Chapter 10 of 17

Summary

Summary

7

Youth Ministry Among Nones and Functional Syncretists

Mission Possible 1

Individuals become nones in at least four distinct ways. Therefore one approach won’t work with all types. In this chapter we will work with the four-context descriptions I have supplied in chapter three. For each type, I will share my own approach as well as resources and approaches of others.

Family Context Nones

Family context nones come from a family background in which religion and faith are not modeled or discussed. They are likely neither hostile or skeptical, but carry an awareness that some people are religious, whatever that may mean.

How and why do these nones end up in our youth group meetings and programs? It’s not because of slick advertising but because they were invited by and come with a friend. We have members of our youth group name five of their “most wanted” friends so we can pray for them. We pray that they would visit our youth group and come to faith. Our youth group meetings certainly are for the spiritual growth and encouragement of Christian students, but they also are understandable and accessible to nones.

These meeting are designed to help nones be open to the gospel, become part of the group and then realize that faith has sprouted in their hearts. They then are ready to self-identify as followers of Christ. What program features help this happen?

Certainly, worship is an important element. Seeing peers engaged with something (Someone) beyond themselves may trigger a feeling of wonder or curiosity. I have participated in some European youth festivals that bring together nones and Christian teenagers. Often events like these are the first time students from Eastern Europe, whose parents were atheists by law under communism, encounter a person their age who is a practicing Christian. It is astonishing, unexpected and filled with mystery. Many of them want to know how they can have what these Christian peers have.

Though the none students who have shown up in my youth groups were not from former communist countries, their stereotypes of religion and religious people often are disrupted by what they see and feel in the group.

I confess, music has never been my strength as a youth worker. Not only am I not musical but I’m not very good at recruiting musical people. There have been rare exceptions, but they have been just that, exceptions to my norm of zero music in my youth group meetings. In spite of this sad fact, none students have often come to Christ via the youth group meetings I’ve had a part in.

One thing that interests them is a student-led youth ministry. I try to get kids to lead any way I can. And when I lead a typical twenty- to thrity-minute Bible lesson, I never speak more than seven minutes, often less. I have students leading pieces of the lesson, and much time is spent in processing the lesson and in small group discussion. A paradigm shift often occurs to none students who experience a youth ministry with a high percentage of student leadership. They see peers who love Christ, and over time what once was inconceivable becomes imaginable, even possible and sometimes desirable. I have seen this happen hundreds of times.

Student leadership paired with peer-to-peer care and love becomes a compelling apologetic to nones. My student leadership core (see chap. 8) creates a climate of friendship, openness and care. When a none first comes to the youth group, he or she is a little disoriented by the vibe of this group compared to school. As the none continues to come, he or she begins to belong and eventually begins to believe.

A good example of a youth leader training resource and curriculum that emphasizes student-to-student care is Sonlife (sonlife.com). They anchor their whole ministry perspective on the model of Jesus’ ministry in the Gospels. Jesus modeled care to his disciples. How do we do that and help our students do it too? The tools we use to create care includes retreats, small groups, service projects and Bible teaching that facilitates an “other centered” consciousness.

How do we help none parents?

I find that some none parents are open to me as a Christian youth worker and don’t mind that their son or daughter is becoming interested in a Christian youth group.

Sometimes single parents feel desperate, especially single mothers of boys. If our student ministry actively engages the adolescent son or daughter in what are deemed “positive activities,” the religious content is often seen as innocuous or irrelevant to a grateful parent. To have caring adults and seemingly “together” peers actively caring about a son or daughter helps the single parent feel she or he is not alone. Being cognizant of the financial pressures many single parents experience and the potentially prohibitive costs of some youth group events, retreats or trips, I offer these teens a 50 percent subsidy or more if necessary.

None parents who are in some kind of crisis or under chronic stress seem wide open to their son’s or daughter’s involvement in a Christian youth group. I find that stressed parents feel guilty they are not providing for their children as well as they would like. They do not have the time or energy to help their son or daughter get involved in fun activities or extracurricular events that would add value to his or her life. A student ministry that provides their daughter or son with friendship, transportation, financial help (when needed), new experiences and the chance to learn new skills can be pretty impressive to stressed-out parents.

Behavioral Preference Nones

Behavioral preference nones perceive that religion will suppress their ability or desire to party, act out or be sexually active. These students typically do not show up in our youth group meetings to check things out. Instead, they avoid anything to do with religion.

