Chapter 19 of 26

Chapter 10 How Can Our Youth Ministries Use Their Money So the Poor Gain Power?

Chapter 10 How Can Our Youth Ministries Use Their Money So the Poor Gain Power?





NOW? (DISCERNMENT)

When it comes to the way many youth ministries use money Now, the road to shallow justice is paved with good intentions.

I know. I’ve laid some asphalt there myself.

Odds are good that you have, too.

I recently received this letter from a youth worker who realized his ministry’s money had provided only a shallow topcoat of justice:

In the last six months, Danny has become very involved in our youth ministry. He and his friends were especially active in their Tuesday evening small group. Summer camp was fast approaching, which was always a highlight for our small groups to experience together. I was confused, however, because Danny was not yet signed up for camp even though most of his friends were. I asked one of his friends what was up with Danny and camp. He said Danny’s mom had been laid off and was doing temp work, but it was not steady enough to pay all the bills. Danny was embarrassed and did not want to ask for help.

I was quick to explain to Danny that we help a lot of kids who need financial assistance by providing odd jobs to earn money for camp and that we even had some scholarships available. I wanted him to know money should not keep him from joining us for camp. As a result of that conversation, Danny was able to join us at camp, and our church even helped his mom with the money for rent one month.

But now I realize that I took the easy way out in that situation. I made quite an effort to find the resources for the rent and a camp scholarship, but truthfully, I spent fewer than five minutes thinking about how to help Danny’s mom get a steady job. I changed the short-term situation for Danny and his mom, but did nothing to help alleviate the real problem. Living justly is about using our ministry’s money to solve the deeper issues, not just the more immediate or obvious needs.

Why did I think so short term in this situation? Was I really that busy? What would have been a better use of the $1500 it took for rent and camp? What if I had used some of the money to hire someone to help her find a solid job? These questions still haunt me.

Most of us have been in the same boat. And, unfortunately, most of us probably focused on figuring out a quick and convenient way to get some money for camp without thinking about how to paddle through the ocean of injustice that caused the problem in the first place.

When it comes to using our youth ministry’s money to right wrongs, youth workers Now have a reputation for thinking short term. We buy a cheeseburger after youth group for a student whose family is short on cash, or we offer rides to a kid whose family doesn’t have a car. Cheeseburgers and car rides are not intrinsically bad. The problem is that our ministry’s money Now slaps on a short-term Band-Aid while the wound of injustice festers underneath.

Those of us who escape the pitfall of thinking short term often fall into another trap: making selfish decisions with our ministry’s financial resources. We decide to do another spring break trip to Tijuana, and we mobilize our church to help us raise money to get our kids there for a week. Since we had such a great time playing with the kids at the orphanage last year, we tell the folks there that’s what we’d like to do again. Maybe that’s what they need; but maybe it’s not. The point is we’re so busy thinking about our wants that we never ask about their needs.

A one-dollar bill met a twenty-dollar bill and said, “Hey, where have you been? I haven’t seen you around here much.” The twenty answered, “I’ve been hanging out at casinos, went on a cruise, headed back to the United States for a while, went to a couple of baseball games, to the mall—that kind of stuff. How about you?” The one-dollar bill said, “You know, same old stuff—church, church, church.”

Or maybe a few kids in your youth ministry ask if your group could sponsor a child overseas, sending $20–30 per month so she can receive food, clothing, and education, as well as hear about the good news of Jesus Christ. You go online with your kids—but instead of reading the fine print of various international organizations’ Web sites to see how they partner with local churches, and ways they support not just that kid but that entire kid’s family, you and your students simply pick the girl who looks the “cutest.”

The good news is that you can Now hang a picture of your “cute” adopted girl on your youth group wall, and that kid will receive spiritual and practical help. The not-so-good news is that you may never know if your youth ministry’s money is really giving her—and her family—the tools to escape poverty and oppression for the long haul, or simply offering some solace from the wrongs of poverty and oppression for a few hours each day while she’s at school.

