Conclusion
9
A Multifaith Pastoral Theology
Presence and Power in Youth Work
I love to design and carry out ministry programs that are explicitly outreach oriented. That is, I’m looking for on-ramps to the Christian faith that students of no faith, syncretistic faith or other faiths can travel. I’ve made many mistakes in the process. Some of these mistakes are funny now; some of them will never be. Here are two examples.
I’m probably the only youth worker in all of history to hold a youth retreat in a house of prostitution.
Thinking back, the sign behind the registration desk did strike me as odd: “No illegal activities allowed on the premises.” Having confirmed that the motel had received our full payment in the mail a month earlier, I walked back out to help the senior highers unload the church bus. The retreat was going great. We had slept on the floor of a church near Whistler Mountain, British Columbia, on Friday night, skied all day Saturday, and were excited about the rest of the weekend in the beautiful city of Vancouver. City Motel was now our headquarters.
A police car roared in from Main Street and stopped a yard from me. The officer got out and approached. Looking confused or lost or something, he asked, “What are you doing?”
“Well, officer,” I replied, “As you see here, we’re unloading the church bus. We’re from Seattle; we were at Whistler today, and now we’re going to stay here.”
“Don’t you know what this is?”
My life began to pass in front of me. “What do you mean?”
“This is a house of prostitution, serves this end of the city. Better keep a close watch on your kids.”
“Thanks . . .” My voice trailed off as he returned to his patrol car.
My mind was a blur. We had no money, there was no place else to stay, and most of the kids heard this conversation. No wonder City Motel was so cheap; just wait till news of this one gets out: “Youth Pastor Jailed for His Own Protection as Angry Parents Picket Church.”
Fortunately, our bus driver was a respected church elder. I called him aside. With a gleam in his eye he said, “I think God wants us to overtake this place.” That’s all I needed to hear, because I was starting to think the same thing.
We moved into our rooms. They were so dirty most of us went right back to the bus to get our sleeping bags. The hotel towels were paper thin and stained. I crammed everyone into my room and we discussed our situation. Then followed a wonderful (and loud) time of worship and prayer right there.
Just as the officer predicted, it was a very busy night. Male and female customers came and went all night. Most of us didn’t sleep very well. We were glad to get out the door and on to Grouse Mountain for more skiing the next day. When we got home, the elder took the initiative to call key parents and explain what happened.
My students, Christian or not, saw and experienced a sense of God’s presence in the hotel room worship service.
Here is a second story. Wasn’t funny then, still isn’t.
Dear Pastor Kageler,
With regards to your so-called youth rally next month, I am writing to inform you again that I feel what you have planned is a godless abomination. I am writing our denominational headquarter and our Christian college presidents, as well as the other pastors in our district to ask them to join me in fasting and prayer, and to call upon God to stop this evil. You will be held accountable by Almighty God for the worldliness you are fostering among our precious young people.
I intend to do everything in my power to stop this event.
Again, as was the case with the ski retreat at Whistler, this youth rally’s (a lip-sync contest) purpose was to interest and engage not only Christian students but others as well. I’ve learned to expect problems, and my observation is that any youth worker who seeks to guide students toward the Christian faith will encounter difficulties. It’s all the more important then to get our theology, particularly our Christology, right.
Building on a Good Foundation
In the last twenty years there have been several attempts to help youth workers see Christian youth ministry within a theological framework. These authors are offering, each in their own way, a cognitive gyroscope for ministry. Here we will acknowledge the positive contributions of these theological approaches. I want to then make a new contribution.
Used by youth ministry professors for many years as a required text for youth ministry education, Richard Dunn and Mark Senter’s Reaching a Generation for Christ speaks of systematic theology in terms of “building blocks” for ministry. Several of the major topics of systematics (God, Scripture, humanity, sin, salvation and the church) are not only explained but both personal and student-ministry implications are explored. Dunn and Senter see youth workers as “theological construction workers.”
