Chapter 11 of 26

4: Peers

4: Peers

4

peers

My parents don’t know me, my teachers don’t know me, even my coach doesn’t know me. The only people who really know me are my friends.

high school student

Kyle, a junior on the football team, and I were in the midst of a conversation about his life, his parents, and his friends. Kyle was among the most fortunate of the midadolescents I knew. His parents were married, they seemed to like each other, and the family was as stable as any. He was cared for, and his parents were supportive and active in his life.

The longer we talked (this had been the fifth or sixth occasion we had spent time one-on-one), the more he allowed me to glimpse the tougher aspects of his life. When he talked about his father, a “man’s man” who seemed to be “more into my football than I am,” the incongruity he felt in the relationship was clear. Kyle loved and even liked his dad, but he sensed somewhere inside that, while his father loved him, at times he was more interested in his accomplishments than in him. Kyle was not observably scarred, but he saw his dad as a relatively distant yet powerful force who ultimately wanted success for his son. When it came to his mom, Kyle said she was great and “of course” he loved her. Then Kyle made the statement, “My parents don’t know me. . . . The only people who really know me are my friends.” Studies have demonstrated that Kyle is not alone in these sentiments: adolescents feel free to be more authentic with their peers than with anyone else. Susan Harter and her colleagues report that perceived relational support is associated with true self-behavior and high self-esteem and that for adolescents “the least false self-behavior is reported in relationships with close friends.”

In chapter 2, I made the claim that nearly every adult system, structure, organization, and institution has systemically abandoned adolescents. In early adolescence, children do not have the cognitive ability to recognize this, and because they are closer to childhood than to adulthood, they have a greater connection with the relationships and institutions that provided safety during childhood. The early adolescent will show signs of entering a new psychosocial phase, called the second separation-individuation (the first is the developmental shift from infant to toddler), but because he or she does not have the cognitive ability to identify the source of the offending system or individual, he or she turns to a parent and the family system to ease the as-yet-unidentified pain.

During midadolescence this changes. The shift from early to midadolescence occurs when the ability to apply abstract thought begins to take shape. At roughly fourteen or fifteen years of age, adolescents begin to reflect on how they have been treated for much of their life, and it slowly dawns on them that they have been abandoned by those who—either explicitly or implicitly—were once there for them. When I encouraged adolescents to talk about past disappointments, to bring these feelings to the surface, and to examine past and present systems and institutions that impacted them, the emotions expressed ranged from disappointment or mild sarcasm to outright bitterness and hostility.

The Reason for Clusters: Kids Need a Safe Place

Changes have taken place across all segments of society, not the least of which is the high school sociological landscape. In the 1950s, a large pool of homogeneous adolescents jockeyed for a closer link to the inner circle of the popular students. Today, high schools are populated by smaller groupings of friends, or clusters, who navigate as a unit the complex network of social interdependence with a loyalty similar to that of a family. Nearly two decades before my study, Donald Posterski recognized the emerging new social order of clusters.

A friendship cluster is more than just a circle of relationships. It is heart and soul of being young today. It is a place to belong. There is no formal membership. You are either in or you are not. Being in means you share many things: interests, experiences, intimate thoughts, problems, and triumphs of the day. Being in means you tune in to the same music, wear each other’s sweaters, and generally just enjoy each other.

Today, the cluster is a family with a set of respected and controlled expectations, loyalties, and values. Sometimes the flag for a cluster is a similar interest, but what gives a cluster its power is a common, almost tribalistic bond and unifying social narrative (a grand story that gives meaning and cohesiveness to the cluster and defines who is in and who is not). This bond is the hallmark of the social group that nearly all mid-adolescents will rely on throughout their high school life.

The inability during midadolescence to balance disappointment over specific events, people, or institutions by separating the good from the bad drives the intense need for a safe place. Midadolescents gather in like-minded groups to protect themselves from the forces they perceive as alien to them. This is the main reason clusters have replaced cliques in today’s adolescent social economy: adolescents believe they have no alternative.

Clusters: The Social Self-Defense Mechanism of the Midadolescent

One of the most clearly observable aspects of middle adolescent life is the structure of their social world and the operational expectations of their peer relationships. A social hierarchy organizes their relationships, both friendships and romantic relationships. Students also arrange their daily tasks according to this socializing structure. From what hallway to walk down between classes, to where to see friends, to whom to go to the homecoming dance with, the parameters of day-to-day experiences flow directly from the phenomenon labeled clustering.