In four decades of student ministry leadership I have seen only one path (with two subsequent branches) that may lead a behavioral preference none to faith: the proximity of a peer, a friend, who is a Christian of living faith.

The none student may understand this friend is religious, even Christian, and respond that it is “her choice” or “It’s fine for him; that’s cool, but it’s not for me” or “Whatever works, just don’t push it on me.” Nevertheless, knowing a practicing Christian peer (who also cares about his or her friends spiritually) is the first step. There are two scenarios in which a none who has a Christian friend comes to faith.

The first scenario is that the Christian friend invites this none to something that sounds amazingly fun. I’ve used Jello wrestling and pudding fights as special events. (It is precisely here that some may heap criticism on Christian youth ministry and its emphasis on fun.) My students find it easy to invite a friend to something like this. My urban youth worker friends use basketball tournaments as a draw. My artsy and hip youth worker friends have a storefront or warehouse stocked with the latest electronics and media equipment, and have rehearsal space and recording studios (I’m not making this up). And kids, brought by Christian friends, come.

I’ve used retreats or trips to desired destinations as outreach. For example, my Seattle and Vancouver youth group students found it easy to invite friends to ski and snowboard retreats at Whistler, British Columbia. In my New Jersey church I used winter retreat trips to Quebec as an “invite a friend” event.

In the context of fun events or amazing retreats I’ve seen “noneness” get deconstructed, not through teaching or preaching, but by being with Christian peers and seeing firsthand that one does not have to be drunk, high or in bed to have a great time.

The second scenario that draws a none to Christ is when she or he experiences a crisis that is too hard to handle. The none’s parents may be unable to help, or they may be the cause of the crises. A none in crisis, desperately seeking help, may wonder about that one Christian friend, Can she help me? What does he have that I don’t?

I find that parents of behavioral preference nones are often profoundly grateful for the positive influence a Christian youth group has on their wayward son or daughter.

Intellectual Issues with Christianity Nones

Nones that have intellectual issues with Christianity do not normally show up at youth group when invited, and they may even resist the urge to ski at Whistler or some other high-profile youth program. They steer clear of Christian youth events because they assume they will be preached at. They want none of it.

On occasion I have met these students when one is with a youth group member at a coffee, ice cream or a burger shop. I get introduced, and the none’s eyes reflect his or her thoughts: Poor stupid soul. I know my friend here thinks this guy is great, but how can he be so dumb? Sometimes they’ll smile and fire a question or two at me—something like “So, can God make something so heavy he can’t pick it up?” Or perhaps, “Since you believe God makes everything, does he make babies that have severe birth defects?” Or “So you believe that just because someone is born in Mongolia and they’ve never heard of Jesus, they will go to hell when they die?” I’m sometimes told that these nones later comment to my youth group student, “Well, I guess he’s not as dumb as I thought.”

The only way I have seen an intellectual issue none come to faith is through a crisis that the none cannot handle alone. A none in crisis often turns to a Christian friend, and sometimes even to me.

If I were invited to converse with none parents who are likewise skeptical for intellectual reasons, I would first ask how they came to nonfaith. I would then ask them if by chance they had read the French scholar Alain de Botton’s book Religion for Atheists: A Non-Believer’s Guide to the Uses of Religion. As I mentioned earlier, it is a compelling read. De Botton believes that religious faith is nonsense, but that atheists and agnostics should steal the good things that religion creates, such as wisdom, community, kindness, tenderness, educational motivation and perspective. Then I would invite them to consider the corpus of social science religiosity research (see chap. 5), which compellingly shows that living faith causes a host of positive life outcomes in adolescents and young adults. I would also ask them to consider something that may be an inconvenient truth: that the relation between living faith and these positive life outcomes is linear; that is, the more living faith a young person has, the better off the young person is. If the vibe was right in this conversation I would then comment, “I’m not suggesting you change your stance on faith, but I am suggesting you consider it okay that your son or daughter explores religious faith. Apparently, a great deal depends on it.”

Negative Experience None

We must admit that since Christians are indeed human, there is, unfortunately, ample opportunity for persons, young and old, to have a negative experience with Christians or in the church. The sad thing is, of course, that the rest of us get painted with that same negative brush.

