Chapter 5 of 17

Conclusions

Conclusions

2

The Scope and Nature of Muslim Youth Work

Have They All Read Purpose-Driven Youth Ministry?

The day is coming, and has likely already come in some places, that a student in your youth ministry will come home from high school and a conversation like this will take place:

MOM. Hi, Jenn, how was your day?

JENN. It was great, we’ve got a new assistant coach for the girls volleyball team, her name is Rashida, and she’s really nice!

And Rashida, a full-time youth worker at the local mosque, has volunteered her time and expertise at the school. She seeks to do relational youth ministry, just like the thousands of Young Life, Youth for Christ and church-based youth pastors who give their time to volunteering in sports, drama, music and other venues.

In chapter one I spoke briefly about student ministry from the standpoint of several religions, including Islam. Here is a full account of my research on the foundations and models of Muslim youth ministry. In the coming decades Islam will be the most visible of the “religious others” in our communities. My research encompassed the United States, Canada and the United Kingdom.

Here I attempt to locate Muslim youth work in a historical and sociological framework. I give an account of how this research was conducted, as any serious research effort should. After summarizing the parameters of Muslim youth ministry’s footprint nationally, regionally and locally, I describe how this youth work is anchored theologically in the Qur’an and hadiths (the reported sayings and activities of Muhammad not contained in the Qur’an), as well as culturally in the Arabic words associated with adolescents and youth. I close this section with an overview of Muslim youth ministry praxis. Christian youth workers will readily recognize key features of Christian youth ministry replicated by their Muslim counterparts.

This research has, among many things, a particular microlevel value. When a large mosque is built in your neighborhood and you see from the mosque website that they have youth programs, you will understand how their youth workers see themselves and what they are doing. This knowledge will be a good first step before building a bridge of friendship and possible joint Christian-Muslim youth group service projects.

Introduction

Though Islam has been a global religion since the Middle Ages, it has come to the forefront of attention in the West through highly visible negative events. Though each of these events cast Islam in a less than positive light, thinking people understand that Islam is not a monolithic religion bent on jihad. Rather, Islam comes in many versions, similar to Christianity and Judaism.

Scholars have shed light on the various contours of Islam in many ways, especially juxtaposed with other religious faiths. Examples include Christine Carabain and Rene Bekker’s 2012 study comparing philanthropic behavior of Christians, Muslims and Hindus in the Netherlands. Khari Brown and Ronald E. Brown’s 2011 examination of interfaith contact in America. And the intersections of Christianity and Islam in Britain by Steve Bell and Colin Chapman.

It should come as no surprise that Muslim parents care about their own children and their religious faith development. This is particularly true for families who emigrate from a Muslim majority nation to a Western nation where the Muslim population is a tiny percentage of the whole. It is also no surprise that some Muslim leaders in Western countries are concerned that there may be a weakening of the faith (if not outright faith abandonment) among children and youth born to first-generation immigrant Muslim parents now raising their children a culture awash with mores completely foreign to traditional Islam.

This research explores an important outgrowth of this Muslim concern for their own young people: Muslim youth work. Here we will explore the Qur’anic, philosophical and sociocultural foundations of Muslim youth work, as well as Muslim youth work praxis.

Theoretical and Research Antecedents

Subculture identity theory. Subculture identity theory, a subfield within sociology of religion, provides a conceptual home for the consideration of Muslim youth work. It provides the theoretical framework to analyze the processes by which religions and religious groups maintain (and grow) within modern, pluralistic societies. This maintenance and growth occurs by creating a subculture that affirms, according to Christian Smith, collective identities that provide adherents with meaning and belonging. Smith explains, “In a pluralistic society, religious groups which are better at transmitting and employing the cultural tools needed to create both clear distinction from, and significant engagement and tension with other relevant out groups, will be relatively successful.” We will see some of these “cultural tools” when Muslim youth work praxis is considered.

Subcultural identity theory is a new field first given impetus in the United States through the study of religious denominations, and particularly those labeled “evangelical.” Subculture identity theory forms the backdrop of studies regarding Muslim youth as well. For example, young people in Germany of Turkish descent whose parents are essentially secular are flocking to a “pop” version of Islam in which the rediscovery of Islam is seen as “young, chic, and cool.”

