Jesus and the Kingdom of God: Four Encounters
8
Christian Engagement with Other Religions in Youth Work
Mission Possible 2
When I was a student at the University of Washington I took the required introduction to philosophy course. One day our professor asked, “If you are a born again Christian, please raise your hand.” Of the two hundred or so students in the class, six (including me) raised their hands.
The professor then spent the next ten minutes berating us, telling the whole class we had no place in this class or the university, and expressing his hope that we would put away our childish, regressive religious ideas, grow up and enter the modern world. During his tirade against evangelical Christians I smiled faintly, my inner self was calm and I had one dominant thought: I am so glad I’ve heard all this before. This poor guy doesn’t know any better.
You see, in high school I was part of debate club, and some of my closest friends there were atheists who reveled in their evangelistic zeal to deconstruct the Christian faith. I had another close friend who was a spiritist who enjoyed telling me about the “trumpet séances” he attended where, purportedly, a trumpet floated around the room talking. I also had the “problem” of two girls liking me at the same time, one of whom was a devout Mormon. By the time I was eighteen I had been forced to confront myriad hard questions about religion, faith and especially my historic Christian miracle-believing faith.
In an anthropology class the professor explained to us that all ancient cultures had a flood myth, and Christians were silly to believe that all the “mythology” in Genesis actually happened. I raised my hand: “But another way to look at it is that if all cultures around the globe have a flood myth, wouldn’t that mean a worldwide flood actually happened?”
I concluded chapter one with a discussion of “positive doubt.” This is the notion that as the adolescent brain gets its cognitive upgrade we should expose our students to other points of view regarding faith. In this chapter we explore several ways to help young people have meaningful encounters with the “religious other” and subsequently have their own faith deepened.
Bridging to Other Faiths Without Evangelism Being Job One
In Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry Andrew Root provides a gentle but scathing rebuke to youth ministries and youth workers who seek to build relationship with teens for the sole purpose of winning them to Christ. He does not deny that evangelism is a legitimate concern, but he points out the hypocrisy of a youth worker building a relationship with a teen and then moving on if that teen is not responsive. It is hypocritical, says Root, in that Jesus loved people without regard to their acceptance of his message.
Counterintuitively, a strong plea for Christians to develop a biblically based and theologically sound foundation for interfaith engagement and cooperation comes from Eboo Patel, a devout Muslim. He suggests such a biblical basis would include Jesus’ story of the good Samaritan (Lk 10:25-37), his dealing with the Roman centurion (Lk 7:1-10) as well as his encounter with the Samaritan woman (Jn 4:5-42). Patel, founder and president of InterFaith Youth Core, says,
Interfaith cooperation doesn’t mean all religions are the same at the core, or our differences should be watered down. It also doesn’t mean we don’t have real disagreements and exclusive truth claims that may come into conflict with one another. It does mean, however, that we have shared values in common, values that diverse religious traditions insist their followers act on, like mercy, compassion, hospitality, and service. . . . As a Muslim, I am called to care for those who suffer in my community, called to be a good steward of creation, called to seek justice and mercy wherever I go. As a Christian, are you called to care about these things? And if so, can we work together on them?
The needs of the poor and hurting of the world are so great, says Patel, that people of differing faiths who share common values should join together in their efforts to meet human needs. Here is the key for cooperation across religions. His organization, the InterFaith Youth Core, calls it “service learning.” In this effort he tries to harness the common values found in all the world’s religions: hospitality, cooperation, compassion and mercy.
Joining with a Muslim youth group to clean up a community after a flood, for example, has at least four potential positives for our Christian youth. First, they will be connected with the heart of God in helping the hurting. Second, working alongside a Muslim may cause our students to think about their own faith. Christian students may ask questions of their faith they may not have been inclined to ask before. I want my students to ask questions and wonder about “the religious other” now, not in the future when they are away from home and in an environment that is potentially hostile to their faith. Third, even though our service event may not have evangelism as the primary purpose, evangelism may indeed result from our efforts. Students from the other youth groups will see the resources the Christian faith offers. Fourth, I want to provide my students with opportunities to serve instead of being served. Growth in having a servant heart is a critical part of spiritual formation.
