Anne Streaty Wimberly
Mara: Transformed through Mentoring
When Mara came to the Youth Hope-Builders Academy, she did not love life or herself. Carrying heavy burdens, she cried often and retreated to her room. Slowly, through patient conversations with caring adult mentors, she began to tell painful stories of being deeply hurt, ignored, and silenced, and how she hated everything about herself. Mentors prayed with her, offered guidance around anger, and affirmed her beauty and gifts of worship leadership, music, and empathy. Indeed, other participants gravitated toward her because of those gifts. In this caring community, Mara gained a stronger sense of self, determination, and life direction. She went on to college, where she studied with the aim of serving young people who had experienced trauma. When she later returned to the YHBA program, she came as an exceptional leader and caring presence for participants in pain, and her current vocation centers on child welfare in addition to youth ministry leadership in her church. As Mara tells it, her life was changed through the experience of mentoring at YHBA:
Because of my mentor, I am in a place today of loving life and myself; and I’m in the process of doing all I can to make a difference in the lives of the next generation. My mentor listened to me as I talked about my struggles with so many things and where I was headed. I could tell it all, complete with yelling and crying! It wasn’t always easy being pushed to own up to my abilities. I hadn’t given much thought to having them or where and how I as a Christian might use them. I found myself, and there was no giving up. I received encouragement. I still do. I can count on my mentor even now. The word has always been that God has a plan for my life. It’s true! God does! I’m so grateful!
As Mara’s story of pain, healing, and ministry shows, the practice of mentoring responds to a real need: many youth feel that no one listens to them or cares about them, and they desperately desire spiritual companionship. They long for mentoring that reveals to them a model of the Christian life that can catalyze life-changing faith. They desire mentors who will help them act in spiritually anchored and purposeful ways, and who will do so in the face of time constraints and wider cultural “tutoring” that runs counter to Christian spirituality and values. Youth seek this up-close and safe relational space in order to share openly their stories of trial and triumph to caring persons who receive them as gift and who act as story-sharers, freely giving back the gifts of self, guidance, and wisdom. Young people long for the countercultural ministry of spiritual mentoring that has at its center companionship guided by God and that demonstrates the caring, guiding qualities of Jesus Christ.
One participant said appreciatively of the mentors in his program, “They’re there to help us to focus and stay on the right path.” His reference to a path helps us name the relational space that youth seek as holy ground where they experience God’s love, hope along the way, and a life direction patterned on the values revealed in the ministry of Jesus Christ. This is the kind of spiritual mentoring Mara experienced, and it is a pivotal practice across the High School Theology Programs. Drawing on firsthand observations and testimonies of leaders, mentors, youth participants, and parents in the HSTPs, this chapter explores the urgent need for mentoring, its theological bases, and ways to foster such spiritual companionship. The chapter concludes with suggestions for theological educators who want their students to glean the benefits of such relationships.
Listen Up! The Need for Mentors Is Real
Mentors play a crucial role in the vocational formation of young Christian leaders in every High School Theology Program. Leaders in these programs confirm that high school youth long for caring mentors, are ready to engage in mentoring processes, and have the skills necessary for in-depth collaboration. In spite of this, most young people have little experience with mentoring. They — and the adults around them — arrive at the mentor-rich environments of HSTPs from individualistic, productivity-oriented, and tech-saturated cultural milieus in which people give little time to listening, substantively caring for, or guiding young people along their journey through adolescence and into adulthood.
Young People’s Longing, Readiness, and Skills
The desire to be seen and heard is a basic human longing. Youth long for meaningful and authentic relationships in which they are seen and heard as valuable people, where they can voice their questions about faith and life in the presence of listeners who care and who take them seriously. Particularly for youth of color, whom my own program predominantly serves, this acceptance means seeing youth as more than a problem to be solved or potential yet to be discovered. Focusing on the primary need to be heard and loved corrects a common misperception of mentoring: mentoring is not just about teaching, modeling, or directing. Instead, good mentors listen, take young people seriously, and affirm them before giving guidance — though guidance is also needed.
Longing for vocational guidance
Young people especially express a need for guidance around purpose and vocation. Reflecting on her experience at the Youth in Ministry Program at Emmanuel School of Religion, Phyllis Fox writes that young people long to “know who they are and what their purpose is. . . . [They] have big dreams, deep loves, courage to take risks, and radical idealism” that need to be “directed to the right goal, the right object, the right call.” Young people are often anxious about the future and want someone with greater life experience to help them prepare. One teenager commented on the way mentors help youth get ready for the rest of life:
They’re teaching us to prepare for life, and I feel as if they have done an outstanding and wonderful job, because they’ve been there. We haven’t been there yet. I’m only going to be a senior in high school. What do I know? . . . I feel as if the mentors have been the biggest blessing that I’ve received in a long time, and for that I am forever grateful.
In a culture that rarely frames experience theologically, it is no small thing that this participant regards the presence of a mentor who offered guidance as a “blessing.”
