1: The Changing Face Of Adolescence
1
the changing face of adolescence
These kids are no different from when I was a kid. They are just more indulged today. And they have more options—from sports to money to the internet. Kids today are just a more spoiled breed of us when we were young.
high school teacher
This assessment was volunteered by a veteran teacher I had gotten to know over the course of my time on the high school campus. Occasionally, he would ask me how my research was going. On one occasion, he made this definitive declaration. Once he said it, and because of the way he said it, I knew it would not be easy to convince him that, indeed, things had changed—and changed a great deal.
Through numerous conversations since, and by immersing myself in literature related to the study of adolescence from a variety of disciplines, I have become aware that many adults have a similar view of adolescents. The tune of accepted folk wisdom goes something like this: “Kids (i.e., adolescents) have always been kids and have always been a part of the social landscape. Things may change on the surface, but teenagers have always been with us and have always pushed the extremes of adult society. They are basically the same now as they were thousands of years ago. Only the styles have changed.” This perception is regularly supported in articles, stories, media reports, and books about the young. Even the term kids can mean many things. It can refer to any age group from pre-elementary school children to those in their mid to late twenties (such as when a new teacher confided in me, “I’m as much a kid as the guys in my class!”). When referring to the young, adults rarely attempt to distinguish between those who are just leaving the psychosocial and relational confines of childhood and entering that strange and wholly different experience known as early adolescence, and those who are in graduate school living off their parents and “trying to figure out what to do with my life.” It is all too easy in our culture not to ask the question, what is the difference between adolescents today and teenagers of the past? Instead, we fall back on the caricature that kids are kids, and they have always been kids. But is this true?
At times, adults attempt to reach back into antiquity to add credence to this characterization. Socrates, for example, is often erroneously credited with this comment on how the young of his day were viewed: “Our youth love luxury. They have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for their elders, and love to chatter in places of exercise. Children are now tyrants, not the servants of their household. They no longer rise when their elders enter the room. They contradict their parents, chatter before company, gobble up their food, and tyrannize their teachers.”
Augustine, bishop of Hippo in North Africa (fourth century AD), is known for his philandering and “adolescent” lifestyle prior to his conversion to Christianity. Augustine himself described his teenage years in his Confessions: “I had a period of leisure, living at home with my parents and not doing any work at all, the brambles of lust grew up right over my head.”
These and a handful of other similar quotations have been cited to add credibility to the notion that young people throughout history have always been basically the same. The attempt is to show that adolescents of antiquity were essentially the same as adolescents of the 1940s and the early 2000s, and that the issues facing adolescents and their responses to them are universal. Indeed, Eddie Haskell, the prototypical deceiving and conniving adolescent of the late-1950s and early-1960s television show Leave It to Beaver, is but one example from the past of a teenager who would be no different today. Add to that James Dean (Rebel without a Cause) in the 1950s, Arthur Fonzarelli (The Fonz from Happy Days) in the 1970s, and even the rebellion showcased in the movie The Breakfast Club in the 1980s, and it is easy to see that in the minds of adults, adolescence has not changed much over the decades or even the centuries. It is for this reason that today’s teenagers—particularly with all the time they spend creating and maintaining profiles on social networking websites—are often deemed to be “all about me, me, me,” even though research has revealed that such activities certainly “need not imply narcissistic self-absorption” but are more likely an extension of peer-group relationships.
This book contends that adolescence is a fundamentally different thing than it was even thirty years ago. There is, in fact, nearly universal support for the idea that adolescence as we know it was a cultural invention of Western society that was first noticed around 1900. Numerous anecdotal narratives across time and cultures depict characteristics of what we call adolescence. The examples often cited (such as the ones above), however, represent extremely unusual exceptions to the record of civilization. Citing these and other examples from antiquity to assert that the adolescent experience in contemporary American culture is equivalent to the experience of teenagers in ancient Greece is participation in a reductionism that is dangerous at best. For example, Socrates’s argument, mentioned above, is not even true to the original text and, moreover, was not concerned with the young but with the excesses of the entire society. In more recent decades, media depictions of rebellious and insolent youth have offered a clear distinction between the “good” kids and those who lived on the fringes of the youth culture rather than the mainstream, like Eddie Haskell in Leave It to Beaver and Happy Days’ The Fonz. Yet society’s view of teenagers has been subtly shifting over the last several decades to where many adults view teenagers in general as insolent, difficult, and arrogant. Even while this perception has gained momentum, there still is this fundamental perspective that kids have always been the way we now see them.
