7: Sports
7
sports
The numbers—and what do sports train us to trust more than numbers?—tell us that high school athletics have never been healthier. Roughly four million boys and three million girls, more than ever before, participate in one or more of some 50 athletic endeavors before kiting off to the rest of their lives. . . . The win-at-all-costs coaches and preprofessional priorities commonplace in college sports have seeped into grades 12, 11, 10 and below. . . . As coaches demand year-round proof of dedication, kids spend a greater and greater proportion of time practicing rather than playing, and many state high school federations, which once enforced strict rules on summer activities, throw up their hands, sometimes eliminating those rules altogether.
Alexander Wolff, “Special Report”
Craig is a star water polo player, Carrie is a dancer on what is called the varsity Song Squad, and Grant is a second-string football player. Craig hangs out mostly with water polo players (there are only two non–water polo players in his cluster). Carrie’s cluster tends to ignore her dancing. Grant has found security by being aligned with football players (although half of his cluster stopped playing after their sophomore year). Three students, three sports, three experiences. In their own ways, these students allowed me to see how coaches and parents have added a layer of performance anxiety to their love of sport. The stories are unique, as are the circumstances, but what provides the backdrop for the struggles these midadolescents face as they “play” comes from the same source: they are the casualties of systemic abandonment by those charged with their care. Sports (including dance) are no longer about fun, exercise, experience, and play. They are about competition, winning, and defeating an opponent. Sports are no longer child’s play; they are a grown-up dog-eat-dog reality.
Surprised on a Saturday Afternoon
One Saturday I attended the peewee football game of a close friend’s son. The players were seven to nine years old, and most of them could barely hold their heads up when they ran, most likely due to the weight of the helmets they wore. They looked like miniature football players, right down to the wrist bands, receiver gloves, neck rolls, and taped fingers. But most of them wandered, yelled, pouted, and ran like little children. The sidelines were packed with parents, either videotaping or chewing their nails. Most were yelling. Near the end of the game, if “our” team could somehow take the ball away from the other team, we would get one more chance to score. Then the man next to me, camera in hand, nearly lost his hat as he screamed at his son, “If you don’t strip the ball, you’re walking home!”
My wife, a relationally sensitive but nonetheless culturally savvy and experienced football mom, and I glanced at each other, not believing what we had just heard. Sure, we had been passionate sideline parents ourselves and had seen our share of over-the-top parental enthusiasm. How this man behaved, however, completely stunned us. His venom was so pointed, his threat so real, that we both actually feared for the boy were he to miss the play.
Sure enough, no one was able to strip the ball, and the team we were rooting for lost another game. The son cried as he approached his father. His father, with visible reluctance and more than a hint of sarcasm, told his son, “I guess you can’t win ’em all. Let’s get the hell out of here!”
The Pros and Cons of High School Athletics
The above true story hints at what every high school student has experienced on some level throughout his or her athletic career. The pressure is intense—to compete, to excel, to perform, and to remain in the game. By the time an athlete gets to high school, his or her chance of participation, much less success, in a sport has been all but settled. Certainly, an outsider could catch the eye of a coach and be catapulted above others to active participation. But in most high school sports, the main players are set even before the season begins. The ones who are safely nestled into the security of a starting spot are called jocks, and most of them wear the badge proudly.
There are, of course, many positive aspects to high school sports, and they have been well documented for years. The recent report of the American Psychological Association’s Healthy Adolescents Project offers this well-worn benefit of high school athletics: “Participation in sports, which has important direct health benefits, is one socially sanctioned arena in which adolescents’ physical energies can be positively channeled. . . . These activities provide adolescents with opportunities for getting exercise, making friends, gaining competence and confidence, learning about teamwork, taking risks, and building character and self-discipline.”
Adolescent participation in sports has consistently been linked with higher levels of self-worth and self-esteem, higher likelihood to engage with both peers and adults, and positive short-term and long-term educational outcomes, especially for boys.
Yet in comparing this view to both the conversations I had with athletes and nonathletes and the observations I made during practices and at sporting events, I found that few students participate in activities because they get exercise, make friends, and so on. Certainly, some of these aspects become side benefits along the way, but for the most part, by the time athletes get to high school, the level of expectation and the pressure to perform make their participation an all-consuming commitment. For many athletes, even the nice and concerned coaches can be hardheaded, demanding, and, while rhetorically committed to what is best for each student, ultimately more concerned with what is best for the team.
The report also describes the reasons many adolescents do not participate in sports: cost, lack of transportation, time commitment, and so on. What was not on the list is what I believe to be the most important reason of all: there are not enough sports or enough room in the ones that are available for “average” student-athletes to compete. Even if there were more opportunities for participation, I am convinced that few of these average players would enlist, mostly because they have been told since before junior high that they did not have what it takes to be an athlete. This attitude creates inside the developing identity of an early adolescent a defining stereotype that most have a hard time shaking. Trying to convince a late-blooming tenth grader to try out for basketball is asking him to risk a great deal, especially if he was derided as a child or early adolescent. One more rejection, especially for the fragile midadolescent, may be one too many to risk.
