Jeffrey Kaster
Samantha was a rising high school senior at her second two-week Youth in Theology and Ministry Summer Institute (YTM) at St. John’s University. After her morning theology class, she approached me and announced, “Jeff, I’m really mad at you.” Taken aback, I asked, “What’s up, Samantha?” She replied, “I had my whole college academic program all worked out. I figured out all the classes I would need to qualify for a career in physical therapy. But now because you had us take these theology classes, I have to revise my entire plan. I love theology so much, I now have to figure out how to include theological study in my college coursework.” Samantha in fact went on to minor in theology in college and spent the next four years not only studying theology, but also actively engaging in multiple Christian practices that deepened her faith over the course of her college career.
Samantha’s story points to the fundamental question of how Christian discipleship is sustained. Samantha wanted to keep learning. Rather than simply speaking about an emotional or spiritual camp experience, Samantha was captivated by the theological exploration of the Christian tradition that the Youth in Theology and Ministry Summer Institute offered, and realized that she wanted to learn more. Like Peter on the mountaintop at the Transfiguration, she wanted to “stay a little longer.”
Directors of the High School Theology Programs often tell similar stories in which participants approach them at the end of their program and ask, sometimes literally: “Can’t we stay just a little bit longer?” These young people have had an encounter with God that touches their hearts and minds and, like Peter, they would like to build a tent and linger. We might say that youth have conversion experiences at these programs. They experience God’s love and grace through a variety of pedagogical practices that incorporate service, justice, prayer, community, vocational discernment, creativity, and pilgrimage, and they want the experience to continue.
How can we help such youth move from a spiritual high to a sustaining faith so that, like Samantha, they continue to grow as disciples, both for their own sakes and for a church desperate for young leadership? Catechetical leaders must discern a combustible mix of elements that can fuel young people’s discipleship journeys over the long haul.
Intellectual Community in High School Theology Programs
Despite the variety of High School Theology Programs, they all share one conviction: discipleship over the long haul requires familiarity with the texts and traditions that have fueled Christian faith for centuries. As a result, every HSTP plunges participants headlong into these resources, emphasizing a pedagogical practice typically missing from congregational youth ministry programs: robust theological reflection on Christian texts and traditions. The HSTPs develop “intellectual communities” of teenagers and adults in order to deepen their capacities for living theologically informed lives.
“Intellectual community” is a pedagogical strategy that is more often associated with graduate school than youth ministry. Indeed, the Carnegie Initiative on the Doctorate (2006) identified “apprenticeship” and “intellectual community” as the two signature pedagogies of excellent doctoral education, citing five essential elements that make such communities formative. In addition to being “knowledge-centered” (i.e., having as their goal the explicit purpose of generating understanding), intellectual communities are also “broadly inclusive,” integrating young scholars fully into the practices of the community, viewing them as equal contributors to it. Furthermore, intellectual communities are “flexible and forgiving”: they make room for creativity and risk-taking. They are “respectful and collegial,” building camaraderie on “engagement, if not agreement.” Intellectual communities are also “purposeful and deliberate” — they do not happen by accident, but have established structures, regular opportunities for students to lead as well as learn, and give students permission to ask unpopular questions. Finally, such communities are “relationship-based.” Since all learning is social, students succeed best in communities that prize “thoughtfulness, attentiveness to the needs of others, a willingness to listen carefully and engage in meaningful communication across and in spite of differences, an ability to work collaboratively . . . and a commitment to the ethical treatment of others, especially those in disempowered positions.”
Every High School Theology Program director recognizes his or her own program in these descriptors. As it turns out, intellectual communities are as powerful for teenagers learning to reflect theologically on their faith as they are for doctoral students studying neuroscience. Engaging youth in a dialogic pedagogy of both theological reflection and experiential engagement in faith practices effectively helps them become Christian disciples for the long haul. Unfortunately, theological reflection on the Bible and on the teaching and practices of faith is an element frequently missing from adolescent catechetical efforts. This lack stymies the development of durable, “sticky” faith among adolescents.
A key lesson of the HSTPs is this: a holistic pedagogy that blends intellectual engagement with experiential learning improves the chances that young people’s faith will grow with them. In other words, as youth engage in a variety of Christian practices and participate in theological reflection on those practices through the resources of Christian tradition, they experience faith as intellectually substantive and practically demanding. Asking youth to intellectually reflect on the texts, traditions, and practices of Christian faith, while simultaneously immersing them in the doing of such Christian practices, is a combustible combination, igniting teenagers’ desire to live as Christian disciples and equipping them for long-term faith.