Concern about the future also translates into concerns about vocational direction, in which youth wrestle with the authenticity and meaning of their call. For example, in the Ministry Quest program at Tabor College, a young man perceived an audible call from God to become a medical doctor. Upon hearing call stories of mentors in church ministry, he grew anxious about what this experience meant. When his mentor clarified the diversity of God’s call, he expressed relief, saying, “I was worried that the only way to fully live out my calling was to be a pastor or missionary. That’s what was troubling me. But now I realize that I can still be faithful to God’s call as a doctor.”
Longing for authorship and agency
Further, youth long for mentors who help them respond to and make sense of their suffering, the world’s messiness, and the difficult realities of society. They experience or observe instances of abuse and are aware of racial and cultural tensions. Many face broken relationships, loneliness, alienation, and depression. In the midst of these struggles, mentors give teenagers space to share their experiences safely while helping them frame their experiences theologically and make decisions to act as people of faith.
In this sense, mentors help young people author their own stories and become decision-makers in their own lives of faith. Tonya Burton at Perkins Youth School of Theology points out that young people are capable of thinking theologically, exploring their faith deeply, and working through challenges to their beliefs, their character, and their present and future actions as unapologetic Christians. In the mentoring relationship, youth become equal partners with spiritual companions who encourage their agency in fulfilling important goals for others’ good, in exploring their religious experiences and traditions, and in making connections between faith and life, theology, and practice. In the end, these young people long for a deepening relationship with God, rather than mere information about God, and they seek mentors who can help them reflect critically as they exercise their own abilities to frame their lives in light of faith.
Many congregational youth ministry programs have sought to provide young people with caring, Christian-centered, and faith-forming mentoring relationships. Yet many of these well-meaning programs — fearful of “turning off” teenagers — have inadvertently re-cast them as consumers of experiences rather than as critical thinkers who are actively engaged in constructing their life worlds. Youth long to be invited into respectful, non-condescending mentoring relationships with people who, as Fred Edie from the Duke Youth Academy writes, do not regard them as “strangers, aliens, or imbeciles.” In addition, youth seek mentors who recognize their high ideals and vision, and their desire to make a difference in the world. Young people want opportunities to exercise their abilities to “think, judge, act and create [and] discover themselves as agents of change,” and they seek mentors who recognize and honor their uniqueness, and give them space in which their unique gifts can blossom.
Christian Companionship as a Countercultural Activity
The incarnational, relational nature of spiritual mentoring serves as a countercultural alternative to individualistic, achievement-oriented, and techno-centered relationship patterns that engulf North American young people. The commercial sector promises a perfect life, available through material items that make us feel good, look good, and live better than others — paving the way for relationships marked by competition and interpersonal estrangement. Technologically mediated relationships produce a sense of anonymity, even sequestering family members away from one another as father, mother, and child pursue their individual social media interests. These cultural pressures not only obscure our abilities to connect with others; they damage our relationship with God, creating a sense of deep relational hunger that Skype and FaceTime cannot satisfy.
In this context, in-person mentors who come alongside both parents and young people offer youth an entirely different kind of relationality. One young person interviewed spoke about the mentors from a High School Theology Program in this way: “I think they’re more understanding. It feels more comfortable talking to them.” Such mentors help adults and youth move beyond the cycles of busyness, shouting, silence, and isolation in order to create space for questions about life and faith, deep and fearful feelings, aspirations, and hope. As they are “listened into being,” teenagers feel their own agency taking shape. As one young person said, “[Mentors] are there to listen to us. That’s what also builds great leadership. My mentor would always remind me when I wouldn’t know what to do. He’d offer ideas or stuff. . . . He’d also remind himself to back off, [saying] ‘I forget that this is your project.’ ”
Mentoring as Hospitable Spiritual Companionship
Theologically, mentoring relationships in Christian community depend on the reality of the household of God, where people experience God’s purposes of abounding love in relationships. God’s household connotes a personal environment that Archbishop Desmond Tutu calls ubuntu. In Archbishop Tutu’s words, the Bantu term ubuntu means, “My humanity is caught up, is inextricably bound up, in yours. . . . A person is a person through other persons. I am human because I belong, I participate, I share.” The mentoring relationship that occurs through spiritual companionship exemplifies this understanding of relationships in the household of God. In God’s realm, in this household, youth are not foreigners; they do not experience relational estrangement. Instead, the spiritual companion sees, accepts, and embraces the young person as kindred. God’s love becomes a felt reality in the hospitality of the spiritual companion. In a hospitable relationship, youth reconnect with others and experience joy, celebration, and healing.
Scripture provides a guide for such hospitality. Hospitality is first of all an extension of the ministry of Jesus. As the Apostle Paul wrote, “Welcome one another, therefore, just as Christ has welcomed you, for the glory of God” (Rom. 15:7). Hospitality is also a proper response to divine grace. As 1 Peter 4:9-10 says: “Be hospitable to one another without complaining. Like good stewards of the manifold grace of God, serve one another with whatever gift each of you has received.” Further, in hospitality, Christians open themselves to a larger spiritual reality. Hebrews 13:2 (KJV) refers to those who extend hospitality as entertaining “angels unawares,” while Matthew 25 suggests that in showing kindness to others, Christians show kindness to Jesus himself. As spiritual companions welcome youth, they welcome Jesus. Hospitality is the mark of the household of God, binding spiritual sisters, brothers, mothers, fathers, and children to one another in love.