Throughout time and in every society, the dominant culture has seen the young as its most sacred treasure. Because of this, the human life span has historically been understood as having only two primary stages: childhood and adulthood. Children were viewed as a precious and nurtured resource and as such were guided into their place in the world by those responsible to care for them in their family and community. Once a child had completed the rituals, rites of passage, and training experiences necessary to be accepted into interdependent relationships within the adult community, he or she was fully assimilated as an adult member of that community. This process, called the rite of passage by Arnold van Gennep in 1908, had three elements: separation from the old status; transition, usually with a specified ritual; and incorporation into the adult community. For over a century, formalized processes of incorporating the young into adulthood have been devalued, especially in the United States.
First labeled and identified around the beginning of the twentieth century, the span between childhood and adulthood, beginning with puberty and ending with the assuming of full adult responsibilities or even economic independence, was approximately three years. The average age of menarche, the most common measurable marker for the beginning of adolescence in a society, was, prior to 1900, fourteen years, and a person began to assume an adult role in society as young as sixteen. Many accepted developmental theories, created primarily in the mid-twentieth century, tend to view the adolescent journey as a relatively stable, predictable, and orderly, though sometimes difficult, process. For the past two or three decades, however, researchers and theorists attempting to understand human development more fully have challenged many of these orderly themes and stages of development. Postmodern culture has also tossed a proverbial wrench into the gears of developmental theory. In particular, variables such as shifts in cultural values and structure; changes in the family system; new research into peer relations, gender, and ethnic uniqueness; and new ways of thinking about morality, character, and ethics have become increasingly important in describing the nature of adolescence. Some researchers believe that culture has changed so quickly that the developmental, societal, and relational needs of children have been neglected in recent decades and that by the time children reach adolescence they have been left on their own to attempt to navigate the path toward adulthood.
Adolescence—What Is It?
Many adults not only struggle with the notion of changing adolescence but also have a hard time describing what an adolescent is. I have experimented with defining an adolescent in a variety of settings with adults, and with few exceptions, when a group of adults are asked to vote on whether teenagers are big, more sophisticated children or inexperienced young adults, they will invariably be split fifty-fifty, generally with parents of older adolescents voting the former and parents of young children the latter. Society has not provided much help, for the inherent ambiguity and relative imprecision of the term adolescent causes us to fall back on more easily measured and therefore identifiable terms such as teenager and pre-teen or even blatantly generic terms such as youth. Adolescence has been relegated to an amorphous transitionary phase of life. Most people see those in this general age range as being “sort of adults and sort of kids.”
This foggy view of the period of adolescence has given rise to much adult ambivalence and even to systemic neglect. We simply have not agreed on who or what we are dealing with, and it is therefore easier to turn a blind eye to the unique needs of this population. In spite of the rhetoric and wishful thinking that adolescent life has not changed all that much, the vast majority of adults believe that there is something different going on in the world of today’s adolescents. In hundreds of casual and formal conversations I have had with adults, when it comes to nailing down what is truly happening with young people in our society, nearly everyone agreed that the rapid and in many ways severe changes in the last few decades have created new challenges, issues, and dilemmas for adolescents. But what those challenges and issues are and how they impact adolescents remain unclear. On top of this, many adults are not clear about the most fundamental question of all: Are adolescents big children (a view that brings with it a more or less clear set of assumptions) or little adults (a view that moves us into another set of assumptions and practices)? Or are they a blend of both? As Frederick Buechner puts it, “The opaque glance and the pimples. The fancy new nakedness they’re all dressed up in with no place to go. The eyes full of secrets they have a strong hunch everybody is on to. The shadowed brow. Being not quite a child and not quite a grown-up either is hard work, and they look it. Living in two worlds at once is no picnic.”
