2: Abandonment—The Defining Issue For Contemporary Adolescents
2
abandonment—the defining issue for contemporary adolescents
The adolescent community is a creation by default, an amorphous grouping of young people that constitutes the world in which adolescents spend their time.
Patricia Hersch, A Tribe Apart
Part of my melancholy is just the loss of childhood. I can almost remember the day I realized nobody could really take care of me or protect me, that awareness of mortality and being on my own. Nothing’s been the same since.
singer Lucinda Williams
I did not conduct this study in a vacuum. My career calling has kept me in close relationship with adolescents since my own graduation in the early 1970s. Further, as an actively involved parent of three high school students, I have seen multiple sides of adolescents. Because of this background, I began my study with the misguided belief that I possessed a fairly thorough understanding of young people. As prepared as I may have been, however, I was not as ready as I had thought. My middle son, a high school junior at the time, sensed my apparent comfort and offered a meaningful warning: “I know you think you know a lot about kids, Dad, but you had better be ready for a shock. I don’t think you really get it! I don’t think any adult gets it!”
Out of what I would later recognize as naïveté at best or blatant academic and professional hubris at worst, I was, in fact, ill prepared for what I encountered in the world of the middle adolescent. I had known a great number of students over the years and had built close relationships with many of them, but when I approached students seeking to understand the complexities and nuances of their world, my simplistic views were quickly challenged, if not outrightly dismantled. I had expected a few surprises in penetrating the walls and secret places of their society and community, but what I now understand is that my history and training had given me an incomplete and therefore distorted picture of their world. In many cases, I had been able to get close to the students I had known over the years, but during this study, I recognized that each of those relationships had been rooted in my terms and created on my turf. The people I had known were in reality only conjured presentations. In effect, those relationships were based wholly on my social and worldview contexts rather than theirs or even a mutual context. I had failed to recognize that each young person exists in a social setting vastly different from my own. Therefore, as painful as this admission may be, I missed truly knowing most of them. I now believe this is true of almost every adult, including those who work with adolescents on a daily basis. The world of young people is different, period. It is fragmented, complex, and multilayered, and therefore, their worldview, lexicon, value system, and even the framework used to decipher and navigate the extraordinary complexity of adolescence has changed.
The State of Contemporary Adolescence: The Academic Debate
Pulitzer Prize–winning author Ron Powers made quite a stir in March 2002 with the publication of an article in the Atlantic in which he made the observation that “the inconvenience of children, the downright menace of children—has become a dominant theme of life.” His article and subsequent interview on 60 Minutes II focused on the increasing culture of disenfranchisement of the young and the resulting violence perpetrated by adolescents, especially in his home state of Vermont. His intent was to encourage adults to sit up and take notice regarding the condition of our young.
There are those, however, who believe that Powers’s view was skewed by a few isolated events and that he ignored the overwhelming evidence that suggests precisely the opposite—that adolescents are in far better shape than they have been in years. University of California, Santa Cruz, sociologist Mike Males, for example, is one of the most vocal scholars arguing against Powers and others who claim that life is changing for the worse for today’s young. Males not only disagrees with Powers but also attempts to dismiss his perspective when he states, for example, that today’s young “are doing better than ever.” Males says that those who claim that youth are “in trouble” suffer from “ephebiphobia—extreme fear of youth,” and that the popular writers and pundits who perpetuate the view that adolescents are in trouble are creating a “full-blown media panic.” An increasing wave of reports describing arrogantly delinquent and dangerously violent new adolescents has spawned what Males believes is a false fear that we as a society have abandoned and neglected our young. Focusing primarily on the media attention given to Powers and his book on violence and youth, Males attempted to discredit Powers and whoever else tended to agree with him. He asserted that today’s adolescents are healthier, happier, and more nurtured than ever before. Indeed, on paper, his use of a wide variety of empirical data clearly refuted Powers and those who follow him.
