Chapter 27
Chapter 27 Magazines, Racks of Books, and Church Bulletins L NOT LONG AFTER the publication of Living Letters in 1962, Margaret and I were having a picnic with our children at Northside Park in Wheaton. At a table near us we saw our friends Ted and Jeanne Miller and their young sons. Ted was an editor at Scripture Press, publishers of Sunday school curriculum, and we naturally got to talking about our mutual involvement in publishing. To our surprise, we discovered that each of us had been dreaming the same dream about a Christian digest magazine.
For many years I had wanted to publish a Christian magazine that would be similar to Reader's Digest except that its content would be digests of articles from a wide range of Christian magazines.
I told Ted that if I ever had enough money to finance getting a magazine started, we should get together. He would be the editor.
The following spring as we published successive printings of Living Letters, there was more and more profit left over, and I informed Ted that we could proceed. He could continue to work at Scripture Press and do the editorial work for our new magazine in the evenings and weekends. I had decided to call it The Christian Reader.
MY LIFE: A GUIDED TOUR
We would publish the magazine bimonthly and sell it through Christian bookstores. The stores could put our special display near the cash register, where customers would see the magazine and pick up a copy to add to their other purchases.
Fortunately we still had time to rent a small booth (Separate from our tiny Tyndale House half-booth) at the 1963 CBA convention in Washington, D.C., where we proudly displayed the first issue. It was dated October-November 1963, and it contained sixteen brief articles, each one a digest of a longer article that had appeared in a major Christian periodical. We wanted the magazine to appeal to a variety of readers, so we chose articles for that first issue from periodicals as widely diverse as Christianity Today, Decision, Eternity, Alliance Witness, Sunday School Times, and Bibliotheca Sacra.
Now we needed more help at our home/office for record keeping, typing labels, and helping with mailing The Christian
Reader, Cynthia Rodgers, daughter of our friends Bill and Emily Rodgers, was a high-school senior. She was available to come after school every day.
How shall I ever forget the last afternoon Cynthia and I were working together, packing magazines into cartons to mail to bookstores? For at two o'clock the next morning—a bitterly cold January predawn—the phone rang. It was Emily
Rodgers to tell us that their house was in flames and they couldn't find Cynthia or her ten-year-old brother, Bobby. Later we learned from the fire inspectors that Cynthia had stayed in the house to try to rescue one of her brothers. Neither she nor Bobby made it through the smoke.
As The Christian Reader grew, other friends came to help us, and soon our dining room/office was crowded with wonderful people—Grace Braker, Fran Kawano, Jeanne Burton, and others who worked with us from time to time.
At first we sold our new magazine only to Christian booka2
Magazines, Racks of Books, and Church Bulletins stores, but we gradually developed a list of individual subscribers, soon reaching a circulation of twenty thousand copies per issue. Ted and I were excited to think of that many copies going out regularly into homes, with surveys indicating that each copy was read by more than one person.
We had expected that the circulation would continue to grow steadily, so it was discouraging when we found we had hit a plateau. New subscribers just about balanced those who dropped out. I longed for the magazine to bring spiritual growth and encouragement to many, many more readers and their families and friends. One cold Sunday afternoon in January 1965 I felt so deeply troubled and burdened about this that I put on a heavy coat and went out to the garage/shipping room where I could be alone to pray and even talk aloud to God about it. I lit the heater and spent an hour with God, telling Him in detail all the reasons why I thought He should give us 100,000 subscribers within one year. As usual, I was not conscious of any direct reply, but I returned to the house, hopeful that He had been listening sympathetically. Remembering the many miracles He had done in behalf of Living
Letters, | was encouraged to expect the same for The Christian Reader.
An hour later the phone rang. The caller was Bob Hawkins, who was then a bookstore owner in Portland, Oregon. I had met him at the Christian Booksellers convention the previous summer. I recalled that he had expressed interest in The Christian Reader and had ordered a few copies for his store.