When it comes to using our youth ministry’s money for justice Now, such approaches—though they may be short term or self-centered—are probably better than doing nothing. But they don’t give the poor what they really need: a base of power and resources that catapults them forward long term.

It’s time for our youth ministries to move beyond service that does little more than make us feel good…

It’s time for us to skip past stop-gap solutions that last a few weeks or months at most…

It’s time to do the deep work of pouring our ministries’ financial resources into kingdom justice that gives power to the poor.

NEW? (REFLECTION)

WHO OWNS THE POND?

In my observation, part of the reason some kingdom followers feel reluctant to use their resources to give New power to the poor is because they think a commitment to empowering the poor means endorsing an anything-goes approach to social change that may include bloodshed and violence. But that’s not the kind of power we’re talking about.

The kingdom power we’re talking about is exemplified by a New power twist that Dr. John Perkins (the subject of our Who interview in

) brings to a familiar justice narrative. According to Dr. Perkins, “Some people say ‘give a person a fish and he will eat for a day, but teach a person how to fish and she will eat for a lifetime.’ Baloney! The crucial question is, Who owns the pond?”

“Power as understood in the kingdom of God will reverse the so-called natural order and the popular understanding of power.”

JAYAKUMAR CHRISTIAN, GOD OF THE EMPTYHANDED

The question, Who owns the pond? takes us beyond selfish or short-term responses and forces us to ask deeper questions about the unfair power structures that perpetuate our world’s brokenness. If you want to expand the focus of your ministry’s giving and advocacy to who owns the pond, you need to lead your students through two New shifts—one shift in your theology and one shift in your view of power.

NEW SHIFT 1: JESUS IS NOT WITH THE POOR

What? Jesus is not with the poor? Is that a typo? Well, it’s more of a trick statement.

In a sense, Jesus is with the poor. But he’s more than just with the poor. His image—the image of God—is in the poor.

We know this from Jesus’ parable of the sheep and the goats in Matthew 25:31–40. We’ve already looked once at this parable in

to better understand the kingdom story of Good/Guilt/Grace/Gratitude, but it’s so important to the way our ministry handles our money that we need to look at it again:

“When the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all the angels with him, he will sit on his glorious throne. All the nations will be gathered before him, and he will separate the people one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats. He will put the sheep on his right and the goats on his left.

“Then the King will say to those on his right, ‘Come, you who are blessed by my Father; take your inheritance, the kingdom prepared for you since the creation of the world. For I was hungry and you gave me something to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you invited me in, I needed clothes and you clothed me, I was sick and you looked after me, I was in prison and you came to visit me.’

“Then the righteous will answer him, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you something to drink? When did we see you a stranger and invite you in, or needing clothes and clothe you? When did we see you sick or in prison and go to visit you?’

“The King will reply, ‘Truly I tell you, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did for me.’ “

As Jesus explains in Matthew 25, part of the mystery of deep justice is that when we offer comfort to the needy, we’re actually offering comfort to Jesus.

Jesus isn’t just standing next to the 16-year-old infected with AIDS in Mozambique or the incarcerated inner-city teenager in Minneapolis. His image is actually in them. His image—the image of God—has been present in them since the very second they were conceived.

Because every person is made in God’s image, each of us has potential to develop New relationships with both God and others. That means that we as kingdom youth workers need to use our ministry’s resources to partner with the marginalized in developing transformative relationships with our King as well as meaningful relationships with one another.

So what would this New understanding of the image of God mean for your youth ministry? Imagine if Jesus were left alone in a convalescent home, forgotten by his 12 closest friends. You’d undoubtedly invite some youth group kids to swing by on the way to your youth service and sit by his bed with you for a while, right? Even more, you and your students would raise money to offer special outings and opportunities for the seniors in the home, and you’d hire specialists to train the home operators to treat the elderly with the utmost respect and dignity. If you really wanted to move past short-term solutions, you’d also lobby your state officials to improve the healthcare and support systems for the elderly.

