Chapter 12 of 26

Chapter 7 When It Comes to Race, Why Can’t We All Get Along?

Chapter 7 When It Comes to Race, Why Can’t We All Get Along?









Noel Castellanos, the associate executive director of the Christian Community Development Association, has worked in full-time ministry in urban communities since 1982, serving in youth ministry, church planting, and community development in San Francisco, San Jose, and Chicago. Noel is a highly sought after speaker, motivator, and mentor to young leaders throughout the United States, and has a deep passion to serve and invest in the lives of emerging leaders. He and his wife, Marianne, have three children, Noel Luis, Stefan, and Anna, and make their home in the barrio of La Villita in Chicago.

NOW? (DISCERNMENT)

A few years ago at a Christian Community Development Association Conference, I was given the responsibility of introducing Rodney King, the central figure of the 1992 race riots in Los Angeles. I said, “I want to introduce you to a man who you’ll recognize by his now famous words ‘People…can we all get along?’”

Rodney King came to the microphone and said, “I don’t have anything else to say. You just took my only line with your introduction.” To my surprise, Rodney really didn’t seem to want to say much more—so I prayed for him, and the two of us sat down.

I felt terrible that I had stolen his thunder. But I assumed he’d have more to say about race relations than simply urging everyone to get along despite our differences.

Yet in a similar way, when we as youth ministries Now enter into discussions about race, we often have very little of substance to offer. The best we can do is ask, like Rodney King, “Can we all get along?”

EITHER COLOR-BLIND OR COLOR-FULL

When I have conversations Now with youth workers about how we should right racial wrongs, it’s common for someone to suggest we should all be “colorblind” when it comes to race. Instead of seeing black people or Asian people or white people or Latino people, we should just see people. Period.

To be honest, whenever someone tells me, “When I see you, I don’t see a Mexican person, I just see a person,” I don’t believe him. That’s a little bit like someone looking at me and saying, “When I see you, I don’t see a male.” You can’t help but notice that I’m male, and you can’t help but notice that my skin, my eyes, and my hair reflect that I’m Mexican.

The irony is that Now I also hear the opposite. Just as some youth workers claim to be “color-blind,” others seem to be “color-full.” All they see is my color, my race. When they look at me, they attribute everything about me to the fact that I’m Mexican.

Why do I think the way I do? In their eyes, it’s because I’m Mexican.

Why do I treat people the way I do? Because I’m Mexican.

Why do I view the world that way I do? You guessed it—because I’m Mexican.

As a result, instead of denying that I am Mexican like the color-blind folks do, the color-full folks deny that I am anything but Mexican.

Maybe part of the reason we as youth workers are often left muttering nothing more than “Can we all get along?” is that we have Now bought into these either/or views about race. While I believe our youth ministries can and should relate to people of all races with respect and kindness, we don’t have to deny people’s ethnic or racial reality to accept who they are. Nor do we have to focus solely on their ethnicity, thereby denying the rest of who they are as human beings. Instead, kingdom justice makes our racial differences opportunities to experience intimate community with others who all express and bear the image of God in unique ways.

NEW? (REFLECTION)

To read more about the pressure that kids of color feel to act “white,” check out our free additional Deep Justice resources available at www.fulleryouthinstitute.org/deep-justice.

THE MO’ COLOR THE MO’ BETTER

I am convinced that well-known movie director and Knicks fan Spike Lee understands God’s New vision for racial unity and reconciliation better than most youth leaders. A number of years ago, Lee filmed a commercial for Nike in which a bunch of guys were playing a heated game of very competitive basketball. As you watched the two teams involved more closely, it became clear that all the players on one team were white, the other team’s players were all black, and there was a whole lot of trash talking going on.

The trash talk escalated to the point where the guys stopped playing ball and ended up at center court, looking like they were ready to throw down. Just as the scene was about to get ugly, Spike Lee’s big head filled the TV screen, and he yelled, “Yo!” After everybody stopped in their tracks, the commercial ended with him saying, “If we’re going to live together, we have to play together. The mo’ color the mo’ better!”

