Chapter 19 of 26

12: Kids at the Margins

12: Kids at the Margins

12

kids at the margins

Shawn shouted across the room just as I was leaving for the lunch area, “Will you eat with me? No one eats with me!”

Since I had been his substitute teacher three times, I knew Shawn fairly well. He was a small guy, even for a freshman, and he could barely walk. It was true that Shawn rarely ate with anyone, and it appeared that he didn’t have any, or at least very many, friends. He was part of a “special ed” class, and I didn’t know quite where to discuss him in this book. While this encounter with Shawn haunted me for some time, in the first edition of Hurt I didn’t mention it because I could not find a way to make it fit the macro design of the book. So I left out the story of this tender, lonely, wandering kid. In life, and in the book, he didn’t fit. Shawn could be described as a kid at the margins.

During the follow-up study to the first edition of this book, I met Terry, a thin, darting young man whose only words to me were, “I hate school!” Terry clearly loved to laugh, mostly at others, and yet he could turn a smile into a mask of disdain on a dime. After a very brief introduction and conversation, it was clear that Terry didn’t want to talk to me. I was at his school with one of my graduate students who spent most of his time in and around this particular neighborhood. Terry’s school is among the poorest in one of the most impoverished parts of Los Angeles, and I had come to gather at least a bit of insight into the unique issues the kids of this neighborhood deal with, in contrast to the issues of the kids I included as part of the “macro” majority of American teenagers. My grad student and I moved on from group to group, occasionally finding someone who would agree to chat, even briefly, but mostly just being visible and present. But the one person I remember most from that day is Terry. Something about his eyes told me how far apart we were. If I had met Terry before I had first written Hurt, he, like Shawn, probably wouldn’t have made the final edit. He was too far out at the margins.

Sara was as close to the perfect teenager as any I had met. She was attractive in a cute, wholesome way, and she had the grace and demeanor of a dancer, the movements of a gymnast, and the poise of a choirgirl. Sara was committed—a committed student, a committed athlete, a committed child, and a committed churchgoer. But as we interacted when we first met, and as I observed her in a focus group I later facilitated at an elite private school, I began to notice that there was a difference between Sara and other teens I had encountered throughout the study. On the one hand, she seemed to be more genuine than most young people I had encountered. Yet at the same time she seemed younger than her age and her classmates, perhaps by as much as a year. I can only describe her as naively optimistic and developmentally sheltered. The more our team observed Sara and her peers, the more we noticed that they all seemed significantly younger and less emotionally aware than their peers from public schools. As of the first edition of Hurt, I hadn’t yet encountered this disparity between the more mainstream teenagers and those, like Sara, who had extremely invested parents and tightly controlled school and social environments. Even if I had, I am not sure what I would have said about Sara and her friends. From the outside they appeared to be the elite among their age-group—and they clearly knew how to play the part well—but they belonged in a different category.

Sara, Terry, and Shawn: three teenagers who in many ways are equally part of the adolescent community that has been affected by systemic abandonment, and who are living, like their peers across the board, out of a sense of isolation and the need to perform. Yet they are all what I now call “kids at the margins,” a designation that describes those young people who, though still in the same macro world as their peers, in some ways fall well outside of the sociological mainstream. This book attempts to provide a comprehensive description of a diverse population of midadolescents, but there is no question that many young people exhibit behaviors, values, and attitudes that do not cleanly fit such broad characterizations. Yet to get a sense of where teenagers are today, to really get inside their world, we must examine those at both ends of the sociological and developmental spectrum—what I call “the margins”—using the results of my ethnographic study and research triangulation to better understand in what ways their experience may be more difficult than for the mainstream young teen.

At the outset, it is important to note that while much of contemporary scholarship views adolescents as basically healthy, there are emerging voices who believe that the teenage life is not quite the free adventure many adults assume. Among those who study adolescents there is an increasingly pervasive perspective that growing up today is harder and more treacherous than in generations past. As Osgood, Foster, and Courtney put it, “Moving into adulthood involves a long and often difficult transition in the United States and other industrialized nations in the West.” In both editions of Hurt I have attempted to make the case that, at least at some level, all midadolescents experience life as painful and precarious; they grow up feeling more isolated than previous generations and are therefore more stressed and lonely than adolescent populations in the past. I have observed and studied kids at the margins—both those who have less opportunity and resources than the average young person and those who seem to have everything—and I have wrestled with the literature regarding both extremes, but it is not an easy task to describe how these teenagers experience life in comparison to their peers. To simply say that both groups of young people struggle as they grow up would be insulting to those who have had few resources in navigating the transition to adulthood; the issues they face, like racism, poverty, and the like, certainly disadvantage them in ways their more fortunate peers will never understand. Yet at the same time there is ample evidence that—as Madeline Levine puts it in the title of her outstanding book The Price of Privilege—there is a high cost to what she calls privilege, especially in contemporary society. So instead of attempting to offer comparisons of who has it worse, in this chapter I will focus on describing what I have observed in light of the latest research that illuminates how kids at the margins experience life in different ways from their more, for lack of a better term, mainstream peers.

