Chapter 5 Is the Gospel about Personal Salvation or Social Reform?
“We need to study and be formed into a profound relationship with God in order to know his character—and when we know his character, we will know that he grieves over the widow, the oppressed, the suffering.”
Richard J. Mouw, “Educating for Justice,” September 27, 2006, Opening Convocation address, Fuller Theological Seminary
NOW? (DISCERNMENT)
As youth workers, we Now have a reputation for going to extraordinary lengths to help students in their faith journeys. One spring, following a powerful weekend camp experience during which lots of kids expressed a desire to follow Christ, I let out all the stops.
Although neither my wife nor my son had ever seen me without a mustache, I decided that during my message at our next group meeting, I was going to shave off my mustache as an illustration of committed faith.
As I talked about our great weekend together, I subtly began to prepare my shaving gear on a small table at the front of the room. As I described the emotions of that Sunday morning at camp, when so many made a public decision to live for Jesus Christ, I started dabbing shaving cream on one side of my mustache.
Kids finally caught on to what I was about to do. The girls started yelling, “No, no!” while the guys screamed, “Go for it!”
Just before I made that first cut, I told them, “Saying you want to belong to Christ but not actually following him is like walking around with only one half of a mustache…” And then I shaved off one half of my own mustache, and left it that way for the rest of my talk.
Yet I have to admit, for years I had been guilty of half-mustache youth ministry. I often told students God’s main concern was our response to his love, and then I would focus all I said and most of what I did on that single message. Later, under the rubric of “discipleship,” I would try to convince those same kids that following Christ also meant serving our broken world by addressing the needs and hardships of others. But in the way I prioritized my ministry emphases, I was in truth living, teaching, and leading with only half a theological mustache!
TWO EITHER/OR EXTREMES
Last summer I informally surveyed youth workers across denominations, asking them how they describe and present the call of the gospel in their ministries. Most of the youth workers I surveyed, especially when they were not prompted toward any viewpoint, tended to land squarely in one of two camps.
The majority of the youth workers I surveyed landed where I was in the early years of my ministry. Typically defining the gospel as the “invitation to accept Christ’s sacrifice on the cross,” their single-focused description was limited to an individual’s internal response to this invitation.
The other group of youth workers, smaller but no less passionate about their perspective, was equally single-focused in describing the essence of the gospel as serving others and righting wrongs in God’s name. These are two important, even vital, aspects of the gospel’s call. Yet when given an open-ended opportunity, just about every youth worker took one “side” that was explicitly opposed to the other. One group emphasized the finished work of Jesus on the cross, and the other the ongoing work of the risen Christ in bringing his kingdom to fulfillment.
“Although evangelism may never simply be equated with labor for justice, it may also never be divorced from it. The relationship between the evangelistic and the societal dimensions of the Christian mission constitutes one of the thorniest areas in the theology and practice of mission.”
DAVID BOSCH, TRANSFORMING MISSION
While the responses themselves were not all that surprising, I was struck by the extreme polarity of the two viewpoints. I was especially intrigued by the way most people seemed to go out of their way to diminish the importance of the other perspective as they defended their own. Among those who felt a personal faith decision was primary (often citing for support a passage like John 3:16, “… whoever believes in him shall not perish…”), there seemed to be a general skepticism toward emphasizing the call to service and justice.
In the same way, youth workers who experienced the gospel as God’s mandate to give our lives to serving and caring for others tended to discount those who stressed a “personal faith decision” as more concerned with self than with the kingdom of God. Typically emphasizing the teachings and example of Jesus, like in the parable of the sheep and goats (“whatever you did for the least of these…you did for me,” Matthew 25) and Jesus’ encounter with people like the Rich Young Ruler (“Go, sell all you have and give to the poor…” Mark 10:21), the call to fulfill the Great Commandment to love God, neighbor, and self (Matthew 22:34–40) took center stage.
Although both positions are solidly rooted not only in the Bible but in the instructions and life of Jesus himself, very few in my informal poll expressed any interest in trying to bring these two positions together. These results confirmed my own experience. Those youth workers who Now believe a vital personal faith in Jesus Christ is primary tend to fear that those who advocate for justice and service might “water down” the gospel. At the same time, those youth workers who are Now convinced of God’s concern for the poor and oppressed fear that those who emphasize personal piety inevitably direct others toward a faith that is self-absorbed and narcissistic. This two-way suspicion causes both sides to dig in their heels and easily fall prey to wearing only half a theological mustache.