A few years later another heavy text entered the field. Starting Right: Thinking Theologically About Youth Ministry takes an opposite approach to theology and praxis. Whereas Dunn and Senter started with theology and later moved to ministry implications, Starting Right begins with specific aspects of ministry and posits how each aspect can be understood theologically. Topics such as ministry models, evangelism, family, student leadership, community and innovation are addressed. Much more recently Andrew Root and Kenda Creasy Dean considered theological connections with a variety of programmatic components and emotional states common in student ministry.
Five years later two books entered the field from a theological and spiritual formation point of view, focusing particularly on the personal spirituality of the youth worker. For example, Presence-Centered Youth Ministry envisions the youth worker as functioning out of the overflow of God’s presence in her or his own life. Contemplative Youth Ministry provides fresh vocabulary for this interior spiritual life and focuses on what it means to practice the presence of Jesus.
Shortly thereafter Jesus-Centered Ministry emphasized Jesus as the proper center of all youth ministry. Rick Lawrence, taking his cue from the nineteenth-century sermons of C. H. Spurgeon, brings the reader back to the point that made Spurgeon’s ministry so comprehensively powerful: all aspects of ministry have their basis in the person and work of Jesus Christ.
The Living Christ and How We See Ourselves and Ministry
My own heart is very much in the same stream as Rick’s Jesus-Centered Ministry, but I wish to consider more specifically the challenges of multifaith-society youth ministry. I began this book with a declaration that our Christology uniquely connects us with both Jesus’ presence and power as we engage in student ministry in a multifaith society. In this chapter we’ll explore Christology expressed in (1) the seven “I am” statements of Jesus in the Gospel of John, (2) the two most important paired words in the entire New Testament, “In Christ,” and (3) how Jesus as Suffering Servant can connect the dots in praxis. These aspects of Christology can equip us to be persons of presence and power, and help our students navigate their multifaith world.
Jesus’ “I am” statements. How did Jesus understand himself? It’s not possible for us to grasp what it would have been like to be “very God and very man.” In the Gospel of John we especially see Jesus trying to interpret himself, often in metaphor. There were almost always three different audiences present when Jesus said “I AM.” His disciples, already believers, were there. The second group is those who gathered around Jesus for a variety of reasons. They may have seen a healing or heard of one. They knew that Jesus was somehow different. The religious leaders comprised the third group. They were generally skeptical, cynical or hostile.
So then, this in a very real way parallels our own audiences in Christian youth ministry. Some of our students believe (group 1). We know (and try to reach) students who are or may be open to Jesus (group 2). We may also know students or parents who are skeptical, cynical or hostile, whether they are committed to a different faith or to no faith at all (group 3).
The bread of life. Having just fed the five thousand it was getting dark and Jesus tried to slip away to get some downtime on the other side of the lake. Crossing the lake by boat was a tad traumatic for the disciples, but they made it. Perhaps Peter tweeted about it or posted it on his Facebook page, because the next morning the crowds arrived. To them Jesus eventually said, “I am the bread of life. Whoever comes to me will never go hungry, and whoever believes in me will never be thirsty” (Jn 6:35).
Jesus was saying there is something more important than physical food and drink. A relationship with him sustains us in a very different way. Seeing Jesus as the bread of life gives us the possibility of life with unlimited reserves. It makes it possible for us to be able to recover from ministry setbacks. It prevents us from losing hope or becoming cynical when a youth group member makes a poor choice.
Many of our students who are of no faith or of another faith have already realized their own “bread” is not satisfying for the long term. They will see the difference and be drawn to have this bread.
The light. We can’t be sure from the text if Jesus’ “I am the light” statement immediately follows his confrontation with the Pharisees over the woman caught in adultery (Jn 8:1-11). It probably did because the Pharisees, now angry that he made them look bad in front of the people, were instantly hostile when Jesus then says “I am the light of the world. Whoever follows me will never walk in darkness, but will have the light of life” (Jn 8:12).
To the crowds that heard this sharp interaction between the Pharisees, Jesus was a fresh voice with a point of view they’d never heard. The religious leaders lived and taught “follow the law or else.” Jesus, by contrast, said, “Follow me. I’ll be your way to see forward.”
