Chapter 5 of 26

Motivation For Justice: Finding Our Place In God’S Story

Motivation For Justice: Finding Our Place In God’S Story

A quick glance at the table above reveals that not all these passages contain all four movements in the kingdom story, and the Good/Guilt/Grace/Gratitude story isn’t always presented in a linear order. Given the complexity of the story, it would be unrealistic to think that all four elements will appear in every slice of Scripture or in the same order. But the threads of this story weave their way through the Scriptures as a whole.

MOTIVATION FOR JUSTICE: FINDING OUR PLACE IN GOD’S STORY

I’ve alluded to this already, but I need to say it clearly: Our lives find meaning as we view ourselves as participants in God’s unfolding story. Just as we need to discern how Scripture passages fit into the story of Good/Guilt/Grace/Gratitude, we also need to recognize how our own stories do.

For more insights about findings from our short-term missions research, please see our Deep Justice Journeys Curriculum and resources at www.fulleryouthinstitute.org/deep-justice.

My last decade of teaching about justice, as well as the 70 youth worker interviews we’ve conducted, confirms that students’ motivation to right wrongs is directly related to their view of themselves as participants in God’s story. When kids shift from thinking of themselves as the audience of God’s drama to seeing themselves as participants in a New community living out Good/Guilt/Grace/Gratitude together—and helping others live out the kingdom story also—their interest in serving our broken world skyrockets.

THE ROLE OF JUSTICE IN GOD’S STORY

As a youth worker, you’re probably familiar with Micah 6:8 and its command to “act justly,” but the threads of justice weave their way through the kingdom story far more than you might realize. The table below includes less than half of the verses about justice in the Old Testament alone.

Selected Old Testament Verses about Justice

Exodus 23:2

justice

Exodus 23:6

justice

Leviticus 19:15

justice

Deuteronomy 16:20

justice

justice

Deuteronomy 24:17

justice

Deuteronomy 27:19a

justice

1 Kings 3:28 “

justice

1 Kings 10:9

justice

Job 8:3

justice

Psalm 7:6

justice

Psalm 9:16

justice

Psalm 11:7

justice

Psalm 36:6

justice

Psalm 72:2

justice

Psalm 89:14

justice

Psalm 99:4a

justice

Psalm 101:1

justice

Psalm 103:6

justice

Psalm 106:3

justly

Proverbs 8:20

justice

Proverbs 16:10

justice

Proverbs 18:5

justice

Proverbs 21:15

justice

Proverbs 29:7

justice

Isaiah 1:17

justice

Isaiah 1:27

justice

Isaiah 5:16

justice

Isaiah 10:1–2a

justice

Isaiah 28:17a

justice

Isaiah 30:18

justice

Isaiah 42:1

justice

Isaiah 51:4

justice

Isaiah 56:1

justice

Isaiah 61:8a

justice

Jeremiah 9:24

justice

Ezekiel 22:29

justice

Ezekiel 34:16

justice

Hosea 12:6

justice

Amos 5:24

justice

Micah 6:8

justly

Zephaniah 3:5a

justice

Zechariah 7:9–10a

justice

TEACHING THE KINGDOM STORY HELPS US SIDESTEP TWO DANGEROUS JUSTICE TRAPS

The interviews we conducted revealed two traps that hinder the steps of youth ministries as they move toward God’s intentions for deep justice. Teaching and ministering with a New sense of God’s story helps us sidestep them both.

Trap 1: “Those Poor People…”

As you’ve helped your students right wrongs on behalf of the broken and the brokenhearted (both in their midst and around the world), you’ve undoubtedly heard students express pity by describing them as While those three words might seem harmless, they actually pose a significant threat to your students’ ability to offer deep hope in the midst of brokenness. When students feel pity for those who are “worse off” than they are, this can often rob those people of their God-given dignity, and hide the God-given part we all play in the King’s story.