For every teenager, regardless of life circumstance, the three basic issues of the adolescent journey are identity, autonomy, and belonging. Those who fall outside the mainstream of the social or developmental spectrum are just as concerned with and consumed by the need to discover who they are as those who might be considered more typical. This chapter seeks to challenge cultural myths and stereotypes that keep us from recognizing what is going on with those at the margins. Although it may not seem that privileged teens would wrestle with the issue of autonomy in the same way as their peers, research indicates, for example, that they actually have a more difficult time recognizing and living out of a strong sense of self with the internal belief that they matter as a unique person. Even kids of privilege carry within them a longing to love and be loved, to find themselves embedded in a community where who they are is celebrated, needed, and desired. Cultural perceptions about kids at both ends of the developmental and social spectrum abound, but like all adolescents they also must seek identity, autonomy, and belonging. Yet kids who are particularly advantaged or disadvantaged are uniquely shaped by the circumstances that have placed them on the fringes of the mainstream. Thus this chapter will look at the distinctives of both the vulnerable and the privileged as they attempt to navigate these three tasks of adolescence.

The Vulnerable and the Privileged

The midadolescent population “at the margins,” as I conceptualize it, includes those on the one extreme who, relative to their peers, have fewer opportunities and resources (and generally more roadblocks) to achieve healthy individuation and those on the other extreme who have more opportunities and resources. The former, whom I refer to as vulnerable, include those who grow up under extreme systemic or societal oppression or who have been beaten down by the impersonal vagaries of life circumstance. This group includes young people who face severe poverty, are homeless, or are where they are due to class and/or racial oppression. According to scholarly studies on vulnerable adolescents, especially those who are from poor urban communities, the majority are of color, are more likely to be male, are more prone to mental illness and depression, and are far more likely to be involved in substance abuse. There are of course exceptions to these generalities, but these are the broad categorizations applied to more at-risk adolescents.

Difficult life circumstances can also nudge children and adolescents toward the vulnerable category. Regardless of the events leading to the circumstances, this marginalized group consists of the disabled, the socially illiterate, those who self-describe as GLBT (gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgender), and those who fall into a distinct separatist subculture, for whatever reason, like highly religious students. While many teenagers who might self-identify with one (or more) of these categorizations are not actually outside of their peer-group structures and therefore should not be viewed as “kids at the margins,” in my observation these are the two broad categories that describe the vulnerable.

At the other end of the continuum are those who have been commonly referred to as privileged. This term describes those teens that have a great deal more social capital, environmental resources, and relational and vocational opportunities than the average population. While not all private school students should be considered privileged, many privileged youth do attend private schools, especially elite private schools, and they are typically wealthy, have parents who are accomplished and deeply invested, and have been raised under the banner of possessing, for a variety of reasons, “exceptional” potential. They can be described as “special,” often due to their pedigree or their parents’ achievements, social status, fame, or power. Privileged kids are taught at a very young age that they innately possess a special status among the world in general and their peers in particular, and they are programmed to live accordingly.

Identity

While there is debate over the precise definition of and process related to the term identity, most people recognize it as the way we see and define ourselves as “me.” Scholars generally agree that identity can be described as having a well-formed “sense of self.” Madeline Levine explains the need for the development of the self as an adolescent grows up: “The reason that a well-developed sense of self is so critical is that, in the desirable and inevitable absence of external support, a sense of self provides both a comfortable home base and an internal compass for navigating through life. Lives are never perfect—not our own, not our children’s—but a healthy sense of self helps insure that life will be interesting, satisfying, and manageable.”

It is difficult to engage in adult society without at least a relatively grounded sense of the self as distinct from others. The development of identity is a much-debated topic in developmental literature, but there is little doubt it involves an internal quest to embrace one’s unique sense of self while interfacing with a socially mediated and communally affirmed portrayal of who one is. As David Moshman put it, “Our efforts to construct an identity are constrained not only by external social factors but by a need to be true to ourselves . . . the actual construction of identity may sometimes partake more of creation, and sometimes more of discovery, but in general, it involves elements of both.” For an adolescent moving toward healthy interdependent adulthood it is vitally important to have help navigating this treacherous developmental terrain of discovery and integration. The question before us, then, is how do kids at the margins discover and create a unique sense of self that they can carry into the rest of their lives?

Identity Discovery for Vulnerable Kids

Every culture desires its children to grow up into healthy, productive, and contributing adults. In order for a child to become such an adult, however, it is essential that adults are present, available, and committed to providing the environment where each child can discover and live out of his or her unique sense of self. To take this obvious assertion one step further, every child deserves the opportunity to have the chance to grow up in such a way as to realize his or her distinctiveness as a member of society. This is a much more difficult task for vulnerable kids than for those growing up in the mainstream.

Part of the community’s role in identity formation and self-discovery is to name, or label, what that community—whether parents, neighbors, coaches, teachers, or other adults—sees as the emerging self of the child. This naming has great power—power that can be either productive in affirming a child’s growing sense of self or destructive in negatively determining his or her identity. Depending on the source and relationship of the messenger, negative labeling has great power to become a curse that a child must overcome in order to move into healthy adulthood. When a vulnerable child, for example, is labeled a failure (by being either explicitly told or implicitly treated as such), that child will learn to live into the label that the community confers. When such labels are harmful, damaging, or demeaning, because they come from those with the power of authority and the weight of the community, children often embrace this tag as the definition of who they are. As Vasudevan and Campano note, “The proliferation of labeling in American schools has garnered ample critique (e.g., Hudak and Kihn, 2001), particularly in light of increased high-stakes testing and an era of accountability as measurement (Darling-Hammond, 2006). Labels and classifications, by themselves, may not be harmful. . . . However, when labels create an exclusive norm for human behavior and reinforce an ideology of (in)ability, there invariably will be hierarchy.”

