Chapter 6 of 17

Summary

Summary

3

The Rise of Syncretists and Nones

Understanding Those Whose Faith Is to Have None at All or, More Tolerantly, Believe That All Faiths Are Equal

In my decades of student ministry I have rarely met an atheistic teenager who is evangelistic, that is, one who is missional in his or her desire to convert peers from faith to nonfaith. Typically such an adolescent is raised in a home with no living spirituality. Religious faith is not seen as important or relevant; there are more pressing and tangible concerns. The National Study of Youth and Religion (NSYR) observes that young people turn out a lot like their parents in many ways, including faith or lack thereof (see table 3.1). Therefore, when thinking about nones we need to include their parents and family context.

The study of declining religious participation and belief among adults in the United States is a fertile field for social science. The American Religious Identification Survey of 2008 revealed that the number of adults identifying themselves as having no religion increased from 13.1 million in 1990 to 30.4 million—15 percent of the population—in 2008. Among Americans ages eighteen to twenty-nine the figure is 22 percent. The ARIS study also revealed that the majority of nones are “neither atheists nor theists but rather agnostics and deists (59%) and perhaps best described as skeptics.” This observation is important when considering parent-student ministry implications later in this chapter.

Table 3.1. Parents’ Faith and Their Teens’ Faith

Teen importance of faith

Parent importance of faith

Extremely

Very

Somewhat

Not very

Not at all

extremely important

30%

37%

24%

5%

3%

very important

14%

32%

36%

12%

5%

fairly important

7%

23%

38%

21%

10%

somewhat important

8%

15%

41%

20%

16%

not very important

3%

11%

37%

22%

26%

not important at all

2%

15%

37%

19%

28%

Source: Christian Smith and Melinda Denton, Soul Searching (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), p. 56.

As we think more specifically about youth and emerging adults and the subject of nones, the NSYR is a good place to begin. Only about 20 percent of emerging adults are engaged in their Christian faith, pray, read the Bible and are active in their church or parachurch organization. This is about a 10 percent decline from those same young people five years previous.

Interestingly, this 20 percent figure of active faith and engagement for nineteen- to twenty-five-year-olds has not changed in forty years, according to the General Social Survey. In a helpful step to understanding the other 80 percent, the NSYR five-year follow-up among individuals now ages nineteen to twenty-four divided emerging adults into six major religious types, three of which would fit under the none umbrella.

“Religiously indifferent” nineteen- to twenty-four-year-olds (25% of this age cohort) don’t oppose religious faith; they simply see no need for it their lives right now. Religion may be wonderful for others, and they are certainly tolerant of religious people, but faith is not a priority for them. Smith and Snell, after interviewing a large portion of their sample population, posit a possible “cognitive logic” of the religiously indifferent:

Major premise: Serious religion means no partying and no sex before marriage.

Minor premise: I do or may want to party and have sex before marriage.

Conclusion: I am not legitimately part of or interested in serious religion.

The second category is “religiously disconnected” emerging adults (5% of this age cohort). They have no real knowledge of religious faith; it was not part of their family’s DNA. They do not favor or oppose religious faith; it’s just a nonissue to them.

The third category, “irreligious” nineteen- to twenty-four-year-olds (10% of this age cohort) are skeptical of religious faith and are able to articulate, with some incredulousness, their reasons for nonbelief. ­Irreligious emerging adults usually have parents who were either once religious but left their faith, or who were agnostic or atheistic from the outset.

Antecedents of Noneness

Family context. We have already seen that adolescents and emerging adults tend to mimic the religiosity of their parents. It makes perfect sense that a child growing up in a family context devoid of God talk or even Easter and Christmas church attendance, and being educated in a school system that steers clear of any mention of faith, would quite naturally be irreligious. The NSYR is only one of many empirical studies that affirm the parent religiosity and teenage/young adult religiosity link. As a youth worker these are my favorite not-yet-Christian people. They may know nothing about faith and may not be interested, but at least they are not hostile. (I love helping these youths and their parents gradually come to the realization that perhaps they should think about faith.)