“There is always the creeping danger that even our servanthood is a subtle form of manipulation. Are we really servants when we can become masters again once we think we have done our part or made our contribution? Are we really servants when we can say when, where, and how long we will give of our time and energy? Is service in a far country really an expression of servanthood when we keep enough money in the bank to fly home at any moment?”

DONALD P. MCNEILL, DOUGLAS A. MORRISON, AND HENRI J. M. NOUWEN, COMPASSION

Following Hurricane Mitch in 1998, Kurt Ver Beek and his team conducted interviews with members of short-term mission teams and those in the Honduran communities they visited. They asked the 40 Hondurans who received homes from the short-termers if they would prefer to have the North Americans come and build the home or be given the $20, 000 the short-term groups raised to cover the expense of their trip—an amount that would have enabled the Hondurans to build not just one home but ten. While the Hondurans appreciated the chance to build relationships with North Americans, they often said they would rather have the financial resources so they could help more families and employ more Hondurans.

One Honduran, while very appreciative of the help she received, reported through tears, “It is better for them to send the money in order to help more people who are in need.”

Another local Honduran leader answered, “They gather money to come here to do work, work that we are capable of doing.”

Of course, the Hondurans were also consistently appreciative of all the North Americans had provided for them. Yet their comments leave us wondering: How can we create an environment of mutual ministry and reciprocal learning so those who “receive” are also in a position to teach and give back?

Often, even subconsciously, we subtly view ourselves as the “great white (or black or Latino or Asian) saviors” who swoop in to “rescue” others, thereby minimizing the God-given gifts and resources of those we are “rescuing.” Viewing all people as made in God’s image and equally capable of participating in God’s unfolding kingdom story not only eliminates this degrading position, but also invites us to ask: How can we better partner with the poor so that they live their own lives as thank-you notes to the King?

The painful truth is that much of what we currently do in the name of service and justice is based on the assumption that we who have more power and resources play a more important role in the kingdom than others. This justice trap is alluded to in research on short-term missions recently conducted by Kurt Ver Beek, an assistant professor of sociology and third-world development at Calvin College. While his surveys weren’t confined to youth ministry, his findings have New implications for us if we want students to grasp that “those poor people” have a role in the story that’s as important as our own.

Trap 2: “There’s not much I can do…”

The needs and injustices of the world are overwhelming, even downright paralyzing—especially if you’re a 15-year-old still wrestling with issues of your own identity and significance in the world.

The kingdom story doesn’t come with any age requirements. In a world in which our national and state laws require kids to cross certain age thresholds to drive, drink, and vote (not all at once, we hope!), the kingdom story invites all of us—whether we’re five, fifteen, or eighty-five years old—to step into its pages and contribute a few sentences—or maybe even paragraphs—of our own.

“Reading the Bible from the margins of society is not an exercise that reveals interesting perspectives on how other cultures read and interpret biblical texts. To read the Bible from the margins is to grasp God in the midst of struggle and oppression.”

MIGUEL A. DE LA TORRE, READING THE BIBLE FROM THE MARGINS

This brings New freedom to all kids, but our interviews with urban youth workers confirm that it brings a special sense of destiny and purpose to kids who come from under-resourced or high-risk backgrounds. Those kids are used to standing on the receiving end of governmental and social services. When youth leaders like us invite them to stand on the other side of the table and not only receive but give their skills, time, and dreams, we help them realize all they have to offer as children of the King.

We are seeing this now in our church as we invite kids from the poorer areas of Pasadena who are part of our ministry to serve others. As they help repair roofs, paint rooms for the church, and support our church’s computer lab, they’re relishing the chance to contribute their own text to God’s story. As one of these kids summarized, “I haven’t had it easy, but now it’s my chance to give back.”

One of these young people is Demetrice. He was a sophomore when his stepdad stopped paying the rent, forcing Demetrice to move in with his friend, Adam. Adam was a part of our youth ministry, so Demetrice started coming to our youth group because (in his words), “I heard there were pretty girls there.”