I cringe when I recall the negative encounters some students in my own youth ministries have experienced. I recall Anne, the rather attractive eleventh grader who appeared in our youth group when her family had moved to the area. The boys were noticing her (an understatement!). On her second visit to our youth group meeting I was cleaning up the food table at the end of the meeting and overhead behind me one of our most discipled and leadership-­oriented girls, a senior, say to Anne, “We don’t need you here.” Or I think of Charlie, cognitively and physically disabled, who was so proud of the huge watermelon he brought to our youth group. During our “Summer Study and Swim Series” we always met at a home with a swimming pool. Cruelly, two of our other regular attenders (both males) took the watermelon from Charlie and smashed it on the road in front of the house where we were meeting, laughing at both Charlie’s shock and the hipness of their action.

Sigh! Times like these cause me to wonder if a career at Home Depot or Walmart might be more suitable.

If a negative experience none begins to come to youth group (always at the invitation of a vital-faith friend) and I have found out about his or her background, I don’t do anything other than pray. I observe that more often than not the new student seems to enjoy the experience and over time begins to identify with the group, sometimes even coming to faith. In these cases the caring Christian youth community deconstructs noneness through the fruit of the Spirit lived out before the newcomer. It must eventually dawn on the new student that not all Christians (young or old) are mean, hypocritical or abusive.

I’ve never had the opportunity to personally engage with a parent who is a none due to negative experience. (If I have known such parents, they did not identify themselves as such.) I have observed, however, that almost always nonchurched parents begin to like what they see in their son or daughter as a result of youth group attendance, and they are impressed with the quality of interest and care evidenced by the adults who are part of the student ministry leadership.

Student Ministry Among Those of À La Carte Faith

I was having one of those nights with our junior high group where everything went right. Well, almost everything. Attendance was good and the games went well. The kids (about forty 11- to 13-year-olds) participated with enthusiasm and did not adopt an “I’m too cool for this” attitude. They sat quietly when I was giving the Bible study, and many hands shot up when I asked discussion questions. My theme was unity and being kind to one another. The main point was, just like the early church, our group is very diverse, yet it can be a safe place. All heads nodded their assent. It was one of those times when, had it been a camp situation, we would have joined hands and sung “Kumbaya” or Michael W. Smith’s “Friends Are Friends Forever,” with faces and hearts aglow.

When we closed in prayer, over half the kids prayed out loud, variously offering thanksgiving to God for our wonderful group or praying that we would be kind, have unity and so on. It was one of those nights when things went right. Right, that is, until just after the last amen.

Sitting on my left side were the guys. They often tried to act tough, macho and oh-so-cool. The girls were on my right. Two seconds after I said amen and we were all enjoying the moment, Troy yelled, “Hey Liz, you’re fat, and you’re ugly!” He rolled over in laughter and was joined by most of the other guys in uproarious delight at such a well-timed insult. While the guys were still rolling on the floor, Liz stood to her feet, briefly surveyed the guys who were mocking her, burst into tears and ran from the room.

The rest of the group quickly dispersed as parents arrived to pick up their kids. It didn’t take a PhD to figure out what would be reported to parents on the way home.

If this had happened to you, which do you feel would have been the best course of action?

  • Confront Troy and banish him from the group for a month as discipline.
  • Call a parent meeting to go over acceptable behavior in youth group meetings.
  • Call the pastor or elders and report the incident. Perhaps then seek a meeting with Troy and his parents to agree on appropriate discipline.
  • None of the above.
  • Resign and seek a career with Home Depot or Starbucks.
  • I picked “None of the above.”

    I confronted Troy kindly in the parking lot. “Troy, I was a little confused by what you did in there. Weren’t you one of the people who thanked God for the wonderful feeling and unity we have in this group?” Troy replied, “She’s my sister, I can say what I want.” “Well Troy, what you did was wrong, and I know you’ll feel differently about this eventually.” He then turned and got into the car that was waiting to take him and his sister Liz home.

    I didn’t worry about the incident or do any follow-up. I knew Troy had yet to receive his cerebral upgrade. (Cerebral upgrade is my term for the hormonally triggered wiring of the prefrontal cortex of the brain, from which emanates the ability to think and reason deeply.) I knew that when Troy got his cerebral upgrade it would finally occur to him that the Christian faith actually applies at home, at school and at youth group meetings, and it is even applicable to siblings.

    By the time a year had passed and Troy was in ninth grade, he had had his upgrade and was a Christian who evidenced the fruit of the Spirit everywhere, including at home with his sister.

    This chapter examines adolescent cognitive development (which has many implications for youth work, including dealing with adolescent misbehavior), and gleaning how the insights gained may help inform our efforts to mitigate the cultural pressure toward syncretism and Moralistic Therapeutic Deism.

