Chapter 8 of 17

Summary

Summary

5

Theology in Praxis: Latent or Articulated Views of Multifaith Society

Youth Ministry on Purpose

Students with no Christian background routinely attended our youth group meetings. Their parents were Jewish, new age or nones. Cortney began coming to our junior high group at the invitation of a friend, and she seemed to enjoy it. She came back regularly for several months, and I got to know her better through hangout time and playing amoeba tag, capture the flag, sit down backwards basketball, volleyball and so forth. It quickly became apparent that Cortney was not from a Christian background and had no knowledge of the Bible or its stories. She used rough language and seemed to know the lyrics of every secular song about sex, and enjoyed rattling off the lurid lyrics to shock our homeschooled kids. Poured into her clothes, Cortney was a typical “twelve going on twenty.” In our “together time,” where the Bible is presented, Cortney began to show some engagement with what was going on, in an aloof, oh-so-hip kind of way.

I was leading the Bible study portion of our weekly meeting and out of the blue she asked, “Will I go to hell if I have sex before marriage?” This was way off the topic of the night, and I told her I’d answer her later. During snack time she asked me again. Years earlier I would have used the opportunity to present the biblical view of sex and lead right in to something along the lines of “Cortney, God loves you and has a wonderful plan for your life.” That would have been a very traditional approach. A more modern approach would be to unpack different approaches to the salvation question with the goal of helping her understand her choices in the matter. Instead, I came at the situation in a more postmodern way. I said, “Good question, bring it up again in a week or two.” She looked a little befuddled and walked off.

Next week, she sought me out as soon as I arrived. “Will I go to hell if I have sex before marriage?” My answer? “Well, Cortney, whether or not you go to heaven or hell kinda depends on who you know, not what you do.” And with that I walked off to play Ping-Pong with some of the boys. Her wide eyes displayed her confusion.

The following week I approached her. “So, Cortney, have you figured it out yet?” “No.” She frowned. Then I gave her a few sentences about knowing Jesus and again walked away, leaving her standing there.

Two weeks passed and the group was playing frozen tag on the basketball court. I happened to be “frozen” about five feet from where she was similarly frozen.

“Say, Cortney, do you know him yet?”

“I’m afraid.”

“Good! I think you’re getting close.”

Almost immediately I was “unfrozen” and ran off.

Later that evening someone else on the staff was leading the Bible study. Cortney raised her hand in the middle and asked, “How do you know Jesus?”

This was way off topic, but Mark, who was leading that night, responded, “Good question.” He turned toward the group (these are kids ages 11-13) and asked, “Would any of you like to answer Cortney’s question?” About six kids raised their hands and one by one contributed their thoughts about what it means to come to have a relationship with Christ.

Mark thanked them for their responses and returned to the topic of the evening.

What happened afterward is amazing. Brent, whose physical appearance was the opposite of Cortney’s, was twelve but looked nine. Brent often has a blank look on his face that seems to say, “Notice, the lights are on but no one is home.” Well, that night, the lights were on and someone was home.

After the meeting ended, Brent took Cortney into a side room, explained the plan of salvation, and prayed with her to receive Christ! She came out with tears of joy. And over the weeks we all saw a complete transformation in her. She was no longer cold, hard, edgy and proudly sexual. We watched the fruit of the Spirit begin to form in her life. Everyone could see the difference in her life.

This chapter explores three primary perspectives on religious ministry in a multifaith society. The traditional, modern and postmodern perspectives make a difference when it comes to youth work. A multifaith perspective can be latent; that is, someone might not be aware she or he is working out of a certain theological worldview. Others, though, might be very aware of their theological stance related to religious pluralism. Each perspective has implications for youth work praxis.

Theological Understanding Affects Youth Ministry Praxis

Social scientists measure the effects of theologies on ministry practice by comparing denominations. Though convenient, this is also problematic.

I will use the theological labels “liberal,” “mainline,” “evangelical” and “conservative” for convenience. An evangelical or conservative denomination would interpret Scripture from a traditional Christian framework, believing that salvation is mediated only through Christ. A church from a more liberal denomination may be less likely to teach Christ as the only way because it appears intolerant of other faith communities.

