Summary
4
Christians in Occupied Territory
The Church Has Been There, Done That
In Mahwah, New Jersey, there is a busy intersection that is typical of intersections in North America. Yes, there is a Dunkin’ Donuts shop and a gas station, but at or near that corner there is also a small Lutheran church, a large charismatic church and a megamosque.
In the Vancouver suburb of Richmond it is not just an intersection but a mile-long stretch of No. 5 Road. The locals call it “Highway to Heaven.” The Ling Yen Mountain Buddhist Temple is across the street from the Richmond Bethel Mennonite Church. Nearby is Nanaskar Gudwara Gursikh Temple, and down the road is the Az-Zarhraa Islamic Center. A little farther along one comes to the Richmond Jewish Day School, the Hindu Ram Krishna Center, the Vedic Cultural Centre and the first Tibetan temple in North America, which is also the home base of the Thrangu Monastery. Richmond Christian School is there as well.
I recall as a child asking my parents about other religions as we drove to church. However, by “religions” I (unknowingly) meant denominations. On our four-mile drive to Portland Avenue Baptist Church we passed a Lutheran, a Methodist, a Catholic and a Bible church. My question was simple: “Would people other than Baptists go to heaven?” My mother indicated that answer was probably no. (She relaxed on that point some years later, however.) Eventually, of course, I became aware of other religions, not only by means of hearing missionary stories at church but by interacting with Hare Krishna members while attending the University of Washington, and interacting with Sikhs, Hindus, Muslims and Jews in the years since.
Christians now live in a world where other religions are both visible and viable in the United States. This basic reality, however, is nothing new. The Hebrew and Christian faiths were born into very robust religious marketplaces. As we help young people and their parents navigate their daily lives, it helps to know that the challenge we face is illustrated, exemplified and amplified in the Old and New Testaments. As we will see, there is considerable connection between the biblical world and today’s world in this regard, but there is a huge disconnect as well.
The Old Testament World
The story of God’s people begins with the life of Abraham in Genesis 12. Here we see Abraham and family on the move, first to Canaan and then, because of famine, on to Egypt. We know from archaeology and extrabiblical sources that these changes of address put this man and his family in a cultural milieu brimming with gods other than the one true God. The Canaanites were polytheists. They believed in a god for nearly every aspect of their lives: twenty-three gods in all. Three of these, Baal, Dagon and Molek, receive considerable coverage in Scripture. As we can well imagine, it was no small task for Abraham’s family to continue believing in one God when everyone around them believed otherwise.
Similarly, Abraham’s move to Egypt (Gen 12:10) put his family in a context that was even more polytheistic. Egypt had nearly two thousand gods, some regional, some national, some representing earth creatures, others representing stellar objects. Chief among the Egyptian gods was Amon-Ra, god of the sun. Despite living in this religious stew, Abraham both evidenced and articulated a belief in a single God who actually showed up in his life.
Among many other examples of his positive response to God, Abraham accepted a covenantal relationship with God (Gen 17:9). As a sign of the covenant he required all male members of his household to be circumcised (Gen 17:23) and, unlike Sarah, who took the notion of bearing a child late in life as hilariously improbable, Abraham believed God’s promise of a son. And Sarah indeed became pregnant (Gen 21:2).
We can imagine that none of these acts of faith were necessarily easy. We do not know the inner workings of Abraham’s mind as he counterculturally believed in one God. Quite probably, however, the story of his willingness to obey God in the sacrifice of his son Isaac brings us close to a spiritually fatal worldview collision for Abraham. In the NIV Study Bible, Genesis 22 is titled “Abraham Tested.” What an understatement! When God asked Abraham to slay his young son on the altar, we can imagine his confusion and mixed emotions. Abraham loved his son deeply, and what about God’s promise that Abraham would have numerous decedents (Gen 15:5)?
Here it seems God was asking Abraham to worship in the same manner as a worshiper of Molek, that is, by child sacrifice. Abraham’s whole adult life had been lived in contrast to the religious culture of his day, and now this. However, in testing Abraham’s faith, God, who called a last-second halt to the sacrifice, is confirming a faith that is distinctly different. Abraham is called to a distinct faith, belief in the one God who actually shows up and makes a difference time and again.
After Joshua led Israel into Canaan, much of the remaining Old Testament narrative contains a subtext with this as a dominant question: How do we live in this place when everyone around us believes differently than we do?
Did these ancient Hebrews really know and understand the religious beliefs of those around them? They certainly did. The vocabulary of the Old Testament is telling.