During the early 1990s, as I was making the vocational move from direct work with adolescents to an academic arena, the ideas postulated by Posterski and several others rang true for me, but I did not have a comprehensive framework that allowed me to understand fully this changing social system. Over the next ten years, I relied on research on peer relationships from around the world to help me grasp the complex changes going on in the world of adolescent peer relationships. I became convinced that something new was happening in the way adolescent friendships were formed and operated. Friendships and popularity as described in the media seemed to match my own experience from the 1970s and early 1980s, but it was evident that neither most adults nor the media—print, film, and television—was accurately portraying the radically changed nature of adolescent life and relationships.

While an increasing body of literature looks at peer relationships in adolescence, most focus on a single issue, such as drug or alcohol use, risk behavior, or sexuality. These issues are integral to adolescent life and are therefore included in this book. Unfortunately, far too little is known about the unique characteristics of peer friendships when applied solely to midadolescents. Yet it is during this period that peer relations take on an extremely significant role in the life of an adolescent.

Peer Cluster Theory

The construct known as peer cluster theory has been discussed for several years, albeit rarely, in adolescent academic literature. Yet it remains difficult to study adolescent peer relationships. An obvious reason is that researchers face difficulty getting inside the sociologically defined and psychosocially arranged relationship groupings, or clusters. Research literature, therefore, is filled with conflicting accounts and conclusions. For example, in a chapter in Readings on Adolescence and Emerging Adulthood, one of the most prestigious contemporary compilations on adolescent life and development, the authors dispute ethnographic and participant-observation findings that describe the increasing concreteness of adolescent peer groups (a precursor to fully developed clusters), despite the findings of more recent, solidly researched articles. They appeal instead to classically palatable theoretical and empirical research. The problem is that the studies and reports used in the chapter to soften (and in some ways even discredit) the recent findings were written in the 1970s and 1980s. Thus, even in the most current academic textbook on adolescent development, the issue of peer relationships is mired in theories at least twenty years old.

In all fairness, because the adolescent landscape is changing at such a rapid rate, it is extremely difficult for studies and theories regarding peer relationships during adolescence to keep pace in any meaningful way. There is, however, an alternative way to pull together divergent research and conflicting data. Typically, social science begins an inquiry into human activity with observation and open-ended research to try to get an accurate picture before attempting to test results, conclusions, and hypotheses. After the parameters and basic elements of a targeted population and area of study have been framed, instruments and methodologies are designed to test both the original assumptions and the resultant conclusions and hypotheses. This is generally referred to as the process of developing grounded theory, the most basic and unbiased form of research methodology.

The current process for interpreting information regarding adolescents, however, especially when attempting to understand them as a population, has not typically followed this method. Those who study adolescents have tended to reverse this process, starting with theories of development, performing narrowly framed empirical studies, and then forming generalized conclusions. This reversal of scholarly inquiry has created assumptions about adolescents that may have led to a theoretical framework that is neither helpful nor accurate. Theories, constructs, and data must be reassessed in light of fresh, unbiased qualitative and grounded research.

Based on the research I had encountered, I came to the present study prepared to witness elements of clustering and to attempt to describe and discern the power and impact of clustering on the social reality of middle adolescence. What I discovered as I lived among the students at the high school was far more powerful and pervasive than I had expected. Not only did I come to see clusters as the social order of the day, but I also observed firsthand the almost complete dismantlement of the social system and structure that I had experienced in high school in the early 1970s.

As we seek to understand how adolescents experience, define, and order their world, four aspects of clusters are especially significant: the reason clusters emerged, the distinguishing characteristics of clusters, how clusters are chosen and identified, and the protocol for members of one cluster relating to members of another.