The apostle Paul says basically the same thing in a letter he wrote to kingdom followers in a city named Galatia:

So in Christ Jesus you are all children of God through faith, for all of you who were baptized into Christ have clothed yourselves with Christ. There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, neither male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus. If you belong to Christ, then you are Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise. (Galatians 3:26–29)

That passage is probably familiar to you. Maybe you’ve even heard a portion of Galatians 3:28—“you are one in Christ Jesus”—used as a slogan reminiscent of Rodney King’s “Can we all get along?” But righting racial wrongs in and through our youth ministries means taking a deeper look at what was happening in first-century Galatia when Paul wrote the letter.

In Paul’s day, a growing number of non-Jewish people (known as Gentiles) were responding to the New kingdom message of God’s love. This might seem like something the early church would welcome, but the animosity between Gentiles and Jews made it both controversial and complicated. During the early Old Testament era, the Gentiles generally received hospitality and favor from the Israelites (see Deuteronomy 10:19, Exodus 23:9, Judges 1:16). But while the Jews were in exile during the later Old Testament era, their Gentile captors often mistreated them. As a result, during the New Testament era, many Jews viewed Gentiles with scorn and hatred. Gentiles were regarded as unclean, and it was unlawful to befriend them. Gentiles were seen as enemies of God and his people, and if they asked questions about divine matters, Jews were expected to curse them.

As people who had been excluded from Jewish culture, the Gentiles were blown away by the way Jesus—a Jewish Jesus no less—loved everyone regardless of class, gender, or race. When the Gentiles heard that they too could become a part of God’s family, they must have flipped, realizing it would mean becoming brothers and sisters with Jews. They must have wondered how this was going to work, since they had always been shunned by these Jewish people and considered their enemies.

So in Christ Jesus you are all children of God through faith, for all of you who were baptized into Christ have clothed yourselves with Christ. There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, neither male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus. If you belong to Christ, then you are Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise

GALATIANS 3:26–29

Take some time to reread Galatians 3:26–29 (printed in the sidebar to the left) through the New backdrop of the Gentile/Jewish division.

In essence, Paul does what Spike Lee did by helping these first-century believers—and the believers of our day—see that, in Christ, we are all part of the same family. If the Jews and Gentiles of the early church were going to be part of the same family, they would have to learn to play together. Instead of helplessly wondering why we can’t “get along” without offering any kingdom hope, Paul reminds them (and us) that the mo’ color, the mo’ better!

WE NEED DEEP RACIAL JUSTICE

BECAUSE THE ROOTS OF INJUSTICE ARE SO DEEP

One reason Paul’s New message is hard to implement in our youth ministries today is because so many ethnicities and races have been wronged throughout our country’s history. Take a look at a few historical examples of how racism has birthed oppression and suffering for people of color:

According to Joni Hersch, a Vanderbilt University professor who analyzed data from 2, 084 male and female immigrants, those with the lightest skin color earned, on average, 8–15 percent more than immigrants with the darkest skin tone. The effect of skin color persisted even among workers with the same ethnicity, race, and country of origin.

•    Native Americans have been killed by the millions, had their land stolen from them, and have experienced extreme discrimination. Today, only 1 percent of the U.S. population is Native American, and the majority of us have virtually no knowledge of any public figures or governmental leaders who are Native American.

•    Much of the wealth of our nation was built on the brutality of slavery, with African men, women, and children forced to come to this country for the benefit of whites. Even after the abolition of slavery, African Americans have struggled to be seen as fully human, have been denied numerous human rights, and have struggled with the slavery aftermath and the continuing burdens of discrimination, racism, and segregation.

• Latino immigrants have been valued by our country’s economy when we have needed cheap labor, and then have been kicked out, asked to leave, or criminalized as “illegal aliens.”

• Japanese residents and citizens have been detained by our government; many Asians struggle to be seen as fully American because of their different cultures and languages.

