Chapter 13 of 26

6: Family

6: Family

6

family

Twenty-five percent of the people polled in a recent national inquiry into American morality said that for $10 million they would abandon their entire family; a large number of people are evidently willing to do the same thing for free.

Stephanie Coontz, The Way We Never Were

Regardless of headlines labeling us “helicopter” dads and “soccer” moms, in many ways parents seem almost invisibly removed. Twenty-first century parent-managers, negotiating every single logistical challenge of their kids’ crammed schedules became too frenetically busy to be a magnetic presence in the internal landscape of a child’s world.

Ron Taffle, Childhood Unbound

By the third week of my study, I was beginning to realize that the world I was being allowed to see was far more complex and precarious than I had imagined. One stunning illustration came in a conversation with a junior named Jeremy. What Jeremy told me about his family seriously threw me.

“Okay, I’ll tell you something I’ve never told an adult. In fact, I’ll tell you something I’ve never told anybody. Three years ago my parents got divorced, and they decided to keep it a secret. They told me and my sister that we weren’t allowed to tell anyone, not even our grandparents, or we would get in big trouble. So for three years we all have been living a lie. I haven’t told my friends, my coaches, my teachers, nobody, and neither has my little sister. My parents hate each other, and they fight all the time, but they pretend to be happily married around everyone else. It sucks!”

As I was trying to hide my shock and anger over what this young boy was being forced to carry, a shy girl on my left began to bite her nails and squirm.

“Me, too,” she said quietly.

“Excuse me?”

“Okay, I guess it doesn’t matter anymore anyway. My parents did the same thing last year to us. I hate them! I hate them both!”

Then the bell rang, and they were gone.

This event was not only gut-wrenching but also decisively instructional for me. I knew that for this study to mean anything, I needed to probe into every corner and pursue every possible angle of new information. Frankly, it had never crossed my mind that adults could do what these parents had done to their children. Unfortunately, such selfishness reflects a growing trend of parents placing their own needs ahead of those of their children.

It is likely that I had overlooked hundreds of hints and markers of the dark side of family life and had been fooled by the sophisticated callousness many young people are forced to exhibit on a daily basis. There are obviously many solid, supportive parents and families in American society. Generally, their children are the strongest and healthiest adolescents and are able to find a relatively stable path through the issues presented in this book. But the depressing and eye-opening reality I encountered that day is that the brokenness in today’s families is far more pervasive and destructive than I had ever imagined.

The Definition and Meaning of Family

The concept of the family has undergone intense and contentious change over the past twenty or so years. Today it is commonplace for popular television shows to depict “family” in a variety of nontraditional ways. The sitcom Modern Family, for instance, portrays three immediate families that are connected as extended family (a father and his two adult children): the father is remarried and has a young son the age of his grandchildren; the daughter is married and in a traditional family; and the homosexual son and his partner are raising an adopted daughter. Over time the idea of the family—what it is, who (or what) is included, and why it matters—has been slowly relegated to private opinion, creating a sociological and cultural divide.

I first encountered the battle over the definition of and the standards ordering the concept of the family in my doctoral studies. One well-respected professor told us that one of her more passionate academic goals was to change the definition of family in academic literature. She was dedicated to the ideological position that lesbians and gay men should have the right to raise children from birth and that therefore the more traditional understanding of the family (one man, one woman, and children) was an oppressive and outdated social construct that needed to be dismantled. I liked and admired this professor in many ways, but I believe she violated the most important command of academic integrity that she herself had drilled into us as PhD students: “Let the research lead you to conclusions about life, and do your best not to let your personal life or your pet perspectives taint your research conclusions.” The academic and popular debates adults have waged over the definition, meaning, and impact of the family have taken a toll on the young. What has happened with the notion of and attitude toward the family is perhaps the most significant form of cultural abandonment midadolescents have endured.

Overwhelming data regarding the influence of parents on child and adolescent development reveal that the most important place of safety for a young person is a supportive dual-parent setting. The kind of environment in which a child, especially during midadolescence, may ultimately be strengthened as he or she moves through the adolescent process is provided by a family with a relationally committed father and mother and a home that is a place of safety and security and where, even during conflict and rocky circumstances, an adolescent knows that he or she is unconditionally accepted and loved.