Even if our interfaith activities do not directly result in conversions (now or ever), if we have helped the hurting, we have connected to the heart of God for people. That in itself is good.
There is yet another way to look at student activity that helps the needy, whether alongside other religious young people or not. It comes from the missions perspective called the “Engle Scale” (see fig. 8.1). This simple conceptual scale posits that the road from no knowledge of God to becoming a fully functioning disciple of Christ involves incremental steps. So, individuals and people groups we encounter are somewhere on the scale. Anything we do with others has the potential to move people up the scale. Though we may not see or experience the person come to faith in Christ, we were part of a chain of contacts leading to that point.
-8
No knowledge of God or the Christian religion
-7
Initial awareness of God or the Christian religion
-6
Awareness of the fundamentals of the gospel
-5
Grasp the implications of the gospel
-4
Positive attitude toward Christians and the gospel
-3
Recognition of personal need
-2
Decision to act
-1
Repentance and faith in Christ
+1
Post-decision evaluation
+2
Incorporation into body
+3
Conceptual and behavioral growth
+4
Communion with God
+5
Life stewardship in terms of the kingdom; able to disciple others
Figure 8.1. The Engle Scale
Some Christian thinkers observe that in the process of becoming a follower of Christ, a person tends to “belong before believing.” That is, the interested person is first attracted to the believing community, and over time belonging to the community turns to belief. Then more of the content of the faith gets filled in as the person grows in Christ. This does not negate the helpfulness of the Engle Scale; it affirms that the journey to becoming a Christian is often a multistep process. Our young people help others along that journey in any activity that reflects selfless giving and relational care.
Now that we have the conceptual basis for our student ministry proactively engaging with other faith communities, let’s look at specific examples of how this is being done.
The Interfaith Youth Core is the most visible of the many organizations in the United States that promote interfaith activities, IFYC especially is geared for the college campus. Incorporated in 2002, their literature points out Martin Luther King Jr. and Mohandas Gandhi were both in the twenties when they began having an impact on society. The aspirations of IFYC are well expressed in the words
We view religious and philosophical traditions as bridges of cooperation. Our interfaith movement builds religious pluralism. We define religious pluralism as a world characterized by:
Their national office recommends a “leadership team” of students or faculty. Once gathered the team will plan and carry out events under the banner “Better Together.” Among the many positives of IFYC is the notion, expressed by their founder Eboo Patel, that interfaith activity does not mean participants give up the exclusive truth claims of their respective faiths but rather harness the compassion implicit in that faith for the good of others. Beyond the impulse for compassion found in many religions, Patel says interfaith work helps promote a civil society in a pluralistic cultural.
To date there is no national organization that promotes interfaith activities at the high school level, but there are many local organizations doing just that. Examples include the Youth Interfaith Council in New Jersey, which sponsors multifaith social activities for the purpose of building relationships and having fun. It was founded by the youth workers of several area churches. In the Twin Cities area the Interfaith Youth Leadership Coalition grew out of the St. Paul Area Council of Churches (SPACC.org). It focuses on collaborative projects that show compassion by helping the poor and hurting. The Muslim Jewish High School Leadership Council (muslimjewishnewground.org/high-school-leadership-council.html) is a Los Angeles organization that does student leadership training (Muslim and Jewish youth being trained together) so those leaders can influence their own schools. The Puget Sound Interfaith Youth Camp (soundinterfaithcamp.org) provides an annual opportunity for students of different faiths to come together for a time of fun and mutual understanding. A new group for high school students in the Boston area has been started by the Interfaith Alliance (interfaithalliance.org).