Molek, the god who requires child sacrifice, is named nine times. The god Baal is mentioned over one hundred times, and sometimes the locations of Baal altars are noted (Baal Zephon [Ex 14:2] and Bamoth Baal [Num 22:41]). Apparently parents enthusiastically (or at least superstitiously) named their children Baal, such as Baal-Hanon in Genesis 36:38 or Baal Meon in Numbers 32:38.
The Canaanite god Dagon is connected to crop fertility and is mentioned eight times. Dagon is the darling god of the Philistines, Israel’s nemesis in the Old Testament books of Judges and 1 Samuel. Old Testament literature is rather sparse when it comes to actual humor, but Dagon temples in Philistia become a source of great hilarity as told in 1 Samuel 4–6. The basic story, which illustrates well Hebrew knowledge of other religions, is as follows.
The Israelites were, it seems, in a constant state of war or near war with their neighbors the Philistines. One of the Hebrew elders suggested that in the face of the most recent defeat by the Philistines, they ought to bring out their secret weapon: the Ark of the Covenant. Much to the disappointment of the Israelite army, the Ark didn’t work as a weapon and was captured by the Philistines. The Ark, then, became a disconcertingly real “issue” for the Philistines.
Philistine decision makers first put the Ark in the temple of Dagon in the town of Ashdod. Big problem! The next morning the statue of Dagon had fallen down (bad enough) and the people in the town were stricken with tumors (some scholars think the proper translation is hemorrhoids), and there were rats everywhere. The Ark was moved from town to town, and in every case the result was the same: broken Dagon, hemorrhoids and rats. Finally, the Philistines sent it back on a cart to the Israelites, having put as a peace offering a few golden rats and hemorrhoids in the Ark with the tablets. This story, told and retold, must have seemed hilarious to those listening. Those poor Philistines, ha ha.
The writer of 1 Samuel divulges a few details which demonstrates the detailed knowledge of this Dagon religion. Apparently when Dagon fell before the Ark at Ashdod, it broke apart over the threshold of the temple. The author points out then, “That is why to this day neither the priests of Dagon nor any others who enter Dagon’s temple at Ashdod step on the threshold” (1 Sam 5:5). Many hundreds of years later the Israelites are still aware of Dagon temple details, as the Prophet Zephaniah mentions those who “avoid stepping on the threshold” as a widespread practice in the land, and that Jews should not do it (Zeph 1:9).
Many other gods appear in the pages of the Old Testament. Asherah, the mother god, is mentioned forty times; high places for other god worship, over seventy times; and general idols are mentioned and warned against over 140 times.
The point is, the Old Testament people of God were trying to be faithful to Yahweh and in an environment chockfull of other religious choices—just like Christian young people and their families today.
A very poignant Old Testament statement of faith is profoundly given in Psalm 121:1-3. David says,
I lift up my eyes to the mountains,
where does my help come from?
Not stated but very possibly in his mind was the thought, No, it’s not that Asherah pole over there, or that Molek altar on that hill, or that temple of Dagan you can see, but rather
My help comes from the LORD,
the Maker of heaven and earth.
He will not let your foot slip.
The New Testament World
Like their Hebrew counterparts, early Christians came to faith while living in a very multicultural and multireligious setting.
We know from the book of Acts and the Epistles that the early church was urban. This social fact helps scholars such as Wayne Meeks, David Horrell and Larry Hurtado explain and account for the growth and normative practices of the early church.
Many aspects of this New Testament world seem familiar to us in the twenty-first century. The Roman world had a common currency, hot tubs, fast food, shopping malls, extensive (and safe) travel, labor unions, international trade, high taxes, mail, professional sports and individually ticketed seats in coliseums seating forty thousand, career tracks, government bureaucracy, apartment living, running water, heated floors, political intrigue, vacation homes and villas with a view.
Early Christianity and the Roman religious world often intersected. Paul comments on the religious statues around Athens in his famous words “People of Athens! I see that in every way you are very religious” (Acts 17:22). We see also in Acts that the increasing number of Christians was hurting retail sales in a whole sector of the economy in Ephesus—the manufacture of travel souvenirs depicting the Greek goddess Artemis. Regarding this, Demetrius, a pagan silversmith and entrepreneur, gathered other craftsmen and shopkeepers and said, “You see and hear how this fellow Paul has convinced and led astray a large number of people here in Ephesus and in practically the whole province of Asia. He says that gods made by human hands are no gods at all” (Acts 19:23-27).