My observations confirmed this idea. The midadolescent students who struggled the most in nearly every category of adolescent development—for example, self-concept, sexual behavior, substance abuse, and trust in friends or authority figures—almost universally came from a family system in which the home was not a safe, supportive environment. For example, midadolescents known as sexually “loose” often come from families in which the father is not present or there is a specific and usually observable disconnect between the child and the father. (This was true of both boys and girls, although it was more easily recognizable in the behavior and attitudes of girls.) Based on dozens of conversations and many observations of this aspect of midadolescent life, I found that those who had learned (or were learning) to use their bodies to find comfort and connection through sexual play were trying to prove to themselves and to the world that they were worthy of love. Upon directed reflection, most adolescents came to the conclusion that those who were the most desperate for affection were not receiving it at home. Even midadolescents themselves could see how family life and parental relationships affected them. And the effects were not limited to external behaviors such as sexual experimentation, substance abuse, or partying. They also related to attitudes, confidence, and just about every other aspect of a person’s life. The family is paramount in the developmental and psychosocial life of adolescents.

Yet according to a recent article published by the American Psychological Association, there is no longer a standard definition of family. It simply means what one wants it to mean: “Families today can take many forms—single parent, shared custody, adoptive, blended, foster, traditional dual parent, to name a few.” Yet in many cultures of the world, the central role of parents has been maintained as responsibility for the nurture of the young. As mentioned in chapter 1, the family has been defined in the same way for centuries in American society: “two or more persons related by birth, marriage or adoption who reside in the same household.” Not only has that definition become simply one form among many and been assigned the label “traditional dual parent,” but it is also mentioned last on the above APA list of the many forms of contemporary families.

Not only is there no longer a standard definition of family, but it has become a word that allows for the justification, meaning, and structure of whatever situation adults find themselves in. During my time with midadolescents, I never encountered a dissenting voice that challenged how a household defined family. The rhetoric universally and unquestionably affirmed anyone and everyone’s definition.

Here are some of the ways the word family was used among the students:

  • Geri lived with her little sister and mother and her mother’s latest boyfriend in his house with his three kids (when they were not at their mother’s). Her family was her mother, sister, and the boyfriend (but not his kids).
  • The man Kim calls Dad is actually her mother’s former boyfriend. Kim never met her real dad, and she refers to the man she now lives with, her legal stepfather, by his first name. She told me she does not have a family.
  • Kara lives with her mother, older sister (whose boyfriend occasionally lives with them), and the grandfather of one of her closest friends. The word family is used only to talk about her mother’s family, meaning Kara’s maternal grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
  • Greg, the youngest child of a two-time divorcée, lives next door to his mother’s boyfriend of ten or so years, and his mom forces him to call this man Dad. He blames his mother for forcing the father he seldom sees out of their lives. His mother refers to both households, his immediate family (his mother and himself) and the family next door, as “their family,” but this usually happens only during holidays when some of them gather for “family holidays.”
  • Sam lives with his two moms and has never had a dad. His two moms are his family.
  • These are but a few samples of how varied and complex the notion of family is to many adolescents in American society. I had wrongly assumed that those in traditional dual-parent families would see these other expressions as somewhat less than ideal or at least contrary to the norm. Yet that was not the case. The concept of family is fluid for the developing midadolescent.

    Because the family is the primary source of the relational and emotional stability necessary for healthy development, these changing definitions are noteworthy. The family system can shift and change at the whim of adults with little care given to the consequences of these changes on the developmental life and health of children and adolescents. Unfortunately, those who advocate the changing labels and fluid definitions of family do not consider these consequences. In this study, however, the erosion of the family as the central, stable institution designed for and dedicated to the protection and nurturance of the young revealed significant (if not devastating) consequences for the psyches, relationships, worldviews, and overall lives of midadolescents.

    One particularly challenging—and rapidly growing—new form of the family unit involves cohabiting couples. Susan L. Brown contends that “the growth in heterosexual cohabitation exemplifies the informalization of the family and the increased emphasis on emotional (rather than legal) ties to others. Cohabitation is a distinct family form, neither singlehood nor marriage. We can no longer understand American families if we ignore it.” She goes on to report that children living in these situations “exhibit lower levels of well-being” and warns that “the private nature of cohabitation may be advantageous for adults but harmful to children . . . as dissolution can occur without court intervention that would determine custody and support.” As other studies have emphasized “the difficulty of any family structure change for adolescents,” parents must begin to take seriously the selfishness of this kind of shift and consider carefully the damage it may be doing to their kids. Furthermore, what happens in the family of a midadolescent spills over and affects every person who comes in contact with that adolescent. The changing definition of family, therefore, does not simply affect a few unlucky adolescents. It affects the entire society.