Or if Jesus were living in an African village, your youth ministry would never be satisfied with merely sending $30 every month for his food, shelter, and clothing. You’d drop everything, buy plane tickets, and visit him and his friends.

Throughout the history of Christian theology, many leaders and thinkers have equated the “image of God” with a quality or characteristic that is part of our human nature. These “substantive views” describe God’s image in us as either a physical resemblance, or a spiritual quality, or even our ability to reason. More recently (in theological terms, “recently” means in the last two centuries), an important additional definition of the image of God has emerged. The “relational view” claims the image lies not in who we are or anything we possess, but in how we relate to God and others.

More and more justice leaders are involved in new international programs that help microenterprises (small, locally owned businesses with less than ten employees). In the last five years, U.S. organizations and donors have supported more than 3.7 million microenterprises worldwide that offer essential services and goods including furniture, footwear, and handcrafted products.

Not only that, but you might also work as a youth ministry to send small loans to villagers so they could earn their own living by making bamboo stools or rattan baskets, thereby creating their own path out of poverty.

Or if Jesus were homeless, you would think it lazy—and probably even downright sinful—to offer him a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and a quick “God bless you” and keep walking. Instead, you’d sit and eat with him and his buddies, asking them to share their stories and giving them opportunity to hear your own stories. After you left, you might raise money to start a job-training center and give Jesus and his friends a ride to the computer seminars the next week. After the center was up and running, you’d become a political advocate for the homeless, sharing the lessons you’d learned with other city officials.

Our broken world shouts from the rooftops (and generally pays a lot of money on eBay) when images of Jesus or the Virgin Mary appear in pancakes, grilled-cheese sandwiches, and potato chips. Ironically, we don’t have to look to baked goods to see Jesus’ image; his presence is in the homeless woman we pass every day on the way to work.

Often those who have power in a society are threatened by deep justice, and the parents of some kids in our youth ministries will likely fall right into this fear. To find out more about how to engage parents in your youth ministry’s justice work, visit our free resources at www.cyfm.net.

NEW SHIFT 2: IT’S NOT JUST ABOUT ECONOMIC POWER

Not only are we blind to the presence of Jesus in the poor, but we’re also blind to the variety of ways that poor persons lack power. Sure, we usually recognize that those who are poor lack economic power. Yet the poor also lack other forms of power that are less obvious:

The poor lack powerful geography. In general, poor people are more vulnerable to natural disasters because their jobs are often related to outdoor work (i.e., agriculture), and because their homes are often located in regions more vulnerable to floods, fires, and hurricanes. (Think about who was most affected by Hurricane Katrina in 2005.)

The poor lack intellectual opportunities. It’s likely that some of the world’s finest minds are among the poor, but most of the world will never know it. Due to lack of good nutrition during childhood and lack of opportunities during adulthood, the ability of poor persons to contribute their innovative ideas to the intellectual capital of the world is squelched.

The poor lack emotional freedom. According to Jayakumar Christian in God of the Empty-Handed, poor people are often caught in a “web of lies” about their own ability to solve their problems, robbing them of hope and affirming the status quo.

The poor lack political capital. Few groups lobby on behalf of the poor at your city hall or on Washington, D.C.’s Capitol Hill. Politicians tend to want the votes of those who are poor, but after the ballots are cast, winning candidates usually focus attention on more powerful special interest groups.

DOES MORE POWER FOR OTHERS MEAN LESS POWER FOR ME?

If we’re going to move to the Level 3 justice described in

, we can’t ignore this question. It’s an especially critical consideration for youth ministers who come from a race or class of position and power, and/or work with students of similarly privileged backgrounds. Will using your ministry’s resources to help the poor gain power mean you end up with less power?

If your ministry raises funds to help poor kids apply to and attend college, will this make it less likely that your own students will be accepted at their top college choices? Or if your ministry supports job training that helps the unemployed gain computer skills, will the parents of your kids have greater difficulty finding a job in your town if they are laid off?

