Chapter 10 of 26

Chapter 6 How Do We Help Students Move from Doing Kingdom Thingsto Being Kingdom People?

Chapter 6 How Do We Help Students Move from Doing Kingdom Thingsto Being Kingdom People?

NOW? (DISCERNMENT)

Have you ever wondered why your kids seem fired up for deep justice after spending a day feeding the homeless, but the next week they ditch the chance to right wrongs on the street and instead go to Magic Mountain?

Maybe you’ve found that even though your kids say they “want to make a difference,” the majority want to make a trip to the mall first.

Kids today are known to draw their significance from helping others, but most of yours seem drawn first to video games.

The evidence Now points to two conflicting trends: either kids are selfish or they are selfless. As youth workers who want to help students dig into deeper kingdom justice, we’re left wondering: Which one is it?

The truth is: They are both. No kid is 100 percent selfish or 100 percent selfless. As they navigate issues of identity, autonomy, and belonging, adolescents Now swing between self-denial and self-gratification—sometimes within the same five minutes.

The fact that adolescents can think about others is partly why it’s not all that hard Now to get them to take some baby steps in righting wrongs—to give some money to sponsor a kid overseas, or to choose coffee that is fair trade. The fact that they’re still self-focused partly explains why they trip and fall and never race toward kingdom justice as a lifestyle.

MOVING THE NEEDLE

This tension between kids’ ability to care about others and their ability to care about themselves can be pictured like a gauge with a needle that wavers between selfishness and selflessness.

Kids Waver Between Selfishness and Selflessness

As Tony Campolo describes later in this chapter, it’s ultimately the Holy Spirit who moves the needle for kids. Yet the Holy Spirit often works in and through (and though we hate to admit it, sometimes despite) us as kingdom people. When we as youth workers Now try to create an environment in which the Holy Spirit is more able to move students from doing kingdom things to being kingdom people, we tend to resort to a few typical strategies.

Typical Strategy 1: Learn More Scripture

I love Scripture. As you know from

, I love the way the story of Scripture prods us to right wrongs.

But learning more Scripture Now is not enough to catapult average kids—or average adults—from doing kingdom work to being kingdom people. We know that from an experiment showing how rarely people stop to help someone in need who crosses their path. Literally.

In the experiment, students at a New Jersey graduate school were asked to give spontaneous, unplanned speeches in another building on campus. Students were told to head to the new building quickly, since they only had a few minutes before delivering their “pop” speeches.

The two researchers had “planted” a man along the path to the new building. Not only was he lying on the ground and wearing disheveled clothing, but he also appeared to be semi-comatose. Every student who walked that path had a decision to make: With the deadline of a spontaneous speech on their minds, would they stop or would they keep walking?

The majority did not stop. Those students who were told they had only a few minutes to get to the new building were especially unlikely to stop and help.

That might not be all that startling. But I’ve left out a few important details that might surprise you. First, the study didn’t take place at just any graduate school. It was conducted at Princeton Theological Seminary, meaning the students—both those who stopped and those who didn’t—were likely preparing for ministry.

Second, the researchers had given the soon-to-be-ministers a topic for their spontaneous speeches: the Good Samaritan. So those students were probably mulling over the Good Samaritan narrative even as they walked past the man lying on the ground.

It’s not that the seminary students weren’t committed to God. And it’s not that they didn’t know what the Bible says about helping others in need. They were just about to stand up and preach about it. In the midst of studying Scripture, there was still a deep disconnect between what they knew in their heads and what they showed with their lives.

Jesus ran into this gap between knowledge and action constantly, especially when he dealt with religious leaders. He reserved his harshest words for those who claimed to know about God while their lives showed they didn’t really know God.

If you want proof that simply studying Scripture isn’t enough to move your students toward becoming kingdom people, check out Matthew 23, a passage commonly known as the “Seven Woes.” Jesus starts his speech to the crowds and his disciples with some relatively positive words: “The teachers of the law and the Pharisees sit in Moses’ seat. So you must be careful to do everything they tell you” (Matthew 23:2–3a).