This ongoing debate between those who believe that the young of our culture are in trouble and those who are optimistic about the state of teenagers is usually waged in battlegrounds characterized by the protected confines of academic literature. In such cases, empirical data (i.e., quantitative studies and hard numbers) are often seen as proof of legitimacy on both sides of the debate. Because Males’s studies cite “objective data,” for example, many scholars and academics tend to side with his view. His argument echoes the disdain some researchers express toward those who perpetuate unproven yet sensational “findings” or “alarming trends” that are regularly reported in the press. Frustrated with what is seen as a “popular” view of today’s adolescent struggles, many in the academic world believe there is substantial evidence that today’s young are flourishing and that they are “resilient.” Males is one of the few social scientists to receive a public hearing in the media, for he has the ability and the commitment both to engage in primary research and to interpret academic findings and conclusions in a way that the average person can understand. Popular literature may be fueled by violent or other sensational events such as those Powers relies on or by stories of darkness or loss of innocence, such as that of the nine-year-old girl who was recently arrested for prostitution, claiming that she “wanted to make money.” Yet, neither academic nor popular literature would go so far as to say that as a society life is as stable as it has ever been, especially as it relates to developing adolescents. In fact, esteemed psychologist Robert Epstein contends that the systems and structures we have erected to serve our young have actually done them great damage by holding them back, what he terms infantilization.
Perhaps the most interesting question has not yet been introduced into the debate. Does the type of research most academic studies rely on (i.e., historical theories, quantitative studies, and survey research) actually tell us all we need to know in order to understand the reality of the inner lives of today’s adolescents? The apparent contradictions and differing viewpoints actually represent different angles of the same adolescent experience. As young people attempt to navigate the increasing complexity of life, they are both incredibly resilient and deeply wounded. The culture itself is no longer as attentive to the needs of children and adolescents as it once was, and therefore, the young work hard at finding out how to make it on their own. This, however, is an almost impossible task. As David Elkind argues, “identity formation requires a kind of envelope of adult standards, values and beliefs that the adolescent can confront and challenge in order to construct and test out her own standards, values and beliefs. . . . Today, however, adults have fewer standards, values and beliefs and hold on to them less firmly than was true in the past. The adolescent must therefore struggle to find an identity without the benefit of this supportive adult envelope.”
On the surface, the adolescent world appears to be relatively stable and healthy. Yet beneath the calm waters presented by positive empirical data there is turmoil that is difficult, painful, lonely, and even harmful to our young. Even among those who argue that adolescents are basically fine, virtually no one would question the need young people, and especially adolescents, have for adults who are available, who care, and who come to them without a hidden or self-centered agenda. The fact is that adolescents need adults to become adults, and when adults are not present and involved in their lives, they are forced to figure out how to survive life on their own. As Patricia Hersch notes, “The more we leave kids alone, don’t engage, the more they circle around on the same adolescent logic that has caused dangerous situations to escalate.”
In this study, I found that a far wider relational and social chasm exists between adults and adolescents than I had previously considered. The data and observations from this study, especially when triangulated with academic and popular literature and with feedback from middle adolescents across socioeconomic and ethno-geographic lines, do not allow me to respond with casual academic indifference or cavalier theoretical dismissal. There is simply too much cumulative weight that points to a disturbing trend: the way midadolescents have been forced to design their own world and separate social system has created perhaps the most serious and yet understudied social crisis of our time. We hear such statements so often that it is easy to turn a skeptical or even deaf ear, but my hope is that the evidence emerging from this study will prove too convincing for even the most dubious readers to ignore.
The Hurried Child and a Culture of Abandonment
Tufts University professor David Elkind wrote the first edition of The Hurried Child in 1981, then followed up with a revised version in 1988 and again in 2001. In both revisions, Elkind emphasized his understanding of how things had changed for young people. In the 1988 edition, he wrote that in earlier books he was attempting “to further document how our changed treatment of adolescents and of young children was making life harder rather than easier for them.”
In the 2001 edition, he stated:
Many of the problems that I described in the preface to the second edition have only gotten worse. The concept of child competence, which drove much of the hurrying of childhood in previous decades, is very much alive today. Parents are under more pressure than ever to overschedule their children and have them engage in organized sports and other activities that may be age-inappropriate. Unhappily, the overtesting of children in public schools has become more extensive than it was even a decade ago. In some communities even kindergarteners are given standardized tests. Media pressures to turn children into consumers have also grown exponentially.