In this chapter I will first present research data that suggest the positive impact of one High School Theology Program on participants’ attitudes and vocational trajectories. I will then suggest that the HSTPs offer a third way between two previous models of religious education. This third way is a dialogical, praxis-oriented pedagogy that fuels faith over the long haul. Focusing on the intellectual engagement of young people in theological reflection, I will ground the pedagogical approach of the HSTPs in the doctrine of Holy Mystery and in Bernard Lonergan’s concept of “intellectual conversion.” I will end with several implications for the church and theological education.
Research Data: The Impact of One High School Theology Program
At the program I direct, the Youth in Theology and Ministry program at St. John’s University, we conduct ongoing research on the impact of our curriculum on participants. Initial findings were published in the journal Religious Education in 2011. The study conducted extensive telephone interviews with youth who completed the YTM curriculum between 2000 and 2004 (N=105) and gives a representative sample of this population (N=67). At the time of the survey, two-thirds were twenty-one years of age or older. It is not surprising that the faith of YTM alumni had durability; even though High School Theology Program participants tend to name these programs as decisive in their vocational trajectories, the influence of families and local parishes who send teenagers to such programs clearly factors into faith longevity. Predictably, in our research, those who completed the YTM program continued to be engaged Christian disciples as young adults:
However, the research interview also asked participants to reflect specifically on the influence of the Youth in Theology and Ministry curriculum. The data suggested the following:
Such measures, while subjective, suggest that the program forms habits that in turn nurture long-term faith.
It is admittedly the case that students self-select into programs like Youth in Theology and Ministry and are thus be more likely than the general population to continue engaging in Christian practices or to pursue theological education. Yet a second study conducted at YTM showed that the program appears to affect a variety of participants’ attitudes. All participants took a pre-test before they started the YTM program, and this same instrument was used as a post-test at the end of YTM’s thirteen-month program. The following data represent four cohorts of youth (N=88) who started YTM in 2008-2011 and completed YTM in 2009-2012 respectively.
The most significant findings in this study are the changes that occurred in considering theological study in college and in reading theology books. The movement from 25 percent (pre-test) to 67 percent (post-test) for considering theological study in college, and the movement from 12 percent to 41 percent for reading theology books, suggests that YTM’s holistic pedagogy of theological reflection is effectively fostering greater interest in and excitement for theological learning. Likewise, the data related to experiencing a call to follow in the footsteps of Christ and his ways (from half to nearly three-fourths of the youth) suggest that YTM provides space for youth to consider responding to God’s call to discipleship. Given these data, it is worth exploring what YTM and other HSTPs are doing that so powerfully affects young people’s habits, attitudes, and vocational trajectories.
Pre-Test
Agree %
Post Test
Agree %
I have experienced a call to follow in the footsteps of Christ and his ways.
49%
73%
I am considering theological study in college.
25%
67%
I am considering priesthood or religious life.
48%
78%
I am considering working for the church in some capacity.
84%
91%
I read theology books.
12%
41%
Extremely Committed
Extremely
Committed
How committed are you to the Catholic Church?
22%
38%
Extremely
Important
Extremely
Important
How important or unimportant is religious faith in shaping your major life decisions?
41%
57%
High School Theology Programs: A Third Way
The pedagogical approaches of the HSTPs, when placed in historical context, can be seen as a third way between two previous approaches — a schooling paradigm and a relational, experiential paradigm. The last fifty years saw a dramatic shift away from the schooling paradigm that once dominated biblical and doctrinal education, in which faith formation depended on memorizing the catechism or reciting Bible passages. Religious educators and youth ministry leaders contended that this school paradigm of formation, separated as it was from a total ecology of faith formation and from relationships, failed to foster Christian discipleship.