The behavior context. Does belief create behavior or does behavior create belief? Social scientists love to study things like this. In short, the academic consensus is that it goes both ways. This connects well to the “cognitive logic” in which an individual wants to be free to party and have sex and therefore steers clear of religious belief, expression or close relationships with those who seem to have an active faith. Here the individual sees religious faith as a straightjacket to be avoided, that religious faith is regressive and limiting to personal freedom. I have known many adolescents who held this view. Religious faith would, they believe, spoil their fun.

The intellectual context. Among the main reasons adolescents and emerging adults step away from an active faith and become, for all practical purposes, nones is that they cannot reconcile faith and science. Other intellectual reasons for faith exit include rejection of the exclusive claims of Christianity and the perception that the church is hostile to doubt. Additionally, some none young people see the church’s answer to many issues, sexuality, for example, as simplistic and judgmental.

The negative experience context. Many of us who work with youth and young adults know young people who have been deeply scarred. It is extremely difficult, for example, for someone raised by a judgmental, vindictive and abusive parent (even one who was outwardly religious) to sense God’s love or a desire to affiliate with a church. Aside from faith-killing negative experiences in the home, there are ample additional sources of emotional toxicity that foster distance from faith. Among these are clergy child abuse, made famous in the 1990s and 2000s in the Roman Catholic Church, and the departure of a much-loved youth pastor. Breaking these important relational bonds can trigger an exit from a youth group and the church. Certainly, experiencing hypocrisy in the church also serves as a faith repellant to young people. Left unchecked, negative experiences foster cynicism, which is certainly inimical to faith.

The Emerging Cultural Infrastructure for Noneness

No matter how a person becomes a none, there is a growing multifaceted movement in the United States (and Western Europe) that affirms, encourages and supports individuals in their nonaffiliation with religious faith. It is important for those of us in Christian youth ministry to be aware of this movement.

Among the most developed none organizations is Recovering from Religion, which likes to highlight Mark Twain’s famous words: “Faith is believing what you know ain’t so.” They introduce themselves with the words:

If you are one of the many people who have determined that religion no longer has a place in their life, but are dealing with the after-effects in some way or another, Recovering From Religion (RR) may be just the right spot for you. We welcome everyone, from doubting theist to ardent atheist, and our goal is to assist you in dealing with the negative impact of religion in your life. We are honored to be part of your journey to be free from faith!

The organization has no youth outreach, but they have support groups across North America (and globally). Undoubtedly the subject of parenting teenagers in nonfaith is raised in such gatherings.

Another example is the Reason Rally Coalition, which held its first major gathering in Washington, D.C., in 2012, with twenty thousand in attendance. It was billed as a celebration of secular values and the nontheist view of the world. Among the twenty sponsors of the coalition is the Secular Student Alliance. Unlike other none organizations, the Secular Student Alliance is specifically for university and high school students. The alliance offers resources to begin, maintain and grow Secular Student Alliance groups on school campuses, and there are over four hundred of these groups in America. Beyond none organizations and events, there are emerging social networks for nones, such as facebook.com/skeptictalk as well as books that affirm and celebrate nonbelief. Titles include Happily Godless: A Young Adult’s Guide to Atheism by Paul Donvan, and The Phoenix and the Peacock: A Tale of Feathers and Hidden Treasure by Sienna Storm. The websites and literature of the none organizations reveal that there is immense optimism that secularism will continue to gain in visibility and influence.

Syncretism

Every fall a very strange thing happens in the United Kingdom. If one happens to be on a flight into or out of any of London’s four airports just after sunrise or just before sunset, Roman cities appear outlined in some of the fields below. I am not kidding. I read about this phenomenon twenty years ago and have seen it with my own eyes once. Since one of my odd interests is Roman Britain, I nearly yelped with glee at the sight.

While the phenomenon seems mysterious, it really is anything but. Just below the plowed surface of many fields in the United Kingdom lie the stone foundations of Roman buildings. The proximity of these stones to the surface has an impact on moisture retention, which affects the growth rate of the crops directly above. Thin-soil crops grow slower than crops growing in deeper soil. Late in the growing season this growth differential is noticeable from the air, and especially when the sun is at low angle. The sun’s low angle throws into relief the crop growth differentials, and thus Roman streets, houses, shops, government and military buildings are all of a sudden there.

