together, p. 26, emphasis mine.

. Educators like John Dewey, Lev Vygotsky, Benjamin Bloom, Parker Palmer, bell hooks, and others — representing a range of educational theories — for more than a century have argued in favor of the superiority of imagination and holistic engagement as formative for the most complex and integrative forms of thinking. This cause has been taken up in various ways by the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching in the United States and the European University Association in Europe. Cf. Pat Hutchings et al., The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning Reconsidered: Institutional Integration and Impact (San Francisco: Jossey-­Bass), 2001; the recommendations of the European University Association report, Creativity in Higher Education (Brussels: European University Association), 2007; and (specific to Christian leadership) Charles Foster et al., Educating Clergy: Teaching Practices and Pastoral Imagination (San Francisco: Jossey-­Bass), 2005.

. Howard Thurman, The Inward Journey (Richmond, IN: Friends United Press, 2007), p. 120.

↑ Back to top

↑