Chapter 17 of 26

10: Ethics and Morality

10: Ethics and Morality

10

ethics and morality

The evidence is that a willingness to cheat has become the norm and that parents, teachers, coaches and even religious educators have not been able to stem the tide. The scary thing is that so many kids are entering the workforce to become corporate executives, politicians, airplane mechanics and nuclear inspectors with the dispositions and skills of cheaters and thieves.

Michael Josephson, quoted in Josephson Institute, “The Ethics of American Youth: 2002”

Sociologist Mike Males used an interesting phrase in his article for the Los Angeles Times when he referred to adult concerns and fears about the state of the young as “bogus moral panics.” I have already discussed his attempt to discredit those who believe that adolescence is changing and presenting serious challenges for us as a culture (see chapter 2), but I have not yet considered his use of the term moral panics. Males and others may disagree with me, but if there is one arena in which adolescence is rapidly changing it is the realm of ethics and morality. To say that asking questions concerning the changing ethical standards, rules, and norms of adolescents is a “moral panic” is reductionism at its worst.

Ethics: Discarded or Redefined?

When plague afflicted the Greeks in the fifth century BC, an overwhelming sense of hopelessness impacted the entire society. Thucydides describes how this feeling affected people’s ethical commitments:

Men now coolly ventured on what they had formerly done in a corner, and not just as they pleased, seeing the rapid transitions produced by persons in prosperity suddenly dying and those who before had nothing succeeding to their property. So they resolved to spend quickly and enjoy themselves, regarding their lives and riches as like things of a day. Perseverance in what men called honor was popular with none, it was so uncertain whether they would be spared to attain the object; but it was settled that present enjoyment, and all that contributed to it, was both honorable and useful. Fear of gods or law of man there was none to restrain them. As for the first, they judged it to be just the same whether they worshipped them or not, as they saw all alike perishing; and for the last, no one expected to live to be brought to trial for his offences, but each felt that a far severer sentence had been already passed upon them all and hung ever over their heads, and before this fell it was only reasonable to enjoy life a little.

For much the same reason, contemporary midadolescents filter much of their thought processes through the lens of self-interest and self-protection. They see themselves as having been abandoned and left on their own to navigate the complexities of life. Living in the world beneath has left a mark on their ethical norms. Adolescents are not looking for the pleasure of the moment because they believe ethics are irrelevant in light of certain, unavoidable death. They are, instead, developmentally and practically preoccupied with the pleasure of the immediate because they have a driving commitment to create for themselves a world that makes life easier, safer, and more satisfying. But does that mean they have become lawless and have discarded any commitment to ethical rules and standards?

Systemic abandonment and midadolescents’ subsequent burrowing into their own world have created a new standard and setting for ethics, one in which ethical norms are still important, for what society or even subculture can possibly survive without an ethical system for defining and ordering life’s choices and relationships? Yet the ethical system in operation in the world beneath is a pragmatically revised version of a culture’s values. Many of the same ethical issues that are present in the larger culture are present in the midadolescent world, but the way these issues get resolved flows out of the reasons for the world beneath in the first place. The ethical system of the world beneath is limited to those primary ethical issues that affect midadolescents’ abilities to feel safe, protected, and fulfilled. Loyalty (primarily defined as loyalty to friends but occasionally involving loyalty to one teacher over another, their school, or their community), staying within the preordained boundaries of social life (such as where to sit, whom to date, what activities to participate in), and other straightforward and easily negotiated ethical parameters of adolescent life make up the ethical scaffolding of midadolescence today.