Based on my observations during the course of this study, I agree with Elkind’s theoretical assessment that as a culture we tend to “hurry” our children. However, I prefer to use the label abandoned rather than hurried. As Ron Powers and many others note, adolescents have a longing that parents, teachers, and other adults have ceased as a community to fulfill. The reasons are many and varied, but this concept of the systemic abandonment of adolescents as a people group seems to capture the widest range of descriptors used by careful observers of adolescents and adolescents themselves.
Numerous articles and books have noted the prevalence of this systemic abandonment of adolescents. In Ties That Stress: The New Family Imbalance, for example, Elkind states, “Like all those whose needs are not being met over the long term, postmodern children and adolescents are feeling victimized. They believe that they must suppress their own needs for security and protection to accommodate their parents’ and the society’s expectations that they be independent and autonomous. Like modern mothers, postmodern young people either turn their anger on themselves (for letting themselves be used) or at the world around them.”
Gen-X authors William Mahedy and Janet Bernardi, coauthors of A Generation Alone: Xers Making a Place in the World, detail their generation’s rebellious nature and summarize their experience by stating that “we know that no one really needs us.” They are, in actuality, describing a societywide slide in focus, nurture, and care of the young.
This concept of systemic abandonment became a major theme in Hersch’s groundbreaking study, A Tribe Apart, in which she concluded, “The adolescents of the nineties are more isolated and more unsupervised than any other generation.” Over the course of this study, I not only came to agree with these assertions but also experienced firsthand their stark reality. “A tribe apart” is more than just the title of a book; it is a vivid and intensely accurate description of modern middle adolescents. The young have not arrogantly turned their backs on the adult world. Rather, they have been forced by a personal sense of abandonment to band together and create their own world—separate, semisecret, and vastly different from the world around them.
Abandonment by External Systems
As has been noted, the concept of adolescence as a social construct, or definition of a unique life stage, has been recognized for just over a century. Prior to this, the transition from childhood to adulthood was seen less as a process and more as an event, marked in many cultures by significant ritual and celebration. It is as though the mere act of naming the stage caused a change in the way we thought about and acted toward our young. Prior to the official recognition of adolescence, for example, only 10 percent of the population attended high school. Today, more than 90 percent does. Within two decades of naming adolescence, public high school, or secondary school, became a common experience in the United States. Over the next several years, innovative programs began to spring up across the country. Youth sports, music, dance, drama, and even religious youth programs provided opportunities for teens. These were originally designed and structured with a common goal: to nurture emerging adolescents by providing systems, structures, and activities to help them grow into adulthood by means of the smoothest, most productive transition possible.
Consider how this new support worked in the middle decades of the twentieth century. Educators, for instance, may have required homework, but rarely did it place an overly weighty burden on students’ schedules. Rather, it was a way to encourage students to spend time assimilating the information they had received in class. Girls and boys were taught dance and social skills in social settings. They also had opportunities to experience music, drama, and fine art both within and outside the school context. While these and other nurturing structures and movements were beneficial in many ways, a subtle change soon took place. These structures eventually distanced adults from the specific needs of adolescents.
Fast forward to today’s environment, by the time adolescents enter high school, nearly every one has been subjected to a decade or more of adult-driven and adult-controlled programs, systems, and institutions that are primarily concerned with adults’ agendas, needs, and dreams. Take these examples as evidence of how far we have drifted in our commitment to the young:
What is interesting is that many adults will highlight these and other activities as proof of their commitment to the young. “I drive my kid to all of these activities. I sacrificed my own life, work, avocation, and enjoyment in order to take the kids to soccer games, concerts, and competitions.” This statement is in and of itself yet another subtle form of abandonment. As Madeline Levine has observed, “Achievement pressure often comes from parents who are overinvolved in how well their children perform and inadequately involved in monitoring these same children in other areas. We can be overinvolved in the wrong things, and uninvolved in the right things, both at the same time.” This kind of misplaced involvement, says Levine, is “startling and unproductive,” putting adolescents in a place where they are so micromanaged on the outside that they are “inadvertently deprived of the opportunity to develop an inside.”
