Summary
6
Multifaith Perspectives: A Reason to Care
Youth Religiosity, Flourishing and the Public Good
Though you’ll not see this answer posed on the TV game show Jeopardy! try your hand at this one:
Answer: This European country’s leaders became so concerned about the terrible mindset and behaviors of their teenagers that they mandated an hour of Christian worship or biblical teaching every day in every classroom in the entire country.
I’ll give you some help (choose one question):
___ What is Belgium?
___ What is Portugal?
___ What is the United Kingdom?
___ What is Slovenia?
Beginning in the late 1960s and continuing into the 1980s it became almost a universal feeling in this country that their teenagers were, well, lost. Purposelessness and despair were the norm, and substance abuse was continuing to rise, and with that criminality.
In the 1980s sociologists from several universities of this country surveyed young people regarding all aspects of their lives and behavior. The effects of income, education, family structure, race, gender and many other possible variables were statistically removed. The researchers were trying to get down to the basic variable or variables that actually made a difference in the lives of youth. What correlates, in a statistically significant way, with prosocial behavior in the youth of that country?
The results were shocking, even to unbiased sociologists. One variable made more difference than any other—by far. Christian faith! And what is the country? The United Kingdom.
Religiosity and Flourishing Youth Are Strongly Linked
In this UK research, youth who possessed a vital Christian faith possessed a cluster of prosocial behavioral and attitudinal dispositions. There was a linear, statistically significant correlation with religiosity and a flourishing life. This faith-prosocial behavior linkage persisted across the categories of race, class, gender and political geography.
Sociologists measure the religious faith of young people in a variety of ways—worship and youth group attendance, reading Scripture, prayer and other indicators of spiritual engagement. These many measures can be combined into a “group score” of sorts and is termed religiosity. Some researchers in the United Kingdom quipped, “Our country either needs to build more prisons, because that’s where our youth are going, or we need to find a way to better support Christianity among young people.”
The Education Act of 1988 declared that every school in the United Kingdom (England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland) would have regular worship experiences and daily religious education. Religious education became part of the core curriculum along with math, science and history. It had been on the books since 1944, but in 1988 it became very important.
It is a fascinating story, especially to any who may be interested in the history of youth ministry.
This requirement for schools to teach religion, however, was very difficult to put into practice at the local level because so few teachers were practicing Christians. In some schools the administration simply parceled out religious education responsibilities to various teachers, who produced materials based on their own knowledge of religion, which apparently included Wicca, Celtic traditional religion, Druidism, Hinduism and others. The Education Act was strengthened in 1994 to specify that the Christian faith was to be taught. At this new Parliamentary directive, many school administrators threw up their hands in despair, and wondered, Is there anyone we could get to do this for us? Do churches, for example, have youth workers who could come in and relieve us of this burden?
Prior to 1994 there were probably only a couple hundred full-time youth pastors in the entire United Kingdom. A few years later there were thousands of them, virtually all of whom do “schools work.” That is, they go to public schools and hold worship and Bible teaching assemblies or teach in specific classes. A massive infrastructure emerged in the United Kingdom to support youth pastors doing schools work. Christian colleges now offer youth-work degrees. There are training conferences, seminars and excellent Web resources (such as schoolswork.co.uk). Those of us in youth ministry in the United States, where it is almost illegal for us to put one foot on a public school campus, fantasize about being welcome at our local high school to teach about the faith and encourage young people to pay attention to this aspect of their lives.
The research findings from the United Kingdom were published in several premier social science journals, and soon sociologists around the globe were asking, “So, there is a correlation between religiosity and prosocial behavior in the United Kingdom. I wonder if the same is true here?”
Yes.
In almost every country on every continent the results are virtually the same: Christian youths who pray often, read the Bible, have a sense of Christ’s presence daily, go to youth group, go to church and youth retreats, have characteristics, variously called assets or protective effects, in greater measure than do their less religious peers.