Take the impact of violence on identity, for example, which is a present reality for many vulnerable kids. Children who grow up in homes or communities that normalize violence have a greater chance of seeing themselves as violent, and thereby not only will be prone to perpetuate a lifestyle of violence, but also will view themselves as violent persons, a defining label. It has been shown that for certain vulnerable children, high-risk behaviors provide a sense of security and stability as they attempt to find their own sense of self within a high-risk population. In one study, adolescents reported that they were able to achieve a “mature status in the eyes of their caregivers through antisocial behaviors such as criminal activity, sexual promiscuity, drug use and other forms of delinquency and risk-taking behaviors.” For homeless teenagers, a population about whom we know very little but that is estimated to number at least 1.7 million, the most common trigger leading to homelessness is household violence. For most of the teens in the vulnerable category, the violence they see and experience creates an environment that stifles, if not directly shapes, their identity. Thus not only do they not have the same opportunities to discover their own unique sense of self or to explore the various options of their mainstream peers; it is also likely that vulnerable youth will be dragged down into perpetuating a lifestyle of violence.

The issues related to vulnerable youth have been well documented in academic literature, and occasionally have made their way into our national discourse, mostly through political posturing. But the actual plight and environment of vulnerable kids is rarely engaged by the general populace, especially with any credible data driving the discussion. When an acquaintance found out I had spent time with some members of the Los Angeles gang reduction staff and visited some of their sites, he flippantly remarked, “They just need to get with the program, and improve their lives. Nobody ever helped me out when I was growing up.” This type of attitude is common today, especially among those who have never had to endure the realities that vulnerable kids face every day—from violence and drugs to systemic economic and racial oppression. What I observed at an urban public school versus at an elite religious private school, for example, made it impossible not to notice the differences in how our society cares about our young—discrediting the myth that in the United States we all have the same opportunity.

As we grow up our identity is shaped by the interaction between those voices and messages we receive and our internal conception of ourselves. Vulnerable kids often receive negative or destructive messages, which sets the course for their identity development. A resounding default perspective toward vulnerable young people is that it is their fault that they have a hard time finding their way out of economic, educational, and societal circumstances that hold them back. So we as a culture often ignore the needs of our most vulnerable and implicitly join in the chorus of those negative influencers. It is no wonder we are a divided nation; we simply do not offer everyone a level playing field, and then we try to rationalize the inequities in order to make ourselves feel less responsible. Vulnerable kids are told that they will never amount to anything, that they are not as smart, or as talented, or as gifted as those of privilege, and the cycle rolls on. Our children are the losers, and therefore so are we all.

Identity Discovery for Privileged Kids

While identity discovery is not an easy task for most adolescents—especially given the profusion of disparate messages bombarding them throughout their young lives—most kids have the opportunity to explore the interaction of external messages and internal sense of self. For privileged kids, however, this dance becomes even more complicated as their environment becomes more controlled and manipulated. They know that they are constantly being watched, evaluated, and judged. They learn from a very young age that their life is and will always be measured by externals, especially how they look, adapt, and perform.

Just as labeling can reinforce a negative perception of one’s sense of self, it can also undercut the healthy development of the self. There is no doubt that on average privileged kids are able to perform at a higher level than their peers. In discussing the impact of labeling on vulnerable kids, Vasudevan and Campano assert that labeling at either extreme invariably results in a hierarchy for all young people. The privileged, then, grow up believing that they are better than, smarter than, and more capable across the board than their peers. The educational culture we have allowed to control the defining of our young has used labels to separate them by employing phrases like “gifted and talented.” As a result, privileged kids are conditioned to believe that they have an external standard and expectation they are destined to attain, while vulnerable teens are conditioned to expect that they have no chance in life because they are not gifted and talented, according to the prescribed definition.

For the purposes of this discussion the concern is not whether some young people are more academically and environmentally “wired” for a rigorous degree of educational opportunity. The issue for privileged teens is the worldview that defines individuals according to their “potential,” which goes well beyond academics and spills into sports, music, dance, commerce, and just about any other human activity. For privileged kids, there is simply the expectation that they are somehow a cut above others. This creates, then, an implicit—and at times explicit—label that they must carry and address as they seek to discover who they are.

As discussed in chapter 9, today’s kids are under more stress than any previous generation. Privileged young people, however, because they are trained to see themselves as the elite, are under far greater pressure to live up to external expectations and agendas than the rest of the adolescent population. While most adults tend to view adolescents as spoiled or at least unfiltered and unfettered consumers who do not seem to have a care in the world other than themselves, another reality is buried beneath the surface of today’s teenagers. They are attempting to discover who they are in a world that defines them by externals. In our research with privileged kids our team observed in every focus group and saw affirmed across a wide range of academic literature that growing up today with the requirement to represent oneself with strength and prowess adds yet another layer to what adolescents must bear. With privileged adolescents, this additional coating of entitlement and power adds a complex dimension to an already difficult life. Because privileged youth are trained to see themselves as superior to others, they carry the added burden of having to avoid showing any weakness or even struggle, sometimes even hiding the truth of human vulnerability from themselves.