If I were one of the teachers in the crowd, hearing those words would cause my shoulders to relax a bit. Finally, this Jesus of Nazareth wasn’t condemning me! Instead, he was acknowledging my authority as a successor of Moses to teach the law. He was even commanding his followers to obey me.

But then Jesus lets loose.

“But do not do what they do, for they do not practice what they preach” (Matthew 23:3b).

So much for relaxing.

In the rest of the chapter, Jesus gives seven examples of the gap between what the Pharisees teach and how they live. When it comes to helping kids right wrongs, I am fascinated by Matthew 23:27 when Jesus says these teachers are “hypocrites” who are “like whitewashed tombs, which look beautiful on the outside but on the inside are full of the bones of the dead and everything unclean.”

In Jesus’ day, anyone who stepped on a grave became ceremonially unclean for seven days. In order to prevent the accidental tromping of graves, graves were whitewashed (painted white) every year before Passover to make them more visible,especially at night. On the outside these graves appeared clean and pristine. On the inside they were full of rotting corpses and filthy earthworms.

“Anyone out in the open who…touches a human bone or a grave, will be unclean for seven days.”

NUMBERS 19:16

When it comes to righting wrongs 2000 years later, we often try teaching more Scripture to move kids’ needles toward justice as a lifestyle. But if the Holy Spirit hasn’t really permeated who they are and changed them into kingdom people, no matter how pretty they may look when they serve, there’s decay down deep inside.



Typical Strategy 2: More Chances to Serve

If more Bible isn’t enough to move kids toward deep justice, maybe giving them more chances to serve will do the trick. Unfortunately, as with the first strategy, research tells us otherwise.

As we saw in

, the way we sometimes devalue the contributions of those with whom we partner can make them feel dehumanized and separated from God’s kingdom story as it unfolds on earth. But if we are really honest, some of us Now care more about the transformation that occurs in our own students than what happens among those who are supposed to benefit most immediately from our justice ministries. At least we can be sure that short-term mission (STM) trips are effective in moving the needle for the 13-and 17-year-olds we load onto buses and airplanes for a week of service and social justice.

Maybe, maybe not. When Kurt Ver Beek and his team from Calvin College studied more than 100 North American STMers, they examined 11 factors, including their levels of giving and the time spent volunteering, reading about missions, and praying for missions. In the case of financial giving to the organization that sponsored their trip, 16 percent reported that their giving significantly increased after the trip; 44 percent reported a slight increase in giving; 40 percent reported no increase.

Ver Beek then compared the STMers’ impressions of their own giving with the financial records of the mission organizations. According to the records, only 25 percent of the participants gave at all to the mission organization that sponsored their trip. Financial giving to the STMers’ own churches increased an average of 1 percent, with six churches experiencing an increase in giving and eleven churches actually receiving less money.

Further studies about short-term mission trips should leave us questioning whether the “If we send them, they will grow” mantra is really true. Consider the following:

  • The explosive growth in the number of STM trips among both kids and adults has not been accompanied by similar explosive growth in the number of career missionaries.
  • It’s not clear whether or not participation in STM trips causes participants to give more money to alleviate poverty once life returns to “normal.”
  • Participating in a STM trip does not seem to reduce participants’ tendencies toward materialism.
  • These provocative findings make us wonder: What New approaches can we take to create space for the Holy Spirit to transform kids into kingdom people long after that “social justice high” wears off?

    NEW? (REFLECTION)

    For more insights about findings from our short-term missions research, please see our Deep Justice Journeys Curriculum and resources at www.fulleryouthinstitute.org/deep-justice.

    KIDS AND JUSTICE: WHAT MTV HAS TO SAY

    It’s not just those of us in the church who have something to say about moving youth from doing kingdom things to being kingdom people. MTV has a voice too.

    In 2006, MTV conducted a nationwide survey in order to understand how and why youth in America are already active in social causes.