In the 1960s, youth ministry started taking faith formation outside of the classroom, providing space for young people to encounter Jesus Christ and experience a sense of belonging. These efforts often isolated youth from the multi-generational church community, but youth ministry practitioners argued that experiences of communion with Christ and a small community would place youth on a trajectory of lifelong Christian discipleship. Youth ministry leaders developed skills for evangelizing youth with the good news of Jesus Christ, using retreats, service and mission trips, and worship experiences to help young people encounter God. As the pedagogical pendulum swung, the intellectual content of Christianity became secondary to fostering personal experiences and communicating moral content. Yet as with all pendulum swings, a loss occurred. Like the seed that falls on rocky soil and sprouts quickly only to fade in the heat of the sun (Matt. 13:5-6), many young people with initial conversion experiences felt their faith life wither without the good soil of theological reflection.
Current research suggests that the church is still failing in its responsibility to sustain young Christian disciples. The “sticky faith” research of Kara Powell and Brad Griffin at the Fuller Youth Institute suggests that 40 to 50 percent of the youth engaged in youth ministry programs drift away from their faith once they go to college or leave home. Further, the National Study of Youth and Religion (the largest study ever done on the religiosity of youth and their parents) showed that youth are basically illiterate about religion.
In response to these data, the Catholic bishops in the United States have initiated a push for doctrinal literacy for all adolescent religion curricula in parishes and in Catholic schools, and Protestant leaders have called for a stronger emphasis on biblical literacy. A consensus is growing across denominations that intellectual engagement of the Christian tradition, its texts, and doctrines needs renewed attention. Yet it is clearly not enough simply to swing back to the old catechetical model, forgetting the lessons of youth ministry in the last fifty years.
For twenty years the youth theology programs have offered a third way, drawing on the best of the two previous pedagogical models. Unlike in the 1950s, when religious educators used biblical and doctrinal instruction nearly exclusively for cognitive learning, or more recent youth ministry approaches that have relied on experiential teaching, the theological programs for high school youth do both. They introduce youth to the texts and resources of the Christian tradition, involve them in practices of service, justice, community, worship, and vocational discernment, and challenge them to reflect theologically on those practices.
For example, in our program at St. John’s University, young people study theology together in the morning, are engaged in community service in the afternoon, and experience a variety of Christian prayer forms in the evening. At the end of each day, counselors engage youth in theological reflection to help them connect the dots, appropriate faith, and discern their call to discipleship. Such an approach can effectively sustain Christian discipleship because it helps young people integrate affective, cognitive, and behavior dimensions of Christian faith as they begin to make personal commitments to live out their lives as disciples of Christ.
Key to this approach is the retrieval of intellectual aspects of faith formation through theological instruction and reflection. Many of the High School Theology Programs offer courses taught by seminary professors, who endeavor to promote biblical and doctrinal literacy. At YTM, for example, young people experience twenty hours of classroom theological instruction by seminary professors. Most of the youth come to these programs from parishes where young people have been instructed by dedicated volunteer religion teachers who have little theological training. While students are generally appreciative of their teachers at home, they express eager enthusiasm for studying with knowledgeable, professional theologians. The six courses offered at YTM in the summer of 2013 included:
In addition to their hours of classroom time, YTM participants read the Bible, biblical commentaries, and theological texts designed to connect with their interests and with the content of the whole program. In 2013, those texts were Parker Palmer’s Let Your Life Speak; The Rule of St. Benedict; Michael J. Himes’s Doing the Truth in Love: Conversations about God; Vincent Smiles’s The Bible and Science: Longing for God in a Science-Dominated World; Joan Chittister’s The Cry of the Prophet: A Call to the Fullness of Life; and Michael Casey’s Strangers to the City.
Contrary to the stereotype that paints all high school youth as disengaged or superficial, the youth in HSTPs embrace substantive theological reading, and often express happy surprise that compelling theological readings exist at all. As Kenda Creasy Dean mentioned in the introduction to this volume, young people in HSTPs frequently mention how much they appreciate “being taken seriously” enough to be challenged with deep theological reading. A student attending Calvin Seminary’s HSTP explained:
Before we came, we had to read some books. Everyone had four books to read, and each excursion site had a specific one that helped you. I have never been more inspired or more excited than I have been reading those books.
Youth at YTM also engage in fifteen hours of theological reflection. Each evening they meet in small covenant groups for an hour or more, where they and a counselor engage in theological reflection integrating the day’s theology classes, service, and prayer. The classes, readings, and small groups combine to create a stimulating intellectual environment for theological exploration — often a first for our church-going participants. Participants across programs express how good it feels to be taken seriously and challenged intellectually in the context of faith formation. Many lament that they have never been asked to think seriously about what they believe in their home contexts, and others complain that when they have posed hard questions at home, they have been met with resistance or with facile answers. The HSTPs can attribute much of their success to the fact that they take young people’s minds seriously, expose them to rich resources of the tradition, give them skills for interpreting and appropriating that tradition, and offer opportunities to articulate their questions and discoveries.