"How's it going, Bob?" I asked. I expected some general shop talk, but he had a specific reason for calling and got right to the point.
"You know that little digest magazine you publish?" he started enthusiastically. "Well, it's terrific, and it ought to have twice the circulation—and I know how to do it! Send me a thousand extra copies!"
MY LIFE: A GUIDED TOUR
I was amazed but gladly sent him the copies. Two weeks later he called again, asking for another thousand.
"Bob!" I exclaimed, "whatever are you doing with them?"
"I'll tell you later," he replied. "Let me test my idea a little more, and then I'll call you again."
In due time he called me with his report. He had given sample copies to local pastors; he urged them to take a regular supply of the magazines and to encourage their congregations to pick up copies in the foyer after the service. The price at that time was thirty-five cents a copy. The church would pay the store, which would then pay us.
I said, "Bob, I think it's time for you to come to Wheaton and tell me just how you are doing this. Can it be done elsewhere than in Portland? Can it be done across the nation?"
He came, and we spent a lot of time together working out a plan to implement his idea in many more churches. One of the most successful methods was pastors' breakfasts. We would set up a breakfast meeting for all the pastors in a community, give them copies of the magazine, and sign up as many as possible to institute this distribution in their churches. Of course these church copies led in many cases to individual subscriptions as well. Within a year the circulation had climbed rapidly from our 20,000 plateau to 100,000 copies each issue—the very number for which I had prayed on that cold Sunday afternoon.
I invited Bob Hawkins to join me at Tyndale House as sales manager, and he accepted, bringing his wife, Shirley, and their three children from the beautiful Pacific Northwest. He was with us for eight years, leading Tyndale House to very high sales records in Bibles and magazine distribution. He also started us on publishing books, something I had not originally planned for Tyndale House to do. Bob brought us some outstanding authors whose books are still top sellers after many years. Eventually Bob left us to begin his own
Magazines, Racks of Books, and Church Bulletins company, Harvest House, where he is just as successful as he was in steering Tyndale House to major publishing status.
But not all of my projects were successful. We were selling huge numbers of Living Letters, Living Prophecies, and Living
Gospels, with more money flowing in than we needed to pay salaries and bills. We had a healthy balance in the bank, and I felt it should not stay there, but be put to work. With some of that money we launched a new periodical in 1967 entitled
Christian Times. It was a weekly newspaper for adult Sunday school classes. It reported on Christian events and movements around the world—and I thought it was one of the most terrific ideas I had ever had!
A weekly Christian newspaper seemed to me a good way to make Christians more aware of the Lord's work all over the world. I supposed this would make them more prayerful and would increase their giving. Whether or not those results could be confirmed by research, I don't know. I didn't even think of research or of analyzing the costs of editing, printing, promoting, and circulating. We had enough money to support it until it got going, and we had skillful staff available in the form of editor Don Crawford and his assistants, Donna Birkey and Donna McLean.
Unfortunately, budgets and cash flow projections were not attempted. Sometimes that casual approach may work, but in this case it didn't. Two and a half years later, having lost
$250,000 on Christian Times, I surrendered to reality, and that excellent weekly sent out its final issue.
The story doesn't end there, however, because God did not let my dream come to an end. A year later, in 1970, while I was still nursing my personal pain and the financial disaster caused by the failure of the weekly news publication, God gave us a new and practical way to achieve the original goal. We prepared a monthly news sheet called The Church Around the World, designed to fit into church bulletins. We sent sample copies
MY LIFE: A GUIDED TOUR
with order cards to many thousands of pastors, who responded warmly. The monthly circulation grew, and by Christmas of 1976 we were mailing out more than a million copies of the little news sheet each month, and this circulation has continued ever since.
So out of disaster came great usefulness. Why did the disaster have to come first? I think it was to destroy any pride and teach me valuable lessons in business. I had begun to think of myself as a successful businessman, something I had always wanted to be, but I needed to discover the truth about my shortcomings in that area. I had been impetuous about starting my pet project, assuming that anything I perceived as a need was obviously God's plan as well. Nor had I counted the cost, as the New Testament counsels us to do—and as a truly successful businessman would have remembered!