Such “kinship hospitality” has several important effects. First, it creates a process of respectful mutual exchange in the mentoring relationship. In this process, the spiritual companion attends to the quality of welcome young people receive so that trust builds and what Anthony Gittins calls “gift exchange” can occur. In gift exchange, the youth and the spiritual companion reciprocally speak and listen, sharing voice and perspective. Second, hospitality means that a mentor is careful to ensure that each person can enter the conversation from his or her own perspective, which in turn affirms appreciation for the elements of “positionality” — the way in which youths’ social, gendered, ethnic-cultural, and religious identities locate them and give them perspective in a conversation. Finally, hospitality in mentoring teaches young people hospitable behaviors by modeling love, care, and respect in a process of “mimetic moral work.” In such mimesis, youth internalize and translate into their own behavior the hospitality they experience and witness.
Spiritual Companionship as a Mutual Process of Doing Theology
Mentoring carried out by spiritual companions is a form of discipleship and spiritual direction. The spiritual companion journeys alongside a young person in her unfolding story, hearing and assisting her in exploring life’s questions and giving wise counsel that promotes her decision to live faithfully as a Christian. The mentoring relationship extends hospitality to youth in a safe space — holy ground — where a mentor listens to a young person’s stories and helps him or her connect those stories to God’s story, considering what such connections mean for everyday life. On such welcoming holy ground, spiritual companionship involves a “holy conversation” that becomes a mutually active process of doing theology. This form of theology, instead of being purely verbal or academic, is personal and embodied, relying heavily on eye contact and body language. In holy conversation, mentor and mentee deal with existential questions: “Who am I?” “Why am I here?” “Where am I going in life?” “Why is life so hard?” “What should I do in this situation?” “What’s God got to do with it?”
This embodied, personal approach to theology-as-conversation builds on the biblical model of Jesus as Mentor of the disciples. Jesus offered personal relationship with the disciples, and as spiritual companion, he posed and answered deep questions of life. He dealt with questions about healing (Mark 9:28), signs of the end (Mark 13:4), and issues of faith and the need to understand (Mark 4:10, 4:38, 4:41). Other biblical figures also engaged in mentoring relationships, learning from one another and facing difficult questions or situations together. Scripture supports mentoring as an activity of doing theology that involves raising deep questions and struggling with the answers.
Setting Spiritual Companionship in Motion
Sanders entered the Youth Hope-Builders Academy (YHBA) Summer Residential Program shortly after the death of his father. During the opening days, his unusually quiet and withdrawn demeanor pointed to his grief. In a small mentoring group called Heart-to-Heart, he gradually began to open up about parts of his story and related concerns. He was the only child in his family; and, now with his dad gone, he was grieving deeply. The Heart-to-Heart mentor met with him individually to provide comfort, care, and conversation about his grief, and to explore his questions about who and how God is in situations of life and death. In the small group meetings, Sanders expressed worry about his mother and how she would cope. He wondered about his role in the family, what would happen to him, and if he had what it would take to honor both of his professional parents’ expectation for success in life as a Black male. His peers rallied around him. In the process of story sharing, they too told of their painful experiences of loss and of worries about their futures.
In ongoing Heart-to-Heart conversations, and in the whole group Exploration Sessions, questions about the meaning of success and Christian vocational direction arose. Sanders described his understanding of success as a high-paying leadership position, but he was unsure of the kind of position that appealed to him. Neither he nor the rest of the group had given much thought to Christian vocation because they connected it to being a church pastor. Sanders completed a gifts inventory and said that it was helpful, but not until after he completed the High School Theology Program did Sanders tell a remarkable unfolding story. He said,
My whole perspective of my purpose and why God has placed me on this earth is totally different as the result of being in YHBA. I was able to tell my story about my dad’s death. . . . I received comfort and assurance from the leaders and, through them, from God. But I also heard stories from others that seemed far worse than mine. From them, I thought, “It’s not about me. God has something for me to do to help others.” I have been fortunate in so many ways — where I live and what my parents have given me. I plan to help others as much as I can.
Sanders has since completed undergraduate studies, is in leadership in a community service organization with youth, and is preparing to enter law school. Sharing his story was the beginning of a new life for Sanders.
Sanders’ experience of story sharing points to a key aspect of mentoring in YHBA and in other High School Theology Programs: treating youth as whole persons. Emphasizing young people’s whole selves reflects the belief that God creates whole persons who live out multifaceted, evolving stories. Moreover, youth want and need to share their complex stories. When spiritual companions tend to these stories, they treat the “sacred texts” of young people’s lives as essential parts of the gift exchange between themselves and young people. They allow young people to explore their thoughts and feelings about life, to discuss their recognition of or hope for God’s activity, and to wonder what God’s activity means for their unfolding story. Shared stories transform and deepen young people’s faith.