In this chapter I throw into relief an aspect of youth and emerging adult belief about religion: many have a faith whose constituent parts seem to have been chosen à la carte. We will come at this from several angles: quantitative research, sociological-cultural theory and theological reflection. Each in turn will throw into relief in a slightly different way the syncretistic nature of adolescent faith today.

Quantitative research. When seen from the angle of social science research, which involves surveys and statistics, a decades-long shift in religious allegiances in the United States is thrown into relief. In the 1960s and 1970s as the precipitous decline in mainline church attendance became noticeable, sociologists documented what was happening. Religious switching continues to be a huge and fertile field in social science research.

For example, one early study in the 1960s revealed marriage was a frequent cause of religious switching. The spouse with the strongest denominational attachment normally determines which church the couple identifies with in the future. A scale was developed that ranks the denominations most likely to lose out in a marriage-choice situation. Roman Catholics are most likely to switch because of marriage, followed by Episcopalians and then Lutherans.

Today the best studies related to adolescent and emerging adult religious shifting comes from the National Study of Youth and Religion and the Jesus Survey. Other sources such as the General Social Survey and the Baylor Religion Survey of 2005 also make positive contributions.

National Study of Youth and Religion. Five years after the National Study of Youth and Religion, which began in 2002 and was completed in 2003, an extensive follow-up study was done with the same youths, now eighteen to twenty-three and termed “emerging adults.” While most young people continued to identify with the religion of their parents, emerging adults who identified themselves as Protestants declined 7 percent (from 53% to 46%), and those who identified themselves as Roman Catholic declined 6 percent (from 24% to 18%). Thus Roman Catholics and Protestants had lost the allegiances of 13 percent of those in the study. Interestingly, those who identified themselves as “not religious” increased by exactly 13 percent (from 14% to 27%).

We don’t know what nonreligious specifically means from the research. It could mean religion is no longer important to them, but it could also mean they retain an amalgamation of religious beliefs but no longer attend any church.

Among the many tables in this 2007–2008 National Study of Youth and Religion we can establish the traditions the newly nonreligious came out of. (We’ll consider nones again in chapter seven, including ways they are reachable.)

Table 3.2. Percentage of 13- to 17-year-olds by Religious Tradition Who Left That Tradition and Became Nonreligious as 18- to 23-year-olds

conservative Protestant

15%

mainline Protestant

24%

black Protestant

11%

Roman Catholic

20%

Jewish

37%

Morman

17%

other religions

30%

Source: Christian Smith and Melinda Denton, Soul Searching (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), p. 109.

We see in table 3.2 that conservative, black Protestants and Mormons had losses of under 20 percent, while mainline, Roman Catholic, Jewish and other religions experiences losses of 20 percent or greater.

The 2007–2008 National Study of Youth and Religion also asked emerging adults about their beliefs relating to religious pluralism. Since the same people were interviewed in both studies, we can compare attitudes of religious exclusivity compared to five years prior (see table 3.3).

In question 1 we see three perspectives—“only one religion is true” (traditional), “many religions may be true” (modern) and “there is little truth in any religion” (postmodern)—and the shifting attitudes over five years. Forty-five percent of conservative Protestant eighteen- to twenty-three-year-olds held the traditional perspective, which was down slightly (2%) a half-decade later. Mainline Protestants and Roman Catholics were down 4 percent. Some conservative Protestants might look at the change and be satisfied that it dropped only 2 percent. Others would be aghast at the first number, that slightly less than half (45%) of their eighteen- to twenty-three-year-olds believe only one religion, presumably theirs, is true. In any case, both the traditional and modern views shrank while the postmodern view has grown.

