Chapter 9 of 26

3: The World Beneath

3: The World Beneath

3

the world beneath

One of the more common comments I heard as I shared my research with others was, “Is it really that much different now than when I was in high school?” (which typically ranged from ten to thirty-five years ago). This comment usually revealed a subconscious yet nevertheless cognitive debate concerning the changing world as it affects not only adolescents but the rest of us as well. In many ways we want life to remain, if not static, at least somehow related to the world in which we grew up. But there is so much that reveals the opposite, and the conversation that followed such comments almost always headed in this direction: We think it is or at least should be pretty much the same for teenagers today as it was in the 1970s, but when we honestly look at the daily realities of the world today’s young are growing up in, we must admit that, as much as things may look the same, the world is very different.

Many researchers who study adolescence have concluded that far more research is needed to allow for a deeper and more penetrating psychosocial glimpse into the culture and life of the high school student community. Jeffrey Lashbrook, for example, while describing the difficulty of understanding this population using quantitative methods, suggested, “Videotaping peer interactions in a natural setting would be ideal, since it would offer a record of both verbal and nonverbal cues.” This suggestion and others like it reflect researchers’ view that what we know about adolescents is minimal at best, is often discovered via artificial methods, and is most likely limited to an individual issue (such as smoking or sexuality). Those who yearn for a larger data pool from which to draw in attempting to grasp the sociological reality of the adolescent experience see the need for a closer, firsthand look. In this study, therefore, I sought to become a part of the landscape so that the adolescents being studied were free to live their lives without filters (see the appendix for a more complete explanation of the study).

Another issue frequently raised regarding the study of adolescence is the concern that a researcher could do damage to an already fragile group by either trivializing its experience or reducing the complexity of the midadolescent experience to stereotypes and labels. As I have mentioned, what I observed was tested by both the academic literature and informal discussion groups.

I came to two conclusions within the first few weeks of this study. First, the vast majority of adults simply do not comprehend the complex and different world in which nearly all midadolescents dwell. Second, most adults fear and in many cases are basically repulsed by what they see in the adolescent world. The first conclusion was articulated by Patricia Hersch in A Tribe Apart. She states, “Adolescents today inhabit a world largely unknown to adults.” The second conclusion was not limited to my observation but has been evidenced in other literature as well. In a 1999 survey by Public Agenda that asked adults what they thought of American teenagers, the words that came to mind were rude and wild. Both conclusions confirm the need to find out how abandonment and adult attitudes have affected adolescents.

A World Beneath

I did not approach my study believing that I would discover an overriding framework within which to organize the data and conclusions, but that is what happened. I discovered that midadolescents have responded to systemic abandonment by creating a separate and highly structured social system, what I call the world beneath. The world beneath is a broader concept than the notion of a youth culture or a generation gap. This world has been evolving over several decades, but within the last several years, it has shifted from a rather innocuous and at times innocent withdrawal to a unique and defended social system. Whereas midadolescents of the past formed “treehouses”—esoteric but largely conspicuous expressions of separation—the world beneath today’s adolescent landscape is much more like an underground society: sophisticated, pervasive, and not meant to be seen. It is not unlike the social system of any culturally oppressed subgroup: while its members know they must live in the majority world, they also have a distinctively different world that is reserved just for them, where few “outsiders” are welcome. It has its own rules of relating, moral code, and defensive strategies that are well known to midadolescents and are tightly held secrets of their community.

The separation of youth from the world of adults began perhaps as early as the first few decades of the twentieth century. During World War II and throughout the 1950s, there was a distinct flavor to the younger generation. Rock ’n’ roll, teen films, and adolescent dress and style were introduced as markers of this newly developing subculture. As previously discussed, the 1960s was the decade of change in many areas of American life. Our naïveté and carefree life of post–World War II culture were shattered by political assassinations, the civil rights movement, the Vietnam War, and the newly highlighted drug culture. By the late 1970s and early 1980s, we were well on our way to a we/they relationship between the adult world and the adolescent community.

