Chapter 3 How Can My Teaching Motivate Kids to Deeper Justice?
NOW? (DISCERNMENT)
It’s one thing to read what the Bible says about the poor and broken and understand it. It’s an entirely different thing to read what the Bible says about the poor and broken and actually live it.
For the last two decades, I’ve experimented with strategies to teach kids what the Bible says about the poor so they’ll want to seek God’s hope for our broken world. As I look back over those years, I’ve found that I seem to have evolved through two phases of shallow teaching about justice.
Phase 1: Pack Your Bags for a Guilt Trip
My first phase of teaching kids about justice went something like this: Others are living in hell now, and going to hell when they die, so how can you just sit there?
Kids, pack your bags. We’re going on a guilt trip.
Granted, I camouflaged the guilt trip by talking about the difference between the sheep and the goats in Matthew 25:31–46, and the Great Commission’s command to “go” and “make disciples” in Matthew 28:18–20.
But what I was really after was making students feel so bad about the poverty and power imbalances around them both locally and globally that they would get up and right some wrongs.
The good news is that kids did act. They visited kids in the children’s hospital, they raked leaves for senior adults on Saturdays, they pooled their money to sponsor a few kids overseas, and some even spent their spring breaks or summer vacations sharing the gospel with people in Africa and Asia.
But any movement toward deep justice was shortlived. When I didn’t constantly remind them of their responsibility to God and others, they reverted to life as usual. When it came to righting wrongs, most kids took 3 steps forward and 2.93 steps backward. Not a very big net gain.
“The King will reply, ‘I tell you the truth, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers of mine, you did for me.’ “
MATTHEW 25:40
“Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you.”
MATTHEW 28:19–20A
Using guilt to motivate kids to serve did work with a kid named Jason. He definitely got the message that there were problems in the world, and that he needed to do something. He decided to give his life away. The problem was that he didn’t give his life to Jesus, he gave it to Communism.
Seriously.
Jason felt like Communism was more about helping the poor than Christianity. When I saw my kids choosing Karl Marx over Jesus Christ, that’s when I knew I had a problem.
Phase 2: Less Than Amazing Grace
One of my life mottos—and a great slogan for the both/and kingdom—is “Balance is something we swing through on our way to the other extreme.”
“He has shown all you people what is good. And what does the Lord require of you? But to act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God.”
MICAH 6:8
Once I realized guilt wasn’t working, I swung to the other extreme. After all, I told myself, Christianity is the only religion in the world that revolves around grace. We don’t have to earn our way into heaven; we simply receive the gift of salvation extended to us by God the Father through Jesus the Son.
So I talked about grace. Amazing grace. I didn’t want to turn kids away from their faith by forcing them to right wrongs if they didn’t want to. So I didn’t talk much about “going” or “doing.” I just talked about “being.” Since I’d learned that shouting wouldn’t convince them, I whispered instead. I focused on different Scripture passages in this phase, like Micah 6:8, but in my teaching the commands to “love mercy” and “walk humbly with your God” seemed to somehow trump the command to “act justly.”
“The crisis of American church and theology becomes even more intensive when one reflects on two opposite patterns that can be witnessed in churches throughout the United States. The first pattern offers a gospel without demands… The second pattern lies at the other end of the spectrum: demands without the gospel.”
ORLANDO COSTAS, CHRIST OUTSIDE THE GATE
This quickly degenerated into what German theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer called “cheap grace,” or a form of “grace” that allows us to maintain the status quo without seeking God’s justice for others. As Bonhoeffer describes, “Cheap grace is not the kind of forgiveness of sin which frees us from the toils of sin. Cheap grace is the grace we bestow on ourselves.”
Kids were comforted by the grace I talked about, but they got a little too comfortable. Truth be told, so did I. We were going to heaven, but we weren’t taking anybody with us. And we did precious little to help others experience a taste of heaven’s love and justice here on earth.
In talking with youth workers around the country, I’ve realized I’m not the only one who’s dabbled in excessive guilt or cheap grace in the past. In fact, my hunch is that most youth workers have Now set up their justice teaching tents in one of those two camps.
In describing our theological shallowness, Dallas Willard in The Divine Conspiracy warns, “Should we not at least consider the possibility that this poor result is not in spite of what we teach and how we teach, but precisely because of it?”