KINGDOM LOVE THAT BUSTS BARRIERS

Unfortunately, New research indicates that racial injustice still continues in our country, and even in our churches. Through a nationwide telephone survey of 2,000 adults as well as 200 face-to-face interviews, Michael O. Emerson and Christian Smith found that U.S. churches reflect our “racialized society.” According to Emerson and Smith, a “racialized society” is a society in which race creates profound differences in life experiences, life opportunities, and social relationships. Even if we believers don’t intend to perpetuate racial inequality and division, research indicates that even though formal segregation by race ended in the United States in 1964, informal segregation still exists in our housing developments, our schools, and perhaps most tragically, in our churches.

Given our nation’s past and present, what New insights must pervade our youth ministries if we would try to right wrongs in a racially divided world? Simply put, our youth ministries are called to be filled with radical love in a broken world torn apart by racism, discrimination, and oppression. Our youth ministries need to overflow with the same love Jesus and Paul had, a love for every kind of person—especially those who are different from us, and whom we might even consider to be our enemies. As we right wrongs through barrier-busting love, the world can see that God’s plan and design for his kingdom people and for the church is different from anything found on this broken and divided planet.

“Whites can move to most any neighborhood, eat at most any restaurant, walk down most any street, or shop at most any store without having to worry or find out that they are not wanted, whereas African Americans often cannot…Whites are assumed to be middle class unless proven otherwise, are not expected to speak for their race, can remain ignorant of other cultures without penalty, and do not have to ask every time something goes wrong if it is due to race, whereas African Americans cannot.”

MICHAEL O. EMERSON AND CHRISTIAN SMITH, DIVIDED BY FAITH

I had an unforgettable taste of the power of a barrier-busting love when I met Pat Williams, a well-known and successful general manager of professional basketball teams. Besides his high-profile job, there’s something else unusual about Pat Williams. He and his wife have 19 children; 14 of them are adopted children from 14 different countries.

Imagine the amazing diversity that exists in that family! That’s the kind of diversity our heavenly Father has always envisioned for his church: Men, women, and children from every nation loving one another, caring for one another’s needs, and absolutely committed to one another as sisters and brothers of the same family—the family of God.

In a broken world filled with racial strife and hatred, we as kingdom followers have a New message: We can go beyond just getting along. We can actually learn to appreciate and love one another as members of God’s family.

NEW WAYS TO SHOW BARRIER-BUSTING LOVE

We youth workers can play a primary role in helping our kids live as God’s family in a number of New ways:

  • We can teach kids to be intentional in reaching out to friends who are different from them. Encourage your students to be like Lydia, a girl in our mostly Latino youth group, who was always inviting her African-American friends to our ministry because she cared about them.
  • We can challenge kids to be intense in confronting misconceptions about race. Once I invited a Latino young man to camp who couldn’t wait to get into a fight with a black kid—because he hated all black people. Once he got to know a few of the guys in his cabin that week, he not only asked Christ to come into his life, but admitted to others that he was wrong in his attitudes toward blacks, and asked for forgiveness.



    Interestingly, many of our kids need to confront not only their misconceptions about other races, but also false ideas about themselves and those of their own race or class. I’ve personally seen Latino and African-American kids from our youth group transformed when they’ve traveled to another country with great poverty and realized they aren’t just “poor minority kids.” As people created in God’s image, they have talents, passions, and resources to give.
  • We can help our kids be informed about the racial injustice that goes on around us. When news events with racial themes erupt in your city or in our nation (which happens regularly), invite your students to share their responses with you. When possible, push them to think about the underlying causes of these racial tensions, as well as how Jesus would respond.
  • Finally, we can help our kids push toward all forms of integration. These days, as some churches are priding themselves on making progress toward racial integration, we must recognize how racial and class barriers overlap. Just yesterday, I heard from a youth pastor who was celebrating that his formerly mostly white church was becoming more racially diverse, thanks to the example of the youth ministry. While this is encouraging, the problem is that even though the church is more racially diverse, it’s still basically an upper-middle- class congregation. The only non whites are people of color who fit the socioeconomic level of the vast majority of the congregation, so everyone still feels pretty safe. (Jeremy will cover class divisions in more detail in
    and
    .)
  • The Christian Community Development Association revolves around eight philosophical components crucial to deep justice: relocation, reconciliation, redistribution, leadership development, listening to community, church-based, holistic approach, and empowerment. (see www.ccda.org for more)

    A SNAPSHOT OF BARRIER-BUSTING LOVE

    For ten years, I pastored a church in a Mexican neighborhood in southwest Chicago called La Villita. The barrio has about 100,000 residents who are almost all of Mexican descent. From the time my family arrived here, we worked hard to establish a church where everyone felt welcome, regardless of their race.

