Chapter 12 Who Is My Neighbor?
“Charity begins at home, and justice begins next door.”
—Charles Dickens (1812–1870)
NOW? (DISCERNMENT)
The knots in my stomach tightened. As the distance between us grew, I could feel the color leave my face. “You hypocrite,” I thought. “So busy with ministry that you pretend not to notice?”
Truthfully, I had noticed. In fact, I saw her so vividly that I crossed the street so she wouldn’t see me ignoring her. Not that it would have really made a difference. She didn’t know me from the thousands of others who ignore her every day, and we’d never even seen each other before then as far as I knew. That wasn’t the point.
The point was that I felt guilty—and I didn’t want her judging me like I was judging her. It was just shameful, especially since we’d been praying for her for weeks. Not her specifically, but for teens like her—with matted, green hair, body piercings, and unshaven armpits.
It was July 1996, and I was one of thirteen inner-city young people ages 14–22 who had joined together to open a youth center called Generation Xcel in one of the country’s oldest housing projects in Manhattan’s Lower East Side. At 21, I was the unqualified youth pastor and the oldest cofounder involved in our day-to-day activities. Like the rest of the neighborhood, we were mostly Latino, with two white girls and a black guy thrown in for good measure.
But that summer, a change had come to the neighborhood. Suddenly, there were lots of white kids hanging around, and not just the Range Rover teens and college students who liked to party at night and leave before the sun rose. Homeless and dirty, this wave of newcomers did strange things to their hair and wore funny clothes. They slept in parks and banded together for protection.
A couple of our youth leaders asked why none of the green-haired kids came to our new youth center. Good question. I suggested that we should pray for them and maybe then they’d come. So as a group, that’s what we did.
Now I found myself walking away from one of the people our youth ministry was praying for. Even worse, I was walking away from the chance to be an answer to those very prayers.
There she was, one of those girls, panhandling on a stoop across the street from the entrance to the park. And I was too busy for her. Worse, I was a phony, pretending not to notice.
I tried to justify my actions internally.
I’ve got things to do, places to go. The youth center. The interns. The kids we’re already serving.
It didn’t work, so I tried excuse-making.
Too late now. I already passed her. It wouldn’t make sense to waste more time and go backward.
Not good enough. As an aspiring attorney, I even appealed to precedent.
I’ve ignored homeless people before without feeling like this. Surely she’ll survive just as the others did.
The jury was close to reaching a verdict. And then the kicker came.
You Levite. You Pharisee. Where’s the Samaritan in you?
Conviction fell, so reluctantly I went back, wondering as I walked: What am
I going to say? “I’m sorry for ignoring you?” How weird is that?
Weird, maybe, but appropriate. A couple of false starts later, I finally walked over. “God, help me,” I muttered under my breath.
I squatted beside her, introduced myself, and awkwardly apologized for being a hypocritical youth pastor. She looked hungry, so I invited her to breakfast. She told me she hadn’t eaten in several days because her last meal—scraps from someone else’s garbage—had made her sick. She was just starting to feel better.
We went to a diner a few doors down from where she’d been sitting. She ordered French toast, as I recall, and saved half the portion for “her” stray dog, who hadn’t eaten, either. She ate. We talked.
She had run away from family problems at home and hitchhiked to the city. She said she was waiting for some friends to take her to California. She claimed to have just made an appearance on an episode of The Montel Williams Show about teenage runaways.
How much of her story was true, I don’t know. But for an hour that morning, I did everything I could to make her feel important. Like she mattered. Nothing special, really, I just tried to treat her with the dignity that God our Father gave her. Like I’d want someone else to treat my sister.
I told her about the youth center a few blocks away that we’d started “by youth for youth,” and about our church, Abounding Grace. If she or her friends ever needed anything, I promised they could visit anytime. She was grateful, but said she didn’t think she’d stick around the city long enough to take me up on the offer. Before she ate, we prayed. Before we said goodbye, I prayed for her again. That was the only time we ever met, but periodically God reminds me to pray for her some more.
