Chapter 21 of 26

Chapter 11 What’s Just about the Rich Getting Richer and the Poor Getting Poorer?

Chapter 11 What’s Just about the Rich Getting Richer and the Poor Getting Poorer?





Jeremy Del Rio, Esq. works as a consultant, providing advice and resources to churches and community groups on youth development, social justice, and cultural engagement. He is the cofounder and director of Community Solutions, Inc. (CSI), a holistic youth-development agency based in lower Manhattan. CSI provides after-school education, summer programs, and community outreach through Generation Xcel, and hosts service learning missions trips nationally through Chain Reaction. Jeremy is the founding youth pastor at Abounding Grace Ministries and has also worked as a corporate attorney in New York.

“I had to say, ‘God, I repent, because I can’t think of the last time I thought of widows and orphans’… And so I went back and I began to read Scripture, and it was like blinders came off… I’ve got three advanced degrees. I’ve had four years in Greek and Hebrew and I’ve got doctorates. And how did I miss 2,000 verses in the Bible where it talks about the poor? How did I miss that? I mean, I went to two different seminaries and a Bible school; how did I miss the 2,000 verses on the poor?”

—Rick Warren

NOW? (DISCERNMENT)

Is there a city anywhere in America—or, for that matter, anywhere in the world—where the rich do not get richer as the poor get poorer Now?

If there is, I don’t know of it.

In my own city of New York—the “Capital of the World” and home to some of this planet’s greatest financial institutions—the gap between the rich and poor grows wider every year. During Christmas of 1999, the depth of the chasm became especially real for me. I’d been involved in inner-city ministry for seventeen years, since I was eight years old, and five years earlier, I had cofounded a storefront youth group for teenagers living in the low-income housing projects of Manhattan’s Lower East Side.

That year, we wanted to do classic “Christmas in New York” stuff—Rockefeller Center, the Lord and Taylor windows, ice-skating in Central Park—so a couple dozen of us took the subway 2.5 miles to 49th Street. We might as well have traveled across the country.

My wife and I took half the group for a walk toward Central Park along the priciest real estate in the world, Fifth Avenue, and ended up stopping at the lobby of the famed Plaza Hotel. The Plaza, legendary for its luxurious décor and clientele, was hosting a holiday party of some sort, with Manhattan’s upper crust decked out in tuxedos and evening gowns, and limos lined up for blocks outside. After five or ten minutes, one of our kids, Vanessa, turned to my wife and with a faraway gaze in her eyes, said wistfully, “I could never imagine myself at an event like this.”

Two weeks later, I found myself back at the Plaza, this time for my law firm’s New Year’s party. This time, I was one of the folks wearing a tuxedo and gorging myself on yellowtail sashimi and filet mignon. The open bar was flowing, and my inebriated colleagues were celebrating record bonuses and the still blazing Internet economic bubble.

My head was spinning. As a first-year attorney at a major New York firm, tent-making to support inner-city youth ministry, I knew functions like this went with the territory. But could it really be that some would feel so affirmed in this setting, while others—like Vanessa—would feel so excluded?

Yet this bizarre duality between the very rich and the very poor exists every day Now in Manhattan. As 2006 drew to a close, executives for the New York-based global banking company Goldman Sachs enjoyed $16 billion in year-end bonuses, with the highest earners receiving $100 million each. At the same time, gentrification in Manhattan, and increasingly the outer boroughs, displaces the middle class and renders upward mobility for the poor virtually impossible in their own neighborhoods. New York City spends over $14 billion—with another $1.9 billion of state aid on the way—educating its 1.2 million public school students (who, all by themselves, would be the tenth largest U.S. city). Yet statistically, 60 percent of the fourth graders in New York’s public schools can’t read at grade level and 70 percent fail statewide math exams.

Whether in New York or your own town, whether upper class or lower class, whether rich or poor, none of us chooses the family that births us, the class we are raised in, or the community that surrounds us.

But we as youth ministries Now do have a choice. What is our kingdom response to the widening canyon between the rich and the poor? Unfortunately, we Now tend to fall into either/or extremes that keep us from offering deep justice to all, regardless of class.