On the other hand the liberal-conservative distinction is problematic in that not all churches in a “liberal” denomination are theologically liberal. There are many Methodist, Presbyterian, Lutheran and Episcopal churches that proclaim Christ as the one and only way to salvation.

The architects of the National Study of Youth and Religion have chosen, however, to use the denominations as representative types, and they expanded the list to include Roman Catholic and black Protestants. The specific denominations are named in the study’s footnotes.

The NSYR is a good place to consider denominational difference and youth ministry emphases and outcomes. The NSYR found a spectacular variance among young people raised in these denominations when it comes to understanding and articulating a Christian faith. That variance actually follows very closely what Dean Kelly found in 1972: youth of liberal/mainline denominations were barley able to identify themselves as “Christian” let alone articulate it or see faith as having any relevance to their lives. On the other hand, the more evangelical/conservative denominational youth were able to identify the basic tenets of the Christian faith, and many were able to articulate a living faith that made a difference in daily life.

The NSYR included in their surveys and interviews questions related to religious pluralism. Significant differences are immediately apparent as denominational types are set side by side (see table 5.1).

Table 5.1. Religious Particularism and Individualism Among US Adolescents, Ages 13 to 17

US

CP

MP

BP

RC

Beliefs about religion’s truth

Only one religion is true

29%

46%

26%

31%

19%

Many religions may be true

60%

48%

67%

63%

71%

There is very little truth in religion

9%

4%

5%

4%

9%

Beliefs about religious particularity

People should practice only one faith

46%

59%

38%

57%

40%

OK to practice religions besides one’s own

51%

36%

59%

40%

58%

Beliefs about conversion attempts

OK for religious people to try to convert others

54%

70%

58%

54%

43%

Everyone should leave others alone

43%

27%

39%

42%

55%

OK to pick and choose aspects of different faiths for oneself without accepting the whole

46%

36%

53%

34%

54%

(US = all US youth, CP = conservative Protestants, MP = mainline Protestants, BP = black Protestants, RC = Roman Catholic)

Source: Adapted from Christian Smith and Melinda Lundquest Denton, Soul Searching (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), p. 74.

Some conservative Protestants may be upset that only 46 percent of their youth think a single religion—Christianity—is true. Compared to mainline and Roman Catholic youth, however, conservative Protestant young people generally lean to the traditional/historic religious stance, while a much higher percentage of the youth in mainline and Roman Catholic churches reflect a modern stance. It is interesting to note that a measurable percent of young people seemingly embrace the postmodern stance, given their positive response to “There is very little truth in religion.”

Undoubtedly the denominational reactions to these results were varied. Conservatives and evangelicals would find the numbers shocking and alarming. Some mainline Protestants may have been satisfied that their young people reflect an enlightened and modern perspective. The day the NSYR data was published probably was not a good day for Roman Catholic bishops. By definition Roman Catholics are traditional, and yet they seem to be producing the fewest percentage of young people who maintain the historic Christian faith.

Other studies have produced similar findings in the United States as well as in other countries. A study of 269 church-based youth groups in Indiana, for example, revealed that the purpose and programming varied widely across denominational categories. For example, while 95 percent of the youth groups in the survey had retreats and service projects, only 53 percent had mission trips, only 34 percent had some kind of adult leadership structure to give oversight and encouragement to youth workers, and only 63 percent had any youth activities or events scheduled for the month in which the survey was conducted. And a study of 275 Roman Catholic parishes around Detroit found that adults in these parishes felt an urgent need for a greater emphasis on youth ministry leadership and programming. Perhaps these people already sensed, from their own children, the diminution of faith.

A major study among rural churches in eight denominations from the Northern Plains states examined evangelical Protestant, mainline Protestant and Catholic denominations. Among these churches, evangelical Protestants were much more likely to have active youth programs with higher participation rates. Catholic youth groups were more likely to be led by paid youth workers and participate in ecumenical activities. Mainline youth ministries were much more likely to be led by the senior pastor because of the lack volunteers or financial resources to hire a youth pastor.

Another US-based study leaned primarily on the National Longitudinal Survey of Adolescent Health (known as the ADD). The ADD’s statistical sampling approach assured highly reliable representative results, and their survey included many questions about faith and religious affiliation. The author of this research was able to cross-compare participation rates with church and denominational growth (or decline) rates. The results? The greater percentage of a denomination’s young people who were actively engaged in a church youth group, the greater the numerical growth of that denomination over the ten-year period of 1995–2005. Evangelical Protestants (including charismatics) saw denominational growth, and mainline denominations saw decline during the same period.

