Chapter 8 What Else Is There Besides Silence and Screaming as We Talk about Race?
“We must face the sad fact that at eleven o’clock on Sunday morning when we stand to sing ‘In Christ There is No East or West,’ we stand in the most segregated hour of America.”
Martin Luther King Jr.
NOW? (DISCERNMENT)
As I sit in a 24-hour Starbucks on the north side of Chicago at 10:30 p.m., I’m starting to wonder if this Starbucks has Now found the secret to creating diverse and multicultural community.
The place is filled with young people from every ethnic group imaginable. There are no open seats, and the place is humming with music of every variety at just the right volume. Folks are busy typing away on laptops, talking to friends, reading books—all while nursing lattes or espressos in hopes of being able to stay awake to complete their work or conversations.
The vibe is welcoming, and even though most of the people crammed together don’t know one another, we are bound by the fellowship of the green mermaid and her brew. Sadly, many people find more acceptance, more camaraderie, and more loyalty at this coffee house (as evidenced by their willingness to shell out $4.00 for a cup of coffee) than they’d find in many of our youth ministries.
STRANGERS WHO ARE SILENT
But let’s put the community at Starbucks Now under a microscope.
While people of all skin colors and languages are sitting at the same location, we aren’t looking one another in the eyes. And while we exchange polite smiles and pleasantries (“Looks like you’ve got a lot of work there,” “Yup, sure do…”), we remain strangers.
If I’m lucky, the Starbucks baristas I see a few times each week will memorize my first name and my preferred drink order (if you’re curious, it’s a grande, extra-hot, three-quarters Misto with foam). They know a bit about me, but they don’t really know me.
We converse, but we don’t really talk.
In spite of the diversity gathered inside, my local Starbucks, like many of our youth ministries, is stuck Now in comfortable silence instead of really dealing with racial injustices. At first glance, we may think we see community. But the deeper we look, the more we realize this community is about as deep as the lid on our café mocha.
Our youth ministries may be filled with kids of different skin colors, just like this Starbucks. But when it comes to honest conversations about race Now, our lips are sealed. Whether our kids are all the same color or as varied as the rainbow, whether we don’t know how to talk about race or we simply don’t want to, the end result is the same: We stay silent.
ENEMIES WHO MAKE US SCREAM
Equally toxic to deep kingdom youth ministry is a second approach to racial injustice: Screaming at those whom we view as enemies. If silence doesn’t right wrongs Now, then maybe yelling until we are hoarse will.
Sometimes it’s actual yelling. It’s blacks condemning whites for being “The Man” who keeps them oppressed. Or white parents blaming Asians because their kid wasn’t accepted into their college of choice.
But probably more often in youth ministry circles, it’s the way we keep others at arm’s length by using language that alienates them. We might not be yelling externally, but our internal anger and frustration spews out in belittling sarcasm and stereotypes.
I’ll never forget the struggle we had in our primarily Latino youth ministry when a few African-American kids from across the way began attending Friday night youth group. These kids wanted to come because our church was right down the street, but too often they did not feel welcome. The Mexican kids spoke in Spanish to hide their conversations from these youth who did not speak Spanish. Even the Latino parents voiced their doubts about the wisdom of “mixing” blacks and Latinos in the same youth group.
“Strangely enough, the havoc wreaked by indifference may be even ‘greater than that brought by felt, lived, practiced hatred.’”
MIROSLAV VOLF, EXCLUSION AND EMBRACE
I have one friend in youth ministry who’s white and does all he can to help his students right wrongs around them. But he’s been in countless discussions with folks of color who, in describing how their minority status has hindered them, have made him feel like the oppressor. He’s been told repeatedly, “You’re white. You just can’t get what it feels like to be a minority.” True, he can’t. But every time he’s been told that—whether it’s been yelled at him or merely whispered—he’s felt like the enemy with no friend in sight.
Now, at a time when people are looking for solutions to our race problems, our youth ministries must offer them the type of kingdom conversations that transcend the fears that keep us silent.
At a time when almost every war and major conflict in our world today has a racial element to it, we have to offer kingdom dialogue that rises above the anger that makes us want to scream.