Extreme 1: Denial

It’s easy for youth workers in the middle or upper classes to avoid or deny the class canyon that Now fractures our world and our relationships. As long as we are comfortable and taken care of, we keep our blinders on and ride the wave of wealth as high and far as we can.

Whether by actively withholding good or through passive indifference or neglect, our youth ministries often fail to take seriously the mandate to act on behalf of the lower classes. But concern for the poor is a priority God takes very seriously. We know this because his Scripture includes more than 2,000 verses about the poor, among them the famously misunderstood story of Sodom.

Why did God destroy Sodom? Instinctively, we evangelicals think we know the answer. It’s been ingrained in us since Sunday school, and popular words—sodomy, sodomite—express our notion of Sodom’s fatal flaw. We believe God destroyed Sodom because of homosexuality and related sexual behaviors. But is our conventional understanding correct?

Although the Genesis account of Sodom’s destruction refers to homosexuality and other passages reference “sexual immorality,” the prophet Ezekiel identifies Sodom’s greater sin:

Now this was the sin of your sister Sodom: She and her daughters were arrogant, overfed and unconcerned; they did not help the poor and needy. They were haughty and did detestable things before me. Therefore I did away with them as you have seen. (Ezekiel 16:49–50)

Arrogant.

Overfed.

Unconcerned.

Failing to help the poor and needy.

FACTS ABOUT POVERTY NOW IN THE UNITED STATES THAT MIGHT SURPRISE YOUR STUDENTS:

  • At age 20, more than one in ten Americans live in poverty.
  • By age 40, more than 1/3 of all Americans have experienced at least a year of poverty.
  • In just the four years between 2000 and 2004, the number of children in poverty in the U.S. increased 12.4 percent.
  • In America today, children are just as likely to be poor as they were 40 years ago.
  • According to U.S. Census Bureau figures, the income gap between the top 20 percent of households and the bottom 20 percent of households is the widest ever.
  • The median incomes of black and Latino families are 62 percent and 70 percent of white family incomes, respectively.
  • A full-time minimum-wage paycheck, which until the 1980s would have kept a family of three above the poverty threshold, now provides an income equivalent to only 75 percent of the poverty line.
  • Of female-headed households with no husband present, the percentages of families falling below the poverty vary by race: 18.0 percent for Asian families, 22.6 percent for white families, 37.4 percent for black families, and 39.0 percent for Latino families.

We know from the story of Lot that not even ten people in Sodom cared (Genesis 18:16–33). As a result, God destroyed the entire city by raining down fire from heaven.

Yet how many of our evangelical leaders and youth workers are speaking out against the injustice of the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer Now? Some of our most outspoken voices rant about “sodomy” and mobilize costly crusades against the politics of “sodomites.” Yet they often ignore completely the problem the Bible identifies as Sodom’s greatest sin—the same inhospitality that can so easily befall us in America.

Fast forward to the New Testament and Matthew 25’s parable of the sheep and the goats, which we’ve considered earlier in the book. Notice that the “sheep” in the parable, the ones the King gathers to himself on the last day, are those who feed the hungry; offer a drink to the thirsty; welcome the stranger; clothe the naked; and visit the imprisoned—for in doing so, Jesus says, they have ministered to Christ himself. By contrast, the “goats”—those who see others in need and fail to respond—are damned “into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels” (Matt. 25:31–46). It’s the only parable that speaks of judgment as eternal fire, and it reserves that judgment for those who neglect economic and social justice.

Extreme 2: Despair

When Vanessa told my wife the Plaza party was out of her reach, what came through most clearly wasn’t her distaste for evening gowns and fancy food or a preference for one party style over another. Her prevailing emotion was one of despair. Hopelessness. Like she’d just viewed the pinnacle of some mountain she could never climb, no matter how much she might want to.