The majority of contemporary evangelical churches and youth ministries (especially in white or middle-class contexts) Now stress a distinct personal “decision for Jesus” as the primary calling of the gospel. This focus supersedes or at least preempts an emphasis on God’s concern for the poor, marginalized, and oppressed. In some cases it is assumed that once someone “becomes a Christian,” then righting wrongs of poverty and oppression will happen as a matter of course. In other situations, because of the way political ideology has stuck its nose under the tent of the church, such social change efforts may even be viewed as something to be avoided. Critics of this emphasis observe that rarely does “personal relationship with Jesus” seem to actually translate into much (if any) commitment to the least, the last, and the lost.
In a similar way, churches and youth ministries who are driven by a commitment to address the needs of the poor and disenfranchised are Now viewed with suspicion as being disconnected from an individual alignment with the personal aspects of faith, especially in terms of lifestyle and ethics. The result is these extremes further separate the body of Christ into two camps that regularly find themselves distrustful of (and even disgusted with) each other.
NEW? (REFLECTION)
“We fall into ‘sin management’—the right focuses on individual sins and the gospel as an eraser for our individual sins. The left focuses only on social sins. We need to do both.”
DALLAS WILLARD, THE DIVINE CONSPIRACY
As much as youth workers try to separate these two definitions of the gospel, the gospel itself does not allow such division. Personal piety that does not produce a life committed to peace, justice, and mercy for all struggling people is hollow and self-serving and, as such, is not actually pious at all. At the same time, a commitment to righting wrongs that ignores the call to abandon one’s life to Jesus Christ and “fix our thoughts” on him may align itself with God’s commitment to the poor and broken but vacillate in its submission to his authority and reign as King. In other words, neither extreme taken alone represents the gospel at all. Both are inseparable emphases of the same call—to proclaim a new way of life that is fully devoted to Jesus Christ and to express that devotion by seeking justice as he advances his kingdom toward all people.
GOD RESTORES SHALOM
From the very beginning, God’s plan has been to establish his shalom (pronounced “sha-lome”) over all creation. The word shalom is commonly translated as “peace”—but that often reduces it to one of two inadequate definitions: Either we think of it as the absence of war and conflict, or we tend to view it as a sense of personal, subjective peace for us as individuals. In reality, shalom has a much wider meaning that brings New depth to our justice. Biblical shalom is far more than just a lack of fighting or a warm and fuzzy feeling
In describing shalom and its relationship to justice, Nicholas Wolterstorff, professor of philosophical theology at Yale University, writes:
The state of shalom is the state of flourishing in all dimensions of one’s existence: in one’s relation to God, in one’s relation to one’s fellow human beings, in one’s relation to nature, and in one’s relation to oneself. Evidently justice has something to do with the fact that God’s love for each and every one of God’s human creatures takes the form of God desiring the shalom of each and every one.
God’s shalom is an all-inclusive peace that encompasses our whole selves and all our relationships: with God, with self, with others, and with the world. When humanity fell, that sense of well-being was broken, leaving in its wake darkness, pain, and death. Yet despite our rebellion and the sin-filled consequences that leave the whole of creation “groaning” (Romans 8:22), God has not wavered in his commitment to restore his shalom. We know this from Jesus’ own words in Luke 4:18–19:
“The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to proclaim good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim freedom for the prisoners and recovery of sight for the blind, to set the oppressed free, to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor.”
Jesus wants all who are imprisoned and oppressed—physically, relationally, emotionally, or psychologically—to experience the freedom and release of his kingdom shalom. As the pinnacle of God’s faithfulness in the face of our lack of faith, shalom was reestablished on the cross when Jesus proclaimed, “It is finished” (John 19:30). Yet those forces and powers that oppress and beat down individuals and societies rob the possibility of shalom. The kingdom of God brings shalom as the experiential reality of being touched by the power of grace, justice, and mercy; the battle is against any system, structure or institution that makes shalom unavailable. That is the call of the kingdom—to follow the call of the Holy Spirit and fight against anything that would stand in the way of shalom for those God loves.