We have evolved to the point where we believe driving is support, being active is love, and providing any and every opportunity is selfless nurture. We are a culture that has forgotten how to be together. We have lost the ability to spend unstructured down time. Rather than being with children in creative activities at home or setting them free to enjoy semisupervised activities such as “play,” we as a culture have looked to outside organizations and structured agendas to fill their time and dictate their lives. The problem is not simply organized activities or sports. It is the cumulative effect that children experience as they grow up in today’s social structure. Sports, music, dance, drama, Scouts, and even faith-related programs are all guilty of ignoring the developmental needs of each individual young person in favor of the organization’s goals. Add to this the increasing amount of homework being assigned to students at younger and younger ages. The systemic pressure on American children is immense. Too many of us actually enjoy the athletic, cultural, or artistic babysitting service provided by those organizations. Even with the best of intentions, the way we raise, train, and even parent our children today exhibits attitudes and behaviors that are simply subtle forms of parental abandonment.
The shift has taken place not only in how our systems react to the demands of a particular enterprise but also in the focus of those in charge. In general, the good of the unique individual has been supplanted by a commitment to the good of the ______ (fill in the blank: team, school, community, class, or organization). Today, even very young children learn that they are only as valuable as their ability to contribute. Rarely are youth activities, especially group activities such as sports and dance, safe places that allow children to explore latent potential, develop appreciation for a sport or activity, or even simply enjoy being involved. Perhaps a “slow” five-year-old (relative to other five-year-olds) will always be “slower” than his or her peers, but does that mean the child should be denied the enjoyment, encouragement, and full participation in a sport? This is just one setting among dozens in which, from an early age, children learn that there are some who are special—pretty, smart, athletic—and some who are not. By the time these students reach middle adolescence, they show signs of the rejection they have been subjected to throughout their lives. As one community leader of youth sports told me, “They have to learn this lesson sometime—that they either are or aren’t an athlete. It is better to find out when they are young.” I wondered, “Better for whom?”
The voices are few that encourage society to focus on the individual adolescent when it comes to the creation of systems and structures. While youth mentoring programs have arisen in part as a response to this unfortunate state of affairs, little research has been done on their effectiveness. Statistics have, however, demonstrated the negative impact resulting from mentors who don’t keep their commitments to their kids, such as “drops in self-worth and perceived scholastic competence” and “increases in alcohol use.” All of this underscores the need for adults to be highly committed to each individual kid, no matter how difficult or delicate the relationship may seem. In general, there is a tremendous momentum of self-protection and self-promotion for institutions and organizations (and even individuals), and this makes it increasingly difficult for even the best teacher, coach, or youth worker to “waste” the time it takes to walk alongside an individual adolescent, much less create an environment in which each one is uniquely nurtured and led. A child who seems relatively slower, distracted, insecure, or otherwise handicapped (according to the dictates of the organization) has little chance of being considered anything other than one needy but incompetent face among many.
One day when I was working with a teacher in preparation for substituting in her class, she illustrated this perfectly, if unintentionally: “My morning class has three or four great kids,” she said, “but the afternoon class is full of average kids, and are they ever a pain.” This comment not only struck me as odd but also deeply disturbed me. Although she had been a teacher for only five or six years, she had already reached a point of hanging an “average” label on several fourteen- and fifteen-year-olds she did not like or approve of. She obviously had never considered (or had simply stopped caring about) the sad fact that many of these kids came from difficult family settings, were not recognized athletically, could not sing or draw or write, and had been consistently reminded of such things since they were young.
