A. Research Methods for the High School Youth Theology Program Seminar
Katherine M. Douglass with Kenda Creasy Dean
This research model was explicitly patterned after another Lilly-initiated project focusing on religious practices, the Valparaiso Project on the Education and Formation of People in Faith’s “Seminar on Practical Theology and Christian Ministry” (2004-2005), one of several religious practices initiatives born out of the religious practices discussion launched by the collaborations leading to Practicing Our Faith (Dorothy Bass and Craig Dykstra, eds., [San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1997]) and Practicing Theology (Dorothy Bass and Miroslav Volf [San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2001]). Utilizing similar research methods and theoretical foundations in the religious practices movement, the present project focuses specifically on the practices of vocational formation employed by the High School Theology Projects, especially since 1998.
Research Team
This research was conducted by an invested team of practical theologians including thoughtful practitioners, graduate student researchers, and professors who provide a multiplicity of vantage points for gleaning subjective and objective information about youth theology programs. As both “outsiders” and “insiders,” this group has contributed to this book in unique ways that offer a prism through which to view these programs rather than a single lens. This intentional “inside-outside” perspective allowed for a more nuanced interpretation of these programs’ formative practices and governing theological perspectives than any one research group could have offered.
As “outsiders,” graduate student researchers conducted site visits and interviews, and read deeply into the written histories of these programs to compare and contrast programs, identify innovative praxis, highlight trends, and begin to analyze the unique contributions that youth theology programs make to the greater ecology of Christian formation.
As “insiders,” program directors involved with this project were asked to reflect on the unique pedagogical and theological practices of their programs that foster Christian leadership. These reflections made explicit many of the implicit theologies and pedagogies that inform the practices of youth theology programs, but until this project had not been openly analyzed.
Research Methods
The research methods were devised primarily to help seminar members curate and reflect upon existing but unexplored data, including the reflections of participant-observers. After perusing this data, we identified our “hunches” about the importance of various practices in awakening young Christians to leadership, and tested the reliability of those provisional conclusions through qualitative research “soundings” that augmented existing data streams. Qualitative data were collected through multiple streams, from multiple sources, both over time and in the context of observed action. Five data streams were explicitly identified:
Choices and Limitations
As with every research project, our research choices have shaped this project’s findings. For example, in the site visit phase we decided to interview not only youth and program directors, but also the staff mentors who helped lead these programs in various ways. This led to an unexpected facet on our research prism, as we powerfully witnessed the vocational significance these programs had for college and graduate students serving as staff, as well as for teenagers themselves. Some of the most interesting findings (with strong implications for seminary education) emerged from that research decision. Having made the decision to interview staff mentors in order to “cover our bases, ” we came to recognize how programs that are intentionally designed to foster leadership among youth have a “spillover” effect that influences the vocational discernment of young adult program leaders as well.
Similarly, we did not plan to interview faculty teaching in these programs. This was a mistake, as we learned quickly from program directors who regaled us with stories about faculty involvement in these programs. In this book, we chose to include the personal narrative of one faculty member simply to “bookmark” this area for future research, and to note that seminary faculty often find the experience of teaching theology to high school students transformative for their own pedagogies as well.
Our research design focused on discovering how these programs define and foster Christian leadership in the lives of youth. This focus emerged from strong evidence from program alumni, as well as program reviews by Carol Lytch and the recent research of Barbara Wheeler, suggesting that the HSTPs were indeed occasions for young people to grow spiritually — but they were specifically valuable in awakening youth to the possibility of their own leadership, in the present and in the future, in the church and in the world.
Timeline
While numerous studies have emerged from data collected at youth theology programs, until now there has been no comprehensive study that considered the unique pedagogical contributions that youth theology programs have to offer to the broader church, and to theological education more generally. In the fall of 2011, Lilly Foundation Inc. — having invested over fifty million dollars in these programs since 1992 — approached Princeton Theological Seminary to develop such a study, starting with the archival data Lilly had been collecting on these programs for nearly two decades. Project co-directors Christopher Coble (then a program director in Lilly’s religion division) and Kenda Creasy Dean (Mary D. Synnott Professor of Youth, Church and Culture at Princeton Theological Seminary) met with seminar members in various capacities over the course of eighteen months, focusing on programs’ practices of vocational formation. After eight graduate researchers made fifteen on-site visits in the summer of 2012, their interviews and field notes were transcribed and uploaded to NVivo, a qualitative analysis program that provides researchers with tools for content analysis.
