Chapter 16 of 26

9: Busyness and Stress

9: Busyness and Stress

9

busyness and stress

Today’s child has become the unwilling, unintended victim of overwhelming stress—the stress borne of rapid, bewildering social change and constantly rising expectations.

David Elkind, The Hurried Child

In a meeting with a small group of government employees whose job was to focus on the unique needs of youth, the subject of stress came up. Because I was in the midst of this study at the time, my data-gathering antennae went up. I was not surprised by what I heard, but I was nonetheless a bit taken aback.

I had come to see that today’s midadolescents are about as busy as humanly possible. They average five to six hours of sleep a night (when some experts insist they should get eight to nine, especially during adolescence). The ever-mounting demands on their time and energies; the heightening expectations from coaches, bosses, and activity leaders; the proliferation of homework; and the accessibility of many communication options make the typical day in the life of a midadolescent a balancing act. Nearly every student I encountered during this study described life as busy to very busy.

I had also noticed that they were observably tired, some to the point of near exhaustion. Instead of being a general laziness or a semibored listlessness (both of which have long been associated with this age group), the tiredness I observed was like what I feel after staying up most of the night due to a delayed flight. Many students experience this zombielike feeling on a daily basis. When I asked why they were so tired, the answers had to do with everything from homework to work to a late practice.

The fact that adolescents are both busy and tired had emerged early on in my study. Until the meeting mentioned above, however, I was not planning on making the topic a major aspect of this book. Following the morning with this eclectic group of experienced, committed, well-trained, self-described youth workers, I was compelled to reexamine much of the data I had compiled.

“I have been working with kids for forty years, and today’s kids are the most stressed out I have ever seen,” said one gentleman.

“They are on the edge, that’s for sure,” said a thirtysomething social worker who spent a great deal of time in the district where I was serving. “And the worst part is, they don’t even know how stressed they are!”

The supervisor, a fifteen-year veteran of city government who was involved in numerous youth organizations throughout the community, jumped in. “They have no other framework, so they don’t even know what stress is or looks like. I was talking to a kid last week, a sharp junior—student government, involved as a leader in the YMCA Youth In Government program, a star volleyball player, who looked like he was a great student—who told me he won’t be able to get into a four-year college because of his grades. He saw my expression and said, ‘Man, I don’t have time to do homework, and I’m just too tired to stay awake in class. After volleyball, the Y, and Young Life, I have to gel and catch up with my friends. Just getting up in the morning is a miracle!’ I tried to get him to step back and to see what’s important, to get him to consider his future and make some priorities in his life. He just looked at me like I was his mom telling him to clean his room. All he said as he turned away was, ‘You just don’t get it, do you?’”

The rest of the conversation was more of the same. Then a kind of cloud of disappointment, discouragement, and even helplessness settled over the meeting. The agenda had to do with creating a strategy to help individuals and agencies serve those not yet at risk but on the edge. After this initial ice-breaking conversation, however, our efforts seemed feeble, and no one had the energy to try to strategize any solutions. We made it through the meeting, but the air had definitely been let out of the tires.

I drove away aware that what I had noticed but dismissed as a relatively minor issue was actually a core aspect of midadolescent life. I was discouraged by the apparent no-win convergence of multiple expectations, a lack of ability to see above the fray of their immediate contextual experience, and an unwillingness to trust adults who might be able to help. Midadolescents today seem to want to be incredibly busy. They do not know any different. And they are turned off by anyone’s attempt to put limits on them or to suggest priorities and boundaries. Midadolescents live in the midst of the only reality they know. They are exhausted in the present but afraid of the unknown. The result of this commitment to busyness? Stress.

The stress is real and powerful, and yet few midadolescents see it as stress or even as a negative aspect of their lives. “It is what it is,” one student told me when I asked why he was so tired. “I have to work, I have to be with my friends, I have to be up for practice, and I have to live my life. I’m doing okay, so don’t hassle me . . . unless I snore in class.”

The Reality of Their Lives

During the research I conducted across the country with both adolescents and adults, whatever the town, whatever the segment of society, the view was consistent: the busyness, fragmentation, and stress level adolescents experience are relatively new, and they are increasing. Whether midadolescents have greater resources today than in the past to cope with the stress and multiple expectations they face is, in reality, beside the point. The issue is what they face and how it affects them.