For privileged young people, especially for those who are temperamentally or environmentally well suited for maintaining an air of causal power and capability, the effort it takes to perpetuate the myth of superiority overshadows and can even stifle the natural developmental process of identity formation and discovery. It is as if the “me” they need to become is pushed aside for the “me” they need to externally produce and display. Thus, as Madeline Levine notes, “When we coerce, intrude on, or take over for our children unnecessarily we may be ‘spoiling’ them, but the far more significant consequence is that we are interfering with their ability to construct a sense of self.” The effect of how children of privilege are raised and led by adult systems, and especially by their parents, is that their chief developmental task during adolescence is often ignored and even diverted while they are reminded that the greatest goal in life is the development of the externals that define them.

Again, Levine asks, “Why are children of privilege, in record numbers, having an extraordinarily difficult time completing the most fundamental task of adolescence—the development of autonomy and a healthy sense of self?” Drawing on a wide array of studies and research perspectives, Levine analyzes and critiques pressure and performance, isolation (in this case directly related to individualism) to materialism, “the emphasis on things over people and character.” Performance is the rubric by which worth is measured and identity defined. Isolation, as a consequence of the ethic of “rugged individualism” (a hallmark characteristic of privilege), is clearly a universal plague among all midadolescents, and with privileged teenagers it is a carefully guarded but nonetheless visible companion. Materialism is a product of the pressure to perform, and is therefore “both a cause and a symptom of impaired self-development.”

The notion of materialism, which is clearly not limited to the privileged, is nonetheless one of the major influences that Levine and others identify that hinder healthy identity development. Curtis Miller, in summarizing literature on the effects of materialism among privileged teens, defines it in this way: “Materialism means the emphasis on things over people and character, and is rampant in affluent communities. Materialism directly attacks a child’s ability to develop a secure sense of self because it means defining oneself entirely through outside markers of status. In other words, you are not defined by your character but by the things you have and by other people’s perception of you. There is no internal self-development since all energy is being used to cultivate external perceptions.”

Thus many privileged adolescents have a much more difficult time doing the hard work required to achieve a healthy sense of self. As we have noted throughout this book, it is not easy for anyone. But for those who live under the labeling, expectations, and agendas of others (especially adults who define adolescents by pedigree, extraordinary talent, or circumstance), it can be even more difficult. For young people who are taught that isolation is the acceptable cost of the privilege and power, and who have been handed a world where materialism teaches that control, power, and desire are more valuable than people and relationships, the cost becomes growing up without a core sense of self.

Autonomy

The second primary task of adolescence, autonomy, has been largely understood in terms of its external expressions, like responsibility and making wise choices. Yet the development of an inner capacity for making the kinds of choices, and thereby assuming the level of responsibility, that is expected of an adult is much more an internal process of growth, awareness, and “owning” one’s choices. In other words, what most adults—parents, teachers, coaches, counselors—are most concerned with is not that young people are developing the internal capability to wrestle through various competing issues and expectations in order to learn how to choose the right course of action for their life, but rather that they would make the kinds of choices and assume the level of responsibility that would serve the interests of the adult. Therefore we readily judge our young not by the trajectory of learning and growing they are on, but rather by how they are fitting inside the predetermined box we have expected them to live in. This trained compliance, however, is not the developmental task of healthy autonomy; it is learning how to adapt to the agendas of others. And these are very different things.

Autonomy can best be described as the ability to make a difference, to choose a life path, and to operate as an agent in the service of society. The key word, then, at the heart of autonomy is power. As Scot D. Evans notes, “power comes from developing capacity, experiencing voice and resonance, and having opportunities to play meaningful roles in the context of caring adult support and challenge.” For many adults the word power itself, when it comes to working with and guiding adolescents, conjures up a wide variety of potentially negative outcomes, even when it is couched in terms of developing “capacity” and “voice.” For when a developing young person explores her own sense of self, and agency and voice, by that very act she becomes a threat to someone else’s agenda, unless of course that agenda is to best serve the needs of the emerging adult. This is perhaps the most prominent and defining issue for adults as we seek to raise, lead, and guide young people: above all, each adolescent needs the chance to discover who he or she is as a person who matters and who has a significant role to play in society. As they explore and express their power, however, adolescents will inevitably bump into the power sphere of the adults in charge. Thus when an adult is in a relationship with a young person for any reason other than for their developmental health and well-being, the adolescent will eventually find himself in a situation where he hits the wall of adult control. This is the gauntlet that is thrown down any time an adolescent pushes against an authority or power agenda while under the domain of the adult in charge. Even if the adult believes that he or she is exerting authority and control in the best interests of the adolescent, it can actually end up being received as one more expression of abandonment. The mere presence of an adult with an agenda keeps kids from growing up believing that their voice and agency matters. An adolescent cannot become an adult without the opportunity to find her unique power and place, but adults are rarely willing to sacrifice their own power and place in order to allow that to happen.