Feeling stuck without options and powerless to change things is the worst aspect of generational poverty Now. When mom is poor and grandma is poor and dad is absent and big brother dropped out of school and the school is on probation because of abysmal performance and unemployment pushes toward record highs and community leaders play politics with hunger, kids feel hopeless. Why study if two plus two doesn’t equal four? Why cultivate character and competence if all the opportunities are reserved for someone else and all the doors remain closed?

NEW? (REFLECTION)

A BOY IN THE GHETTO

Let me tell you about a teenage boy I know. He appears ordinary enough, with nothing much to distinguish him—except that he’s studious and works with his stepdad in construction. Like many teens, he’s struggling to find his place.

Living in the ghetto is hard, especially since he just immigrated to the neighborhood in the last few years. Try as he might, he hasn’t mastered the accent and local customs. And forget the slang; that’s like learning a third language. Worse, the old-timers all seem to know something about him that he still hasn’t figured out yet. He gets the distinct impression that they talk about his family, reinforced by the name-calling he’s overheard. His peers can be especially cruel, teasing him to his face and instigating fights after school.

Sometimes the mocking gets to him. He wants desperately to fight back, but mom forbids it, promising that someday the rejection will make sense. He tries to take comfort in her words, but for now his heart just hurts, and the unfairness makes him angry.

So he sneaks off to the outskirts of town and hides behind a gnarly old sycamore tree. There he remembers the hunger and loneliness of the refugee camp, and recollects vague memories of a midnight flight from the small town where he spent his childhood. The details are sketchy, but he recalls stories of bloodshed and murder that he barely escaped. Not fitting in has been a recurring struggle for him.

Then those memories fade, and he hears the echo of his mom’s voice telling him about his birth. No way he’ll ever let his schoolmates find out he was born in a barn. The ammunition that would give them! They already call him choice animal names.

Perhaps you know this friend of mine.

No longer a nameless and faceless teenager, his name is both revered and reviled around the world, and artists have imagined his likeness for centuries.

In case you missed it in Sunday school, this boy we call Jesus Christ.

When the King of Kings decided to usher his kingdom “on earth as it is in heaven,” he penetrated class lines to do so—not as a well-intentioned outsider but from within the community. He “became flesh and blood and moved into the neighborhood,” (John 1:14, The Message) and his manner of doing so invited scorn. He was born into straw poverty made worse by political exile, and lived as an immigrant teenager in the ghetto. He worked his ministry with no place to lay his head (Matthew 8:20); made his last trip on a borrowed donkey; spent his last evening alive in a borrowed room; watched his lone possession, a robe, become a gambler’s prize at his death; and was buried in a borrowed tomb.

JESUS’ INCARNATION MEANS DENIAL OR DESPAIR ARE NO LONGER OPTIONS

If you are one of our society’s “haves,” Jesus’ birth, life, and death mean you can no longer live in denial about the injustice of the class canyon. If the King of Kings chose—I repeat, chose—to enter the world through the lower class, then we simply cannot ignore those who enter through it today. He spent his whole life rubbing elbows with members of all classes, even when he was soundly criticized for it.

If you are one of our society’s “have nots,” Jesus’ birth, death, and resurrection mean you can no longer live in despair. Jesus knows—really knows—your every thought and fear, your every fulfilled and unfulfilled dream, because he lived them firsthand. He knows what it’s like to grow up feeling disconnected, rejected, exposed, and exploited. He’s been there, done that, and overcome it—so that he can meet you and love you and empower you toward deep justice. And now he offers New hope by restoring options.

JESUS’ TEACHINGS ON JUSTICE AND JUBILEE CALL US TO COMPASSIONATE ACTION

Jesus’ New lessons about class for our youth ministries don’t stop at his birth. He began his ministry and teaching by declaring his heart for justice—not in some abstract cliché but in concrete statements about his mission and his anointing. “The Spirit of the Lord is on me,” he announced, “because he has anointed me to preach good news to the poor. He has sent me to proclaim freedom for the prisoners and recovery of sight for the blind, to set the oppressed free, to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor” (Luke 4:18–19).