Table 3.3. National Study of Youth and Religion: Beliefs of US Emerging Adults About Religious Exclusivity, Ages 18 to 23

US

CP

MP

RC

J

LDS

BP

Q1. Beliefs about the truth of one’s religion

Only one religion is true

29%

45%

22%

38%

11%

60%

38%

(percent change)

-2%

-4%

-4%

-4%

4%

-5%

4%

Many religions may be true

57%

45%

66%

49%

53%

32%

66%

(percent change)

-2%

0%

-1%

-1%

-24%

9%

-11%

There is very little truth in religion

12%

7%

12%

13%

36%

8%

8%

(percent change)

4%

4%

7%

5%

21%

1%

4%

Q2. It’s OK to pick and choose religious beliefs without having to accept teachings of faith as a whole

Agree

52%

40%

61%

61%

8%

37%

37%

Percent change in 5 years

7%

8%

8%

8%

-11%

8%

2%

US = all US youth, CP = conservative Protestant, MP = mainline Protestant, RC = Roman Catholic, J = Jewish, LDS = Mormon, BP = black Protestant

Source: Christian Smith and Melinda Denton, Soul Searching (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), p. 135. A recent study of adults tells a similar story, with 83 percent of Roman Catholic adults doubting their religion is the only way. Seventy-nine percent of mainline Protestants were similarly pluralistic in their outlook. See Robert Putnam and David Cambell, American Grace (New York: Simon & Schuster, 2010), p. 536.

In question 2 we get at the heart, at least statistically speaking, of the impulse to pick and choose beliefs. Now 40 percent of conservative Protestant youth, and 61 percent of mainline and Roman Catholic youth connect with the à la carte approach to religious faith, and these numbers are up considerably from five years earlier.

The NSYR follow-up also asked the conservative, mainline and Roman Catholic respondents if they engaged in religious practices outside of Christianity. Other practices included aspects of Buddhism, Hinduism, Zen, Wicca, witchcraft or other pagan religions. Five percent of conservative Protestant youth, 15 percent of mainline youth and 9 percent of Roman Catholic youth did.

The NSYR is certainly not the only research effort helping us understand the contours of adolescent belief. Let’s examine some others.

Jesus Survey. The Jesus Survey was conceived in the mind of Mike Nappa, who surveyed the teenage workers of the high-profile youth missions organization Reach Workcamps (www.reachwc.org), which involves over eight hundred Christian teenagers in camps that do work, service and outreach projects in ten US states. To participate as a worker or leader in Reach, a teen has to have strong Christian faith and have a willingness to articulate it. Similarly, he or she must be willing to put that faith in action through hard physical

Table 3.4. Jesus Survey Q19

Do Jesus, Muhammad, Buddha and other great religious leaders all have equal standing in leading people to heaven?

Strongly agree

10%

Somewhat agree

23%

Somewhat disagree

19%

Strongly disagree

48%

Source: Christian Smith and Melinda Denton, Soul Searching (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), p. 73.

work during the summer.

The Jesus Survey included two questions specifically germane to pluralism. Table 3.4 shows the results of the first.

We see then that one-third of these Christian teens held the modern view, that Christianity is not the only way to heaven.

To gain more clarity on the issue, the Jesus Survey asked the question a different way. Question 20 stated, “I am 100% certain that Jesus is the only way to heaven.” Fifty-six percent strongly agreed, another 24 percent somewhat agreed and the remaining 20 percent either strongly or moderately disagreed. Cross-correlations were done between the two questions, and the Jesus Survey suggests that 13 percent of the youth firmly believed Jesus in not the only way, 39 percent were unsure about the issue, and 49 percent were sure.

The Jesus Survey results from questions 19-20 can be seen as consistent with the NSYR results. This survey also looked at denominational differences. Denominations represented in large enough numbers are delineated in table 3.5. The differences are obvious.

Table 3.5. Jesus Survey: Teen Opinions About Salvation

Is Jesus the only way to salvation? (percent by denomination)

Source: Mike Nappa, The Jesus Survey (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 2012), p. 79.

In looking at the statistics of these tables, we can posit that youth who do not believe Jesus is the only way or who are unsure are open to a syncretistic religious faith.

Other questions queried strength of belief in the trustworthiness of the Bible, the divinity of Jesus and Jesus’ resurrection. Table 3.6 shows the numbers of youth who had “strong confidence” in all four basic tenets of the Christian faith.