    Family/Parental Behaviors That Affect Adolescents

    Determining the effects of family life on midadolescents was a more difficult undertaking than understanding other areas of their lives. For the most part, students were closemouthed when it came to details and feelings about their families. The conclusions discussed in this chapter, therefore, are based on random comments as well as observations.

    The first and most striking observation is that parents seem to be fragmented. The time they need to keep their lives in order affects their ability to be there for their children. I encountered many healthy and involved parents, but there were far more uninvolved, stressed-out, and stretched-thin parents. The most common reaction I saw in teens was a sense that their parents do not make much difference in their lives. The feelings of those whose parents were involved and active in their lives ranged from being fairly satisfied with their parents to being frustrated over their parents’ need to control them. Those who saw their parents as being too preoccupied with their own lives and needs to be of any significant help to them reacted with a fatalistic and resigned view that they were doing fine on their own.

    For most, however, the resignation was actually a thin veneer that covered everything from disappointment to a deep sense of hurt and betrayal. In many cases, parental patterns of neglect and/or inactivity had developed long ago, and many adolescents felt they had been on their own since late elementary school. I heard story after story of uninvolved, disengaged, and self-focused parents who, by neglect, busyness, or a false understanding of what it means to be a parent, had pushed their children into a world they were not prepared to handle. Through his in-depth research on middle class adolescents, criminologist Elliott Currie observed this same reality.

    The abdication of parental responsibility in the face of trouble or transgression, the assumption that children themselves bear the primary responsibility for their own well-being and for steering their own path in life, the readiness to sever ties with them when things get tough—recurred again and again in my conversations with troubled middle-class adolescents, and these themes reflect an underlying vision of the problems of families and children that is widely prevalent in America.

    Many midadolescents have been set adrift by parental and familial authorities, and they are operating as if they are on their own. This reality penetrates the behavior and worldview of all midadolescents, even those whose parents are actively involved and committed to providing a stable environment, because they learn from their peers (and the media) that there are many ways to parent. Many adolescents, even those from involved and nurturing homes, may take advantage of the freedoms and lack of rules characteristic of students who are on their own. This is noteworthy because it has been shown that the familial environment contributes to delinquency in all its forms.

    The second observation addresses the intensity and amount of conflict that occur during midadolescence between parents and their children. For the majority of the students, conflict with a parent was almost a daily concern. Such conflicts fell into one of two categories: the nagging skirmishes that seemed to take place on a daily basis (spontaneous conflict over day-to-day matters such as clothes, homework, use of the computer, the shape of one’s room, and a basic lack of communication) and arguments over more global or important issues (conflict based on parental concern regarding things that might affect the child’s future, such as driving habits, substance abuse, grades, dating, and friendships). There is disagreement over whether these typical, almost daily conflicts are negative or positive. As Jeffrey Arnett points out, “Some scholars have suggested that conflicts between adolescents and their parents are actually beneficial to adolescents’ development, because it promotes the development of individuation and autonomy within the context of a warm relationship. This may be true, but high conflict may make adolescence a difficult time for adolescents and their parents even if the conflict ultimately has benefits.”

    In many cases, I got the impression that the parent-child relationship had created a series of communication patterns and responses to daily life. From the adolescent’s perspective, conflicts were almost always about trust. The majority of the conflicts that occur between parents and children, then, seem to be about the dynamics of the relationship rather than a particular issue. Research has shown that parent-child conflict increases during adolescence, especially during midadolescence. These conflicts are often rooted in how a parent deals with a growing adolescent rather than in a specific issue. For midadolescents, who are in the midst of daily internal conflicts, this hidden cauldron can have discouraging consequences, regardless of the nature or resolution of the verbalized issue.

    What matters most in the lives of adolescents, then, is how parents deal with conflict. Most midadolescents rapidly get over the day-to-day conflicts they experience at home, especially if they feel close to their parents. But parents are not as resilient. For many parents, even simple conflicts can push their buttons and drive a wedge in their relationships with their children. Over time, midadolescents pick up on this general sense of separation. This causes them to pull away from their parents. To complicate matters further, the rise of private cell phone use—particularly text messaging—among teens has enabled teens to “establish ‘secret networks’ off limits to parents” which, as might be expected, “may exacerbate whatever conflicts already exist within the family.” Thanks to technologies such as cell phones and the internet, shutting out parents has never been easier.