If Dallas is right (and I think he is), youth ministry as a whole needs to do more Now than simply fine-tune how we teach kids to right wrongs. As I realized myself ten years ago, youth ministry needs a major overhaul.
NEW? (REFLECTION)
FYI RESEARCH: LEARNING FROM THE EXPERTS
In order to understand the type of New overhaul that is needed, we at the Fuller Youth Institute at Fuller Theological Seminary decided to ask the experts. In Fall 2005, we interviewed 70 youth workers, 30 of whom were recommended to us because of their effectiveness in engaging students in serving our broken world, and 40 of whom were local youth workers in Los Angeles.
For more insights about findings from our short-term missions research, please see our Deep Justice Journeys Curriculum and resources at www.fulleryouthinstitute.org/deep-justice
As we compiled the input of these 70 diverse youth workers, one New theme repeatedly emerged: As a whole, youth workers have failed to help students grasp the deep story of the Scriptures that invites all kingdom followers to play a part in the King’s work in the world.
STORIES IN THE BIBLE OR THE STORY OF THE BIBLE
Our 70 youth worker interviews confirmed that a key difference between shallow service and deep justice is whether we teach stories in the Bible or the story of the Bible. The table below illustrates the difference.
THE STORY BEYOND THE STORY
I’m about to give my best description of the story of the kingdom. In all honesty, I’m a bit nervous. For one, it might feel too “linear” for some of you. While I present the story in a roughly chronological order, the reality is that God’s story is far too grand and far too breathtaking for us to plot in an orderly time sequence. And yet, as Western humans, we normally tell stories in the order the events occurred. (“First I showed up at our youth group meeting, next I grabbed a soft drink, and then a kid bumped into me and I spilled my drink on my shirt.”) So take the movements of the kingdom story with a grain—make that a huge mountain—of salt, for as you’ll see in a few pages, the story bounces around in the Bible and in our lives.
“God’s kingdom is what narrates the world for Christians.”
BOB WEBBER, AS QUOTED IN “TOGETHER IN THE JESUS STORY,” CHRISTIANITY TODAY, SEPTEMBER 2006
Second, some of you might think my version of God’s story is too truncated. Mine has four movements; maybe yours has six. Or seven. Of course, no matter how many movements we might use to describe God’s story, it’s inherently impossible to describe the story in its fullness. It is, after all, God’s story.
Third, while I believe the Bible is a wonderful photo album filled with snapshots of God’s story, it doesn’t provide us with all of God’s story. God’s story is so transcendent, and so alive and active from the beginning of time until its end, that while we can appreciate the Bible as the best version of God’s story we have, there is an unfolding story that lies beyond even its texts.
BOTH GUILT AND GRACE AND SO MUCH MORE
Having said all that, let’s work together to come up with a working definition of God’s story. It definitely includes guilt and grace. In fact, it emphasizes them. It’s just that they’re only about half of the story—the middle half to be precise. And just like in any good story, we’ll gain a New appreciation of that middle half when we understand what comes before and after it.
Good
Before we help students grasp their guilt before the King, we need to help them grasp that he originally created us as good. We didn’t start out condemned; we were created in God’s image (Genesis 1:26–27). Being created in the image of God (or in Latin, the “imago dei,” pronounced “ih-mah-go day”) makes us able to receive his love and respond to his invitation to right wrongs around us.
To find out more about what the image of God means for deep justice, flip to .
By “dialectic,” we mean the bounce back and forth between two contradictory ideas until they are eventually resolved.
Guilt
Now comes the bad news. The inherent goodness we derived from being created in the King’s image was permanently marred in the Garden of Eden. Whether you believe that image was obliterated or merely obstructed, the end result is roughly the same: Our world and relationships are broken. Because of our universal sin, every single one of us—from the richest investor on Wall Street to the nameless child caught up in sex trafficking on the streets of Calcutta—is broken. We can no longer have relationship with the One who sits on the throne.
The well-known twentieth-century theologian Karl Barth introduces a theological dialectic that helps us understand the transition from good to guilt. Barth labels our original potential for relationship with God a divine YES. Human nature is still “good” in the sense of our being created by God. But as a result of Adam and Eve’s rebellion, our relationship with the King has been broken. The YES has, in effect, become a NO.
