13: What Do Midadolescents Need?
13
what do midadolescents need?
Sometimes, I’m not who I seem to be
Sometimes, I keep it all inside of me
I know I could use a friend
But how can I tell you what’s in my head?
That’s when I cry
I let the tears run down my face
In the darkness
Where you can’t see me
And you can’t ask me why.
But when you’re there
I keep my head held high
With a smile upon my face
So you don’t know my pain or what I’m going through.
It’s too late, you can’t help me now
It’s too late, you can’t help me now.
Don, a high school student
Throughout this book, I have struggled with the constantly nagging question, so what do we do about abandonment and the world beneath? Almost everyone who read the initial chapters came away with the same question. My friends and associates wanted answers to “fix” this situation, not just more observations and questions. Unfortunately, the issues raised in this book are so subtle, evolutionary, and complex that solutions too quickly offered could trivialize the midadolescent plight and do more harm than good. We live in a culture that tells us we have the ability, with enough focused resources and energy, to conquer any problem, no matter how large. The sweeping changes society has gone through over the past few decades, however, make the multifaceted nature of the issues facing adolescents all the harder to diagnose, much less address. As one teacher lamented near the end of my study,
It is as if the problem of caring for kids is just too overwhelming. As a teacher, I have so many things to think about and deal with—keeping up with grading, staying on schedule, maintaining order and discipline in the classroom. All this and still having to get my kids to perform for the standardized tests that we all feel so much pressure from.
But when I think about it, I know I could listen a little harder, stay a little later, and show a bit more personal interest in the lives of my students. And I sometimes do. But then there are those days when I snap at the least little thing, when I am tough and hard when somebody gets under my skin. I guess more days are like that than not, but to be honest, the demands of the job allow me little time even to think about it.
What Does It Take to Make a Difference?
In X-Men 2, Jean Grey saves the day for her friends by using her mutant powers to hold up a crumbling dam, only to sacrifice herself in the process. In the film Precious, an unflappable and overly committed teacher breaks with convention and sincerely cares for a young woman who has been beaten down by life’s circumstances, taking her in and nurturing her back to health and confidence. In both of these films, I could not help but think that this is what those of us who care about the state of contemporary adolescents are up against. A lone figure with hands upraised cannot alter the societal push of abandonment. That does not mean, however, that we cannot soften its impact or compensate for its cruelty. We are not powerless. When we are willing to walk beside even one young person, we can make a difference.
One of the hallmarks of abandonment is the cultural shift from a nurturing focus on individuals to a focus on the group, the crowd, the statistics, the record, the program, the institution. Granted, addressing the larger, more global issue of abandonment will take an intense, lengthy, proactive assault from every corner of society. But I have reached the conclusion that the most significant help we can offer our young is to address their needs from the bottom up, at the point of the individual adolescent. Adults must care for and reach the individuals who have suffered from abandonment throughout their lives.
This study, along with other current research dealing with intervention strategies that have affected the maximum number of young people, reveals that our cultural ethos of bigger, faster, and splashier does not apply to the issues facing contemporary adolescents. They need adults who are aware of the power of small, deliberate, and consistently authentic applications of relational concern, care, and nurture. As men and women who care about what abandonment has done to our young, we have the opportunity to make a significant difference if we but realize that the biggest need every student has is satisfied in an adult who is there for him or her. Our response must begin with an individual student who needs the encouragement and leadership of an adult who genuinely cares.
One of the main reasons for the retreat of adolescents from the adult world into the world beneath is that many adults have let them down throughout their lives. Most midadolescents carry with them a list of adults who did not protect or look out for them, whether it was a Sunday school teacher who kicked them out of class, a peewee soccer coach who angrily took them out of a game for making a mistake, or a teacher who called on them when they weren’t prepared. These experiences become the locus of a lack of trust in adults who say they care.
If adults are willing to wade through this lack of trust, and if they honestly desire to come alongside and nurture adolescents as they make their way into the community of adults, it will not take long for adolescents to recognize the sincerity and allow these adults into their lives. The only qualification an adult needs is the willingness and fortitude to authentically care. Once this foundation is laid, adults can focus on the three specific needs of midadolescents:
Youth Need Refocused, Nurturing Organizations and Programs
In the not-too-distant past, even in the United States, communities were just what the name implied—networks of friends and neighbors who knew one another and carved out a life together. The community existed for its members, and the young were no exception. Even as late as the early 1960s, community was a central aspect of life together. In larger cities, as community boundaries became less identifiable, this became more problematic. By and large, however, even in the most urban of centers, people attempted (until the last thirty or forty years) to maintain a sense of community.
Across our nation, in villages, towns, and even cities, adults and children celebrated life together. They ate together, danced together, and played together. Little children were scolded by merchants, who often played the role of a relative. A teenager considering college was the talk of the barber shop. An invitation to a state band concert, a bad case of the chicken pox, or a home run at a county softball tournament captivated the interests of the entire community. Everyone mattered, and that included teenagers, even though they were still a few years removed from full adult status.
The benefits of this tribal connection are obvious, especially in light of how far our culture has drifted from that. Not too long ago, even single parents were not alone in raising their kids, for someone was always looking out for them. Even as “rebellious” adolescents, young people knew they were valuable members of the community, were genuinely enjoyed and appreciated, and therefore were given boundaries and protected. Even when teenagers pushed against the adult rules and the seemingly unjust and unnecessary constrictions placed on them by both their parents and the community, it was simply a part of society continually redefining itself as it assimilated new blood and fresh ideas into the life of the village. Adults knew their responsibility to nurture and protect the young, and therefore they held fast, realizing that the young were their most precious resource. They even started activities and programs intended to organize communal nurture of the young.