During the early and middle part of the century, adolescents forged a unique path in the landscape of the adult world. In the 1960s, only a vocal and visible handful attempted to live as if the adult world’s rules and norms did not apply to them. As the years wore on and the abandonment of the young increased, however, adolescents went completely underground and created the world beneath. The contributing factors are varied and complex, but the foundational reason behind the separation between the adult world and the world of adolescents is that society has abdicated its responsibility to nurture the young into adulthood. The blame for this separation cannot be placed solely or even primarily at the feet of the typical enemies of traditional society: Hollywood, television, technology, the Industrial Revolution, music, or even parents. For years, adults have blamed adolescents for their rebellion against society and have, by neglect, pushed adolescents away. The formation of a separate culture for reasons of protection and safety is hardly a new phenomenon. Throughout human history, oppressed people groups have often created private subcultures in response to marginalization at the hands of those in power. What is new is that our own young people—by and large—have become marginalized by a neglectful adult culture.

Three major issues are related to the world beneath. First, adolescents intuitively believe they have no choice but to create their own world; to survive, they have to band together and burrow beneath the surface to create a safe place. Second, because midadolescents sense an emotional and relational starvation, the most important thing in their lives is a relationally focused home where they know they are welcome. Third, midadolescents have an amazing ability to band together in a way that satisfies their longing to connect with others as they try to navigate the challenging and at times harrowing journey of adolescence.

Like the farmer in Field of Dreams who felt he had no choice but to build the baseball field at the bidding of a persistent yet elusive voice, every adolescent hears an equally compelling internal voice calling him or her to build the world and social setting he or she so desperately wants. The notion of social capital, that individuals must receive vital relational and social resources to understand who they are and where they fit, is now viewed by many as a central element of adolescent development. As midadolescents become more aware of their surroundings, they develop a heightened sense of the world around them. As they enter this stage of development, they begin to recognize the abandonment discussed in the previous chapters. Many cannot describe this awareness, but when given the opportunity to reflect on their experiences, they put the essential impression of abandonment on center stage. In light of the culture of abandonment, in which adolescents perceive little adult social capital directed their way, it is no wonder that they feel the need to create the world beneath. As Robert Putnam put it in Bowling Alone, “The absence of positive norms, community associations, and informal adult friendship and kin networks leaves kids to their own devices. It is in such settings that youths are most likely to act on shortsighted or self-destructive impulses. It is in such settings too that youths are most prone to create their own social capital in the form of gangs or neighborhood ‘crews.’”

Every parent who has gone through this period knows that midadolescents have an insatiable appetite for peer relationships. When abstract thought begins to emerge (at roughly fifteen years of age), adolescents have an intuitive awareness that the process of becoming an adult necessitates finding oneself in the context of peer relationships. What is new to this stage is that because midadolescents believe they have been taken advantage of for most of their lives by those in authority (and are not yet developmentally able to distinguish the good teacher/coach/Sunday school teacher from the bad), they experience to a greater intensity the need to build deep, intimate, and powerful peer relationships to survive. Because of this intensity, the drive to build a reservoir of social capital will not be denied, regardless of the source. Thus, extremely potent emotions come with peer relationship development and maintenance.

In an article dealing with the difficulty of being an adolescent in contemporary culture, especially in terms of sexuality and the media, John Chapin borrows from Anne Rice’s novel Belinda, in which she uses a character named Belinda to describe what it is like to have reached physical adulthood and yet not be prepared or equipped for adulthood:

I had my first period when I was nine. . . . I was wearing a C-cup bra by the time I was thirteen. The first boy I ever slept with was shaving every day at fifteen; we could have made babies together. . . . But what is a kid here? . . . You can’t legally smoke, drink, start a career, get married . . . all this for years and years after you’re a physical adult. All you can do is play ’til you’re twenty-one. . . . We’re all criminals. . . . To be an American kid, you have to be a bad person. . . . Everybody’s an outcast. Everybody’s a faker.

This was typical of the kind of talk I heard throughout my study. Few midadolescents have the developmental ability to reflect on why they feel cut off, alone, and anxious, but just like Belinda, they feel the effects. As William Mahedy and Janet Bernardi put it, “Young people who have been abandoned and left to themselves are understandably wary and tentative, trusting little and withholding commitment.” And because their need for social bonds is so heightened, they can think of little else but the quality and experience of their friendships and romantic possibilities (which are linked at this stage to the same developmental need).

