5: School
5
school
Instead of fostering in its students traits of honesty, integrity, cooperation, and respect, the school may be promoting deception, hostility, and anxiety.
Denise Clark Pope, Doing School
I could not believe what I was hearing, and even as the researcher in me was desperately trying to remember each word being said, the adolescent advocate (and parent) in me was ready to go to war! Before me stood a teacher who had been in the classroom for more than a decade and who was describing the students in each class I was going to substitute teach for her. Her flippant, callous description of several students was so disrespectful and arrogant that I literally had a hard time maintaining a pretense of support for her. I knew some of those she was describing, and although I could understand in many cases why she was annoyed or even disappointed in behavior and classroom performance, she was going so far as to dismiss their ability to produce anything of value.
This sentiment is also illustrated well in the 2008 French film The Class, which depicts a year in the life of the teachers and students at an inner-city high school in Paris, primarily from the perspective of teacher François Marin. In one scene, a colleague of Marin’s rants to his fellow teachers, “I’m sick of these clowns. Sick of them. I can’t take any more. They’re nothing; they know nothing. They look right through you when you try to teach them. . . . I’m not going to help them. They’re so basic, so insincere, always looking for trouble. Go ahead guys. Stay in your crap neighborhood—you’ll be here all your lives and it serves you right!”
I have been working among teenagers for three decades, most of that time in and around the public school setting. I have heard countless stories of unfeeling and unfair teachers. Through the years, I have attempted to take a more or less neutral stance when students (or their parents) have been negative toward their teachers, and I have even tried when appropriate to help them see a teacher’s perspective. The experience I had during this study, however, opened my eyes to what young people have been saying for decades—sure, there are a handful of great teachers and a few more good ones, but many teachers have apparently given up on the reason they entered education as a vocation in the first place. As with any occupation, public school teachers are a mixed bag—a few are outstanding, some are good, some are not so good, and several need to be either retrained or removed.
The school in which I lived among students is by any standard a great public high school. The coprincipals were willing to allow me to do my research and also invited me to work with them in making the school a healthier environment for their students. The leadership of the school was helpful, open, and honest.
As I got closer to the front lines of the school personnel, specifically the counselors, teachers, and coaches, I felt from some an authentic welcoming spirit. The reception I received from others, however, was somewhat guarded. I sensed from some a clear message that I was an alien on their turf, and I was being watched. My impression is that, especially in a midsized or large public high school, most counselors and teachers are so overwhelmed with the demands of their job, so fed up with the constant criticism they receive (generally but not exclusively from parents), and so discouraged by the hordes of students who do not seem to care much about anything, that they have responded by creating a nearly impenetrable “bubble” around themselves as they go about their daily activities and duties. High school public education is a tough calling. Yet it is also a high calling, one that demands flexibility, openness, constant retooling, and the kind of temperament and psychological health that can handle student, parental, and administrative critique as well as a lack of motivation and even disrespect from midadolescents.
As made clear previously, this study is not intended as a defense or apologetic for the adults involved in public high school institutions. Were this the case, I would be the first to praise and defend the efforts of those who are willing to serve our young in the public school arena. For the purposes of this study, however, I chose not to allow myself to consider “their side,” for I was most interested in what was happening in the world of the midadolescent.
The Public High School in America
The public high school has become an immortal icon in American pop culture. Prom, homecoming, football players and games, the lunchroom, fast cars, pop quizzes, cheerleaders, school plays, nerds/geeks/freaks, letterman’s jackets, dances, parties, and the yearbook all bring back a flood of memories for every adult. High school has been the mainstay of many songs, novels, television shows, and films. Usually, the high school experience is portrayed as the most glamorous and exciting time in one’s life. As much as adults and the media have tried to maintain the cultural myth of the thrill of high school, to a great many contemporary students, it is anything but one continuous adventure. One student from my study, upon hearing from a teacher that high school is the best time in one’s life, said, “Great! If this is the best it’s ever going to get, I might as well kill myself now!”