Jesus defined his mission as jubilee on behalf of the poor and oppressed, quoting the first two verses of Isaiah 61 and invoking for Israelites the promises of Leviticus 25 and Deuteronomy 15. Isaiah 61 describes a God who provides comfort for those who mourn, exchanges beauty for ashes and praise for despair, rebuilds ancient ruins, and restores places long devastated. “Instead of your shame,” Isaiah concludes, “you will receive a double portion, and instead of disgrace you will rejoice in your inheritance… and everlasting joy will be yours. For I, the Lord, love justice” (Isaiah 61:7–8).

“Action with and for those who suffer is the concrete expression of the compassionate life and the final criterion of being a Christian. Such acts do not stand beside the moments of prayer and worship but are themselves such moments.”

DONALD P. MCNEILL, DOUGLAS A. MORRISON, AND HENRI J. M. NOUWEN, COMPASSION

The “year of the Lord’s favor” is a reference to the Year of Jubilee, which occurred every fifty years (Leviticus 25). Jubilee was an even more extreme “year of canceling debts” (as described in Deuteronomy 15) in which debts were forgiven, new loans were granted without interest, property was returned to its original owners, and slaves were set free.

The year of canceling debts occurred every seventh year. Richard Townsell, executive director of Lawndale Christian Community Development Corporation in Chicago, offers Deuteronomy 15 as a timeless model of the kingdom’s fight to offer deep justice to the rich, the poor, and everyone in between. The Law of Moses established that every creditor, without exception, would cancel any loan made to a fellow Israelite every seven years. Why? Because the kingdom rejects systemic poverty and provides opportunities for the economically disadvantaged to break free. “There need be no poor among you … if only you fully obey the Lord your God and are careful to follow all these commands I am giving you today” (Deuteronomy 15:4–5).

Deuteronomy warned the Israelites about being reluctant to make loans as the year of canceling debts approached:

Be careful not to harbor this wicked thought… so that you do not show ill will toward your needy among your people and give them nothing. They may then appeal to the Lord against you, and you will be found guilty of sin. Give generously to them and do so without a grudging heart; then because of this the Lord your God will bless you in all your work and in everything you put your hand to. (Isaiah 15:9–10)

The passage concludes by echoing a line Jesus would ultimately repeat when rebuking Judas’ self-righteousness toward helping the poor (Matt. 26:6–13). “There will always be poor people in the land. Therefore I command you to be openhanded toward your brothers and toward the poor and needy” (v. 11).

JUBILEE JUSTICE FOR ALL CLASSES: THE SERMON ON THE MOUNT’S COMPASSIONATE ACTION

Youth ministries trying to bring about New justice in a broken world can’t escape the ramifications of Jesus’ jubilee justice for all classes. The good news is that Jesus does not leave us guessing about how to right the wrongs that imprison us, wherever we fall on the economic spectrum. He’s given our youth ministries some New snapshots of kingdom justice for all classes through the compassionate action he describes in his famous Sermon on the Mount.

Compassionate Act 1: Recognize Your Own Poverty

The formerly corrupt tax collector Matthew recounts that Jesus began the Sermon on the Mount—his longest recorded sermon and the one that best defines his kingdom values—with an unsettling premise: “Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven” (Matthew 5:3). The kingdom doesn’t belong to the wealthy, powerful, and self-reliant, but to those who recognize their poverty.

From a kingdom perspective, no matter what class you are in, you are poor. You are a sinner saved by grace, and the knowledge of your destitution apart from Jesus Christ should keep you humble.

Now’s probably a good time to point out that on the flip side, in the kingdom economy, we are also all rich. We have been saved, redeemed, and reconciled to God and to one another. Even if you have just a few dollars to your name, you have the priceless treasure of relationship with God and his kingdom community.

Since each of us is simultaneously both rich and poor, we have much to teach one another, and we have much to learn from one another. That homeless person you walk by on your way to church—she’s got something to teach you. That city mayor you’re meeting with to talk about high-risk kids in your community—he’s got something to teach you. That family displaced by hurricanes in Central America—they’ve got something to teach you. And as someone both poor in spirit and rich in grace, you have something to teach them, too.