Jesus as light invites us into a life of clarity and direction. To our students it is an invitation to connect their stories to a much larger story, and to discover what it means to no longer walk in darkness. I have seen students of no faith and other faiths tune in when a peer tells their story (we used to call this a testimony). In the current youth group I serve, the nones and students from other religions are most apt to ask follow-up questions or seek one-on-one discussion with a peer leader or adult leader when a peer narrates his or her own life walk with Jesus.
The gate. Jesus contrasted himself to the false or useless gates the religious leaders were teaching about. “I am the gate; whoever enters through me will be saved. They will come in and go out, and find pasture. The thief comes only to steal and kill and destroy. I have come that they may have life, and have it to the full” (Jn 10:9-10). Those who heard this must have been dumbfounded to hear someone heap scorn on the religious leaders.
Seeing Jesus as a doorway or gate to a life beyond the self opens us up to feelings of worth and deep happiness. And who of our students or their parents do not want life “to the full”?
In student ministry I have often hosted what amounts to community outreach events aimed at parents of teenagers. Of course it is not marketed as such. Generally I have rented a room at the local middle school as the venue. My favorite seminar title is “Thriving, Not Just Surviving the Strong-Willed Teenager.” My observation is that parents of teenagers whose behavior is wreaking havoc are desperate for help. I’ve seen parents with no faith, syncretistic faith or another faith come hungry for help. My approach is to have at least ten Christian parents attend who have seen Christ make a difference in their homes. It’s fascinating to watch the intense interest (by nones, for example) when this new (to them) narrative is put on the table.
The good shepherd. The next “I am” statement is part of the same conversation about the gate and sheep. “I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep” (Jn 10:11). Now Jesus’ hearers are given an even starker picture of the contrast between the religious leaders and himself. The religious leaders are like thieves and robbers, only “shepherds” for the income generated. Jesus cares enough for sheep that he’d sacrifice his life if one were in danger.
This is one of my favorite “I am” statements. I find it comforting to think of my life being shepherded well. It is an affirmation of Jesus’ caring for us just as the Father does in Psalm 23: “The Lord is my shepherd, I shall not be in want . . .”
Our students notice when we convey a sense of personal flourishing and at the same time have a caring (shepherding) heart toward them. Struggling parents too may deeply appreciate our efforts on behalf of their own children. I long ago lost count of the expressions of gratitude from these parents for care their sons and daughters have experienced in the youth group. With tears in their eyes, secular, angry, single mothers, for example, have expressed thanks for the good influence a Christian youth group has on their teens. I also have had immigrant parents of Hindu background express relief that their daughter is identifying with a Christian youth group.
Resurrection and the life. John 11 tells the story of Lazarus’s death and resurrection. Jesus purposely arrived after Lazarus had died. He was so late, in fact, that his friend was already buried (v. 17). Lazarus’s sisters, Mary and Martha, were grieving, struggling with thoughts of “what if” and “if only” Jesus had come while Lazarus was still living. Jesus told Martha, who had come out of the house to meet him, “Your brother will rise again” (v. 22). Martha, perhaps in a forlorn tone, sighs, “I know he will rise again in the resurrection at the last day” (v. 24). And then she hears him say, “I am the resurrection and the life. The one who believes in me will live, even though they die” (vv. 25-26). This takes on deeper meaning when the grave stone is pushed aside and Jesus commands, “Lazarus, come out” (v. 43). I wish we had a YouTube clip of Lazarus shuffling out of the grave, bound in grave wrappings. Perhaps we would hear a very muffled voice saying, “Help me out here, please!”
Here we see that Jesus is in the restoration business. He does extreme makeovers. We may think we have made a mistake that is unforgivable and our life is ruined. Not so. This is a wonderful Scripture to bring to students or parents who are suffering the results of a setback or life-altering catastrophe. We know that personal catastrophe is no respecter of age, sex or religion, and we offer hope and help to those whose need is acute.