Today, that kind of community, especially in terms of how adolescents are viewed, is all but lost. This study showed that what is true about midadolescents in Los Angeles County is also true in Washington, North Carolina, rural Minnesota, central Georgia, Upstate New York, suburban Chicago, and inner-city Seattle. The young of every village, town, and city in America are in need of the same thing: a community of people, organizations, and institutions that have their individual needs and interests in mind. Some examples of this may be
These are three fairly straightforward and simple examples of what it means to connect adolescents to nurturing adults. The need is real to recover the original intent of nurturing opportunities and to reshape how we serve the young in every community.
Youth Need a Stable and Secure Loving Presence
Connie was confident, proud, smart, and witty. She stopped me after a talk I had delivered on the topic of this book and said, “I just don’t get how you can put us all in a box!” Connie’s initial point was that while she appreciated those adults who took an interest in her, she wanted me to know that she did not need their help. She felt she needed to figure out how to live life on her own. “I am sick of feeling like I can’t do anything right and always having to defend myself.” We sat down, and she told me her story.
Connie was the oldest of three children. Her parents fought all the time. They were still together, but her dad had left at least twice during the past few years, usually flying out the door in a huff. She had become, apparently with little thought by her parents, the stable one in the home. At seventeen, she did most of the laundry, drove the other two kids, and cooked more than half the meals. She was an athlete, involved in student government, had a boyfriend, went to her church youth group, and was a good student.
My talk that morning had focused on the longing for a safe place, personalizing and placing in context the notion of abandonment. Connie felt she didn’t have a safe place, and there was nobody in her life who was truly concerned about her needs. She felt alone, stuck, ignored, and used. Yet she simply could not see a way to escape the unending pressure she felt from every area of her life. The only solution she had come up with, prior to hearing me that morning, was to step up and live her own life. She felt abandoned and desperately wanted a place where she could rest. Connie wept when we talked about her childhood memories of sitting in her father’s lap watching television and going on walks in the park with her mom and little sister. Suddenly she sat up, wiped her eyes, and exclaimed, “Those days are long gone. You know it and I know it. I am on my own. I just can’t let myself think this way. It’s stupid to even think about. I can’t take it. I’ve got to go.” With that, she left.
Her story describes life for many midadolescents. The source of the pressure may be different and may come with unique intensity and challenges, but the feeling of lost childhood, the loss of a safe embrace, and the seemingly unreachable hope of finding true security, safety, and rest are universal. Young people do not want to be smothered or too tightly bound. They need the opportunity to venture out into the world, all the while confident that they have a safe place to return to.
This is the cry of many midadolescents. As they become aware of the difficulty, pain, and complexity of the world, the hurts of the past are magnified. Worse, this causes midadolescents to dive underground and grab on to a few friends for emotional and sociological survival. Midadolescents seem impenetrable, callous, without a need for adults. This is not a smokescreen. It is an authentic depiction of how they have chosen to cope with the danger of abandonment by those they had trusted. Adults should not be fooled by the reactions or even the words of adolescents. They should trust that each one is desperate for a safe and secure loving presence, regardless of whether they know it or not.
Youth Need to Experience Authentic, Intimate Relationships with Adults
Building a bridge between adults and adult-run systems, structures, organizations, and institutions is not enough to bring vital healing to the wounded psyches of adolescents. Each individual, by the time he or she is a midadolescent, needs to know that at least one adult knows him or her well and will do whatever it takes to bring him or her into the community of healthy adulthood.
In popular rhetoric today, that is a job exclusively relegated to parents. One teacher, when he found out the nature of my research project, told me he had a student who showed up late for class almost every day. The teacher had tried everything he could think of to motivate the student to be responsible, and eventually he tried to work with the boy’s parents. When he was finally able to talk to the mother (a single parent), she took no responsibility for the boy’s behavior and truancy. “She said she couldn’t control him. If only the parents would do their job, we wouldn’t have to be burdened with doing their job for them!”
The frustration displayed by this teacher was understandable, and I could certainly empathize with him. But this typical scenario of a parent who is clearly at her wits’ end and a teacher who has simply gotten mad is but one more example of how societal fragmentation has hurt the young. In a segmented, fragmented culture in which neighbors do not know one another’s names and families are so busy that they don’t have time for an evening meal together, even the best of parents cannot possibly hope to meet all the nurturing requirements of raising a postmodern adolescent. Teachers, even the best ones, get overwhelmed by the multifaceted demands of their jobs, and it is little wonder that they sometimes feel as if they are society’s last hope of nurturing the young.
Yet the fact remains that every child needs authentic, intimate relationships with adults until he or she has completed much of the adolescent process. This responsibility cannot fall to parents alone or to teachers, who can influence individual students for a year at best. The only way we can stem the tide of the consequences of abandonment is to encourage a wide variety of adults to take part in the lives of the young. Nothing else will make a difference—not more baseball fields, more programs and events, or more job opportunities. Because the root of the issues related to contemporary adolescence has to do with leaving this age group to flounder on its own, the answer is relationships with adults who sincerely care. That is the most fundamental need of this abandoned generation.