The Why of Clusters

Generally, peer relationships have been seen as a normal part of the adolescent process. Traditional theories of development affirm that the shift from familial allegiance and intimacy to peer affiliation and commitment is a normal process during adolescence. Few would argue against the necessity for intimate peer relationships during adolescence, for they are important for social skill development. Other related theories of development involve important dimensions of peer relationships such as differentiation from parents and the development of communally negotiated moral and value structures. As contemporary theorists and researchers attempt to describe and codify the changes in adolescent development, they recognize that relationships are a, if not the, vital issue. Daniel Lapsley and Jason Edgerton, for example, have noted that “the press toward individuation requires the young adult to shed parental dependencies,” but—importantly—“this should not come at the expense of close family ties. Rather, the goal of individuation is relational autonomy, whereby independence and self-governance are affirmed within the context of continuous, mutually validating relationships.” Jeffrey Lashbrook reports that the social bonds that are developed during adolescence are essential for two reasons: they address the need to belong, and they provide a cohesive unit that serves as glue for society. An even more significant driving force for clustering today is the need to find a safe place.

There have been those who believe that adolescent peer relationships are not altogether positive for healthy adolescent development. As early as 1979, Urie Bronfenbrenner argued that the gravitation toward peer relationships during adolescence has a negative side. While stable, intimate, and satisfying relationships with peers assist adolescents in a variety of crucial developmental tasks, argued Bronfenbrenner, adolescents may tend to distance themselves from their families as they gravitate toward their peers. This is all the more true thirty years later, as the forces encouraging the culturewide abandonment of adolescents are growing more powerful. Many now see that parents have gradually pushed aside their children to the point that they have no choice but to form intimate associations with peers in order to replace what has been lost at home. This is the thesis of David Elkind’s Ties That Stress and The Hurried Child. It is also the conclusion of an important study on peer relationships by Maja Dekovic and Wim Meeus, in which they state that “adolescents turn to peers for companionship and emotional support not because they are inevitably attracted to peers, but because they are pushed in that direction by inattentive and unconcerned parents.” In fact, Madeline Levine has argued that even “well-meaning parents” add to this by “pressuring their children, emphasizing external measures of success, being overly critical, and being alternately emotionally unavailable or intrusive.” As previously shown, not only parents but also society has created the catalyst for clustering.

Midadolescents believe their only choice is to find a relational place where they are not in danger of being ignored, used, or pushed aside. The cluster, then, is not simply a developmental means to the end of preparation for adulthood. It is far more basic. The need for affiliation, support, and security during midadolescence is fertile ground for intensely powerful peer relationships. Because they have a need to discover social bonds that are meaningful and supportive, adolescents’ primary motivating factor is their immediate social structure. As Denis Jarvinen and John Nicholls found, “Satisfaction in peer relationships [is] associated with communal goals and beliefs that represent social interaction as an end rather than those agentic goals and beliefs about the causes of success that make social transaction a means to an end.” In short, clusters develop because midadolescents know they have no choice but to find a safe, supportive community, and in a culture of abandonment, the peer group seems to be the only option they have.

The What of Clusters

A cluster, while not in adolescents’ vocabulary, is a group of adolescents who identify themselves as a defined relational unit. Adolescents describe such a grouping as their “friends.” The word friend has been used for centuries to describe everything from a casual acquaintance to an intimate soul mate. In today’s adolescent world, the word friend represents something much different from what it meant in the late 1970s.

The following list of distinguishing characteristics of clusters represents my observations of adolescent relationships as expressed on a local high school campus.