This connects to our previous discussion on pluralism; youth ministry done from a traditional Christian perspective is often more focused on personal religiosity than modernist or postmodernist youth ministries. In chapter five we saw that one’s theological point of view affects youth ministry praxis. One example in the National Study of Youth and Religion revealed that there are vast denominationally based differences in youth religiosity.
Why should we care? What does it matter whether we have traditional, modern or postmodern youth ministries? If we care about youth flourishing, it matters a great deal.
We will review a bit of a large trove of data related to youth religiosity and prosocial behavior as well as research that demonstrates religious youth groups make a practical difference. Then we will look at data that shows theologically traditional churches produce highly religious youth with a vital Christian faith.
A bit like C. S. Lewis’s conversion. It is well known that C. S. Lewis, an atheist professor at Oxford University, describes his conversion to theism and ultimately to Christianity with the words, “I gave in, and admitted that God was God, and knelt and prayed: perhaps, that night, the most reluctant convert in all England.”
In my university days it was not uncommon for professors to rail against the Christian faith. Sociology professors, beholden to Karl Marx’s atheism, especially saw no place for Christianity (or any religion) in the academy. Those days are gone now. Those professors who were at their prime in the 1960s and 1970s are now retired.
Peter Berger, a well-known sociologist, claimed in 1967 that Christianity was unimportant now and would fade away to near extinction due to the relentless pressure of modernity. He publicly recanted his unbelief at a major gathering of sociologists in 1999, essentially acknowledging that the religiosity-prosocial behavior link was established and that honest sociologists better wake up to reality. Rodney Stark, another high-profile scholar, said to me in a personal interview, “Whereas fifteen years ago it was rare to find a sociologist in an American university who took religion seriously, today the opposite is the case. One hardly finds a sociologist who does not take religion seriously now, though their new respect is sometimes grudging.”
Most universities now, unlike thirty years ago, offer multiple courses on religion and, ironically, sociologists have “found religion.” And what they’ve found is that religion makes a difference in the lives of youth.
Prosocial Behavior and the Youth-Religiosity Link
How is prosocial behavior defined, scaled and measured? In youth religiosity research, prosocial behavior is the absence of something negative or the presence of something positive for the individual. The National Study of Youth and Religion was akin to the major study in the United Kingdom done a decade earlier. The NSYR included a literature review of five hundred US-based studies linking high youth religiosity to, for example, low usage of illegal drugs or high incidence of altruistic volunteerism. The NSYR, with the individual as the unit of analysis, involved interviews with over three thousand adolescents nationwide. Nine variable sets with over two hundred variables were quantified.
Representative variable sets and variables included
1. Risk behaviors and getting into trouble
2. Media consumption
3. Sexual activity
4. Emotional well-being
5. Connection to adults
Each of the two hundred-plus variables measured in the NSYR study is buttressed at a research and conceptual level by studies in the literature that establish the individual asset–individual life outcome link. The following are five examples of variables and how the religiosity link affects behavior and personal outcomes in individual young people.
Youth religiosity and premarital sex. Adolescent premarital sex is a precursor to sexually transmitted diseases, including AIDS, and it is also clearly (and causally) connected to the plight of unwed welfare-dependent teenage mothers. The costs are financial, emotional and quite frequently generational. There is a consistent and statistically significant inverse relationship between adolescent religiosity and premarital sexual experience. For example, in the United States various studies stemming from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth show this inverse link. Sam Hardy and Marcela Raffaelli sampled white, black and Hispanic youth, and showed that the higher the religiosity, the longer the delay in first sexual experience. Looking at the data yet another way, James Nonnemaker, Clea McNeely and Robert Blum confirmed the now decades-long string of studies that the higher the religiosity of youth the lower likelihood their having ever had intercourse. In a study of Mexican American youth in Texas, religiosity was seen as the best predictor of whether the youth in their 413 student sample were sexually active at the present or ever. A major comparative analysis of ten longitudinal studies regarding youth religiosity and sexual behavior found a consistent inverse correlation with religiosity and female premarital sex in all ten studies. The picture was less clear for adolescent males. Among the most recent studies (2011) is a longitudinal study among teenage virgins that again affirmed that religiosity was associated with the delay in genital touching, oral sex and coitus.