Luke is even more explicit. In his retelling of the same story, Luke quotes Jesus this way: “Blessed are you who are poor, for yours is the kingdom of God. Blessed are you who hunger now, for you will be satisfied…But woe to you who are rich, for you have already received your comfort. Woe to you who are well fed now, for you will go hungry” (Luke 6:20–21, 24–25). In the broader context of Jesus’ entire sermon, it’s clear that Jesus is emphasizing that, whether we are financially poor or spiritually poor, we are all dependent on him.

Compassionate Act 2: Change Your Goals

Matthew’s account of Jesus’ most famous sermon continues with a number of other counterintuitive descriptions of what his kingdom represents. Jesus declares blessed those who mourn, the meek, those who hunger and thirst for righteousness (Matthew 5:4–6). His kingdom upends all that we regard as valuable—wealth, happiness, knowledge, self-assuredness, strength, and security—and provides a new range of aspirations.

The concept of shalom expresses this best. In his book Simply Christian: Why Christianity Makes Sense, British theologian N. T. Wright describes biblical justice as “putting the world to rights.” It’s the fulfillment, as Paul wrote, of all creation’s waiting “in eager expectation” to be “liberated from its bondage to decay” (Romans 8:19–23)—what the Old Testament calls shalom. More than the absence of strife, shalom is the kind of peace that holds the far reaches of the universe together. It’s what the Prince of Peace came to reestablish: the in terdependency of healthy communities; the intri cacy of our physiology; the manifold mysteries of a parent’s love; the splendor of the cosmos; and the microscopic details of subatomic matter.

“Jesus ties his being with those who are hungry, thirsty, naked, alien, imprisoned, and ill. Whatever Jesus may look like, he can be found in the struggle of the disenfranchised, not because they are holier but because they struggle for the abundant life. If we want to describe Jesus’ appearance, we need to describe the appearance of those who reside in the margins of society. If we want to commune with Christ, if we want to look into the eyes of the one we call Lord, then we can access him when we walk in solidarity, when we accompany the outcasts of society. For whatever is done or not done to one of these is done or not done to Jesus.”

MIGUEL A. DE LA TORRE, READING THE BIBLE FROM THE MARGINS

Dr. Tim Keller, founder and senior pastor of Manhattan’s Redeemer Presbyterian Church, describes shalom as the webbing together of God, humans, and all creation in a state of universal flourishing, wholeness, and delight. It’s an intricately woven garment that diminishes when things unravel physically, psychologically, and economically. Social unraveling comes when people who “have” hold on to their blessing rather than sharing and interweaving it with those who “have not.”

The condition of sin robs us of shalom, but kingdom justice restores it. The catch is that justice isn’t forced upon us. It comes as we change our priorities, as we begin to hunger and thirst after justice with a poverty of spirit that allows us to mourn its absence. Then we can pursue it with meekness, mercy, and a pure heart.

Compassionate Act 3: Give, but Give Quietly

The same sermon offers guidance on giving to the needy—“Do not announce it with trumpets, as the hypocrites do” (Matthew 6:2)—and perspective on the true value of earthly wealth—“Do not store up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moth and rust destroy, and where thieves break in and steal. But store up for yourselves treasures in heaven…For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also” (6:19–21).

The Western idea of justice revolves around protecting individual rights, but the biblical idea is the opposite: We owe one another what we have. Righting wrongs through our youth ministries means sharing our power and possessions with those around us to enable their social flourishing.

Dr. Keller again offers a convicting warning for our youth ministries: “The way you treat the poor and the way you treat [God] are absolutely linked. If you don’t treat the poor as you ought to it’s because you aren’t treating [God] as you ought to. If you have a bad relationship with the poor it’s because you have a bad relationship with [God], whether you know it or not.”

Or, to paraphrase Proverbs: If you insult the poor you insult their Maker; but if you are kind to the poor you lend to the Lord, and he will reward you (Proverbs 14:31, 19:17).