In an article on the state of college students at prestigious universities, one editor remarked, “Their main lack is time. Students boast to each other about how little sleep they’ve gotten, and how long it’s been since they had a chance to get back to their dorm room.” In high school as well as in college, the lack of enough time to get done all they need to do is a consistently mentioned plague. For some, this is surrounded by a desire to have a full résumé. Most midadolescents who have proven they have the ability to compete academically for coveted admittance into a good school are well aware that the game is less about brainpower and more about tenacity and sheer determination. They know, as this same editorial observes, that “the system does encourage students to exert themselves. Actually, it demands it. As one student at the Yale Political Union astutely noted, the system doesn’t necessarily reward brains; it rewards energy. The ones who thrive are the ones who can keep going from one activity to another, from music, to science, to sports, to community service, to the library, and so on without rest. To get into a competitive school, you need a hyperactive thyroid as much as high intelligence.” But pursuing this kind of success comes at a price. Researchers Suniya Luthar and Shawn J. Latendresse found that “individuals who place high value on occupational success and prestige relative to gratifying personal lives have been found to be at escalated risk for emotional distress.” Indeed, after reassessing the adolescents in their study near the end of their high school careers, they found that “on anxiety, incidence of clinically significant symptoms among girls increased over time, from one in five to almost one in three by the end of high school.”

As Madeleine Levine puts it: “We need to investigate the possibility that some aspects of this culture: materialism, individualism, perfectionism, and competition may actually contribute to psychological problems.”

By the time many students reach the middle of their junior year of high school, they want (most of them say “need”) more money, and almost always that means finding a job. Research has shown that getting even a part-time job exponentially adds to the level of stress and busyness in the life of a midadolescent. The developmental cost of having a job seems to be much greater than the relational and material cost of not having a job. As the American Psychological Association reports, “Adolescents who work 20 or more hours per week during the school year experience consistently negative outcomes. Findings from the National Longitudinal Study on Adolescent Health suggest that these young people are more emotionally distressed, have poorer grades, are more likely to smoke cigarettes, and are more likely to become involved in other high-risk behaviors such as alcohol and drug use.”

The Sources of Stress

Before determining the sources of stress, we need to define stress. David Elkind writes that “stress is any unusual demand for adaptation that forces us to call on our energy reserves over and above that which we ordinarily expend and replenish in the course of a twenty-four-hour period. Although stress, or extraordinary demands for adaptation, can be of all kinds—accidents, breakdowns, being late, major decisions, major failures, successes, and so on—the response to stress is fairly specific and well documented. In other words, our bodies have a very specific way of calling upon and utilizing our energy reserves. . . . [This is called] the ‘stress response.’”

There are several specific and unique stressors in the lives of midadolescents. In his book The Hurried Child, Elkind offers a stress test for children. A point system charts a child’s stress level based on changes in his or her life. If, according to this instrument, a child’s score in any given year is beyond 150 points, he or she has a “better than average chance of showing some symptoms of stress. If your child’s score was above 300, there is a strong likelihood he or she will experience a serious change in health and/or behavior.”

Here are some of the stressors he lists and their point values:

Parent dies

100

Parents divorce

73

Parents separate

65

Parent travels as part of job

63

Parent remarries

50

Parents reconcile

45

Mother goes to work

45

School difficulties

39

Threat of violence at school

31

This is but a sampling of the kinds of things that induce stress and anxiety in the life of a child. A popular assumption is that adolescents, being older and more streetwise than children, are less vulnerable to these and other stressors. Because of the added burdens of abandonment, social fragmentation, and being forced to live in multiple selves, however, midadolescents are even more prone to stress, with fewer points needed to push them over the edge.

In my observation of midadolescent busyness, stress, and pressure, I noticed three areas of stress that took their toll on most students: the pressure to succeed, the pressure to maintain stability at home while remaining loyal and connected to the peer group, and the general pressure associated with relationships. In fact, a 2009 study of significant stressors for students in high school general education programs revealed just these sorts of issues: “parent-child relations, academic struggles, conflict within family, and peer relations, as well as role transitions and societal problems.” These pressure points, while perhaps not overwhelming for all students, at different times and in different ways seem to have a significant impact on the emotional equilibrium of most students.

The pressure to succeed, whether in the classroom, on the athletic field, or in another endeavor that creates a sense of worth and accomplishment, produces an elusive, never-quite-good-enough feeling that students wear like a cloud. When students do something well, they believe it is only a step in the direction of adequate performance. I encountered few students who allowed themselves to do their best in a given arena and then let the chips fall where they may. For most, the pressure to continue to reach loftier heights was the defining sentiment. When someone did well on a test or had a great tennis match, the time for celebration was short-lived. As one student remarked, acting as a spokesperson for several others in a small-group setting, “We feel an incredible pressure to succeed in every area, or it will all fall apart.” When I asked what specifically would fall apart, the group could not put a finger on it, but they were convinced that the statement was nonetheless accurate.