Does high religiosity mean lower premarital sexual activity outside the United States? A study among late-teenage youth in Australia and South Africa had similar results as US studies. Another study, this time among black South African youth only, showed significantly less sexual activity among youth who were high in religiosity.
Is youth religiosity important? Insofar as it reduces teenage premarital sex, the answer is clearly yes. The same is true when it comes to substance abuse.
Youth religiosity and substance abuse. The high social cost of drunk and drugged teenagers is evident almost daily in the popular press. The deleterious impact of smoking on health is well established. The use of these controlled substances by teenagers is seen as a problem by governments and schools. Since this is a high-profile issue, social scientists have engaged in a variety of studies with religiosity as one or more of the independent variables with either direct or indirect effects on youth alcohol, drug and tobacco use.
Researches have given great attention to the urban African American youth population. In a sample of 2,300 urban, poor, black youth, the more they attended church and youth group, the less likely they were to experiment or become controlled-substance users. This correlation held true not only for the younger youth (ages 9-10) but the older youth (ages 18-19) as well. In a similar vein Sung Juon Jang, Bryon Johnson, David Larson and Spencer De’Li found that the power of religious faith and involvement grew throughout adolescence. That is, religious young people in the urban core of US cities were less likely to use illicit drugs, and the older the religious young person, the less likely he or she use controlled substances. In a much earlier study, Stephen Burket explored the direct and indirect effects of parents’ religiosity compared to the religiosity of the adolescent. What would be the strongest factor keeping a young person from alcohol abuse? The religiosity of the teenager was most important, whereas the religiosity of the parents had only an indirect effect and a diminishing one at that.
In the social sciences a meta-analysis is a study of other studies. An example of a very ambitious meta-analysis published in Psychological Reports looked at twenty-two major studies that all came to the same basic conclusion: in young people the higher the religiosity, the higher the “protective effect” when it came to controlled substances: alcohol, cigarettes, marijuana and other illegal drugs. That is, youth with a highly active and real faith were less likely to experiment with or become a user of these controlled substances.
In the United Kingdom, Ian Sutherland and John Shepherd looked at a host of substance abuse issues with 451 eleven- to sixteen-year-olds from five schools. Religiosity was correlated negatively with substance abuse, and the effect became more pronounced the older the youth. Similar results were shown in former communist-block Hungary, where outward forms of religiosity were illegal up until 1989. In a study of 1,240 youth in Szeged, high religiosity meant lower substance abuse.
Youth religiosity and social bonding and attachment. Social bonding and attachment are closely linked to youth flourishing. Youth groups serve as venues for social bonding. Many youth groups provide a dizzying array of subgroups to take part in. There might be Sunday school, a weekly small group ministry, a discipleship/accountability group, a basketball team, a worship band, a drama ministry or worship dance team. In religious youth groups the potential for peer disapproval of negative behavior is very high. Peer disapproval is another way to express the concept of Émile Durkheim’s “attachment to groups” or the notion of the social bond. Durkheim’s description of morality is germane to student ministry praxis and understanding the theoretical link between belief, bonding and behavior. For Durkheim morality does not exist within an individual unless he or she feels strong attachment to a group (or groups). The person must carry in his or her mind a collection of social facts. Social facts are recurrent aspects of human behavior that provide an ordered framework or set of rules in which people function. A social fact is external. It is outside and independent of the individual.