As followers of the King, our youth ministries have to show others a New way.
NEW? (REFLECTION)
“WATCH OUT FOR THOSE WHITE PEOPLE”
New approaches to racial justice that move beyond either silence or screaming will not be easy. I know from my own experience that the distrust and hateful language among the races runs deep.
When I was six years old, my grandfather used to take me on walks from our Texas border town into Mexico to buy beans and rice. It was only a few miles from our home, so it was not a very long walk, and we didn’t have to worry about getting back and forth across the border as we would today.
During these trips across the border, he would warn me about the “Bolillos,” or the white people (a bolillo is literally a white roll of bread). He would say in Spanish, “Those Anglos cannot be trusted, and they will always look to take advantage of you.” As you can imagine, this made a huge impact on me as a youngster.
When I was seven, I moved to California, where I learned firsthand what it is like to be an ethnic minority in our dominant culture. I learned English in a special class and had to endure daily harassment from a group of blonde boys who got their kicks chasing me home as they made fun of the color of my skin and my thick accent. I can still hear their insults in my mind: “Go back to Mexico where you belong, you dirty wetback.” I remember trying to defend myself by telling them I was born here in the United States. I hated going to school, and I hated these light-skinned, blonde guys for how they treated me.
Even more damaging than the fights and insults were the deep scars these experiences left on my heart and in my mind, which would make it nearly impossible to trust my white classmates for years to come. I often wonder how different my childhood could have been if I’d made one good white friend who spoke kindly to me and was willing to accept me even though I was different from him. Maybe I would not have had to fight so much.
JESUS-STYLE RACIAL COMMUNITY: UP CLOSE AND PERSONAL
I love the story of Jesus healing a man infected with leprosy in Luke 5:12–16. In Jesus’ day, people with leprosy were viewed as repulsive, and were isolated physically, socially, and psychologically. When the leper saw Jesus, Luke reports that he fell to the ground, as if full of shame at his uncleanness. Luke also adds that the leper was so desperate for kingdom healing that he begged Jesus to make him clean.
To me, what’s most amazing about this story is the way Jesus heals the man. In the first century, lepers were always kept at a distance. If you touched someone with leprosy, you were rendered unclean. Yet in Luke 5:13, Jesus reaches out his hand and touches the man with leprosy, at which point, the man is made well. In the midst of disease and brokenness, Jesus’ New healing was up close and personal.
In our broken world, racial healing requires Jesus-style racial community, which means getting up close and personal. We cannot do “drive by” racial reconciliation, nor can we be satisfied with Starbucksstyle false intimacy. We have to roll up our sleeves, look each other in the eye, and do the hard work of kingdom conversations about race and ethnicity.
I started learning this after I graduated from college and joined the staff of Young Life in San Francisco’s Mission District, a community filled with Latino families from Central America. I was excited about getting to know some of the kids in my neighborhood and inviting them to a week of Young Life camp. But instead I was asked by our ministry director to take a group of students from Chinatown to camp instead.
I tried to hide my disappointment about having to take a group of Chinese guys—whom I didn’t know—to camp. I felt called to work with Latino kids, and this assignment was not in my plans. I felt nervous about working with kids from a different culture, and I had no idea how to even begin relating to these young guys. Not only were they not Mexican and not into soccer, but they were all into the martial arts. Honestly, I was not looking forward to taking this group of guys to camp for a whole week—even if it was to hear about Jesus.
While Jesus was in one of the towns, a man came along who was covered with leprosy. When he saw Jesus, he fell with his face to the ground and begged him, “Lord, if you are willing, you can make me clean.” Jesus reached out his hand and touched the man. ‘I am willing,’ he said. ‘Be clean!’ And immediately the leprosy left him.
Luke 5:12–13
By the end of the week, I felt so ashamed at my initial negative reaction toward working with these kids. During my many hours of conversations with them about their families, their experiences in Chinatown, and their feelings of rejection growing up in America, I realized I had treated them like many of my white peers had treated me in my childhood. (I wish I’d known martial arts when I was growing up and those other kids were kicking my behind.)