Attachment theory. Another conceptual home for the consideration of Muslim youth work stems from attachment theory. Here the strength of personal bonds and connections (with parents, significant other adults and like-minded peers) is seen as not only important for emotional health and flourishing, but also plays a part in the transmission of culture (including religion) from one generation to the next. Academic studies of attachment and religion abound, as well as specific studies that demonstrate a causal connection between attachment and youth religiosity. Furthermore, researchers are beginning to explore attachment theory and Muslim youth religiosity. For example, a study of 1,861 youth of Turkish and Moroccan descent living in the Netherlands showed a weakening of religious identity within the second generation. Another study posits that attachment has a great deal to do with religious conversion. This is very relevant not only for the relationship of the Muslim youth leader to individual youth but the relationship of Muslim youth and Muslim youth workers to non-Muslims as various dawa (outreach/evangelism) programs become part of the youth group’s schedule.

We will see examples of attachment theory in practice (latently if not explicitly) by Muslim youth workers in both North America and Europe when we consider Muslim youth work praxis.

Youth religiosity research. After hundreds of studies across the globe, the significant connection of youth religiosity and prosocial behavior is incontrovertibly established in the social sciences. While religious youth work (no matter what the religion) may be good for theological and missional reasons, social scientists are interested in youth religiosity from the standpoint of a civil society. Higher youth religiosity, compared to less religious peers, means (among many other things) better emotional and physical health, improved relationships with parents, better academic performance, clearer sense of purpose, and a greater willingness to give time and money to help others. High religiosity also means less alcohol and drug use, less sexual activity, and less criminality.

While initial youth religiosity research primarily focused on the Christian faith, Muslim youth religiosity research is beginning to appear, either in comparison with other religions or with Muslim youth as the sole research focus. A representative comparative-­religion study is the work of David Dollahite, who explored the likelihood of Christian and Muslim youth in the United States to forgo risky (and sinful) behaviors for the sake of a higher good and higher benefit. Mark Grey authored another important study in which Muslim young people were the sole focus of religiosity and personality development.

Insofar as a common component of youth religiosity research is participation in a religious youth group, the study of Muslim youth groups and Muslim youth work is both relevant and contributory to this research.

Data and Methods

Personal interviews. After reviewing Muslim and Muslim youth work websites in both North America and the United Kingdom, I sought to interview key Muslim youth work trainers. Some websites did not have updated contact information. Other Muslim leaders or their organizational office personnel did not answer emails or phone calls. However, I was able to have long phone conversations with Muslim youth work leaders from Vancouver, Toronto and Chicago. On a sabbatical trip to the United Kingdom in February 2012, I was able to have face-to-face interviews with key Muslim youth leaders who comprise, in my opinion, the brain trust of Muslim youth work. The three resided in Oxford, Bradford and Nottingham.

While it was no small task to find and gain access to these six leaders, succinctly convey the macro- and micropurpose of my research, and seek to gain trust and credibility in the crucial first sixty seconds of contact, once I was “in” the conversations held were lengthy and rich in two-way discovery. I came away from the experience with a deep respect for the heart these men had for young people and the work of youth ministry.

Source documents. Especially in the United Kingdom there are rich resources for the scholarly consideration of the foundational understandings that Muslim youth work rests on. Additionally, there are resources that discuss youth work and the merits or appropriateness of various youth work models. These resources will be discussed and cited subsequently in this chapter.

Web research. I stumbled across, as is sometimes the case in searching the Web, a fascinating and comprehensive site. Salatomatic.com touts itself as the “World’s most comprehensive guide to mosques and Islamic schools.” Of interest here, though tangential to the research focus of this chapter, is that this site allows persons to write reviews of individual mosques and rate them on a scale of one to five, a bit like TripAdvisor.com or Hotels.com. In some cases one can know from these reviews the proximity of public transportation or if the restrooms are clean!

There are mosque-related news stories on salatomatic.com as well. For example, the June 21, 2012, homepage featured stories that included the Islamic Center of Murfreesboro (Tennessee) (rated 5.0 by reviewers) and touting their tornado and flood-relief efforts locally, and their ongoing Haiti relief work. A Turkish mosque and their new building program is also featured. When construction is finished, women will be able to pray at the same time as men. (As is normal in Islam, men and women gather separately.) There is a featured story of a mosque “going green” in Abu Dhabi. And the first underwater mosque is under construction in Saudi Arabia!