Yet for all their emphasis on intellectual aspects of faith formation, the High School Theology Programs also emphasize action, involving young people in practices of service, mission, worship, pilgrimage, vocational discernment, and leadership, all in the context of a supportive community. Participants do not just learn about doctrine; they reflect on its relation to lived experience as disciples. This holistic “third way,” combining instruction, practice, and theological reflection, owes much to praxis models of education. Educator and theologian Thomas Groome defines praxis learning as Christian religious education done by “a group of Christians sharing in dialogue their critical reflection on present action in light of the Christian Story and its Vision toward the end of lived Christian faith.” For Groome, praxis learning includes both knowing and being — knowing the Christian faith and being a Christian disciple.
A story from the Youth in Theology and Ministry program illustrates the ways in which instruction, service, worship, and theological reflection are interwoven in the YTM community. In 2013, the summer theme was Eucharist, which youth studied in a number of ways. Each morning theologians gave a plenary presentation on a theological theme related to the Eucharist (covenant, real presence, body of Christ, communion, paschal mystery, justice, reconciliation, and Sabbath). Youth also took morning theology classes. One of the classes offered was entitled “Hidden Treasure in the Covenants of God.” This class met for ninety minutes each day for ten days and explored the covenants in the Old Testament and the new covenant instituted by Christ at the Last Supper, thus connecting students to the theme of Eucharist. Youth read, reflected on, and discussed scriptural and theological texts related to Eucharist.
Our engagement with Eucharist did not stop with such intellectual engagement. Two YTM counselors, Jennifer Line and Alyssa Terry, both theology majors at the College of Saint Benedict, created a session focused on paschal mystery. They started the session with personal testimonies about their experiences of the paschal mystery and then invited the youth into the following prayer experience, which had been created by one their theology professors, Sister Mary Forman, OSB. During the prayer, Jennifer and Alyssa gave each youth a small cup filled with a little wine. The meditation on the wine invited the youth to reflect on their personal suffering, the suffering of the world, and on Christ’s suffering. Some youth reflected on the suffering they had recently become acquainted with through their service sites. Toward the end of the prayer, Jennifer and Alyssa asked the youth to imagine uniting their suffering with the suffering of Christ. They invited each person to come to the front of the room and pour their wine into a common carafe, which represented communion with each other and Christ. At the end of the prayer, Jennifer and Alyssa explained that this carafe of wine would be consecrated at the next day’s Eucharist.
Abbot John Klassen, OSB, presided at this Eucharist for the YTM community. Young people brought the bread and the wine to the table as offerings. Abbot John received these gifts and then consecrated the wine by saying the words of Christ:
Take this, all of you, and drink from it, for this is the chalice of my blood, the blood of the new and eternal covenant, which will be poured out for you and for many for the forgiveness of sins. Do this in memory of me.
Because the youth had already reflected on Eucharist, covenant, and suffering, these words of consecration suddenly took on new meaning. Adult counselors noticed that students’ faces during the words of consecration radiated new understanding. The transformation at that moment was palpable. That night small groups spent an hour reflecting on the day. As the youth talked, they discussed the Mass, their new understanding of it, their personal experiences of suffering, and, crucially, the experiences of suffering they were seeing at their service sites. This story is just one example of how HSTPs engage young people’s intellects with the doctrines and Scriptures of the Christian tradition, while interweaving these reflections into young people’s service in the world, worship in community, and theological reflection on experience. This is the transformative power of praxis education at work.
Theological Grounding: Holy Mystery and Intellectual Conversion
The connection between students’ reflective capacities and the lifelong nurture of faith is theological — it has everything to do with who God is, and who God calls us to become as we encounter God. In Catholic tradition, the human-divine encounter is often framed in terms of Holy Mystery. At YTM, we introduce youth to the concept and experience of Holy Mystery using Isaiah 55 as a grounding text:
For my thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are your ways my ways, says the Lord. For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways and my thoughts than your thoughts (Isa. 55:8-9).