I encourage those who are over thirty-five and who hold any illusion that the high school they went to is similar to the one today’s students attend to visit the school, walk the halls, and listen to the students talk to one another at lunch or during breaks. Unless you have stayed in close touch with the changing adolescent culture, you will most certainly be struck by the fact that the world you inhabited and the experiences you had are but a distant memory.
The intent of this chapter is to discuss just how different the school of today is compared to that of the past and how the changes have affected midadolescents both as individuals and as a population. This chapter examines the school environment from two viewpoints, that of teachers and that of students. It is not directly concerned with the adults who run schools but with how the concept of societal abandonment has affected midadolescents as they function in the high school environment. It has been shown that school-based influences play a role in the healthy development of children and adolescents, and therefore, the attitudes and behaviors of teachers will be discussed alongside the attitudes and behaviors of students.
View of the Teachers
Teachers are like everybody else—it is nearly impossible to speak about them as a group without ruffling a great many feathers along the way. I have narrowed this discussion of the attitudes and behaviors of teachers to three basic issues that directly impact the lives and development of most midadolescents. (1) Most teachers believe that learning for its own sake should be enough to motivate students. (2) Far too many teachers pigeonhole students to the detriment of their developmental health and progress. (3) Teachers feel overburdened and overwhelmed, and the consequences of this spill over into their teaching.
First, I observed an underlying conflict between students and teachers as soon as I entered the classroom. Teachers seem to hold fast to the perspective that learning is (or at least should be) a pleasurable experience and that the ultimate goal of learning (and thus teaching) is the joy of learning. To midadolescents, however, the only pleasurable experiences that register in their developing worldview are those that bring instant and immediately recognizable benefits. Research has consistently documented that teachers who are passionate about their subjects are more effective teachers. Likewise, a teacher who genuinely likes students has a greater likelihood of encouraging students to be better students. As Michael Nakkula and Michael Sadowski demonstrate in their recent book Adolescents at School: Perspectives on Youth, Identity, and Education, the teacher who has a passion for both the subject matter and students is by far the most effective at helping students to excel. They write, “For the vast majority of youth, school is the single context within which the combination of skill and relationship development occurs on a regular basis, day in and day out. . . . Good teachers teach their subject matter well; great teachers engage students in the learning tasks of the moment and instill in them the desire to keep learning long after graduation.”
If a student can perceive a direct benefit from a specific area of study, then he or she is more likely to be engaged and even excited about that subject matter. I encountered a small but honest handful of students who were able to find something they could latch on to in some of the more traditional disciplines such as chemistry, algebra, or English literature. I also discovered another group of students, exponentially larger than the first, who found room in their curriculum for what they already enjoyed, such as sports, drama, music, student government, and forensics. That said, the overwhelming majority of students, even those who were deemed smart by their teachers, could not find anything “pleasurable” about the academic element of the high school experience. “School is okay—if only I didn’t have to study” was a common mantra. As harsh as it may sound, this kind of sentiment was common across the spectrum of midadolescents.
Teachers’ implicit attitude that learning should be pleasurable is enough to drive an almost instant wedge between them and the students they are attempting to teach. I could sense that students believed most teachers were disappointed in and critical of them as a group because of this bias. Students wanted teachers to appreciate them and not to hold anything against them, even though they did not want to be there. Few teachers I talked to, however, were able (or willing) to see this. Midadolescents are an extraordinarily perceptive lot, and they can smell inauthenticity, judgment, and dismissive critique a mile away. For many students, this is where the rub starts, and, sadly, it begins the day class convenes.
My second observation was that many teachers pigeonhole students, thus hindering students’ ability to grow and develop. While there are obviously many effective, caring, and dedicated teachers in American public high schools, I encountered far too many who boxed, categorized, labeled, and dismissed their midadolescent students. Sociologist Elliott Currie found this as well in his study of middle-class youth: “The bottom line was that the schools functioned less as actively nurturing institutions, committed to building the competence and intellectual capacity of all their students, than as instruments for sorting and categorizing them—sifting the good from the bad, the promising from the ‘losers,’ the troublesome from the ‘OK.’” Some schools may actually do more harm than good when it comes to the care of midadolescents.