Youth Group Joint Activities
Born in Birmingham, England, the “Feast” has a focus of bringing together Christian and Muslim youth and youth groups. Their three-step model can be used anywhere youth groups of different religions coexist. All it takes is at least one youth group leader from each faith to do the planning.
Step one is “exploring faith.” In this gathering students eat together, play low-competition games and meet in small groups comprising equal number of Muslims and Christians. Around the circle, each student is given the opportunity to explain to the others what they like about their faith. This is not meant to be a debate but rather a sharing of personal feelings and information. After this round of sharing, students may ask questions of each other. Andrew Smith, founder of the Feast, observed when they began to do this most Christian young people were unable to fill their allotted five minutes; it appeared they had not given their faith any thought. Subsequently he asked the leaders of Christian youth groups to help their own young people think about and discuss in advance what they like about their faith. This process helped in their own spiritual formation.
Step two is “creating friendships.” Though this begins at the initial meeting, it really happens when the groups work on projects that help people in need. Smith observes that through mutual activity for the benefit of others come friendship, understanding and unity. He observes that youths want friendship.
Step three is “lives are changed.” The friendships continue beyond the service projects and the positive feelings about people of different faith transfer to families, siblings and other friends. More projects and events are eventually planned and led by the students themselves, which has a significant positive impact on their own lives.
The ministry approach and purpose of the Feast has been endorsed in the United Kingdom by both Christian church leaders and leaders within the Muslim community who have agreed on “Ethical Guidelines for Christian and Muslim Witness in Britain.”
The Christian Muslim Forum offers the following suggestions that will equip Christians and Muslims (and others) to share their faith with integrity and compassion for those they meet.
1) We bear witness to, and proclaim our faith not only through words but through our attitudes, actions and lifestyles.
2) We cannot convert people, only God can do that. In our language and methods we should recognize that people’s choice of faith is primarily a matter between themselves and God.
3) Sharing our faith should never be coercive; this is especially important when working with children, young people and vulnerable adults. Everyone should have the choice to accept or reject the message we proclaim and we will accept people’s choices without resentment.
4) Whilst we might care for people in need or who are facing personal crises, we should never manipulate these situations in order to gain a convert.
5) An invitation to convert should never be linked with financial, material or other inducements. It should be a decision of the heart and mind alone.
6) We will speak of our faith without demeaning or ridiculing the faiths of others.
7) We will speak clearly and honestly about our faith, even when that is uncomfortable or controversial.
8) We will be honest about our motivations for activities and we will inform people when events will include the sharing of faith.
9) Whilst recognizing that either community will naturally rejoice with and support those who have chosen to join them, we will be sensitive to the loss that others may feel.
10) Whilst we may feel hurt when someone we know and love chooses to leave our faith, we will respect their decision and will not force them to stay or harass them afterwards.
Certainly one does not need to be part of the Feast franchise to have youth groups of different faiths come together for understanding. It is helpful, however, to benefit from the wisdom garnered by others who have chosen to go down this road. For example, Andrew Smith has observed that many of the Muslim young people he knows are children of immigrants. They do not have freedom, within the context of their own families, to choose their religion. He feels it’s unethical to encourage a teenager to convert to another religion and then tell the teen to keep it a secret from his or her family. Smith believes that many of these young people will step toward Christianity when they are university age and on their own. The point here is to be sensitive to the home environment of the young person.
Church-Based Afterschool Programs
No national organization tracks the number of church-based afterschool programs for children and youth. School-based programs increased beginning in 2002 when the Clinton administration committed a billion dollars to these programs in rural and urban communities, spawning programs in 7,500 schools.
In communities where these programs have been defunded or where the number of programs fall short of the need, churches try to meet the needs of their communities through their own afterschool programs. The parents of many teenagers, for example, are not home when school dismisses, and the schools themselves have no afterschool programs of any kind. In this situation a church can make available their facilities for recreation, arts or homework. Depending on the community makeup, these young people may be of another religion or none at all.
