Chapter 3 of 26

Preface to the First Edition

Preface to the First Edition

preface to the first edition

Why would anyone want to study us?”

This cynical sentiment from a seventeen-year-old high school junior struck me as a bit odd.

“I mean, what’s the big deal about kids? Why would you get paid to write a book about us?”

Sharon had been in a class I had substitute taught, and the only thing I knew about her was that she seemed to have a cold cloud of gloom constantly hanging about her, like Seattle in November. She had been bugging me for some time about my motive for hanging around the school. My explanation of a sabbatical leave from my teaching job failed to satisfy her, as did my lighthearted quips about liking kids, and even my more detailed, serious explanation that I believed most adults had little understanding of where adolescents were coming from. Sharon simply thought there had to be an ulterior motive, an angle that would somehow serve me at the expense of her community of peers.

“Is this going to make you famous?”

I laughed out loud. “After writing some books that few actually read, I gave up on that kind of thing a long time ago.”

“Then, why? Why are you doing this? Will it really matter to anyone?”

Her last question caught me off guard. What began as an idea for a sabbatical evolved into this book. I started with a desire to get to know students. I have spent my entire adult life attempting to care for what most adults refer to as “kids.” But as the research objectives, methods, hypotheses, and scope of my interest took shape, and when a publisher became intrigued with the idea of a series devoted to the study of youth, family, and culture, I realized that this book had become far more than just several hundred hours of personal reflection on the state of contemporary middle adolescence. It had become a vital story that needed to be told. But the question has haunted me ever since: will this book matter to anyone?

Whether it will has ceased to be my concern, because I cannot force people to care about something; they must ultimately choose. I wrote this book for those who are willing to consider how life is different for today’s high school students compared with past generations. This book will matter to anyone who chooses to take my findings seriously. Not every adult, or perhaps not even most, will agree with the discoveries I share and the conclusions I make. I offer, however, a detailed attempt to bring to light what the vast majority of adults have either ignored or missed. My goal is to raise the level of dialogue and ultimately the level of individual, corporate, and systemic commitment to the young of our communities.

As you read, I hope you will not lightly dismiss or easily disregard the observations contained here. I may not be right about everything. As with most ethnographic reports, this study is bound to be filled with theoretical holes and at times even missteps. But I have attempted an honest look at American teenagers from the inside perspective of their world. I have tested my conclusions with a wide variety of young people across the United States. They have affirmed that this is the most accurate and compassionate observation of their world they have ever received from an adult. Obviously, many others have gone before me, but I do not know of a single trained social scientist who has entered the adolescent world to gain a deeper understanding of today’s postmodern teenagers.

For me, this project was more an exploration of a new world than an academic enterprise. The deeper I ventured into their world, the more I realized how much I had to learn. For me, this was Hillary’s Everest, Cousteau’s oceans, and Lewis and Clark’s adventures. Like the handful of Europeans who headed over the western horizon to find an easier, more direct route to the East but found themselves in foreign and at times unrecognizable territory, I too had an unexpected adventure. I experienced a myriad of emotions over the course of the last two years, as I could not step away from the passions, the arrogance, and the groanings of the youth I came to love. May this book become an adventure of intrigue, concern, and compassion for you as well.

I started this project as an attempt to add to the research literature and scholarly understanding of what is happening in the developmental stage known as midadolescence (which spans roughly ages fourteen to twenty). As a result of spending hundreds of hours observing and interacting with students, I came away with far more. I realized that if I were going to speak and write about breaking the cycle of abandonment that our young experience so that they can somehow experience the kind of life we as adults so earnestly strive for, I had to be changed. I could no longer live as I had. I had to find a way to care for the young people in my community. I was reminded that I am a steward of the most precious resource any society can ever have: its young. I am still in my late forties, a typical husband and father with a job, a mortgage, and a hidden need to figure out life for myself. But I have found a way to flesh out my desire to make a difference by having dinner with three high school boys every week.