Actual research on the positive aspects of high school sports has produced mixed results at best. Certainly, in some ways, participation in sports is a good thing. There are, however, a few downsides to contemporary society’s fascination with sports. Merrill Melnick, Kathleen Miller, and Donald Sabo report:
Conventional wisdom has it that participation in high school athletic programs positively influences adolescent health-related behavior. Coaches, athletic administrators, the mass media, and the general public often assert that interscholastic athletic participation helps teenagers develop healthy habits while steering them away from tobacco, alcohol, drugs, dangerous dietary practices, physical inactivity, and other detrimental behaviors. . . .
On the other hand, some sport critics focus on a variety of negative health-related behaviors they believe are associated with athletic participation such as binge drinking; drug use; on- and off-the-field aggression; the “female triad,” namely eating disorders, amenorrhea, and osteoporosis; actions that result in unintentional injury and death, such as irresponsible automobile, motorcycle, and bicycle use; and unprotected sex.
In my experience, adults’ views on sports participation varied according to whether their children were “slow” or “gifted” athletically. Parents of nonathletes had to create an explanation for the crushing disappointment of exclusion and often saw sports in a negative light.
In terms of who is “good” and who is not, two thoughts struck me throughout the study: First, there are many more non-all-stars than there are all-stars. Second, by the time second-stringers enter high school, the die has been cast, and the athletic roles they will play throughout their high school years have already been settled.
In The Hurried Child, David Elkind quotes sportswriter John Underwood as he courageously takes on the “Little Leagues—the worst destroyers of the playfulness of sport.” The article, written more than twenty years ago for Sports Illustrated, is even more ominous today.
The sine qua non of sport is enjoyment. When you take that away, it’s no longer sport. Perhaps the worst creators of specialists are the Little Leagues in all sports. Although some observers believe there’s much value in them, the Leagues have their own ethics. “Abolish the Little Leagues,” says philosopher Robert Weiss. “Forbid ’em,” says sociologist David Riesman.
Sports psychologist Bruce Ogelvie laments the sickening arrogance of Little League coaches, too many of whom are unqualified. Some coaches, says another psychologist, Thomas Tatlio, even “think sports is war.” They make eight year olds sit on the bench while others play, learning nothing beyond the elitism of win-at-all-costs sport. Token participation—an inning in right field, a couple of minutes in the fourth quarter—can be equally demoralizing.
To visit on small heads the pressure to win, the pressure to be “just like mean Joe Green” is indecent. To dress children up like pros in costly out-fits is ridiculous. In so doing, we take away many of the qualities that competitive sports are designed to give to the growing process.
The most alarming piece, though, may be the story of Carl Stotz, the founder of Little League Baseball himself, who, as author and journalist Mark Hyman explains, was stiffly dismissed in 1956 from the movement he started nearly twenty years earlier. Stotz initially welcomed the national attention Little League received, and eagerly leveraged the publicity into more leagues to span the breadth of the teenage years. Despite the celebrity it afforded him, the expansion eventually began to reach levels that made him uncomfortable, but his advocacy for reform came too late: Little League had become big business, and it continues as such today. What began with neighborhood boys on makeshift ballfields enjoying America’s pastime has now mushroomed into a worldwide brand and sophisticated financial enterprise, complete with equipment sponsors, advertising revenue, and an international World Series broadcast in High Definition on ESPN. We enjoy so much seeing an amazing catch or a clutch hit, we forget that those who make errors or strike out do so while bearing the name of their neighborhoods, or their states, or even their countries across their twelve-year-old chests.
What our hyperfocus on competition has inserted in the place of these qualities is a lucrative niche industry of club sports and private coaching. In days past, high school athletes looking to hone their skills might practice privately or attempt to put together a pickup game. Not so anymore. Today, students in all fifty states have the opportunity to participate nearly year-round on a club team in any number of sports—soccer, lacrosse, softball, volleyball, swimming, etc.—so long as their skills are acceptable and their families’ finances are in order. As Eric Sondheimer of the Los Angeles Times reports, the last twenty years have seen a meteoric rise in the club sports industry, “with private coaches being paid thousands of dollars to develop elite athletes—and the parents of those athletes paying up to $7,000 a year to participate.” Some clubs have established official partnerships with professional teams both in the United States and abroad, so that kids as young as seven compete while wearing the exact garb of multimillionaire athletes on the other side of the globe, right down to the corporate logos. So consumed are many clubs with winning—and thus maintaining their sponsorships and brand recognition—that oftentimes the most gifted student-athletes must choose between competing for the club and competing for their high school.