The development of autonomy, then, is a necessary step in growing up, and for every adolescent it is a precarious journey. For kids at the margins, this is an even more difficult and elusive process. As a result of my work with young people from both extremes, I believe Evans has it right when he says that “research also suggests that adults need to find a way to help teenagers find their voice and influence in community settings. There is much recent evidence to suggest that this is happening in community organizations, and some school and city contexts. Unfortunately, many of these examples fall short of providing youth genuine influence and power. Many of these opportunities are simply token gestures that give teenagers the perception of influence without really sharing any power at all.”

All adults, not just parents, bear the responsibility to ensure that children are given the chance to explore who they are and what gifts they bring to society. Very few kids at the margins have relationships with adults who understand this as their role, much less with adults who are willing to adjust their own expectations and put their own needs aside to make it happen. Certainly parents hold the greatest influence and have the greatest opportunity of anyone to help their children discover their voice and power. Another influential group of adults, one that has almost as much potential to make an impact on adolescents as parents, is comprised of those who are committed to deeply investing in helping a child or teenager discover what power they have. In addition to parents, those adults who are closest to children and adolescents, like mentors, coaches, teachers, youth leaders, and so on, can provide a supportive environment in which an adolescent can recognize that her voice and her gifts matter, and that she is a powerful agent in the world. Adults can help youth to build a sense of power and autonomy in various ways, from boosting measurable aspects of autonomy, like confidence, to inspiring the kind of future adolescents will explore as they get older.

In the following discussion of autonomy for kids at the margins I have chosen to spend a great deal more time and space describing this issue for privileged kids than for vulnerable kids. Adolescents on both extremes face adversity in finding their own voice and living out of that unique calling, but the issues for these two groups are very different. I have done my best to highlight some of the salient issues facing vulnerable youth as they attempt to find their own sense of power and autonomy, and I firmly agree with those who advocate that a hard, honest look needs to be taken at vulnerable kids and communities, but for the most part I will offer my own perspective and leave deeper discussion of these issues to other scholars and forums. What hinders privileged kids’ ability to discover and explore their growing sense of power and voice is less clear, and in fact is something disputed by many adults (especially those who are charged with direct responsibility for nurturing them). Because the plight of privileged kids as they seek autonomy has not found its way into the cultural conversation, I have therefore given a bit more focus to this side of the spectrum.

Autonomy Opportunities for Vulnerable Kids

There are multiple factors at work in denying vulnerable kids the opportunity to grow into healthy, productive adulthood. This is true as they seek to discover and live out of a sense of self (identity), and it is even more true as they strive to explore their own power and voice (autonomy). To many vulnerable kids, the greatest obstacles they face result from the overwhelming systemic forces that deny power not only to them but to their entire community. The oft-repeated cultural mantras that anyone can make it and that one only needs to work hard and good things will happen mean something very different to the vulnerable than they do to other teens. In a provocative and powerful article studying the perspectives of “female inner city youth,” Ruta Valaitis reported how adolescent girls felt about their community’s lack of commitment to the development of their autonomy: “In summary, youth’s abstract ideals of community and their experiences with community were incongruent. These negative experiences coloured their perceptions about their position and power to influence their community. . . . Under the major theme of ‘threats to empowerment,’ there are three subthemes: ‘grown-ups run everything,’ ‘we’re just kids,’ and ‘they don’t trust us.’ . . . Youth’s feelings of being ‘put down’ by adults help to further explain their perception of having low control.”

These perceptions mirror what mainstream adolescents report, especially in relationship to their sense of powerlessness and the lack of adult support they receive as they attempt to develop their own voice. Yet vulnerable kids, especially in depressed urban contexts where even the adults in the community feel disempowered and pushed aside, face even greater developmental challenges. In communities where oppression and depression have been a constant reality for decades, there is little capacity available for helping children and adolescents believe that they can rise above the only life they have known. When the adults in a child’s life model a general malaise of hopelessness and resignation, the child grows up believing that is his lot as well. Without meaning to discourage or hinder the future for their kids, such communities nonetheless reinforce and even participate in a repeating cycle of systemic disempowerment. This makes the development of autonomy, power, and voice an elusive if not unreachable dream, in spite of the fact that it is a core task in human development.

For vulnerable kids who may have access to relatively supportive adult relationships but still find themselves at the margins—like those with even slight disabilities or those who may have relatively low emotional or social intelligence—it can be equally difficult to develop a healthy sense of internal autonomy. Because society at large and their peer community consistently perpetuate the message that these young people are “less than” others and therefore do not possess the power or ability to function as viable agents, these marginalized teens also find it extremely difficult to develop a healthy sense of internal autonomy. Even when there is an occasional encouraging voice, an assigned “mentor,” or some other random source of support, the forces arrayed against them are potent. There is simply no doubt that vulnerable kids of all circumstances face a much harder road toward healthy autonomy than their mainstream peers.