Compassionate Act 4: Forgive

Jesus also stresses kingdom economics within the prayer he teaches his disciples, the one we call the Lord’s Prayer (Matthew 6:9–13). In it, he tells us to ask for personal forgiveness only “as we also have forgiven our debtors” (v. 12). It’s not a coincidence that the fundamentals of kingdom faith—sin, its wages, redemption, forgiveness, and even people who hurt us—are described here and throughout Scripture in economic terms. Because our heart lies where our treasure is, Jesus speaks directly to the hearts of his listeners. Sinning, he says, is like racking up debts that get increasingly difficult to repay. Being sinned against is like holding a worthless promissory note that can’t be repaid. Forgiveness, whether extended or received, is like an economic transaction that relieves the debtor of his obligation to repay. But redemption comes after the price has been paid in full. Because Jesus paid the price of shalom in full, he expects nothing less than forgiveness from those who follow him.

Compassionate Act 5: Don’t Worry about Stuff

Jesus further says not to worry even about sustenance—“what you will eat or drink… or wear”—but to seek his kingdom first, and everything else will fall into place (vs. 25–34). For Americans raised on a culture of rugged individualism and Puritanical self-reliance, what could be more contrary than that? Yet God’s upside-down kingdom overturns even those things we consider most basic to our survival—food, drink, clothing. It’s the same impulse that allowed Jesus to resist the temptation to eat during his 40-day fast in the wilderness by reminding himself: “People do not live on bread alone, but on every word that comes from the mouth of God” (Matthew 4:4). Justice, kindness, compassion, and the everyday incarnational realities of the Word made flesh and living among us—these are the things that sustained Jesus throughout his ministry. And he says these are the things that must become most important for us.

We’re so busy pursuing the American Dream that the pursuit itself can keep us from seeing what really matters to the kingdom. Even within many churches, we’re told that our best life now includes material booty that comes to those who call forth blessings from on high. But Jesus says not to concern ourselves with such things. Seek God’s justice, he tells us, and all those things that keep you awake at night and preoccupy your thoughts during the day will be take care of. Mei-Ling is a woman whose life was transformed by the compassionate action of kingdom leaders. I first met Mei-Ling when we were teenagers. She visited our youth group with a friend and kept attending because she developed a crush on one of the boys. Over time I learned that her father was absent, and her mother was dying of AIDS, which she’d contracted in the 1980s through intravenous drug use or the unprotected prostitution that supported her addiction. Mei-Ling had recently returned to New York after several years living with various foster families in Puerto Rico. Odds were that Mei-Ling would drop out of high school and stay stuck in generational poverty.

A comprehensive youth development agency in Lower Manhattan, Generation Xcel exists to empower young people so they can transform their cultures and communities. It was founded in 1996 by 13 young people who defied the stereotypes about their generation and overcame the absence of money, space, equipment, or paid staff to open two youth centers, build a theater in the heart of the East Village, serve hundreds through after-school and summer-camp programs, employ dozens of neighborhood teens, invest in a retreat center upstate, and touch thousands through extensive outreach activities.

To download and hear more about indigenous leadership development in urban youth ministries, check out our free additional Deep Justice resources available at www.cyfm.net.

Instead, kingdom justice came knocking on her door.

But Mei-Ling was not destined to end up a casualty of a war she didn’t start and couldn’t finish. In her final weeks, Mei-Ling’s mother approached my parents, who were also the pastors of our church, Abounding Grace, and asked them to take in her daughter when she passed away. They agreed, and Mei-Ling became my sister. She grieved her mother’s passing, and became mildly rebellious for a while. But her adoptive family wouldn’t let her go. We understood that deep justice for Mei-Ling was worth a fight.

During high school, Mei-Ling joined 12 other young people from the same storefront church in cofounding a youth center to provide their peers refuge from the streets. Ten years later, Generation Xcel—the ministry she and her friends started without money, space, equipment, or paid staff—continues to provide opportunities for kids like Mei-Ling through after-school and summer tutoring, arts programs, athletics, and mentoring.

Because a few church leaders decided to do something about the poor getting poorer, Mei-Ling is now crossing the class canyon. She went on to complete high school and then became the first college graduate in her biological family when she got her degree from New York University. Mei-Ling remains a vital part of our church and now works as a registered nurse at NYU Medical Center, where she helps the infirm find shalom in their physical bodies.