Of direct interest to the study of Muslim youth work is the searchable feature of the website. For every continent on the globe one can search by country, by region/state/province and by city. Information includes a list of mosques and their “denomination” (e.g., Shia, Sunni or Sufi). Information on each mosque is as comprehensive as possible. If there is any kind of youth group, school or “Sunday school,” it is listed under “Services Offered.” If this youth group has a website, the URL given. This makes possible the collection of quantitative data. From January 2011 to April 2012 two Nyack College students and I examined the salatomatic.com information on over three thousand mosques. Among those mosques, if a youth group website was given, we studied it as well.

The Big Picture of Muslim Youth Work

Mosque based. How prevalent is mosque-based youth work in the countries studied? (We will look again at mosque-based youth work when Muslim youth work praxis is considered.)

While the majority of mosques do not yet have their own youth groups, in the United States, Canada and the United Kingdom there are regionally based youth ministries that seek to provide Muslim youth work infrastructure. These would be especially helpful for smaller mosques that do not have the personnel, vision, or resources to provide their own youth programming.

Regionally based. Regionally based Muslim youth work takes on a variety of forms. Houston, Texas, for example, has a regional youth center with several program options including service projects, a soccer league, karate classes, and open volleyball and basketball nights. They use three words to describe their misson: activism, spirituality and tarbiya (the latter meaning “education or increased knowledge”).

Another example of regional Muslim youth work is the Muslim Youth Camp of California. Held annually since 1962, MYC offers a one-week premier camping experience. Their mission statement gives the heart of the organization’s purpose:

The Muslim Youth Camp brings Muslim families and individuals of diverse backgrounds together for a fun-filled week of Islamic living, learning and inspirational experiences in nature. By encouraging camaraderie, personal spiritual exploration and respect for diversity of Islamic practice, MYC seeks to be a strong catalyst in the creation of American Muslim identities.

A typical day at MYC involves daily prayers, swimming and group sports, teamwork competition, classes, campfire and free time. Their marketing materials indicate they not only draw from the state of California but nationally and internationally.

Regional Muslim youth work organizations often provide the leadership training infrastructure to support Muslim youth work in other regions or in local mosques. The youth department of the British Columbia Muslim Association has a full-time paid director whose office and volunteers offer multiple services:

  • formulate guidelines and policies for youth group at each branch or chapter for common good
  • develop a program of events and activities with focus on Islamic values and leadership training
  • conduct yearly Muslim youth conventions
  • sports and recreation services to promote sports activities.
  • As in Canada and the United States there are multiple Muslim youth work organizations in the United Kingdom that are local (but not mosque based) and have a regional draw. They function akin to parachurch organizations so common in Christianity. One of the most developed of these organizations is Muslim Youth Skills, headquartered in Bradford. They offer youth work training courses. The current list of courses offered includes

  • Engaging Young People
  • Understanding Culture
  • Islam and Muslims
  • Introduction to Muslim Youth Work
  • Tackling Crime
  • Muslim Youth Skills also offers onsite consultation by their trained leaders as well as personal counseling and youth-work-related problem solving. They position themselves as offering “first class service to the Public, Private, and Third Sectors.” And they declare,

    Muslim Youth Skills draws upon over a decade of experience in the youth and community work field. Our trainers and consultants come form various professions, thus enriching the services that we offer. Although our services combine an understanding of religious, cultural and spiritual needs of Muslims specifically, our service is not exclusive to this community. Many of our programmes and workshops respond to wider social issues.

    As we have seen Muslim youth work exists at the local and regional level. There are many national-level organizations facilitating Muslim youth work as well.

    Nationally based. The Muslim Association of Canadian Youth is a department within the Muslim Association of Canada and exists to provide activities that reflect the values of faith, brotherhood, personal development, citizenship, inclusiveness, relevance and excellence. They also publish a monthly magazine titled My Voice.

    In the United States a representative example is Muslim Youth of North America: “Connect, Inspire, Belong.” A national gathering ­related to Ramadan was held in July 2012. Other activities include an annual convention, summer camps and resources for Muslim parents. Another project is sponsored by the Muslim American Society. The Muslim Youth Leadership Forum: Building Young Muslims for a Better America states its goal as

    to mentor and prepare young Muslim leaders to provide leadership not only to the Muslim community but the greater American society at large. The institutional design focuses on developing and enhancing leadership skill sets of Muslim youth that will impact America’s civic, social, economic and religious life. Youth participants will be placed in a leadership social mentoring network that will allow them to communicate after the initial forum on an ongoing basis with qualified mentors and other forum participants.