What often goes unmentioned is the physical toll that year-round competition exacts on young bodies. As Mark Hyman writes, “Lyle Micheli, the youth sports medicine pioneer, estimates that of the seventy young patients who file into his clinic each Thursday at Children’s Hospital Boston, 75 percent are victims of overuse injuries. . . . Back in the early 1990s, the figure was at about 20 percent. . . . Adults are the great enablers of overuse injuries. . . . Children entertaining themselves at their own pace, in their own way, simply did not play sports until it hurt.”
By the time many of the student-athletes fortunate enough to play beyond high school enter the university setting, they have endured so much extra competition that, while they have become highly skilled players, they are also “orthopedic time bombs.” At the same time, such may be the price for the opportunity to play at that university level, or even the high school level; students who do not practice or play year-round for upwards of fifteen or twenty hours per week simply cannot compete with those who do. Factor in the fringe benefits of the club system—namely, social belonging and identity formation, for both students and adults—and it is clear that the system is not going anywhere any time soon.
A Little Experiment
I performed an experiment in the middle of the study, attempting to get a handle on how preadolescents and high school seniors felt about the athletic “haves” and “have-nots.” I included three groups: preadolescent athletes, seniors in high school athletics, and nonathlete seniors. The questions I asked were intended not to elicit specific answers but to get them talking about their impressions regarding the high performance and competitive aspects of youth and high school sports and how these aspects might affect different kinds of children and youth.
The first group contained three preadolescent boys who played organized baseball and three young girls who played competitive soccer. They were between eight and ten years of age. Most were from relatively affluent intact families in which there was a great deal of emotional support. They all considered themselves “good” to “pretty good.”
They were at the highest level in their respective sports, and they did not feel it was wrong for them to get to go to special tournaments, get more playing time than other kids, and be separated from the “not-so-good athletes” in how they were treated by coaches, parents, and their teammates. Not only did they feel fine about this performance segregation, but they also felt it was “more fair” than letting those who were not good take playing time away from them. Every one of these children believed that the good should get to play, and those who were not of their caliber should have to wait until they (the better athletes) were tired. I asked at what age this should begin to happen, and they immediately agreed—as soon as they start sports! “If we’re better than they are, then why should we suffer?” one child said.
Then I talked with six seniors, three male baseball players and three female soccer players, who had always been starters. While they acknowledged that children’s feelings could possibly get hurt if they were not given much playing time or, somewhere around the fourth grade, no longer allowed to compete, they seemed to deflect any understanding of how it must feel for those kids. They all defended the process of highlighting the better athletes, even at ages as young as eight years old. As much as they tried to feign concern for those who were not born with athletic skill and talent, they had little compassion for the nonathletic students.
As much as the first group was marked by entitlement and the second by defensiveness, the third was marked by hurt and even resentment. These seniors, who for one reason or another had been told at a fairly young age that they did not have the ability to participate in sports, left me sad and a bit angry. The stories varied, from a boy who quit all sports because his soccer coach told him in third grade to quit because his play was costing the team games, to a girl who lost her best friends in fifth grade when she was cut from a competitive soccer team (the pain was as fresh as if it had happened the day before). Most of these students hated jocks and everything related to sports.
I walked away from these conversations contemplating how our culture had gotten to this point. In our competitive and performance-driven world, by the time a child is in the fourth or fifth grade, ten or eleven years old, he or she has it or does not. For a variety of reasons, this message is not in and of itself enough to cause lasting damage to an adolescent. Some kids who are told they don’t have it become firmly committed to showing a coach, friend, or parent how wrong they are. Yet we have a long way to go in understanding how our intensity concerning sports has impacted our young, especially those who have been excluded from participation and denied a sense of personal worth because they developed late, were not able to contribute, or simply got in the way of a coach’s, a parent’s, or even a teammate’s drive to excel.
Every adult has been reared on the notion that youth sports build character. In light of what I have seen—the advancement of the best at the expense of the weak, the preference for the skilled even as the eyes of the awkward plead for a chance, the pressure of the parent who lives vicariously through his or her child’s “play”—little character is being built. I have observed just the opposite in fact. True character is built when one is rewarded for hard work, when one is willing to sacrifice for a friend or teammate, when one experiences the instilled value that proclaims the love of sport and not the lust for competition. This is perhaps the most obvious arena in which abandonment has made its mark on the adolescent psyche. We still use the rhetoric that youth sports build character, yet in reality what we have taught our children builds nothing other than arrogance, self-centeredness, and a performance ethic that is destructive to healthy, communally connected development.