Autonomy Opportunities for Privileged Kids

Few adults would suspect that privileged kids have any struggle at all with the development of autonomy, especially when terms like power are used to define the task. Most are convinced that the more resources one has, the more able one is to handle anything that comes along. There is actually a growing body of evidence with an accompanying groundswell of support that would seem to indicate exactly this: kids with the most support, belief in themselves, and even academic achievement have a much greater ability not only to survive difficulties and obstacles, but even to thrive. In surveying this literature, youth service worker Maria Drews summarizes:

A few essential elements are necessary to develop and protect that natural resilience we all possess. Studies show that good intellectual functioning (including IQ, problem solving, and information-processing), competent and effective parenting (including monitoring, boundaries, and support), and the ability to regulate emotion and behavior are all essential parts of developing natural resiliency. If these systems are compromised, a kid’s natural resilience will be hindered, and the chance of poor outcomes in the face of adversity will be much higher. On the other hand, if a kid has adults who care for them, normal cognitive development, and the ability to manage their attention, emotions, and behavior, they are more likely to develop a strong natural resilience to adversity.

When examining the existing literature through the lens of thriving, sometimes also called “positive psychology,” it is evident that there are distinctives that enable some to flourish and leave others to flounder, especially in the face of difficulty. Adolescents who, as Drew asserts, have “adults who care for them, normal cognitive development, and the ability to manage their attention, emotions, and behavior,” or, perhaps better to say, who know and believe they have such a rich environmental pool to draw upon, there is a greater likelihood that their transition into adulthood will be smoother and healthier than it would be for someone who does not. Instead of finding what is wrong with youth, then, “positive youth development” as a theory prefers to focus on what is going right. According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, “the Positive Youth Development approach understands that all young people need support, guidance, and opportunities during adolescence. It also looks toward creating supportive communities for all young people and at the same time, engaging youth to contribute to the well-being of the larger community.” According to advocates of this theoretical framework, positive youth development also emphasizes that youth are producers of their own growth, counting heavily on the idea that there is an innate and accessible “human capacity for motivation that drives development.”

That said, throughout this book we have demonstrated that, at least for a brief season during midadolescence, roughly fourteen to twenty years of age, very few report feeling like they have such a robust support system, either externally or internally. This is true across the board for this age group. In our studies with a wide variety of kids, the “human capacity for motivation” during midadolescence was in practice latent at best. For some kids (and in my observation this was a very small percentage of the midadolescent population) their developmental progress included an occasional and context-specific rhetorical nod to a forward-thinking motivation. Yet even for most such kids, and certainly for everyone else, an internal drive toward growing up was hardly on the observable radar. More pressing was surviving the myriad agendas and expectations their world was throwing at them while trying to make sense of the competing interests, needs, and longings that they were seeking to fulfill. For vulnerable kids this may be obvious, but this is also an expressed reality for privileged adolescents.

It clearly is important to focus on the positive where it is appropriate and to do all we can to help our children “thrive” by providing for them what they need to become successful, productive, even resilient, adults. But, and this is true even for the privileged, before we jump too quickly into what is good out there and identify whom we may perceive as thriving, it may be important to first look carefully at what is really going on with today’s teenagers—all of today’s teenagers. We need to investigate what lies beneath the surface and see how our adolescents are actually experiencing the environment they’ve been handed by us as a society. Acting and responding to circumstances with a positive outlook and commitment is important, yet before we respond we must have a clear picture of whom and what we are dealing with. In so doing, by recognizing and cataloging systemic abandonment and its effects, the eventual outcome for those who care about kids may be an even more robust theoretical understanding that could lead to a more effective strategic response so that more kids, families, and communities are well served.

Studies done by prominent psychologist Suniya S. Luthar, for example, reveal how far off from reality our perceptions of privileged kids are. While most adults believe that kids who have greater resources and opportunities than their peers are generally happier and more satisfied with life, recent studies (and media headlines) overwhelmingly challenge that myth. Luthar and Latendresse found that teenagers in affluent communities have significantly higher rates of depression, eating disorders, substance abuse and addiction, anxiety disorders, cutting, and other self-destructive behaviors than all other groups of teenagers. In addition, for several markers of mental health and development, affluent kids are worse off than even “high-risk” (or vulnerable) adolescents in urban centers. According to adolescent psychology expert Madeline Levine, the root of these problems is that affluent teens display a disturbing lack of independence and are therefore quite fragile in the face of relatively minor adversity. This lack of independence and fragility in the face of adversity can ultimately lead to the need for self-medicating and self-destructive behaviors.

Research indicates that “competent and effective parenting” is an essential component of the landscape necessary for healthy development of autonomy and resilience, and yet for many privileged kids parents may end up providing exactly the opposite of what they need to thrive. There is current evidence that as privileged adolescents move into emerging adulthood their experience and perception of the kind of parenting they receive has a strong correlation with their ability to develop a healthy sense of internal power and autonomy, especially during times of crisis and stress. For parents who are able to convince their children over time to perceive that they are and have been “competent and effective” in their parenting skills (“monitoring, boundaries, and support,” and the key word is perceive, because the predictors are tied to an adolescent’s perception of the parental role, not his or her parents’), children will tend to ultimately create narratives of their histories and lives that demonstrate a growing sense of competency and resilience. Yet when children perceive their parents as controlling or as having an alternate agenda that is not for the ultimate good of the child, or when parents simply are not present, a child’s historical narrative will tend to express dissatisfaction and struggle. Parents know that to be perceived by their children as committed and supportive requires a finely tuned and mysterious dance, and that finding a healthy balance between “monitoring” and “support” is much easier said than done. As Michael Ungar found, “teens in this study demonstrate that they want a parent to remain involved in their lives, but not to dominate the child’s own choices regarding how he or she nurtures health.”