    In the United States books written for young people to affirm and support their Muslim religious faith are beginning to appear. The subculture identity theorists would understand the publication of magazines and books as contributing toward the creation of an understandable and acceptable Muslim youth framework to see themselves in their religion.

    The United Kingdom is rich with organizations seeking to service the needs of British Muslim young people. These include Young Muslims UK (ymuk.net), and Muslim Youth Skills (muslimyouthskills.co.uk). One of most developed organizations is the Muslim Youthwork Foundation, whose mission is “Creating safe spaces for Muslim young people to explore personal, social, spiritual, and political choices.” Their website offers (among many other choices) a poets’ corner, mentoring opportunities, Muslim youth-related art and a create-your-own video feature called “Witness.” The MYWF has a subsidiary website, muslimyouth.net, which is “the coolest online space for Muslim youth!”

    Qur’anic, Hadithic and Cultural Foundations

    Christian youth ministry thinkers, as well as practitioners prone to reflection, seek to anchor what they do in the Bible, Christian theology and cultural theory. Recent works by Kenda Dean and Andrew Root, Pete Ward, and Tony Jones are representative examples. Muslim youth workers are beginning to similarly reflect on their work.

    When asked for a basis of Muslim youth work in the Qur’an, many Muslim youth leaders will, without hesitation, speak of sura 18, “The Cave.” Here we see the Prophet taking seriously the spirituality and spiritual potential of young men:

    [Prophet], we shall tell you their story as it really was. They were young men who believed in their Lord, and we gave them more guidance. We gave strength to their hearts when they stood up and said, “Our Lord is the Lord of heavens and earth. We shall never call upon any god other than Him.” (sura 18:13-14)

    In the verses surrounding this text we see that the belief of these young men was considered a sign by the Prophet. We also see them as capable of not only belief but of following the way and being divinely guided.

    In Islamic culture puberty is the mark of entry to accountability and responsibility in life. The Arabic word is taklif, legal obligation. It is incumbent on Muslim parents (and now youth workers as well) to help young people “get it,” that is, to believe and behave in such a way as to reflect they are in the Way (called Deen in Arabic). Verses in the Qur’an such as sura 41:44—“a guide and a healing to those who believe”—applies to not just adults but young people as well. Similarly, exhortations to justice (sura 4:35) and to be a receiver and giver of mercy (sura 1:1) apply to all Muslims who are of age.

    Yet another foundation of Muslim youth work comes out of the Arabic language and culture, the concept of ilm, which simply means “knowledge” or “knowledge of.” Allah is seen as the source of truth and knowledge, and it is the responsibility of all Muslims to know and follow this truth. Those who do not yet know this truth must be taught it by those who do. Whatever the sphere of Muslim youth work, be it local, regional or national, there is tremendous emphasis in Islam to teach this knowledge or to teach those who will teach. Teaching, in many mosques, is everything.

    While ilm has to do with what the individual knows, ummah has to do with what the individual feels. Muslims are to feel connected to other Muslims around the globe in a sense of unity in their faith. With Muslims living not only in “Muslim” nations but scattered abroad, the meaning of ummah has been much discussed in the Muslim community. Nevertheless, for those who provide the youth infrastructure ummah provides a conceptual foundation for the websites, events and gatherings of Muslim young people locally, regionally and nationally. Muslim youth work helps youth feel connected to a larger whole.

    Among Muslim youth workers there are multiple tensions as to what constitutes acceptable youth ministry practice. These tensions usually relate to cultural practice and tradition. For example, I asked the six Muslim youth work leaders I interviewed about the use of music in youth work. All of them stated that music must glorify Allah, which is theoretically possible. But they would never use music in a youth gathering at any level—mosque, region or national gathering. It would be too controversial. These leaders are concerned with helping, preserving and conserving the good character of Muslim young people as they maneuver within a culture awash in non-Muslim values. One Muslim youth worker, citing sura 68:4 of the Qur’an—“indeed, your character is of a vast ethos”—stated, “I have [a concern] of many current models, which appear to be based on and regulated by the norms of consumer society.”

    Based on the Qur’an and the hadiths we can establish a threefold purpose for all Muslims, including young ones who have attained taklif, as (1) attain faith, (2) do good works, and (3) be one who is God conscious or God fearing.

    Let’s examine how Muslim youth work seeks to do this.

    Models of Muslim Youth Work Praxis

    Nonconfessional models. Especially in the United Kingdom, much of Muslim youth work is essentially secular; that is, it is done by men and women (who happen to be Muslims) who desire to help young people who are economically hurting, feeling disenfranchised by the larger culture and are seen as “at risk.”