WHO? (OBSERVATION)

Thanks to justice advocates like Bono, awareness efforts like the One Cam-paign, and (increasingly) evangelical leaders like Rick Warren from Saddleback Community Church—whose public repentance for neglecting the poor and needy was a watershed moment for evangelical America—combating global poverty has become a priority for many in the United States. The language of grace and jubilee are hallmarks of the movement. Bono, for one, is fond of saying: “Rather than ask God to bless what you’re doing, find out what he’s doing among the poor because it’s already blessed.”

As the founder and executive director of the New York-based Youth Ministries for Peace and Justice, ALEXIE TORRES-FLEMING is doing just that. The mission of Youth Ministries for Peace and Justice is twofold: First, they work to rebuild the neighborhoods of the South Bronx that were decimated in the late 1960s and early 1970s by the crack epidemic and the divestment of the city resources. Second, they mobilize young people to be prophetic voices for peace and justice. Given that Youth Ministries for Peace and Justice is located in the poorest congressional district of the United States, Alexie and her team have endless opportunities to partner with people of all classes to right wrongs.



Alexie, in thinking about deep justice when it comes to class, can you help us understand some of the reasons poverty exists in our country today?

Poverty exists in this country for one simple reason: greed. When the highest paid CEOs in this country make a base salary of $1, 273, 978 and the average worker makes around $36, 000, you can see there is no grand or complicated reason for poverty—except that some people in this country accumulate wealth. Jesus said the equality of the kingdom of God will be made manifest when we love one another as we love ourselves. Given the gap between the rich and the poor, it is quite clear that we are not treating one another by the commandment Jesus set forth to those who call themselves his disciples.

To download and hear the full audio interview with Alexie, check out our free additional Deep Justice resources available at www.cyfm.net.

From a kingdom justice perspective, what mistakes do youth workers in middle- and upper-class communities make when it comes to seeking justice for all classes?

I’ve observed that middle- and upper-class youth ministries that want to “empower” the poor often forget that people in poor communities are already empowered, and that they do not require the assistance of their well-to-do counterparts to empower them. My poor brothers and sisters have the talents, skills, and ideas necessary to challenge the structures of injustice that benefit from their oppression. This is one of the main reasons Youth Ministries for Peace and Justice has been so successful in our organizing campaigns; we partner alongside our brothers and sisters, rather than judging them or giving them the answers. I think folks from middle- and upper-class communities need to stop doing what they think needs to be done in poor communities and start listening to those closest to the problem. The poor know what changes need to be made in their communities. We need to start trusting their analysis and then have the courage to take action against those in the seat of oppression—which is, ironically, usually found in middle- and upper-class communities.



Given that, what advice would you give youth ministries that want to start seeking justice for all classes?

As someone who believes in the community-organizing model of social change, I believe it is inappropriate for me to give any solutions for another community. I would suggest that it is important to first look at yourself and truthfully assess your own level of involvement in maintaining structures of inequality. Don’t automatically assume it is someone else’s fault. The places we shop, the things we consume, the cars we drive, how we treat our employees, and so much else greatly contribute to our existing structures of inequality. Too often, middle- and upper-class folks come to the poor with the idea that the poor need to change. I truly believe people in well-to-do communities need to first take a long and honest look at themselves and come to their own conclusions about what they need to do to live the gospel of Jesus Christ faithfully.



When you think about youth ministries that have transcended their biases and preconceptions about folks in other classes, what exactly did they do?

Youth ministries that have transcended these biases and preconceptions have learned the difference between charity and justice. When young people realize that charity work (homeless shelters, food kitchens, clothing drives) deals only with the effects of injustice, while justice deals with the underlying structures or causes of injustice, they can begin to see that justice is what is necessary to have an honest and faithful relationship with people living in poorer communities.

“Four main assets can be identified in any neighborhood: (1) the capacities and gifts of local residents, (2) the power of local associations and organizations, (3) the potential of local public institutions, and (4) the diverse streams of local economic activity, including the neighborhood’s land and other physical assets.”