For mentors to honor the whole of young people’s lives requires attentiveness to the many elements of their complex identities, such as their ethnicity, socio-cultural location, gender, and religious affiliation. It requires an awareness of how youth perceive themselves in relationship to their immediate surroundings and in the wider culture and world. Sanders, for example, referred to his ethnicity and gender as a Black male. He also described his fortunate circumstances — having two parents who had loved and nurtured him and encouraged him to succeed. When mentors attend to the social contexts of youth, they are listening through young people’s stories for clues about where they live, attend school and church, play, and work, as well as the qualities of these environments as informed by available resources. As Sanders’ story revealed, mentors also must attend to young people’s networks of relationships. Sanders’ story was shaped by his relationship with his parents, but also by his relationships with other family members; school peers and friends; and others in church, community, and workplace; as well as those with whom he connected in social and mass media. The nature of Sanders’ connection with God is also part of his relational network. Such networks, of course, change over time. Various events taking place in the family — such as the death of Sanders’ father — or that happen in school, church, and beyond alter their relationships, and add to the stories young people bring into the mentoring relationship.
Moreover, mentors help young people recognize that their stories are laden with life meanings. Teenagers’ thoughts, feelings, attitudes, and values reveal what goes into the way they make sense out of their lives, and these meanings may extend to their views about the future. Sanders had definite thoughts about a future of success based on internalized parental expectations. But he later spoke of an alternative view of his future, transformed through interactions with peers and the outcomes of his theological reflection on God’s purpose for his life. All of these aspects of identity factor into the stories youth tell, and mentors do well to attend to their interrelation.
Purpose-Driven Mentoring in the High School Theology Programs
Mentors in the High School Theology Programs have the overall goal of providing spiritual accompaniment that helps catalyze young people’s positive development as persons, and helps them form life-changing faith. In surveying these programs’ use of mentoring, four specific purposes stand out.
Purpose One: Giving Youth a Voice
The first purpose of mentoring in the HSTPs is to give youth a voice in a world where youth often feel no one listens to them. The mentor who seeks to give a young person a voice must take on three action roles: listener, inquirer, and spiritual resource. The mentor as listener addresses the prevalent complaint of young people that nobody listens to them. In order to give the young person a voice, the mentor provides an inviting space for the mentee to talk about whatever he wants without being judged. As one young person said of mentors, “They want to listen to you. They want to hear your side of the story, too. It is very encouraging to know that adults will listen and adults will take you seriously.”
Yet listening without judgment does not mean passivity. In order to help youth wrestle with the meaning of their life, their beliefs about it, and their place and action in the world, the mentor becomes an inquirer, asking hard questions and again listening carefully. They help the young person ask herself questions like, Do I see myself as beautiful? Damaged? Lovable? Do I live a life of grace? Do I choose to see the world as hostile or affirming? How does God see me? How does that change how I see myself and other people and, in turn, how I act in the world and the choices I make? Youth respond well to this kind of inquiry when it does not function as a veiled attempt to simply convey what the adult already believes. One participant said with appreciation of the mentors, “They actually asked me what I thought.”
Third, in seeking to give youth voice, the mentor takes on the role of a spiritual resource, becoming aware of and responding to young people’s questions and concerns about Christian faith and life, including its doctrinal tenets and scriptural sources. In their search for certainty, youth ask questions like, Is there a God? What is God like? Is my grandma in heaven? What’s the difference between a Christian living their life wrong and an atheist living their life right? Why do many Christians condemn homosexuality and premarital sex? To function well as a spiritual resource to young people, a mentor must actively invite hard questions and encourage youth to talk about their view of Christianity and their experience of themselves as Christians. Being a spiritual resource does not mean that mentors must have all the answers, but only that they are willing to point young people to other resources that will help young people make sense of their questions, and to wrestle with them more deeply as they find answers . . . or more questions.
Purpose Two: Collaboration and Relational Co-Authorship
Mentoring also creates collaborative relationships with young people as it helps them take on authorship of their own lives. For this reason, the mentor remains flexible, taking on a variety of roles — e.g., friend, self-revealer, learner — depending on what the context demands. The friendship a mentor gives goes beyond instrumental support by offering real care, keen interest in the present and future well-being of youth, and collaborative involvement in activities of leadership. As a friend, the mentor attends to the emotional state and needs of youth; gives encouragement, praise, support, and truthful advice when necessary; and plans activities with the young person, drawing on the young person’s skills and giving increasing responsibility to youth. Youth appreciate the friendship they receive from their mentors. One young person reflected, “They seem like they really care about all of you.” They also respond well to the collaborative, reflective spirit. One participant said, “Your mentors, they’re usually higher than you, [and] you just listen to what they say, and [they] try to do all these things to make them like you . . . but here, you’re talking face-to-face.”
In the context of such trusting, collaborative relationships, a mentor can reveal details about his or her own life, using judicious self-disclosure to show care and warmth, build positive connection, and encourage their mentee’s own self-disclosure. The mentor might reveal thoughts and feelings about the mentoring relationship, personal experiences akin to those of the young person, stories of struggles and how they were resolved, and stories of the Christian faith journey and calling. This has the effect of making the relationship mutual, which can remove clinical distance. As one young person commented, “Yeah, [mentors] share their own stuff too, so it’s not like they sit back and watch you.”