But Demetrice met more than just cute girls; he also met Dave, one of our mentors, who looked beyond Demetrice’s past and saw kingdom hope for his future. In a world in which Demetrice had experienced people making assumptions about him because he’s black and lived in a “bad neighborhood,” Demetrice says, “Dave saw me for who I really was, and helped me see the kingdom of God for what it really is.”

Now Demetrice is a junior college student and a part-time middle school intern at our church. He focuses on reaching out to kids who act out in school and in youth group. Demetrice is one of a very few African-American male middle school leaders at our church, and most of the kids in Demetrice’s small group are white. As a result, he often has to fight against people’s stereotypes and assumptions about him. At our last winter camp, another small group leader asked Demetrice to teach him how to hold a gun. Why? Because that leader assumed all young black men know how to hold guns.

Yet in the midst of people assuming Demetrice plays drums (when he really plays piano), or guessing he only likes hip-hop (when he also likes rock and classical music), Demetrice is committed to helping the kids in his predominantly white small group understand all they have in common. His dream is that his small group becomes a place “where we can all be ourselves, where we can realize our similarities and our differences, and learn how we all fit together like a puzzle.”

WHO? (OBSERVATION)

GLEN STASSEN and JIM WALLIS are two justice leaders who have dedicated their lives to motivating both kids and adults to deeper justice through their teaching. As president and executive director of Sojourners/Call to Renewal and the author of God’s Politics: Why the Right Gets It Wrong and the Left Doesn’t Get It, Jim Wallis is a highly acclaimed speaker and teacher Who brings kingdom perspectives to faith, politics, and culture. Jim’s long time friend, Glen, is Smedes Professor of Christian Ethics at Fuller Theological Seminary. Glen has written several books on justice and peacemaking, and was coauthor (with David Gushee) of Kingdom Ethics: Following Jesus in Contemporary Context (one of Christianity Today’s 2003 Books of the Year).



Jim and Glen, as you have observed youth workers teaching about justice, how do they try to guilt kids into serving? When is that helpful and when is that not helpful?

Glen:   Kids—and adults—who feel pressured by guilt practice evasion, including evasion of the way of Jesus.

Jim:     Glen’s right. Guilt can get you some standing ovations, but it doesn’t sustain a justice movement long term.



Instead of guilt, other youth workers often rely on grace to motivate their kids toward deep justice. How do youth workers know if what they’re teaching is authentic grace or what Dietrich Bonhoeffer would call “cheap grace”?

Jim:    Authentic grace means we do everything in gratitude because of what God has done for us. We’re all just hopeless sinners in need of God’s grace, and we have nothing over anyone else—except that God has saved us. That’s different from saying we somehow are blessed in our wealth, and there are those who haven’t been blessed for whatever reason, and we want to now be a blessing to them. That’s cheap grace.

Glen:  Bonhoeffer got it right. Authentic grace overcomes our shame by entering into the midst of our lives with love and caring, and inviting us to participate in a new community that includes folks like us, and includes us as participants in a new way of living—not as isolated individuals, but—as the apostle Paul said—I, yet not I, but Christ in me” (1 Corinthians 15:10). “Participation in Christ,” and Christ’s participation in us, was a central theme for Bonhoeffer.



Many youth leaders are helping kids understand that God has a kingdom story, and that we as his creation find meaning within that story. How can youth workers help teenagers realize that justice for the least of these is part of what it means to find ourselves in God’s story?

Jim:    As I’ve been saying for the last two years on the road, when I find 2,000 verses in the Bible about poor people, I insist that fighting poverty is a moral issue. Somehow, most churches are skipping over all those verses. But the God of the Bible is a God of justice, not just charity.



What’s the difference between charity and justice?

Jim:    Charity is just dealing with the symptoms of problems—feeding people, housing people, and clothing the naked. But William Booth, the founder of the Salvation Army, used to say that we can’t keep picking up bodies at the bottom of the mountain and not climb the hill and see who or what is throwing them off the edge. Justice climbs the hill and tries to stop folks from stepping off the cliff.