I often wonder why God sent me back, why he valued the delay on my walk to work. What really happened that day? Did anything change for her?
Maybe, maybe not.
But something changed for me. That day God saved me from myself, and in the process introduced me to kingdom shalom for all classes. Hopefully, she experienced it, too.
“The dominant reality of…suffering is that people are wasted: wasted by hunger, torture, deprivation of rights. Wasted by economic exploitation, racial and ethnic discrimination, sexual suppression. Wasted by loneliness, nonrelation, noncommunity.”
MORTIMER ARIAS, ANNOUNCING THE REIGN OF GOD
Salvation visited me in the person of a homeless runaway who forced me to confront my tendency, even as a youth worker, to live for myself instead of for those around me. The most marginalized and vulnerable among us, like the homeless, are easiest to overlook now. The circumstances of those in lower classes are so foreign to many of us that it’s hard even to try to understand.
As a youth worker, I had felt trapped in the either/or lenses through which we Now view the homeless.
Either we avoid them as a nuisance or we fear them as a menace.
Either we pity them as perpetually less than human or we hope that treatment for their addictions will restore at least some of their human dignity.
Either we wish they’d get a job and contribute to society or we wish they’d disappear from our society altogether.
As if it’s our job to diagnose their problems and dictate prescriptions.
But that day I experienced a bigger kingdom reality, one that transcended my selfish either/or myopia. Regardless of how or why people may have found themselves homeless, the kingdom requires that I not view them as inconveniences or threats or somehow less than human. The kingdom requires that I love them as neighbors.
NEW? (REFLECTION)
THE SCANDAL OF LUKE 10
“What must I do to inherit eternal life?”
The question sounds innocent enough, but its questioner, a lawyer, was attempting to test Jesus. Jesus deftly turned the tables. “How do you read it?” he asked. The man replied simply: “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength and with all your mind’; and, ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’”
“You have answered correctly,” Jesus replied. “Do this and you will live” (Luke 10:25–28).
Do this, and you will live. Coming from Jesus, those six little words burst with meaning. The unending life he offers brings joy and peace and abundance, and its citizenship rests in his kingdom. If that’s the New life our youth ministries want, we must first understand the “this” that Jesus requires us to do.
Curiously, the “this” Jesus speaks of is not the salvation formula we evangelicals describe. There’s nothing in the lawyer’s response about repeating a prayer or responding to an altar call or attending a 12-week discipleship class. Instead this New life he promises grows in proportion to obedience to three commands:
Love God.
Love your neighbor.
And, perhaps most difficult of all, love yourself.
In these three commands, we’re given four New steps that help us walk down the road of deep justice. Whether we spring or crawl, these four New steps are essential to the path of deep justice for the rich, the destitute, and everyone in between.
New Step 1: Receiving Personal Justice
As our youth ministries think about deep justice for all classes, it’s easy to overlook Jesus’ command to love ourselves, and focus only on loving God and others. Still, this third command is there as the standard by which the other two are measured. It’s there when Jesus explains how we love God: with all our heart, soul, strength, and mind. If we resent who we are—if we think we’re not smart enough or we’re too weak or too unattractive or too emotional—then we’re with-holding our love for him. He wants us in our entirety, withholding nothing.
If we confuse who we are—who God has made us to be—with the circumstances which have landed each of us in a certain class, we end up bringing him the wrong gift. If we define ourselves by our economic status or the people with whom we associate—I’m rich or poor or cool or nerdy—then we hide behind those associations rather than probing deeper to see what God really cherishes in us. Every day our culture attempts to define us by our material surroundings—the trappings of wealth, or poverty, or middle-class striving. The American Dream teaches us to aspire to more and more stuff—the cliché white picket fence in a safe subdivision with a high-def plasma flat screen. Music, movies, and fashion moguls all tell us last year’s hot list needs to be replaced with this year’s even hotter list.
Therefore, I urge you, brothers and sisters, in view of God’s mercy, to offer your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy and pleasing to God—this is true worship. Do not conform to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind. Then you will be able to test and approve what God’s will is—his good, pleasing and perfect will.