Further, to foster a collaborative relationship and model the Christian life, the mentor is also a learner. Like the mentee, the mentor grows in awareness of personal strengths, growing edges, and sense of call. One mentor, reflecting the experiences of many others in the HSTPs, said of the experience of mentoring, “I have reaffirmed my youth ministry calling.” In order to act as a co-learner, the mentor invests in his or her own process of spiritual discernment in order to become more aware of areas of learning and needed growth. She might also express gratitude for what she learns from her mentee. Youth show surprise and appreciation for mentors who disclose that they continue to learn, saying, “My mentor will say, ‘Man, I’m learning everything,’ ” or, “He likes learning things from young people.”
Purpose Three: Learning and Personal Development
A third purpose of the spiritual companion is to respond to young people’s desire for personal and vocational development. In seeking this goal, mentors take on the action roles of teacher, counselor/sage, and temporary surrogate parent. As a teacher, the mentor seeks to activate young people’s knowledge, feelings, values, and actions regarding Christian faith and life. To do so, the mentor provides information and tools such as Scripture, stories of faith exemplars, historical material, and media, and uses these materials to engage youth in inquiry, critical analysis, discussion, and Christian values clarification. Youth commonly voice appreciation when they experience a mentor who is well equipped for the task of teaching; as one young person said, “In almost every one of the small groups we have, there’s someone . . . teaching us, so it’s like we have a professional to help us out.” Or, as another youth commented, grateful for the relevance of teaching in the high school theology program he attended: “They’re teaching us to prepare for life.”
Sometimes youth share stories that reveal serious life disruptions, mental health issues, and problems associated with trauma. In these cases, mentors must act as sages with life wisdom to share, and sometimes as informal pastoral counselors. Mentors frequently collaborate to discern needs among youth that require more specialized training, and many High School Theology Programs involve some mentors who are certified to deal with mental health or trauma issues. Mentors also find themselves in bridge roles, filling “gaps” left by fractured family systems. One young person said, “My dad’s death left a hole in my life. I didn’t want to replace him, but, still, I needed somebody. My mentor has been there for me.” By clarifying her role as surrogate (and not actual) parent, this mentor was able to offer a supportive and advising presence as the teenager learned how to seek out networks of love and support.
Purpose Four: Youth Agency and Action
High School Theology Programs also use mentoring to promote agency and action in young people. Teenagers long to address suffering — both their own suffering, and the world’s. To this end, the mentor becomes a spiritual guide or coach, as well as a challenger. As a spiritual guide or coach, the mentor recognizes young people’s need to make their own decisions about the kind of disciples and church leaders they are becoming. By providing teenagers in the HSTPs with a variety of opportunities for leadership, and by engaging youth in exploring their spiritual gifts and talents, mentors help young people imagine how God’s call to them may unfold now and in the future.
As challengers, mentors recognize young people’s penchant for reacting quickly to issues as they try to change the world in a day. Mentors in the HSTPs help the “now” generation try out methodical approaches for the sake of long-term change. Working alongside youth on various ministry projects, mentors challenge youth to take responsibility for all aspects of preparation and implementation. For example, one young person reported the planning process for a big project: “You have a whole meeting with the counselors. . . . [I’d say] I’m thinking I would talk about teen homelessness. They’d say, ‘Okay, go deeper, what’s the need? What’s the need?’ I’m thinking, ‘Oh, I’ll do a food drive.’ They say, ‘Okay, what’s the need you’re filling?’ ”
Do I Have to Do It All?
Effective mentoring requires quality relationships and interactions, but of course no single mentor can fulfill every role. Rather, the HSTPs create a culture of mentoring, where mentors are available to teenagers in multiple contexts, with different roles, personal abilities, and levels of preparation. For example, the mentor as listener is a role in which almost anyone — even peers — can become adept with training. The mentor as spiritual resource requires special preparedness. High School Theology Programs fill these mentor roles with adults who are theologically prepared, who feel comfortable fielding tough questions about faith and life, and who can reflect critically on their own motives, needs, and emotional states. This form of mentoring requires a self-awareness that allows mentors to act as a friend while acknowledging the reality of power imbalances and maintaining appropriate boundaries. Adult mentors who play the roles of teacher, counselor/sage, and temporary surrogate parent constitute another group of mentors who might be called skilled helpers. These adults have highly developed relationship skills, as well as professional or experiential training that help them carry out instrumental tasks. These tasks include engaging young people in formal, outcome-based classroom activities, as well as in follow-up sessions that aim toward more long-lasting learning, personal development, and change.
All of these kinds of mentors need ongoing support and development. Directors of the HSTPs have learned the value of initially assessing potential mentors’ special gifts, strengths, experiences, passion, and commitments, and then helping them engage in self-assessment during the mentoring process. One mentor in the Youth Hope-Builders Academy reflected:
This was not my first time as a mentor. But this time reminded me that mentoring is not always easy. In fact, it can be really tough! There were some breakthroughs. I celebrate them. But I needed more help with knowing what to do with youth who are in what seems like unsolvable situations. I learned that the task of mentoring is not about solving everything. Sometimes, simply being there, listening, and asking the right questions is enough.
Comments like this one can help program leaders discover areas to further prepare all their mentors, as well as places where individual mentors need support and attention.