For us, Holy Mystery provides a theological foundation for a pedagogy that sustains Christian discipleship because it envisions a God who invites us to seek and know more of the divine life. Ironically, it is the mystery of God that makes faith knowable in the first place, as God invites us to participate in the divine life.
Holy Mystery: The God Who Invites Us to Know More
The term “mystery” has been applied to many of the central doctrines of Christianity such as the Trinity, paschal mystery, and incarnation. Theologically, mystery includes the common notion of “something that is hidden or something that is beyond the grasp.” The Catechism of the Catholic Church explains, “The Trinity is a mystery of faith in the strict sense, one of the ‘mysteries that are hidden in God, which can never be known unless they are revealed by God.’ ” More importantly, mystery connotes layers of meaning to be discovered about God and God’s activity. Even as we can never know all of a mystery, God becomes “infinitely knowable” through a lifetime of prayer, reflection, and action.
Augustine, Aquinas, and the twentieth-century theologian Karl Rahner all write about God as Holy Mystery, reminding us that human knowledge and human articulation can never exhaust or completely grasp the totality of God or of human beings. Yet the limits of human thought and language do not prevent us from exploration; mystery, properly construed, should not shut down questions but invite them. Thus Pope Paul VI said in his opening allocution at the second session in 1963, “The Church is a mystery. It is a reality imbued with the hidden presence of God. It lies, therefore, within the very nature of the Church to be always open to new and greater exploration.”
As a theological construct, Holy Mystery conveys revelation as ongoing. Holy Mystery calls us to discern the movement of the Holy Spirit for our time, and thus provides a theological framework for lifelong learning about God that invites exploration, leading us into the “infinitely knowable.” It further grounds a dialogical pedagogy because it opens space for exploration, conversation, questioning, and appropriation. A Latina teenager from YTM noted how this open space enabled her own faith exploration:
During faith formation (in the parish), you’re getting ready to be confirmed, or faith formation you’ve taken all your life — you know catechism and stuff — and they . . . kind of tell you what you are supposed to believe in. We were talking about this in my class [with] Professor Bernie Evans, and he was telling us that theology differs from this. Because theology studies the Bible and studies God and asks how we can apply it for today. So it’s very open-ended. Like I say, at YTM they don’t tell you what to believe in. . . . They raise a lot of questions out of you. You choose what you believe . . . [you] have that freedom.
Such freedom is a sign of respect for young people’s abilities. Youth appreciate being invited to pursue Holy Mystery as theologians in their own right.
Unfortunately, as this young woman suggests, congregations rarely employ Holy Mystery as a foundational theological principle. In the Catholic church, the emphasis on doctrinal literacy for youth often gives the impression that revelation is closed and faith formation is simply about memorizing what has already been revealed. This static perspective on literacy promotes indoctrination in its worst forms and denies a dynamic process of discipleship.
In the Catholic world, the Baltimore Catechism was used as the primary catechetical text from 1885 to 1960. Ask ten elderly Catholics to answer question six from this catechism (“Why did God make you?”), and you will nearly universally receive the prescribed response: “God made me to know Him, to love Him, and to serve Him in this world, and to be happy with Him forever in heaven.” Ask ten Catholic youth today this question, and you will most likely receive ten different responses, many of which are superficial or decidedly at odds with Catholic teaching. This jarring reality has caused some within the Church to go back to a 1950s style of catechesis. But such retrenchment relies on an overly simplistic understanding of literacy as the ability to produce memorized answers to basic questions.
In its work in the developing world, the United Nations has developed a helpful definition of literacy that goes far beyond the concept of simple memorization and repetition:
[Literacy is] the ability to identify, understand, interpret, create, communicate and compute, using printed and written materials associated with varying contexts. Literacy involves a continuum of learning in enabling individuals to achieve their goals, to develop their knowledge and potential, and to participate fully in their community and wider society.
If we follow the U.N.’s definition of literacy, being literate about the Bible or about Christianity does not mean simply knowing the contents of memorized Bible passages and catechisms. Rather, the kind of literacy we seek is a set of skills and abilities that includes interpretation and invites people into participation in Christian discipleship and community.