What this means, then, is that many of the ethical standards of adult society have a secondary relevance for midadolescents. It is not that they do not care about some of the more “traditional” ethical issues—such as lying, stealing, and cheating—but these issues can be rather easily discarded if they violate the more pressing ethical standards of the adolescent world. Adults, on the other hand, at least nod toward an acceptance of ethical standards as an important guide for life. Adults may in actuality be no more moral in their behaviors and attitudes than adolescents, but they will typically have a harder time admitting their deviance from the acknowledged norm. In the General Social Survey study, for example, Gerald Celente of Trends Research states, “We are seeing precisely what this report is saying. They [adolescents] have been hardened by today’s realities. They have seen an acceptance of disposing of ethics and morals if it serves a need. They see it is OK to do what you want to do as long as you meet your personal requirements.” This modeling by adults has served to further erode a commitment by midadolescents to live up to the lofty standards of ethical rhetoric. They have grown up in a world in which adults say one thing and do another. We even have a saying for this: “Do as I say, not as I do!” The young, therefore, have learned from the example of adults how little ethical standards mean.

Adults see a wide discrepancy between what adolescents say and what they do. Young people seem to behave with inconsistency and defensive relativism. As one editorial that attempted to understand apparently conflicting data put it, “On some political issues involving religion, America’s youth seem to be more conservative than their elders, but cheating, stealing and lying by high school students has increased with alarming vigor.” For adults to understand the world of midadolescents, they must understand where the ethical lines are drawn and what constitutes an ethical or moral issue.

This chapter identifies and describes two issues as examples of how adolescents view their standards of ethics differently than adults (or at least adult rhetoric): lying and cheating. These are not the only ethical issues in which adolescents function differently, but they do represent a sustained, regular, and even daily rejection of the ethical definitions of the adults who raised and trained them. When it comes to adolescent ethics, issues such as sexuality, alcohol, drugs, justice, racism, and a myriad of other topics are viewed through a similar lens.

Moral Categories

In any discussion of adolescent morality, the default academic position begins with theories put forward by people such as Jean Piaget (child and adolescent development) and Lawrence Kohlberg (moral development). Simply put, Piaget taught that developmental growth is a process of the increasing ability of internal reasoning. Kohlberg went further by arguing that there are six stages of moral development, culminating in an internalized locus of moral commitment. The process for both of these perspectives is linear according to stages (i.e., the older one gets, the more one grows toward a moral commitment). As theorists have worked to revise, reshape, and strengthen these perspectives, the generally accepted understanding of moral development has stayed relatively constant. It “refers to the development of a sense of values and ethical behavior. Adolescents’ cognitive development, in part, lays the groundwork for moral reasoning, honesty, and prosocial behaviors such as helping, volunteerism, or caring for others.”

Cathy Stonehouse reworked Kohlberg’s theory using three basic levels. In terms of what she calls “the source of authority” for each level, level 1 is primarily concerned with the needs of the self, level 2’s driving motivation is “how others might respond to one’s moral choices,” and level 3 is the pinnacle of moral development as one becomes more concerned with “internal principles” than with personal needs or even the perceptions of others. Stonehouse’s understanding of justice, related to moral choices and commitments, is also arranged from concern with personal fulfillment and satisfaction (level 1) to conventional standards of a culture (level 2) to the notion of blind and equal justice for all individuals (level 3). The implication is that as people grow up, they generally follow this path, unless they experience a block or trauma along the way that thwarts the process.

In my study of midadolescents, the stage theory, at least as set forth by Stonehouse, did not apply to the overwhelming majority of students. Kohlberg’s classification and his six stages of moral development did not hold in terms of the ages most commonly associated with moral growth. In fact, there seemed to be a regression in moral development from middle school to high school (early to midadolescence). Students seemed to bounce back and forth between levels of moral development. The most common stage of Kohlberg’s moral reasoning I observed was the pre-conventional level, stage 2, in which a child is concerned primarily with satisfying his or her own wants and needs. The conventional level, stage 3, in which a child seeks approval from others, was in view when adolescents were operating within adult-controlled layers (e.g., school, sports teams, church, or work).

In the world beneath, Kohlberg’s stage theory (and variations of it) was not able to address moral reasoning because midadolescents believe they must be in a constant mode of self-protection. A strong survivalist mentality exists just under the surface for many students, affecting their ability to move toward more advanced stages of development, especially moral development.

Lying

“Everybody lies, and everybody knows that everybody lies.”