Jesus told his disciples, “Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of God belongs to such as these” (Mark 10:14, emphasis added). We must help our students realize that when we ignore or rationalize away the pain and needs in our families, our towns, and around the world, our inaction “hinders” the work of the Spirit in bringing shalom. The call is to do as Jesus did; to gather the children, the lonely, the sick, and the oppressed into our arms and bless them (Mark 10:16) with shalom.
RESTORING SHALOM IN OUR YOUTH MINISTRIES
The shalom that has been regained through Christ is best experienced within a community in which God’s gracious commandments are honored and obeyed. When the poor and needy are deprived of their God-given right to flourish, it is both an opportunity and a responsibility for our youth ministries to try to restore divine peace and potential. Far more than just “stuff we do to help poor people,” we can help students see justice as one of God’s—and our—means to remove the obstacles that prevent others from flourishing.
“From our covenant relationship with God to our social institutions, shalom is God putting back together a broken world…Precisely because shalom is about the world made right in holiness and truth, it cannot be detached from right relationships, but is preceded by and dependent upon justice.”
MARK R. GORNIK, TO LIVE IN PEACE
God invites the youth in our ministries to so much more than just an escape from hell, or even a sense of fulfillment now that our eternal status is settled. The in-breaking shalom of the kingdom is not just God rescuing us from our foibles and failures, or “allowing” us to make sure we are saved. The wonder of the gospel is that the shalom we receive by faith in Christ compels and empowers us to give ourselves away for the sake of the kingdom of God. E. Stanley Jones writes that the gospel “is not just the way of salvation from sin, but the Way written into our blood, tissues, relationships…We are structured for the kingdom. Jesus and the kingdom are the Way and the life and therefore the truth.”
Being true to the gospel means celebrating that God not only rescues us from sin but also creates in us a whole New kingdom-driven agenda for all of life. To come to Christ by faith means we accept not only our need for the forgiveness offered on the cross by the Incarnate Word of God, but also that we are lifted by the resurrection into a whole New purpose for life. Once we have tasted the shalom of God, we then find our calling in serving Jesus as he brings his shalom to the world. The gospel is about Jesus Christ and his kingdom—and we invite kids into the trajectory of kingdom service that comes as part of the package of salvation.
To get updated on more recent research about evangelism and justice, check out our free additional Deep Justice resources available at www.cyfm.net
A DEEP SENSE OF RIGHTEOUSNESS
Just as students’ interest in kingdom justice will be increased by a deeper understanding of the power of shalom, the same is true with a deeper understanding of the word dikaiosune (pronounced “dih-ky-ohsue-nay”). In general, this Greek word used in both the gospels and the epistles is translated “righteousness.” While that is an accurate translation, it’s not the full story. Dikaiosune also means God’s just rule—or God’s justice.
Let’s look at a few of the more well-known verses that include the word dikaiosune in light of this expanded, or secondary, meaning. For instance, Jesus teaches, “Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for dikaiosune, for they will be filled” (Matthew 5:6) and “But seek first his kingdom and his dikaiosune, and all these things will be given to you as well” (Matthew 6:33).
When we insert the word righteousness for dikaiosune in these two passages, our North American minds often associate it with an individualistic form of “right living” that falls in line with those who equate the gospel with personal salvation. As long as our students do not “smoke, drink, chew, or go with those who do,” they’re honoring Jesus’ intention.
What happens when we insert the word justice for dikaiosune? Suddenly, our minds jump to a New form of “right living” that is much more holistic. We seek to build youth ministries that hunger and thirst to extend God’s kingdom to meet others’ spiritual, emotional, social, and physical needs. Indeed, that type of New Testament dikaiosune echoes the Old Testament shalom that allows all to experience the kingdom in its fullness.
“Salvation must…be understood as shalom in the Old Testament sense. This does not mean merely salvation of the soul, individual rescue from the evil world, comfort for the troubled conscience, but also the realization of the eschatological hope of justice, humanizing of man, the socializing of humanity, peace for all creation.”