Table 3.6. Jesus Survey: Confidence in All Four Key Doctrines of the Christian Faith

nondenominational

36%

other denominations

26%

Baptist

17%

Presbyterian

12%

Brethren in Christ

5%

United Methodist

5%

undeclared

3%

Catholic

1%

Episcopal

0%

Lutheran

0%

United Church of Christ

0%

Source: Christian Smith and Melinda Denton, Soul Searching (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005), p. 89.

Baylor Religion Survey. The Baylor Religion Survey provides us with more data regarding the context of adolescent faith and beliefs about other religions. Funded by the Templeton Foundation, the survey included only those ages eighteen and older in a national sample. The results are telling (see table 3.7).

Table 3.7. Baylor Religion Survey Question 25

Which one statement comes closest to your personal view of religious salvation?

My religion is the one true faith that leads to salvation.

19.6%

Many religions lead to salvation.

52.9%

I do not believe in religious salvation.

16.7%

I don’t know.

10.7%

Source: The Baylor University Religion Survey 2005, accessed November 25, 2012, www.thearda.com/QuickStats/QS_64.asp.

More than half of the respondents held “tolerant” or “modern” views. Little wonder young people believe as they do.

The quantitative data provides a clear picture. Let’s now look from another angle.

À la carte faith in cultural trends and sociological theory. The authors of the NSYR do not blame the ebbing of the historic Christian faith on heretical preaching or even anemic teaching in youth groups. Rather, they place the blame squarely on public education.

Nearly all teens seem to have adopted a posture of civility and careful ambiguous inclusiveness when discussing religion. . . . It is also obvious that, in all of this, public schools have served an effective training ground for teaching teenagers to be civil, inclusive, and non-offensive when it comes to faith and spiritual matters.

Nappa observes, “The overarching value of supposed tolerance for other religions has somehow trumped the value of truth, making it natural for our Christian students to actually deny their own beliefs when they may be perceived (whether rightly or wrongly) as intolerant.”

A parallel cultural trend is that religion is only one of many social institutions competing for the finite attention of adolescents. School, sports and television have been part of the scene for decades. Today adolescent time and attention is additionally taxed by video games, smartphones, Facebook, Twitter and so on. Smith and Denton observe,

Religion clearly operates in a social-structurally weak position. . . . If we conceive of adolescents’ lives as bundles of finite interest, energy, and investment, then we can think of the various social institutions that touch adolescents’ lives as seeking to lay claim to shares of those resources.

The competition-for-youth-attention model sees young people as simply not paying enough attention to religious teaching to notice that significant theological differences exist among competing religions. The default teenage opinion easily becomes “religions are all pretty much about the same thing.”

Five years after the first study, the authors of the NSYR were able to look at the data related to emerging adults and articulate a more comprehensive analysis of the predominate mindset of this age group. The data suggests that vocabularies of simple “tolerance” and “cultural competition” are insufficient descriptors. Rather, emerging adults can be described as having a difficult time seeing objective reality beyond themselves. They understand their own experiences, opinions and preferences as the dominant (if not the only) reality. Beyond that, in the words of Smith and Snell,

Most have great difficulty grasping the idea that a reality that is objective to their own awareness or construction of it may exist that could have a significant bearing on their lives. In philosophical terms most emerging adults functionally (meaning how they actually think and act, regardless of the theories they may hold) are soft ontological antirealists, epistemological skeptics and perspectivalists, . . . although few would have any conscious idea of what these terms mean. . . . They are de facto doubtful that an identifiable, objective, shared reality might exist across and around all people that can serve as a reliable reference point for rational deliberation and argument.

Simply put, the NSYR demonstrates that most emerging adults have difficulty believing the notion of truth that applies to everyone. It simply does not make sense to them. This is why many now see all religions as equally important or equally superfluous.

This contemporary expression of postmodernism was first expressed by social theorists such as Talcott Parsons, Jürgen Habermas and Michel Foucault. Among the many lines of social theorizing Habermas’s theory of communicative action best provides a conceptual foundation for an educational system emphasizing tolerance and that all truth is provisional. For Habermas the spread of knowledge, economic systems or political systems impinge on a person’s consciousness or “life world.” It is intolerant, according to Habermas, to foist new knowledge or systems on others, and it makes no sense to do so since one person’s “truth” is no more valid than anyone else’s truth.