While we may implicitly affirm that adolescence is an in-between-but-not-quite place, this view may not tell the whole story. Developmental theorists have acknowledged for decades what the general populace has yet to comprehend, much less embrace: Adolescence is not a blend of both child and adult, nor is it an expanded phase of either. Adolescence is a unique phase of life that must be understood and dealt with on its own merits.
A generally accepted definition of adolescence has been summarized by developmental psychologist John Santrock. He calls adolescence “the period of life between childhood and adulthood. . . . [The process] lasts from roughly 10–13 years of age and ends at 18–22 years of age. [However,] defining when adolescence ends is not an easy task. It has been said that adolescence begins in biology and ends in culture.” Santrock offers as tight a definition as the phenomenon allows, for the entire adolescent experience fluctuates constantly and deviates greatly according to such variables as culture, locale, and even familial stability and makeup. A standard academic definition of adolescence comes down to “two main components—separateness and self-assertion.” Other scholars add to this drive for uniqueness (“separateness”) and quest for personal autonomy (“self-assertion”) a desire to move toward the discovery of community, belonging, and interdependence. Adolescence, then, is a psychosocial, independent search for a unique identity or separateness, with the end goals being a certain knowledge of who one is in relation to others, a willingness to take responsibility for who one is becoming, and a realized commitment to live with others in community.
Another important factor in understanding the nature of adolescence has to do with brain development. A recent radio report noted a significant aspect of this: “The nerve cells that connect teenagers’ frontal lobes with the rest of their brains are sluggish. Teenagers don’t have as much of the fatty coating called myelin, or ‘white matter’ that adults have in this area.” Neurologist Frances Jensen contends that teenagers “often seem so maddeningly self-centered” simply because that’s the particular developmental phase their brains are in: “They aren’t yet at that place where they’re thinking about—or capable, necessarily, of thinking about the effects of their behavior on other people. That requires insight”—which, as the report goes on to state, “requires . . . a fully connected frontal lobe.” Particularly because it is still in such a crucial state of development, the teenage brain is “tuned to be responsive to everything in their environment” and is “wired to form new connections” in response. This is valuable information for us to consider as we reflect on the way teens are often regarded. Joseph Allen and Claudia Worrell Allen note, “It seems we humans have a strong, persistent bias to attribute behavior to innate qualities of individuals even when the objective evidence that their environment is shaping their actions is overwhelming. . . . This bias is at its most persistent and most dangerous when applied to groups that lack the social status or verbal skill needed to articulate just how much they are affected by their environments. Groups like adolescents.”
Some pressing questions arise from these observations. First of all, what is the difference between the ways kids’ brains are being formed today and how they were formed in previous generations? How have shifting environmental factors affected the development of our teens’ brains? As we did not have MRIs forty years ago, it is impossible to answer these questions definitively. However, calling attention to research conducted by Bogdan Draganski and his colleagues in 2004 on the dramatic way the human brain is influenced by its environment—even to the point where the simple act of learning to juggle can quickly change the structure of the brain—Allen and Allen rightly wonder, “If a few weeks of juggling practice can change the brain, what can years of passivity and overprotection do?”
The Timing and Duration of Adolescence
To understand adolescence, it is important to define its parameters—where it begins and ends and what it involves. Using Santrock’s definition—that adolescence ends when culture affirms one’s entrance into the mainstream of adulthood—we can say that adolescence is the journey from biological adulthood to societal adulthood. This is the process sometimes referred to as “second individuation.” The emerging adolescent, embarking on a new journey in development, seeks to assert his or her distinctiveness and move toward an internal locus of control, while at the same time remaining relationally connected as an ongoing member of the family system and the community. While there is no standardized definition of the term, individuation has, for many, become the central issue of the adolescent process and therefore the overall motivating task of adolescence.
As noted above, the oft-cited beginning point of adolescence is puberty. There is debate, however, over when the exact physiological changes of puberty begin, and this is even harder to determine for boys than for girls. It is relatively accepted that the age of puberty for girls has been slowly dropping, from fourteen-and-a-half years old a century ago to as early as twelve years old today. The American Medical Association, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control, and the majority of social scientists report this as demonstrable fact.