    Here’s what that study found:

  • Of the kids they surveyed, 70 percent say it’s important to help others in need. Only 19 percent are “very involved” in doing so.
  • The Top Five reasons kids are not involved are:
    1. It’s just not for me (18 percent).
    2. I like to hang out with friends (15 percent).
    3. I don’t have enough time (14 percent).
    4. I don’t know how to get started (14 percent).
    5. I want to see concrete results (8 percent).
  • 62 percent say the issues that matter most to them are those that have touched them or someone they know.
  • 70 percent of kids involved in activism report that their parents’ encouragement played a major factor in their choice to get involved.
  • The top two factors that would motivate kids to be more involved are:
    1. If they could do the activity with their friends.
    2. If they had more time to volunteer, or more convenient volunteer activities.
  • As we think about our roles in creating space for the Holy Spirit to transform self-centered kids into kingdom people, one New theme emerges from the MTV findings: Justice needs to hit kids close to home. It needs to be in their home literally—as we invite parents both to exemplify and to encourage their own kids to right wrongs around them. It needs to hit close to home thematically—as we help kids understand how particular injustices relate to their lives. It needs to hit home logistically—as we offer opportunities that can be done at various times and at various levels of intensity. It needs to hit home personally—as we expose our kids to people who have been oppressed, thereby giving injustice a face and a name. And justice ministry needs to hit home relationally—as we help kids right wrongs in partnership with their friends.

    Many of us have found that the parents of our kids are one of the chief obstacles to deep justice. Whether it is parents’ fear of the unknown, or their hesitation to have their family’s status quo shaken, often justice isn’t all that close to our kids’ homes. To find out more about how to help parents catch a vision for deep justice, check out the free resources available at www.fulleryouthinstitute.org/deep-justice.

    CONVERSATIONS THAT HIT HOME

    To help engage in New conversations that both hit home and provide opportunities for the Holy Spirit toward kingdom justice, we recommend an experiential education framework originally proposed by Laura Joplin

    , and later modified and used by Terry Linhart
    on youth STM trips.

    To learn more about this model and how to apply it to deep justice with your own students, check out the Deep Justice resources available for free at www.fulleryouthinstitute.org/deep-justice.

    Component 1: FOCUS

    As students start doing justice work, we need to help them FOCUS and prepare for both the victories and challenges they will experience. Some key topics that could be included in this New FOCUS time are:

  • Identifying our motivations for serving (both the shared motivation we have as a youth ministry and the honest reasons individuals have for doing justice work).
  • Honestly exploring some of our fears and anxieties about what it means to seek God’s justice for the broken and brokenhearted.
  • Seeking to understand what God is already doing in those we will be meeting and serving.
  • Identifying ways to ensure that we don’t objectify or exploit those we serve, while also being intentional about our own growth.
  • If we’re entering a different ethnic culture or economic class, efforts to increase cross-cultural understanding as part of our FOCUS can deepen our kingdom impact. According to David A. Livermore in Serving with Eyes Wide Open, youth ministries often lack “cultural intelligence,” or “CQ.” As a result we may underestimate the differences between our own culture and the culture of those we are serving—causing us to offend or unintentionally insult those in the other culture. Or we overestimate the differences between the cultures, causing an artificial distance to develop between “us” and “them.” As youth workers we can help students FOCUS on cross-cultural understanding by learning how our own culture shapes us, understanding some basic differences among cultures as a whole, and identifying key differences between our culture and the other culture.

    During this FOCUS time, we may also want to encourage our students to keep written journals of their thoughts and feelings as they think about what lies ahead. Or we might want our group to study certain chunks of Scripture or even memorize passages that seem especially relevant to our justice work.

    Component 2: ACTION-REFLECTION

    A main component in creating space for the Holy Spirit to move students toward deep justice is the ACTION-REFLECTION process. In this ongoing cycle, students are placed in a situation or activity in which they are purposefully stretched by using a new set of skills or by exposure to New injustices.

    Whether it’s flirting with a new girl at school or talking with a homeless person over sack lunches, students are constantly making meaning out of their experiences. Though they are usually unconscious of this process, students are continually engaged in a highly personal, ongoing internal “conversation” about who they are in relation to God and others. Since these thoughts often go unspoken, students may draw conclusions from their experiences that do not reflect reality. As adult youth workers walking alongside students in the midst of New justice experiences, we can help the Holy Spirit move the needle by asking questions that help them decipher the meaning behind what they’ve experienced.