What they are striving for is not the thing itself but rather what the accomplishment will bring with it. Performance, then, is not about the touchdown, the A, or a role in the school play. It is about how others will perceive them. In other words, adolescents have learned that what matters is not who they are but what they do—or more pointedly, what they can point to and say, “Look at me! I am worthy of attention and affection.” For most students, the accolades that seemed to penetrate were those that went beyond a deed and focused on their intrinsic worth. This also seemed to diffuse some of the need to perform and the stress that came along with it.

Students regularly feel that their greatest struggle is when there is stress in their relationship with their parents. A fight with a mom, dad, or stepparent just as they are walking out the door to school can produce a brooding mood that lasts much of the day. They do not like to talk about it much, but they are easily discouraged when there is unresolved conflict at home.

Midadolescents desperately want what they know they cannot have: parents who affirm everything they do and care enough about them to be their biggest fans, and yet who know when to keep their distance. Even midadolescent logic can, when summoned to do so, see that these desires cannot coexist when it comes to parents. There is no way a parent can be a caring, involved parent who draws boundaries and makes certain a child is appropriately guided and nurtured and at the same time is such a great pal and fan that they never interfere in their child’s life. This paradox is nonetheless what a midadolescent believes is not only possible but also preferable.

The greatest rub occurs when parents attempt to step into the protective strategy of the midadolescent: the cluster. Parents are under considerable strain as they seek to exert influence over their child and to know when to back off. This is not easy for a parent or a child, and it can cause stress for both.

The most delicate and yet easily disguised source of stress for midadolescents is keeping people happy. Midadolescents may not seem to care about how others react to them, but that is an act. They actually care deeply about what others think. Much of the time their self-focus and self-centeredness keep them from reading the cues available to them. They also may wear dismissal by an adult or a student they do not like as a badge of assertive honor. But inside, they know they are taking a risk and desperately want everyone to respect, affirm, and hopefully like them.

A student handed me a note after class one day that read, “The thing we worry about the most is not disappointing others.” The cynic in me immediately recalled the exceptionally rowdy and flippant class, and I was tempted to dismiss the note as a sarcastic attempt to manipulate my research. Yet the next day I felt different about the tone of our conversation. It seemed to me that what I had read as callous indifference and even arrogant disregard was actually a test. Did I really care about what they thought or, more importantly, about them? Was I interested in each one as a unique and valuable person, or was I one more adult who was willing to use and exploit them for my career? When I recognized what was at the core of their response to me, I saw twenty-eight fragile midadolescents who wanted to know that they mattered to me. What a gift that note was!

Developmental Issues Related to Busyness and Stress

In a report published by the American Psychological Association, the section titled “Adolescent Emotional Development” begins with the following sentence: “Emotional development during adolescence involves establishing a realistic and coherent sense of identity in the context of relating to others and learning to cope with stress and manage emotions—processes that are life-long issues for most people.”

As I watched the frazzled busyness, the burden of multiple layers of expectations, the overlapping and competing commitments to activities, and the desire to access and utilize the latest technologies, I could not help but feel that midadolescents have been backed into a difficult corner. On the one hand, a major aspect of their developmental responsibility is to learn how to cope with stress and manage their emotions. On the other hand, adults have continued to pile increased burdens and complex demands on them. What occurs when these two competing forces clash? Midadolescents feel the need to flee from both the pressures and their responsibility to cope. This becomes one more factor—sometimes the deciding factor—in the creation and sustenance of the world beneath.

Mary Pipher, in Reviving Ophelia, says that adolescent girls “need good habits for coping with stress” (though I assume she would include boys as well). In context, she means that adults must teach and train the young how to handle the stress of everyday life. Perhaps there is some truth in the concept that development ultimately comes down to the individual journey of an adolescent, but the search for a satisfying and unique identity that includes the abilities to cope with and manage stress and emotions also has a great deal to do with one’s environment. As Patricia Hersch notes:

What kids need from adults is not just rides, pizza, chaperones, and discipline. They need the telling of stories, the close, ongoing contact, so that they can learn to be accepted. If nobody is there to talk to, it is difficult to get the lessons of your own life so that you are adequately prepared to do the next thing. Without a link across generations, kids will only hear from their peers. The Carnegie Council on Adolescent Development report A Matter of Time: “Young adolescents do not want to be left to their own devices.” In national surveys and focus groups, America’s youth have given voice to serious longing. They want more regular contact with adults who care about and respect them.