A study based in Melbourne, Australia, held in-depth interviews with five Roman Catholic youth workers, three Anglican youth workers and four Uniting (evangelical) youth workers. The authors were struck by the very real differences in how these three categories of youth workers viewed the purpose, role and program of church youth work. For example, the Roman Catholic ministries focused heavily on helping youth know and experience the meaning of the sacraments and understanding God’s mercy and what it means in terms of obligation to work for social justice. The Protestant youth workers seemed less concerned about theological foundations and more concerned about “doing something.” On the other hand, Protestant youth ministries heavily focused on youth “ownership” of the youth program and feeling empowered. This aspect of youth ministry was not articulated by the Roman Catholic youth workers. Again, theological context seems to make a difference in youth ministry praxis.

We have looked at youth ministry practice outcomes based on denominational differences. The following is an empirical study that used direct measurements of theological perspective not mediated by denominational affiliation.

In 2006 I was engaged in a research project to discover the differences and commonalities among church-based youth ministries in every continent. One of my interests was to explore theology and youth ministry practice. What better way than to consider the subject of infant baptism, the “waters that divide” the church?

Table 5.2. Youth Ministries Within Churches That Practice Infant Baptism Compared to Those That Do Not

Baptize infants

Do not baptize infants

Size of group: percent indicating 150-500

38%

62%

Have outreach events 1-4 times per month

47%

69%

Youth leading more than half of each meeting

36%

45%

Have a mission/vision/core values statement

64%

87%

(N = 298, 171 baptize infants, 127 do not)

Source: Len Kageler, “A Cross National Analysis of Church Based Youth Ministries,” Journal of Youth Ministries 8, no. 2 (spring 2010): 49-68.

We see here a clear theology-praxis link. Churches who do not baptism infants but see their children and youth as lost and needing to be saved have much larger youth groups, have more outreach events, have young people themselves leading meetings more often, and are more likely to have a mission/purpose statement.

Let’s examine youth ministries that are clearly represent one perspective or the other.

The Traditional View

What does Cortney’s story have to do with pluralism and multifaith student ministry?

The youth pastor and volunteers in our youth ministry hold a traditional, historic Christian view of religious pluralism, which is often referred to as exclusivism. That is, while there may be beauty, goodness and value in other religions, they are not the way to God. The only way to know God is through Jesus Christ and his sacrifice on the cross. Given this foundation, our entire youth ministry is about loving young people into a personal relationship with Christ, walking with them as they learn to live it out in community, and helping them learn to share their faith with others.

How else do we see the traditional view evidenced in our youth ministry?

First, the youth pastor and the five volunteers (including me) firmly believe that God uses youth. We believe twelve-year-olds are capable of knowing Jesus, and once they have committed their lives to him they have the Holy Spirit in their lives and are able to experience God’s direction. They are able to re-present Jesus in their own lives, as did twelve-year-old Brent in his conversion conversation with Cortney.

Of course, not all youth in traditional-leaning youth ministries do this well. I could fill a chapter with horror stories of good kids acting out. For example, a few months after Cortney’s conversion I came in from the basketball court and found Troy simulating having sex with the couch—not on the couch but sex with the couch. (This situation is not covered in any youth ministry books I’ve read!)

I firmly told him to stop and informed him this was not appropriate youth group behavior and that if he persisted he would need to go home. He desisted and was a pretty normal (and nice) thirteen-year-old boy the rest of the night.

Despite their missteps, failure and shocking setbacks, however, we see Jesus in most of them much of the time, and we believe we are all equal in this sense: the ground is level at the foot of the cross. Whether we are thirteen or a much older college professor, we are all trying to figure out how to live the Christian life on a daily basis. Furthermore, we all mess up some of the time. Most of these kids know their leaders are walking with them, not above or behind them. In this youth group, they sense they are valued.

Second, the traditional view is implied in five key features of our youth ministry.

We meet as youth come to the weekly gathering, having heard from their friends that it is interesting, a lot of fun, and they’ll feel accepted. Newcomers are welcome at other “meet” events as well, such as a trip to the paintball place.