    One way to help students more accurately interpret their justice experiences is to ask three New questions:

  • What?
  • So what?
  • Now what?
  • According to Dr. Duane Elmer of Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, we who seek deep justice should remember a few principles:

    1. All of us are products of our unique cultural heritages, which dictate how we see and interact with the world.
    2. We tend to think everyone else sees and interacts with the world the same way we do.
    3. Withholding judgment can be the best gift we give to another person.
    4. Asking why another person behaves in a certain way helps us suspend judgment and learn more about that person’s cultural heritage.

    DUANE ELMER, CROSS-CULTURAL CONNECTIONS

    By asking “What?” students have a chance to talk about what they actually saw, heard, smelled, and felt. In asking “So what?” students have an opportunity to think about the difference this experience can make in their lives. By reflecting upon “Now what?” students can consider how they want to live, act, or be kingdom people in the weeks and months to come.

    Component 3: SUPPORT-FEEDBACK

    “I’m often at national conventions where short-term missions organizations are exhibiting. When I walk up to talk to ministry reps from these organizations, I ask them how the national church is engaged in what they’re doing. Consistently I hear, ‘Oh yes, we’re very committed to working with the national churches there. We ask them if they want to be involved.’ Did you catch that? We ask them if they want to be involved. Maybe we should start by asking if we should be involved at all, and if so, how?”

    DAVID A. LIVERMORE, SERVING WITH EYES WIDE OPEN

    To facilitate the ACTION-REFLECTION cycle, Joplin recommends surrounding the discussions and experiences with walls of SUPPORT and FEEDBACK. The support usually comes from other people involved in the experience, such as other students, adult leaders, and community members.

    Unfortunately, many youth workers who long to move students’ needles toward deeper justice overlook the importance of high quality, ongoing feedback. As the ACTION-REFLECTION cycle continues throughout the learning process, we must jump in with the students and help them talk about their reflections. Good feedback offered in the context of supportive conversations can help students see the systemic injustices that contribute to the wrongs they’ve tried to right through the ACTION of Component 2.

    Component 4: DEBRIEF

    When the action component is completed, the students begin the process of DEBRIEF. Different from the reflection time (which many of us call “debriefing”), the DEBRIEF used in the Joplin model is an organized process of identifying what learning has happened, discussing it with others, and evaluating it. This process can be done individually but is most effectively done in community.

    Component 5: LEARNING TRANSFER

    Part of the reason we so often fail to move kids toward deeper justice is we ignore the final component that makes justice work meaningful: LEARNING TRANSFER. Since most of the significant learning during justice work takes place in a context different from students’ normal day-to-day environments, the students often don’t know how to transfer the learning to their own lives. If we’re going to help create space for the Holy Spirit to transform kids into kingdom people, we need to gather with them regularly to translate what they have seen, heard, and felt into deeper justice every day. Whether we do this with one student at a time or with large groups, LEARNING TRANSFER is time consuming. But we’ll never help kids embrace justice as a New lifestyle without it.

    WHO? (OBSERVATION)

    Who has done more to help move kids from doing kingdom work to becoming kingdom people—the church or MTV?

    You might be surprised by TONY CAMPOLO’S answer. (On second thought, if you know much about Tony, you might not be so surprised after all.) As a nationally renowned speaker, longtime professor of sociology at Eastern University, and founder of the Evangelical Association for the Promotion of Education, Dr. Anthony Campolo has spent the last forty years motivating the church to care about those outside its walls. During that time, Tony has encountered plenty of youth ministries that create space for the Holy Spirit to move kids’ needles from doing kingdom work to being kingdom people. But as you’ll read below, he’s also bumped into youth workers and kids who seem to prefer splashing around in shallow justice waters.

    To download and hear the full audio interview with Tony, check out our free additional Deep Justice resources available at www.fulleryouthinstitute.org/deep-justice.

    Tony, the media sends mixed messages about kids today. Some reports label them selfish and self-focused while others call them selfless. What do you think about kids today—are they selfish, selfless, or both?

    It’s all across the spectrum. I think to generalize about young people is a serious mistake. I find that the studies collecting empirical data show that in general there is an egocentricity to young people. However, the same studies indicate that young people with deep religious convictions have moved in a very altruistic direction. So, you can say one thing about young people in general, but another thing about young people who have deep religious orientations.