For by the grace given me I say to every one of you: Do not think of yourself more highly than you ought, but rather think of yourself with sober judgment, in accordance with the faith God has distributed to each of you.
ROMANS 12:1–3
But when we allow our socioeconomic class and possessions to define us, we miss out on the richness of receiving justice for ourselves. The Apostle Paul tells us in his seminal letter to the church in Rome not to conform to the world’s standards of beauty and value but to be transformed by the renewing of our minds. Receiving personal justice means learning to see what God sees in us and to appreciate what God appreciates so we don’t think of ourselves “more highly than (we) ought,” but “with sober judgment.” Instead, Paul invites each of us to offer our whole self as “a living sacrifice, holy and pleasing to God, which is our spiritual act of worship.” Everything else, including the capacity to view our neighbors through the prism of heaven, flows through that.
New Step 2: Justifying Ourselves by Extending Justice to Others
The lawyer who questioned Jesus in Luke 10 understood the self-love part of the equation. Brimming with self-confidence, he was, after all, attempting to trap the incarnated Word in a battle of words. But “wanting to justify himself,” he comes back for more and asks the critical question: “Who is my neighbor?”
Jesus responds with a parable about a man on a journey. On an isolated stretch of road, thieves rob him, beat him, and leave him battered and bloodied in a ditch. In time, the local priest (or, in our context, the pastor) passes by on his way to the synagogue (the church). Too hurried to stop, he crosses the street and pretends not to notice. Then a Levite (the worship leader) also approaches, perhaps on the way to the same church. He follows the pastor’s lead and similarly ignores the man.
“The true fellowship of the poor is of more value than all the alms and development aid of the rich…the fellowship of the poor and suffering Christ is the secret of the ‘holy church’ and the ‘communion of saints.’”
JÜRGEN MOLTMANN, THE CHURCH IN THE POWER OF THE SPIRIT
Then a Samaritan rounds the corner. Unlike the pastor and worship leader, he doesn’t pretend not to see. Kingdom compassion compels him to right wrongs for all classes, so he rolls up his sleeves and prepares to get dirty.
Why did Jesus make the “neighbor” in his story a Samaritan? Why not the priest or the Levite? Why not a Jewish layperson? The reason has everything to do with the race and class issues of Jesus’ day. The Jews to whom Jesus was preaching, even his own disciples, reviled Samaritans. Most infamously, in Luke 9—the chapter before this parable—Jesus rebuked James and John (the disciple whom “he loved”) for praying that fire would consume a Samaritan village.
Samaritans were hated because they descended from Assyrian soldiers who centuries earlier had conquered Israel and marched all the able-bodied survivors across the desert as slaves. The infirm and vulnerable who were left behind—the elderly, women, and children—were plundered and raped. When exiled Jews returned years later, they found children fathered by the Assyrian conquistadors. These they called Samaritans—and their presence in Israel reminded Jews of slavery, colonialism, and injustice.
Yet this Samaritan’s love mirrors God’s kingdom love. “Go and do likewise,” Jesus tells the lawyer. Learn to love like this Samaritan loved. Then you’ll truly live.
To find out more about how neighborhoods and “space” foster identity, check out our free Deep Justice resources available on www.cyfm.net.
The Samaritan’s love for his Jewish neighbor, even though the broken man likely would have disdained him under different circumstances, was made possible because the Samaritan, who had been marginalized his entire life, had learned how to love.
New Step 3: Moving Beyond Compassion to Justice
It was compassion that compelled the Samaritan to respond to the bloody mass of human flesh beside the road. But it was justice that kept him there. Kingdom justice required him to get dirty, and restoring shalom meant overcoming the absence of adequate remedies for the battered man’s need. There was no 911 operator to call. There were no EMTs to provide urgent care and high-speed transports to a hospital. There wasn’t an appropriate health care facility nearby, and no insurance or Medicaid to finance treatment.
