The Positive Doubt Perspective
1
The Rise of Youth Ministry in Other Religions
A Good Thing for Christian Youth Work?
For better or worse, I receive a lot of opportunities to speak and teach about all kinds of things related to youth and youth ministry. Recently, I led a seminar with the title “Muslim Youth Ministry . . . Coming Your Direction.” There were probably seventy-five persons present, two of whom left in a huff after five minutes when they realized I was not “Muslim bashing.” About an hour into the presentation I was making the point that in the United Kingdom many youth pastors actually look for opportunities to get Christian and Muslim youth groups together for joint projects (e.g., to raise money for disaster relief). They do this thinking that Christianity “wins” when placed side by side with Islam, and that both Christian and Muslim young people will see this as they become acquainted with one another. (We’ll talk a lot more about that notion in chapter two.)
A youth pastor from Michigan raised his hand and said, “Yes, he’s right! We have Muslim students showing up in our youth group meetings all the time. After a while many of these Muslim young people will say something like ‘Wow, I had no idea Christianity was this good.’” He went on to say, “We didn’t understand at first, but we (both adult volunteers and kids in our group) now ‘get it’ bigtime that there is no concept of grace in Islam, and that it is all a matter of self-effort. We find that over time Muslims in our youth group connect the dots and they’re, well, they’re astonished really.” There were a half dozen other Michigan youth pastors sitting with him and several of them affirmed, “That’s what happened in our youth group too. And it has really helped our students know and appreciate their faith.”
At first hearing, the idea can be a real shocker. I have come to believe the presence of youth and youth ministries from other religions just may well be a very good thing for the Christian church, the Christian family and the Christian youth group.
We will first take a look at non-Christian religious youth ministry in the United States and beyond. Many of these same developments are occurring in other Western countries as well. We will also consider the social science research that reveals a tested or challenged faith is better.
Other Religions in the United States
Demographers, sociologists and cultural anthropologists are fascinated by the mixing of the world’s peoples through migration and the global culture spawned by technology. The rise of other religions in the United States is certainly not as huge as in some other countries. For example, in Australia there are now more Buddhists than Baptists, more Muslims than Lutherans, more Hindus than Jews, and four times as many witches than Quakers. In the United States 60 percent of the population will affirm that religion plays an important part of their lives. In France that number is 11 percent. Tracking religious affiliation in the United States is not as straightforward as in many other countries because the US Census does not include any questions about religion. The United Kingdom, for example, routinely includes a religious affiliation question as part of the decinal census. In the United States researchers glean the information not from the census but from General Social Survey (GSS) conducted by the National Opinion Research Center (NORC) of the University of Chicago.
Table 1.1. Religious Affiliation of US Population
Christian
78%
none
16.4%
Jewish
1.8%
Buddhist
1.2%
Muslim
0.9%
Hindu
0.6%
other
0.6%
folk religion
0.2%
Source: “Religious Composition by Country,” Pew Research Religion & Public Life Project, accessed March 21, 2013, www.pewforum.org/uploadedFiles/Topics/Religious_Affiliation/globalReligion-tables.pdf.
NORC uses statistical sampling techniques to arrive at numbers that represent what can be understood as true for the whole country. Many researchers use additional surveys such as the Religious Identification Survey to corroborate or expand the General Social Survey results. See table 1.1 for the most recent GSS based numbers available on US religious affiliation.
So we see there are other religions in America, but do their adherents have any notion or cultural vocabulary parallel or equivalent to the concept of adolescence as we understand it?
Religions and “Youth” as a Cultural Concept
French sociologist Michael Mitterauer is most certainly correct in his observation that in all cultures and in all epochs of human existence a span of time known as “youth” has existed. Its beginning and ending markers have varied among cultures, but every culture and every religion has recognized those who are clearly not children but also clearly not adults.
The Bible. A good example of this cultural understanding of “youth” in an ancient context is our own Old and New Testaments. The word na῾ar is used forty-five times in the Old Testament and is translated as “youth” in our English Bibles. Remarkably, there are twin positions on youth in the Old Testament Scriptures. On the one hand na῾ar is a time that people do things they regret later in life. On the other, it is a time to set a positive pattern for life. For example, David implores the Lord, “Do not remember the sins of my youth” (Ps 25:7). Another time the psalmist affirms “Since my youth, God, you have taught me, and to this day I declare your marvelous deeds” (Ps 71:17). Job, whose very bad day turned into a very bad year, speculates about the reason for his sudden misfortune. Looking heavenward with a sigh, he says, “You write down bitter things against me and make me reap the sins of my youth” (Job 13:26). And pity those poor male na῾arim, forty-two of them to be exact, who make the terrible mistake of commenting on the prophet Elisha’s lack of hair. Elisha curses those boys in the name of the Lord, whereupon two bears appear and certainly ruin their day (2 Kings 2:23-25).