When culture affirms that someone has individuated in terms of identity, is willing to take responsibility for his or her life and choices, and has entered interdependently into the community and adult relationships, that person is said to be an adult. This, then, defines the end point or completion of adolescence. Interestingly, almost no social scientist or developmental theorist uses legal age as a reference point for the end of adolescence. Because the process is psychosocial, chronological factors such as readiness for marriage, driving, smoking cigarettes, voting, or drinking alcohol are not considerations when defining the end point of adolescence.
The process is about how one sees oneself and thereby relates to others. Nearly everyone today who ventures to define when adolescence ends states that it is somewhere in the middle to late twenties. According to a recent study by the MacArthur Foundation Research Network on Transitions to Adulthood, “people between 20 and 34 are taking longer to finish their educations, establish themselves in careers, marry, have children and become financially independent.” Allen and Allen assert that “twenty-five is becoming the new fifteen,” and Robert Epstein laments that “for the first time in human history, we have artificially extended childhood well past puberty. . . . Somewhere along the line, we lost sight of—and buried—the potential of our teens.” While proposed responses to this issue may differ significantly, the phenomenon of extended adolescence itself is widely acknowledged.
This ambiguity bumps up against everyday life when decisions have to be made regarding when a person is an adult or a still-developing adolescent. Unfortunately, at times governmental agencies and systems do not seem capable of or even interested in wading through the complex issues that emerge when someone clearly is a midadolescent, behaves like a midadolescent, and yet participates in behaviors that have adult consequences. This is but one stark example of what we all must ultimately face as we consider the changing adolescent. There are countless other examples, many of which I experienced and are in this book, that demonstrate the need for adults to wrestle with the facts of our changing culture when it comes to caring for the young.
What about Now?
“When I was in high school . . .”
Throughout this study, I must have heard this preamble several dozen times. I did look for ways to stoke the fires of critique and dismay buried beneath the sheen of adult compassion for the young, but it rarely took much effort to get adults going on a critically laced, negative comparison between today’s adolescents and themselves. Inevitably and without much prodding, the focus would turn from what I was seeing to what they were convinced of, as evidenced by the following comments:
Although academics argue over whether empirically verifiable statistics can help us to understand what is going on in the world of adolescents, when pressed, most adults intuitively recognize that the world is different from when most of them were in high school. I have presented my findings and observations in numerous settings, and as those in attendance reflected on the overwhelming evidence, rarely did anyone reject outright the premise that things have indeed changed, and changed significantly. Along with this admission, however, consistently emerged an attempt to rationalize or at least explain away the severity and the impact of the changes. Almost always something or someone was to blame for the changes: the media, parents, the educational system, Vietnam, post–cold war society, a lack of religious conviction, a loss of family values, or a myriad of other demonizing forces. But there was never a doubt that change had indeed occurred and that today’s adolescents are clearly a different breed.
What Has Happened in the World of Adolescents?
Within the span of a few short decades, adolescence changed from a relatively brief two-to-three-year period to a five-year process with two distinct stages: early and late adolescence. The reasons for this change are beyond the scope of this book, but somewhere in the late 1960s, a massive social upheaval occurred that altered the social landscape of all segments of American society. There are different labels for the changes that took place and several opposing theories regarding why it happened, but for the purposes of this study, I will simply affirm that this was a watershed time for our culture in how it affected adolescence as a stage of the life span.
The culturewide social shift that took place during this time influenced the young both directly and indirectly, and it has significant implications for our understanding of the adolescent landscape. The evolving changes of the twentieth century directly affected how social systems, structures, organizations, and institutions nurture the young, and they indirectly influenced the developmental processes relating to the psyche and inner security of adolescents.
External Impact of a Changing Culture
During the early and middle decades of the twentieth century, especially during the 1950s and 1960s, adolescents enjoyed a newly affirmed status in the dominant culture. There was, at least in terms of popular rhetoric, an identifiable “subculture,” sometimes referred to as the “teenage culture.” Society was still orderly, especially compared to today’s standards, and yet teenagers were increasingly granted a certified cultural niche that was generally embraced by the adult culture. Certain elements of this trend, of course, were not wholly endorsed: James Dean (Rebel without a Cause), Elvis Presley, long hair, and even the Beatles still caused a stir with many adults. But for the most part, these were relatively minor distractions as the “teenager” became a vibrant, exciting aspect of American life and culture.