For example, the spread of a capitalist economy into, say, tribal Africa, whose economic systems are tied to tribe, kinship and mutual exchange, has a colonizing effect. Similarly, new ideas or systems imposed from without have a colonizing effect on individuals. “Colonizing my life world” became a pejorative expression for any truth claim (whether a religious truth or an economic or political system) foisted on another with the purpose of changing or influencing that person.

Smith and Snell point out that religion tends to be associated with a “settled life.” Social science research has affirmed that major life disruptions may also serve to knock one off their religious (or nonreligious) center. This is called the “transition effect.” For example, church growth specialists have often recommended churches specifically target newcomers to a community because they may be open to attending church in the first place or to attending church not of the same denomination as their previous location. Most social science literature on the impact of disruption focuses on major life transitions: divorce, death of a family member or job loss. Most adolescents do not experience these in their teenage years, but for those who go to college the disruption list is long: leave home, new living situation, new friends, new ideas, new everything. Part of the transition from high school to college may be that the individual meets persons of other faiths. Knowing someone of another religious faith is associated with a more positive attitude about that faith.

Of all sociological theories that intersect religion, rational choice theory has become a well-accepted explanation for how and why people gain, change or lose religious faith. Rational choice, using vocabulary common to economics, posits that the large historic Protestant denominations, as well as Roman Catholicism, have become lazy; that is, they assumed they would always maintain their market share in the United States. When a denomination becomes lazy, it does not bother to understand the changing needs of its “customers.” This works as long as the “customers” have no other options, but in a free (religious) market such as the United States, new churches and new denominations have done their homework, so to speak, and know how to meet the customers’ felt needs. So, people leave the old and tired denominations and flock to churches that meet their needs. Simply stated, rational choice theory states that people make choices according to their own immediate felt needs. This includes religious choices.

Rational choice theory is germane when it comes to the near disappearance of actual Christianity (as opposed to cultural Christianity) in many Western European nations. State (tax supported) churches do not have to innovate to gain market share and revenue since their coffers are supported by national governments. As a result the church in much of Europe has lost two generations of adherents. Fortunately, there is a resurgence of vital faith among emerging adults in many of these places.

A fine example of a study about adult religious switching was conducted by the Pew Forum on Religion in Public Life, which concluded,

Americans change religious affiliation early and often. In total, about half of American adults have changed religious affiliation at least once during their lives. Most people who change their religion leave their childhood faith before age 24, and many of those who change religion do so more than once. These are among the key findings of a new survey conducted by the Pew Research Center’s Forum on Religion & Public Life. The survey documents the fluidity of religious affiliation in the U.S. and describes in detail the patterns and reasons for change.

Rational choice also explains why some youth groups flourish while other youth groups founder. For example, my own PhD dissertation involved the study of five hundred youth groups in four evangelical Protestant denominations. I examined thirty-five variables in three sets: context, leadership and programmatic. My research question was, “What variables, over a two year period of time, correlate significantly with numerical growth in the main youth group weekly gathering?”

I looked at the variables at a certain time and again two years later, particularly looking for the addition of leadership or programmatic features correlated with numerical growth. Of the top five variables that correlate with numerical youth group growth, I found one having to do with leadership (the increase in the number of volunteer staff) and two having to do with program feature (youth developing a youth-group website, and the addition of sports teams). All three of these can be construed as meeting needs or connecting with natural adolescent interests.

We have looked at a lot of data. Now we will look at biblical and theological perspectives.

À la carte faith and biblical and theological perspectives. The notion of religious pluralism is nothing new from a biblical perspective. Both Old and New Testaments make abundant reference to the religious cultural milieu that is both different from and hostile toward the Abrahamic or nascent Christian faiths. There are also ample cases of persons who attempted to combine the disparate faiths that surrounded them.