Second, morality is “constraining in character”; that is, a person aware of a certain social fact would feel a sense of wrongdoing should the fact be ignored. Attachment to the group means the person will not act in a way that will damage or hurt the social group. This attachment, in normative socialization, begins with the family and expands to school, other groups (like a religious youth group) and eventually society. The person who is aware of what a group expects and is committed to avoid violating, displeasing or confusing others within the social group will behave in a moral fashion vis-à-vis that social group. When a person is not properly attached to a group, that is, he or she lacks awareness of social facts, this person is likely to behave in a manner that the group sees as wrong. Attachment and social bonding has proven to be a huge and fertile field for sociologists. Social bonding correlates positively with behavior that is good for society, and more recently it has been shown to correlate positively with youth religiosity.
Social bonding is a personal feeling of connectedness to peers, family, school, a common interest group or community. Andrew Cherry studied junior high school students in one Delaware town and found that the more connected kids felt to the school and its groups, the more socially constructive their behavior. Another study involving one thousand junior high students in Rochester, New York, found that attachment to parents, school and teachers was a significant determinant of decreased at-risk behavior compared to young people who were not so well attached to others. The greater the attachment, the less delinquency and drug use. These findings support a 1992 study in Ohio that also tested the association of attachment to school and teachers with delinquent behaviors. Higher religiosity correlated with higher social bonding (and lower delinquency) in a major study by Johnson, Jang, Larson and De’Li.
Adolescent bonding with parents is strongly correlated with academic success, and a host of studies demonstrate that youth high in religiosity are more likely to have healthy bonding with their parents. For example, in Sweden a study of 196 youth showed that religiously active youth were more bonded to their parents than their secular peers. Similar results were found in the urban context of the United States.
Another study of 2,300 teenagers randomly selected in a national sample found that youth religiosity spilled over into school activity participation rates. For example, kids highly active in church were more involved in school clubs (83%) than their church inactive peers (44%), their school sports participation was slightly higher (67% to 63%), school music participation more than twice as high (75% to 34%) and so was their involvement in other school activities (49% to 30%). Highly religious kids were much more likely to do more than six hours homework per week (69% to 47%).
Youth religiosity and emotional and mental health. Who doesn’t want to see young people experience a positive sense of self, be empowered and have the ability to get over the normal setbacks and crises that are part of teenage life? Youth religiosity is highly and positively associated with resilience in adolescents.
One meta-analysis of US-based research revealed a convergence of similar results correlating a vital religious life with outcomes such as purpose in life, the ability to forgive and to move on, and a sense of well-being. Mental health professionals show a keen interest in such research. One does not have to work long in adolescent social services, counseling or adolescent psychiatric wards to wonder why some kids are so troubled while others seem to face similar life setbacks without much difficulty. In nonscholarly terms, youths with a vital faith have something their less-religious peers do not possess.
As with other youth religiosity research the results are similar around the globe. The following abstract from a recently published study in the United Kingdom is typical.
Most studies show that religion is a protective factor for mental health. A few argue that it is detrimental and the remainder conclude it makes no difference. We investigate the religiosity correlates of childhood psychopathology—strength of belief, importance of being able to practice one’s religion, and worship frequency. Questions on religiosity were included in the mental health survey of children in Great Britain administered to 2992 11-19 year-olds in 2007. The Development and Well-Being Assessment was used to generate rates of clinically recognizable mental disorders. Logistic regression analysis was used to establish the magnitude of the religiosity correlates of emotional and conduct disorders. Young people with a stated religion who had weakly held beliefs or who regarded religious practice as unimportant were those with the greater likelihood of having emotional disorders. Regular attendance at religious services or prayer meetings reduced the likelihood of having a conduct disorder.
In São Paulo, Brazil, an interesting study was conducted among 325 incarcerated teenagers. The research involved first assessing their exposure to community violence, such as a neighbor, friend, sibling or parent being the victims of beating, torture, or murder. They then surveyed religiosity, focusing on both the interior sense of God in prayer and their past exterior participation in organized religious expression (worship). Finally, each young person was given an extensive mental health survey and interview. They concluded, “religiosity may indeed buffer the relation between violence exposure and certain mental health problems.”