The Dethroning of the Esteemed Athlete
I discovered something else during this study. The jocks no longer occupy the highest rung on the status ladder. The historically definable and clearly observable social ladder is being dismantled in favor of a web of social influence. In the school where I conducted this study, athletics still mean a great deal, hundreds of people attend sporting events, and sports are still seen as somewhat cool. But even at this school, jocks’ influence has waned. They are no more esteemed than any other group, including the band. Students no longer put up with the stereotype that athletes rule the school, and perhaps in a subconscious attempt to get back at the childhood athletic systems that hurt them, many nonathletes disdain jocks.
I came to this study being drawn to and even slightly defensive of those with whom I felt comfortable in high school. In my case, I was aligned with the athletes. In this chapter, it may appear that I am taking a hard line against successful athletes. My original bias notwithstanding, I am determined not to take a stand for or against any individual or group of adolescents. I am equally concerned about those who have been rejected by the competitive world of sports and those who by innate design, hard work, or both have achieved athletic prowess. The former’s pain and disappointment are obvious and easily documented by anyone who would but look at life through their eyes. The latter’s struggles lie far deeper, but I am convinced that even the top stars feel pangs of loneliness and insecurity as a result of being raised in a culture in which athletic excellence is measured only by the last pass, kick, or basket. All have suffered at the hands of a culture of abandonment when it comes to the decay of play and fun.
I opened this chapter with three students who take pride and find a sense of identity in their ability to perform well enough to be included on a team. Craig, the water polo player, is a naturally gifted player. He is also a leader in a sport that is considered second tier (especially when compared to football, basketball, or baseball), and he therefore feels the need to convince people that water polo players are “the best athletes in the school.” This need to prove himself has become a major element of his personality and his relationships. He can no longer play for fun and sport. He must make sure that others know that he, as a water polo player, matters.
Carrie has always loved to dance. As a little girl, trying out new moves for her parents, putting on a fancy dress for the Christmas recital, and freely floating around a room with giggling friends made the pain of learning how to stand on her toes worthwhile. When she started fourth grade, dance was no longer a joyous adventure of free expression. It had shifted to a physically grueling gauntlet every weekday in preparation for the next competition. By fifteen, the pressure from the driven coach, the early morning practices, the continual (misguided and unnecessary) fight with her weight, and the daily pressure not to mess up and hurt the team had taken its toll. She quit the team after one year on varsity. She had lost her love of dance in order to become a dancer.
Grant was never quite good enough, or so the head varsity coach told him, to play “at this level.” He had played football since he was ten, had even started for most of his sophomore season, but once he got to varsity, the head coach made it clear that he was barely welcome. He would be on the team, but he should not expect to play. As much as Grant saw himself as a football player, and his cluster and others on the team treated him as an equal, the coach never came around. Grant received an award at the banquet, but the head coach made it clear that he had not contributed. When I asked the other guys about Grant and the coach, the response was predictable: “The coach is a jerk. Grant should have started, at least a few games. He was a leader on the team.” Grant’s saving grace was his cluster. His friends showed compassion, loyalty, and concern. The coach was too concerned about being in charge, regardless of whom he hurt in the process.
Conclusion and Musings
How do we fight our socially ingrained, competitive instincts to recommit ourselves to making sports fun? How do we remove our adult need to live our lives through our kids so that they can recapture the love of sports? How can we revamp our systems and structures so that even in high school sports are about play?
During this study, I became more convinced of how insidious and self-serving youth and high school competitive activities have become. These activities are no longer for or about the students; they are for and about the adults in charge. The deification of competitive prominence and the defeat of one’s “enemies” have choked much of the life out of the human desire to play for play’s sake and even to compete with class and honor.
Of course, there are exceptions to this, as there are with every assertion I have made. I got to know many of the coaches at the school, and as individuals, they are a top-notch lot. The system they operate under, however, and the ethos of that system are focused on competitive excellence (defined simply by a season’s record), and this is what is taking its toll on our young. A sensitive, savvy coach in an overly competitive system may be able to ensure that that sport or that season does as little developmental damage as possible, but the wave of winning and performing is a large force indeed.
As with every aspect of the consequences of abandonment, the most potent tool we have in helping adolescents overcome the damage caused by the negative aspects of sports and other competitive activities is to help them see that in the final analysis competition doesn’t matter. We have been giving lip service to this message for decades (“It’s all about trying your best, kids. It’s not winning that counts; it’s how you play the game.”), but our rhetoric and our behavior have not lined up. When the father of the football team’s kicker screamed at his son in front of hundreds of parents and students after he missed an extra point, he demonstrated that the message of “doing your best” was merely a convenient and hollow postgame speech coaches use to try to motivate athletes following a loss. Shame on that father! And shame on us for allowing a destructive system to continue in the name of sport.
It used to be fun to play sports, but for far too many of the students I talked to, their involvement ceased to be fun a long time ago. I cannot think of any other area of life in which we as a society have abandoned our young more thoroughly. From the time they hear “Play ball!” they know that they had better come through and perform, even if they are only playing for fun.