In the midst of this driving need to create places of safety and belonging, even as they intuitively feel the results of being abandoned, they are what literature refers to as “resilient.” An external optimism characterizes them, such that they feel they are okay, that they can take care of themselves, and that they do not need anybody. As one teacher remarked, “I don’t know why I keep hitting my head against the wall. Maybe the kids are right when they tell me that I don’t know them or understand them and that they are fine without me. Sometimes I just don’t know anymore why I even bother.” Many adults have felt this same frustration. Because of the multiple forces and agendas squeezing them, many teenagers exhibit a callous and indifferent spirit. They often act as if they believe that adults are unnecessary. Yet this is never the whole story, for at their core each one is crying out for an adult who cares. By the time adolescents have entered the middle stage of the process, they have so little trust that they are reticent even to allow an adult to glimpse how badly they desire an adult who cares.

A year or two before I began this study, I was invited to attend a lecture by a world-renowned developmental psychologist. One of the points of his lecture was to sell the notion of “kids’ resiliency,” which he viewed as an important component of healthy adolescent development. When this speaker-researcher was asked about this in the context of divorce, he stated simply that “kids for the most part get over divorce, for divorce is episodic and kids are generally resilient.” On a superficial reading of the available evidence, he was technically correct, for data affirm that adolescents have a powerful capacity for surviving and even thriving in extremely difficult circumstances. He called divorce, then, “episodic,” a singular episode that, in his opinion, a young person can and usually does move on from in relative wholeness.

But divorce, or any other expression of abandonment, is episodic only in that most young people generally learn how to find a way through the pain, even though the hurt runs deep. While it is fairly clear that adolescents are resilient, traumatic events are permanent reminders of abandonment that can cause significant psychological suffering many years down the road. Being resilient to trauma is similar to “getting over” the loss of an arm. The consequences of a ripped-apart family system remain a constant source of brokenness throughout one’s life. In this same way, while abandonment may be experienced due to episodic events scattered over time, and while adolescents may learn how to rebound, the cumulative results of this perceived abandonment still weigh heavily on them.

A Complex Social Reality

In tunneling beneath the observable adult landscape and creating the world beneath, the primary preoccupation of midadolescents is to find a place of relational safety. As society allowed for the erosion of consistent and coherent rules, norms, rites, and rituals that nurtured the young from childhood to adulthood, midadolescents were forced (or believed they were forced) to create their own. In every human there is a driving need to fit in with others and to find one’s sense of place in a social grouping. This search for a larger story, or what some call a metanarrative, coupled with the desire to be with others who make one feel comfortable, is what drives the adolescent need to create a unique world without adults. The world beneath is concerned with one major feature: safety.

In my study, I was amazed by midadolescents as they sought to create their own sense of place in a complex and intricately structured social hierarchy and setting. As freshmen went about the task of determining where and how they fit, even apart from the process of developing their primary friendships (which is discussed in chapter 4), they were drawn in and enveloped by the web that had been spun by those who had gone before. The entry into this world, therefore, is a fait accompli by virtue of their being thrust into the midadolescent social setting of the school. The environment is in many ways sophisticated and tightly controlled, for it accommodates the constant ebb and flow of the release of graduates and the assimilation of incoming freshmen.

One of the most striking discoveries I encountered was the degree of adeptness required to function in the varied social settings of midadolescence. As Chapin notes, “Models of adolescent development differ in the number of tasks they posit and the labels attached to them. However, most agree that the central work of adolescence includes developing a positive body image, beginning to achieve economic and emotional independence, more completely defining sex roles, developing relationships with the opposite sex, preparing for future occupational and family roles, and developing civic competence.” This list, however, barely scratches the surface of the variety of tasks assigned to adolescents in contemporary culture. It does not include, for example, the necessity of determining how to navigate the multiple expectations of teachers, parents, and other adults while maintaining satisfying and fulfilling adolescent relationships. One needs to balance loyalty to family with creating a sense of family with peers. One also needs to learn how to please a parent, coach, teacher, or other youth influencer while dealing with an internal sense of abandonment. These are but a sampling of the multiple contexts of life within which every midadolescent must live. Each of these contexts presents its own unique challenges, making the world of midadolescents a highly volatile, at times hostile, place. The world beneath provides for midadolescents the respite they need to survive the aggressive anonymity of the high school world.