    We had many Spanish-speaking families and kids in our church as well as a good number of white families who had a deep burden to live and work with Mexican people. We also had families like mine that were mixed. I am a fourth-generation Mexican-American and my wife is Italian, so we brought biracial kids into our church, as did a few other families. Together, we all had to compromise and sacrifice and work at celebrating our diversity. When conflicts arose, many of us felt like it would be much easier to worship with others who were all alike.

    “The commitment to submit to Jesus and follow him into displacement all our days is a lordship commitment. It means a lifetime of allowing Jesus to call us out of comfort and ease and into places and communities where we are awkward and weak. Those of us who have made this commitment know that displacement will always be a part of what we do. Our worldview leads us to regularly ask, ‘Where in my life am I the minority, the learner, the one who is displaced?’”

    PAULA HARRIS AND DOUG SCHAUPP, BEING WHITE

    I was always surprised at how little misunderstandings between our white members and our Mexican members became the seeds for huge blow-ups and conflicts. Once a white sister in our church decided to have a party for one of her Mexican friends, but didn’t invite all of the women in our small church. While she didn’t intend to leave anyone out, the women who were not invited felt rejected and hurt. Instead of talking openly about the expectations of different cultures regarding party invitations, some of these mothers stopped bringing their kids to our after-school program. It wasn’t until months later that the truth about their feelings came out.

    As a Mexican pastor I had to wrestle with questions about race when a group of white leaders seemed resistant to my leadership. Instead of taking their concerns at face value, it was easy for me to play the race card and assume their problems with me were racially motivated. I assumed they did not want to follow a Latino leader, instead of accepting that they might have been right about certain issues. It was only after I took the time to listen—really listen—that we were able to work through conflicts that were fueled by our racial backgrounds.

    In spite of the many challenges we faced, we knew we were experiencing something in our diversity that was pleasing to God. One of the most committed youth workers in our church was an African-American young woman who learned Spanish and became immersed in the Mexican culture so she could minister better to the kids in our youth group. Because of her willingness to be an agent of reconciliation, she has had a huge impact on the people of our church and community.

    Imagine the impact our generation could make if we truly committed ourselves to realizing God’s desire that his church would be one big diverse family. Imagine if you and your students decided to learn Spanish or Chinese so you could reach out to the other kids in your neighborhood. Imagine if urban and suburban youth ministries began New partnerships to address the racial injustices in their communities. Imagine if it became normal to see black and white and Asian and Latino kids and adults all celebrating and worshipping God together on Sunday mornings. Do you think this type of kingdom love might help us get along in cities all across America?

    WHO? (OBSERVATION)

    EFREM SMITH thinks this kind of kingdom love can make a difference in our world. As senior pastor of Sanctuary Covenant Church in Minneapolis, coauthor of The Hip-Hop Church, and author of Raising Up Young Heroes, Efrem is one of our country’s leading voices in helping youth ministries bring deep justice to our racially divided world. Regardless of whether your group is of one ethnicity or already full of diversity, Efrem is someone Who is full of practical ideas for you and your kids to bust racial barriers through kingdom love.



    How do you feel when someone says to you, “When I look at you, I don’t see your skin color?”

    I don’t feel like I’m in an authentic dialogue. We live in a racialized society, and if someone has the natural ability to see, they see I’m an African American. But I know what people are trying to say when they say that. They’re trying to say, “I’m attempting to live a life where skin color is not a barrier for me,” and I respect that desire.