Some youth ministries involved in deep justice are using their money to support organizations seeking to help accomplish the United Nations Millennium Development Goals established in the year 2000. This campaign seeks to accomplish the following by 2015:

  1. Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger.
  2. Achieve universal primary education.
  3. Promote gender equity and empower women.
  4. Reduce child mortality.
  5. Improve maternal health.
  6. Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria, and other diseases.
  7. Ensure environmental sustainability.
  8. Develop a global partnership for development.

“As the oppressors dehumanize others and violate their rights, they themselves also become dehumanized.”

PAULO FREIRE, PEDAGOGY OF THE OPPRESSED

Maybe. Perhaps even probably.

But let’s go back to the view of kingdom shalom presented in

. The King’s deepest desire is that all people experience his full potential for them—relationally, physically, emotionally, and spiritually. If your power can be retained only by ensuring that others stay powerless, do you really want to keep that kind of power?

A SNAPSHOT OF INCREASING POWER

Learning New ways to use our ministry’s resources to support and sustain the God-given dignity of those who are poor and increase their financial, political, educational, and vocational power has been a 13-year process for me. In my early days of ministry, our ministry channeled much of its financial resources into summer interns who led powerful evangelistic Bible Clubs in four barrio neighborhoods in Santa Ana, California, through our KIDWORKS ministry.

Were people helped by these interns? You bet. But were we using our ministry’s resources in partnership with the community to bring about long-term transformation that brought more power and potential to the poor in these communities? Not even close.

So we made a New shift that forced our entire team, including my wife and me, to use our time, skills, and resources for more than short-term or selfish responses on behalf of the poor in the Latino community. Instead of offering evangelistic Bible studies during the summer, we became a holistic community development corporation that operated year-round. We continued to meet the spiritual needs of children and families in the neighborhood, but we didn’t stop there.

To find out more about KIDWORKS and the kingdom impact it’s making, visit www.kidworksonline.org.

To increase the neighborhood’s academic potential, we began to provide an after-school educational program and computer lab.

To enhance employment possibilities, we offered English as a Second Language (or ESL) classes for kids’ parents and other adults so they could access higher-paying jobs.

To help instill a sense of neighborhood pride and community, our KIDWORKS staff teamed up with a park redevelopment project in the neighborhood.

To increase the political power of those living here, we used our ministry’s money to support voter registration campaigns and encourage community organizing initiatives.

Thinking holistically about community development also meant we couldn’t start working with kids when they turned 12 years old. We launched our own preschool and school-readiness programs, recognizing that one of the best ways we can use our money to help teenagers is to make sure they get early academic and relational anchors that will help them withstand the storms of gangs and drugs that thunder around them.

To hear more of Larry’s practical insights about fund development, check out a CYFM interview available for free at www.cyfm.net.

None of this was rocket science. It was simply a process of discovering what was wrong, and then increasing the power of the neighborhood to right those wrongs.

By now you’re probably realizing that thinking more holistically about power development for the poor might mean more fundraising. In all honesty, fundraising is not my favorite part of justice ministry. But I do love figuring out how to help our ministry—and other ministries like ours—use resources to bring about long-term power transformation on behalf of the least, the last, and the lost.

WHO? (OBSERVATION)

To download and hear more of Rudy’s insights about justice and leadership, check out a CYFM interview available for free at www.cyfm.net.

Using resources to help the poor gain power drives the mission of Pasadena’s Harambee Christian Family Center. Under the leadership of its executive director, RUDOLPHO (“RUDY”) CARRASCO, Harambee provides after-school programs and a private, Christian school that emphasizes personal responsibility and indigenous leadership development. As a strategic thinker and gifted communicator, Rudy shares his insights about deep justice regularly through articles in Christianity Today, The Los Angeles Times, and other publications. Thanks to his hands-on experience with Latino and African-American kids as well as his extensive networking with youth leaders around the country, Rudy has philosophical and practical ideas that can help your youth ministry devote your resources to deeper justice.