    The Cerebral Upgrade

    Those who work with teenagers have observed at least two things having to do with cognitive development: (1) young teens are different from older teens when it comes to the ability to “get it,” and (2) that girls generally “get it” before boys.

    Jean Piaget was among the first to propose a cognitive development schema, calling the maturation that takes place in adolescence “formal operations” or “abstract thinking.” One helpful way to think of this is that a child is incapable of thinking about a thought. That is, a child cannot reflect on the fact that he or she is thinking. Sometime between eleven and thirteen for girls and fourteen-plus for boys, hormones complete the wiring of the prefrontal cortex. Neuroscience tells us that the prefrontal cortex is where abstract thinking, time horizon, risk assessment and emotional intelligence emerge in the brain. Additionally, “executive function” and impulse control is generated by the prefrontal cortex.

    Another way to illustrate it is that a seven-year-old, for example, can express an opinion about liking their family car (it’s red!). But they are not able to explore the meaning of that thought in their head. They are not able to ponder why they like the family car: Is it the advertising I’ve seen? Is it that our neighbors have a car like ours? Is it because this car is appropriate to our socioeconomic status?

    When the prefrontal cortex starts to wire-up, it changes nearly everything for the young person. Typically they revisit every major area of their lives, including faith. Why do I believe in God? What will my future be? Life is full of choices, I can’t do everything, which will I choose and why? I want to be distinct from my parents, how can I do that?

    It is quite fun to watch the intellectual lights first come on in student ministry. When it happens the early teen girls are capable of deep spirituality, while the boys would rather play sports or blow stuff up (video games). I also enjoy seeing the slightest evidence that the boys have a prefrontal cortex at all, and over a year or two see them experience the delight, fun and terror of thinking about things in an entirely different way. That is, of course, what I knew would happen to Troy.

    There are many theories why it appears that prefrontal cortex development is happening later in life then it did decades ago. The academic consensus is settling around the notion that well-meaning parents are oversheltering their sons and daughters. That is, being too zealous to shield their kids from disappointment, setback, pain and responsibility. For example, in rural America, at least in the past if not the present, children and youth had responsibilities around the farm. Whether it was bringing in the eggs, milking the cows or making sure the horses had water, a farm kids could see the importance of their contribution to the family.

    Let’s see how understanding the cerebral upgrade may influence how we approach the subject of pluralism.

    With younger teens, it is certainly fine to present the beliefs and practices of other religions. It is certainly fine to explain that “of course we know the Bible teaches Jesus is the only way.” While perhaps one of the girls may then ask, “Does that mean my Buddhist locker partner is going to hell?” the vast majority of young teen boys will just take our words at face value and not give it a second thought.

    With older teens who have had their cerebral upgrade, we have the joy (and maybe the pain) of helping them wrestle with the not-so-subtle implications of the historic Christian faith’s view of Jesus as the only way of salvation. We can also give kids experiences and teaching that helps them see how important it is to not go à la carte when it comes to faith. We can model and teach what it means to believe in Christ as the only way, while at the same time be loving and welcoming to our friends of other faiths or no faith at all.

    We will come back to this hugely important topic shortly.

    Can Anything Be Done to Hasten Cognitive Development?

    It is my observation that cognitive and moral development are closely linked in teenagers, which makes sense. When we are developed enough to understand that we are recipients of God’s grace and mercy, it make us grateful and gives us the desire to live a life of gratitude, passing on to others the grace and love that has been given to us.

    As stated earlier, cognitive development can be hastened through a rich social environment that includes youth who are empowered to interact, plan and carry out those plans.

    Of course a youth group is an ideal venue for group decision making. For nearly four decades I have used a student-leadership-team approach to most youth ministries I have been involved with. That is, I have students in charge of certain major and minor decisions within the student ministry setting. In the context of our leadership team meetings, their ideas are put forward, evaluated, debated and ultimately decided on. The list of opportunities for student decision making are nearly endless: dramas, musicals, mission trips, Vacation Bible Schools and so on. Educators today would say critical thinking is facilitated in collaborative decision making.

    Taking responsibility for things that matter is the other side of the coin. Student-led small groups are a good example of youth responsibility. I use students (even young teens) to lead part of the Bible study or a portion of an outreach event. My personal policy is “The more important the event, the more important that youth are leading up front, much of the time if not the whole time.”

    Another strategy I use to encourage moral and cognitive development is to ask pre-cerebral-upgrade boys about their future behavior or what their behavior would look like if viewed from space.