Mentoring Patterns in the High School Theology Programs
By creating cultures of mentoring, young people in the High School Theology Programs have access to many levels of mentoring beyond the one-on-one mentoring that occurs over (and sometimes beyond) a specified program period. The most common pattern is the use of small mentoring groups, often called “covenant groups,” where mentoring is carried out under the heading of theological reflection. In these small group settings, spiritual companions may come in the form of adults or youth peers, staff counselors or pastoral caregivers, professors, pastors, spiritual directors, or seminary students. Periods of reflection are often organized according to specific topics and include activities such as story sharing, lectio divina, prayer and other liturgical practices, journaling, art and other expressive modes in concert with other approaches.
Multi-layered mentoring is also common. We designed this sort of multi-layered organizational structure for the Youth Hope-Builders Academy in order to respond to major breakdowns in intergenerational relationships and to the dire need of both youth and parents for mentors and guidance. This structure includes group mentoring of youth by adult mentors, one-on-one mentoring by caring, committed adults working with teen mentees, peer mentoring among adult leaders, and cross-age mentoring carried out by high school teens with middle school mentees. For example, group mentoring carried out by adult mentors with teen mentees takes place in small, gender-specific Heart-to-Heart Clusters — “family-like pods” of six to eight youth that meet for one-half to two hours daily during the YHBA Summer Residential Program. The adult mentor typically creates significant time at the outset of the group meetings to build a safe space for sharing. These times entail relationship-building games, bonding experiences, setting rules of engagement, and discussing and committing to confidentiality agreements.
As part of the group-mentoring process, youth freely frame the conversation, typically focusing on group or personal issues, or past and present problematic experiences with family, school, church, or community. At times, the adult mentor also proposes a topic for group discussion and reflection based on observations of the youth over the days of their academy participation, including biblical stories and passages and personal story sharing by both mentor and mentees. Over the course of the Heart-to-Heart mentoring process, the mentor structures time for “praise reports” and “prayer concerns,” and may introduce case materials, journaling, and artistic expression as vehicles for critical reflection. All of these activities help youth reflect theologically on God’s presence and activity in all their lives, and enable them to discover prayer as a spiritual resource to be used individually and collectively.
A key movement in the mentoring process is the invitation to youth to move from a problematizing stance to a problem-solving position through concrete decision-making. The mentor frames the transition with questions like: “What will you do with this concern? How will you handle that issue? What might this suggest for your actions with others here and after you leave YHBA? What has happened here that gives you some ideas for vocational direction?” Peers may also offer recommendations for reflection and potential decisions. Particularly for young people with expressed or apparent low self-esteem, the mentor may give personal affirmation or invite youth to repeat the affirmation in the first person: “You are a valuable creation of God. You are a valued and handsome human being. Know that you are loved by God and loved by me.” They may also add biblical passages, such as Psalm 139:1-18.
Cross-age mentoring by high school teens with middle school youth began at the Youth Hope-Builders Academy in 2009 with an initiative called TAPs (Teens And Pre-Teens). In this initiative, each high school youth was paired with a middle schooler whom he or she mentored with adult supervision over the program year. High school mentors were prepared for their role at a week-long, post-residential program intensive. Each day began with teen-led worship, followed by program activities interspersed with recreation and arts experiences — all designed to form leaders who embrace responsibility for giving back to their community, modeling Christian character for middle school youth, helping guide their Christian formation, and engaging in community service with mentees. To this end, the mentoring pairs were selected in conversation with the young people involved, their pastor(s) or youth pastor(s), and the parents or guardians of both the mentor and the mentee — who, Tuesday through Thursday during the training period, brought their middle school youth on site to participate in targeted activities to prepare them for the year-long cross-mentoring activities. Parents also attended sessions to explore supportive parental roles.
Once the mentoring relationship was underway, an adult liaison maintained monthly contact with the youth, receiving testimonies from the high school students about their experiences with their mentees, including responses from the parents. One high school mentor’s story shows the power of modeling and mimesis mentioned earlier in this chapter:
At church, I am an altar server. During one of our conversations, she [the mentee] told me that she was interested in serving. So I contacted the leader of the altar servers and asked if she could serve with me, even though she hadn’t gone through the training. [The leader] agreed. We arrived at church thirty minutes early in order to prepare and set up for the Mass. During Mass, I guided her through the proper reverence, the holding of the book, the washing of the hands, the correct protocol, etc. After Mass, while we were cleaning up, she told me how much fun she had, and it was just a wonderful experience.
Another teen mentor’s story expresses the way a mentor can offer support and challenge to a mentee: “We had a youth conference that our church hosted. I encouraged my mentee to step out of her comfort zone and fellowship with different people. She did it. It was a wonderful day.” These mentoring relationships provide opportunities for the mentors to show maturity and to establish their own sense of self in the midst of collaboration. One eleventh grade mentor reports,
After my homecoming football game, my mentee told me that he was proud of me for winning Mr. Eleventh Grade. He also told me that I’m not better than him, because he won Mr. Eighth Grade. I told him that my goal is not to be better than him. I’m just trying to lead in a positive way. He responded and said, “Yeah, I know.” To sum up that whole conversation, I just basically told him that you have a chance to be the best you can be as an African American male; but it’s your choice to take the responsibility and make the right choices.