The idea that literacy involves a continuum of learning so that people can “participate fully in their community and wider society” provides a bridge between the theological concept of Holy Mystery and the goal of sustaining Christian discipleship. God, who is mystery, invites us into exploration, driven by authentic questions and the delight of finding rich answers that raise yet more questions. Being literate means being equipped with the necessary knowledge and skills to explore Holy Mystery. As we encourage young people to seek Holy Mystery, we teach them skills for exploration so that they can learn, understand, act upon their learning, and participate in the Christian community.
Intellectual Conversion: Asking Our Way into Discipleship
Even though raising questions is a crucial and ongoing part of seeking Holy Mystery, the High School Theology Programs do not end with questions. Rather, they seek to foster what Bernard Lonergan refers to as “intellectual conversion” that has its ultimate goal in communion with God. In Method in Theology (1972), Lonergan describes three different types of conversion: intellectual, moral, and religious. He explains that common to all three types of conversion is a shift away from what is inauthentic in life toward new meaning and a commitment to a distinct way of living in the world. Lonergan argues that Christ’s love is at the center of this shift from self-absorption or self-enclosure to self-transcendence. Robert Doran (2011) explains:
What Lonergan calls religious conversion, then, is a process that frees one from the self-enclosure that Lonergan calls radical lovelessness. God is love, our scriptures tell us, and whoever abides in love abides in God, whether one acknowledges this or not. This process, more often than not, is mediated by participation in some religious community.
For Lonergan, authentic humanness occurs through an ongoing dialogical movement away from lovelessness and self-absorption toward the radical love of Jesus Christ and self-transcendence. In this conversion process, the intellect (not only the emotions or heart) must be converted, because radical lovelessness distorts the horizon of one’s intellectual interest and concerns, significantly limiting the range of questions one is even interested in asking. Doran adds,
Intellectual conversion in its basic form will open that horizon of questions. It will transform one’s cognitional life so that questions regarding meaning and truth are pursued for their own sake, and not for utilitarian and narrowly pragmatic purposes.
Doran emphasizes that for Lonergan, intellectual conversion demands raising and answering questions. If young people are to experience intellectual conversion, they must be encouraged to ask questions — an insight shared by every High School Theology Program. A female participant from Leadership Now, the youth theology program at Lancaster Theological Seminary, remarked on how affirming it was to ask her own questions:
Well, they make us feel very welcomed . . . [we] can ask any questions we want. They want our opinions on it too. So they are not just trying to teach us, “this is the right way,” and “that is right.” They want to know how we look at it from our point of view too. . . . Sometimes when you’re in your teens, I feel like you’re in between [being] the kid and adult, and you’re not really sure where you fit, and some people still treat you like a kid, but here we’re [treated] like full-on adults.
Her comments point to what happens when teachers respect high school youth and give them freedom to think carefully about Christian faith.
Lonergan’s emphasis on questions finds further support in transformational learning theory. Peter Block argues that transformational learning happens when teachers ask students real questions rather than providing the answers. Block notes that certain kinds of questions have greater impact:
Conversations that evoke accountability and commitment can best be produced through deciding to value questions more than answers, by choosing to put as much thought into questions as we have traditionally given to answers. . . . Questions that have the power to make a difference are ones that engage people in an intimate way, confront them with their freedom, and invite them to co-create a future possibility.
Just as the HSTPs let young people ask their own questions, they also consistently ask deep questions in order to foster intellectual conversion. One young man who attended the Perkins Youth School of Theology at Southern Methodist University remarked on the power of being questioned:
Well, the main thing they did in class is that they gave us a case study. They gave us a situation in the church and asked us how our theology looked behind it and how we would face the situation ourselves. I went through the entire [case study] and said what I thought should be done. My response was challenged by my instructor. He wondered why I did that. He never said that I was wrong, but he gave me a different standpoint and asked how I felt about this, and I would say [whether] I agreed or disagreed. He asked me why and I gave him my reasons. It wasn’t more of an argument, not even a debate, but more of a dialogue. I’ve never seen that before. I’ve never been able to contest a teacher’s point before, so the moment I did that I felt so, like, enriched. It was the most awesome feeling ever. Back where I live it’s the teacher who’s right, so make sure you agree with the teacher or you’ll be wrong. Here, it’s [that] the teacher has an opinion and you do too, so try to contest with them. Try to dialogue, try to debate why. They will listen to you. They will seriously give you consideration.
As this young man tells it, the professor who asked hard questions created a dialogue that enriched students and gave them permission to entertain new possibilities.