    Marcus was in eighth grade, and by the middle of that year he was almost six feet tall and weighed nearly two hundred pounds. Some of the sixth graders in the group were only chest high to and less than half Marcus’s weight. Marcus loved to hog a whole couch to himself after playing group games. He would run into the youth room, jump over the back of a couch and spread himself out to take up all the space. If there was another kid already on the couch, Marcus shoved the kid with his massive foot until the couch was his alone.

    Marcus had a good side, however. Sometimes during the Bible study I could tell he was listening, and he occasionally made a comment or asked a question that showed a hint of cerebral activity.

    One evening I purposely ran in from outside along with the kids. As usual, Marcus jumped over the back of the couch and splayed himself across it. I sat on the floor, literally at his feet.

    “Hey Marcus, got a question for you.”

    “What’s up?”

    “How old do you think you’ll be when you stop hogging the couch all to yourself?”

    “What do you mean?” He looked at me with eyes wide.

    “What I mean is that when you get into the high school group next year you’ll probably observe that no one behaves the way you do when it comes to couch sitting. They share. Sometimes even boys and girls sit on the same couch. So, I was just curious, what year in high school do you think you might be when you start sharing the couch too?”

    Marcus starred at me and eventually offered, “I dunno.”

    He never hogged the couch again, ever.

    Here’s another example.

    Brian had a gift for verbal torture. He was a hyperactive seventh-grader. One of his main activities before and after youth group was to tease, ridicule and humiliate a small sixth-grade girl. Brian projected the image of being cool, urbane, hip, popular and worldly wise. He took every opportunity to help Missy know she was the absolute opposite: stupid, out of it and worthless. I had to hand it to Missy; she seemed generally unfazed by this negative attention. She was a deeply Christian girl (for a sixth-grader, anyway), and although I’m sure she would rather not face Brian’s onslaughts each week, she never­­theless came faithfully week after week.

    Another youth pastor had already addressed the group about how we treat each other, but Brian either didn’t hear or didn’t care. I did notice, though, that on rare occasions during Bible study Brian sometimes said something insightful. He had, as it were, one foot on the dock and one foot on the rowboat. Generally he was extremely immature, but there were glimpses of what I hoped would be the mature Christian that would eventually emerge.

    One night when Brian’s verbal abuse of Missy had risen to new heights, I pulled him aside (not in anger, but it was clear to him that he was to come with me). “Brian, I’m going to give you some feedback. I know you are not asking for any, but I’m going to give you some feedback anyway.”

    He stared off into space, purposely avoiding my eyes.

    “If I was from another planet and was visiting earth for the very first time and was sitting here for the last half hour, I would have concluded that it was your sole purpose as a human being to torture Missy. I would have guessed that this is all you have had on your mind all day, and that tonight, now that you two are in the same place, you are unleashing all the negative things you’ve been planning against her.”

    He continued to look away.

    “So I guess I’m a little confused. In Bible study sometimes you seem to say that you are a Christian and believe the Bible and stuff. Yet out here, you are clearly trying to make Missy not only miserable but miserable that she was ever born in the first place. So, what gives? Help me understand.”

    He ran off to join his friends.

    Brian did not come near Missy the rest of the evening. He didn’t next week either. Missy and her family moved away at the end of the school year, and as far as I observed and know from others, Brian had completely ceased his rotten treatment of her. I think my extraterrestrial point of view got his attention and made him actually try to think about something from a different point of view. Seeing a different point of view is a marker of the beginnings of a cerebral upgrade. Having said that, though, and looking back on it, I probably should have gone further some weeks later and asked him to apologize to Missy when I noticed his behavior had consistently changed for the better. I missed an opportunity to affirm him, which was unfortunate since especially middle school kids don’t get much positive adult input.

    To me, one of the most enjoyable things about youth work is being on hand to watch kids mature before my very eyes. In Brian’s case the next school year he was contributing regularly and positively to the discussion times in Bible study. In high school he was on the student leadership team and admired for his commitment to both the youth group and to Christ.

    Whether they become cerebrally upgraded early, late or right on schedule, we can help Christian adolescents be less inclined toward an à la carte faith. Let’s look at how several different youth ministries intentionally help their students in this way.

    Stories from the Front

    How are youth groups today seeking to help their own young people maintain a traditional Christian faith that is vital, heartfelt and welcoming?

    To get a feel for what was actually happening in youth groups (aside from the one I volunteer in) I received permission to survey the youth workers of the Evangelical Free Church of America, which comes from the traditional Christian perspective described in chapter five. I appreciated more than a decade earlier their being one of the four Protestant denominations that participated in my PhD research on youth group numerical growth.