The twin stance on “youth” carries forward into the New Testament, where the word neotēs is used five times and the related words neōterikos and neanias are used once each. Paul urges Timothy to “flee the evil desires of youth” (2 Tim 2:22) but at the same time encourages him with the words “Don’t let anyone look down upon you because you are young, but be an example for the believers” (1 Tim 4:12).
So Christians have a heritage of viewing youth as a specially demarcated time in a person’s life. But what about other religions in America? Do they have a term equivalent to the English youth? How do these religions conceptualize adolescence and how to they promote and protect the faith of their own sons and daughters? In other words, how do they do youth ministry?
Islam’s understanding of childhood and adolescence. In the sacred text of Islam, the Qur’an, two important milestones of maturity are recognized. The term b’lum captures the concept of psychological maturity, and a’sudd, which is closely associated with it, carries with it the right to conduct business and the duty to fulfill religious obligations, which are (1) the declaration of faith, “There is no God but God and Mohammed is His Prophet,” (2) praying five designated times a day, (3) giving alms to the poor, (4) fasting from before sunrise until sunset during the month of Ramadan, and (5) making the pilgrimage to Mecca, if one can afford it. Those who have achieved b’lum and a’sudd are expected to engage in these five obligations side by side with other adults in the community.
The Arabic language contains four additional words, not found in the Qur’an, that cumulatively define “youth” or adolescence. Bulugh is the Arabic equivalent to the English concept of puberty. It refers also to the growth of pubic hair and the distinctive smell of the armpit of both sexes. Once a young person begins to evidence reflective reason and discernment, he or she is gaining ‘aql. The person who is acquiring ‘aql can see his or her self acting in relation to others. However, this rise of social self-awareness, which is so prominent in Western theories of adolescence, is of only minor importance in Arab cultures, where the primary focus is family, kin and one’s place in this constellation of primary relationships. A further term in the Arabic language, rush’d, captures the attainment of “reason guided maturity of thought and action, particularly in religious and moral matters.” One who is growing in the attainment of rush’d is seen more as an adult than as (the fourth Arabic term) shabb (youth). The conceptual framework for understanding and describing youth exists, then, in the Arabic language and in Islam. Yetkin Yildirim summarizes Islamic theology:
Islam teaches that every child is born sinless and is certain to gain paradise if he or she passes away before reaching puberty. Children are viewed as precious gifts from God and need to be taken care of and protected by their parents and their surrounding communities. The primary way for children to attain spiritual development is to observe the personal spiritual practices of adults in their surrounding communities. Therefore, Islam not only gives these people the responsibility for the spiritual wellbeing of children, but also makes them accountable.
Muslim youth work. In my studies and travels I have noticed that formal youth ministry as we understand it does not exist in Islamic majority countries. However, in the West, where Muslims are a tiny minority and the social structures of the old world have frayed (if not collapsed altogether), Muslims are making considerable effort to provide for the unique needs of those who have entered bulugh but have not yet attained rush’d.
There are 1,947 mosques in the United States, and of that number 350 of them (18%) have some kind of youth program or functioning youth ministry. Muslim youth ministry has a regional and national infrastructure. For example, the Muslim Youth Association of North America has a paid national staff, which puts on national and regional training events for Muslim youth workers (paid and volunteer). They also facilitate events for Muslim young people. Leadership training is a huge priority in all Muslim youth work, and these events are analogous to Christian youth ministry events such as the National Youth Workers Convention by Youth Specialties and Simply Youth Ministry by Group. Though Muslim youth work bands and music have been slow to emerge on the US scene, they are now a normal feature of most gatherings.