Analysis
Analysis of data occurred in two stages. The principle investigators (Dean and Coble) and graduate student researchers began the analysis of these programs through reflection upon the interviews, site visits, theological self-reflections and written histories submitted by HSTP program directors. This analysis was then brought into conversation with the written and oral self-reflections of program directors, shared during three three-day seminars over the course of this project. This multi-dimensional analysis was then used by Dean, Coble, and project associate Christy Lang Hearlson to create a framework for reporting data. This framework gave rise to the chapters in this book.
Writing and Reporting
Coble and Dean, with co-editor Christy Lang Hearlson, invited program directors whose programs exemplified the key pedagogical practices emerging from this analysis to write about these topics. In addition to the program directors, authors of this volume also include a guest professor from a High School Theology Program; editors Dean, Hearlson, and Coble; and one researcher who had been part of the graduate research team during her PhD program. Authors were invited to not only reflect on their own programs, but where relevant, to use the analysis and findings of both the seminar conversations and the NVivo transcripts to broaden their chapters’ reflections to include other HSTPs.
In order to bring this project full circle, the various chapters were reviewed and edited, first by the editors, and then also by an expanded team of graduate student researchers to ensure that the reporting of findings resonated with the observations and findings that emerged from site visits, and to ensure readability to those who were not already familiar with these programs.
This multi-faceted process of data collection, analysis, writing, reviewing, and editing, accomplished by a large team of collaborators rather than by an individual, capitalizes on the value that multiple perspectives offer to a research project. This dialogical process of writing is similar to other projects on religious practices, especially Dorothy Bass’s “Seminar on Practical Theology and Christian Ministry” (2004-2005). The collaborative approach to writing is also resonant with the writing approach used in other practical theological and educational literature, such as Brian Mahan et al.’s Awakening Youth Discipleship and Mary Belenky et al.’s Women’s Ways of Knowing.
The limitation of this methodological approach is the risk that dissenting voices may not be adequately acknowledged, especially since these dissenting voices might have interpreted or highlighted various findings differently. It also must be clear that no one person has an omniscient view of these programs.
Our intention was to invite those who are closest to and most invested in these practices to reflect on them within our community of practical theologians, so that their excellent praxis might be amplified and shared for the sake of sparking a reformation in theological education.
. The team consisted of five doctoral students, supplemented by two senior MDiv students who had taken a doctoral research methods seminar at Princeton Theological Seminary. One doctoral student was an alumnus of an early HSTP that was not included in the scope of this research.
. Andrew S. Jack and Barrett W. McRae, “Tassel-Flipping: A Portrait of the Well-Educated Youth Ministry Graduate,” Journal of Youth Ministry 4 (Fall 2005): 53-73.
. Mark Oestreicher, “The Top 10 Books That Have Influenced Youth Ministry” (January 10, 2007), accessed November 7, 2013, https://www.luthersem.edu/cyf/children/childrensministrybibliography.pdf.
. Carol Lytch, “Summary Report I: Strategic Advances in Theological Education: Theological Programs for High School Youth, 1999-2004,” Theological Education 42 (2006); Barbara Wheeler, “On Our Way: A Study of Students’ Paths to Seminary,” unpublished report of survey data submitted to the Lilly Endowment (August 2013).
. See David F. White, Practicing Discernment with Youth: A Transformative Youth Ministry Approach (Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim, 2005); Katherine Turpin, Branded (Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim, 2006); Dori Grinenko Baker and Joyce Ann Mercer, Lives to Offer (Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim, 2007); Fred P. Edie, Book, Bath, Table and Time, (Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim, 2007).
. See Brian Mahan, Michael Warren, and David F. White, Awakening Youth Discipleship: Christian Resistance in a Consumer Culture (Eugene, OR: Cascade, 2008); Mary Field Belenky et al., Women’s Ways of Knowing (New York: Basic Books, 1997).