We lead when all are gathered, one of the leaders calls the youth together and some aspect of the Bible is presented creatively and with much student involvement. This takes place in Sunday school as well, where the explicit focus is spiritual growth.

We empower students as they are given leadership opportunities within the student ministry. These opportunities include helping in the worship band, speaking as part of the Bible time or being on the student leadership team, which plans most of the nonweekly events of the group. Students are also empowered as they are taught what it means to share Christ with their peers.

We release youth to make disciples in various service-oriented projects, either for a day or, in the summer, for a week, doing simple construction projects in rural West Virginia or leading an evangelistic daily Vacation Bible School for another church.

Among the many advantages of these five ministry aspects is that the youth pastor and volunteer staff are clear about the ministry’s purpose. We know the purpose of each aspect of the ministry and how it fits into a larger whole. The metanarrative is leading youth to Christ and discipling them to disciple others. The individual pieces support this overall narrative.

There is no ambiguity about Christ here. Jesus is the one and only way to God. This theological understanding is the foundation for the whole purpose of this youth ministry, and the point specifically comes up in the teaching done within the context of the youth group or Sunday school.

This traditional view, the historic view of the Christian church, is that the Bible pretty much means what it says. However, it is important to distinguish genres of literature. This approach acknowledges that biblical literature includes history, prophecy, poetry and epistles. For example, poetry (e.g., Psalms) uses metaphors whereas history (e.g., Exodus) typically doesn’t. In poetry we do not take everything literally. When the psalmist writes in Psalm 63:7 “Because you are my help, I sing under the shadow of your wings,” it does not mean that God literally has wings. Furthermore we often need other Scripture to help refine the meaning of a particular text. A good place to begin in biblical understanding is to ask how the original hearers/readers were likely to understand it.

Using these principles then, many youth workers understand that Jesus taught that he was the only way to God.

  • “I am the gate for the sheep. . . . Whoever enters through me will be saved” (Jn 10:7-9).
  • “I am the way and the truth, and the life. No one comes unto the Father except through me” (Jn 14:6).
  • The unique character of Jesus was the reason the apostles and the early church told others about Christ as the only way to salvation. “Salvation is found in no one else, for there is no other name under heaven given to mankind by which we must be saved” (Acts 4:12). This missional imperative, then, did not expire at the close of the first century but is the mission of the church and the mission of Christian youth work today.

    The youth ministry that led Cortney to Christ does not see missions or evangelism as simply “spiritual scalp hunting” or “saving souls.” It emphasizes caring about and serving people because God loves all people, and believers are to re-present Jesus in that selfless service, even if there are no evangelistic results.

    Protestant and Roman Catholic scholars are exerting much effort to understand their faith in the context of the “religious other.” For example, in 1962 Pope John XII opened the gathering of Catholic Church leaders known as Vatican II. In this great counsel those present reflected on the place of the Christian church in the modern world. Vatican II affirmed that while the Spirit of God is working everywhere in the world, including other religions, these other religions, no matter how noble, do not offer a way to salvation. The Belgian Jesuit priest Jacques Dupuis, after a lifetime of serving the church in non-Western settings, set forth his take on this in the towering work Toward a Christian Theology of Religious Pluralism. He expresses his deep appreciation for the depth and beauty found in many other religions.

    While all reviewers applaud the book, some are saddened that he does not take the next step, to say that other faith communities also mediate salvation for their adherents. Dupuis does quite the opposite. He rejects the “deabsolutizing” and the “deobjectifying” of the historic church’s view of Christ as being the one and way to salvation. He points out that those who make truth relative, situational or only personal are “claiming to enjoy higher ground, above and beyond all the particular perspectives. This, in fact, looks very much like making an absolute objective judgment about the allegedly subjective and relative nature of any truth available to others with their limited world views.” He goes on,

    The Christian claim for Jesus Christ, as traditionally understood still stands: faith in Jesus Christ does not merely consist in trusting that he is ‘for me’ the path to salvation; it means to believe that the world and humankind find salvation in and through him. Nothing short of this does justice to the New Testament massive assertions.

    Let’s look at a second perspective on religious pluralism.

    The Modern View

    Many churches and their Christian youth ministries happily affirm their Christian faith but also affirm there are other equally valid ways to know God. For example, a large Congregational church in Illinois says, “We are grounded in tradition, centered in worship, called to serve and free to dream. We believe that everyone is a child of God.”