The way, the truth, and the life. The disciples were disoriented and upset that their three-year road trip with Jesus was soon to end. Thomas blurts out his confusion, “Lord, we don’t know where you are going!” and Jesus answers, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me” (Jn 14:5-6). The disciples struggled to get their heads around what was happening, and as the conversation unfolds some of them show glimmers of comprehension. (It all became much clearer in the presence of a resurrected Christ a few days later.)
I see the first part of verse 6 as an invitation to a life of purpose. As we respond to Jesus’ loving initiative, he becomes the center of our lives. And of course the second half of the verse, “No one comes to the Father except through me,” is among the key verses for those of us who espouse the traditional Christian faith. This verse is also a key to the church’s entire missionary enterprise. We understand there is only one way. This impels us to make our student ministry welcoming to those who are not yet believers. My friends who hold afterschool programs in neighborhoods that are predominantly Muslim or Hindu tell me that these parents and their kids see something different in them. They want to learn more of this Jesus.
The vine. In John 15 we are invited into a holy huddle of Jesus and the disciples. Here Jesus uses the analogy of connectivity. “I am the true vine, and my Father is the gardener. . . . I am the vine; you are the branches. If you remain in me and I in you, you will bear much fruit; apart from me you can do nothing” (Jn 15:1, 5). All his hearers knew the vine-branch image and what happens when a branch is cut off. And in verse 15 Jesus says their relationship is even more personal, and he calls them “friends.”
This connectivity is for us as well. When things go bad in our lives, our connection to Christ and his followers is the key to flourishing. When things go bad in our ministries, these connections count as well. In the opening stories of this chapter, for example, it was the sense of Jesus’ presence, the sense of his friendship, that sustained me.
Connection with Jesus makes possible deep and authentic connection with others. That sense of connection, love and fellowship can be sensed by a newcomer to our youth group. It is one of the most powerful apologetics we have for a vital faith in Christ. We offer presence.
Recently, I was working with several youth group members at our church’s booth at the Nyack Street Fair. We handed out 1,100 bottles of cold water to some very grateful passersby. We were having a great time with each other as we served others, and we received several comments about this from those we served. There was obviously some deep connection we had. Even in receiving water and a smile, people saw presence that day.
“In Christ.” Whereas the “I am” statements help us realize and experience Jesus’ presence, “in Christ,” used by Paul seventy-three times, helps us realize and experience Jesus’ power. Paul’s belief that being “in Christ” is the central descriptor of the Christian and the source of daily living power. Paul states that if we are in Christ it means that the same Spirit who raised Jesus from the dead resides in us as well (Rom 8:10-11). This chapter of Romans contrasts two kinds of lives. One is life outside Christ, the other life in him.
The old way of life, the life outside Christ, can be summarized in my paraphrase of Joshua 1:8, “Here is the law, just do it.” The problem is, of course, no one is able to do it, at least not for long. In 2 Corinthians Paul describes it as a letter that kills (v. 6). By contrast “in Christ,” where the power to please God does not stem from our own discipline and effort but rather Christ’s power in us, is described by Paul as a letter of life (v. 6). He states plainly that because of this new covenant (this new way of living in Christ) we have confidence “through Christ before God.” Not that we are competent to claim anything for ourselves, but our competence comes from God” (2 Cor 3:4-5).
I did not fully appreciate the concepts of the “new covenant” and being “in Christ” until I read The Normal Christian Life. Watchman Nee explained the new covenant in shocking language:
What does it mean in everyday life to be delivered from the Law? At risk of a little overstatement I reply: It means that henceforth I am going to do nothing whatever for God; I am never again going to try to please Him. “What a doctrine!” you exclaim. “What awful heresy! You cannot possibly mean that!” But remember, if I try to please God “in the flesh,” then immediately I place myself under the Law.
Nee explains that God, in Christ, is much more interested in living through us than having us try hard and then helping us out when we come up short.
Incensed by this preposterous claim, I pulled out a Bible concordance and looked up all the Old Testament verses that contained the word help as part of a prayer or affirmation of what God does. There are over forty such instances. I went to the New Testament with the same question. How many times in the New Testament is the word help used in prayer? Zero! In the Gospels various people asked Jesus to help them (e.g., Mt 15:25), but there are no such prayers in the Epistles.