Rudy, why are youth ministries prone to use their money for short-term solutions on behalf of the poor?

I think it’s usually for pretty practical reasons. Short-term solutions are easier. They don’t take as much time, and they don’t take as much money. Youth ministries who do short-term work can definitely meet some needs and be transformed some themselves.

The problem is that most injustices and challenges are complex and deep. They’ve been around for a long time. Effective solutions require an equal response—one that is committed for the long term.



When are short-term solutions most effective?

No question it’s when they are partnered with long-term solutions. Here at Harambee, we have youth groups from around the country come and invest their resources in short-term work all the time, but they come to partner with those of us who are living here long term. If short-termers don’t have partnerships with long-termers, they can actually make the situation worse. Folks in the community can learn how to manipulate short-termers and tell them sob stories so they give money. No one gains when that happens.



How have you seen youth ministries use their money selfishly in the midst of trying to seek kingdom justice on behalf of the poor?

Usually groups act selfishly when they don’t take the time to get to know the real causes of injustice. They are usually well-intentioned, and they think they know what the needs are, so they show up and start addressing the wrong issues.



What difference should it make to us that according to the parable of the sheep and the goats (Matthew 25:31–40), Jesus’ presence is in the poor?

It should make a huge difference. In fact, that passage is one of the most important sections of Scripture in my life. It’s so dramatic, and even offensive. I’m glad Jesus said it, and I didn’t. Now I can just read the Bible and tell folks, “That’s what your Lord and Savior says.” For many youth ministries, the justice starting point is simply to take a few weeks and reflect on the fact that Jesus’ presence is in the poor. He doesn’t give us any wiggle room.



Besides economic power, what other types of power do the poor lack?

There are so many types of power that the poor lack, but one major one is they lack connections and access. And even if they somehow end up making some connections and gaining some access, they often don’t know what to do with those networks.



What do you mean by “connections” and “access”?

Let me give you an example. Imagine you know a bunch of restaurant owners; perhaps they are in your social circle or you somehow become friends with them. Because of these connections, you get inside information. You learn about hiring trends, which restaurants have job openings, and what types of people they hope to hire. If you gain access to that information, you gain power.



How can privileged youth ministries use their money so the poor gain power?

One of the keys to helping others gain power is giving them sustained attention, probably for at least a year. Maybe you can mobilize your kids to give enough money to provide a one-year scholarship for an inner-city kid to attend a good private school. You can track that kid over the year, get to know him, and even get to know people at the school and in the community.

We’ve had that happen here at Harambee, and one of the great bonuses is that it’s not just dollars that come, but also ideas. As 20 kids in a local suburban youth group decided to stop spending their cash at Starbucks and gave that money to one of our students instead, not only is that kid changed, but the youth group has been transformed as well. The parents of the suburban kids often see this transformation and end up wanting to partner with us in even greater ways.



Besides providing school scholarships, what else can privileged youth ministries do with their resources to increase the power of the poor?

My general answer is that privileged youth ministries need to do a little bit of investigative research and learn what people really need. I’ll tell you one thing that most folks need: help getting a job. If youth ministries could use their money to help the unemployed gain jobs, that would definitely increase their power.

I think it would also help if suburban or privileged youth ministries pooled their resources. If six churches got together and combined their money, that would be a much larger chunk of money that could take justice to a deeper level.



What about youth ministries serving in poorer communities?

My answer is going to be controversial, but here it is: almost the exact same thing. I think poorer kids are rarely challenged to give of their resources to right wrongs around them. In our urban neighborhood, kids have never been invited to go on a mission trip, and they’ve never been challenged to give their own money to others. Our kids tell us they’re broke, and often that’s true, so we encourage them to be creative. Maybe they have an uncle who has some resources, or maybe they could sacrifice something they have and give it to those who have even less than them. We have to insert a different script into the minds and hearts of urban kids. Even in the midst of the bad stuff they are experiencing, they have capacity.



Whether you’re in a suburban, urban, or small-town youth ministry, how can you do the type of justice work you’re describing and maintain the dignity of those you are helping?