Churches seeking to meet real community needs through an afterschool program do not have to reinvent the wheel to do so. A good source of collected wisdom is Saving Souls, Serving Society: Understanding the Faith Factor in Church-Based Social Ministry, which provides a case study approach to different scenarios. A comprehensive step-by-step guide for starting such programs, applicable to schools and churches, has been produced by the state of Utah. It covers licensing, organizational structure, risk management recruiting and hiring, and training.
The Salvation Army has combined with Scripture Union to similarly provide guidelines and programming for afterschool programs specifically for churches. Called “PrimeTime,” its focus is young people ages six through twelve. The program includes startup guidelines, curricular resources and staff training resources.
All of the approaches discussed in this chapter have great potential to foster the spiritual formation of our own students and help them make the Christian faith their own faith. They are also likely to help others move a step closer to commitment to Christ. Now let’s look at how Jesus engaged those who were not yet partakers of the kingdom of God.
Jesus and the Kingdom of God: Four Encounters
During his three-year ministry on earth, Jesus had four different types of encounters with others: the love encounter, the truth encounter, the power encounter, and the allegiance encounter.
Love encounter. Jesus repeatedly demonstrated love that was surprising and unconventional. For example, he initiated an extended conversation with a Samaritan woman (Jn 4). Not only was she a woman, she was a religious outsider. So the reader won’t miss the significance, the author of the Fourth Gospel says, “For Jews do not associate with Samaritans” (Jn 4:9).
When Jesus’ dear friend Lazarus died (Jn 11), Jesus not only wept in grief but did something astonishing to express love: he raised Lazarus from the dead! It is interesting to note that while Jesus called to Lazarus (“Lazarus, come out!” [v. 43]) he involved the community in releasing Lazarus from his grave clothes (v. 44). Now there is a community-building exercise!
Jesus cared for and loved his disciples until they “got it.” He certainly gave them his time. The further along he went in ministry, the more time he spent with them. He articulated his love and called them “friends” (Jn 15:9-17). With at least one disciple who was slow to understand (Peter), he had a personal counseling session (Jn 21:15-19).
Jesus was indeed God’s love incarnate.
When I first came to a church to serve as youth pastor, the students were brutal to each other. The group was rife with gossip, arguments flared up often, and the f-bomb was hurled at others. This dysfunction was one of the group’s attractions to me. I knew I would have to be dependent on and in tune with the power of God to foster change in the group. I arrived on the scene in the spring and observed the sorry spiritual state of many of the student leadership team. When June came I instituted a new selection procedure for the leadership team. I gave the students a list of all the group members and asked them to circle the names of up to five males and five females who, in their opinion, were most committed to the group and to Christ.
I then began to meet regularly with these students. In our opening meeting I asked them to share why they were willing to commit to leadership. (Many were in despair over the disunity and meanness in the group.) I asked them to come up with a list of mutual commitments for being in leadership. As they talked, I guided them toward four areas: commitment (1) to God, (2) to each other, (3) to all members of the youth group, and (4) to myself and the adult staff.
Our bimonthly leadership meeting typically included the following: (1) We prayed for each other and discussed our accountability regarding our own walk with God. (2) We each answered the accountability question: Who in the group did I speak with in the last two weeks that I normally do not speak with? (3) We evaluated the previous two weeks of youth group gatherings, such as our weekly youth group night, Sunday school, and (for example) basketball and pizza night. (4) We planned for upcoming events. (5) We had a brief training time (e.g., What does it mean to listen to someone?) (6) We got on our knees and prayed for the youth group members and our plans.
Over time, the emotional climate of the group shifted dramatically toward the positive. In my mind God used two things to cause this change. Now we had at least ten students who committed to speaking to someone outside their friendship clusters. These leadership students weren’t asked to abandon their clique but to speak once with someone outside their norm. This had a ripple effect. Often a student leader would bring a close friend to speak to this “other.” Second, the time spent on our knees changed the mindset of the student leaders from consumer to provider.