Just as in the Old Testament, there are many warnings against falling prey to the allures and temptations of the Greco-Roman culture. The New Testament writers seem to have had the same question as the Old Testament writers: How do we live in this place when everyone around us believes differently than we do?
It’s hard to imagine what it would have been like to be a Christian in the Roman world.
Christians certainly faced misunderstanding. The words of Jesus “whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood” (Jn 6:56) were understood by Christians to have symbolic meaning in the bread and wine of Communion. To non-Christians though, these words were shocking and repugnant. Additionally, especially in the early years people thought it very strange that Christians believed in only one God. Christians were an anomaly in a world where most people wanted to cover all their bases in life by believing in many gods. In this respect Christ followers were seen as curiously less religious than most people.
Christians faced sexual temptation in a culture awash with not only pornography and legal prostitution, but pagan-temple fundraising involving sex for financial donation and worship via sex. Brothels dotted the urban landscape of most cities in the Roman world. Since they were legal establishments (and taxed by city government), they spared no expense to advertise with lurid drawings, sayings and, if street frontage was large enough, display of available girls. Funding of pagan temples was enhanced through temple prostitution. The annual festival of Venus held in April was of particular note. One pagan religion, the cult of Aphrodite, required all its female adherents to have sexual intercourse with a stranger at least once in their life, preferably on the front steps of the temple while others looked on.
Little wonder that Paul repeatedly warns Christians to remain sexually pure. In one letter his warning includes a reference to pagan practices: “You should avoid sexual immorality; . . . each of you should learn to control your own body in a way that is holy and honorable, not in passionate lust like the pagans, who do not know God” (1 Thess 4:3-5).
Misunderstanding, mockery and sexual temptation. Early Christians felt very much like a minority in their cultural context. Sound familiar? How do we help youth and families navigate these waters? We will consider this in chapters five, seven and eight.
Christians knew they were different. Most Christians would not swear allegiance to Caesar (their first and highest loyalty was to Christ). They would not acknowledge Caesar as divine. This was no big deal to emperors like Trajan and Hadrian (A.D. 98–138), brilliant military leaders and strategic thinkers, who were too busy to care about such silliness. On the other hand, emperors with fragile egos or who lacked assurance desired acknowledgment of their divinity. Christians, an identifiable subpopulation in the Roman world, were officially persecuted, often brutally. The emperor Nero blamed the ills of the city on Christians and infamously hoisted many Christians on poles, burned them alive and enjoyed the street lighting this provided.
The rise of Christianity in the Roman world from the birth of the church in A.D. 33 to the purported conversion of Emperor Constantine in the early 300s is a subject of interest to historians and sociologists. How and why did the Christian church grow from 120 persons (Acts 1:15) to an estimated 30 million in three hundred years? Why not the worship of Mithras, Sibyl or any number of the religions that were thriving as the church was born? This is not simply an academic question. The answer may inform our own youth ministry in today’s pluralistic culture.
Sociologist Rodney Stark suggests the primary reason is that Christians were simply different. They lived in a manner different from their not-yet-Christian neighbors and work associates, and many of those differences were obvious much of the time.
Different in what respects?
First, says Stark, Christians did not practice infanticide or abortion, and thus had a higher birthrate over time than others. Urban dwellers who could afford it had access to abortion, and the practice was not uncommon. Though abortion is not explicitly mentioned in any apostolic letter or Gospel teaching, Christians connected the dots and avoided these practices. Infanticide, that is, tossing newborns (usually females) onto the garbage heaps or, alternatively, just exposing them to the elements without care, was one way urban people tried to cope with overcrowding in their apartments.
Second, when Christians were tortured or killed for entertainment, it was a profoundly disturbing experience for many onlookers. Christians seemed happy facing death. Christians, as a group, when facing the lions or burning, often sang. Onlookers went back to their apartments in confused wonder, Why did my neighbor sing when the fire was lit? I really liked my Christian neighbors, why are they being killed? What do Christ followers have that I don’t?
Third, and most salient from Stark’s point of view, is what Christians did when plagues swept the Roman world beginning in the late second century. When individuals began to show symptoms of plague, it was not uncommon for people in the neighborhood, including family members, to flee the city. Some cities became virtually depopulated within a week. Plague victims were left to die alone.
Some Christians also died, of course, but the striking truth is most Christians stayed behind in the cities to care for their plague-stricken friends, neighbors and total strangers. Stark points out that given proper nursing care (food, shelter, water) about 20 percent of afflicted people recovered from plague.