  • Size: Clusters can contain as few as four or five and as many as eight or ten (and rarely, more) members.
  • Gender: Clusters are almost always gender specific. Often a male cluster will align itself with a female cluster (see “The ‘So What?’ of Clusters” below), and they will spend a great deal of time together.
  • Timing: Typically, a significant mark of the move into midadolescence is affiliation with a cluster. In most cases, this happens sometime during the latter months of the freshman year and is often solidified by the end of the sophomore year. Once the cluster attachment begins to give way to the psychosocial broadening experience of college or the military, there is usually a shift into late adolescence, marked by a willingness to explore new relationships and alliances. For those who stay in town to work or go to a local college and remain regularly devoted to their cluster, the power of the cluster can cause them to remain in midadolescence for several years.
  • Loyalty and commitment: A cluster is familial in that once it is formed, there is a strong implicit agreement to remain loyal and intimately and regularly connected to the members of the cluster. In their 2005 study, Ricardo D. Stanton-Salazar and Stephanie Urso Spina found that “the principle of mutual trust also assumes a key role in adolescent friendships—specifically, the expectation that friends will not reveal confidences, will not break promises, and will not sabotage other vital ties in the peer network.” Because a cluster is formed out of an internal need for safety and belonging, loyalty to those with whom one has chosen to align oneself has the highest value.
  • Rules and norms: While a cluster is being developed, a subtle, almost imperceptible negotiation goes on among the members. The necessary rules, norms, values, and even narratives of the cluster that serve to bind the members together are all worked out prior to the cluster’s ultimate formation. After these have been negotiated and established (again, almost never through explicit dialogue or reflection), the members of the cluster tend to subordinate their own personal convictions, loyalties, and norms to the will of the collective whole. While midadolescents may believe that their parents continue to influence “beliefs about control over social conventional and prudential issues,” Christopher Daddis has shown that “close friends were the most relevant in the construction of boundaries regarding personal and multifaceted issues.” This subordination of the individual’s personal convictions to the will of the cluster is also demonstrated by the numerous studies conducted regarding peer influence on adolescent drug and alcohol use and aggressive or nonaggressive behaviors.
  • The How of Clusters

    There has been scant quantitative research addressing why teenagers choose the friends they do, especially during midadolescence, when clustering takes place. Even less research has asked how they go about the process of choosing their friends. What evidence there is has shown that contemporary adolescents choose friends who are similar to themselves. As Kathryn Urberg and her colleagues state, “Adolescents are choosing new friends who are as similar to them as are their existing friends, and . . . the similarities often predate the friendship.” This basic assertion is helpful in confirming what I observed on the high school campus. As emerging midadolescents begin to realize that they need friends in order to have a home base from which to navigate the psychosocial journey they are on, they see the path of least resistance as the most important factor in determining their friendship cluster. Most students remain close to their natural affinity groups even while they search for friendships that could go beyond mere acquaintance or activity-based friendship.

    Every person enters the adolescent phase of life shaped by three forces: genetic makeup (what some call nature and others refer to as the created self), familial and parental influences (often referred to as environment), and an internal determination of how to integrate the two. When children begin the process of embarking on the individualized journey of adolescence, they come to this phase of life with a fairly well-developed sense of self, or what is sometimes called self-concept. By this point (at eleven or twelve years of age), family setting, social environment, and the millions of messages from every experience have created inside the child an internalized picture of who he or she is, especially in how the child sees himself or herself as a social being. Relying on John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth, some believe the adolescent self-concept is formed according to the degree of attachment with the mother (or primary caretaker). But there is evidence that this is but one of several factors that influence the development of self-concept. Certainly, infant and child attachment are highly significant, but the stability of the familial environment, including the perceived stability of the relationship between the mother and the father (even if they are no longer married but remain cordial and emotionally safe), and the child’s experience of growing up are also important elements in the development of self-concept. Once formed, this self-concept creates the soil from which the natural process of cluster development occurs. B. Bradford Brown and his colleagues affirm the importance of familial influence in determining adolescent self-concept and its relationship to peer clustering. “The evidence . . . indicating that parents influence many behaviors by which adolescents are assigned to crowds, seems to favor a conceptual model in which parents play a significant but indirect role in adolescent peer group affiliations. . . . [S]pecific parenting behaviors are significantly associated with specific adolescent characteristics, which in turn predict the peer group with which the adolescent is associated.”

    Some researchers assert that parents play a significant role in cluster formation. They make the assumption, however, that parental behaviors get passed on from parent to child and that these behaviors then predict the peer group. While this view is one possible explanation as to how parents influence adolescent peer relationships, an equally plausible explanation is that what gets passed on from parents to children is less dependent on specific behaviors than on a psychosocially internalized self-concept. In my observation of cluster formation, the common draw for students seemed to be less about behaviors or even activities and more about a sense of comfort and safety. As students navigate ninth grade, an almost ritualized courtship process takes place as friendships and groups are tested. Once relationships begin to solidify and a cluster begins to form, the attraction that formed the basis of the cluster becomes easier to observe.