In 1968, while Christian Times was still being published, another project began. It was a monthly tract called Have a Good Day. It is not an ordinary gospel tract, for the first three of its four pages are filled with items of human interest, heroism, inspiration, and trivia, plus humorous cartoons. The back page has an interesting, solid presentation of the good news of Christ. We think of it as a "nontract tract"—a tract in its purpose and result, but not in its format. As a result even timid Christians can give it away. No one is offended by being handed an attractive pamphlet called Have a Good Day. It is used not only by individuals and churches, but by businesses owned by Christians who send it out with their invoices and statements.
The idea was mine, but the genius who chose the material and designed the leaflet is Leslie Tarr, a Christian journalist in Toronto, Ontario. For twenty-three years, until his recent retirement, Les edited Have a Good Day from his wheelchair.
Les is a paraplegic, living with pain but trusting in God. Surely much credit for Have a Good Day must also go to his wife,
Magazines, Racks of Books, and Church Bulletins Catherine, and I pay tribute to her faithful support of Les through all these years.
The other major genius behind Have a Good Day is Dwight Hooten. Shortly after The Christian Reader began its rapid circulation growth, I had a visit from Dwight, an advertising executive and personnel director of a national advertising agency in Chicago. He and his wife, Jean, had a God-given desire to be involved in a direct, full-time Christian enterprise.
This was not the first contact I had had with Dwight. Several years earlier he had visited me at Moody Press with the same interest in joining a Christian organization, but there had been no openings at Moody. Now the way was open for him to join
Tyndale House.
Dwight took quite a cut in salary to make this change, but he was extremely happy in his new work as business and circulation manager of The Christian Reader and Have a Good
Day. Later, as we added other periodicals to our list, he became director of the periodicals division of the company, a position from which he has only recently retired.
Have a Good Day has reached a circulation of close to a million copies a month, sending the Word of God out to both nonbelievers and believers all across America.
One Saturday morning in 1971, I was alone in my office at Tyndale House, busily engaged in all the paperwork that didn't get done during the week. At first I did not notice a tall young man standing hesitantly in the doorway. When I greeted him, he introduced himself as Ed Elliott, and I invited him to sit down. He seemed reluctant to take my time but had two messages to deliver. One was his deep appreciation for The Living Bible and what it had meant to him and his family.
The other was to tell me about a friend of his who was between jobs and who he thought would fit into Tyndale House in our sales department.
I was not able to find a place in the company for Ed's friend,
MY LIFE: A GUIDED TOUR
but within a few weeks we asked Ed to join the Tyndale House sales department, with the special assignment of developing the distribution of The Living Bible into drugstores, grocery stores, and all manner of outlets other than Christian bookstores.
One of my highest goals has always been to distribute Bibles and Christian books to the 80 percent or more of church families who never go into a Christian bookstore. This means our books must be sold in general bookstores such as Waldenbooks and B. Dalton, and also in grocery stores, drugstores, and the many other stores where people shop.
It was an amazing situation that confronted us in 1971 and 1972—hundreds of secular stores clamoring for The Living
Bible because of its immense popularity. A great many stores were happy to display and sell it along with their other merchandise. When in all publishing history has there been such an opportunity for Bible distribution?
So Ed stepped into a huge network of unforeseen distribution opportunities. One day he came in to tell me that he had just been talking with the manager of a J. C. Penney store in a small midwest city, who was selling many Living Bibles but wondered how he could get a rack full of other Christian best-sellers such as The Late Great Planet Earth by Hal Lindsey, Dare to Discipline by Dr.
James Dobson, and others.
Since the books he mentioned were published by numerous companies, the manager did not have time to try to contact them all, and his orders for a few copies would not merit the discount he would need.