Mosque-based youth ministry usually has a program mix similar to Christian youth groups. Teaching is done in a variety of ways, either large group gatherings (such as in a mosque in Alexandria, Virginia, which hosts weekly “Pizza and Prophets” night, or in the “knowledge circle” small group approach taken by a mosque near Toronto). Sports and recreation is a normal feature in larger and more developed Muslim youth groups, such as the Islamic Society of Greater Lansing (Michigan), which offers sports leagues and tournaments. Leadership development is always a feature of regional and national Muslim youth work, but it also occurs at the local level, such as the Taric Youth Committee of a mosque in the Upper Midwest. Service projects round out the program of most well-developed youth ministries, such as the King Fahd Mosque of Culver City, California, which regularly does hospital visitation as well as senior center visitation. (We will look at Islamic youth ministry in much greater detail in chapter two.)
Hindu understanding of childhood and adolescence. The masses that populate the giant Indian subcontinent are in one sense a people steeped in tradition, and in another sense they are a people in social and cultural transition. The modern age has come to India, and with it a swelling middle class. The traditional extended family is a self-sufficient economic unit, with agriculture, fishing or crafts comprising its productive focus. In the extended family, roles and status are explicitly and securely demarcated by age, sex and kinship. Youth know their place, which is bound by this sticky web of relationships in the family and village. As a child grows she or he learns the skills necessary to function as an adult in the constellation of relationships that form the family and the village. There is no need for free association with other youths outside this small world, as even marriage is arranged on behalf of (but not necessarily for the benefit or pleasure of) the growing young person.
As Aileen Ross has pointed out, the emergence in India of the middle class, and the concomitant necessity of an educational infrastructure to prepare young people for work in the modern world, has brought about a nuclear family structure, which is supplanting the traditional structure. Where fathers and mothers are employed outside the home, the children go to school all day, and the backdrop is not the village but the city or suburb; “the father’s authority tends to equalize with that of his wife, and children become more independent of parental control, and . . . agencies such as schools and youth organizations develop [which] impinge on the former total authority of parent over child.” In this context youth are not workers in the household economy but individuals preparing for their own freely chosen careers. This has become a big issue in India and even more so for the families of Indian background who have emigrated to Western countries.
Adherents of Hinduism, no matter where they live, believe in karma and reincarnation. This has profound implication for their view of children and adolescents; all children have spirituality already within them from their previous lives, and all that is required is to awaken that spirituality as the children age.
One of the priorities of adult Hindus is to fulfill the obligations in this life to ensure they are making progress toward betterment in the next. Among these important and necessary duties is to help children and youth with their dharma, karma and rina. Dharma has to do with conscious spirituality; karma deals, in part, with sacred rituals that provide further connection to the gods and spiritual enlightenment; and rina is the notion of being responsible.
Thus adults are obliged to help facilitate the emerging spirituality of their children and other youth.
Hindu youth work. As in all major religions in the United States, Hindu youth work is organized nationally, regionally and locally.
The Hindu Swayamsevak Sangh organization seeks to resource Hindu families with specific age-appropriate activities and spiritual events. It assumes that practicing Hindus in every community have found each other and are in mutually supportive relationships. Regarding Hindus in America, their website declares,
The uniqueness of Hindu Dharma and the culture as practiced by the Hindu community has a significant contribution to make for the benefit of humanity. It is therefore essential for Hindus living in America to develop unity and harmony in their community to effectively promote these salient features. There are around two million Hindus in the US. Their contributions to the economic, social and cultural life are widely acclaimed.
Chapters are found in every state.
Tattva, an online magazine for youth, was launched by the Swayamsevak Sangh organization and is a high-production spread with a variety of features of interest to Hindu high school and university age young people. Tattva means “essence” and, as such, tries to support the inner life and inner quest of Hindu youth as they learn about themselves and the Hindu religion.
There are two hundred Hindu temples in the United States. Most states have at least one. California has the highest number of temples, followed by New York, New Jersey and Texas. Only a handful of temples have websites, but we can get a feel for temple-based Hindu youth ministry through the lens of the temple in Livermore, California. In 2001 this temple established a cultural center whose first mission is to promote Hindu religious education appropriate to children and youth. Subsequently, their programs have expanded to include music and dance, both of which are vital parts of worship in the temple.
Buddhist understanding of childhood and adolescence. Buddhism is the predominant religion of Japan. Being a modern country and culture, there is a Japanese understanding and cultural stance toward youth and young people. It must be acknowledged, however, that Eastern religion is difficult to understand by those from the West or of monotheistic religions. Winston Davis acknowledges this difficulty and proposes a hermeneutical bridge that, once established, helps sociologists (and hopefully us) to understand religious affiliation, at least in the Buddhist framework. Much of the religious activity or affiliation in Buddhism is instrumental in nature; that is, one goes to the shrine in order to achieve some good luck or fulfill a perceived obligation. While “religion” is present, in no respects is it on the Buddhist mind as it is in Christianity or Islam.