Youth religiosity and personal morality/moral reasoning. We have reviewed a tiny slice of social science research regarding adolescent religiosity and its behavioral and attitudinal outcomes. Aspects of the research we have looked at measure the evidence of personal morality and moral reasoning (e.g., sexual behavior, drug usage). Yet another category of social science research seeks to measure adolescent moral reasoning itself and how this moral reasoning (or lack thereof) affects behavior.
Though there is not a vast literature proving that church youth groups produce personal morality and moral reasoning in young people, we can confidently proceed for several reasons. First, we know that from the previously cited studies, personal morality is a component of religiosity and makes a difference in behavior. Second, church youth groups teach and model personal morality. Whether the youth leaders are coming from a traditional, modern or postmodern perspective, we can assume that personal morality is modeled and either latently or explicitly taught. Third, fostering personal morality is an explicitly stated goal of many denominational youth ministries.
Lawrence Kohlberg’s famous work regarding moral development began in the late 1960s and continued through the 1980s. Morality, according to Kohlberg, develops at three levels, each with two stages. While many are familiar with the Kohlberg’s stages, a key point critical to the “good for society” discussion should not be overlooked. He believes there is a positive benefit for society as more people ascend the stages of moral reasoning. His research reveals what triggers moral growth:“The more social settings encourage role taking, voluntary participation, communication, and decision making, the more individuals confronted with these settings will advance to higher stages of moral consciousness.”
This is exactly what many youth groups do. They are young people doing what they do best: socialize with their peers. Youth groups are social settings par excellence. Decision making is central. Participation is voluntary. While “parental constraint” may account for the presence of a young person in Sunday school, kids participate in religious youth groups because they want to. And communication—adult to youth, youth to youth and youth to adult—is central. This communication is often about spiritual matters, but as often it is about life-world experiences played out on the stage of daily life.
In chapter five we saw that those youth pastors who eschewed infant baptism were much more likely to have some kind of youth leadership structure in which young people are empowered to make decisions. One large youth ministry (traditional perspective) in New York City, for example, has many extracurricular activities for their kids, including various sports teams, dance groups, bands, choirs, and literary and social service action groups. Most of these are led not by adults but by older youth (ages 18-20). The drama group decides how to best illustrate a point in the youth pastor’s pending sermon. The music and dance groups plan how to support the theme of the morning. These kids feel empowered, and younger ones look forward to being able to step into leadership. These activities create strong peer pressure for kingdom-related aspiration and achievement.
In my judgment, if one were to imagine an ideal type of social setting to move a young person from one moral stage to the next, it would be difficult to envision anything better than the religious youth group.
We have reviewed literature that reveals there are positive behavioral, health and dispositional outcomes associated the vital faith. Youth groups contribute both to personal religiosity and attachment and moral reasoning. These outcomes contribute to the public good. Youth workers can be doubly thankful: their work is good for the kingdom and for their community.
Denominational Differences in Adolescent Vital Faith Creation
The National Study of Youth and Religion asked students questions about their personal religiosity that provide a nuanced understanding of their interior spirituality (see table 6.1). Some questions asked reveal that conservative Protestant youth were higher in religious experience and expression. Mainline Protestant youth were stronger in some areas. Generally, Roman Catholic youth were some distance behind their Protestant peers.