I also used this approach in a large youth group representing twenty-six high schools, and the result was the same! The group became welcoming, friendly, open and, eventually, loving. (In both situations we also instituted small groups as part of the normal youth group menu.)
How does this fit in with Jesus’ love encounters? When a new person invited by a friend came to our youth group meetings, they would experience love and acceptance. After coming a couple of times, it wasn’t unusual for that person to ask the equivalent of “What must I do to be saved?” What they saw in these peers, they wanted for themselves.
Many students of Muslim background will find the emotional climate of a church youth group a dramatic change from what they are accustomed to. As we saw in chapter two, only 18 percent of mosques in the United States have a youth program, and the percentage is not much higher in most other countries. If they attend the mosque at all, they experience (endure?) preaching and teaching aimed entirely at adults. Often, young people are neither acknowledged nor valued by adults other than their parents. In a church youth group they find the opposite. They are cared about as individuals, and their needs, interests and problems are addressed from a biblical point of view.
Truth encounter. The word truth is used twenty times in the Gospel of John alone, including the famous words of Jesus “You will know the truth, and the truth shall set you free” (Jn 8:32) and “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me” (Jn 14:6). Clearly Jesus spoke and taught the truth. Indeed, he is the truth! When the truth of Christ is taught, students of all persuasions experience a cognitive and behavioral paradigm shift.
Virtually all student ministries stemming from the traditional Christian perspective emphasize teaching the truth. All of the Evangelical Free Church youth pastors who responded to my survey (see chap. 5) indicated that teaching is a huge piece of their ministries.
An important question, however, is what constitutes effective teaching? Jesus’ parables, illustrations and stories used items from everyday life. At the very least teaching in youth ministry needs to follow this pattern. I try to facilitate a teaching model that is filled with Scripture illustrated by examples, stories and references to everyday reality. As I mentioned earlier in the book, I encourage student involvement when I teach. I speak for only a fraction of the time allotted. While a typical youth lesson I lead is thirty minutes, much of the interaction is in pairs or small groups.
Our student ministries might include newcomers who are hungry for truth. They may be experiencing emptiness stemming from narcissism or a postmodernism worldview. Or a student from another religious background may wonder what a Christian friend has that serves as an internal gyroscope, keeping her friend steady and on course despite the storms of normal adolescent life. Or a Hindu student might be interested in the simple truth of the gospel. Compared to the many gods of Hinduism and the pressure to live right without anything other than self-effort, the gospel is indeed good news.
Power encounter. Any miracle, be it healing or otherwise, is a kind of power encounter that is not of this world. When missiologists speak of power encounters, however, they are often referring to the demonic. Jesus routinely cast out demons as part of his own ministry (e.g., Mk 1:34, 39). He expected his disciples to do this as well (Mk 3:14-15). The disciples’ success in power encounters was lumpy. For example, after an especially embarrassing failure Jesus said they had “little faith” (Mt 17:14-20).
Unless we are part of a Pentecostal or charismatic church, power encounters are unlikely to be a routine part of student ministry. I help my own students understand the power encounters are real in several ways. I don’t ignore power encounter texts in Scripture. I invite missionaries to explain how they experience power in their own ministries. I emphasize “The one who is in you is greater than the one who is in the world” (1 Jn 4:4) and that we have nothing to fear when it comes to the demonic. Furthermore, I explain that should they realize they are in a demonic situation, as believers they can trump any satanic presence or influence following the pattern of Paul in Acts 16:18: “In the name of Jesus Christ I command you to come out!”
I’ve had to do this once in front of the whole youth group. That was a teachable moment! We had about thirty students helping to present the evening service at the local Union Gospel Mission. In this facility, homeless and hungry men sat through a service and then got a hot meal and a place to sleep. Our students led worship and gave their testimonies. I preached. During my sermon I moved from the platform to be closer to the audience, and a man sitting ten feet from me rose to his feet and threw a hymnal at me. It hit my shoulder and continued its trajectory to a nearby wall—bang!