“Is it wrong to lie?” I asked.

“It depends,” this junior girl from rural North Carolina went on. “If it doesn’t really hurt anybody, and it is necessary for any reason, a ‘white lie’ is not really a lie, and then it’s not wrong.”

Some people call this relativism, others pragmatism. I suppose it depends on the perspective of the one doing the lying.

“Does everybody really lie? Even to their parents or ministers?”

“Especially to our parents and pastors! They can’t be trusted with anything!”

I heard variations on this theme throughout my study. Researchers have come late to the game and often ask questions that are seen as almost silly by the respondents. “Everybody lies, and everybody knows that everybody lies.” In typical academic understatement, one study reported that in an overview of literature dealing with deceptive behaviors of children and adolescents, previous studies had determined that the ability to deceive had been significantly underestimated. When I shared with the students involved in my study that more research was going to focus on the extent of adolescent lying behaviors, they looked at me as if I had said that researchers were going to study whether adolescents breathe. Lying, especially as defined by adults, has become one more natural reflex of daily living, and besides, it is not even really lying!

I am not saying that every midadolescent moves through this process in the same way or even with the same effect. Some students do not seem to care what an adult thinks, and therefore their propensity to lie may be triggered less frequently than that of students who are trying to play the social game with excellence. All students, however, when they find themselves in a position in which a lie would be the easiest route to self-protection, will lie just as easily as the next kid. Pervasive and unchecked lying has become a central reality to almost every midadolescent in our culture.

There is no question that adolescents, especially midadolescents, lie. In studies on the adolescent tendency to deceive parents, for example, only 5 percent of adolescents said they never lied about where they were. This survey measured what adolescents said, meaning that it is possible that even fewer adolescents did not lie in such cases. The survey also revealed that girls lie more to parents about sex and more often to their dads than do boys; boys lie more often than girls to their moms. They are both highly successful in their lying; only 5 percent say they were often caught.

I observed that the most regular defense offered for lying, especially to authority figures (parents, teachers, coaches), was a perceived need to protect oneself or one’s friends. In incident after incident, the most often reported reason for lying was to avoid being punished for doing something that in general they did not believe was wrong. One student put it this way: “Most things are kept from my parents because of the repercussions.” As research has shown, when students feel that an issue is none of their parents’ business, or that full disclosure would lead to excessive restrictions on their autonomy, lying is not just an option, but a virtual certainty.

I rarely encountered a midadolescent who believed that lying was unethical. Midadolescents reshape the idea of lying to the point where a justified deception, including an outright, bald-faced lie, is not actually lying. Nearly every student admitted to lying regularly, without remorse. Yet these same students actually believed that they were highly moral, ethical, and honest people! This is consistently confirmed by research. One study found that 85 percent of adolescents surveyed said yes to the question, “Are you basically an honest person?” Here is a typical string of logic that I heard over and over again: “I lie, sure. So does everybody else. I’m an honest person, though, and that’s what really counts.”

Early on in my study, I became increasingly aware that terms and concepts that carry definitive meaning for adults are continually up for grabs according to the ethical mind-set of midadolescents. One day I was told by an athlete that when a coach looked him in the eye and asked why he was late for practice, he made up a semiplausible but fabricated story. As he told me what he had done, he made no attempt to conceal or even justify it to me. In fact, he shared it with me as if it were the most natural and normal thing in the world. When I pressed him, asking him how he could defend his deception, he looked at me with near amazement and said, “He would have made a big deal out of it, and it wasn’t a big deal. He didn’t deserve to know the truth.”

“But you lied to him,” I said. “Isn’t that wrong?”

“I didn’t lie, exactly. I just didn’t think it was his business to know my business.”

“What happens,” I went on, “if that same coach told you that you were going to start next week, and then he turned around and had someone else start in your place? Let’s say he was trying to motivate you, and it worked, and you figured out later that he never really intended to have you start. Is that wrong? Is that a lie?”

“Obviously. No coach can lie like that, and to a kid? That’s wrong.”