    Their ministry includes a large pastoral and associate staff, which places a high priority on children’s and youth ministries. Their youth pastor, Rachel, has experienced a God-calling into youth work, and she feels at home in ministry at this church for a variety of reasons, especially that its “theology is progressive and reflects that God is still calling us to love kindness, do justice and walk humbly before our God.” The vision of their Junior High Fellowship is representative of the other ministries as well. This vision includes “experiencing spiritual practices from a variety of faith traditions during our Spiritual Practice nights.”

    The Senior High Youth Fellowship is described in part as “a faithful gathering of open-minded youth welcoming of diverse perspectives and critical thinking.” One of the group’s goals for the coming year is to improve in the area of “creating opportunities for ‘Dialogue Across Culture/Creed’ through interfaith youth group opportunities and working with other churches, synagogues, mosques, etc.”

    Another large Congregational church in the Seattle area has a well-developed sense of identity. They describe themselves as “An open and affirming congregation, we celebrate our diversity in religious background, sexual orientation, race, and abilities.”

    Their youth pastor, Margaret, like her counterpart in Illinois, has a clear calling to ministry with students and seeks in a variety of ways to help young people feel empowered and to see how God fits into everyday-life issues they face. Her ministry vision statement is: “Youth Group is a place where we TALK about things that matter, we DO things that matter and we KNOW we BELONG! We Build Community through play, service, leadership, celebration, trust and prayer.”

    Margaret explained to me that very few of her youth group students’ friends identify themselves as Christians. They either belong to another religion or have none at all. So they are often in relationship and conversation with a diverse group of young people. Her church affirms itself as wholeheartedly Christian, while acknowledging and celebrating other religions and paths to God. They acknowledge that the congregation comprises many spiritual journeys. Because of this Margaret’s model for youth ministry is to affirm the youths’ questions and each individual faith journey. While teaching the stories of Jesus and the importance of what he modeled in service, caring for one another, unconditional love and deep justice, she encourages the young people to make their own informed decisions about faith. Her church and youth group seek to embody an extravagant welcome, and by engaging the youth in living out that extravagant welcome, they are invited into the radical message of the gospel characterized by love, justice and restoration of creation. She emphasizes in her ministry that God loves everyone and therefore all are welcome.

    Certainly there are many commonalities between the youth ministry at the church I attend and that of the Congregational churches in Illinois and Washington. In each case the youth leaders, both professional and volunteer, love youth, love God and sense their call to minister to youth. Both programs balance fun and teaching with serving others. The difference comes, however, in the interpretation of Scripture.

    Those who hold the modern view of religious pluralism may affirm the truth of all the verses the traditionalists hold; however, they would add a “but” or a caveat to these verses. For example,

    The Spirit of God has been revealed in many places throughout history and it makes no sense (it is in fact, arrogant) to disclaim the truth of other religions and how God, through his Spirit, has revealed himself. Think of religion as a mountain, with knowing God as the peak, and different religions represent different approaches to the peak, all heading toward the same ultimate goal.

    This “all heading for the same ultimate goal” is exemplified in the following seminary course description:

    This course will explore theological questions posed by religious plurality, especially the diversity among Jews, Christians, and Muslims. If God is One, how can different understandings of that Oneness be valid? Could the One Lord of nature and history have chosen to covenant with different faith communities? And if different communities are, in fact, “chosen” by God through Divine election and revelation, can they come to see themselves as spiritual allies, rather than adversarial rivals for God’s favor? Finally, how would a multiplicity of covenants enhance the prospects for the “messianic” transformation of history that our various traditions anticipate? On three occasions, guest teacher/facilitators will be invited to address these questions, drawing on perspectives from Judaism, Christianity, and Islam.

    Much of the modern viewpoint of religious pluralism rests on the writings of John Hick. Hick was a conservative Christian until he moved to the United Kingdom to teach philosophy at the University of Birmingham and became closely acquainted with Muslims and Hindus. Hick believes the traditional view of God and Christ is simply not adequate for the modern world and that those who believe in absolute truth must demythologize their own religious singular truth claims.

    He seeks to explain four realities that became apparent as his life intersected those of other faith communities.