The turbulent 1960s saw a marked increase in social unrest and upheaval. The decade began with an escalation of the cold war that nearly erupted in a global nuclear exchange. In just a few years, three popular and powerful American leaders were gunned down, displaying our vulnerability and shattering our sense of social cohesion, control, and power. First, John F. Kennedy was assassinated, then Martin Luther King Jr., followed almost immediately by the likely next president, Robert Kennedy. The Vietnam War became decisively polarizing, primarily along age lines. The ugliness of personal and institutional racism and the resultant fight for civil rights showed the underbelly of an American national narrative that was painful for everyone. These were dark and frightening days for all Americans, and a tremendous sense of confusion, societal insecurity, and cultural instability spilled into nearly every institution, social structure, and relationship in the nation. The fights over hair length and music were but symptoms of a much more sweeping social movement: the idyllic American image of post–World War II days was being ripped apart, and there was little to replace it.
Out of this chaos came political scandal, a national recession, and ultimately a country trying to take a collective deep breath from all the upheaval. By the middle of the 1970s, we had settled into a rhythm marked by a societal philosophy that conveyed that it was up to each person to make sense of the social fragmentation, its mantra being “Live and let live.” We had embarked on a path where the rules, norms, and values of society were left up to the individual. The 1980s came to be known as the “me” decade, in which the only thing that truly mattered was recapturing the American ideal of radical individualism and independence. The 1990s followed with the collapse of what we thought was our last identifiable enemy, the Soviet Union, thus removing the last remaining reason for a national metanarrative. We experienced a powerfully expanding economy, which created a greater number of jobs and opportunities for a wide range of people but also threw us once again into a catatonic state of false security and independent arrogance. The media took a prominent place in our daily lives, its adolescent-oriented messages focusing on the temporary pursuits of leisure, comfort, and living for the moment.
During this time, the biggest change affecting adolescents was the shift in focus for adult systems and institutions. Until the late 1960s, adult-led organizations and structures were primarily focused on caring for the individual and corporate needs of adolescents. Youth sports, activities, education, and even religious movements saw each young person as a gift to be cared for and cherished. But as society began to unravel, adults found themselves trying to find their own safe place, a haven of security and rest. No longer was there energy and health available for giving to others. Instead, adults waged a fight for emotional and relational survival, and this in turn spilled over into the developmental longings of adolescents.
For youth-directed organizations, institutions, and systems, the shift in focus was not immediate; in fact, it evolved over several decades. But as society in general moved from being a relatively stable and cohesive adult community intent on caring for the needs of the young to a free-for-all of independent and fragmented adults seeking their own survival, individual adolescents found themselves in a deepening hole of systemic rejection. This rejection, or abandonment, of adolescents is the root of the fragmentation and calloused distancing that are the hallmarks of the adolescent culture. The evidence for and the eventual consequences of this trend are the basis of this book.
Internal Impact of a Changing Culture
Virtually every theory and scholar of human development recognizes the importance of a stable familial environment on the developmental health of a child and adolescent. From Mary Ainsworth and John Bowlby’s work on childhood attachments and Margaret Mahler’s work on childhood separation-individuation to Peter Blos’s “second” separation-individuation and William Damon’s youth charter, a great deal of research, scholarly investigation, and resultant intervention strategies have gone into trying to understand and address the psychosocial needs of children and adolescents. Yet the cultural changes that occurred during the 1960s and 1970s also had a powerful implicit and internal impact on development that, like a social earthquake, caused so much foundational damage that historically dependable developmental theories and assumptions must be revisited.
One of the most underreported but striking aspects of these years occurred within the structure of the family itself. David Elkind, in his book Ties That Stress: The New Family Imbalance, argues that during the post–World War II era of American family life, men enjoyed stable, routinized family lives; children and adolescents were nurtured and cared for; and women experienced a disproportionate burden of expectations, roles, and responsibilities. As the culture virtually dismantled previously rigid guidelines for family life, a new family imbalance occurred as men and women attempted to redefine their roles and relationships within the family system. The consequences of this imbalance began to fall to the child/adolescent, who was left to fend for himself or herself as parents sought to find their own way in life.