JÜRGEN MOLTMANN, THEOLOGY OF HOPE
APPROPRIATING THE NEW: MAKING CHRIST’S MISSION OUR MISSION
Certainly there are countless self-described “Christians” who are more interested in the warm and fuzzy shalom and the moralistic dikaiosune than God’s call to be ambassadors of peace, justice, and mercy. The folly is that this kind of self-centered “faith” is really not faith at all.
“A fascinating feature of Matthew’s summary of Jesus’ ministry is not only that it confirms that Jesus’ evangelization was centered in ‘the good news of the kingdom,’ but that it describes Jesus’ holistic method: teaching, preaching, and healing. The good news of the kingdom is for the whole person—physically (healing), intellectually (teaching), and spiritually (preaching).”
MORTIMER ARIAS, THE GOOD NEWS OF THE KINGDOM
But what about those who do care, those who are sincere in their desire to follow Jesus Christ? How do they take seriously the compelling call of the gospel that reflects a New self-sacrificing commitment to take on poverty and oppression in our broken world? The answer lies in our ability and commitment to translate our devotion to God into service and justice. We must broaden our perspective and understanding of what it means to follow Jesus to include every aspect of our lives so we are transformed into living a kingdom agenda that is reflected in a sacrificial kingdom lifestyle.
In our youth ministries, it is our responsibility as leaders to present the entire gospel—both personal commitment and social reform—in everything we say, do, and teach. We must help people to follow Jesus as he brings the kingdom to fulfillment. As Ruth Padilla DeBorst writes:
“Why, we asked, need each of us grapple with such issues as injustice, poverty, and hunger? Because God does. Acts of justice spring out of his heart of love. It must be the same with anyone who calls himself or herself God’s child. Acts of justice are expressions of true worship. They delight God.”
As men and women who have great influence in shaping the lives, faith, and theology of future generations, we must take care to let our kids know that the gospel is both repentance and social justice, not either/or. As our youth ministries live and proclaim God’s shalom and dikaiosune to a world filled with racism, poverty, oppression, economic injustice, selfishness, abuse, and war, we experience transformation—both as individuals and in our social systems.
WHO? (OBSERVATION)
There are few leaders alive today Who have worked harder, longer, or more effectively to right wrongs in our broken world than DR. JOHN PERKINS. John is the founder of Mendenhall Ministries, Voice of Calvary Ministries, and Harambee Christian Family Center, and the co-founder and chair of the Christian Community Development Association. An internationally known civil rights leader who has experienced racism himself as a black man in America, John has written nine books, including A Quiet Revolution, Let Justice Roll Down, and With Justice for All. As someone Who watched his brother die in his arms after being shot by a white police officer and was beaten himself and left for dead by his white Mississippi neighbors, John is a national treasure of inspiration and insight into deep justice that reconciles us both to God and to one another.
“I’ve become convinced that if the good news of Jesus were carried in a newspaper today, it wouldn’t be hidden in the religion section (although it would no doubt cause a ruckus there). It would be a major story in every section, from world news (What is the path to peace, and how are we responding to our neighbors in need?) to national and local news (How are we treating children, poor people, minorities, the last, the lost, the least? How are we treating our enemies?), the food section (Do our diets reflect concern for God’s planet and our poor neighbors, and have we invited any of them over for dinner lately?), the entertainment and sports sections (What is the point of our entertainment, and what values are we strengthening in sports?), and even the business section (Are we serving the wrong master: money rather than God?).”
BRIAN MCLAREN, THE SECRET MESSAGE OF JESUS
John, so often as youth workers, we tend to take the complexity of gospel and kingdom justice and oversimplify it. Given your decades of experience and reflection, do you think the gospel is more about individual salvation, or is it more about reforming abusive and oppressive systems, or is it equally about both?
The short answer to your question is that it’s about both. Within the evangelical community, we have created this dichotomy. Yet Jesus wants us to love God with our whole heart and soul, and as we do that, we will love others who are absolutely different from us.
The marvelous kingdom blend of commitment to both personal salvation and social reform is often easier to find in the church outside of the United States. Seek out opportunities for face-to-face or e-mail conversation with leaders from other countries to learn ways they are already embodying this Newboth/and.