    In the midst of relationship with Jesus making a difference in kids’ levels of altruism, why do many youth workers find that their kids would rather go to Disneyland for a weekend than feed the homeless for a weekend?

    I think a lot depends on where you live. I’ve observed regional differences in terms of how young people look at life. I think the Eastern seaboard has nurtured in young people a more serious orientation to social problems. In some parts of the country, like California, the segregation of the affluent in the suburbs and the poor is very dramatic. In cities in the Northeast, the interaction is much, much more prevalent, and this of course leads to young people becoming more conscious about the needs of the poor because they see the poor. It’s very hard to get excited about doing something for the poor and the oppressed if you don’t see them on a constant basis. But when you have to ride with them on the subway trains and see the homeless on the streets—when you are confronting poverty constantly—you will be more inclined to respond to those needs.

    I find that in certain newer sections of the country, the segregation between the middle class and the underclass is much more pronounced. And that of course disengages young people from where the needs really are.



    In thinking about the kingdom of God, what’s the difference between simply doing kingdom tasks and being kingdom people?

    The difference is that those who are into good works often do not have an overarching view of what the kingdom is all about. To be kingdom people is to be committed to the transformation of the world that is into the world that ought to be. It’s to be involved in recognizing that when Jesus came into the world, he came not to get people into some kingdom in the sky somewhere. He came to transform people into agents of change who will work toward the realization of the social justice dimensions of Scripture.

    There are people who are trying to actualize what many of us call the “Isaiah covenant” outlined in Isaiah 65:17–25 where there’s a call to change the world into a society in which children do not die in infancy, old people live out their lives in health, people have decent housing and good jobs, environmentalism is a reality, and people live with hope for the future. We don’t do good works in order to get people to listen to the gospel. Instead, the gospel is the good news that God is at work in the world through people to transform this world into a society that actualizes what the Hebrew prophets were all about.

    “God’s kingdom is a new society that Jesus wants to create in this world—within human history, not after the Second Coming or a future apocalypse or anything else. But right now.”

    BRIAN D. MCLAREN AND TONY CAMPOLO, ADVENTURES IN MISSING THE POINT

    Anyone who reads Scripture seriously can’t help but notice the themes of justice and care for the poor. Some youth workers tend to think that if we just teach more Scripture, then kids will become people who transform the world from what it is to what God wants it to be. What would you say to someone who thinks the key to helping kids become kingdom people is to teach them more Scripture?

    “See, I will create new heavens and a new earth…”

    ISAIAH 65:17A

    Well, my answer is that the concept of praxis must be at work. By praxis, I mean the combination of Scriptural reflection in the context of social action. Reading Scripture divorced from actual experience will not do it. Nor will involvement with justice work without biblical reflection.

    Real change happens when people are put to work, and in the context of working, look over passages of Scripture and are asked to discuss, “In light of what you’ve seen and what you’ve done as you’ve worked among the poor, what do you think this passage of Scripture has to say about what you have just seen, what you have just experienced, and what you have just done?” It’s reflection in the context of action, rather than reflection without action, that is the core of transformational Bible study on this issue.



    Do you think that can be done ahead of time as kids are thinking about serving? Can we as youth workers prepare them even before they are hands-on with the poor to do some of that praxis?

    Yes, I think that praxis always presupposes what we call in sociology—and what Robert Merton, one of the deans of American sociology once called—the “serendipity pattern” of investigation. That serendipity pattern works like this: You read Scripture, you discuss it and say, “This is what I think it says.” And then you go into the existential situation, and you begin to recast your understanding of the Scripture in light of that setting. Then you come back and ask, “What did we think about this Scripture prior to our involvement, and how has our perspective on the Scripture changed?” So that it’s think first, then act, then reflect, then come back and recast your thinking, then act again. That process goes on endlessly.



    What do we do in youth ministry that hinders this feedback loop in which Scripture informs our justice work, and our justice work informs our understanding of Scripture?