Yet shalom came to the battered man because the Samaritan was willing not only to sit with him in the ditch, give him water, and bandage his wounds (a compassionate response), but also to transport him to an inn, personally care for him overnight, and prepay his medical expenses. Compassion, as commonly practiced in youth ministries today, would have served the beaten man but stopped short of healing him. But Christ’s kingdom justice brought healing and reconciliation and restoration.
New Step 4: Being Kind
Finally, righting wrongs on behalf of the least among us requires rejecting oppression of those in any class and replacing it with kindness. Proverbs 14:31 reads, “Whoever oppresses the poor shows contempt for their Maker, but whoever is kind to the needy honors God.” The word kind in this verse is the Hebrew word for grace. The gospel tells us that, because of grace, God loved us despite our inability to love him back. The price of sin, which corrupted humankind and disrupted shalom, was death. But God’s grace—his infinite kindness—paid the price of that sin so we wouldn’t have to die.
“Revolutions begin when people who are defined as problems achieve the power to redefine the problem.”
JOHN MCKNIGHT, THE CARELESS SOCIETY
When our youth ministries remember this, then looking down on the poor becomes repulsive. If we realize when we see those who are poor that we’re looking in the mirror because we’re “poor in spirit,” then we won’t feel superior. Their economic need matches our spiritual need. Just as the remedy for spiritual poverty began with someone else’s kindness, so too the remedy for economic poverty begins with kindness.
FAITH, NOT WORKS, BUT FAITH WITHOUT WORKS IS DEAD
Amidst all this talk about justice for all classes, I can hear the time-honored clatter of skeptics who would remind us that we’ve been saved by grace through faith—not by works (Ephesians 2:8–9). But God’s saving grace demands a response. When Jesus instructed us to love him and others as ourselves, he wasn’t urging passive acceptance of something that would be imposed on us externally. Instead, he imbues his invitation to love with everything that makes the act of loving someone meaningful. Love that is coerced or otherwise manipulated is no love at all. But love that is voluntary and active demonstrates itself in how we choose to treat others.
Evangelicals esteem John 3:16 as our credo for personal salvation: “For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life.” The ubiquitous reference is everywhere, from bumper stickers and gospel tracts to sporting event banners and altar calls. Sometimes we even quote verse 17 for good measure: “For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but to save the world through him.”
But what about another passage most likely written by the same author: John 3:16? “This is how we know what love is: Jesus Christ laid down his life for us. And we ought to lay down our lives for one another.” (Emphasis added.) In case laying down our lives for one another is too vague a concept, John elaborates again in verse 17: “If any one of you has material possessions and sees his brother or sister in need but has no pity on them, how can the love of God be in you?”
We live in a culture where our economic class dictates where we can live, who our friends are, which educational and career options we have, and how we view the world. Some would argue that class is even more important than race, religion, and ethnicity, because in a who-you-know world, wealth associates with wealth and begets more wealth. But 1 John requires that even in this culture, the poor and rich alike are siblings, and kingdom justice requires that we and our youth ministries lay down our very lives for the benefit of all classes.
WHO? (OBSERVATION)
The good news is that evangelicals are starting to reconcile John 3:16 and 1 John 3:16 by righting wrongs for all classes. In the tradition of Saint Francis of Assisi—who spent his life serving the poor and urged his fellow Christians to preach the gospel always (and even use words if necessary)—SHANE CLAIBORNE is a modern exemplar Who embodies the kind of selfless self-love to which Christ calls us. Shane lives out this love as part of an Acts 2 community called the Simple Way in Philadelphia.
Shane, for those who haven’t read your book The Irresistible Revolution, what is the mission of the Simple Way?
We sort of stumbled into all this. I am from the Bible Belt in East Tennessee, but when I was a student at Eastern University, some friends and I heard about a group of 40 poor and homeless families who were living in an abandoned cathedral in North Philadelphia. The archdiocese was trying to evict them from the cathedral; if the families didn’t leave, they were facing arrest for trespassing on church property. That didn’t add up for us, so we decided to do something about it.
