Up Close And Personal Conversations As We Serve Together
UP CLOSE AND PERSONAL CONVERSATIONS AS WE SERVE TOGETHER
Shortly after I established La Villita Community Church, a youth worker called on the phone with a very interesting story. Lou was a Mexican American who had lived in the La Villita community as a young man. He was later adopted by a white family in another state and left Chicago for good—or so he thought.
After becoming a follower of Christ and completing his studies, he moved to a city in southern Indiana where he became a junior high pastor. Lou saw something about our church in a magazine and called to investigate the possibility of bringing his kids to Chicago on a weeklong mission trip.
When Lou first told me he wanted to bring a mostly white group of 70 squirrelly junior high students to our inner-city barrio, I almost told him, “No thanks.” First of all, how much help could they be to us? What kind of work or activities could they engage in that would be safe and positive for them and also a good experience for our own young people?
The week they spent with us that summer was so positive, I was blown away. These kids had really been prepared for this trip. They’d learned about Chicago and about the Mexican culture—even learning some essential words in Spanish.
They came to listen, learn, and serve, understanding that they were the outsiders coming into our hood. Together, we debriefed as many experiences as possible, allowing kids and leaders to ask questions about what they’d seen or experienced but did not really understand. One boy asked me, “What is the difference between a Mexican and a Hispanic?” I told him the terms Hispanic and Latino are used to identify all ethnic groups that come from Spanish-speaking countries, and that Mexicans were people from the country of Mexico. (In some communities there is even disagreement about whether to use the term Latino or Hispanic.) Another young lady wanted to know the proper way to address the adults in the community, and began to call me Don Noel or Mr. Noel.
I’ll never forget an African-American friend of mine instructing his boys on what to do if they got stopped by the police—stay in the car, keep your hands in plain view, keep your mouth shut, and pray! I was shocked, because these were good kids. They were not gangbangers or troublemakers, yet their father knew the dangers of being an African-American young person in our society. The same kind of fear is present in the Latino community and among most immigrant groups.
For more on the value of preparing students for short-term missions experiences, see .
They joined in our activities without trying to change the way we did things, and they constantly communicated their gratitude to us for allowing them to come. Recognizing that attitudes about time vary across cultures, Lou and his kids learned to be more relaxed about schedules, instead of striving to finish each program in an hour and move on to the next activity. Although activities would often feel “unplanned” or less sophisticated than what they were used to, by the end of their stay they learned a New appreciation of our cultural differences.
Finally, they brought some funds they’d raised to help us establish a youth center in our building. Instead of dictating to us what they wanted to do for us, they worked hard to ask our kids and leaders what we needed, and then they tried to do their best to come alongside our dreams and desires.
We had such a good experience serving with this group that they’ve continued to return to La Villita to be with their Mexican brothers and sisters in Christ. Every time they come, not only do we serve together, but we have deeper kingdom conversations about righting racial wrongs. They are so committed to kingdom conversation that they have also established a relationship with an African-American church down the street, as well as with a church in Chinatown a few miles away.
I’ll never forget the day I learned that a young Latina from our church had been invited to move to Indiana to live with one of these white families while her family was going through some struggles. That’s deep racial community just like Jesus would want it: up close and personal.
WHO? (OBSERVATION)
Up close and personal relationships and conversations lie at the heart of LINA THOMPSON’s commitment to righting wrongs for the broken and brokenhearted. As the national director for training and capacity for World Vision’s programs in the United States and an adjunct faculty member in Fuller Seminary’s Urban Youth Ministry Certificate program, Lina is respected nationally as a thoughtful and passionate justice thinker, teacher, and leader.
Lina, why are youth ministries so hesitant to have honest conversations about race?
For more information about the two-year, fully accredited Fuller Seminary Urban Youth Ministry Certificate offered through the Fuller Youth Institute, visit www.fulleryouthinstitute.org.
No matter what our skin color, anytime we talk about race, there is pain involved. So we often choose to ignore or deny deep reflection and conversations about race because we don’t want to feel uncomfortable. And there aren’t many places where youth workers can practice how to talk about race in a way that’s safe and meaningful.
How do we get over these fears about race?
I think the degree to which we have meaningful relationships with people who are different ethnically and culturally is the degree to which meaningful conversations about race can take place. As a person of color and a Samoan woman, deep justice means I need to engage with people who are African American, Caucasian, and Asian—not just to talk about race but to actually have meaningful relationships. I cannot limit myself to people just like me.
To download the full audio interview with Lina, visit the Deep Justice resource section of our Website at www.fulleryouthinstitute.org/deep-justice.
Once youth workers have those types of relationships, how can they then start having conversations with kids about racial justice?
I’ve had people invite me to come and speak to their ministries or their leadership teams about race. Those conversations are really hard, because there is no context for those conversations outside of that meeting. You need to have an experience that brings up questions about race and justice before you can really talk about it. That experience becomes a catalyst for deep discussions about race.
What types of experiences are you talking about?