I walked right over to him, and pointing my finger at his heart I said, “In the name of Jesus I command you to come out of him!” The guy immediately fell backward over his chair onto the floor, and as the security people were running forward from the back of the auditorium, the man was exclaiming, “That man threw the devil out of me!” When the security people got to the man, I told them they were no longer needed. After the man righted his chair and sat calmly, I continued my sermon. You can well imagine that in the church bus on the way home I had thirty students who were eager to unpack what happened.
We don’t have to be an exorcist, however, to help students understand this. In addition to what has already been suggested, mission trips are a good way to help students experience spiritual warfare. I ask them if they felt “darkness” at any point during the day. In this I’m trying to help them understand there is an unseen world and some of that unseen world is malevolent.
In the Gospels power encounters had evangelistic impact. There is no reason the same cannot be true in youth ministry today.
The county in which I live is 35 percent Jewish, and this population is divided into two very different groups. The Orthodox-Hassidic group is insular and are not open to those outside their group. The other group of Jews is the opposite. They are liberal in theology, attend synagogue only rarely and are essentially secular in perspective. For many young people of this background the Jewish religion is not relevant. For these young people the notion that God is alive and actually does stuff in the lives of their Christian peers is both interesting and astonishing. It doesn’t take an exorcism or dramatic healing to gain their attention. They may sense God’s reality in a youth group worship experience or listen with drop-jawed amazement as a peer testifies how she had a dramatic answer to prayer or an undeniable sense of God’s personal direction.
Allegiance encounter. An allegiance encounter is a volitional challenge. Jesus often called people to align themselves with him and his kingdom. The early chapters of the Synoptic Gospels include the calling of the disciples. Among the many interactions with others we see that not everyone said yes to his invitation. When Jesus encountered a rich young man, telling him to sell all he had and give it to the poor before following Jesus, the text says, “At this the man’s face fell. He went away sad, because he had great wealth” (Mk 10:22).
Student ministries with the traditional biblical understanding see “reaching students for Christ” as an essential component of ministry. An immense amount of programming creativity is poured into outreach events.
I’m attracted to a pattern in which there are two kinds of outreach events. The first is for the sake of fun and building community. At these we have no prayer and no devotional. There is nothing overtly spiritual. Guests are invited (and they do come!) and they have a great time. As a byproduct they discover that Christians have fun without getting drunk or high. Second, every three months or so we have an event where we gather as part of the evening and the gospel is explained (usually by a student), and an opportunity is provided for some kind of response.
My favorite of these is what I call a student-led “in-house” outreach event. About once every five or six weeks, instead of a normal youth group meeting, we have this special night. It is completely student led; no adults are up front. The night has a theme (e.g., friendship). The program is in four sections. Games/fun stuff, which has something to do (however loosely) with friendship, comes first. Then we have media or skits that support the theme. Next, three students explain how Jesus has made a difference in their lives when it comes to friendship. Finally, the last student to give the friendship talk concludes with something like “If this interests you and you want to find out how you can come to know Christ like a friend and have him make a huge difference in your life, when we do “name grabbers” next, just put a big X on the back of your name grabber and we’ll find you during the ice cream sundae time so we can talk.”
Name grabbers are 3 x 5 cards that ask for the students’ name and contact information. We do this in youth group every week, and there is a drawing at the end for some kind of prize. We collect the name grabbers and dismiss people to the food area. At that point three student leaders quickly go through the pile of cards looking for “X.” When found, it is determined who will speak with whom. (Only students speak with the “X” students, not adults.) It’s not unusual to have students cross that line to living faith as a result of these outreach nights. Students from other faith traditions, especially those traditions and cultures that are adult centered, are quite shocked to see peers providing religious leadership.