  • People are religious.
  • Their religious beliefs are not the same.
  • Religious belief is not an illusion.
  • Religion seems to benefit the adherents.
  • He further rejects naturalism, which holds that all religious truth claims by definition are false. He also rejects religions that see the natural world itself as only illusory.

    It seems to Hick, particularly as he observed the religious worship of different faith communities, that they were all seeking an ultimate reality. Call this ultimate reality “God,” “Allah,” “Spirit” or whatever; it seems to be the same thing. What most religions are after he termed “the Real.” Granted, they come at the Real differently, but knowing the Real is the goal. For Hick, embracing religious pluralism is a matter of (1) realizing the common goal of most religions, (2) finding common ground in beliefs about the Real, and (3) discarding exclusivistic or superioristic claims.

    Finally, let’s consider a third perspective.

    Postmodern Religious Pluralism

    The essence of postmodernism is the notion that beliefs are just that, and that absolute truth is illusory. Truth is “personal” and if you seek to impose your truth upon me you are trying to colonize my life world. Life-world colonization is both arrogant and inappropriate.

    One religious denomination that is almost by definition postmodern is the Unitarian Universalist Church. In the Blue Boat blog, a trove of interesting stories about UUC churches or church members, the UUC is described as “a group of people who believe in organized religion but are skeptical about doctrine.”

    They have extensive resources for youth work and youth ministry leadership infrastructure at a national, regional and congregational level. The Welcome website explains it this way:

    As Unitarian Universalists, our call to the work of youth ministry rests on our spiritual commitment to build the world we dream about—a world in which our faith communities welcome people of all ages, cultures, and backgrounds to join hands in nourishing our spirits and healing the world.—The Youth Ministry Working Group Report, 2009.

    This is very much in the spirit of Mark Heim, who says that people should not worry about religious doctrines but focus on meeting the real needs of people or as the UUC statement says, “healing the world.” Another way to see the priority of UUC youth ministry is to view the curriculum they desire all local youth groups to affirm. Their core teaching curriculum for high school students is called Tapestry of Faith. The following is the course description for “A Place for Wholeness”:

    Youth, like adults and children, need to be able to talk about what it means to be Unitarian Universalist. Whether delivering an “elevator speech,” taking part in an interfaith dialogue, or conversing with friends at the lunch table, youth need practice in describing our multifaceted faith in terms that are personally meaningful and true. Building upon the faith development of Coming of Age and other UU identity programs, this curriculum encourages youth to look inward for a clearer understanding of their personal faith and guides them to express that faith outward into the world.

    Another comfortable home for a postmodern view of faith is the Inter-Faith Youth Core, founded by Eboo Patel. This organization, now international in scope, seeks to harness the altruistic DNA of religious youth toward the high calling of helping people in real need. Patel carefully exclaims he is respectful of religious identity; he seeks to unite youth of any or no religious belief for understanding and cooperation.

    Here the emphasis is not so much about finding common ground religiously. Instead religiousness is seen as unimportant compared to the mighty effort to help the world, help hurting people and become a better person. Postmodern religious pluralists do not expend energy worrying about differing beliefs or understanding theologies.

    Postmodern religious pluralism stands on the shoulders of Mark Heim and John Cobb. In Salvations: Truth and Difference in Religion Heim acknowledges that every religion has its own exclusivist claims. Nevertheless, there is no one way to salvation; there are, instead salvations. Religious people should not worry about these different salvations, instead they should be secure in their own belief or lack thereof. John Cobb extends the implication of this perspective in his Transforming Christianity and the World.

    In essence Cobb states we are to focus on a “creative response to the world crises. . . . [We need] passion for the earth and its poor and oppressed people.” While Cobb is himself a practicing Christian, his book posits that all doctrines are a response to a particular problem, question or challenge. The Christian faith then is a living faith in that it must now vigorously respond to the world crises. Faith is not important per se, but the response that we and others make is.

    Summary

    In this chapter we have looked at youth groups representing three different stances toward religious pluralism. We also examined the philosophical underpinnings of each. It’s obvious that one’s perspective on pluralism (one’s theology, actually) affects youth ministry praxis. I have documented this point anecdotally and by scholarly research.

    Some may ask, So what? Does it really make any difference in the real world when a youth group is traditional, modern or postmodern?

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