    The first questions of my survey covered demographic and ministry context matters, while the other questions addressed matters related to “Jesus as the only way.” The survey is not scientific in that it is not a random sample of Evangelical Free youth workers. The results cannot be generalized to other conservative youth workers, or youth workers of any denomination. Having said that, seventy of their full-time youth workers completed the survey and returned it to me within twelve hours of the survey launch. Their answers provide an interesting glimpse of how these particular youth pastors conceptualize and experience the subjects of the adolescent tolerance, syncretism and à la carte faith. Some narrated their experiences at considerable length. All the data reflected here speaks of these seventy full-time youth pastors.

    Survey summary. The youth workers of the Evangelical Free Church have been serving in their church, that is, the same church, for 6.35 years. That is a year longer than the typical youth pastor stays in his or her post according to other research. Eighty-six percent are male and the middle age range (42%) is thirty to thirty-nine. Two-thirds of these youth workers have a ministry-oriented bachelor’s or master’s degree and another 25 percent have a bachelor’s or master’s degree in a different subject area. Just over half minister to youth groups that are combined middle and high school age; most of the others lead groups that are senior high school only.

    Survey question 7 reads: “I believe Jesus Christ is the only way of salvation, that only Christianity, no other religions or religious leaders, provide a way for salvation and heaven.” They had to choose one of three answers: yes, not sure, not really.

    All seventy youth pastors chose yes.

    Table 7.1. Youth Ministry Setting Where “Jesus as the One and Only Way” Is Presented

    Especially if you teach/present once a year or more, what is the setting?

    They were then asked to indicate how often Jesus as the one and only way to salvation was addressed in a typical year. Ninety-one percent indicated “We present on this more than once a year.” I next asked what youth ministry settings this teaching took place in. Table 7.1 presents the results.

    Survey question 11 stated, “If you teach on this once or more a year, describe how you do this.”

    Most said they teach a lot from Scripture, and since Jesus is the only way of salvation expressed in the New Testament, this message is communicated clearly and often with their youth. One youth pastor from California put it this way:

    This truth is dripped into every message, sermon, small group and devotional. You can’t teach anything in a Christian ministry setting and not bring it back to the Bible and the fact that everything we believe hinges on the fact that Jesus lived, died, and lives again and He did this to give us relationship with Him and a purpose to life. Everything we teach must go back to this truth. If it does not it is only self-help and feel good advice and opinions. We can get that from a doctor, therapist, spiritualist or bar tender.

    Another, from Wisconsin, put it this way:

    This is ingrained into everything we do. We teach this all the time because we teach the Bible and I don’t see any way in which to teach the Bible without teaching that Jesus is the way, the truth, and the life and that no one comes to the Father except through Him.

    The final three questions allowed the youth pastors to state specific examples of how they try to get this across to their students. Their response could be as long as they wished. They were also asked to identify the resources they use and whether they have experienced pushback from youth or parents in this regard.

    Among the ideas that are not tied to a specific curriculum, one youth pastor from just outside of New York City divides his students into small groups every three years. Each group is assigned a topic related to pluralism or a specific religion other than Christianity. Each group can use a computer for research (their youth room has wifi); resource books are provided as well. On three successive weeks the students work in their groups to become “experts on their topic.” In the next several weeks each group presents their material, which is then discussed in light of the historic Christian view.

    Another youth pastor, this one from Michigan, likes to have some kind of mission or service trip every year. They may help with natural disaster cleanup in a different state or neighborhood cleanup in their own. They may go to a different country to partner with a church in their Vacation Bible School or in some other way. As a prerequisite to going on this trip, students must be able to articulate what they believe about Jesus and why they remain Christians instead of joining some other religion, designing their own faith à la carte or drop faith altogether. In preparation they role-play different scenarios and receive group feedback from their peers.

    A youth pastor in Texas states he does not usually teach through particular books or chapters of the Bible, but rather he addresses topical themes such as identity or relationships. In his own words,

    When talking about identity I will highlight Jesus alone can give a real and life-giving identity. When talking about prayer I will highlight that because of Jesus alone we are able to approach God in prayer. When talking about relationship I will teach that Jesus alone offers the way to loving relationships.