    To read much more about hip-hop and what it means for your youth ministry, check out our free additional Deep Justice resources available at www.fulleryouthinstitute.org/deep-justice.

    What about when you face the other extreme and people seem to attribute everything about you to your race or ethnicity?

    To say you don’t see skin color is unhealthy, but to attribute everything to skin color is just as unhealthy. I think multiple ethnicities, cultures, and languages are opportunities to see the creative power of our loving God. At the same time, if everything is attributed to race or ethnicity, then we build stereotypes by believing, “All white people think like this,” or “All black people are like this.” Those stereotypes begin to fuel prejudice.



    Why is it tough for us as youth workers to bridge the racial divide that exists in this country?

    Because youth ministry is part of the broader church, and the broader church in America struggles with the issue of race.



    When you say the broader church is struggling with race, what do you mean?

    We can’t talk about race, slavery, Jim Crow segregation laws, or the Civil Rights movement without talking about the church, because for good and bad, the church has been at the center of justice issues, particularly race, throughout our country’s history. We have various ethnic churches because people of color were not historically welcomed in the white church. The black church in our country was forced into existence because African Americans were not welcome in the all-white church.

    At the same time, we can celebrate the ways the church has historically spoken out against slavery, inequality, and racism. So we as the church have to wrestle with the part we’ve played in racism as well as the part we’ve played in fighting against racism.



    What are you doing at Sanctuary Covenant Church to be a reconciling racial community?

    The Sanctuary Covenant Church began in 2003, so we’re fairly young, but we’ve grown into a multicultural church by being very intentional from the beginning about building a multi-ethnic community. Our staff, our elder board, and our core groups are all multi ethnic. We’ve tried to be very intentional about being multi ethnic in our preaching, teaching, and ministry models. As a result, our congregation is 55 percent white, 32 percent black, 8 percent Latino, 2 percent Asian, and 3 percent Jamaican or bi racial.



    In your 12 years of hands-on youth ministry and your time now as a senior pastor spending time with students and young adults, what have you learned about effective racial reconciliation in youth ministries?

    As a teenager here in Minneapolis I was greatly impacted by the ministry of Park Avenue United Methodist Church. Later I became Park Avenue’s youth pastor, and I still have the privilege of observing its justice work, since it’s located near our church. One reason that church is effective at racial reconciliation is because in the late 1960s and early 1970s, as the racial dynamics of our city began to change, the youth ministry embraced that change. Through its youth ministry, this affluent, all-white church began to integrate intentionally. As the youth ministry experienced deep racial reconciliation, the entire church was influenced. Just recently the church called an African-American senior pastor for the first time in its history. And for the first time in the history of Park Avenue, white folks are not the majority of the staff. I think it’s amazing that this intentionality began with the heart of one youth worker, Art Erickson.



    What did Art and the youth ministry do to right the racial wrongs around them?

    Art was a Young Life leader before he came to Park Avenue. I think that parachurch background made him more of a pioneer in developing a reconciling youth ministry model. Art and the team of volunteers he developed went out to schools to get to know all types of kids. They’d invite them not just to church but also on rafting trips and other fun events. As a result, churched and nonchurched kids got to know one another, and kids of all skin colors realized what they had in common. They all needed Jesus, and they all needed one another.



    What other recommendations do you have for youth workers who want to engage in racial justice?

    Well, first we have to preach it and teach it. I think we need to teach the Bible as the most multicultural piece of literature that exists. When we read the genealogy of Jesus in Matthew 1, we can’t help but conclude that Jesus walked the earth as a multicultural human being. When we read of Jesus’ travels, we have to ask ourselves why Jesus went through Samaria in John 4 and what that means for us today. When we read of the Day of Pentecost in the second chapter of Acts, or Revelation 7 and its vision of a multitude of every tribe and language in heaven, we have to wrestle with its implications for us as kingdom followers.

    “God yearns to interact with young people, and he is in the business of using them to do incredible things in the world.”