    While students did not express their parents’ involvement in their choice of group, and many suggested that their parents were against their choice of friends, a preference common to the members of a group was present that made the mutual attraction of the group understandable. This sense of self, which became the marker of the group, was not formed by the group itself but was what drew the individuals together. The unifying concept had been developed long before the group formed. Maja Dekovic and Wim Meeus demonstrate a similar observation in their assertion that “the quality of the parent-child relationship affects the adolescent’s self-concept, which in turn affects the adolescent’s integration into the world of peers.” Self-concept gives shape to an adolescent’s still-forming worldview. This personal worldview and the accompanying sense of self, which is the center of that worldview, are the basic criteria on which clusters are based.

    This hypothesis held up as I observed both the formation of clusters and the clusters themselves in action. As has been mentioned, when an adolescent achieves a sense of reflective personhood in the process of becoming an independent, unique individual, he or she shifts from early adolescence to middle adolescence. In middle adolescence, friendships are perceived as indispensable to survival. There is, therefore, an observable difference between the way incoming freshmen relate to their peers and the way juniors and seniors relate to their peers. The first several months of the freshman year are a time of recognizing the new realities of middle adolescence.

    Here is a sample of comments made by freshmen during the first few months of high school:

  • “My friends from junior high are different now. It’s like everybody is changing.”
  • “I’m not the same person I was last year. And my friends, well, they just don’t seem to do it for me, you know?”
  • “I don’t feel as close to my friends as I did last year. We promised we’d stay close, but now we’re kinda drifting apart.”
  • These comments reflect the view that the transition from junior high to high school is a transitional shift from one stage of adolescence to another. The difference between today and twenty or more years ago is that adolescence has lengthened, creating three stages of adolescence instead of two. The shift, therefore, is between early and middle adolescence. This remains a dramatic and sometimes traumatic experience for adolescents (and their parents).

    This transition between stages of adolescence sets the stage for the drive toward clustering and provides the setting in which clustering takes place. As young people enter high school and ultimately begin to recognize that life is going to be different for them from this point forward, they look at their friends in new ways. In contemporary culture, the psychosocial marker of adolescence is a recognition within a child that he or she must begin to separate from his or her family and the role he or she played in that system in order to continue on a unique journey to becoming a unique person. Adolescence is a fifteen-year psychosocial journey of self-discovery and self-acceptance, and the middle adolescent recognizes that walking the “tightrope of adolescence” is a long and at times treacherous experience. No matter where adolescents are on that fifteen-year tightrope, they remain squarely situated between reliance on and connection with their family, on the one hand, and reliance on and connection with a welcoming, embracing community of peers, on the other. For middle adolescents, the emotional and relational antidote to this no-man’s-land is found in the protection of intimate peer relationships. During this time, friends attain heightened significance as the only support system believed to be both authentically committed and readily available.

    In my observation, students’ choice of cluster, based on their self-concept, became a permanent defining expression of how they viewed themselves when compared to other students. If, for example, a student attempts to build a deep and meaningful friendship of mutual support with someone who holds a higher degree of self-concept, that student will constantly feel inferior to that friend, thus negating the reason for clustering in the first place. If, however, a student attempts to build a cluster with someone who has a lower self-concept, then that person will feel as though he or she is being socially and emotionally dragged down by the other person. While this all takes place with little or no verbal or even reflective deliberation, that does not mean it is an unintentional process. I repeatedly observed the dedicated and proactive search for a safe social place, as located in the potential of a cluster. This dance of cluster formation is a highly complex process of relational exploration and negotiation.

    As I began this study, I was not prepared for the necessity and power of clusters. The middle adolescent, especially early in the process of cluster formation, depends heavily on a cluster for rules, norms, and expectations. This is a time of rethinking previously held commitments and assumptions. The primary concern of the vast majority of adolescents is finding common ground with their newly aligned cluster. Previously held convictions are latently present, but pleasing the cluster is more important.

    This all takes place beneath the conscious awareness of the adolescent. I had thought that in many cases kids—especially those who join clusters in which other members seem to possess a higher social status—were acutely aware of a certain sacrifice they would have been making in order to join. What I observed, however, was that clusters are more primally negotiated according to who will make one feel the most welcome and safe with the least amount of work and stress, even though this central criterion is rarely verbalized. Once the choice of cluster has been settled, there may be some overlap and movement from cluster to cluster, but this too seems to be the exception rather than the rule.