The more I tried to tie these two events together, the less this young man seemed interested in or capable of connecting the dots. To him, a lie was not a lie and was not wrong unless it was done to him. When I shared this story with adolescents around the country, it was clear that to some his statement reflected an ethical infraction, but to many others it did not. Even those who saw the inconsistency, however, still believed the guy was right.

During the summer following the year of this study, I spoke at three high school conferences. I told the students that I was finishing this research project and needed their help to correct any points or conclusions I had made. Among nearly three thousand students, there was not one dissenting voice regarding the major elements of the research findings. On the topic of lying, not one student disagreed with my near exaggeration of the phenomenon. After one conference, I received a letter from a young man. His three-page note was filled with personal struggles, despair over his sense of abandonment, and his being “fake more often than he was real.” One line particularly struck me, as he was considered by his adult leaders, his school, and his community a moral leader among his peers: “I lie because I have never truly found a person to be honest with. Most likely I lie because I find it likely that any feelings I may convey to that person would eventually come back to haunt me, whether my parents, or even my friends, school, or church. I just can’t trust anybody, so I need to protect myself. If I have to lie now and then to do that, so be it.”

Despite the behavior, flippancy, and defensive rationalizing of midadolescents, lying does represent an important ethical issue for them, and when pressed, most of them do “get it.” The issue for them is that the morality regarding truth telling is a second-tier ethic, meaning that while it is an important and necessary ethic on which any society is built—trust being central to social cohesion—these long-term and global realities may be placed on “developmental hold” when young people face a more immediate need to protect oneself (or one’s friends). It remains unknown whether the perceived need to lie is based on a fear of shame within the peer group, as some have argued, or is simply an example of the limitations of the cognitive abilities and developmental reality of midadolescents. My hunch is that as midadolescents attempt to create a sense of continuity, congruence, and order while living in multiple layers, a concern for something as lofty as what lying does to the fabric of society does not register on their cognitive radar screens.

Cheating

As mentioned in chapter 5, some believe that cheating has become an epidemic, and research shows that it is widespread and growing among high school and college students. Some of these studies, however, were flawed in that the authors often influenced their subjects by the framing of their questions. That said, studies on cheating have provided insight into the prevalence of and attitudes concerning cheating: it increases during middle and late adolescence, students have a number of rationalities and reasons for cheating, and midadolescents tend to blame their cheating on others (teachers, parents, the school itself, or even society at large).

In one study, researchers found that high school students were far more carefree and casual about cheating than were college students. This supports the notion that midadolescents, by developmental definition, do not seem to give much energy to ethical issues that do not provide immediate self-promotion or protection. Even the definition of cheating varied from context to context and, in my study, from situation to situation. If, for example, a teacher was well liked and was seen as honest, respectful, and fair, then most students would self-police their own against too much cheating in that class. But if that same teacher “unfairly” gave a pop quiz, then whoever felt the need to cheat was only giving the teacher what he or she deserved. These findings are consistent with a recent study showing that students readily justify cheating when they perceive a teacher to be incompetent and/or disrespectful. This particular study took as its point of departure prior research that positively associated permissive attitudes about cheating with the perception that a classroom is driven more by performance than enrichment. In another situation during my observation, when a student who was relatively respected felt that he or she had the right to cheat for one reason or another, it was up to the class to protect and defend that student’s choice. But if another student who, for whatever reason, was not seen as a peer ally chose to cheat, that student would be turned in (this was actually quite rare, but it happened now and then).

Donald McCabe, in a study on academic dishonesty among high school students, offers some of the comments he recorded in a midadolescent focus group:

“I think times have changed. Cheating is kind of considered, I don’t know, just a kind of daily thing that’s out there, almost kind of acceptable. Teachers know it and students know it. . . . Maybe when our parents were growing up or their parents were growing up, it was a lot tighter and stricter on people cheating. Today it’s just not happening. I think grown-ups have gotten a little bit more with-it in terms of knowing that you’re just going to kind of cheat. . . . It’s almost a big deal if you don’t cheat. . . .” It appears that cheating does not weigh heavily on the conscience of high school students. . . . “People cheat. It doesn’t make you less of a person or worse of a person. There are times when you just are in need of a little help. . . . I think people are going to cheat so it will help them to get into an Ivy League school. . . . You can’t change that; you can’t change people wanting to get the A or whatever. . . . If cheating is going to get you the grade, then that’s the way to do it.”