I remember the first night we drove down to the cathedral to meet the people. On the front of the cathedral, they had hung a banner that said, “How can we worship a homeless man on Sunday and ignore one on Monday?” We knocked on the cathedral’s front door and the families just wrapped their arms around us, poured out their stories and struggles, and invited us in. We went back to Eastern really stirred up, and we organized students to come alongside those families. Eventually 100 of us were involved in that housing crisis. Thanks to the attention of other kingdom-minded people as well as the media, the families received housing.
To download and hear the full audio interview with Shane, check out our free additional Deep Justice resources available at www.cyfm.net.
“I remember hearing about an old comic strip… Two guys are talking to each other, and one of them says he has a question for God. He wants to ask why God allows all of this poverty and war and suffering to exist in the world. And his friend says, ‘Well, why don’t you ask?’ The fellow shakes his head and says he is scared. When his friend asks why, he mutters, ‘I’m scared God will ask me the same question.’”
SHANE CLAIBORNE, THE IRRESISTIBLE REVOLUTION
To find out more about how the multiple layers of our neighborhoods shape us and our kids, check out our free resources available at www.cyfm.net.
About two years later, we started the Simple Way. Simple Way is simply a community trying to live like the early church. We see the kingdom of God as something that we are to live out incarnationally in neighborhoods that are struggling as well as in neighborhood that are beautiful.
As you have spent time with the poor in Philadelphia, in other cities in the U.S., as well as in countries like India and Iraq, what have you learned about the causes of poverty, and how we as kingdom people should respond?
Mother Teresa said, so well, “Poverty is not created by God, but by you and me because we haven’t figured out how to love.” It’s clear in Scripture that God never intends for people to be poor, but that our ignorance and our indifference allow poverty to continue. I think in God’s eyes it’s an absolutely heartbreaking reality that there are people on the streets while other folks have extra bedrooms in their houses. That there are kids starving while others have extra food in their cupboards. Our justice work flows from a real love of God and of neighbor that recognizes that these blessings of God are too good to keep for ourselves. God created enough stuff for all of us, but when we take more than our share and insulate ourselves from our neighbors, it creates poverty. Gandhi was right when he said there is enough for everyone’s need, but there is not enough for everyone’s greed.
You just mentioned love for our neighbor. When Jesus said, “Love your neighbor as yourself,” who is our neighbor?
When I was in East Tennessee, “love your neighbor as yourself” meant Southern hospitality. It meant sharing sugar with the person who lived next door.
That’s beautiful, but it’s not enough. Our neighbor is also the person who is sleeping on the streets. Our neighbor is the refugee in Iraq. Our neighbor is the person who is deeply suffering in this world.
Jesus could have said, “Love your neighbor as much as I love you,” or “Love your neighbor a whole bunch,” but he said, “Love your neighbor as yourself.” What does it mean to love our neighbors as ourselves?
Grounding our love for others in our love for ourselves is so essential because it’s so important to know we are loved. We all deeply long to know we are loved. We try to prove we are lovable in so many heart-wrenching ways. We try to fill our longing for love with stuff and with addictions and with forms of love and intimacy that are unsatisfying. In the middle of that, if we hear that whisper that we are loved, it fills us with love and compassion for other people, because just like us, they are created in the image of God.
When you think of youth workers who are seeking God’s justice for all classes, what makes them effective?
They model it. I think we replicate who we are. So it’s impossible to develop students who care about the poor if we don’t care about the poor. It’s impossible to produce disciples if we’re not following after Jesus. The youth workers I know who are having incredible fruit in this area of justice are people who are living with integrity—and their students are magnetized toward that.
Mother Teresa was so insightful when she said, “Of course we care about the poor. Everybody cares about the poor. But if we really care about the poor, we can name them.”
What would you say to a youth worker who wants to be involved in deep justice for all classes but is doing ministry in a church where that sort of thing isn’t all that welcome?
I would say get ready to get in trouble. So many of the things that are at the core of the gospel are in conflict with our culture that there comes a point where they collide and we realize, “Oh my gosh. My kingdom really is not of this world.” If we don’t have some collision with the culture, then are we really imagining what it means to follow Jesus and be a part of another kingdom?
“The reality of our rebirth should mess with us.”