Think of Gideon, the hero of Judges 7, believing (perhaps while trembling) that God would provide victory over the Midianites despite his small army of three hundred. The battle went well, and Gideon deflected the popular opinion that he should be a king. Unfortunately, Gideon allowed a great quantity of plundered gold to be gathered. He commission a sacred apron (ephod) to be made (Judg 8:25-27) and allowed (or led?) the worship of this apron. Apparently Gideon was comfortable in believing in both the power of God and the power of his newly manufactured idol. The author of Judges states this golden apron “became a snare to Gideon and his family” (v. 27). Not exactly a ringing endorsement of a God-plus perspective!

We see a New Testament example in the book of Acts when it did not turn out well for some of the Jewish preachers who were jealous of the apostle Paul’s preaching and its power. Apparently the practice of exorcism was especially dramatic. The awe and applause of people was attractive to some of the Jewish men, and they also tried their hand at exorcisms using the formula they heard the apostle using. Seven sons of the Jewish priest Sceva tried their hand at this and found Jesus-plus something did not work as anticipated.

The classic New Testament text of pluralism is Paul’s experience in Athens (Acts 17). Paul was well aware that on Greek soil the gospel was in a crowded religious marketplace. In his famous speech he acknowledged this directly: “I see that in every way you are very religious” (v. 22). He acknowledged their religious sensibility and proclivity, but boldly said that everything had changed because of the gospel. Clearly in Paul’s mind, Jesus plus the Greek or Roman pantheon is both abhorrent and impossible.

Fast-forwarding to the present day, the authors of the NSYR propose that the dominant faith of adolescents and emerging adults is no longer the historic Christian faith. It is rather a smattering of quasi-religious fumes, endued with a hefty backstory of tolerance and riding on the notionality of the metanarrative congruence of all faiths.

This becomes the latent theological praxis of adolescents and emerging adults, and is called “Moralistic Therapeutic Deism.” This new theology is summarized as follows:

  • A God exists who created the world and watches over it.
  • God wants people to be nice, as taught in the Bible and other religions.
  • The goal in life is to be happy and feel good about oneself.
  • God is handy to help resolve a problem, but otherwise religion is not important.
  • Good people go to heaven.
  • The NSYR authors are not claiming that people are leaving their denominations to join a new religion called Moralistic Therapeutic Deism. Rather Moralistic Therapeutic Deism

    is simply colonizing many established religious traditions and congregations in the United States, which it is becoming the new spirit living in the old body. Its typical embrace and practice is de facto, functional, practical, and tacit, not formal or acknowledged as a distinctive religion.

    In the theological realm the move from the Christian faith toward syncretism, the à la carte approach to religious faith, is ultimately about Christology. What do we believe about the person and work of Jesus Christ?

    Christology Quick Tour

    A good place to begin to understand the historic Christian faith is to see what the creeds say. The Apostles’ Creed devotes 69 of its 109 words to the person and work of Christ.

    I believe in Jesus Christ, his only Son, our Lord,

    who was conceived by the Holy Spirit,

    born of the Virgin Mary,

    suffered under Pontius Pilate,

    was crucified, died, and was buried;

    he descended to the dead.

    On the third day he rose again;

    he ascended into heaven,

    he is seated at the right hand of the Father,

    and he will come to judge the living and the dead.

    The second article of the Nicene Creed says,

    We believe in one Lord Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God, begotten of the Father before all worlds, God of God, Light of Light, Very God of Very God, begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father by whom all things were made; who for us men, and for our salvation, came down from heaven, and was incarnate by the Holy Spirit of the Virgin Mary, and was made man, and was crucified also for us under Pontius Pilate. He suffered and was buried, and the third day he rose again according to the Scriptures, and ascended into heaven, and sits on the right hand of the Father. And he shall come again with glory to judge both the quick and the dead, whose kingdom shall have no end.

    It is interesting that neither creed explicitly states that Jesus is the only way to salvation. I believe it was assumed by the early church fathers that creed hearers would see Christ as the one and only way. I once possessed the entire ante-Nicene and post-Nicene fathers’ writings as part of my library. The multivolume set ran well over ten thousand pages. I haven’t read every word in that series, but I’ve read a good deal of it, and these early church fathers certainly believed in Jesus as the only way, and many of them died for their beliefs at the hand of Roman officials.