These comments could have been verbatim records of the conversations I had with students during my study. Others who spent time with midadolescents discovered the same themes. Cheating is rarely seen by midadolescents as a violation of some moral code, but instead is viewed as a pragmatic though potentially risky decision that serves larger, more important goals. Gerald L. Zelizer, in an editorial in USA Today, reported that in a discussion with a handful of high school students he was chastened by a seventeen-year-old: “Don’t you know, rabbi, cheating is pretty much the norm in high school? Besides, most of the teachers don’t really care.” So how bad is it?

In a nationally publicized study conducted by the Josephson Institute of Ethics in the fall of 2002, researchers found that “stealing and lying by high school students have continued their alarming, decade-long upward spiral. A survey of 12,000 high school students showed that students admitting they cheated on an exam at least once in the past year jumped from 61% in 1992 to 74% in 2002. . . . The percentage who say they lied to their teachers and parents also increased substantially.” The methodology the Josephson Institute used consisted of self-report surveys. All this tells us is that 74 percent of those asked admitted to the behavior, and therefore, the number could be even higher. In addition, the way the question was framed implied that cheating is limited to personally and proactively cheating. Cheating has traditionally been defined as allowing someone to cheat from your work as well as allowing the behavior to happen in front of you. If this definition were applied, the number would probably be 90 to nearly 100 percent.

An example of adolescents’ inconsistent understanding of the ethics related to cheating is found in a student’s letter to the editor of the Los Angeles Times in response to the Josephson Institute report:

I am an A student. I budget my time, even though I have basketball practice and don’t arrive home from my bus ride until 6 p.m. But I have had friends tell me that they didn’t study or they didn’t know how to do the work or didn’t try. They anticipate that the kid next to them studied, and they look at that student’s paper. I have on occasion knowingly let someone copy from my paper. It was a smart kid who went blank on a question. I know he studied, so I put my paper to the edge so that he could get a look. Some say that it is not cheating if you don’t get caught. But to me, cheating is cheating, for you are cheating yourself of an opportunity to learn.

In the rest of the letter, the student remained critical of those who cheat who are not smart or do not really care. At the same time, she defended students who are smart by stating that “all types of kids cheat. Some are really smart, but they forget to study.” I shared this letter with several students at the school where I did my study, and in the discussion not one picked up on her inconsistency until I pointed it out. At that point, they admitted that her behavior proved she was, like everyone she disdained, just one more cheater.

Another form of cheating that has been around for a long time but is now presenting a serious threat to the ethical standards of high schools, colleges, and even graduate schools is plagiarism, and it is not even seen by most kids as cheating. Donald McCabe, a professor of management at Rutgers University and founder of the Center for Academic Integrity at Duke University, notes that the internet has provided an unprecedented opportunity for plagiarism: “Copying a few lines from an obscure website into one’s own term paper is not defined by many students as plagiarism,” and more than 70 percent of college students do not consider such an act “serious cheating.” An almost perfect storm of unethical scholastic behavior occurs when three factors converge: ours is a world in which adults and even the media portray relativism as the ethic of the day; ethics are related to self-interest, self-protection, and relational loyalty instead of to rhetorically affirmed moral standards; and the internet offers not merely a wealth of information and resources, but also an abundance of sites that offer essays, term papers, and the like for an affordable fee.

Like lying, cheating is clearly widespread and shows no sign of abating. Unfortunately, most adults agree that we as a culture have reached a point at which it is only an offense when one gets caught. Students in my study admitted that that is how ethics are defined in their world. If someone gets hurt or if one gets caught cheating, then that person is wrong. In the interim, however, the chorus keeps singing, “What is the big deal? So I cheat, so what?”