Ed neatly solved the problem by buying the books from our local retail store, half a dozen copies of each, and shipping them to the J. C. Penney manager, who displayed them on the racks in his store. A week or two later Ed came into my office with the encouraging report that the store was selling fifty
Christian books a week. So Ed went to New York to see the
Magazines, Racks of Books, and Church Bulletins book buyer for the J. C. Penney chain, who was already buying The Living Bible. Ed came away with an order to supply twenty-six of the major Penney stores across the nation with racks of Christian books! All Ed needed to do now was sell the idea to the twenty Christian publishers whose books were involved. They were as eager as we were to get their books into secular outlets. Thus Unirack was born, a name meaning that one rack contained books from many publishers. Eventually our racks were in five hundred Penney stores. Then three hundred K mart stores joined the program, along with Gibson's, Montgomery Ward, and several other major chains.
In 1975, when Ed Elliott was given new responsibilities, Jim Lofton, and later Paul Mouw, provided Unirack with excellent leadership and developed the program even further. For many years I have had the joy of seeing my dream in action, of reaching beyond the Christian bookstores. It was a wonderful experience, and very much an answer to earnest prayer. It was also the result of hard work and expert selling of the program to chain-store headquarters.
I have never calculated the totals, but hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of books went out across America in this unique way and found their way into many, many homes and lives. Meanwhile, other Christian "rackers," such as Successful Living, were doing the same kind of good distribution, and we eventually merged this part of our work into theirs.
In 1977 we added another new magazine to our periodicals division, but it proved to be a disappointment. We called it
Bookshorts. It was similar to The Christian Reader in format, and it contained condensations of several new Christian books in each issue. It was, naturally, of interest to book readers and was an excellent platform from which to promote wider reading of worthwhile books. We issued it to churches every other month, alternating with the bimonthly copies of
MY LIFE: A GUIDED TOUR
The Christian Reader, We developed an excellent staff and began to publish (again with no research, since its potential success seemed so obvious).
We notified the churches that subscribed to The Christian Reader about this new product, and several thousand churches sent in orders. Unfortunately, they discovered that their people divided their interest and purchases, some continuing to choose The Christian Reader and some switching their allegiance to Bookshorts. Few chose to buy both magazines. The result was that while the new magazine quickly climbed to a circulation of 100,000 copies, The Christian
Reader plummeted to 200,000 copies from its previous peak of more than 300,000. We were selling the same total number of magazines, but we had the much higher costs of publishing two magazines instead of one—more editors, double art costs, double promotion costs, and so on.
After three years we tried to solve this problem by discontinuing Bookshorts, so that those 100,000 customers would come back to The Chnistian Reader. We even added a couple of book condensations to each issue of The Christian Reader to keep everyone happy. But for some reason the Bookshorts subscribers never came back in great numbers. Thus another of my "brilliant" ideas bit the dust! Meanwhile, The Christian
Reader continues to maintain its high quality and has one of the highest circulations among Christian magazines today. It frequently wins awards for journalistic and artistic excellence.
In 1988 we launched our next periodical. And it was a big one! Called Dr James Dobson's Focus on the Family Bulletin, it is a church bulletin insert edited by Dr. Dobson's staff at Focus on the Family. I wasn't enthusiastic at first about the idea (which came from Bob Screen and from my son Mark), because I was afraid it would cut into the circulation of The Church Around the World. | was remembering how Bookshorts hurt the distribution of The Christian Reader, But when Mark
Magazines, Racks of Books, and Church Bulletins persisted with the idea of the new periodical, I jumped on board and pasted together a sample issue. I was challenged by what I read and felt sure that many parents would be helped by reading it. It quickly became our periodical with the largest circulation, 3 million copies a month, without substantially reducing the circulation of the other periodicals.
And now, as I write, we are beginning to publish a similar monthly bulletin insert edited by Charles Colson, founder of Prison Fellowship. We feel there is room for all of these, for our combined circulation is reaching only a quarter of the 150,000 churches in America. We still have a long way to go.