Since the late 1960s and 70s, two powerful shifts occurred, changing the way adolescents perceive the familial reality and influencing how they see themselves. The first shift was the way in which the definition of family was radically altered from the long-held definition of “two or more persons related by birth, marriage or adoption who reside in the same household” to the current definition of a free-flowing, organic “commitment” between people who love each other. This is exemplified in a Tufts University course for undergraduates titled “Family and Intimate Relationships,” in which family is “defined broadly as those with whom one shares resources and values and to whom one has a long-term commitment.” The second shift involved how we view the institution of the family itself. We moved from a culture with a divorce rate that affected 2 percent of the married population in 1940 (264,000) to a society in which 43 percent of first-time marriages end in separation or divorce within fifteen years of marriage, as of 2002. Recent statistics show that in 2008, 67 percent of children ages zero to seventeen lived with two married parents, down from 77 percent in 1980.
I observed this new ratio firsthand while attending a dance competition in Orlando with my daughter. Of the thirteen girls on the team, all from the high school where this study took place, more than half came from divorced families. Of the parents who attended, one forty-year-old mother brought her sixty-seven-year-old live-in boyfriend, and a fifty-six-year-old father was accompanied by his thirty-one-year-old girlfriend, while his ex-wife brought her live-in boyfriend. It is indeed a new day when it comes to what the word family means.
For the adolescent who is trying to hold on to something, at times anything, that is stable and safe, societal mores and parental choices concerning divorce, adult sexuality, and the trend for unmarried parents to cohabitate while children are in the home has had a noticeable impact. In the course of my study, I found that for many kids this effect has been powerfully destructive, and the pain and betrayal they experience are real. The reshaped definition of family has been used to affirm and legitimize even the most casual of liaisons, and this change represents a monumental shift in social history. The adolescent is left to discern how to handle the conflicting messages related to home, stable relationships, and internal security—all while trying to figure out how to survive lengthened adolescence. This only adds to the aloneness most young people feel.
The Emergence of Midadolescence
Beginning in 1904 with G. Stanley Hall’s two-volume Adolescence, and throughout the last hundred years of focused attention and research on adolescence, the almost universally accepted concept of adolescence held that it involved two stages: early and late adolescence. During this time, studies and theories generally dealt with adolescence as a unit, but occasionally they would focus on or highlight one stage or the other. For most of the twentieth century, since adolescence lasted a relatively stable three to five years, this was an appropriate framework in which to study the phenomenon. As the average age of menarche began to drop, however, and as adolescents began to delay entrance into adulthood (for reasons to be discussed later), adolescence began to lengthen. Until approximately 1960 or 1970, for example, the average age of menarche was thirteen years, and most people met the test of individuation by the time they graduated from high school. Thus, adolescence was a five-year process. Junior-high-aged students were described in academic literature as early adolescents, and high school students were late adolescents.
A shift began as early as 1980 with the emergence of an entirely new stage in the adolescent process. Early adolescents were still defined as junior-high-aged students, but several studies included children as young as ten years old, considering them adolescents. Late adolescents were still studied, but many of these studies focused on college-aged students or even graduate students and young adults. The newly appointed stage known as midadolescence emerged as a distinct phase in the 1990s, but little work has been done to define precisely the differences among these stages. The fact that social science has affirmed this new stage is remarkable because historical theories of development do not provide the necessary theoretical framework for studying this middle stage. An e-newsletter from the American Counseling Association defines midadolescence as follows:
Midadolescence generally corresponds to grades 9 through 12 and ages 15 through 18. Many of the developmental changes of early adolescence are extended and refined during midadolescence. This period also presents new challenges and changes for high school students. . . . As students move through high school, they are progressively faced with important decisions regarding future schooling, career paths, and related options. This is both exciting and stressful for many adolescents. The exhilaration of new opportunities and freedoms is often coupled with a sense of isolation and vulnerability (“What if I make the wrong choice?”). Adolescents “face leaving the world that they have always known and stepping out on their own” (Wallbridge & Osachuk, 1995). Increased privileges, such as driving a car and scheduling one’s own time, also represent increased responsibilities. Freedom and responsibility represent two sides of a developmental coin that can become a major source of conflict between high school students and their caregivers.