MARK R. GORNIK, TO LIVE IN PEACE

Can you give an example of what you mean?

I work with a coalition of youth groups around the country doing extraordinary work for social change. They train their young people in community organizing by raising social consciousness and then stepping back as the young people themselves lead campaigns for environmental justice, economic justice, education reform, immigration reform, gender equity, and so much more. They are courageous and are transforming the oppressive systems of this country, block by block.



It’s pretty clear this type of kingdom justice will only come as our youth ministries build relationships that cross the class divide. I know a lot of youth ministries want to build those types of relationships, but they don’t do it very well. Why do you think it’s so hard?

Relationships between well-to-do communities and poor communities of faith are hard to establish and maintain because they require deep levels of honesty and sincerity. These relationships need to be based on mutual respect, not on a charity model in which the wealthy are coming to save their “poor and impoverished brethren.” I think it is very hard for people to give up the inherent power and privilege that comes from being situated in the middle or upper class.

Another difficulty that arises in maintaining these relationships is that most poor communities are hesitant to deal with wealthier communities because they believe wealthy communities are not in it for the long haul. Poor communities are well aware of the fact that these relationships rarely reach the point of tackling systemic change. So people begin to question the point of forming these relationships if they are not going to be true and honest partnerships in the struggle for justice. I believe these relationships will only work when both parties are truly committed to the quest for peace and justice, rather than seeing the work as an opportunity to log a few community service hours.



In all honesty, some youth ministries probably won’t be able to make the type of long-term commitment you’re describing. Is doing a little bit better than doing nothing?

Unfortunately, I think sometimes a half-day in the inner city or a short-term mission trip can do more harm than good for suburban kids, because they can feel like they’ve done their “justice thing,” and then they become complacent.



As you’ve seen youth workers lead their ministries into deep justice, what separates those who “get it” from those who don’t?

Those who “get it” don’t assume the goal is to make all of us middle class. The work of the church is not to make people middle class. When I turn to the Acts of the Apostles, and I read what the early church did to care for the poor, the widows, and the orphans, nowhere does it say they were working with them to make them wealthier.

Our mission is not to turn poor people into capitalists who make lots of money and consume more and more. In the end, that will only make poor people here richer at the expense of poor people somewhere else.

The hope is that we all critically look at ourselves and understand the broken values within middle- and upper-class communities. We’re all guilty, and we all need to work together to create a society that is truly economically just.

HOW? (APPLICATION)

DEEP JUSTICE APPLICATION QUESTIONS

  • Which of the two either/or extremes best describes your ministry’s response to the class divide: denial or despair?
  • If you were to ask God why he had Jesus enter the world through a poor family, what do you think his answer would be? How does that answer impact your view of the Good/Guilt/Grace/Gratitude kingdom story? What are the implications of his answer for your youth ministry?
  • What would happen if you tried to launch Jubilee in your church?
  • Of the five compassionate acts, which do you think would be most effective in taking your youth ministry into deep justice? What can you do in the next few months to try to make progress in that area?
  • How do you think your youth ministry would be enriched by bringing justice to all classes?
  • Alexie asserts that “the work of the church is not to make people middle class.” What is your response to that? If you were to ask your students to react to this statement, what would they say? How about your students’ parents?
  • In light of
    ’s portrayal of the kingdom as encompassing both personal salvation and social reform, what exactly is the work of the church when it comes to class?
  • Of the following list of Deep Justice Recommended Action Steps that flow from this chapter, which would best help you as a kingdom follower right wrongs? Which would best help your youth ministry?
  • NOTES

    Rick Warren, “Myths of the Modern Mega-Church,” The Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life, pewforum.org/events/index.php?EventID=R80

    See “Income, Poverty, and Health Insurance Coverage in the United States,” U.S. Census Bureau, and “State of America’s Children, 2005” by the Children’s Defense Fund.

    Dr. Tim Keller, Resurgence Conference, 2006, jeremydelrio.com/blog/2006/11/21/thanksgiving-for-justice/

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