You need to find a trusted partner on the other end who can help you know what to avoid, what not to say, and what not to do.



Rudy, in your widely circulated article “Protest and Invest,” you write, “From the vantage point of my home, next to a corner store in a black and Latino neighborhood, what I see is a generation carrying picket signs in their hearts but running no businesses, owning no property, creating no wealth, tempted to commit crimes, and doomed to wallow in poverty. The very kids who should be disciplining themselves, saving money, working long hours, practicing how to write a business plan, and learning how to win investor confidence, are instead walking around complaining.”

What type of responsibility do you think those who are under-resourced have for increasing their own base of power and opportunities?

The primary responsibility is theirs. It’s their life. Just thinking about it practically, you can’t sit around and wait for others to fix your situation. It’s your situation. You know what you need.



If that’s true, then what’s the role of the church?

The church’s responsibility is secondary. As we follow the Lord, the Holy Spirit will reveal injustices we need to be involved with. Suddenly, we’ll end up with a real heart for the homeless in our community, or we’ll become burdened for children affected by AIDS in Africa.

And it really takes the whole church, not just us as individual believers. In the New Testament, the word that’s often translated in English as you is actually plural. Many of Scripture’s commands related to poverty are meant for a group or a body, not just one individual.

I’ve seen the importance of the body working together in real life, too. I tried to do what I could as an individual in college and failed spectacularly. Then I had an experience where a group of 15 people worked to help one mother overcome a tragic situation, and you know what? She made it. That has changed the way I think about the role of the church in God’s justice. Often it takes a whole bunch of people to help one person. It makes sense both practically and theologically.

Since President George W. Bush first mentioned the “soft bigotry of low expectations” in a 2000 campaign speech, it’s become a frequent theme in his comments regarding education and poverty.

I’ve heard you mention a few times the statement by President Bush regarding the “soft bigotry of low expectations.” Why is that statement so significant for you?

Folks who feel victimized often want to lash out and call others “racist” or “oppressors.” Frankly, I think calling others racists at every turn isn’t all that helpful, and it isn’t all that accurate. I think what happens more often is that the rich have low expectations for the poor, and the poor have low expectations for themselves.

We assume poor kids won’t be able to do their homework, so we don’t try to help them get it done.

Honestly, there are days when I think the low expectations we have toward the poor are the number one problem. We’re created in God’s image, so no matter what our situation or background, we can make it. Sure, it’s a challenge, but people are created in God’s image. It may take a miracle, but God’s in the business of miracles.

HOW? (APPLICATION)

DEEP JUSTICE APPLICATION QUESTIONS

  • Is your ministry Now more likely to offer either short-term or selfish help to those who are poor or oppressed? Why do you think your ministry leans to this extreme?
  • In addition to financial power, what other types of power do the poor in your community lack?
  • In both this chapter and
    , we’ve discussed the relevance of seeing the image of God in the poor for our justice work. If your ministry viewed the needy of the world as Jesus himself, what would you do differently? What prevents you and your kids from viewing the needy this way?
  • After reading this chapter, in what ways is your youth ministry currently seeking holistic justice with and for the poor? How does this goal of holistic ministry relate to God’s shalom as described in
    ?
  • In Larry’s experience, shifting from a summer-only evangelistic Bible study to a New year-round holistic community development corporation meant he and his team needed to raise more funds. Do you think the same will be true for you if your group moves toward a more holistic approach? Who from your church or sphere of relationships can partner with you to raise funds that will increase the power of the poor?
  • Of the following list of Deep Justice Recommended Action Steps that flow from this chapter, which would best help your youth ministry right wrongs?
  • NOTES

    Lowell Noble, “Ownership and Justice,” unpublished manuscript, page 2.

    Jayakumar Christian, God of the Empty Handed (Monrovia, California: World Vision International, 1999), 161.

    http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/

    Rudolpho Carrasco, “Protest and Invest,” Prism, Summer 2004.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