This line of thought led me to another startling observation, namely, that today’s midadolescents have been forced to live according to the multiple selves that define them. As Susan Harter and her colleagues report, adolescents develop a “proliferation of selves that vary as a function of the social context. These include self with father, mother, close friend, romantic partner, peers, as well as the self in the role of student, on the job, and as athlete. . . . A critical developmental task of adolescence, therefore, is the construction of multiple selves in different roles and relationships.” This necessity for multiple selves, a far more complex developmental requirement than for any previous generation, causes midadolescents to seem almost schizophrenic to adults who can see life only through the lens of a single (or dominant) self who plays many different roles. As midadolescents bounce from self to self, the ability to handle each situation and setting requires a heightened capacity for integrated abstract thought. Over the course of this study, I became convinced that the defining developmental characteristic of midadolescence, then, is the ability to draw on abstract and complex processes of thinking and logic within each layer. Interestingly enough, however, midadolescents are not yet able to integrate such thinking across the many layers in which they live.

I came to this conclusion after observing numerous contradictions within sharp and clever students. For example, I listened to a sophomore girl (a self-proclaimed active church attendee) convince me that she loved her parents more than anyone else and that she would never do anything to hurt them. Yet almost immediately afterward she engaged in a profanity-laced conversation with a friend as she described her sexual relationship with a boy she had met the previous weekend. I was clearly within earshot of this discussion, yet she seemed oblivious to my presence. When she turned back to me a few minutes later, I admitted to her that I had overheard a bit of her conversation. I asked her, “How would your parents feel if they had heard you?”

She simply smiled. “What they don’t know won’t hurt them.”

“Would you lie to your parents if they guessed anything?”

“Of course. Well, not lie, exactly, but I know that they would be mad at me, and so I would make sure that they would not find out the truth.”

This winsome, attractive, and deceptive young woman did not see the contradiction between her behavior and her attitude. She lived her life in multiple selves and, in this case at least, did not see a conceptual bridge between them.

Adults who acknowledge that adolescents operate in multiple layers tend to think that this is their way of attempting to create a more coherent sense of identity as they grow up. Such adults also often implicitly believe that adolescents simply move from setting to setting trying on different selves as they move through their day. What I observed, however, tells a substantially different story. The home base of a midadolescent is the world beneath. Therefore, any entry into a layer of living that is ordered and controlled by an adult (or even under the influence of an adult-controlled system, such as a student-led and -run endeavor like the school yearbook, student government, etc.) is a temporary excursion into potentially hostile territory and is, therefore, basically not safe. An adolescent will move back as quickly as possible into the world of adolescents, where he or she feels included.

Today’s midadolescents have discovered that they must adapt to the expectations of those who control the world in which they live. They have become adept, therefore, at making adults believe that the selves they see are in reality the entire package. This was incredibly discouraging in my work with midadolescents. The person I cared for, taught, counseled, and even befriended was not the true, authentic, unfiltered self that friends saw. What parent of a contemporary midadolescent has not heard, “You don’t even know me. The only people who know me are my friends!” For midadolescents, living in multiple selves is pretense and accommodation while the world beneath is reality.

Not only did I observe midadolescents living in multiple selves, but I was also struck by the consistent and bald-faced self-centeredness of the community. It makes sense, of course. If adolescence is the process of trying to discern who one is and ultimately take responsibility for one’s life (individuation), then the process itself forces the midadolescent to be self-focused. As adolescents recognize that for much of their lives they have been under the authority of an adult agenda that they perceive holds little regard for them, they feel the need to flee and create their own world away from adult control. Hersch states, “The adult agenda is not about what might work better for adolescents. It’s all about let’s control the kids, keep them in check. That is the attitude that turns kids away.” In this turning away, they burrow beneath the surface of the adult world, which they perceive as a threat to, or at least a roadblock in, their personal journey. They see this distancing from adults as the only option for happiness, security, and safety. In light of internally perceived abandonment, then, midadolescents live in a constant state of reactivity.