May this book challenge you, disturb you, and cause you to be a champion for those who are desperate for the advocacy of an adult community who cares.

My High School Adventure

I had just started substitute teaching as a central part of my research project on the state of contemporary adolescence. Soon after telling a few high school students that I was there to listen to them, to try to understand them, and to write a book for adults about what life is like for teenagers today, one vocal junior became the spokesman for about a dozen others.

“Tell them our story,” he remarked. “Tell them the truth—that nobody cares, that nobody listens, that teachers and coaches and cops and parents don’t even know who we are. Tell them that and see if anybody listens. Ha! Not a chance!”

Although most were enamored by the idea of “being in a book,” this remark was typical of a deeper skepticism I sensed in many students as I began a study of high school life. For more than six months I spent nearly every day with high school students as a participant-observer in their world. I wanted to get close and to listen to them, to develop enough trust for them to let me in to places that few adults are allowed. I wanted to discern their complex, contradictory worldview and watch how they navigate the multilayered expectations and relationships that control their landscape.

As a practitioner who works directly with adolescents, as well as an academically trained professor of youth, family, and culture, I had found that the literature about young people (from both religious and secular sources) provided conflicting data at best and was usually too generic and stereotypical to offer caring adults the level of information that could help them to connect authentically and deeply with students in a rapidly changing world. I sensed a vital need for an academically based research project that studied the world of contemporary adolescents. After years of hanging around the fringes of the adolescent world and reading books such as Patricia Hersch’s A Tribe Apart, I knew that the only way to be invited in was to log the time and to build trusting relationships with students on their turf.

This study applies accepted social science research methodology to the reality of life for the middle adolescent in contemporary American society. The goal is to follow in the footsteps of some of the courageous pioneers, such as Hersch, who have reported on the world of today’s young by applying a standard and quality of research methodology that scholars, academics, and even practitioners who care about and interface with adolescents have to engage.

The Method

I decided to function as a participant-observer at a public high school in north Los Angeles County. I chose Crescenta Valley High School because it is a nationally recognized Blue Ribbon School for excellence in academic achievement; has a widely diverse ethnic population (including many newly arrived immigrant students); has historically strong and diverse sports, music, and drama programs; and has a mean population that is socioeconomically middle class with an extremely wide economic divergence. In addition, the coprincipals were supportive of my noninvasive research methods and were even interested in interacting with and learning from the study in order to improve the academic experience for each student in the school.

In attempting to understand more fully what life is like for middle adolescents, I decided to conduct an ethnographic study (which basically meant becoming a part of their world) instead of relying on either objectified quantitative instruments such as written questionnaires, which would greatly limit the scope of the inquiry, or less personal qualitative methodologies such as phone surveys, which depend heavily on small sample interviews and controlled environment settings. Participant-observation research methodology allows for and even encourages new and fresh insights and avoids a priori conceptual or theoretical limitations in a changing sociocultural environment. A tenet of qualitative research methodology is the conviction that “social research is an interactive rather than controlling process.” Therefore, ethnography, a form of more deeply involved qualitative research, is a useful tool in attempting to grasp the world of a specific population in a changing environment. Although this type of research has some obvious limitations, such as the researcher’s own historical, socioeconomic, gender, and ethnic biases, a social scientist can gain a great deal of insight when he or she is welcomed as a participant in a relatively closed system and is allowed to record his or her experiences as an observer.

Even though I sought to have an open mind and to learn from the world of the students instead of from my experience, training, and literature exposure, I had to concede that I carried into the study a powerful set of preconceptions. It was impossible for me to be completely value- and theory-free. I acknowledge this limitation in both the methodology and the research conclusions.

There is a helpful aspect, however, to a highly informed and dedicated investigator applying knowledge and experience to a qualitative sociological methodology. I am, and was when I began, intimately acquainted with the diverse and sometimes contradictory views of both the academic and popular literature on adolescence and adolescent development. I was also aware of the emergence of midadolescence as an accepted substage of the adolescent process. If I had not known that in the last ten to fifteen years scholars had accepted the existence of three stages of adolescence (early, middle, and late) instead of the historically understood two (early and late), I might have inadvertently ascribed attributes to the high school students in this study in a way that could have skewed my results and therefore affected my conclusions. My prior experience in the field of adolescent studies prepared me to enter this population.