Suppose you had the plague. Suppose your family fled in panic when you got the spots on your skin. Suppose one of your last memories before you sank into feverish incoherence was some Christian neighbors gently carrying you into their home. Suppose you woke up one bright day, fever gone, to a room full of smiling faces. Would your first words be “I’d like to give thanks to Mithras”? Apparently most recovered plague victims woke and, for all practical purposes, said, “What must I do to be saved?”
Christians thus had a reputation of being good and caring people who could be trusted. They had a higher purpose in life, lived to please Christ in this world and looked forward to being with him in the next.
As the numbers of Christians increased, the numbers of followers of the Greek, Egyptian or Roman pantheon shrank. In the second half of the fourth century, after Christianity became the de facto religion of the Roman world, the emperor Julian tried to resurrect paganism. He wrote exasperated letters to the leaders of the few pagan temples that still existed in the empire, pleading, “Can’t you teach people who still believe in our gods to be nice [like Christians]?” In another letter he exclaims to his pagan priests, “These impious Galileans not only feed their own poor, but ours also; welcoming them into their agape, they attract them, as children are attracted, with cakes.”
Today: Linkage and Disjuncture
We have seen how the Hebrews in the Old Testament and Christians in the New Testament era lived their faith in a context rife with other religious choices. The same is true today. However, our day and the day of the Hebrews and early Christians are vastly different. Ancient Jews and Christians knew they were different from their pagan neighbors, and they had considerable knowledge of the religious beliefs and practices of the others around them. They felt no shame in being different. The early Christians most likely came to faith as adults and were baptized in a very public setting. They had a very distinct before-and-after conversion testimony.
It appears that most Christian young people today do not understand their own faith, let alone the faith (or nonfaith) of others. And many young people (and their parents) loathe being different from peers. In the mighty quest to “fit in” they jettison any aspect of the Christian faith that causes them to stand out.
Houston, We Have a Problem
There was a big explosion and gages went berserk. Unbeknown at first to the astronauts aboard Apollo 13, their spacecraft was venting oxygen—not only oxygen to power their fuel cells but also for them to breath. The movie Apollo 13 depicts the frantic attempts to figure out what just went wrong and what to do about it.
Christian Smith and Melinda Denton’s Soul Searching has been a “Houston, we have a problem” moment for the church and for youth ministry. The National Study of Youth and Religion, described in Soul Searching, revealed that most adolescents who would identify themselves as Christian have only the slimmest grasp of what the Christian faith actually entails.
Our culture has produced young people who “typically consider themselves to be self-directing, autonomous individuals, the key mediators or arbiters of all outside influences, fully in charge of their own interests, choices, and actions.” Outcomes of this pervasive attitude affect adolescent faith (or lack thereof) in three important respects. According to Smith and Denton, most adolescents (1) view religion as not relevant to their lives now, (2) are very hesitant to expose personal religious beliefs in public, and (3) the adolescent world is full of so many more visible and more important things (such as sports, music, drama club, a part-time job, and a bevy of TV shows or movies that must be viewed) that there is little motivation (or energy) to consider deep issues of faith or spirituality.
Smith and Denton are hesitant to even call the faith of American adolescence Christian. Rather, as we saw earlier, they use the term Moralistic Therapeutic Deism. Smith and Denton had data regarding the denominational background of the more than two thousand youth interviewed. Youth from liberal Protestant and Roman Catholic homes generally had an abysmal grasp of the Christian faith. On the other hand, young people of conservative denominations possessed vocabulary to articulate the what, why and how of the Christian faith. Subsequent research and follow-up publications stemming from the National Study of Youth and Religion have affirmed and given greater nuance to the original findings. In chapters seven and eight we will consider many proactive moves youth leaders can take to make it more likely our youth will understand the Christian faith and their own role in re-presenting Christ to their peers.
Summary
In this chapter I have provided a historical perspective of being a believer in a context where most people are not. Our situation is not that much different from that of the Old and New Testaments. We too are surrounded by people of other faiths or no faith at all. Handwringing is uncalled for. The church has been there, done that, for centuries.
Unlike the biblical and early church eras, however, today many Christians, young and old, have a perilously shallow understanding of faith. Before presenting proactive solutions to this problem, we first need to clarify our understanding of pluralism and multifaith society (chap. 5), which makes a difference in how we conceptualize and carry out youth ministry. Clearly this is an important issue not only for the church but the personal flourishing of the young people in our own student ministries (chap. 6).