    I think youth pastors are sometimes afraid and unable to recognize that there needs to be structural change in order for there to be social justice. It’s not enough to work on the micro level. When youth ministers go to a third-world country, it is important for them to see the ways the political, social, and economic structures on the macro level create and maintain poverty. If all they do is see things on the micro level, they will fail to grasp the real causes of poverty. Doing micro projects is very good, and gives people an opportunity to see the pain and suffering of people. But to understand and see the social forces that create such poverty is very, very important. In most cases, young people very seldom grasp the macro situation.

    For instance, a situation they are not likely to grasp is the relationship between the poverty in a place like Zimbabwe and the free-trade policies advocated by the U.S. government. Free trade, of course, says we do not want any barriers or any protective tariffs. The reality is that the U.S. subsidizes wheat farmers to the tune of $18 billion a year, which makes it possible for them to sell wheat in places like Zimbabwe at a much lower rate than the wheat and rice produced indigenously. This drives local farmers out of business, creating poverty. It’s great for American farmers, and creates great markets for them because they can sell their products so cheaply, because their products are subsidized. But it’s hell for farmers in Zimbabwe.

    I find that most youth workers haven’t a clue as to what macro economics are all about, and how macro economic factors create the poverty in third-world countries. They don’t understand why third-world peoples are angry with Americans. They listen to the President of the United States who says people out there hate us because they hate democracy. Well, it’s deeper than that. They hate a powerful country that is able to control international trade in such a way as to increase poverty in the third world while it aggrandizes itself.

    “What can be done to eliminate poverty, rather than to merely relieve it for a season? Can we, like the adage says, not merely give starving families fish to eat now and then, but actually teach them how to fish so that they can feed themselves?”

    BRIAN D. MCLAREN AND TONY CAMPOLO, ADVENTURES IN MISSING THE POINT

    The ways that macro factors controlled by politics and economics in third-world countries and in our country foster poverty are rarely understood by most youth workers. As a result, what is generated is pity instead of anger. We should be angry at what is being done to these people by forces beyond their control. And we should be coming back to this country and not simply saying, “We’re going to do more to raise money for the poor church in Haiti, or the Dominican Republic, or wherever.” Instead, we should be saying, “We are going to sit down with our congressman or congresswoman and ask some very serious questions as to why the United States maintains certain economic arrangements with these countries that cause so much poverty.”



    Can you give a couple of tangible examples that get beyond what students should be doing to what they actually are doing?

    There was a group of students at Eastern University who, through a stockholders’ action, were able to bring about massive changes in the way a certain corporation functioned in the Dominican Republic. They were so effective that the company ended up spending over $100 million a year over a ten-year period investing in health programs, education programs, and the restructuring of the entire economy of the eastern half of the country. As a result, the country was totally transformed.

    Right now a group of students in a Christian student organization called SPEAK has been very active in the peace process in Northern Ireland. They have arranged for representatives from the conflicting parties to come share their positions, and then will help organize peace talks between the two parties in that country, held at Eastern University. This is an example of what students are able to do.



    What is the role of the Holy Spirit in moving kids from doing kingdom work to being kingdom people?

    I am fascinated by the ways that mystical experiences with Christ transform young people into ardent social activists and evangelists. We have to recognize that we need more than just a socially conscious youth worker who has a good program. We need young people to be invaded by the Holy Spirit, and inwardly motivated. I really believe the Holy Spirit is a transforming force in people’s lives and, when the Spirit of Christ is alive in people, they become very aware of injustices. They become very sensitive to the needs of the poor and oppressed.

    I don’t want the church to simply become just another social activist group.

    I want it to be packed with people who are filled with the Spirit that has sensitized them to injustices in the system and to the sufferings of the poor. Increasingly we’re finding that as we nurture intimate spirituality, one of the consequences is not this “me and Jesus” faith where Jesus becomes my best friend, but a process whereby Christ becomes a motivating force within people that drives them into ministry with needy people.



    What else do youth workers need to know about deep social justice with their kids and communities?

    I think they need to know that their young people don’t know what’s going on in the world. They don’t read newspapers. They don’t ever discuss the crucial events of the day. As a case in point, most young people haven’t a clue that, of the 22 industrialized nations, the United States is dead last in the proportion of its national budget that it assigns to helping the poor in the third world. The average young person in the United States thinks America is the most generous nation on the face of the earth, but in terms of our national budget, we are the least generous of all the industrialized nations. They aren’t aware of these things, they don’t get angry at these things.