This radically altered my prayer life and my view of what it means to be a Christian. I no longer ask God for help with anything. In the morning instead of praying “Lord, help me to live like you want today” I say, “Lord, I’m all yours. I’ll step aside and enjoy your wonderful self as you operate through me today.” Jon Acuff says something similar: “God has no interest in better. He is, on the other hand, all about new.”
This made a big difference in how I felt about the Christian life. Previously, if someone asked, “Would you say living as a Christian life is hard or easy?” I would, without hesitation, answer “It’s quite hard, but basically doable much of the time.” Now my answer is “Quite easy actually.”
This perspective is immensely helpful when facing the challenges and crises of everyday life, including those of student ministry. Living “in Christ” gives us power to get up each day and function in a kingdom-connected way. Our students too can experience this.
This can help us with our interactions with youth and parents of other faiths. The adherents of Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism and all other religions strive to fulfill what is expected of them. For example, Muslim youth work places a high priority on teaching students to work hard to stay on the correct path. By contrast, being “in Christ” releases the person from self-effort. This perspective is filled with grace and empowerment. This is exactly what Muslim high school students notice (or should notice) when they show up at Christian youth group gatherings.
Being “in Christ,” however, does not exempt us from sorrow and pain.
The Suffering Servant. Isaiah 52–53 introduces the notion that the Messiah will be a servant who suffers. How does our belief in the Suffering Servant inform our lives as believers and our efforts to facilitate student ministry in a society full of other faiths or no faith at all?
Jesus suffered in at least four respects. He suffered physically, of course. The desert experience described in Luke 1 was not held at an upscale retreat center with a breakfast buffet. We see in the Gospels that Jesus was sometimes exhausted and needed to get away from the pressing crowds. And the cross? Enough said.
Jesus suffered spiritually. Before the crucifixion he pleaded with his Father to exempt him from what was to happen (Lk 22:42-44). And on the cross he felt the cold terror of abandonment by God (Mk 15:34).
Jesus have suffered intellectually. Despite his repeated explanations of his nature and mission to his disciples and the crowds, most just did not get it. Imagine his chagrin when he heard his disciples arguing over which of them would be the greatest (Mt 18:1).
We know Jesus suffered emotionally as he saw physical, mental and spiritual pain of people (Lk 19:41). He felt the loss when his friend Lazarus died (Jn 11:35).
And we suffer as well in student ministry. We are physically tired after a lock-in or retreat. We are sad when ten kids show up to an event when we expected fifty. We are grieved when our brightest and best students make poor choices and are unrepentant. We lie awake at night over an unkind comment by a student. We suffer spiritually when we cry out to God for this key student, that big program or that well-meaning but angry parent who has turned against us. We also suffer spiritually when we are so tired we fall asleep while praying or reading the Bible.
And we all experience, over time, the healing, comfort, solace and restoration that comes from the presence of the living Christ and the dear people around us who re-present him to us when we can’t see him for ourselves.
But sometimes suffering enables us to make kingdom progress in our efforts to see lost people come to faith. This happens in two respects.
Our own suffering may be a powerful apologetic to the students and parents of other faiths or no faith. When our suffering is public, people are watching. If they see something in us that, despite our suffering, gives us the ability to put one foot in front of the other each day and still thank God and care about others, it is a powerful witness. It may cause others to seriously examine their own life foundations and question whether they would have the same resources in a similar situation.
This is very much in the same vein as the evangelistic impact of ancient Romans watching Christians getting mauled by lions or roasted in the flames at the local arena. For some it was great sport. For others, watching this cruelty deconstructed their Roman life assumptions, causing them to wonder, What do Christians have that I don’t?
This is not the only way in which suffering may trigger spiritual interest by others.