Listening to and asking questions have become the hallmark of the High School Theology Programs’ approach to theological reflection. While all HSTPs take young people’s questions seriously, some base their entire curriculum on a series of questions. The Compass program, for instance, sponsored by Gordon-Conwell Seminary, is based on the following six questions:
Yet unlike a catechism that envisions only one correct answer to each of these questions, Compass engages young people in exploratory conversations about these questions, even as leaders unpack various ways Christian tradition has answered them.
Gordon-Conwell and others have developed pedagogies of questions in order to help young people more deeply engage Christian tradition. High School Theology Programs encourage young people to root their responses to such questions in biblical and doctrinal teaching, while also making space for teenagers to develop their own questions in an unfolding process of intellectual conversion. Unlike the Baltimore Catechism that provided both the question and the answer, potentially stifling questions of great personal interest, the pedagogy of questions common in HSTPs opens up new horizons of thinking and believing. A pedagogy of real questions ultimately raises excitement for learning about God, because young people engage directly with the Holy Mystery of God. Furthermore, by immersing young people in an ordered process of discovery, these programs equip teenagers with tools that allow them to continue this reflective process when they return home. The HSTPs have seen that pedagogies of theological reflection — undertaken in supportive Christian communities where people are willing to risk asking and entertaining hard questions — create a foundation for theological literacy, and equip students to pursue Holy Mystery for life.
Implications for Forming Christian Leaders
For the last twenty years, the High School Theology Programs have experimented with pedagogies that foster excitement for theological learning and encourage young people to consider vocations in church ministry. Much evidence suggests that emphasizing theological reflection on both historic Christian tradition and present Christian action contributes to long-term discipleship. The experiment on holistic theological education at YTM and other HSTPs offers a number of implications for the church, for seminaries and schools of theology, and for anyone concerned with preparing leaders for the future church.
Congregations
Since the long-term vitality of Christianity is dependent on fostering and sustaining Christian disciples, congregations may find inspiration from how the HSTPs help young people engage faith intellectually. First, churches might embrace Holy Mystery as a theological framework that invites youth to meet God and grow in faith, prompting churches to open space for dialogue as youth and adults alike pursue answers to fresh questions. Second, Holy Mystery releases churches from indoctrination, providing both the questions and answers, on the one hand — just as it releases churches from feeling like they must manipulate youth by provoking an emotional or spiritual “conversion” experience for them. Instead congregations can combine action and reflection, offering teenagers experiences of service, worship, and learning in the midst of a practicing faith community, and work intentionally to connect these experiences to the tradition of faith. In so doing, they create meaningful opportunities for theological reflection with both young people and adults. Third, congregations can help youth engage the Christian tradition intellectually by giving them opportunity to talk with pastors and trained theologians, by helping them find theological resources they may not know exist, by opening space for their questions, and by taking their ideas seriously.
Seminaries, too, may find the HSTPs’ approach to teaching theology helpful. For one thing, intellectual conversion is one of the primary tasks of theological education. Nurturing intellectual communities that provoke and support shifts toward new meanings, and that evoke commitment to a way of life that embodies these new meanings, is the crucial work of the theological educator (and anyone concerned with the church’s intellectual, as well as moral and religious, leadership).
Furthermore, seminaries might take note of pedagogical models in the High School Theology Programs that seem to assist in such intellectual conversions. Most HSTPs rely on seminarians and seminary professors as adult leaders, and in the process train them to become holistic educators in their own right. Seminaries and theological schools that use the HSTPs as laboratories for training leaders and teachers will find that these programs tend to expand their pedagogical comfort zones, as they become familiar with action-reflection models of learning that foster and sustain Christian discipleship. Seminaries might consider how their own curriculum forms future church leaders by their pedagogical approaches to teaching theology: Do we teach theological reflection and foster theological literacy by immersing seminary students in holistic educational environments that integrate worship, service, and learning? Or do we teach theology with “talking heads”? Since people tend to teach as they were taught, seminaries that adopt praxis-oriented holistic pedagogies have potential to change the church, and in so doing, improve the durability of faith in the pews.