What happens when youth ministries emphasize just one half of that dichotomy?
I think we are already seeing that lived out in fundamentalism on one side, and liberalism on the other. In reality, both of those two extremes—meeting spiritual needs and meeting physical needs—are two halves of the whole gospel. Jesus illustrated that whole gospel in Luke 10, the story of the Good Samaritan. When describing what love for God and neighbor looked like to the expert in the law who had questioned him, Jesus pointed to the sacrifice of the Samaritan as the model of God’s intent for how we are to treat each other. The expert thought he knew what love for God looked like, but Jesus made it clear that true love for God is expressed through the Samaritan man’s love for his neighbor.
Why are we so prone to do one half without the other?
It’s our pride. If you listen closely, folks who are “liberal” pride themselves as being better than those “conservatives,” and the “conservatives” see those “liberals” as not being quite all they need to be. Each side has this sort of imperialistic view to it, as if they are the only ones who know what’s right. I find that same dislike of the “other side” in issues about women in leadership and homosexuality. It lacks the humility that ought to accompany the gospel.
What advice would you give a youth worker who’s been emphasizing one half of the gospel but now wants to help his or her kids and ministry both love God and love others?
Fundamentally, we have to understand that all people are created in God’s image. That gives us all equal dignity before God. I don’t see how you can accept that other humans are created in God’s image with inherent dignity and then exploit them. Once we view others as created in God’s image, we won’t want them to live without him, and we won’t want them to live in unjust social structures. So we’re going to want to embody both halves of the gospel.
What should a youth ministry that wants to embody both loving God and loving others do?
To download and hear the full audio interview with John, check out our free additional Deep Justice resources available at www.fulleryouthinstitute.org/deep-justice.
We can’t do it apart from living with and interacting with people in different classes and races. Tribalism, and the sense that we are superior to one another, keeps us apart. Only people who have interactions with folks who are different from them can get rid of injustice.
Martin Luther King Jr. claimed that 11:00 on Sunday mornings was the most segregated hour of the week. Do you think that’s still true 40 years later?
It’s not as true now as it was then, but he still might be right. But I have hope for the church as I watch the students who come and visit our work in Jackson, Mississippi. They are generally middle-and upper-class students, but once they come and live among those who are oppressed, they usually find a creative way to express their sense of justice. And they are healed in the process.
When it comes to building relationships with folks who are different and understanding that we are all created in God’s image, is it more incumbent on those who are white to reach out, or equally incumbent on both whites and people of color?
On a practical level, since justice is an issue about not just race but economics, it’s more incumbent upon whites to take the first steps. But whites cannot heal themselves. They need blacks and Latinos and Asians. It would be unjust of those of us who are people of color to remove ourselves and expect whites to heal themselves. They can’t do it. So we all end up being equally responsible.
Can youth workers help their kids experience the fullness of the kingdom and its invitation to love both God and others if they aren’t doing it themselves?
That question is a lot like the question about the chicken and the egg. In an ideal world, it would be the adult leader who would be really leading. But sometimes it’s in the midst of serving with kids among the poor that adults really get transformed. When we have students and youth workers come down to Mississippi, it’s often the youth worker who’s most impacted.
John, as a black man who has been physically beaten by whites just because of your skin color, how have your personal experiences with injustice deepened your commitment to eliminate the dichotomy between loving God and loving others?
I think I’ve been blessed because, even as I began to confront racism, and racists began to confront me, I never felt inferior. The theology that lies behind the song, “Jesus loves the little children, all the children of the world. Red and yellow, black and white, all are precious in his sight” has always been a part of me. I think that’s why I do what I do.
HOW? (APPLICATION)
DEEP JUSTICE APPLICATION QUESTIONS
Do you agree that most Christians tend to view the gospel as either about personal salvation or about social reform? Why or why not?
When have you seen, felt, or experienced God’s shalom? In general, what keeps us from experiencing shalom? What does God want our youth ministries to be like and do in order to help restore shalom?
If you understand Matthew 5:6 as “Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for justice, for they will be filled,” how would that change your own life and your ministry?