A case in point was the annual banquet for one of the varsity sports teams at the high school where I did my initial study. Each year the coach stands in front of the students and their parents and summons each student-athlete to the podium to receive his letter. This particular coach is one of the more well-known teachers/coaches in the school and has a reputation for being gruff. He chose, instead of writing down his comments to ensure that every athlete was affirmed, thanked, and encouraged for his participation in the sport, to make up his comments on the fly as the boys’ names were called. Those who were talented or well liked by this coach received a glowing acknowledgment of their contributions. Those who did not play much, however, or who for one reason or another did not turn the eye of the coach, heard either almost nothing as they walked forward or, worse, heard disparaging—even degrading—comments about their lack of performance, playing time, or physical skill. Year after year this painful ritual continues. When I asked other coaches and parents about it, the most common response was, “Oh, that’s just how Coach is. He doesn’t mean to hurt anybody; he just tells it like it is.” This last year I even heard the rationale, “He is great. He doesn’t pull any punches. These kids have to learn how to handle the truth!” This ritual can be so uplifting for the favored young men and yet so permanently painful in the lives of the others.
As a rule, many teachers are far more willing to get to know and invest in “good kids,” “talented kids,” or “smart kids” than in those they do not feel contribute to their own agenda. With these teachers, midadolescents recognize quickly that it is up to them to decide whether they want to play that game. The ones who are typically embraced are those who have chosen (whether the choice is conscious or not) to win the attention and affection of the teacher. They have decided that their midadolescent experience will be more satisfying and productive if they convince teachers that they are worthy of their engagement. For so many kids, relationships with teachers have become little more than a game. During this phase of development, students live out their “school self” as they operate within the school’s expectations and parameters of conduct. This includes the persona they reflect and the relationships they initiate with their teachers.
For many teachers, the litmus test of a “good” young person is how much respect the student shows the teachers. One of the most common reasons given as to why teachers write off the majority of their students is the lack of respect they receive from many of them. As almost any teacher will tell you, respect from students is no longer an automatic expectation. It is a hard-earned benefit to be won. It is no wonder that many teachers disdain their students.
The issue of the lack of respect teachers feel, however, is not limited to students in the classroom. Most teachers feel underappreciated and even abused by their administration, district, and even state. In a thoroughly researched report by Public Agenda, teachers said that “their views are generally ignored by decision makers, with 70% feeling left out of the loop in their district’s decision-making process.” Along with budgetary woes, this was the leading source of complaint I heard consistently from teachers. From what I observed, it was one of the more significant factors in causing teachers to become discouraged. This discouragement is sometimes reflected in a negative attitude that spills over into the classroom and onto the individual psyches of the students they have committed themselves to serve.
Third, a significant number of teachers feel overwhelmed by the very task of teaching in the contemporary American public high school system. They also feel that when it comes to external support and recognition, a vital component of employee morale, they are on their own. Researchers have suggested that the role of teachers today is more about the developmental trajectory of adolescents than about the observable or measurable behavior or academic achievement of a student at any particular time. Many teachers recognize this expectation, and yet the demands of standardized testing, score-based evaluation systems, the disruption of behavior problems, and a host of other factors all converge, causing teachers to feel stretched beyond their ability to do and be everything demanded of them. Add to this situation the contemporary educational mind-set that teachers are one of the last remaining groups that truly understand and care for the young and that therefore teachers need to take on the lion’s share of responsibility for rearing adolescents, and it is little wonder that teachers are discouraged.