Some children and adolescents rise to the top early, whether through a unique skill, a quick wit or tongue, or an attractive look, style, or quality. Some learn how to cope with abandonment by adopting a countercultural style or persona. They discover, again often at a very young age, that they do not have the ability to receive attention in a positive way, yet they have an inner desire to be noticed. Both extremes, the achievers and the challenging youth, are known by teachers and the administration and are therefore given the greatest amount of energy and attention. The fact that teachers I talked to knew well those who were the stars as well as those who were the troublemakers led me to the first stark observation I made during this study: there is a third category. The “middle” student, who has not, for a variety of reasons, taken the steps necessary to be unusually liked and coddled or to fight and rebel, is an almost unnoticed person. There are far more of these middle students than there are students in either of the other two categories. The sharp and attractive and the rebellious and countercultural make up only 20 percent of the population, and yet they receive 80 percent of adults’ attention.
This observation led to another that was even more startling: those who were noticed intuitively knew that they were noticed because of something they produced, displayed, or created. I tried to find and talk to the “cream of the crop,” the sharpest students, to see if they were indeed what they appeared to be. I wanted to know if they were playacting to gain attention. The closer I got to those who occupied the upper tier, the more I realized that these kids wore their uniqueness—intelligence, athleticism, wittiness, or respectability—like a cloak. Underneath the surface, even for the top students, there is a great fear of being found out and losing everything they have worked so hard to attain. “I have to get the grades and play sports,” one senior male student confided. “I have nothing else.” (This from a student held in the highest esteem by the faculty, carrying a 4.0 grade point average, a starter in a major sport, and well liked and respected by everyone on campus.) Indeed, some of these bright and talented students even seek other—sometimes harmful—ways of standing out from the crowd. Cultural trends researcher Walt Mueller quotes an email sent to him by a student:
I come from an upper-middle-class home. I’m a straight-A student, class president, and an overachiever in every way. I don’t really know why I am anorexic, but I think it’s partly because I thought that if I got really sick, people would pay attention to me more and like me. I know my parents love me, but they think I am so bright and capable that I don’t need help or attention anymore. I just want people to realize I do not have a perfect life, and I am lonely.
No adolescent is immune from the need to “play at” various roles to survive this phase of life. As Paul Willis observes, “For young people, passing through adolescence means that they are in one way or another marginalized.” In American culture, this marginalization begins at an early age in nearly every system originally designed to serve, nurture, guide, and protect the young. A careful look at such systems—such as the classroom or athletics—reveals that a shift has occurred over the past forty to fifty years. Organizations, structures, and institutions that were originally concerned with children’s care, welfare, and development have become less interested in individual nurture and development and more interested in institutional perpetuation (or the competitive, even pathological, needs of the adult in charge). Today’s adolescents have indeed been abandoned.
Perhaps you are not yet convinced. Many reviewers who read early drafts of this chapter, primarily graduate students but professional adults as well, could see my general perspective but were not wholly convinced of the pervasiveness of this assertion. One in particular encouraged me to offer “oodles of quotes and scenarios” that would convince readers by their sheer volume. I have chosen to take a slightly different tack. I am starting with the assumption that midadolescents are where they are because of systemic societal abandonment. Throughout the book, I present the specifics of how this plays out in various areas of life. At this point, I am not concerned that you buy the notion of abandonment but that you are open to the possibility.
Abandonment by Internal Systems and Relationships
The notion of systemic abandonment is not limited to those external systems originally designed to nurture, protect, and help shape a unique adolescent. Another form of abandonment, perhaps more subtle yet far more insidious, has occurred that has had a devastating effect on the adolescent psyche and landscape. Adolescents have suffered the loss of the safe relationships and intimate settings that served as the primary nurturing community for those traveling the path from child to adult. The most obvious example of this is in the family. The postmodern family is often so concerned about the needs, struggles, and issues of parents that the emotional and developmental needs of the children go largely unmet. Add to this trend the rarity of extended family available to the vast majority of adolescents, the deemphasizing of the importance of marriage, and the lack of healthy relationships with adults as friends and mentors, and it is easy to see why today’s adolescent faces an internal crisis of unprecedented scope.