As the study progressed, an obvious question was, is this world beneath limited to the dominant culture, represented by the European-American middle and upper-middle classes? As much as I sought to distinguish ethnic differences in response to abandonment, I saw few differences, with the exception of newly arrived Korean immigrant students. I observed that Latino, African-American, Armenian, and Asian students who had been even moderately assimilated into the dominant culture experienced and responded to the issue of abandonment in ways similar to those of European-American students. Studies have shown that while ethnic adolescents tend to reject their parents’ rules and norms, just as those in the dominant culture do, they do not reject identification with their ethnicity. In the world beneath, all students are looking for a safe place, even when in that world there remain ethnic and socioeconomic subgroups.

As has been noted, many researchers believe that, despite compelling evidence to the contrary, “the picture of adolescence today is largely a very positive one. Most adolescents in fact succeed in school, are attached to their families and their communities, and emerge from the teen years without experiencing serious problems such as substance abuse or involvement with violence.” My study confirmed that on several levels this is indeed the case. Most midadolescents are basically healthy and solid young people who are simply trying to make sense of a life made almost unbearably difficult by adult society. There are several wonderful things to be said about the state of contemporary adolescence, for a spark of creativity, resilience, inner strength, and determination resides at the core of the human person.

But I cannot affirm that “the picture of adolescence today is largely a very positive one.” I instead prefer the image of the vaudevillian plate spinner who is skilled at getting several plates to spin at once and even making it look easy at times. But the performer and the audience both know that the plate spinner is one small event, decision, or experience away from having the entire show fall to pieces. There are many good things going on in the world beneath, but the plates are spinning at an alarming speed, and the energy it takes to keep them on their poles is taking its toll on the hearts and psyches of midadolescents. As Madeline Levine writes, “Not only are many of these kids expected to perform at the highest levels; they are also expected to make it look easy. Heavily dependent on their ‘public’ success for a sense of self, many of these youngsters have little in the way of authentic purpose in their lives, leaving a void where conscience, generosity, and connection should be.”

The Outer Shell and the Inner Reality

The most visible mark of the world beneath is the callousness that most adolescents wear like a defiant badge of honor when adults try to penetrate their world. Adults often mistake this air of callousness for a genuine hardness and indifference, thus increasing the distance between them. Whether this callousness arises from a general defensiveness or in an effort to claim power and collective identity in a world perceived as hostile, adults often perceive this shell as an indication of a separate and resistant youth culture. Adults are, frankly, afraid of most adolescents and therefore too intimidated to see how deep the layers of hardness go. This is most often misinterpreted by adolescents as a lack of care and concern for them, and thus the cycle continues.

I, however, did not observe a culture of calculated defiance emerging from midadolescents. What I encountered was a reaction perceived as necessary by a specific age group that sees itself as abandoned and therefore on its own. The apparent callousness and indifference I experienced seemed to be a test for any adult who tried to come too close. Midadolescents generally do not trust adults with the intimate reality of their lives. These fragile young people are not pretending to be callous; rather, they are wearing their toughness like a shield to protect them from further disappointment. This, however, is an exhausting and never-ending game, for even midadolescents know that many adults really do care and are worthy of trust. For most, however, the risk is too great. And yet they are so tired of keeping up the pretense.

One of my graduate students who read the first draft of this chapter asked at this point, “Is this pure speculation, these last few sentences? They are poetic, but are they substantiated?” The last few paragraphs represent my strong impressions as I reflected on the idea and state of the world beneath. I offer the following example in response. It is anecdotal, to be sure, but it is nonetheless representative of the kinds of things I heard and saw as I was let into the world of midadolescents. This poem by a junior is but one of nearly one hundred serious poems students composed and gave to me.

Step into the Dark

Step into the dark where no one can see

Step into the dark where all you see is me

Step into the dark where there is suffering and pain

Step into the dark where not a single person knows your name

Step into the dark where the only color is black

Step into the dark where love is a mystery

Step into the dark where real men don’t come back

Step into the dark where no one leaves tracks

Step into the dark where hell is a block away

Step into the dark where you might brighten my day

John M.