I am talking about creating a relational context for real transformation. It doesn’t make any sense to try to talk about race relations if no real relationship or desire for relationships exists. It doesn’t work when there isn’t a commitment on both sides to pursue authentic relationships. You can’t do it from a distance.
The experiences I am talking about are not necessarily creating programs either—unless those programs are intentionally designed to create relationships.
We all know relationships take time, especially for natural “enemies.” I think time is the biggest barrier. We have to be willing to invest the time and resources over years to see relationships transformed. It only happens when people are intentional about their own development and growth related to breaking down racial, social, and ethnic barriers.
Can you give us an example of what you mean?
I serve as a commissioned lay pastor in a small, urban, multiethnic neighborhood. Over the last 10 years, we have forged a relationship with a very large, powerful, predominantly Caucasian congregation in our city.
This relationship has expressed itself in a variety of ways over the years.
Currently, this relationship is expressing itself in a building renovation project for our church.
To the uninformed outsider, it looks like the rich church helping the poor church. But to all of us insiders, it is far, far more. It is a commitment to walk together on this journey toward answering the missional question, “What does it mean to be and act like the church?” This question is the backdrop for the relationship between our two churches. While the “agenda” for our relationship is not overtly “reconciliation” or “justice” or “power,” those conversations invariably happen because we are transparent about our commitment to authentic relationship.
So when you have experiences like these, what types of questions normally come up?
Questions about power almost always come up, especially with kids from urban or distressed communities. Kids who are on the margins have such an intuitive sense about justice, and it’s always related to issues of power.
They start to wonder what God does when there’s such an-unlevel playing field. Why does he allow it? What does God want his kingdom followers to do about it? And, why isn’t the church doing more?
Do you think white, privileged kids have the same type of intuitive sense about justice?
I do. I think young people in general have a strong justice radar about what’s right and what’s not.
If that’s true, then why aren’t more conversations about justice and race happening in our ministries?
I think youth workers are often the ones who struggle with letting those questions surface. God uses young people to be his prophetic voice, and often that prophetic voice makes us very uncomfortable. So when you have youth workers who haven’t struggled with these issues themselves or they’re in a setting or church context that doesn’t allow these questions to surface, they aren’t able to frame these conversations.
So how can youth workers start working through issues about race?
Go find somebody who is different from you and be mentored. When I was leaving Young Life staff, they asked me a phenomenal question as part of my exit interview: “Talk about a relationship you have with a person who is different from you culturally and how that person has mentored you.” We all need relationships like that.
What advice would you give to youth workers who live in communities where there’s not a lot of racial diversity?
That’s where the Internet is great. Even if you live in a monocultural place, you can go to a conference or a gathering in another city that draws diverse leaders and then keep in touch with them afterward online or by phone.
So if Jesus were to walk into a youth ministry meeting here in America and launch a discussion about race, what kinds of questions do you think he would ask?
That’s a question we all need to ask ourselves. I think Jesus would ask, “What is the good news?” and, “What does the good news look like here?” Every youth ministry needs to ask these questions about their own communities.
What kinds of questions about race are taboo?
If you have a real relationship with someone, then I don’t think any questions are taboo. If you have a friendship, then there’s grace toward questions that might otherwise be offensive.
What should we do when our kids are making subtle but still derogatory jokes or comments about people of other skin colors or ethnicities?
When that happens to me, I ask the kids, “What’s up with that? What’s behind that comment? Does what you’re saying bring dignity to others?” Even if kids say, “We were just kidding. It was just a joke,” I think there’s almost always something real behind the so-called joking.
What mistakes do youth workers tend to make in talking about race?
I think we’re often not very well informed. We’re not taking the time to do our own personal theological reflection. If you haven’t spent time dealing with your own racism, then you can’t pretend to be able to walk with kids through it.
HOW? (APPLICATION)
DEEP JUSTICE APPLICATION QUESTIONS
When it comes to conversations about race, does your youth ministry lean toward silence or screaming? Instead of either silence or screaming, how do you think Jesus would engage in conversations about race?
Which of the suggested questions to ask about race on would spark the most provocative conversations with your students? When do you think you could ask them those questions?
Lina talks about a number of obstacles that prevent us from having deep conversations about race, including pain, fear, a shortage of time, and lack of practice. Which obstacle best explains your hesitations? Which best explains the hesitations of your students?
What is the deepest relationship you now have with a person of another skin color? Are you satisfied that this is enough? Why or why not?
In , we looked at the full Jesus who transcends our narrow either/or categories. When you picture Jesus, what color is his skin? How do you think that mental image affects your up close and personal relationships with people of other races?
The Joplin framework in is designed to help you debrief justice experiences like the ones Lina suggests. In the midst of potentially awkward and heated discussions about race, how can you and the other adult leaders in your youth ministry provide the type of support and feedback that is pivotal to the Joplin model?
Of the following list of Deep Justice Recommended Action Steps that flow from this chapter, which would best help you as a kingdom follower right wrongs? How about your youth ministry?