Teachers say they want more involvement from parents, and it is a fact that parents are less and less involved with high schools. Over the course of this study, I found that most teachers do—publicly and privately—bemoan the lack of parental involvement in children’s high school education, for they understand precisely what researchers Robert Crosnoe and Glen H. Elder observed, which is that “the linkage between emotional support from parents and adolescent academic performance is well-established. Warm and supportive relationships have been found to promote academic achievement and positive attitudes about education, whereas more distant or conflictual relationships can be tremendous stressors that disrupt proper functioning in school.” But I also witnessed several events and conversations in which parents who showed an interest in working with teachers were seen as a threat.
The parent-teacher relationship is one of the more complex and at times stressful relationships in the overall high school structure. Teachers believe that children are far more successful when their parents are involved with both the student and the school. At the same time, however, teachers regularly feel as though parents are more interested in defending their children and rationalizing their behavior and performance than in allowing teachers to offer their expertise. To many teachers, partnering with parents means inviting parents onto a team captained by the teacher for the training of children. In my experience, teachers are often apprehensive toward parents, and this fear can quickly communicate to a parent that the teacher is not interested in a parent’s perspective, even if the teacher enthusiastically wants to connect with parents. Added to this dynamic are parents’ fears that they have far less control over their child than they are supposed to have (and the school is often the perpetrator of this perception). These issues place a significant wedge between a parent and a high school teacher even before there is any interaction.
In numerous conversations with teachers and administrators over the past several years, I found that the problem may lie with teachers being implicitly trained that they are the only societal institution left that has the education, training, and commitment to understand and nurture the young. This attitude, unfortunately, applies even to parents and families. Indeed, educators overwhelmingly report the necessity of the involvement and investment of parents in their children’s education. Yet at the same time, they are regularly (and vocally) critical of parents’ lack of commitment, meaning lack of commitment to the narrow perspective and focus of the educator.
The study I conducted consistently showed that most parents are concerned about their children’s education, but for many it is not the highest priority on the list of things that parents of midadolescents have to worry about in today’s society. Parents have to worry about their kids’ sexual behavior, the internet and the media, the impact of clustering and peers, and the constant temptation of substance use and abuse. A high school teacher sees students for less than an hour a day, and for the most part, that teacher’s entire perception of them is based on the external roles, behavior, and academic performance shown during that hour. A teacher almost never knows anything about the dynamics of students’ family systems, their friendships and internal struggles, or how other adults perceive them as they live in the multiple selves created by postmodern society. All too often a teacher makes a snap judgment, and students and their parents are forced to live under that label until the end of the semester.
View of the Students
Getting students to talk about their feelings regarding school was the easiest aspect of this study. What was interesting was the consistent message that came from nearly every corner of the population. Certainly, as with every other element of this study, there were students who did not line up with the general trends. For example, students’ approaches to school and academic performance ran the gamut: some students were serious about their studies (they were committed to getting the grades they needed to open future doors), some were trying to get by doing the minimum required of them to stay in school, and some did not seem to care at all. Four broad areas of consistency did, however, emerge: attitudes toward teachers and the respect they deserve, the motivation behind academic achievement, the prevalence and morality of cheating, and the high level of anxiety that the competitive environment of the classroom can produce.
In terms of respect for teachers, students believe that respect is something to be earned, not granted. In discussing respect for teachers with midadolescents, the widespread view was that teachers do not deserve respect simply because they are teachers. (This viewpoint was not limited to teachers; it applied to every adult.) A report covering twenty-five national surveys confirms this view, stating that “only 9% of surveyed Americans said [high school] students they see in public are respectful toward adults.” What I found especially intriguing was that most students believe that teachers do not even deserve the benefit of the doubt and that, instead, teachers must earn the respect of students by showing them respect first. Several scenes in The Class poignantly demonstrate this. For instance, at one point teacher François Marin attempts to communicate to his class that he is genuinely interested in their feelings and their view of life, and he is met with student reactions such as “you’re only saying that to get us to talk and stuff.” The students clearly do not believe he cares as much as he claims. Later, a student writes a short letter to Marin asserting, “I know you have it in for me, but I don’t know why,” and pleading for some respect. Clearly trust and respect are central concerns for these students, but they desire mutuality: trust and respect have to go both ways.