What else would you like to change about the way youth workers tend to teach about social justice?

Glen:  Jesus confronted the authorities in Jerusalem, and the Pharisees and wealthy, 40 times in the Synoptic Gospels, for their injustice. Many Sunday school classes skip by that or don’t realize it. As Dave Gushee and I show in chapter 17 of Kingdom Ethics, Jesus confronted the authorities for the same four dimensions of injustice that his favorite prophet, Isaiah, emphasized: injustice as domination and suppressing independence; injustice as exclusion of outsiders; injustice as greed oppressing the poor; and injustice as violence to victims. Different kids identify with different dimensions of injustice. I suggest including all four, and asking youth which of the four they have experienced. That is likely to hook their interest. Then connect all four so they identify with the causes and consequences of injustice more broadly.

“Because the Scriptures spend so much time on the poor, we will too. This is the most important ‘political’ issue in the Bible, and it must be ours as well.”

JIM WALLIS, GOD’S POLITICS.

What would you say to a youth worker who feels like justice is a step beyond what a sixteen-year-old can do?

Glen:   Kids care about injustice; they are struggling for some independence themselves, and struggling against being excluded, and they have a passion about injustice. Adolescence is a great time to teach about justice and injustice. The best group in a church to begin with in starting a program to mentor kids who have needs, or to help feed the hungry, or to do visits and engage in conversation with recipients of injustice, is youth. They’re not set in their ways and their ideologies, and they care.

For more ideas on how to help students process and interpret their justice experiences, flip ahead to

.

But the key is not only to engage in some service project; it’s crucial to ask an expert or two about the causes of poverty and what can be done to make a difference for justice to come, and help students process and interpret what they are experiencing.

Jim:    I agree with Glen. We’re finding that young people are not as narcissistic or apathetic as we might think. As I speak around the country, kids are responding in deep and profound ways. They’re coming to me to tell me how they are changing the world already.

“If the faith community is really ready to get to know those kids who would be sleeping in bunk beds that night, we won’t just be providing them shelter. We’ll start asking why the shelters are needed in the first place.”

JIM WALLIS, FAITH WORKS

I had a nine-year-old come up to me after I had spoken about the “Silent Tsunami” killing children. This nine-year-old girl told me, “You talked about a Silent Tsunami killing little children like me. I was sitting there and thinking to myself, ‘If I’m a Christian, I better do something about that.’” So the next week I told the students in my class at Harvard University, “If you want to lead this movement, you’d better move fast, because there’s a whole generation coming behind you, and they’re going to push you out of the way.” In 30 years of working for justice, I’ve never seen such a growing student movement.



How does the fact that every single person is made in God’s image affect the movement that you’re describing?

Jim:    It’s central. Because we’re all made in God’s image, a kid living in a garbage dump in Mexico is just as important as my own kid. I’m going to pick up my two kids from school this afternoon—and what has got to motivate me is that other people’s kids are just as important to God and to me as my own kids.

Part of why I’m concerned about the religious right is that they care about the sacredness of life, but if I want their support and I’m an unborn child, I’d better stay unborn as long as possible. Once I’m born, I’m off their radar screen. The reality is that we are just as much made in God’s image after we’re born as before we’re born.



What are your favorite scriptural texts to use when you teach about justice? Why do you like them so much?

Glen:   My all-time favorite is Jesus’ baptismal text, Isaiah 42:1–7, because it says God will bring justice to the nations, which means all people get included; and will not do violence, which means justice and healing for the victims of violence; and will bring healing to the blind, which means justice for the sick; and will deliver the prisoners from the dungeon, which means justice for the dominated and oppressed; and “He will not grow faint or be crushed until he has established justice in the earth,” (42:4, NRSV) which means when we work for justice, we are participating in what God is doing through Christ.