    One thousand years later the English Parliament asked its scholars to come up with a longer, more definitive and explicit statement of the Christian faith. The Westminster Confession of Faith (1646) contains eight paragraphs about Christ. The following is the second paragraph:

    The Son of God, the second Person in the Trinity, being very and eternal God, of one substance, and equal with the Father, did, when the fullness of time was come, take upon him man’s nature, with all the essential properties and common infirmities thereof; yet without sin: being conceived by the power of the Holy Ghost, in the womb of the Virgin Mary, of her substance. So that two whole, perfect, and distinct natures, the Godhead and the manhood, were inseparably joined together in one person, without conversion, composition, or confusion. Which person is very God and very man, yet one Christ, the only Mediator between God and man.

    What was assumed in the early creeds is made explicit in the Westminster Confession: “one Christ, the only Mediator between God and man.” Many other descriptions and summaries of Christ’s work have come down to us from past generations. The following are three examples.

    Jesus as Prophet, Priest and King. Foretold by Moses in Deuteronomy 18:15-18 Jesus is seen in the New Testament as Prophet, the one Old Testament prophecies spoke of (e.g., Lk 24:27), and he was himself the revelation of God (Jn 5:19-23). He is Priest in that he is the one acceptable sacrifice, the penalty paid for our sins, described in Hebrews 9:26 and Hebrews 6:19-20. While refusing earthly kingship, he will be seen as King when every knee will bow (Phil 2:10). There have been many prophets, but only one salvation-giving Priest and singularly reigning King.

    Jesus as Savior, Sanctifier, Healer and coming King. The Christological framework articulated by A. B. Simpson, founder of what is now known as the Christian and Missionary Alliance, is that Jesus is Savior, Sanctifier, Healer and coming King. Simpson’s heart was to reach people who were not Christians, and the core belief that Jesus is the only way impelled him and thousands of others to take the gospel to all peoples. The Christian and Missionary Alliance website expands on the idea of Jesus as Savior:

    Jesus is an exclusive Savior. “Salvation is found in no one else, for there is no other name in heaven given to men by which we must be saved” Acts 4:12. Contrary to what contemporary culture tells us, there are not multiple paths to God. There is only one—Jesus Christ.

    Jesus as the Suffering Servant. Foretold in Isaiah 53, Jesus suffered during his life and supremely on the cross. Jesus experienced emotional suffering as a result of his heart for the lost, his disappointment over those who left him, and the weight of the sins of the world. His intellectual suffering came as the result of the obstinate disbelief of the religious leaders of his day. Jesus’ spiritual suffering came in the hours prior to the cross when he asked his Father to remove this “cup,” not to mention the abandonment by his Father while he suffered physically on the cross.

    While it may be possible to discuss Christology without touching the “only way” issue, these understandings of Christ explicitly or implicitly see Christ as the one way to God the Father.

    Summary

    We have discussed the fact that many youths are becoming either religious nones or are dabbling in syncretism. For many, religious belief has been reduced to Moralistic Therapeutic Deism, and in the process most of the markers of vital faith are removed or are decidedly lacking.

    One of the best expressions of what society has lost as people become less religious, quasi-religious or completely nonreligious comes from atheist Alaine de Botton. With acute understanding he speaks of how Christianity fosters community, kindness, education, tenderness, purpose and a host of other benefits. He remarks,

    Secular society has not been able to solve with any particular skill: first, the need to live together in communities in harmony, despite our deeply rooted selfish and violent impulses. And second, the need to cope with terrifying degrees of pain which arise from our vulnerability to professional failure, to troubled relationships, to the death of loved ones and to our own decay and demise. God may be dead, but the urgent issues which impelled us to make him up still stir and demand resolutions.

    Is there anything youth workers can do to help prevent young people and emerging adults from watering down their faith to the point of irrelevance? The biblical world was also a multifaith world, and many persons of biblical fame navigated this world successfully, others infamously did not. In chapter four we will look at some biblical examples.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