The idea that people deserve respect and kindness unless they do something to break that code (and even then many still believe respect should always be granted) was previously an unchallenged value of our culture. Today, that rule does not apply, at least on high school campuses. Not only do midadolescent students not respect their teachers as teachers, but they actually enter a classroom prepared not to respect a teacher unless that teacher wins their respect. Ruben Garza concluded this very fact from his study of white and Latino high school students: “Culturally diverse students need a relationship with their teachers that is mutually respectful if they are to learn. They not only need to like their teachers, but also must sense that their teacher cares for them.” Similarly, Alison Cook-Sather found that “consistently, students argue that in order to feel engaged in their schooling, they need to enter and experience a positive classroom environment and they need to feel that teachers know them and want them to learn.”
The second interesting perspective I discovered during this study involved how students approach academic achievement, especially the motivation for academic achievement. Researchers have begun to look at the dark side of the pressures on the academic elite. David Brooks, senior editor of the Weekly Standard, writes,
There is a dark side to the meritocratic system, however. One of the most destructive forces in American life today is the tyranny of the grade point average. Everyone argues about whether SATs are an unjust measure of student ability, but the GPA does far more harm. To get into top schools, students need to get straight A’s or close. That means that students are not rewarded for developing a passion for a subject and following their curiosity wherever it takes them. They are rewarded if they can carefully budget their mental energies and demonstrate proficiency across all academic disciplines. They are rewarded, as Joseph Epstein put it, for their ability to take whatever their teachers throw out at them, in whatever field, and return it back in their warm little mouths. Idiosyncrasy is punished. Students are rewarded for having a lukewarm enthusiasm for all fields in general and none in particular. They are rewarded for mastering the method of being a good student, not for their passion for the content of any particular area of learning. They are rewarded for their ability to mindlessly defer to their professors’ wishes, and never strike out on their own or follow a contradictory path.
Developmentally, of course, midadolescents are not prepared to recognize that education is a valuable gift not only for them but also for society at large. I found few students who could articulate anything other than their own personal drive and agenda to “get somewhere” when it came to academic achievement. The days of a high school student finding learning to be a pleasurable experience rather than a means to an end are all but gone. Yet academic literature continues to perpetuate the pleasurable experience of learning as an educational motivation.
The motivating factor was the same for those who were high achievers as for those who did not seem to care very much: a student will do whatever it takes to navigate the complex and varied demands of midadolescence with as much self-protection and self-interest as necessary. As already mentioned, midadolescents live much of their lives in multiple selves, and they put on personae that enable them to survive as they move from one layer to the next. Students who believe that getting good grades helps them feel better about themselves do what they have to do to get the grades. For those whose primary strategies lie elsewhere, grades are less important. What seems to be nearly universal is that the high school system forces midadolescents, as one researcher put it, “to falsify their behavior.”
One exception to the idea that midadolescents do not care for school had to do with students’ talk about college. The academically oriented (some would say “gifted”) students talked about college as a goal, and those who were not as academically oriented did not. The issue of what college to attend (or whether to go to a junior college or even at all) seemed to bring with it a mixed cauldron of conflicting motivations and values, and very few students knew precisely what they wanted and why. Most students, in fact, especially until the middle of their junior year, maintained grades and relatively stable relationships with teachers simply because it suited their idea of how best to survive high school, not because it was a means to an end of a specific career goal or even college.
Third, cheating is so widespread on high school campuses that it is considered by many to be the norm. Cheating for midadolescents is a complex issue and will be addressed more fully in chapter 10. The mixed messages from parents and the school itself, the lack of a clear and universal definition of academic dishonesty and cheating, and the widespread relativism of society have created an atmosphere in which even the definition of cheating is nebulous. Many midadolescents simply will do whatever they believe is necessary to fulfill the expectations of their parents and teachers, and cheating becomes the way they deem best to do that.