When a student or parent experiences tragedy, we may find them open as never before to the gospel. I have a good friend who is the head chaplain of a large pediatric hospital in the United Kingdom. The hospital has a staff of ten chaplains; religions other than Christianity are well represented on his staff. Almost every day he sees how having a child in severe health crisis is the great leveler of race, class, gender and religion. One aspect of this that initially puzzled him, but which he now accepts as normal, is that about half of the adherents of other religions desperately want Christians to pray for their child. And if death comes, even a higher percentage want an explicitly Christian funeral.
Keith Miller said, we Christians “lightly run our fingers over a person’s soul until we find a crack, and then gently pour our love into that crack.” A crisis opens a crack, a chasm really. People know they need something they do not themselves possess. C. S. Lewis observed, “Pain insists upon being attended to. God whispers to us in our pleasures, speaks in our consciences, but shouts in our pains. It is his megaphone to rouse a deaf world.”
In youth work we are strategically placed to help hurting persons experience a living Christ in the midst of their own suffering and sorrow. We may even be able to introduce them to a Savior who was a man of sorrows, acquainted with grief (Is 53:3 ESV), and his Father, who lost a Son.
Conclusion
The first two chapters began with the fact that Christians are not the only ones doing youth ministry. We live in a multifaith society. We also looked at the sad statistics that many students and parents are becoming syncretists or nones. But these realities can be good for the church, the Christian family and the Christian youth group in at least two respects. First, it should wake us up to the need to help our own students understand the historic Christian faith, which itself was born in a very crowded religious marketplace. Second, it underscores that theology influences praxis. Our perspective on pluralism affects Christian identity formation. Youth ministries representing the historic faith seem more able to help students flourish spiritually. The early Christians daily dealt with what it meant to be a follower of Christ in a multifaith Greco-Roman culture. There was something noticeably different about their lives, and their message rang true to many of their friends and neighbors. This is why we are in Christian youth ministry. The more we are dwelling “in Christ,” the more able we are to help our students live a vital Christianity in our multifaith society.
A few months ago I was pleased to see three high school students new to our youth group playing basketball in our church parking lot with our youth pastor and other students. As their names were called out, I realized these three guys had come regularly to the middle school group three years previous. They had grown so much I hardly recognized them.
These guys were troublemakers in middle school, and all were temporarily banished from youth group (more than once) for bullying or actual physical harm to other students. They usually came back from banishment, but eventually they stopped coming. In middle school they had an interest in the occult and also were attracted to the many positive role models of Muslim black males. Frankly, I assumed they would drop out of high school and eventually be incarcerated.
As the basketball game progressed, one by one they came over to speak with me. They greeted me warmly by my first name. One explained to me that he and another youth group member were going to visit his father, who lived in another city. Why? Having fasted and prayed, he was going to pray with his estranged father that he would be healed from the injuries sustained in a recent car accident.
The second young man explained his interest in social studies in school and envisioned a future of helping people. The third young man explained he was a state championship–level wrestler with plans to attend a university on a wrestling scholarship. He desired to glorify God in the process and help reach others for Christ.
I was dumbfounded.
Normally I am a very positive and hopeful person, but as I said before, in my opinion three years ago these guys had no future other than prison. If religious at all, I figured they would be part of a new age spiritism or identify themselves as Muslim. But now they were Christians, and rather lively ones at that.
I later learned why they disappeared from the youth group. Our church had shrunk in size, and in the process the budget shrank as well. A much-loved youth pastor had to leave to find other ministry employment. The three of them were devastated by this departure. In the years since, our church’s student ministry had limped along. Now, though, with a new youth pastor things were picking up and long-lost students were beginning to find their way back.
In our middle school youth group these three guys experienced presence and power. They experienced amazing grace as well, despite their behavioral failures. Each had led a part of the weekly Bible study. They experienced all of the seven “I am” statements of Jesus as part of this spiritual family.
Subsequent to middle school each of them had experienced significant relational toxicity and numerous family-related setbacks. And yet here they were—godly young men. Not perfect, of course, but on a positive trajectory. In a milieu awash with other choices, they were good examples of what solid Christian identity formation can accomplish.
Student ministry, with presence and power among nones, syncretists and students of other faiths?
In Christ this is mission possible.