The interviews we’ve conducted with youth workers have revealed two traps that prevent youth ministries from deep justice. The first is when kids look at those they serve and think, “Those poor people.” How can we view those we serve as people who play just as big a part in the kingdom story as we do?

Glen:   First, I’d encourage us all to engage in conversations with people we serve, and to ask questions that lead them to talk about their life stories. Second, I’d encourage youth also to engage in discussion with a couple of experts on injustices that cause or contribute to this suffering. Just serving isn’t enough, because we come with ideologies that have infiltrated our ways of perceiving, and with shyness about asking questions that can reveal shame. We need help from people who have worked with the poor. Youth ministries would be wise to remember how often Jesus said, “You’re not seeing what’s happening.”



The second trap is when kids look at the overwhelming needs of the world and think, “There’s not much I can do.” What would you say to a teenager who feels that way?

Glen:   I wouldn’t say anything. I’d help my youth group engage in projects with Bread for the World, World Vision International, my Baptist denomination’s World Service, the Heifer Project, or in a local project like mentoring teenagers who could use some help with their studies and with setting their values for life.



Any last advice for youth workers trying to teach kids about deep social justice?

Jim:    If you’re a youth worker serving kids who are middle or upper class, please tell them flat-out that most people in the world don’t live like they or their friends do. As long as they have a narrow view of reality, they’ll never understand the world. We have an enormous opportunity to expose teenagers to the world as it really is, because young people like to go places. They like to get out of the house. So we have the chance to send them into the world so they see it as it really is.

“Integrity of character is shaped when we see ourselves, our lives, and our loyalties as part of a larger drama that shapes our community.”

GLEN H. STASSEN AND DAVID P. GUSHEE, KINGDOM ETHICS

“If the church is functioning as it should, it will continually and very earnestly engage in a search for authoritative direction and insight concerning its character and its conduct. It will desire above all else to know and live out the answer to the prophet’s question, ‘What does the Lord require?’ (Micah 6:8).”

GLEN H. STASSEN AND DAVID P. GUSHEE, KINGDOM ETHICS

“My neighborhood has constantly given me a perspective that I would not otherwise have had. Once, I returned from a meeting at the White House about youth violence only to find the infamous yellow police tape on the sidewalk right across from my house, indicating where another young man had just been shot and killed. I remember reflecting that most people who attend such meetings don’t come home to places like this.”

JIM WALLIS, FAITH WORKS

HOW? (APPLICATION)

DEEP JUSTICE APPLICATION QUESTIONS

  • Which are you more prone to over emphasize in teaching kids about deep justice: guilt or grace? How has that affected your youth ministry and your justice work?
  • How would describing God’s kingdom story as Good/Guilt/Grace/Gratitude affect your teaching and justice work?
  • What impact would it have on your students to realize that participation in the kingdom story doesn’t come with any age requirements? How could your teaching help them embrace that?
  • Glen points to four dimensions of injustice: domination, exclusion, greed, and violence. Which of these four dimensions would most resonate with your students? Why do you think that is?
  • Jim points out that “Because we’re all made in God’s image, a kid living in a garbage dump in Mexico is just as important as my own kid.” How would the deep justice work of you and your students be different if that truth was imprinted on the minds and souls of those in your youth ministry?
  • Of the following list of Deep Justice Recommended Action Steps that flow from this chapter, which would best help you as a kingdom follower right wrongs? How about your youth ministry?
  • NOTES

    Some books of the Bible, especially the New Testament epistles, follow this Good/Guilt/Grace/Gratitude flow. They first discuss our creation and curse, next they describe our new life in Christ, and then they conclude their final chapters with commands about reflecting this new life in our attitudes and actions. 47

    Kurt Ver Beek, “The Impact of Short-Term Missions: A Case Study of House Construction in Honduras After Hurricane Mitch,” Missiology Volume 34, no. 4, October 2006, 482–483.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