Buddhists admire and acknowledge children not as individuals but as wonderful metaphors for a life of simplicity and spiritual essence. As in Hinduism, Buddhism sees all life as part of a cycle, and thus children and youth have in-built spirituality that will eventually appear. The Four Noble Truths of Buddhism—(1) life as suffering, (2) suffering comes from craving what is impermanent, (3) suffering ceases through the extinction of craving, and (4) the path that keeps one from craving—can be understood intuitively by an individual as he or she matures. Programming specifically designed for young people is almost nonexistent within Buddhism. One researcher noted that in North America the children of Buddhist immigrants rarely remain Buddhist after they pass age eighteen. There seems to be no official concern about generation-to-generation transfer of Buddhism.
Buddhist youth work. A rare exception to the lack of Buddhist concern for the religious education of youth can be seen at the Orange County Buddhist Church in Southern California. It gives every impression of being a temple on steroids when it comes to child, adolescent and family-centered programming, which is as extensive as any Protestant megachurch. From their website comes the invitation “From Ikebana, to the Digital Media Center—There are so many ways to get involved at OCBC. Take a look at what OCBC has to offer with our Social Groups, Cultural Groups, Sports Programs, Scouting and Youth Groups.”
From the root of Buddhism has sprung a new branch that takes a more intentional stance regarding young people. Soka Gakkai International, headquarted in Japan, is an international association of over seventy Soka Gakkai centers that aim to “realize the absolute happiness (enlightenment) of individuals and the prosperity of each country by the spreading understanding of the Buddhism of Nichiren. Toward that end, the SGI engages in various activities to promote peace, culture and education based on True Buddhism.” There are thirty-three Soka Gakkai centers in the United States, and all feature youth groups, Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts, and other youth-related programming. They also sponsor annual festivals and retreats. They have recently added full-time youth workers to their headquarters staff to increase their footprint in the United States among high school and university age young people.
Jewish understanding of childhood and adolescence. Children are highly prized in Jewish religion, culture and tradition. To have children is a sign of God’s blessing, and raising children is a high honor. In the words of Michael Shire,
Childhood itself is an important state of being in Judaism, signified both by the cherished status of children in the classical literature and by the child-parent relationship that epitomizes the way in which the human-divine relationship is understood. Childhood is a symbolic depiction reflecting the special covenant between God and the People of Israel, which is characterized as a parent-child relationship.
Within Judaism pre-adulthood is a time of learning to carry out the Ten Commandments and observing one’s religious duty, both of which come into full play at age thirteen, the age of moral maturity, through the rite-of-passage bar mitzvah (for boys) or bat mitzvah (for girls). The rite is not like a commodity to be attained or something on a list to be checked off. Rather, it is something one becomes as well as something the community bestows. The parents and the believing community are responsible to help a young person live into this reality.
Jewish youth work. The B’nai B’rith Youth Association (BBYO) is one of many national Jewish organizations that seeks to engage middle school and high school Jewish young people. There are forty local offices throughout the United States. Their location depends on the Jewish population of the region. For example, Westchester Country, New York, just north of New York City, has an active program and extensive staff. By contrast, less-populated Arizona, Nevada and Utah have one BBYO. Each region is divided into local chapters, which offer a range of meetings, programs and events.
For university students, the Jewish Student Association functions on all Ivy League campuses and most major universities nationwide. Harvard’s JSA mission is “To serve as a resource to develop, inform, support, and enrich the Jewish community on campus. Our goals are to encourage student participation in Jewish events, build stronger ties among Jewish students and nearby Jewish organizations, and foster a sense of community.”
The BBYO and JSA are only two among many Jewish youth organizations. Others are local only or are based on conservative theology or practice. All are aimed at fostering “community,” which is so vital in retaining and maintaining the Jewishness of its children.
Other religions’ influence on Christian youth ministry. How does the youth ministry of other religions apply to Christian youth ministry?
Not long ago religious “others” lived overseas. Unless North Americans lived in major metropolitan areas, they experienced people of other religions only through books and magazines like National Geographic. Not so today. It is likely that students in our youth ministries will know someone from another religion. They may share a locker with a Muslim, sit next to a Buddhist in class or have a Hindu teammate.