A final word that must be addressed is how midadolescents perceive and deal with cheating or lying when it involves one another. The assumption in articles, studies, books, and even this chapter is that the object of the deception is almost always an adult or adult institution. The adolescent world, though, is filled with its own deceptive and unethical practices. In my study, however, students were reluctant to talk about how such a breach of trust is handled within the midadolescent community. As I unintentionally bumped into scenarios, I was allowed a glimpse of how this behavior is handled. In general, when there is a violation of trust within a cluster or between friends, a flurry of accusation and counteraccusation takes place, followed by intense neutral party negotiations intended to heal the rift as quickly and as painlessly as possible. In the cases I observed, the conflict subsided as quickly as it erupted, with as little public fanfare as possible. A close group of friends is so committed to maintaining the status quo of stable familylike relationships that the system will not allow an ethical conflict to fester.

I did witness an exception to this when a guy felt he was being pulled to choose between his girlfriend and his cluster. The crowning blow occurred when the cluster perceived that he had lied to them to spend time with his girlfriend. This incident was quickly handled and seemed to blow over, but the sin was not wholly forgiven. Some of the guys in his cluster felt he had violated a sacred ethic—the sanctity of the cluster. Responses ranged from cold shoulders to outright ostracism. In this particular case, the cluster ultimately found a way for him to have a girlfriend and to stay friends.

Conclusion and Musings

In the film The Emperor’s Club, Kevin Kline portrays a private school teacher who fudges the grade of a student to do the boy a favor. Although the teacher was attempting to motivate this wayward student, the boy later cheats during a public competitive exam. The boy grows into a man who functions as a world-class cheater, who views the world as a place in which to take any shortcut to get by. When the teacher realizes that his own cheating had hurt another student by denying that student’s right to participate in the finals of the competition, he apologizes to the spurned student. The irony of the film is that the cheating of the teacher empowered the cheating of the first student. This was not resolved in the film, for the teacher remained the protagonist and the student the villain.

The Emperor’s Club is a poignant reminder of how society has arrived at its current ethical position. To point fingers at the young for their relativism and deception is to display a naïveté of the worst kind. Our efforts at stopping the ethical slide of the young have not worked, although the popular media enjoys stories that seem to suggest that programs are paying off in moral dividends. We may try slogans to reinforce ethical values, such as the “ref in your head” advertising campaign designed “to discourage academic cheating among middle-school youth, ages 10–14 years old.” But until we are willing to present the young with societal ethics, values, and moral choices that are tied to the actual behavior of those who are supposed to lead the young into maturity, we will not be able to affect their ethical processes.

William Damon and others, however, are doing some new and promising research on how moral character grows in the inner life and ultimately in the behavior of a child and adolescent—what is now called moral identity. His program promotes the “community charter,” an effort to surround children and adolescents with caring adults who are committed to their development. The key is the coherency of the messages adults bring to the young. As Damon says,

[Of paramount importance is] the extent to which all of those influences are coherent—the way they present to the child a message or a set of standards that the young person can make sense out of in shaping a moral self, a moral identity. An example of coherence is when parents are imparting the same messages that [other] parents, school, police, peers, media are imparting. Then moral identity can be developed. If all these things are happening, then the kid will be able to ask what kind of person the kid wants to be. If these things are not happening together (community cohesiveness), then there will not be the opportunity to develop moral identity.

A system of ethics is operating in the world of midadolescents. Unfortunately, it is filled with inconsistency, self-centered justice, and relativistic ethical opportunism. Adults who care for the young, however, can make a long-term difference in the lives of students when we allow ourselves to be involved, to engage their ethical and moral belief systems and behaviors. If adults commit to train the young to care for others instead of just themselves and reinforce this view with commitment to integrity and honesty, then we have the best chance of influencing their moral development in a positive way.

↑ Back to top

↑