While to those who spend time with midadolescents the information may seem obvious, the very fact that these kinds of unique characteristics are being discussed in academic circles is a new turn in adolescent literature. The authors recognize that midadolescence is a difficult time. The “exhilaration of new opportunities and freedoms . . . often coupled with a sense of isolation and vulnerability” mentioned above is but one of the paradoxical issues facing midadolescents in contemporary society. Dozens of other conflicting elements are unique to the modern midadolescent. This book is intended to cast some light on at least a few of these.
There are three major reasons why this is such a crucial new area of study. First, most of the newfound freedoms that accompany midadolescence were originally designed for late adolescence. The freedom that comes with the privilege to drive, for example, presents an opportunity to get away from the perceived confines of parental authority, to spend additional time with peers, and to find new avenues of discovery, adventure, and even risk. This freedom, however, used to be reserved for a late adolescent, one who was close to completing the adolescent journey and who, therefore, was better equipped to handle the consequences of the freedoms. A midadolescent, in contrast to a late adolescent, retains the residue of self-centered childhood and may not have the developmental acumen to make the kind of choices that make driving, to use this one example, safe. Without knowing the issues related to lengthened adolescence and the developmental reasons behind the newly apparent lack of driving responsibility, state governments across the United States have either raised the driving age or severely curtailed the initial freedoms a driver’s license offers.
Second, because today adolescence lasts up to fifteen years, a midadolescent has a more difficult time than did previous high-school-aged students seeing college and career as the hope of a secure and fulfilling future. In this study, for example, the attitude students had toward the future was “What’s in it for me?” rather than “How am I going to make a difference in the world?” Thus, while appeals to the future may be motivating factors for some midadolescents, for the vast majority they can easily become one more adult mantra and therefore something to be dismissed.
Third, it has generally been assumed that high-school-aged students have the capacity for abstract thinking. What I noticed during this study, however, is that midadolescents’ ability to engage in abstract thought is limited to the immediate context of a discussion. I observed a nearly universal inability to integrate the multiple selves of their lives with any sense of abstract cohesion. In other words, the most significant difference between midadolescents and late adolescents is that late adolescents can cogently discuss multifaceted concepts that cut across social and relational lines in a way that allows for the implications of that discussion to intersect with any level or relationship. Midadolescents, on the other hand, are fully capable of penetrating and insightful dialogue regarding a variety of topics and issues, but when it comes to applying the conclusions reached during these discussions to a relationship or social reality, especially in a different social context, they cannot see the connection. For example, students would go into great detail regarding the love they had for a parent and what that meant in terms of how they treated that parent. Yet a short time later, they would make arrangements with a friend to deceive that same parent in order to do something that, if the parent found out about it, would cause great pain and heartache. When I pointed out this incompatibility to the student, almost always the response ranged from a blank stare, to rationalization, defensiveness, argumentation, and ultimately retreat so as not to have to face such a discussion.
I had glimpsed elements of these three midadolescent distinctives, and I had a hunch that this was just the tip of the iceberg of understanding this population. I chose, therefore, to attempt to get close enough to see for myself what was going on in their world. This book is concerned with one thing: to understand and describe what the adolescent world looks like through the eyes of those who live it.
Why This Book?
I wrote this book because I believe that adults understand very little of the inside life of the American teenager, especially the midadolescent. Now, after a few years of living with midadolescents and looking through the lens of their life experience, I am more convinced than ever that adults need to be more astute students of the kids we are mandated by society to nurture.
Here is a summary of the basic issues that drive this book:
This is not a how-to book but rather a wake-up call to help every adult recognize and struggle with what our choices as adults have done to the children of our society. The majority of this book will explore the issues resulting from feelings of abandonment among adolescents and reflect on what has occurred as a result. A few solutions are offered in the final chapter, but these are somewhat obvious. We as adults need to roll up our sleeves and invest in the lives of individual young people.