    If I were filling out the survey I would have highlighted an idea from my fourteen years as youth pastor in a Seattle church. Every fourth year I invited a different non-Christian professor from the University of Washington to come to our senior high Sunday school class to explain why they had chosen not to be a Christian. This was not designed to be a debate, but students were allowed to ask questions for clarification. The idea was that two or three students would take careful notes during the presentation, and the following Sunday we reviewed and discussed the professor’s talk point by point. My students found this a profoundly helpful experience.

    And as I expected, everyone wanted to be there. The place was jammed on these two Sundays, nearly a hundred students were present. Of the times we did this my favorite presenter was a female philosophy professor. Her lecture began with much bravado and confidence as she strode back and forth as if lecturing to hundreds in some grand Harvard auditorium. Our kids listened well, smiled respectfully and occasionally asked a question. About twenty minutes into her talk, she began to stumble verbally. Her ideas we not flowing, though her notes were in front of her. This got worse, and finally she just quit. She put down her notes, looked up at one hundred pairs of eyes looking at her and exclaimed, “God, I wish my thirteen-year-old daughter had a group like this to attend!”

    Now that is quite a statement from an atheist! She thanked us for the opportunity and sat down. The applause our kids gave her was long and heartfelt. I thanked her for coming and ended the session. Immediately about twenty kids lined up to thank her personally, some gave her a hug and asked about her daughter. She was visibly shaken by this experience, as she had no categories for “Christian teenagers happy to be with each other, their leaders, the church and God.”

    In the survey I asked about pushback. While most youth pastors did not identify anything specific, several did, most having to do with the cultural trend toward tolerance, which is taught at school. The following are some examples.

    Our students are presented with so many differing views and options, it’s hard for them to commit to a single way. (Nebraska)

    I get questions that reflect that (it seems to me) our youth think Christianity is the best/only way in the same way they think their favorite sports team is the only one that deserves to win. So they are comfortable being on the “best team” but would probably struggle to come right out and say that all the other teams are going to hell. (Minnesota)

    My students struggle with the “only way” because they fear if it gets out they believe this it will impact their reputation in a negative way. (Colorado)

    Here push back in the context of small groups, when our kids get secure enough to be honest about their doubts. (Indiana)

    My kids, even the ones from “good” Christian families, seem to have a grocery store mentality when it comes to religion . . . that anything can be added to their shopping cart. It makes me wonder if this stuff has ever been addressed at home by the parents. (Virginia)

    Curious to get a feel from a Canadian point of view, I asked a friend from Vancouver about this. His response included, “a ‘normal’ culturally conditioned youth in Vancouver these days cannot even conceive of the idea that one faith is right and one wrong. When I say that one [faith] is right and the others wrong that is just viewed as part of ‘my beliefs.’”

    Exemplary Ministries

    Among my own contacts in youth ministry are several who provide me with many examples of “best practices” in youth ministry in a multifaith society.

    For eight years Jerry has been one of the youth pastors at a large Church of the Nazarene congregation in Virginia. He is an example of one who is proactively helping his youth navigate their way through a culture of tolerance and pluralism with their hearts, not just their heads. He says,

    First of all, our student ministry clearly and loudly proclaims Jesus as the ONLY WAY to salvation, while maintaining a clear understanding that the trends of our society lean heavily toward that message not only being intolerant, but downright destructive. In a nutshell, the best way to kill a party is to start talking about the exclusivity of Jesus as the WAY to heaven.

    In regards to training/discipleship, we challenge our students toward a “show, THEN tell” approach to sharing their faith. Where is my faith in Christ evidently seen (without being “showy”)? How am I loving God by loving ALL people, regardless if they agree with me or not? And when we do have conversations that turn spiritual in nature, we must be sure to be “R.I.P.” That is:

  • Respectful: We aren’t called to point out wrong as much as we’re called to point to Jesus. I don’t think Christians are called to argue souls into the Kingdom. We teach students that respect comes primarily from listening well, not speaking persuasively.
  • Intellectual: We train our students to be intelligent about what they believe. We train our students that the teen years is prime time to let go of faith because your parents told you it’s true (for example) and grab hold of faith because IT’S TRUE and we understand WHY it’s true.
  • Personal: Every person we interact with is a person Jesus died for. Non-Christians aren’t projects and they aren’t the enemy. They’re the object of God’s affection and it’s up to us to convey that with light and salt.
  • He then goes on to explain the “True North” series he came up with about these issues. All emphasize the truth of the gospel (as traditionally understood but communicated in such as way as to emphasize that our role is to, as Jerry says, “show, then tell.”