Overall, the cross-age mentor relationships prove a valuable source of support and affirmation for younger mentees. One mentor remembers,
I attended my mentee’s step show performance. We met up prior to the show. I wished her luck and told her that I was going to be rooting for her on the front row. She was very excited and ready to go on the stage. She had on this really cool jacket that I later found out was for the act. She did a superb job and I congratulated her.
Two other forms of mentoring are worth highlighting. Parents play an essential role in the lives of youth, but they often desire and need opportunities to explore their role and receive guidance on how to enhance the faith and leadership formation of their children. We hear parents say: “I really don’t know how to raise my teens in today’s world. I want to help. I want to make a difference. I have lots of questions. Just as the youth need guidance from others, so do I.” YHBA’s response has been to provide forums focused on key issues identified by parents that include panels of parents who share stories and strategies around targeted topics, facilitated by professional counselors and pastoral caregivers who provide concrete input.
In addition to parents, mentoring through technologically supported connections is gaining in popularity in High School Theology Programs. Given the reality that young people’s technologically mediated friend networks, relationship-tending and faith-building practices need not be confined to face-to-face contacts. While HSTP directors recognize the downside of our tech-saturated world, some programs also leverage these connections to support the mentoring process. The Youth in Theology and Ministry program of Saint John’s School of Theology and Seminary creates a year-round online community for the purpose of hearing and responding to young people’s issues and questions. Huron University College’s Ask & Imagine program incorporates Facebook for purposes of engaging youth in peer mentoring, while adults guide youth in how to use Facebook to foster peer support, affirmation, and community-building. Likewise, Emmanuel Christian Seminary’s Youth in Ministry program (a partnership with Milligan College) also uses Facebook to encourage peer mentoring, as youth post prayer requests and offer support. For all of these programs, online connections help continue relationships beyond the intensive program experience, and remind young people as they return home that they are not alone.
Expanding the Reach of Mentoring
Mentoring programs go a long way in addressing young people’s need for safe spaces and trustworthy adults, both of which are critical as they develop into teachable, but unapologetic, Christians. There are, however, risks involved in the undertaking. Young people come to the High School Theology Programs — not to mention to churches, colleges, and seminaries — with troubling stories, doubts, and frustrations. They bring questions that challenge the most confident and skillful mentor. In addition, transformation seldom happens quickly, which can leave mentors feeling disappointed in the process or doubtful of their own abilities. Further, because mentoring requires energy, time, and ongoing engagement, some people find mentoring challenging, even overwhelming. Finally, setting up and sustaining mentoring programs requires significant time and energy, since recruiting, screening, training, communicating, and supporting mentors is necessary to their success in this role. Mentoring is demanding.
Yet if the HSTPs are any indication, the relationship-intensive programs and structures that create mentoring relationships are a worthwhile institutional investment. The world and the church urgently need leaders to offer an incarnational, countercultural response to individualistic, achievement-oriented, and technologically centered cultural patterns, making spiritual friendship a primary means of doing theology. Young people report how powerfully formative the mentor relationship is in terms of faith, vocation, and personal development; mentors also report growth in both their confidence as leaders and in their own thinking about faith. In every stage of the discipleship process, mentorship fosters growth and transformation for both the mentor and the mentee.
The High School Theology Programs demonstrate that mentoring requires intentionality. While a mentor relationship sometimes blooms spontaneously like a solitary wildflower on a mountainside, creating a larger culture of mentoring requires communities that serve as “greenhouses” for mentoring: nurturing its early growth; intentionally structuring relationships; providing support, preparation, and self-assessment opportunities; and inviting young people to be mentored or to mentor — or, in some cases, to do both. Admittedly, the HSTPs have access to a stellar group of well-equipped mentors, and they show how powerful such a constellation of caring adults can be. Yet the programs also demonstrate that effective forms of mentoring do not always require “religious professionals,” or even adults in general. Mentoring can occur between same-age and cross-age groups under adult supervision — patterns that are often quite powerful for all involved, especially when those involved are encouraged to make mid-course corrections in response to feedback and experience. Creating a culture of mentoring is demanding, but not impossible.
The significance of mentoring in the formation of Christian leaders requires us to take it seriously as a means of theological formation, and not relegate it to the margins of formal theological education — as a non-academic practice of personal support, something extraneous to the practice of theology. High School Theology Programs demonstrate how embodied, living theology emerges in the midst of holy conversations between mentor and mentee, in a context that more closely resembles relationships in a congregation than theological discussions in a classroom. If the educator’s truism is accurate — that people teach as they are taught — then seminaries, denominations, and congregations have every reason to mentor the future Christian leaders in their care, for a world that desperately needs what mentoring gives.
. One of the contexts most likely to serve as a crucible for faith formation is in mentor relationships (other contexts include families and congregations). Cf. Kenda Creasy Dean, Almost Christian: What the Faith of Our Teenagers Is Telling the American Church (New York: Oxford University Press, 2010), p. 11. Gil Noam and his colleagues also stress that mentoring relationships with caring adults serve as effective means of youth development since development invariably takes place in the context of significant relationships. See Gil G. Noam, Tina Malti, and Michael J. Karcher, “Mentoring Relationships in Developmental Perspective,” in Handbook of Youth Mentoring, ed. David L. DuBois and Michael J. Karcher, (Los Angeles: Sage Publications, Inc., 2014), p. 100.