My time at camp that week not only served to reveal my own need for deeper racial sensitivity, but in actuality, helped prepare me for three years of working with many African-American, Samoan, and Filipino kids, along with the Latino kids I was used to relating to. It wasn’t until I had to reach beyond what was safe and get up close and personal with young people from other cultures that I became aware of some of my own prejudices and fears when it came to race. I was beginning to discover that racial healing was not going to happen from a distance, but by mixing it up with others—getting close, risking conversation, making mistakes, and eating lots of great ethnic food.
UP CLOSE AND PERSONAL CONVERSATION
I know it will be risky, but our youth groups need to be places where we can talk openly and honestly about race, and about the barriers that keep us from being the kingdom community that God intends. When we don’t talk honestly with one another, we live with untested assumptions. Black, Asian, and Latino folks think white folks don’t care about them or the injustices they face. White people react with fear and defensiveness to the anger minorities often express over the way they feel wronged.
“Dialogue with the people is radically necessary to every authentic revolution. This is what makes it a revolution, as distinguished from a military coup.”
PAULO FREIRE, PEDAGOGY OF THE OPPRESSED
As I’ve worked with students, I’ve made a point of bringing up the topic of race. Some New questions I like to ask are:
What are the stereotypes our culture holds toward different races?
How have we learned these stereotypes? Family? Friends? The media? Jokes?
Do you think there is truth in any of these stereotypes? Why or why not?
What’s it like to be a person of your race?
How do you think it would feel to be someone of a different skin color?
How do you think others view you when they first see your skin color?
What do you wish others knew about what it’s like to be of your ethnicity?
What benefits do you enjoy because of your race?
What does being of your ethnicity cost you?
What’s your favorite part about being of your race?
What’s your least favorite part?
Have you ever wished you were another skin color? Why or why not?
Why is it so tough for us to discuss questions like these about race?
I’ll never forget a youth rally I helped plan with a number of youth workers from various churches and youth ministries. In all, about 200 kids gathered together for a night of games and music, with a gospel message at the end. Our goal was to get our kids from different cities across the Bay Area to mix and get to know one another.
Over the course of the night, I was pleased to see kids from different churches getting to know one another. But at one point, I suddenly realized that, while we were all in one room, we were still all divided by race. The Latino kids had found other Latinos to meet and hang out with; the whites had found other whites; the African-American and Asian kids had done likewise. We’d all gathered in the same room, yet we were still divided by race. I could not believe it. It was not intentional, but all of the young people and the adult leaders had clustered together in their racial comfort zones.
As I got up to speak that night, I shared my observation with the group and asked them to think about why we’d segregated ourselves by race. By the end of the night, we gave students an opportunity to share their thoughts and feelings about why it’s hard to get up close and personal with others the way Jesus did. We actually saw the dynamics of the group change before our eyes, as all of us were intentional about going out of our way to talk to one another across racial lines.
It was a New lesson about the toxicity of racial segregation that those students and I will never forget.
“All who follow Christ are called to be bearers of God’s good news to the poor. Ignorance of the underclass or immigrants and their world(s) leads to simplistic labeling of people as ‘poor,’ ‘ex-cons,’ ‘illegals,’ ‘homeless,’ ‘underprivileged,’ ‘disabled,’ ‘poor white trash,’ ‘street workers,’ ‘runaways,’ ‘Mexicans,’ ‘disenfranchised,’ and endless other designations. The church, then, becomes guilty of racial and social-class profiling.”
BOB EKBLAD, READING THE BIBLE WITH THE DAMNED
For more practical suggestions for helping your kids talk about race, check out our free additional Deep Justice resources available at www.fulleryouthinstitute.org/deep-justice.
SPECIFIC QUESTIONS TO ASK IN YOUR YOUTH MINISTRY
Once you have made some progress in your kingdom conversations about race, you might want to try asking New questions about specific ethnicities. Either by using a panel of students or adults or simply through a large group discussion with your kids, consider asking the following:
NOTES
The phrase “greater than that brought by felt, lived, practiced hatred” comes from Arne Johan Vetlesen, Perception, Empathy and Judgment: An Inquiry into the Preconditions of Moral Performance (University Park: The Pennsylvania State University, 1994), 252.