We hear much about how young people are leaving the church. But a great many of the youth who attend the High School Theology Programs want to “stay a little bit longer.” They have experienced a Christian community committed to Christ’s mission. In that supportive context, holistic pedagogies of theological reflection have integrated prayer, community, service, justice, and vocational discernment into the intellectual communities that form the backbone of the HSTPs. Like the disciples on the mount of Transfiguration, youth in these theology programs want to stay connected to the glory of Christ. But like Jesus’ disciples, they are called to travel down the mountaintop to join in God’s Holy Mystery as it is revealed in ministries that involve youth in healing, teaching, and preaching. Now, after twenty years of experimentation, the HSTPs are still discovering the long-term benefits of holistic theological reflection, as young people continue their journey as disciples of Jesus Christ — and their affinity for theological inquiry — years after their summer in a High School Theology Program. These programs have concocted a powerfully combustible mix of theological instruction, action in the world, and theological reflection on texts, traditions, and experience — fuel for faith over the long haul.
. Cf. George Walker et al., The Formation of Scholars: Rethinking Doctoral Education in the Twenty-First Century (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2008), pp. 120, 122.
. Sticky Faith research had been conducted by the Fuller Youth Ministry Institute. See Kara E. Powell and Chap Clark, Sticky Faith: Everyday Ideas to Build Lasting Faith in Your Kids (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2011).
. Jeffrey Kaster, “Evaluating Adolescent Catechesis,” Religious Education 106, no. 1 (2011): 63-81.
. See especially John H. Westerhoff III, Will Our Children Have Faith? Revised ed. (Toronto: Morehouse Publishing, 2000). In the first edition of this book, published in 1976, Westerhoff strongly criticized the schooling paradigm.
. In OMG: A Youth Ministry Handbook, the authors note: “In 1980, sociologist Dean Hoge and his colleagues demonstrated a dramatic shift away from theological formation in youth ministries. Hoge’s team compared the top outcomes sought by youth ministry in six denominations before and after 1980 (figure 4.1). While youth ministry before 1980 placed a high priority on engaging young people in faith-shaping spiritual practices, after 1980 spiritual formation become nearly invisible in youth ministry’s priorities. By 1991, a Carnegie Council on Adolescent Development study found that the largest religious denominations and communities in the U.S. (Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish) shared two parallel goals in religious youth work: fostering faith identity (or sense of belonging in a faith community), and providing young people with safe passage into adulthood.” See Dean R. Hoge et al., “Desired Outcomes of Religious Education and Youth Ministry in Six Denominations,” Review of Religious Research 23 (March 1982): 230-54; and K. C. Dean, “A Review of Literature on Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish Religious Youth Organizations in the U.S.,” white paper (Washington, DC: Carnegie Council on Adolescent Development), 1991. See Kenda Creasy Dean et al., OMG: A Youth Ministry Handbook (Nashville, TN: Abingdon, 2010), p. 64.
. Kara Powell and Brad M. Griffin, “Sticky Faith Cliff Notes 15-Minute Podcast,” Sticky Faith by the Fuller Youth Institute. Cited at http://stickyfaith.org/podcasts/player/sticky-faith-cliff-notes on October 3, 2013.
. Christian Smith and Melinda Lundquist Denton, Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005), p. 262.
. Thomas H. Groome, Christian Religious Education: Sharing Our Story and Vision (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1980), p. 184.
. Catholic Church, Catechism of the Catholic Church (Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 2000), p. 237.
. Catholic Church, Catechism, p. 237.
. Karl Rahner, Foundations of Christian Faith: An Introduction to the Idea of Christianity (New York: Seabury Press, 1978). See part V for a theology of “Holy Mystery.”
. Pope Paul VI, found in Vatican Council, and Walter M. Abbott, The Documents of Vatican II (New York: Guild Press, 1966), p. 15.
. My thanks to Christy Lang Hearlson for bringing this definition of literacy to my attention. Her doctoral work suggests its potential fruitfulness for efforts in the Christian church at increasing religious and biblical literacy.
. “The Plurality of Literacy and Its Implications for Policies and Programs,” UNESCO Education Sector Position Paper (2004): 13.
. Bernard J. F. Lonergan, S.J., Method in Theology (New York: Herder and Herder, 1972), pp. 238-42.
. Robert Doran, “What Does Bernard Lonergan Mean by ‘Conversion?’ ” (lecture delivered at University of St. Michael’s College, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, July 15, 2011), p. 7.
. Doran, “What Does Bernard,” p. 8.
. Peter Block, Community: The Structure of Belonging (San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler, 2008), pp. 103-5.