The loss of meaningful relationships with adults has been the most devastating to developing adolescents. Because midadolescents have not had enough life experience to understand fully the accompanying sense of loneliness and isolation they feel, few could articulate their experience specifically as “loss” in my study. But the reality of the experience oozed out of nearly every student. And in discussions with midadolescents across the country, not one disagreed with this bleak assessment. When feeling safe enough to admit it, every student I talked to acknowledged that loneliness is a central experience. In decrying the panic in the lives of young girls in the midst of contemporary culture, Mary Pipher provides a wake-up call with her poignant summation of how parents so easily miss what is happening with their children: “To paraphrase a Stevie Smith poem about swimming in the sea, ‘they are not waving, they are drowning.’ And just when they most need help, they are unable to take their parent’s hands.” They feel this way about all adults who they perceive are not there for them.
The Consequences of Abandonment
During the course of this study, I was invited to be a panelist for the city of Glendale, California. I was one of four people administering the final interview with the top three candidates for the position of youth outreach coordinator, a position aimed at serving teenagers who were at risk for getting into trouble. I had one question that was designed to tell me how well these candidates understood the world of adolescents: “Describe for us an at-risk kid.” Each candidate was extremely well qualified. Two had master’s degrees, and the third had an experience-rich résumé. When we got to my question, not one of them hesitated or even blinked. Each was emphatic, and each responded identically: “Why, all of them! Every single young person who has grown up in America is only one major event or catastrophe away from falling over the edge into what most would call at-risk.”
Chris Frappier, an investigator with Vermont’s state public defender’s office, recently spoke out against what has happened to adolescents in a culture of abandonment:
So our kids, our children, who feel lost, disenfranchised—they join [gangs]! And why not? . . . I mean, look at the communities in this state that wage war on their youth. You’ve got Vergennes kicking kids out of the park. You’ve got Woodstock banning skateboarding. . . . What I’m seeing in recent years is the total and complete alienation of youth. And it is not coming from them; it is coming from the adults who aren’t bothering to reach out to them. And it is terrifying.
Many people who work directly with a broad spectrum of adolescents have come to similar conclusions.
But it is not only these practitioners who have come to such conclusions. There is also evidence—empirical, verifiable, and quantifiable data—that points to the notion that adolescence today is more difficult, complex, and treacherous than in previous generations. The increasing duration of the adolescent journey, a cultural psychosocial invention, makes the consequences of this systemic abandonment all the more apparent. In a major study of one thousand children and adolescents, for example, the majority reported that the time they spent with parents was often hurried. Even those who did not feel this way lacked evidence of the depth and substance of the child-parent interchange that is essential for healthy adolescent development.
This situation is exacerbated when an adolescent is a member of a conflicted family system. The greater the self-absorption of the parents with their own problems and struggles, the less aware they are of their children’s social and developmental needs. When there is conflict in a family system, parents are more likely to rely on a limited (or misguided) perception of their children’s maturity, which in turn leads parents to depend on their adolescent children for guidance and support—a circumstance that greatly increases the pressure on adolescents. They are forced not only to deal with the pain and fear associated with losing the stability of the most significant system in their lives but also to engage in parental conflict in a way that short-circuits their ability to meet their own needs arising from the crisis. Research has consistently shown that parental conflict forces children to sacrifice their own developmental needs to meet the needs of their parents—needs that they are, needless to say, ill equipped to meet. In fact, they are often pushed into taking mediating roles when things get tough. Young children are even forced to take sides in parental conflict or to offer advice to a struggling parent. This abdication of parental responsibility has devastating consequences for children who must prematurely look after their own needs.