    EFREM SMITH, RAISING UP YOUNG HEROES

    In addition to teaching about it, we have to make it a priority to ask, “How can we begin to have monthly or quarterly services with churches different from our own? What would it look like to go on a service or missions trip together?” Whether our ministry is urban, suburban, or rural, we all need to network with other diverse groups. You can do it through an official youth worker network in your city that coordinates joint training seminars or youth events, or by connecting with another church for your next winter retreat. Or maybe the next time you’re planning an event for your church, you make sure to invite a speaker of a different ethnicity so you model diversity before your kids.



    What should we do when our kids resist building relationships with folks of other ethnicities?

    I don’t see many kids resisting racial reconciliation these days. I think young people in the United States, whether we realize it or not, are becoming more and more multicultural. Kids today want something more than the racialized labels they live with.

    The church ought to be engaging hip-hop culture but should be seeking to create Holy Hip-Hop culture as well.”

    EFREM SMITH AND PHIL JACKSON, THE HIP-HOP CHURCH

    In our own country, especially in places like California, New York, and Texas, European Americans are no longer the majority. If that is true, and our job is to proclaim Christ in such a culture, then we can’t live in all-white or all-black worlds anymore. Through the Internet, kids are tapping into a multicultural world on a regular basis, and we as youth workers must help them realize it’s also a multicultural kingdom world.



    What are the differences between urban youth ministries and suburban youth ministries when it comes to racial justice?

    I think urban churches have unique opportunities, because they tend to be located in communities with greater racial diversity. For example, we have people who drive to our urban church from suburban areas because they want a multiethnic experience. They want to be in a worship experience that looks like heaven.

    Even suburbs are getting more racially diverse. Many first-ring suburbs are starting to look like the city. Also, because of gentrification, many urban people, poor people, and people of color are being relocated to first-ring suburbs and beyond.



    What message would it send to our broken world if we as kingdom youth ministries were leaders of racial reconciliation?

    I think it would send a tremendous message to our world. Usually the American church wears one of two faces. The first is the politicized church that tends to focus on two issues: abortion and gay marriage. The second face of the American church is all about consumerism and materialism, believing God wants to bless you, make you rich, and make your life easy.

    Efrem defines gentrification as the revitalization of a city as housing projects and abandoned buildings are torn down and replaced with new housing and businesses. While that improves the conditions of a neighborhood, it doesn’t necessarily result in justice. Often poor people who live in these neighborhoods are not prepared to take advantage of or well integrated into these developments or they can’t afford the higher rents, so they remain not only poor but also displaced from their homes and community.

    Neither of those faces of the U.S. church is the church I read about when I read about Jesus. Being the church in this culture is complex and difficult. Being a Christian today is not an easy road. But I think if we work toward justice and righteousness together, we will see some phenomenal kingdom-building in our country.

    HOW? (APPLICATION)

    DEEP JUSTICE APPLICATION QUESTIONS

  • How would your kids answer the question of why we can’t, in Rodney King’s words, “all get along”? If your kids fully understood the kingdom story of Good/Guilt/Grace/Gratitude presented in
    , what would their answer be?
  • Paul dealt with the division between Jews and Gentiles. What are the primary racial or cultural divisions in your community? What would it look like if Galatians 3:26–29 started to change your community?
  • In MTV’s 2006 youth survey on
    , in
    , it was clear that issues that hit close to home are more likely to move the justice needle toward our becoming kingdom people. How does the issue of race hit close to home with your students?
  • In
    , John Perkins stated that when we view others as made in God’s image that will make us want to help them be reconciled both to God and to one another. Similarly, how will viewing others as made in God’s image affect the way we respond to racial injustice?
  • Which of the ways to show barrier-busting love described on
    is most relevant to your youth ministry? What could you do in the next few months to experiment with that type of barrier-busting love?
  • Do you agree with Efrem that kids today don’t resist racial reconciliation? Why or why not?
  • Of the following list of Deep Justice Recommended Action Steps that flow from this chapter, which would best help you right wrongs as a kingdom follower? Which would most help your youth ministry?
  • NOTES

    Michael O. Emerson and Christian Smith, Divided by Faith (New York: Oxford University Press, 2000), 7–9, 48.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