. Sean Lansing, “Reflections” (unpublished report, High School Theology Leadership Consultation, Indianapolis, IN, February 23-25, 2012).
. Lansing, “Reflections”; also Jeff Kaster, “Reflections” (unpublished report, High School Theology Leadership Consultation, Indianapolis, IN, February 23-25, 2012).
. Phyllis Fox, “Reflections” (unpublished report, High School Theology Leadership Consultation, Indianapolis, IN, February 23-25, 2012).
. Wendell Loewen and Jules Glanzer, “Reflections” (unpublished report, High School Theology Leadership Consultation, Indianapolis, IN, February 23-25, 2012).
. Loewen and Glanzer, “Reflections.”
. Tonya Burton, “Reflections” (unpublished report, High School Theology Leadership Consultation, Indianapolis, IN, February 23-25, 2012).
. Karcher and Hansen refer to authorship as a necessary aspect of mentoring activities and interactions. This aspect affirms youths’ readiness to be put at the center in decision-making in the mentoring relationship and becomes a basis on which empowerment, meaning, and hope occur. A discussion on authorship appears in Michael J. Karcher and Keoki Hansen, “Mentoring Activities and Interactions,” in Handbook of Youth Mentoring, 2nd ed., ed. David L. DuBois and Michael J. Karcher (Los Angeles: Sage Publications, 2014), p. 69.
. Fred Edie, “Reflections” (unpublished report, High School Theology Leadership Consultation, Indianapolis, IN, February 23-25, 2012).
. Andrew Duran, “Reflections” (unpublished report, High School Theology Leadership Consultation, Indianapolis, IN, February 23-25, 2012); Claire Smith, “Reflection” (unpublished report, High School Theology Leadership Consultation, Indianapolis, IN, February 23-25, 2012).
. Kaveri Subrahmanyam and Patricia Greenfield, “Online Communication and Adolescent Relationships,” Children and Electronic Media 18, no. 1 (Spring 2008): 120, www.futureofchildren.org (accessed February 12, 2012).
. Desmond Tutu, No Future without Forgiveness (New York: Doubleday, 1999), p. 31.
. Anthony J. Gittins, Gifts and Strangers: Meeting the Challenge of Inculturation (New York: Paulist Press, 1989), p. 102.
. An exploration of “positionality” is used most particularly to set forth an understanding of gender issues in education. See Mary Kay Thompson Tetreault, “Classrooms for Diversity: Rethinking Curriculum and Pedagogy,” in Multicultural Education: Issues and Perspectives, 2nd ed., ed. James A. Banks and Cherry A. McGee Banks (Boston: Allyn and Bacon, 1993), pp. 164-85.
. Margaret Guenther uses the term “holy listening” to describe the spiritual director’s love of the Holy Spirit and being led by the Spirit to be present and listen attentively to the seeker. See Margaret Guenther, Holy Listening: The Art of Spiritual Direction (Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, Inc., 1992), p. 1.
. See Elizabeth Struthers Malbon, In the Company of Jesus: Characters in Mark’s Gospel (Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox, 2000), pp. 93-94.
. For example, Jethro’s mentoring relationship with his son-in-law Moses (Exod. 18); Moses’ mentorship of Joshua (Deut. 3:28); David’s and Jonathan’s peer mentoring relationship (1 Sam. 19 and 20); Peter’s and Barnabas’ mentoring relationship (Gal. 2:11-13); and Paul’s mentorship of Timothy (2 Tim.).
. In my own work, I draw on Peter Gilmour’s emphasis on story as sacred text. See Anne E. Streaty Wimberly, Soul Stories: African Christian Education (Nashville, TN: Abingdon, 2005); and Peter Gilmour, The Wisdom of Memoir: Reading and Writing Life’s Sacred Texts (Winona, MN: St. Mary’s Press, 1997).
. The various aspects of the stories of the lives of youth are the same as those comprising the lives of all human beings. These aspects of human life stories are described in Wimberly, Soul Stories, pp. 26-29.
. Notable examples of these organizational plans are described by Elizabeth Corrie, “Reflections on Pedagogies of Vocational Discernment” (unpublished report, High School Theology Seminar, Indianapolis, IN, November 11-13, 2012); Jeff Kaster and Craig Gould, “Pedagogies of Theological Education, Theological Reflection” (unpublished report, High School Theology Seminar, Indianapolis, IN, November 11-13, 2012); Anabel Proffitt, “Building Intentional Community (Koinonia) Towards Formation” (unpublished report, High School Theology Seminar, Indianapolis, IN, November 11-13, 2012).
. An entire chapter on the nature and importance of tech-connections with youth appears in Anne E. Streaty Wimberly, Sandra L. Barnes, and Karma D. Johnson, Youth Ministry in the Black Church: Centered in Hope (Valley Forge, PA: Judson Press, 2013), pp. 132-48.
. Kaster, “Reflections.”
. Judy Steers, “Reflections” (unpublished report, High School Theology Leadership Consultation, Indianapolis, IN, February 23-25, 2012).
. Fox, “Reflections.”