    With 33 percent of Britain’s’ Muslim population under the age seventeen, and 71 percent under the age thirty-one, social scientists and civil authorities were becoming alarmed that many of these young people live in impoverished swaths of the city, which breeds despair, crime and radicalization.

    Scholarly interest in this subpopulation of the United Kingdom has been robust, and the future of these disenfranchised youth has been a concern even prior to the terrorist bombings at London’s King’s Cross Station on July 7, 2007.

    In “community youth work” youth workers engage young people in recreation and positive interaction. In the United Kingdom nearly four thousand full-time community youth workers are employed, many of whom are Muslim.

    One-on-one or small group discussions may take place on issues such as citizenship, bullying, discrimination, sexuality, drug abuse and identity, which are relevant to young people in most communities. Additionally, such nonconfessional youth work may include sports programs like football, basketball and table tennis.

    A very creative approach targeting the personal needs of Muslim young people is the Muslim Youth Helpline. Established in 2001 MYH is led by trained mental health professionals who train the volunteers who receive the phone calls, staff the live online chat service and respond to email inquiries. Muslim Youth Helpline is an example of secular Muslim youth work that helps young people explore what it means to be Muslim in a Western nation.

    Secular Muslim youth work in the United Kingdom comes from a deficit perspective. That is, the focus is on the felt needs, the problems and issues faced in the daily life of Muslim young people. These needs might be emotional, safety related or the need for hope to function in a culture in which they feel misunderstood or not welcome.

    In North America various mosques and Islamic centers offer a variety of programs parallel to secular youth organizations, but the deficit perspective is virtually nonexistent. The flavor of nonconfessional Muslim youth work in North America seems more focused on enrichment, not deficit. For example, Muslim Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts are widespread in North America. Muslim Scouts engage, train and empower parents as troop leaders, so the effort becomes a family activity. (It is, however, sex-segregated.)

    North American Muslims also have the equivalent to Big Brothers Big Sisters. The Muslim Family Network of Calgary explains its program:

    The Big Sister/Big Brother program has been developed so that children can experience the richness, excitement, and warmth of an Islamic environment, a place where children learn the importance of caring, sharing, tolerance, patience, and working with others.

    In addition to arts and crafts, recreational and outdoor activities (including field trips), the program will offer Islamic activities based on weekly themes.

    The classes also provide the opportunity for university and high school students to gain important skills while they serve as assistants and volunteers for the program. Each week of the program will include activities and learning based on a theme.

    While not strictly secular, the BC Muslims organization in British Columbia, Canada, markets a national resource called the Ayal Muslim Youth Help Line to help young people with personal problems. They affirm that all their phone counselors have been raised in Canada and are practicing Muslims.

    Confessional models. Explicitly religious Muslim youth work models encompass most mosque-based and regional and national Muslim youth organizations youth work. While most of these organizations include topics and services germane to young people of any religion—sports and leadership development, service opportunities and evangelism. The chief purpose of all Muslim youth programming is to help youth become comfortable and confident in their Muslim beliefs. The Muslim equivalent to evangelism or outreach is the Arabic word Dawa, which means “invitation.” Dawa events are explicitly planned so Muslim youth can invite their non-Muslim friends. Not unlike Christian youth groups, the program mix varies from mosque to mosque. The following is a sample of the youth ministries of specific mosques.

    Table 2.1. Mosques and Mosque-Based Youth Work in Selected Countries, 2011–2012

    Number of mosques

    Youth groups (number and percent)

    Main province/state/region

    Number and percent of mosques in this area

    Canada

    347

    80 (23%)

    Ontario

    208 (27%)

    United States

    1947

    350 (18%)

    California

    302 (18%)

    UK

    1131

    328 (29%)*

    Yorkshire & Humber*

    239 (21%)

    Netherlands

    33

    6 (18%)

    Norway

    4

    2 (50%)

    Switzerland

    12

    6 (50%)

    *This count of youth groups does not include the 302 mosques in London, which were not studied.