Privileged kids, on average, have highly involved parents who generally take a proactive role in their children’s lives. While most consider this to be their role as “good” parents, their involvement can easily become overly controlling. Having controlling parents, when coupled with the stressors of performance and maintaining a suitable image that privileged kids carry, provides a recipe for deep struggle and anxiety. The indicators of this struggle may not show up for years, because privileged kids are only given two choices when growing up under this level of scrutiny: comply and adapt, or rebel and face the consequences.

This has given rise to “helicopter parents,” who hover over their children and control them almost to the point of living their lives for them. One example of this is the rise of parents writing college essays, a practice that parents usually defend by saying that their kids are “too busy” or “would do it well but can’t focus right now.” This line of logic and style of parenting is prominent in privileged households, and in our research this moral reasoning has been tilled into the soil of the children of these households. So not only are the children of helicopter parents ill prepared for living from the center as they enter the world post–high school; they are also taught that moral rules, like honesty and integrity, do not apply to them if it means getting something or somewhere they want. Similarly, in the last few years we have also witnessed a new type of parenting style related to an adolescent’s developmental journey: the “stealth bomber parent,” who is committed to swooping in and “fixing” a problem or controlling an environment, yet does not have the nurturing commitment to remain and “hover” like the helicopter parent. This parenting style does damage to all parties, yet is becoming an increasing problem among privileged families and communities.

There is ample evidence that privileged teens are far better at adapting to the expectations around them, as they have been trained and conditioned to do just that their entire lives. But the cost of such a commitment to adaptation—adaptation to the agendas, expectations, and sometimes even whims of those adults in control, including teachers and coaches as well as parents—actually stifles their ability to develop the internal sense of personal agency they will need as a healthy adult. For a privileged kid, to succeed is to capably adapt to the goals of the system handed to them, whether in sports, in a class, in playing an instrument, or in how one presents oneself on the outside. There is little room for adolescents to learn how to examine a situation or issue from a variety of angles and to experiment with choices and decisions, for the cost of failure in the system of the elite is often viewed as too steep for even the young to bear.

In my work with privileged kids, I found that they were unaware of their inability to think critically on their own and generally naïve regarding the need for critical thinking and decision making. If ever a population has been trained to live inside the box set before them, it is the subculture of privileged kids. Yet when they go to college, get jobs, get married, and attempt to move into adult life with a well-developed and healthy sense of how to navigate its complexities, they will likely be far behind their mainstream peers. Learning to adapt to the decisions of others more powerful than oneself is an important life skill. Yet learning to integrate conflicting viewpoints; to nuance personality differences; to navigate and interpret pain, failure, and brokenness; and to believe that we all need each other are skills that are even more vital. But the latter are not skills taught in the elite circles of our society, and our privileged kids are not led to develop their own voice while listening to the cherished and valuable voices of others.

Belonging

In a culture that elevates personal accomplishment and individual responsibility over mutual support and communal living, growing adolescents find themselves faced with an inescapable conundrum: is it more valuable to learn how to stand tall as a capable individual or to learn how to recognize my need for others and their need for me? In American culture, for some time we have been taught that we are ultimately on our own and that no one will ever care about us or our needs as much as we do. On the other hand, none of us can escape the fact that to live alone is to die, for we are social creatures who must have others to survive.

With adolescents, cultural mandates do not have the power to drown out the deafening voice of human history. Society is, after all, defined as our life together as a group. We need each other, and none of us can ever hope to live up to the rhetorical expectations of independence and solitude that we have been trained to pursue, even if we wanted to. We are simply not wired to live as autonomous creatures who do not need anyone other than those who can serve a utilitarian purpose. In defining the concept of need, Abraham Maslow called it a “deficiency disease,” which he illustrated by reporting that “most neuroses involved, along with other complex determinants, ungratified wishes for safety, for belongingness and identification, for close love relationships and for respect and prestige.” These basic human “needs” are rooted in our innate need for interconnectedness and belonging.

This book has repeatedly demonstrated how adolescents experience an isolation and palpable sense of loneliness as a result of systemic abandonment. This chapter addresses how kids at the margins in particular deal with the need to connect and belong in a world that can often make them feel alone. Perhaps more than identity and autonomy, this third major task of adolescence is where there is the greatest difference between kids at the margins and their mainstream peers.

Belonging for Vulnerable Kids

The good news is that for those who are vulnerable due to systemic oppression or racial, socioeconomic, or other such factors, there is often a stronger sense of community than in mainstream American culture. The presence of this social network is sometimes, in certain communities, assumed to provide for an otherwise vulnerable adolescent a significant asset as they grow into adulthood. What is rarely acknowledged is that it takes more than the presence of a social network to create the kind of support a developing adolescent requires to meet her innate need for unconditional inclusion and authentic belonging to a group. Even for those vulnerable kids who have a close-knit extended family, for example, the lack of an integrated web of social support networks beyond their kin can create in them a sense that while their family accepts them, the rest of the world does not. This can cause them to have an antagonistic view of their family versus the greater society, which may in turn hinder their sense that they fit outside of their immediate, usually familial, community.