Why Not the Different and the Fringe

Even a cursory glance at the table of contents reveals that this book spends little time on specific issues that divide, segment, or separate students. Certainly an argument can be made that economic, ethnic, or personal history can significantly impact an adolescent’s view and experience of life. After months of consideration, I chose to focus on the more clearly observable, broad-stroke issues facing the vast majority of American high school students, even those who have been oppressed and marginalized by class distinctions and racial inequities. In focusing on sexuality, busyness, athletics, school, family, and the like, I hope to give readers the opportunity to enter the halls, locker rooms, and classrooms of the campus. What I intentionally left out were the sociological differences among races, between the poor and the wealthy, and even between genders. I did this to look at the larger whole, of which all midadolescents are a part, to discover a baseline from which to spawn further discussion and investigation. What I record here is an accurate portrayal of high school life for most students.

In addition to these intentional omissions, I also chose to leave out significant detail regarding some of the deeper, more complex issues that many midadolescents from all walks of life face. Issues such as drug use, eating disorders, physical and other kinds of abuse, date rape, sexual addiction, and cutting (a form of self-mutilation that is becoming more and more common), to name a few, are only alluded to in this book. By not highlighting them I am not saying they are unimportant compared to the more global issues I offer, nor am I asserting that students who face such issues do not warrant a close look. I did not discuss these issues (or in some cases only lightly touched on them) for two reasons. First, I believe these situations and behaviors make sense only when studied and discussed in light of the more sweeping issues presented in this book. Wrestling with “fringe” issues (and students) without an elementary grasp of the overall midadolescent social and cultural landscape could produce superficial and incomplete assumptions and conclusions regarding these issues.

Second, I did not focus on these destructive and painful behaviors and issues because most students between fourteen and twenty years of age touch at least the edges of them at some point in their journey. By its very nature adolescence is a time of great change. Students who enter high school as Goths may become Punks, then druggies, and finally all-league varsity soccer players. This constantly shifting identity formation and experimentation involves various aspects of fringe elements or behaviors, making identifying and categorizing each behavior an extremely difficult, thorny, and even academically suspect enterprise. As soon as you think you understand what is going on with a specific population, group, or even individual student, that population, group, or student takes off in a different direction. Therefore, I chose to leave the discussion of these fringe elements, behaviors, and issues to others.

A Conclusion and a Beginning

Adolescence is a hard thing to describe. It is even harder to define. For the vast majority of adults, it is hard to understand. Most of us want to take the easy route of claiming that it hasn’t changed since we were in high school. Others say it really doesn’t matter if adults understand kids, as long as the young live up to adult values of respect, commitment, and hard work. Still others fall into the category of “If you can’t understand them, join them!” After years of study and conversations with countless adults, there is a gnawing, nagging reality that even though we may want to be committed to being a light to our young, we have no idea who or what we are dealing with.

This book is an attempt to peer into the foreign and seemingly hostile world of midadolescents. My intent is to try to understand them in order to care about them more effectively. This book may disturb you, make you mad (at me as well as the culture), frustrate you, or even cause you to disagree vehemently. As the researcher and author of this study, I find any and all of these reactions welcome. For too many years, even decades, adult society has pushed aside and blamed the young for their “rebellious” bent and for their seeming indifference to societal rules, norms, and values. As you embark on this journey, I ask you to consider who or what has created the catalyst for the rebellious and cavalier arrogance of the younger generation over the last fifty years. Could it be that the source has finally been identified? Is it possible that what we as adults see as a rebellious generation is really a uniquely vulnerable population living out the necessary reaction to being set to sea rudderless, adrift without a compass? Welcome to Hurt: Inside the World of Today’s Teenagers.

↑ Back to top

↑