    Point blank, I’m not impressed with youth workers. I find that just like teenagers, they don’t know what’s going on in the world. Youth ministry is far too often a matter of fun and games. When I go to youth ministry conferences, I sometimes get depressed because I find that youth workers are primarily interested in techniques. They seldom want to deal with the issues. They often evade the hard-nosed facts of what’s going on in the world.

    As a matter of fact, I think MTV may do more to help kids become sensitive to the needs of the world than youth workers. If you’re asking me who is more likely turning young people on to poverty issues, I’ll have to say it’s Bono of U2 rather than youth workers. Youth workers are pressured into maximizing big turn outs at the youth gatherings at their churches, and that doesn’t usually come by making kids sensitive to the needs of the poor and the oppressed. That’s a very sad thing, indeed.

    HOW? (APPLICATION)

    DEEP JUSTICE APPLICATION QUESTIONS

  • When have you glimpsed the tension between selfishness and selflessness in your kids in the last month?
  • Of the two strategies we tend to use to move kids toward kingdom living (more service or more Scripture), which one do you tend to lean toward?
  • In what ways is your youth group similar to whitewashed tombs Jesus speaks of Matthew 23:27?
  • Of the findings in the MTV study, which two or three statistics are most provocative to you? Why do you find them interesting?
  • A theme in this chapter is that we as youth workers create space for the Holy Spirit to move kids’ needles from doing kingdom work to being kingdom people. How would you describe your role in the midst of the Holy Spirit being the ultimate force that transforms your kids?
  • According to Tony Campolo, “Youth pastors are afraid and unable to recognize that there needs to be structural change in order for there to be social justice.” Would he say the same about you specifically?
  • Of the following list of Deep Justice Recommended Action Steps that flow from this chapter, which would best help you as a kingdom follower right wrongs? How about for your youth ministry?
  • NOTES

    Portions of this chapter are derived from an article by Kara Powell, Terry Linhart, Dave Livermore, and Brad Griffin in the March/April 2007 issue of The Journal of Student Ministries.

    According to Chap, identity, autonomy, and belonging are the main issues adolescents work through during the process of “individuation.”

    H. Newton Malony, The Psychology of Religion for Ministry (Mahwah, New Jersey: Paulist Press, 1995), 60–62.

    Of course, financial giving is not the only indicator of whether the needle’s tilted toward justice as a lifestyle.

    Kurt Ver Beek, “The Impact of Short-Term Missions: A Case Study of House Construction in Honduras After Hurricane Mitch,” Missiology Volume 34, no. 4, October 2006, 490.

         Ver Beek’s findings run counter to several previous studies that cite the life-transformation created by STM. Yet critics of previous studies point out that such studies often rely on small sample sizes and are generally done right after the STM trip while participants are still on a “missions high.” In addition, previous studies typically have asked participants to rate how their own lives have changed without checking their perceptions against other empirical measures of change. Such self-report data may be biased, as was possibly the case with the 127 STMers who described their increased giving to Ver Beek.

    Robert J. Priest, Terry Dischinger, Steve Rasmussen, C.M. Brown, “Researching the Short-Term Mission Movement,” Missiology Volume 34, number 4, October 2006, 431–450.

    MTV’s national survey was comprised of 1,308 12–24-year-olds who completed online surveys and 98 students who were interviewed personally.

    This research can be accessed for free at www.mtv.com/thinkmtv/research/.

    Joplin, L. (1995). “On defining experiential education.” In K. Warren & M. Sakofs & J. S. Hunt Jr. (Eds.), The theory of experiential education (pp. 15–22). Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company.

    Linhart, T. D. (2005). “Planting seeds: The curricular hope of short-term mission experiences in youth ministry.” Christian Education Journal, Series 3, 256–272.

    For extensive insights on how to develop cultural intelligence in your youth ministry, see David A. Livermore, Serving With Eyes wide Open (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 2006)

    This 3-question reflection exercise has been popularized by the Campus Outreach Opportunity League.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