Studies on cheating reveal that students have become adept at laying the problem at the feet of everybody but themselves. In other words, to midadolescents, cheating is rarely considered a moral problem, but when it is, a student almost never sees himself or herself as the culprit. Rather, he or she is the unfortunate victim who had no other option. Today, two rigid ethical commitments crash into one another at both the high school and the college level: the traditional ethic of academic integrity and the contemporary adolescent perspective that cheating is an acceptable and even relatively moral option for the student who needs to perform. This is an even bigger problem when one realizes that it is not a few who cheat. In one way or another, everyone cheats (statistically anyway).
The most frequent reason given by students for cheating was the injustice of teachers. If a teacher were fairer, the argument goes, then there would be little need to cheat. In dozens of conversations with students regarding cheating, the closest I got to anyone recognizing that cheating was actually stealing and therefore a moral problem was when a girl told me about a boy who cheated off her tests regularly. He “didn’t care at all about studying,” and he was therefore taking advantage of her. Although I pushed as hard as I dared, she simply could not go beyond being personally “ripped off” to condemning the practice of cheating as an ethical problem. The fact that he cheated was not the problem. She was morally outraged because he had cheated off her.
Abandonment, along with the general neglect in other areas of adolescents’ lives, affects midadolescents in the school arena by contributing to one of the most disturbing trends in their world: the acceptance of deceit to protect, defend, or push oneself forward. To contemporary middle and late adolescents, truth has become little more than a strategic effort to define one’s own version of reality in order to control one’s environment. As Denise Clark Pope points out, “Successful students learned to devise various strategies to stay ahead of their peers and to please those in power positions; unsuccessful students, for a variety of reasons, were not as adept at playing the survival game.” This “game” has produced a continuum of students, ranging from those who are proficient at conforming to what others expect them to be and do to those who have to figure out how to survive when they cannot live up to those expectations. Midadolescents learn to cope, indeed, to survive, without adults. They have become adept at saying and displaying what adults want to hear and see, and they have learned how to play a role that helps them to survive the expectations of adults.
Finally, students who care about grades and academic performance are experiencing an ever-increasing level of anxiety and stress over school. The source of this pressure has been debated for some time—parents, teachers, colleges, society at large—but that discussion is beyond the scope of this study. What I observed, however, is that the locus of the anxiety is within the psyches of those students who have, for whatever reason, made the decision to compete with others and to do as well in school as possible. For some it is a first-, one-point-five-, or even second-generation ethnically driven cultural ethos. Others who are exceptionally “book smart” push themselves by doing things such as taking the SAT “for fun” as early as the eighth grade. Then there are those who are simply trying to maintain an A or A- average to be accepted into the school they (or their parents) want.
Two elements that add to the stress level of these students are the increasing amount of homework required and the university-mandated need to be involved in as many activities as possible while in high school. The school in which I did this study expected each student to spend from forty-five minutes to an hour per day on homework for each class. Students are required to take five classes, meaning that each weeknight they need to spend over three hours doing homework.
Added to this academic requirement is the need to be involved in athletics (two or more hours per day) and in extracurricular activities and clubs (such as school-based Key Club, faith-based Young Life, or a church youth group). And on top of all this, there is often an expectation to put in volunteer hours. Typically, then, a student who cares at all about being a “good student,” doing homework, and pleasing teachers and parents, starts the day before 7:00 a.m., gets home after practice or a meeting at 5:00 or 6:00 p.m., does an hour of homework, grabs dinner before heading out to an activity, gets home at 9:30 or 10:00, and finishes homework around 1:00 a.m. The bulk of the students I observed, especially those who were active and involved, were often exhausted, harried, and frazzled. There seemed to be little apparent systemic consideration for what these schedules, expectations, and pressures do to the development and health of midadolescents.