Grace
But the NO is not the final word in God’s kingdom. The radical and pervasive brokenness created by our guilt is mirrored by the King’s radical and pervasive solution through Christ. The NO is penultimate—or, second to last. Through Christ, God’s YES is ultimate and final. Through Christ, the all-pervasive wrong of our sin has been righted. The mega-injustice has been taken care of. Barth teaches, “God is the one who with his NO says YES to us—a full, unrestricted YES with no question marks, a YES pregnant with God’s will and power to save us, to carry us, to set us on our feet, to make us free and merry.”
“God’s relation to the world is characterized by the polarity of justice and mercy, providence and concealment, the promise of reward and the demand to serve him for his sake. Taken abstractly, all these terms seem to be mutually exclusive, yet in actual living they involve each other; the separation of the two is fatal to both…Tension, contrast, and contradiction characterize all of reality.”
ABRAHAM HESCHEL, GOD IN SEARCH OF MAN
Gratitude
The YES of the King’s grace now allows humankind to respond with our own YES that accepts his invitation. When our own YES echoes God’s YES, we join his kingdom and joyfully accept our role as the body of Christ in its kingdom mission. We live out this acceptance in both our individual and our corporate efforts to see kingdom justice brought to all.
“The remarkable thing about fearing God is that when you fear God, you fear nothing else; whereas if you do not fear God, you fear everything else.”
OSWALD CHAMBERS, THE HIGHEST GOOD
“Be the change that you want to see in the world.”
MOHANDAS GANDHI
This final movement in God’s story is my favorite to explain to teenagers. As we live in awe of the King’s grace, we can’t help but want to serve him. Because of who he is and what he’s doing in us, our entire lives become thank-you notes back to God. As kingdom followers, we don’t right wrongs out of duty, or out of our destined-to-fail attempts to earn our own salvation. We right wrongs because of all God has done for us.
HISTORY IS HIS-STORY
All that is happening today—and all that has ever happened throughout history—finds New meaning as it is viewed through the lenses of Good/Guilt/Grace/Gratitude. That means every time you teach about justice—or any other topic for that matter—you are robbing your students if you don’t show them how the Scripture you’re discussing contributes to, and is affected by, the unfolding plot. Let’s look at some of the “oldie but goodie” texts you and I tend to use to motivate kids toward deeper justice through the perspective of kingdom Good/Guilt/Grace/Gratitude.
NOTES
Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Cost of Discipleship (London: SCM Press, 1964), 47.
Dallas Willard, The Divine Conspiracy (San Francisco: Harper Collins, 1998), 40 (emphasis added).
To identify the 30 youth workers nationwide, we invited World Vision, Vision Youth, the Urban Youth Workers Institute, Compassion International, the National Network of Youth Ministries, the Center for Student Missions, Amor Ministries, and Presbyterians for Renewal to nominate a handful of urban, suburban, and rural youth workers in their circles who do exemplary social justice work with kids. Then we contacted these “exemplar” youth workers and carefully interviewed 30 of them. Next we asked 40 urban and suburban youth workers who are part of our Los Angeles Youth Ministry Network to answer questions like: “When it comes to service, social justice, and missions, what do you wish was happening in your students overall that isn’t?” “What types of tools and resources would help you engage your students in kingdom justice?” 41
One of our colleagues at Fuller Seminary, Dr. John Goldingay, describes the plot of the Old Testament as: “God began. Humanity turned its back on God’s instructions, and God started over. God promised, and a family grew. Israel cried out, and God delivered. God sealed, and Israel imperiled. God gave, and Israel took. Israel equivocated, and God accommodated. Israel turned away, and God wrestled. God preserved, and Israel turned back.” John Goldingay, Old Testament Theology: Volume 1 Israel’s Gospel (Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2003), 32.
Our version of God’s story very closely resembles one common in Reformation theology that was derived from the Heidelberg Catechism of 1563: Guilt, Grace, and Gratitude.
From a sermon preached by Barth on October 7, 1956 in the Bruderholz chapel on Leviticus 26:15. See Geoffrey Bromiley, Introduction to the Theology of Karl Barth (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1994), 84 (capitalization added).