    Dave is the lead youth pastor (of four) in a large evangelical church in New Jersey, where he has been for twelve years. Their student ministry has adopted the whole country of Ireland as a youth mission field and has planted two youth ministry centers that are now self-sustaining and have the enthusiastic blessing of local churches. Three additional youth ministry centers are under development and are close to being self-sustaining. Over lunch he recently told me that they have purchased, in the last six years, 275 round-trip tickets from Newark, New Jersey, to Dublin. By the time students in their ministry graduate from high school most have been to Ireland multiple times and engaged in various leadership roles on the field. And they sustain ongoing friendships with multiple Irish young people. It is quite apparent that most of the students who graduate out of this ministry do so with a traditional Christian faith that has been stretched and tested repeatedly.

    Dave’s ministry emphasizes that students know the Christian faith, but just as important to him is that they feel it and experience it as well. In this he is putting in action his understanding of the four learning styles; that is, most students learn best not by hearing or reading but by feeling and experiencing. In my opinion, outside of getting a graduate degree in education, the best description of the four learning styles is Marlene Lefever’s Learning Styles. Analytic learners (about 30% of youth and adults) love systematic information, enjoy taking notes, and look forward to teaching that involves sitting and listening. They also love predictability in a learning situation. Relational learners (25% of youth and adults) don’t know what they are learning or what they think until they are talking about it with others; concepts emerge and gain clarity as they are processed with and through others verbally. Dynamic learners (about 28% of youth and adults) tune in when things are creatively done. They respond well to visual stimuli and they are happy to be surprised by what happens in a teaching-learning situation. And if they get to stand up, move around or do something with their hands during a teaching-learning situation, it makes them happy and motivated. Common sense learners (17% of youth and adults) may not say it out loud, but in their heads about every three minutes they are asking, So what? They embrace learning that is practical and immediately applicable to the situation at hand.

    In all of the teaching that happens in Dave’s youth ministry, the leaders are very aware that the vast majority of his students do not learn best via the sit-and-listen approach. He tries to hit all four learning styles in every teaching session that lasts more than twenty minutes.

    Certainly the Irish mission is fraught with feelings and experiences, but the whole emphasis in their New Jersey youth ministry is to help youth know, feel and experience the faith.

    This pedagogy comes together sublimely in their retreats. Here is Dave’s description of one retreat.

    We started off our retreat with a game as soon as the teens got there. We split into four different teams and students raced to find different pieces of a puzzle.

    The puzzle pieces have parts of a clue that were written on with invisible ink and so to figure out the final clue they had to bring their puzzle pieces back to the main meeting room. There we had cut the meeting room in half with large dark curtains and had setup the back half of the room with black lights. All of this was to set up the main illustration of the night.

    After the game was complete I gathered the group and had them write on their hands (privately) the different sins they all knew they needed to work on in their lives. We then read from Isaiah where Isaiah sees God and says, “Woe is me. For I am a man of unclean lips and I have seen the Lord Almighty.” I asked them how they would feel if they went behind the curtain in the back half of the room again and I held up their hands to the black lights. I told them that standing before God that’s exactly what it would be like . . . everything exposed. I then shared the truth about Jesus. How only his death had paid the price for their sins so that they could stand before God unashamed and be connected with Him.

    We entered into a time of communion which we had set up behind them while I was speaking.

    We set up large clear plastic cups in the shape of a cross (placed on a plastic sheet) and dipped the cups in red paint. We placed bread around the cross and surrounded it with candles.

    As we sang a response song students were told to eat the bread and take the cup and wipe the red paint over their hands where they had written their sins to symbolize what Jesus had done for them and then enter behind the big curtain into God’s presence. Behind the curtain we had started a blazing fire in a fireplace and so as they ate the bread and took the cup they covered their sins with the red paint that symbolized Jesus blood and walked into a completely dark room with nothing but an intense fire representing God’s holiness and presence.

    Kids stayed there on their face in complete silence for hours. It was reverent and silent and holy. One teen said to me after, “I couldn’t get the blood off my hands!! I never realized it was my sin that He died for and it’s my hands that put Him there.” I said, “And it is your hands that He forgave and cleaned.”

    Summary

    In this chapter we have considered how youth workers try to reach out to nones and stem the flow of students who, knowingly or not, gravitate toward syncretism. I also made the point that awareness of basic adolescent cognitive development guides us in terms of what may be appropriate to present to teenagers at different stages of cognitive and moral development.

    Next we will examine how to help our own students build bridges to sincere believers of other religions and deepen their own faith in the process.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