Conclusion and Musings
As Denise Clark Pope points out, “The school world has been described as a place where, too often, students feel anonymous and powerless.” This was a central observation of this study. Most students had learned at an early age how to “play to” the expectations of the educational system in order to adapt to its demands. Some researchers put a positive spin on this, leaning on the construct of “social capital” to describe how adolescents navigate the complex process of growing up by relying on others to promote successful transitions. Stanford Center on Adolescence researchers Shirley Brice Heath and Milbrey McLaughlin exemplify this perception when they argue that adolescents must learn how to behave properly in a variety of contexts to achieve the kind of support they ultimately need to become successful adults.
But this is a catch-22 for adolescents, both the successful students and those who do not appear to be successful by institutional criteria. The successful students are those who are able to play the game better than their lesser peers. They are not actually being nurtured and assimilated into the adult world by caring mentors; they are learning how to beat the system! Adolescents who lag behind academically often devise another strategy for beating the system, either out of fear of failure or distrust of the system itself. They fall into the category of “average” or “unsuccessful.”
Most teachers are doing a good job under a rigid, politically driven, difficult system. The American public high school places many layers of expectations and demands on teachers, and often what we ask of them as a society is not fair. They are poorly paid, lack sufficient resources, could use additional training and encouragement, and are overloaded with the demands made on them by classroom size, the rigors of objectified test scores, and a difficult cultural world. They get little thanks and are constantly under the microscope of parents and administrators, and it is little wonder many are discouraged.
That said, this book is intended to open the eyes of adults who care about the state of midadolescents in American society. It is intended to advocate for those who have been bruised by what society has done through cultural neglect and systemic abandonment. I, therefore, am not writing as a defender of teachers but as an advocate of adolescents. I intend to be neither harsh nor unfair to those who have given their lives to educating our young. I do, however, believe that what happens on a high school campus in many ways hurts our young. Not a week went by without my being deeply disturbed and sometimes militantly agitated by the attitudes, behaviors, and policies of teachers and administrators in one of the best schools in the state of California. For this reason, I offer two conclusions.
First, we have hurt entire populations of adolescents because we have allowed our limited understanding and definition of “gifted” to be shaped by an extremely narrow view of human potential. One obvious problem is that the timing of development is different for each person. Development has a direct impact on such things as cognitive memory and recall (a central methodological commitment in American education, even though it has proven to be among the least effective ways to educate a developing adolescent). Surviving, much less thriving, in early and middle adolescence requires the ability to focus for fifty minutes on one subject, run to the next class without getting in trouble for being late, and focus on an entirely different subject, all while navigating the complex relational dynamics of each class. Add to this the different styles and expectations of teachers, and a student who is even slightly behind developmentally is put at a severe disadvantage in the rigid, tightly controlled educational environment of the American high school. At a certain level, all kids have the innate ability to learn, and many of those who fall through the cracks are far more intelligent than our systems recognize. There is also strong evidence that both learning and intelligence are extremely complex processes and that there are multiple types of intelligences. We need to recognize that young people are the most precious and fragile resources of our society. Each one has a unique potential and needs and deserves a deliberate, proactive, and nurturing school environment.
Second, I agree with Mel Levine, developmental pediatrician and author of A Mind at a Time, that we have fallen prey to the misconception that we can treat all students in the same age category the same way. We have also forgotten that each adolescent is by definition in a state of transition and growth and therefore needs individual attention in every aspect of his or her life, including education. This is a tall order indeed for a teacher who has five classes of thirty students each, but we do not have the luxury of thinking of students as “classes” or of putting them in boxes with labels such as “average,” “gifted,” and “obnoxious.” Each young person has tremendous potential within the context of his or her unique giftedness and therefore deserves personal care, attention, and a system that seeks individual growth and development. I asked Scott, the 2002–2003 teacher of the year at the school where I did this study, what it takes to be a great teacher. He said, “The same thing it takes to be a great spouse, or parent, or coach, or leader in any setting. It’s not mystical, and it sure isn’t a secret. It is just caring enough for each person in front of you that they know they matter to you. To be a great teacher means I am allowed the privilege of being with great kids. They’re the ones who deserve this award.”