    Teaching. In a very conservative mosque teaching would include the memorization of key passages of the Qur’an and more wide-ranging discussions of the implications of Islamic teaching for everyday life. The mosque at 1 Beech Road in Luton, England, offers regular Qur’an classes for boys and girls. The mosque in Alexandria, Virginia, offers a regular “Pizza and Prophets” night, which includes good food and good study and discussion of the Qur’an or hadiths. The youth group at a megamosque in the Los Angeles area offers a ninety-minute Sunday school class that includes an hour-long lecture followed by discussion. The high school group of the large Waterloo Mosque outside of Toronto has a very active youth program that includes small groups for processing that day’s or the week’s teaching. Called “knowledge circles” these help young people feel part of “Generation M,” that is, Generation Muslim.

    The Mordern Islamic Center in Surrey, England, calls their youth program “Friday Circles.” A typical Friday program involves a brief time of teaching (called “Islamic Reminders”), quiz competition, puzzles, projects and food.

    Sports and recreation. Regional and mosque-based Muslim youth work typically involves sports and recreation. The Islamic Society of Greater Lansing (Michigan) offers a Spring Break Challenge that includes basketball, soccer and football. Similarly, the Young Muslims of the Teaneck, New Jersey, mosque offers a three-on-three basketball tournament for different age groups. A mosque in Bern, Switzerland, offers a series of two-day summer day-camp programs for children and youth. Recreation and sports are the main ingredients, but there are designated times to inspire and support these young people spiritually. In Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, the boys-only sports program (basketball and volleyball) takes place on Wednesday and Saturday nights. The London (Ontario) Muslim Mosque offers drop-in basketball for boys on Friday nights and karate classes on Saturday nights. The Aisha Mosque in Birmingham, England, has sports night every Saturday night for their youth program called “United Kingdom Islamic Mission Youth.”

    Leadership training. Leadership training is a recurrent theme in Muslim confessional youth work. For example, the Yaseen Foundation in the San Francisco Bay Area has an age-divided (13-14, 15-18) youth club led by an elected group of young people under the advisement of former members who are in their early twenties. Similarly, the Husaini Youth Group in Peterborough, England, has a large number of young people on their leadership committee. The Taric Islamic Centre in Toronto seeks to develop leadership in young people by their participation the Taric Youth Committee, which teaches leadership and teamwork skills.

    Service projects. Not unlike Christian youth groups, the King Fahd Mosque of Culver City, California, youth group makes monthly visits to the local hospital and senior citizens center. This mosque has significant resources devoted to youth work, with a youth center that has weekly hangout programs called “The Spiritual Spot.” Their youth group meets here prior to these monthly service outings and uses the center as a base for planning future service efforts. The regionally based Muslim Association of Arizona helps Muslim young people get involved in community services projects such as graffiti cleanup, distributing food at shelters, blood drives and toy drives. The Islamic Association of Saskatoon Regina Mosque includes an orphan sponsorship program aimed at helping young people (and their parents) support poor Muslim children in Palestine, Pakistan, Sudan and Kosovo.

    Dawa. This word comes up frequently in the content of regional and mosque-based Muslim youth websites. A good example is the mosque Es Salam in Chandler, Arizona. They have recently completed their youth center (6,500 sq. ft.) and have plans to add a much larger facility that will include indoor swimming pools, sports courts, and additional office and meeting space for counseling and classes. The Kingston-Upon Thames (Surrey) club and sports programs include the goal of servicing the entire community. Young people are welcome at their activities, without regard to religion. This welcome is mirrored by the Epson and Ewell Islamic Society (Surrey) in their full calendar of youth activities, including frequent trips to the paintball facility.

    Conclusions

    In this chapter I have presented some of the key religious and cultural foundations of Muslim youth work. We have seen that Muslim youth work not only rests on applying relevant Qur’anic texts but also an Islamic understanding of adolescence. Table 2.1 provides a count of Muslim youth groups and their country or region. Future research will establish how these youth groups have changed over time.

    While many British Muslim youth ministries are based on the deficit model, which means they address critical problems related to being British and Muslim, North America Muslim youth ministries are more often based on an enrichment model. This distinction and its implications certainly deserve further study.

    The study of Muslim youth work rests comfortably in at least three bases of social science inquiry. First, subculture identity theory helps us understand what is happening as Muslims seek to facilitate youth work and youth groups for their own sons and daughters. These youth groups provide a place where being Muslim is affirmed, strengthened and celebrated. Second, attachment theory helps conceptualize what happens in Muslim youth groups, youth camps and youth conferences in terms of peer bonding, which is especially important for young people whose neighborhood or school is not majority Muslim. Third, youth religiosity research analyzes how young Muslims experience and live out their faith, how youth work contributes to this religiosity, and the life outcomes of this faith.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