In their book Generation on Hold, James E. Côté and Anton L. Allahar speak about adults who are “excessively self-interested” and note that “as the identity of adult members becomes ambiguous, they are less able to guide the young through the self-discovery process that is an integral part of forming an identity. Consequently, they may feel alienated from their juniors, and be less likely to welcome them into adult society. This ambivalence could precipitate a crisis among the young.” Similarly, Carla Barnhill, writing in Books & Culture on “How Good Parents Give Up on Their Teens,” describes the natural push and pull that goes on between parents and their children. She details how parents who do not maintain their rightful and necessary role of supervisor and authority create stress for children when it comes to understanding themselves. When even their souls are a commodity to be shopped out to someone else, it’s not surprising that teenagers feel their parents are too busy for them or unsure of their ability to parent. Teenagers can smell fear. As soon as they’ve sensed they’ve gained control, as soon as they believe that adults are afraid to challenge them, it’s human nature for them to push until they find the boundary. They may complain about the limits parents set on them, but several studies, including one from the National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse at Columbia University, show that teens desperately need and want the sense of control and safety that healthy boundaries provide.
Adolescents notice when they do not get to spend enough time with parents and other adults. In facilitating a parent/youth event for a community group in Seattle last fall, I asked students to compile a list of what they wanted adults to know about them. One of the most telling statements they recorded was how they perceived time with significant adults: “We spend no time with adults from junior high on—maybe fifteen minutes every other day is the best we ever get.” It is as though adults don’t understand that time spent with significant adults, especially parents, provides the most important environment for healthy adolescent development. But even in the best families, spending time together is a struggle. As Hersch states, “‘In all societies since the beginning of time, adolescents have learned to become adults by observing, imitating and interacting with grown-ups around them,’ write Mihaly Csikzentmihalyi and Reed Larson in Being Adolescent. ‘It is therefore startling how little time [modern] teenagers spend in the company of adults.’ In their study Csikzentmihalyi and Larson found that adolescents spent only 4.8 percent of their time with their parents and only 2 percent with adults who were not their parents.”
There are at least two consequences of parental and adult abandonment. First, the adolescent journey is lengthened, because no one is available to help move the developmental process along. Joseph Allen and Claudia Worrell Allen observe that “the extension of adolescence has expanded so boundlessly that many teens no longer have any realistic sense of what they’re ultimately preparing for, or even that they are preparing for something.” This applies even to those youth who appear to be healthy and successful but who nonetheless “wake up in their mid-twenties clueless about how to get a job, manage money, cook, or live on their own.” Second, adolescents know that they are essentially on their own, for “aloneness is the enduring result of abandonment.”
Surprise! Adolescents Want Adults
Contrary to what most adults may think, middle adolescents want significant relationships with adults who care about them. When asked about this in various settings—one-on-one, in informal groups, or even in a large convention setting—students confirmed this assertion, and most seemed almost eager to have an adult friend. The difficulty comes when they attempt to reconcile this need with their perception of the lack of trustworthiness in adults. When I spent time with a group of teachers, one (who was nearing retirement) said, “They have got to learn to come halfway! I am sick of trying to build trust with kids and then have them reject my overtures.” That comment strikes at the heart of the issue of kids relating to adults—they want and need adults, but because many (or even some) of the adults they have known over the years have participated in abandoning them, they have little trust in any adult (and for most midadolescents, this includes their parents, at least for a season). A middle adolescent, then, simply will not come halfway—why should they risk more disappointment? An adult who wants to connect but who demands that midadolescents come halfway only serves to confirm the mistrust they feel and deepen the divide between adolescents and adults. To the midadolescent, this attitude is yet another confirmation of abandonment.
Due to the midadolescent’s recognition that for most of his or her life the norm has been a lack of authentic concern and care at almost every turn, few are able to easily trust an adult who does reach out. While some people may claim that the way we treat adolescents in this culture is similar to how adolescents have generally been treated over the ages and across cultures, both my observations and those of others who have studied the adolescent world up close offer a vastly different view. Systemic abandonment has created an environment in which midadolescents believe they are truly on their own. As a result, they go underground; they pull away from the adult world. This causes a uniquely ordered society, a world beneath, a world in which rules, expectations, a value system, and even social norms are created to maintain an environment in which the middle adolescent can achieve the single most important goal of this stage of life: survival.