    The “So What?” of Clusters

    Clusters comprise the building blocks of adolescent society. Thick walls develop around various clusters as they create social and operational rules and norms. Each cluster, then, functions as an independent unit with its own approved behaviors, which continually reinforce the predetermined values of the cluster. Yet some clusters’ members have self-concepts similar to those in other clusters, and they create a bond of friendship that can be described as a community of clusters, or a “cousin cluster.” At the same time, individuals within clusters may develop a hostile view toward those in clusters with different social views. I observed definite rules and boundaries between cousin clusters evidenced by such things as where students hung out before school, whom they sat with at lunch, which hallways they walked down, whom they talked to in class, and even what events they attended. The majority of the time, clusters set up an extremely subtle but clearly delineated “demilitarized zone,” and all parties tacitly understand that they will not get involved with one another. On high school campuses across the United States, there is an undercurrent of stratification and even an implied threat of violence (if only emotional violence) between various clusters and cousin clusters.

    Some students can overcome the social barriers that separate students from different clusters by “being friends” in a specific and ordered context (such as on a sports team). In fact, since the first edition of this book, I have increasingly recognized a phenomenon that I did not observe or note in my original study: the shadow cluster. In subsequent focus groups and in dialogue with those who spend a great deal of time with adolescents, I have sought to differentiate between the uniqueness and characteristics of the cluster as described in this chapter and those of other secondary peer groups. I have argued that the vast majority of adolescents rely on their primary cluster as their main nonfamilial social entity, which then serves as the most powerful fallback system in their lives. Yet if midadolescents find themselves needing a mutually self-protective group when their cluster is unavailable, a shadow cluster may act as a temporary friendship group, and therefore in that setting carry the same weight and impact as the primary cluster. These shadow clusters may even be somewhat permanent when located in a given fixed system, such as on a team or in a youth group or student government setting. What is important to note, however, is that the shadow cluster will rarely if ever trump the interests, values, or convictions of the primary cluster when disassociated from the shadow cluster’s setting or environment.

    Conclusion and Musings

    For some time leading up to this study, I had been aware of the subtle shift in high school social structure from a network of relatively homogeneous social relationships to the stratification of clustering. What I recognized early on, however, is how much this phenomenon affects the student community. In effect, on almost every high school campus, there is no such thing as a “student community.”

    The striking thing is that the systems that are present to serve mid-adolescents are typically locked into servicing a more or less cohesive adolescent community. Schools assume the presence of a student community, thus the perpetuation of identity formed in classes (as in freshman, sophomore, etc.). Coaches rely on students’ willingness and ability to work as a team. Even the church tries to bring together young people from a wide variety of schools and clusters into what they call fellowship. These and countless other programmatic assumptions may have a noble intent, and in some cases may even appear to the adults in charge to be somewhat workable, but they do not take the changing youth culture and relational shift seriously. As a result, young people are once again offered up on the altar of an adult agenda at the cost of their personal sense of safety. In other words, today’s teenagers are thrown together in false relationships by adults who think kids connect with one another just like they used to. Teens will perform as necessary to fulfill the roles they have been cast to play, but for many, how they appear on the outside stands in stark contrast to the driving sense of place and home they crave on the inside.

    Clusters are not necessarily bad; they are just different from what most adults have experienced. Those who work with the young can take great strides forward in caring for them by understanding how they organize their social relationships and working with these arrangements. Peer groups are powerful and extremely important. Adults in positions of nurture and influence would do well to remember that these are not their parents’ cliques. They are, instead, a short-term but nonetheless real family for many adolescents. Adults would do well to honor what is important to them and to find ways to invest in the other members of the cluster. I have found that once an adult is “in” with a member of a cluster, he or she is “in” with everyone else in short order.

    Finally, the rhetoric of intense loyalty and commitment to their friends that adolescents often use masks a deeper sense of dis-ease. Even while operating in intimate and exclusive social relationships, they are still lonely. Somehow the cluster is not all it is advertised to be (but few kids can admit this). Should we confront this incongruity head-on? No. We would make a greater difference in individuals’ lives if we were simply there for them, without an agenda or a list of critiques. The quest for a safe place is what drives the cluster phenomenon in the first place. Perhaps a few adults can come alongside an adolescent and provide a safety net without disparaging or discouraging other support systems, especially his or her friends.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