Table 6.1. Personal Religious Practices, US Adolescents, Ages 13 to 17
In the past year, the teen has
US
CP
MP
RC
practiced spiritual meditation not including prayer
10%
8%
10%
10%
been part of a prayer, or Bible group at school
15%
25%
17%
8%
taught Sunday school or its equivalent
20%
28%
26%
15%
burned candle or incense that had spiritual meaning
21%
14%
24%
35%
fasted as a spiritual discipline
24%
22%
25%
29%
been part of any other Bible or prayer group
27%
42%
31%
17%
played or sang in a Christian youth band or youth choir
28%
37%
35%
18%
read a devotional or spiritual book other than Bible
30%
45%
28%
22%
spoken publicly about their faith
30%
42%
33%
20%
attended a religious music concert
34%
51%
51%
20%
shared their faith with someone not of their faith
43%
56%
51%
37%
listened to Christian music (any media)
51%
70%
52%
35%
worked hard to reconcile a broken relationship
59%
61%
63%
61%
prays alone at least once a day, often more
38%
49%
32%
33%
(US = all US youth, CP = conservative Protestants, MP = mainline Protestants, RC = Roman Catholic)
Source: Adapted from Christian Smith and Melinda Denton, Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), p. 46.
The following Protestant denominations had high enough participation numbers for researchers to be able to make statistically significant comparisons: Assemblies of God (AG), Disciples of Christ (DC), Episcopal Church USA (ECUSA), Evangelical Lutheran Church of America (ELCA), Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod (LCMS), Presbyterian Church USA (PCUSA), Southern Baptist Convention (SBC), United Methodist Church (UMC), black Baptists (BB, 3 denoms.), Church of God in Christ (COGIC). Table 6.2 reveals that denominations whose youth ministry praxis leans traditional tend to produce young people with a higher sense of vital faith.
Table 6.2. Percent of Youth, by Denomination, Feeling Very or Extremely Close to God Most of the Time
Assemblies of God
53
Disciples of Christ
38
Evangelical Covenant
22
Evangelical Lutheran
43
Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod
48
Presbyterian Church USA
45
Southern Baptist Convention
49
United Methodist
38
black Baptist
55
Church of God in Christ
48
conservative Protestant
46
mainline Protestant
36
black Protestant
48
all Protestant
44
all teenagers
38
Table 6.3. Percent of Youth, by Denomination, in Which Faith Is Very or Extremely Important in Shaping Daily Life
Assemblies of God
77
Disciples of Christ
47
Evangelical Covenant
40
Evangelical Lutheran
61
Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod
54
Presbyterian Church USA
55
Southern Baptist Convention
72
United Methodist
45
black Baptist
76
Church of God in Christ
91
conservative Protestant
64
mainline Protestant
43
black Protestant
69
all Protestant
60
all teenagers
51
It is interesting to note that the more conservative of the Lutheran denominations (LCMS) has slightly higher results than its less conservative counterpart (ELCA). The Episcopal Church lags behind all the other denominations in the “sense of God’s closeness” category.
When it comes to faith being very or extremely important in daily life, we see in table 6.3 that more than 50 percent of the youth in all the conservative churches indicated this was true in their lives. Mainline churches were less strong in this regard.
Another way to capture a sense of the interiority of adolescent spiritual life is their response to whether they experience answered prayer and a sense of direct guidance from God (see table 6.4).
Table 6.4. Answered Prayer or Direct Guidance from God
Assemblies of God
57
Disciples of Christ
44
Evangelical Covenant
32
Evangelical Lutheran
56
Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod
46
Presbyterian Church USA
59
Southern Baptist Convention
66
United Methodist
49
black Baptist
76
Church of God in Christ
55
conservative Protestant
65
mainline Protestant
46
black Protestant
60
all Protestant
59
all teenagers
51
Once again real differences are apparent. Fifty percent or more of the youth of some mainline and all conservative denominations sense God’s guidance and answered prayer. The Episcopal church young people, however, lag in this regard.
Summary
In this chapter we saw that sociologists have established a correlation between youth religiosity and positive behaviors and mental health. These outcomes not only have personal significance but are important to a community. Youth religiosity research also shows a disparity among denominations in this regard. Conservative denominations and churches tend to produce more highly religious youth.
Regardless of our denominational ties, we all want to see youth flourish spiritually. Chapter seven will examine how we can facilitate a vital Christian identity among students.