The world beneath exists because midadolescents believe that few if any adults genuinely care about them. Writing specifically about the plight of contemporary young women, Mary Pipher, in Reviving Ophelia, asserts that “girls are having more trouble now than they had thirty years ago. . . . Something new is happening. Adolescence has always been hard, but it’s harder now because of cultural changes in the last decade. . . . There is an African saying, ‘It takes a village to raise a child.’ Most girls no longer have a village.” Certainly, this applies to boys as well, and it is most acute in midadolescence, when the ability to reflect and think abstractly reveals a discouraging truth: adult society has contributed to the state of our young by not swiftly and decisively putting a stop to any and all forms of abandonment. We have stood by and allowed a small group of teachers to belittle, authorities to ridicule, coaches to discourage, and parents to neglect and abuse. The young respond by creating the world beneath as the only satisfying option for survival in an unsympathetic world. Hersch puts it well: “Aloneness makes adolescents a tribe apart.”

Today’s adolescents are, as a lot, indescribably lonely. They cling to their friends in the world beneath because they feel they have no other choice. There are certainly notable exceptions in every corner of an adolescent’s experiences—at least a few good teachers, a caring and kind coach, a present parent. But the irresistible conclusion is this: as adolescence has lengthened and midadolescence has become more amorphous and its members more set apart, young people have begun to wonder if anyone truly cares about them. Friends care, but only insofar as they are able to maintain the norms of their peer group. Many adults care, but it takes a great deal of effort to undo what one Sunday school teacher, Little League coach, or piano teacher said or did so long ago. And so for now, they keep their collective chin up and make the best of the world beneath.

Conclusion and Musings

As I said earlier in this chapter, I had the privilege with so many teens to sit on the steps of their secret world. I saw encouraging and positive things coming out of that world. I saw genuine kindness and loyalty. I heard lofty dreams and honest stories. I saw great potential; sincere desire to make a difference; flashes of goodness, creativity, and light.

Yet I also witnessed palpable darkness. I heard vicious and vile conversations. I saw new levels of vulgarity that I found astonishing. I saw tremendous pain masked by obnoxious defiance, an insatiable selfishness, and indescribable cruelty. Even with all the good, the world beneath is filled with dark corners and hidden crevices. We as adults have a long way to go to penetrate the layers of protection that keep us from being one more disappointment in a world filled with them. But I am convinced that we are welcome to visit the borders of this mysterious and separate world, but only if we are willing to become students of our young.

Considering the complexity of the world beneath the surface, adults and adult systems have no choice but to attend to the developmental needs and nurturance of midadolescents. The most discouraging and even offensive obstacle to doing so is the myth that our young are doing fine, a view unfortunately promoted in many books and articles. The first step, then, is for adults—especially those holding positions of power in institutions and systems that interact with adolescents—to repent of neglect and insensitivity. We must see the young as our kids, not someone else’s problem—not the schools’, the parents’, the government’s, or the media’s. We must recognize that we have abandoned our young for decades and that it will take years to correct our indifference. We have no choice. As William Mahedy and Janet Bernardi argue, “No society that alienates its youth and sets them adrift can continue to exist, for it is already in a state of collapse.”

The most vital things those close to individual midadolescents can do are to, first, understand their world, and second, provide boundaries for them in a way that will keep them from making seriously negative choices even as they attempt to navigate this difficult developmental phase of life. Again, Mary Pipher puts it well: “When teenagers temporarily lose their heads, which most do, they need an adult to help them recover.” This help is at its best when an adult or, better yet, a community of adults seeks to truly understand what life is like for contemporary adolescents and then lovingly surrounds them with support, nurture, and authentic care. It is by recognizing that today’s adolescents have felt forced to create their own separate, distinct, and private world—the world beneath—that we as adults can begin to unravel and rebuild what has been lost as we have abandoned our young. To begin to change the current state of adolescence, we need to understand the specific implications and consequences of the world beneath.

↑ Back to top

↑