And as our young people mature cognitively, they may wonder whether we Christians actually believe their non-Christian friend is going to hell. This should force us to be clear about our Christology, helping our young people know what we believe, why we believe and why it makes sense to believe what we do. In chapter seven we will look at helpful resources and how other youth workers approach this vital subject.
Here we will look at two other ways the rise of other religious youth ministries may be a good thing for Christian youth ministry. We will briefly look at the marketplace and positive doubt perspectives.
Other Religions’ Youth Ministry as Competition for Market Share
While Christian youth ministry appears far more organized and developed, other religious traditions are catching up, finding their own young people responsive to the methods Christians use. In the North American context other religions are becoming increasingly aware that, unlike in their home countries, they exist in a free market of religious ideas and opportunities. They must compete or risk seeing their own youth converted by the sophisticated programs and techniques offered by Christian youth ministry. Seeing their own children as religious consumers, then, has forced these religions to become more adept at being religious producers. This “rational choice” vocabulary explains why especially Islam, Judaism and Hinduism have adopted the Christian approach to youth and youth ministry.
From this perspective, given the market nature of free religious association among North American youth, as other religions improve their own youth ministry “products,” Christian youth ministry must keep its competitive edge through innovation and improvement. For years Christian youth groups have happily accepted into their ranks youth of other faith traditions, and sometimes the parents of these youth have followed them into the church as well. There is no market law that precludes the reversal of this flow: other religions might leapfrog Christian youth ministry, resulting in the youth (and perhaps their parents) to begin flowing in the opposite direction.
In North American it seems that the vast majority of Jewish and Hindu youth ministries merely seek to conserve their own youth. The same is true of Buddhist youth work, what there is of it. Soka Gakkai, though, is much more outreach focused. As for Muslim youth work, about half of their youth group websites mention dawa events, which focus on outreach. A dawa event is not for the spiritual growth of Muslim young people but rather a venue for Muslim youth to bring their non-Muslim friends—an entry-level, no pressure “come and have fun with us and see that we’re normal” opportunity. Does that sound familiar?
Most of us will not give this much thought until something like a megamosque is built down the street or next door to our own church. This very thing happened two years ago to a friend in New Jersey. The mosque next door has two full-time youth workers. They are showing up at the local high school sporting events, volunteering to help with drama club and offering their help to the PTA. In other words they are using all the tools Christian youth workers use to build bridges of influence with young people and their parents. My friend understands that on his high school campus the question no longer is how attractive a Baptist youth group is compared to the Assemblies or Presbyterian youth groups. The playing field has changed dramatically. Now Christian youth ministry is compared to Muslim youth ministry!
The Positive Doubt Perspective
While most of our students will not have to choose between their youth group and going to “Pizza and Prophets” with their friend Rashid, they may experience doubt about Jesus as the only way as they are repeatedly confronted with the new cultural norm of tolerance or the repugnant thought of their volleyball team member facing eternity in hell simply because he or she was born into a Hindu family.
Cognitive development, what I call the cerebral upgrade (see chap. 7), commonly includes a revisiting of things once held true. That new mental power, due to the completed wiring of the prefrontal cortex, makes all things new to the person. Picture being in a room with no doors or windows (the childhood brain). Then (as the cerebral upgrade happens), boom, there’s a window! Three weeks later there’s another one! And what’s that? It’s a door! These new portals to the outside world invite exploration.
I counsel parents, when their son or daughter expresses doubt about God or something important, that their heart response should be “Thank God!” This young brain is getting upgraded, which is how God created this brain to function.
Awareness of other religions is like a new window or door that was not previously there. These things call into question previously held assumptions. This is an important and necessary step in the spiritual formation of our youth.
When I do small group processing of issues related to God and faith, I often ask my college freshmen Intro to Youth Ministry students, “At what point did your faith become your own? That is, do you see your Christian faith as a carryover of what your parents told you, or has there come a point when you realized it is now your faith, not theirs? Be honest. Tell me your story.”
Their answers are very interesting. Most have to do with suffering or externally triggered doubt. Suffering fosters the question, Can a good God be that mean or uncaring? Tolerance training at school or the awareness of good people who are religious “others” can foster the response, Yikes, does what I believe make any sense in the real world?
I want my youth group students to know and understand that other teenagers their age who are Muslim and Hindus are very happy with their faith, just like we are. This forces the construction of a new window or door in their cognitive room.
To really get a feel for what is happening when it comes to the youth ministry of other religions, let’s take a close look at Islam.