Albert Bandura suggests that an intricate relationship exists among social environment, self-efficacy beliefs, and development for adolescents. According to Bandura, “Individuals play a proactive role in their adaptation rather than simply undergoing happenings in [the environment]. . . . The success with which the risks and challenges of adolescence are managed depends, in no small measure, on the strength of personal efficacy.” Self-efficacy beliefs “moderate the relation between what the environment affords by way of incentives and demands and the level of success attained.” Bandura offers substantial evidence that stress affects adolescents differently (and significantly so) depending on the strength of their efficacy beliefs. His point is that those possessing belief in themselves have a far better ability to cope with the stress of everyday life, and they are thus less dependent on or subject to the environment when it comes to handling stress.

Midadolescence, however, is a period when even those who believe in themselves have difficulty with the expectations placed on them. Today’s strongest midadolescents face challenges that their parents (and even their older brothers and sisters) did not. Those who possess the strongest self-efficacy beliefs, and who therefore have a greater ability to handle whatever the environment throws at them, still face periods of struggle, insecurity, and stress.

The Impact of Stress

The ordinary effects of stress in everyday life—such as recurring headaches, insomnia, or lack of ability to concentrate—are difficult enough for adolescents to bear. Unfortunately, however, efforts to cope with stress may lead to even more serious problems such as eating disorders, substance abuse, self-injury, and suicide. One of the most unsettling trends among adolescents is the rise of what experts call nonsuicidal self-injury (NSSI), where individuals deliberately inflict some form of harm (cutting, burning, hitting) on themselves without suicidal intent. In their helpful review of recent research on this issue, E. David Klonsky and Jennifer J. Muehlenkamp report that self-injury of this sort typically begins occurring around age thirteen or fourteen and is by far most prevalent among adolescents and young adults. Studies have demonstrated that at least 14 to 15 percent of adolescents in North America have engaged in some form of self-injury. Common reasons given for this behavior include “to release emotional pressure that builds up inside of me,” “to stop bad feelings,” or “to manage stress.” One study of over three thousand university students conducted by Cornell and Princeton University researchers revealed that an alarming “17 percent of college students—20 percent of women and 14 percent of men—report that they have cut, burned, carved or harmed themselves in other ways.” According to these researchers, this trend has led many professionals to conclude that “young people today possess fewer coping mechanisms and face more stressful situations than in the past.”

But self-injury is just one of a number of growing destructive trends among stressed adolescents. Similarly upsetting is the link between stress and eating disorders, particularly, though not exclusively, in female adolescents. And while suicide may seem to be the extreme case, recent reports have demonstrated that it is an option that presents itself to significant percentages of young people. A recent study of stress levels among college students revealed that over the past year, 16 percent of the students had friends talk about wanting to end their lives, 11 percent of the students had friends attempt suicide, and 9 percent of the students had thought seriously about ending their own life. It is nothing less than tragic that adolescents feel driven to these and other destructive coping strategies in order to deal with stress. The adults in their lives must take notice and begin to ask what may be done to help alter this course.

Conclusion and Musings

The most significant impression I had following my experience with midadolescents was this: just below the surface, today’s midadolescents feel a sense of loneliness and isolation that betrays the confidence with which they present themselves, even to one another. The busyness they embrace keeps them from having to reflect on their dreams, their relationships, and their lives. The resultant stress only serves to compound the desperation they feel that somehow, in some way, they might be able to work hard enough or play hard enough to free themselves from the burden of loneliness and fear.

Certainly they are tired, and many are angry. Both of these, however, are but symptoms of a deeper threat to their well-being and ultimately to their ability to progress through midadolescence. At the core, they long for the safety and freedom of childhood and have no clear vision concerning what adulthood will be like. As a result of the abandonment they have faced throughout their lives, most midadolescents carry inside them a powerful defense mechanism that keeps them running as fast and as hard as they can. They know no other way to cope with life. The quicker they move, the less vulnerable they are to ridicule, critique, or even examination. Midadolescents know they must put on a mask of confidence, even arrogance, or they will be chewed up by those who would find them out. May we, the adults who love and care for them, not be fooled. They are busy, yes, and stressed, but they want someone to demonstrate in word and action, “You matter to me.”

↑ Back to top

↑