SHANE CLAIBORNE, THE IRRESISTIBLE REVOLUTION
My mom has taught me this well, because my mom has been on the journey of figuring this out with me, and she was not always supportive. A few years ago my mom said to me, “I used to pray that you’d be safe. Now I’m not sure that’s the best prayer, because I look at Christians throughout history, and they’re not safe. I’m not sure that we’re called to safety, but we’re promised that if we’re where God wants us to be, then there is no place better to be than that. So I pray that you would be where God wants you to be. Maybe there is no more dangerous place to be as Christians than to be in comfort and detached and isolated from the suffering of our neighbor.”
I would also say that I have such deep admiration for youth pastors who are trying to gently open up these questions, because it has to be done with so much humility and grace. Jesus was so wise. He asked a lot of questions. He didn’t go around hammering the answers down people’s throats. In fact, when people would figure it out—“Oh, you’re the Messiah!”—he’d respond, “Shhh. Let everybody figure that out. Let people ask the questions and enter into this, and then it’s their journey.”
What advice would you give a youth worker who’s passionate to help kids love their neighbors and seek God’s justice for all classes, but doesn’t know how to start?
Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. would say we’re called to be the Good Samaritan—but then after we’ve lifted so many people out of the ditch, we start to wonder if the whole road to Jericho needs to be repaved. We want students to reach that point, but they only get there by lifting a lot of people out of the ditch. It comes from getting our hands dirty. It comes from beginning to feel some discomfort and pain with the things that are wrong with the world. Feeling the pain of people who are suffering in the systems and the principalities and powers stirs up the bigger questions around justice like, What is the dream God has for this creation and how are we a part of incarnating that?
In the midst of getting our hands dirty, how do we help our service be than a placebo that alleviates our students’ guilt? How can our justice work instead change the way our students view their role in more our world?
I once heard someone say that this whole adventure is not just about having better vision but about having new eyes. Youth pastors who are living out kingdom justice are starting to have kids who have new eyes. These kids begin to look at people of all classes differently and wonder, “Maybe my neighbor is the high school lunch lady or the person who’s cleaning my bathroom. Maybe that person has a story that I want to know.” Those kids often come from ministries where the leaders are asking, “Who is it that’s making our clothes? Where did this coffee come from? Let’s try to trace some of the products we use every day to their sources and figure out who those invisible people are.” When we start to see that this is a global neighborhood where we’re all interdependent on one another, we end up wanting to make sure the people who make our jackets and shoes are treated fairly.
“There is a movement bubbling up that goes beyond cynicism and celebrates a new way of living, a generation that stops complaining about the church it sees and becomes the church it dreams of.”
SHANE CLAIBORNE, THE IRRESISTIBLE REVOLUTION
I’ve received letters from youth groups who are now making their clothes together as a way of doing something creative to identify with people who are making clothes and to make sure their clothes are made in ways that don’t suppress other folks. Another youth ministry went out to pick cotton and vegetables so they could identify with the folks who do that every day to provide things we need. I know some teenage girls who have committed to visiting senior citizen homes and painting the nails of elderly women who never have guests. They just sit and listen to their stories. There are so many questions that rise up from this type of justice work.
What type of impact do those types of justice experiences have on kids long term?
Creative justice work stirs up all kinds of bigger questions around vocation. Maybe I’m going to be a doctor or a lawyer, but what kind of doctor or lawyer am I going to be? How am I going to use my gifts for kingdom justice and for my neighbors?
Shane, any last thoughts for youth workers trying to seek deep justice with and for all classes?
When we settle for something short of the dreams God has for us then everybody loses. I think that if young people turn away from the gospel and the church, it’s not going to be because we didn’t entertain them well. It’s because we didn’t dare them to risk. We didn’t dare them to try the gospel as a way of life. I think it’s a fun time to be alive, and I’m excited to be a part of this conversation. I’ll be praying for all the youth pastors who will be entering into this conversation, and for those who lose their jobs because of it.
HOW? (APPLICATION)
DEEP JUSTICE APPLICATION QUESTIONS