An example of this is the school system. The majority opinion today in the dominant culture is that our public educational system resolved the issues of racial separation long ago. The facts are, however, astonishing. In December, Time magazine chose as its “most underreported story of 2009” a report that revealed that “African-American schoolchildren are more segregated than they have been since the time of Martin Luther King Jr.’s death in 1968. In the 2006–07 school year, nearly 40% attended schools—many of them subpar ‘dropout factories’—where students of color made up 90% to 100% of the student body.” The UCLA study cited notes that “fifty-five years after the Brown decision, blacks and Latinos in American schools are more segregated than they have been in more than four decades.” While there are many problems and issues that accompany this reality, perhaps the most significant is that the vast differences in the educational opportunities for today’s vulnerable kids compared to the privileged tangibly demonstrate one way that our society excludes the vulnerable from belonging.

The issue of separate educational opportunities often has the effect of excluding the vulnerable from feeling they are a part of “us”; however, those from the populations where most vulnerable kids live universally believe that this is but a symptom of a much greater truth: the mainstream and elite are committed to maintaining the walls of exclusion while perpetuating the image that we are one. (Even writing this sentence, sitting in the company of a planeload of the mainstream and elite, I can just imagine how my flightmates would react to such an assertion.) While this book is not about American society on the whole, our divisions directly affect the developmental health of the children and adolescents we are seeking to understand. One African-American teen, for instance, who could only be considered vulnerable due to his ethnicity, asked me point-blank, “Dr. Clark, have you ever been followed by a police car because you were driving in a neighborhood where you didn’t belong? You ever been pulled over by a cop who kept you from leaving for a half hour because he said he didn’t believe you, and you know full well that’s because you’re black? Well, until that happens to you, don’t say you understand me, because you can’t.” This young man was absolutely correct, and an even greater injustice occurs when I have the audacity to pretend that I do understand. Perhaps that is among our greatest failings as a society: those of us who are by race members of the dominant culture are trained to believe that, regardless of ethnicity or class, we are all the same, with the same opportunities and privileges. This is simply not true, and until we are willing to be honest about this disparity and systematic racism and classism, we will continue to perpetuate this cultural divide.

Belonging for Privileged Kids

When adolescents grow up being conditioned to believe that personal achievement and individual prowess are what ultimately matter most in life, the developmental task of belonging comes to be seen as an optional luxury worth pursuing only if it is not too costly to the quest for status and power. Most privileged adolescents have been trained—even programmed—to believe and live as if they reside at the center of social groups and networks. The way privileged kids are conditioned to view life as one competition after another, coupled with the high value on individualism they have been steeped in (which Levine asserts is ultimately equated with isolation), produces in many privileged adolescents a deep sense of loneliness. Madeline Levine details this clearly and profoundly, summarizing that “the link between materialism and competition is particularly strong.” This third developmental task of adolescence, belonging, is the greatest deficit privileged kids experience as they grow up. When you are raised to see others, and sometimes even friends, as means to an end, the internal drive to belong to others both in peer relationships and as a society is simply pushed aside. The outcome, however, is to grow up wondering, does anyone actually care for me, or do others see and treat me as I have been taught to see and treat them?

Both privileged and vulnerable kids have no greater and no less of a driving need to belong in a meaningful, affirming, and genuine community—to know they are loved and appreciated not for what they can contribute but for who they are. And for kids from both margins the need to belong is not limited to their family or even to their closest group of friends, but is instead a need to belong to the society at large, and to those whom they must somehow relate to for the rest of their lives. The film Crash, which won the Academy Award for best picture in 2006, did a masterful job of reminding us that whether we grow up in a poor barrio in East Los Angeles, are second generation Asian, or have parents who went to Harvard Law and UCSD Medical School, we are all the same and we all need each other. But when you’ve been raised at the margins of mainstream society, this is a difficult if not insurmountable discovery to make. Adolescents at the margins are too often programmed to believe that, in the final analysis, they simply do not, and never will, belong to everybody else.

Conclusion and Musings

Doing the research, spending the time with these kids, and then finally writing this chapter has been a difficult, even painful, journey for me. After skimming the first edition of Hurt, one sociologist remarked to me that it wasn’t a helpful sociological take on the midadolescent population because I was “an advocate.” Since then I have discovered that many sociologists, among them many of the most renowned in the history of their field, find themselves advocating for those they study, especially when over the course of their work they uncover injustice, oppression, or perhaps even relatively fixable issues that cause damage and pain to a group of people. If social science research must be a disconnected analytic quest for “data,” but does not bring action and change that improves the lives of real people, then the academy has written itself out of relevancy.

This chapter caused my heart to break for kids on both ends of the margins. From Shawn, the disabled boy who had few friends, to Terry, my hard-eyed urban adversary, to Sara, the sweet and smart wealthy girl, I have come to see that marginalized young people need what every other adolescent needs: adults who care for them without any self-serving agenda. All kids, regardless of their background, family, ethnicity, gifts, or power, are desperate for a society that will help them discover who they are, what gifts and voice they have, and how they belong in a multigenerational community that values all. Because of the work I have had the honor to do with these kids the last few years, I am now more committed than ever not only to writing as an advocate, but also to advocating with my time, my money, my career, my calling, and my life. I invite all of you who are reading to join me. Our kids, all our kids, deserve no less.

↑ Back to top

↑