    Parents have a tremendous responsibility not to be thrown off or emotionally entrapped by parent-adolescent conflict. Adolescents know that their parents are supposed to be the adults, those who are to lead and guide them, without letting any conflict or emotion get out of hand. Far too often students described their parents as “out of control,” “always mad,” or “totally upset.” They responded by backing down to avoid conflict and becoming relationally disengaged. When pressed, few midadolescents wanted a distant relationship with their parents, yet most feel they have no choice but to distance themselves from emotional entanglement with their families. To them, this conflictual situation is further confirmation of adult abandonment.

    Midadolescents and Time with Their Families

    I asked the following question point-blank during the study: “Do you wish you had a closer relationship with your parents?” For the vast majority of students, this was not an easy question to answer, and so they tended to fudge. Grudgingly, most said something like, “Yes, I guess I would like to be closer, but . . .” The various qualifiers that followed would not come as a surprise to anyone: “they are always on my back,” or “they don’t know how to listen or how to be a friend.” I found that unless they viewed the relationship as irreparably fractured, they answered affirmatively.

    This confirms the research on parent-child relations, at least in terms of time together. As the American Psychological Association’s Healthy Adolescents Project maintains, adolescents know they need more time with adults, and especially their parents: “In a report by the U.S. Council of Economic Advisors, based on the latest research and presented at the May 2000 White House Conference on Teenagers: Raising Responsible and Resourceful Youth, teens rated ‘not having enough time together with their parents as one of their top problems.’” In general, my impression is that this rings true.

    Conclusion and Musings

    Recent studies have demonstrated that during midadolescence, peers have more influence on adolescents than family and parents do. I observed this during my study as well. I also observed, however, that during adolescence, teens have a desire to find safe and satisfying relationships at home. In fact, adolescents actually desire the approval of the family system for the way they live and the choices they make.

    Parents must commit to two vital strategies in leading and loving their midadolescent children: first, to understanding them and their world, and second, to providing them with safe and secure boundaries while still allowing them the necessary room to grow.

    The healthiest and most productive strategy is for parents to be so involved in the lives of their midadolescents that they can understand how complex, incongruent, and layered this phase of life is for their children. Parents who lovingly seek to understand that their son or daughter is in the midst of wildly changing psychosocial experiences and events will be well on the way to being the kind of anchor the child needs during this period. Parents need to realize that adolescence now lasts up to fifteen or more years. They need to see their parental role as a marathon, recognizing that building a relationship in which their child trusts them is even more important than whether they can trust their child regarding the immediate issues of the day.

    Moreover, especially during midadolescence, teenagers need room and flexibility to develop into who they are going to be and to learn what it means to create an internal locus of control (what has been called identity and autonomy). Mary Eastham writes, “The role of parents is to support the emerging young adult in his/her quest for a unique identity, independent of them and yet related in terms of their overriding values. Parents are to listen to their children’s dreams and goals, advise them, be there to support them, and yet allow them to make the important decisions in their lives.” This does not mean, however, that they need or even want to be separated from the one community that they believe will always be there for them. The peer cluster, as has been noted, is important and is even perceived to be their paramount support system. At the same time, most midadolescents recognize that this peer system is fraught with performance and conformity demands, making it a less than ideal place. Even the most independent, cluster-driven midadolescent needs (and at some level wants) to know that, regardless of behavior, problems, conflict, or looks, the family is a safe place.

    This means that parents must provide a safe, warm environment for midadolescents while simultaneously maintaining a stable force of authority and control. Parents must seek to understand their children but must also provide flexible and reasonable boundaries that will allow them to change and grow, relate to others, and make choices that matter, all while under the clear, purposeful, and deliberate leadership of their parents.

    Boundaries and understanding take a great amount of dedicated energy and resources. Parenting has, in many ways, never been more difficult. There are stock “principles” or absolutes. And parenting, especially with midadolescents, requires tedious negotiation and constantly shifting expectations. When parents recognize what their children need and then take the time to be that kind of parent, they discover that their children become stronger, healthier, interdependent adults. And the fruit of a carefully cultivated, lifelong friendship will be enjoyed for decades to come.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