Chap writes, “We must broaden our perspective and understanding of what it means to follow Jesus to include every aspect of our lives so we are transformed into living a kingdom agenda that is reflected in a sacrificial kingdom lifestyle.” As you think about the other youth workers you know, how well do they live out a kingdom agenda in every aspect of their lives? How successful are you in living out such an all-encompassing lifestyle of sacrifice?
Given the gap between our broken world and God’s shalom, restoring wholeness to all people around the world is not something any one youth ministry can accomplish. What other churches, ministries, and social service organizations can you partner with to seek God’s justice in your town, in our country, and around the world?
Of the following list of Deep Justice Recommended Action Steps that flow from this chapter, which would best help you as a kingdom follower right wrongs? How about for your youth ministry?
DEEP JUSTICE IN A BROKEN WORLD DEEP JUSTICE RECOMMENDED ACTION STEPS:
For Yourself
Think back to your first experiences in Christian community and the mentors and leaders who shaped your view of what it means to be a kingdom follower. Consider whether they leaned toward either personal salvation or social reform, and how that still influences you today.
How does the tension of the both/and gospel play out in your theology and actions? Make a two-column list of your beliefs and behaviors that lean one way or the other. How do you feel about the balance of the list? How does it fit with your understanding of the gospel?
Spend some time thinking about how your preferred version of the Jesus-of-Choice from affects your ability to view the full both/and gospel. How, if at all, are the two related? How can you gain a broader view of Jesus that would similarly broaden your view of the gospel?
For Your Youth Ministry
Ask your senior pastor to answer the question that drives this chapter: Is the gospel more about personal salvation or social reform? Think about how your pastor’s answer influences both your church and your youth ministry.
Ask your students the same question, possibly even by devoting one youth group meeting to a debate over the question. Even if students are inclined to say that it’s “both,” don’t let them take that position initially. Force them to choose either personal salvation or social reform, and let them feel the frustration that comes from such a dichotomy, before you let them assume the position that it’s both.
Look back on the last three to six months of your ministry’s calendar through the lenses of personal salvation and social reform. If you have emphasized one more than the other, identify ways you could embody a more healthy both/and kingdom balance in the next three to six months.
Bring several newspapers to one of your group’s meetings. Read the quote from Brian McLaren in the sidebar on to your students and then have them scan the newspapers, looking for ways that personal salvation and social reform are relevant to many types of newspaper stories (such as corruption in sports, shady financial decisions in business, the materialism that compels us to want expensive cars shown in newspaper ads). Brainstorm ways students can help others in the church (including their own parents) view daily living through the lenses of kingdom justice.
Send an e-mail to your students’ parents with a few paragraphs from this chapter. Encourage families to talk about how they tend to view the gospel: Is it salvation or social reform or both? Ask each family to consider making a justice covenant together, specifying the choices they are making together to right wrongs around them. You might want to give them tangible ideas ranging from baby steps of recycling glass and paper to major steps of contacting a local private school and offering an annual scholarship for a kid in need.
The next time there’s an election or political issue causing controversy in your city, talk with your students about how the gospel does (or some might say does not) relate to politics. Since the kingdom is about both evangelism and social action, encourage your students to call or write letters (perhaps along with their parents) to the relevant government officials to help change systems that perpetuate poverty.
Read about the ministry of reconciliation Paul describes in 2 Corinthians 5 and design a talk or small-group discussion about a holistic understanding of what reconciling the world to God through Christ looks like in your city. You may even want to have students talk about what their school campuses would look like if students were reconciled both to God and to one another. Brainstorm the obstacles and systems that currently prevent this type of deep reconciliation, as well as key city or school leaders who might be interested in righting the wrongs that perpetuate injustice and divisions at your students’ schools.
NOTES
Nicholas Wolterstorff, “The contours of justice: An ancient call for shalom,” in God and the Victim:Theological Reflections on Evil, Victimization, Justice, and Forgiveness, edited by Lisa Barnes Lampman and Michelle D. Shattuck (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1999), 113.
E. Stanley Jones, The Unshakable Kingdom and the Unchanging Person (Nashville: Abingdon, 1972), 52.
Ruth Padilla DeBorst, “Scrabble, Injustice, and Me,” Ibid., 13.