If adults cannot be trusted to be authentic, committed, and selfless advocates, then the only alternative available to adolescents is to flee. With early adolescents, families still hold the greatest possible hope of providing the care, protection, and support that kids need. But with the development of abstract thought in later adolescence comes the heightened ability to recognize the complexity of the world and to be able to read mixed motives and inauthentic or inconsistent treatment from adults and adult institutions. Middle adolescents band together to create their own world where they hold the keys to dealing with their perception of abandonment and their need for relational stability, protection, social guidance, and belonging. As Hersch describes it, “Their dependence on each other fulfills the universal human longing for community, and inadvertently cements the notion of a tribe apart. More than a group of peers, it becomes in isolation a society with its own values, ethics, rules, worldview, rites of passage, worries, joys, and momentum. It becomes teacher, advisor, entertainer, challenger, nurturer, inspirer, and sometimes destroyer.”
When I was able to get close enough, to be trusted enough, to get a glimpse of life in this world, I did not hear a few voices crying out. I heard an overwhelming chorus of longing to be cared for and to be taken seriously. The collective adolescent society may appear impenetrable and may even be a powerful social force to be reckoned with, but beyond the perceived hostility that surrounds the midadolescent is a fragile soul hidden behind a sophisticated layer of defense and protection. Even the most “solid” students confessed that life is far darker, far more violent, far more difficult, and far more tiring than adults, including their parents, realize.
Conclusion and Musings
“They have no clue, Dr. Clark.”
This comment about adults in general came from a beautiful junior in high school who maintains a 4.0 grade point average, is an all-league volleyball player, and is one of the more well-liked and respected students on campus.
“But you seem like you are managing it all pretty well.”
“Yeah,” she said, “I’m pretty good at it, huh?”
What she meant was, “I’m good at playing the game, maintaining the show, and somehow surviving the obstacles.”
My conclusions in this chapter may sound depressing, and it may seem far too sweeping an assessment to make, for many middle adolescents are able to overcome the general condition of the whole and do rather well dancing between adapting to the expectations of the adult world and maintaining the relational integrity necessary to connect to the world beneath. This said, many young people are one step away from the abyss of isolation and despair. One articulate junior reminded me of this with a poem.
You come into the world alone,
You go out into the world alone,
In life you have no friends.
In sum, systemic abandonment by institutions and adults who are in positions originally designed to care for adolescents has created a culture of isolation. It is into this world of retreat we must go, determined to listen, to see, and ultimately to understand the circumstances that adult abandonment has helped to foster. By the time children, even the successful ones, reach high school and middle adolescence, they are aware of the fact that for most of their lives they have been pushed, prodded, and molded to become a person whose value rests in his or her ability to serve someone else’s agenda. Whether they experience it from a coach, a schoolteacher, a parent, a music teacher, or a Sunday school counselor, midadolescents intuitively believe that nearly every adult they have encountered has been subtly out to get something from them. When this awareness begins to take root during middle adolescence, it leads to frustration, anger, and a sense of betrayal. These feelings drive the experience defining middle adolescence and create the perceived need for the world beneath.
In Alexander Wolff’s surprisingly critical front-page story on youth sports in Sports Illustrated, he subtly inserted the following line into his conclusion: “To answer the question of whether we believe high school to be a precious interval in a young life or some Scholastic Fantastic stopover on the way to the Show is to learn a lot about who we are.” This poignant and insightful statement was so cleverly woven into the fabric of his article that its power may have easily been missed, but Wolff’s challenge to look in the mirror when trying to understand our young bears repeating. High school life in America left behind the idea of being “a precious interval in a young life” long ago. Unfortunately, few adults have taken the time or had the courage to look closely at what we left behind. Middle adolescents understand their abandonment and therefore spend their youthful energy attempting to find a safe place from which to live out one of the most difficult and challenging developmental periods they will ever face.
The late football coach Abe Lemons once remarked, “You don’t coach seniors. You just tolerate them.” From a midadolescent’s perspective, far too many adults treat them in much the same way. Yet there are exceptions. I have witnessed adults who are bucking the trend of societal abandonment. Put simply, this is my hope—that more adults, especially adults who are in positions to turn the tide of abandonment, would strive to change the systems and structures that have caused collective anguish for our young. As we work together, we can make a difference.
