Chapter 9 of 22

3. Creating Environments Where Faith Families Flourish

3. Creating Environments Where Faith Families Flourish

3

Creating Environments Where Faith Families Flourish

When I ask youth workers about the goals of youth ministry, most respond in one of two ways:

  • Doers focus on action: organizing activities, carrying out programs, and scheduling big events like mission trips so students will learn about the Bible and Christian living.
  • Disciple makers focus on Christ’s “Great Commission” (although he didn’t call it that) at the end of Matthew. For them, it’s about bringing young people to the point where they accept Christ as their personal Savior.
  • But then when I ask youth workers to tell me how their stated goals align with how they actually run their ministries, I receive fewer confident responses. I have found that too many youth workers simply don’t give much thought to connecting the dots between their youth ministry practices and the results and outcomes they say they desire.

    Many doers embrace what I call the youth ministry machine—the network of churches, parachurch organizations, conferences, blog posts, and publishers that pump out a steady stream of ready-to-use programs and materials. Created by experts and talented designers, these resources are designed for a youth pastor’s immediate use without any personal reflection or preparation.

    I confess, my generation of leaders is largely responsible for this model. Once upon a time, there was no such thing as youth ministry. Young people simply tried to involve themselves in adult church programming.

    But then a bunch of us young rebels rose up and declared, “Young people deserve their own form of ministry.” (This trend was happening not just in youth ministry but in education, youth sports, and many other ways adults tried to help young people flourish.) We tried many new exercises and activities with young people, and when one of them “worked,” we passed this activity around in our networks so others could do the same activity with their kids. In time, our networks became parachurch organizations and publishers that promoted ready-to-use activities and programs.

    Perhaps unintentionally we sold a generation of youth workers on the idea that youth ministry equals doing such activities and programs, that little more is required. If you follow what some call “best practices,” you’re good to go.

    Resources are great tools, but when we mistake tools for goals, we get lost. We can wind up thinking we are being successful if we simply offer kids a nonstop conveyor belt of goodies and the kids actually show up.

    The assumption is that so long as kids attend, participate, say the right things, and behave well in groups, they must be solid followers of Jesus. When we see a ninth grader coming to youth group every week, actively taking part in a small group, going to church with her parents, and seeming sincere in “pursuing her faith,” doers feel that their work is done.

    The disciple-maker model has its own goals. At the core of many evangelical Christian youth ministries is the desire to help lead John or Joan toward a personal knowledge of and commitment to faith in Christ that lasts a lifetime. Youth workers “stand in the gap” between Christ and today’s generation of teens. You can find this goal clearly stated in many books, convention talks, and blog posts: individual salvation and discipleship for individual believers. When kids truly know and have a relationship with Christ, disciple makers feel our work is done.

    If only everything were so easy. As we’ve seen in recent years, the fastest-growing “religious” group in America is the nonreligious: nones who profess no religious affiliation. The ranks of the nones are full of the Johns and Joans who used to be in our youth groups but have since graduated from both our group and their Christian “phase.”

    All our plans and good intentions, small groups and mission trips do not necessarily produce the graduates and outcomes we pray for. Trips can release young people from the pretense and burdens of the everyday and ordinary. Missions and service opportunities can help them to see outside and beyond themselves. Small groups can teach them empathy and till the emotional soil for a willingness and ability to go deep with others as they move through life.

    All great stuff! The problem isn’t, and hasn’t ever been, “youth ministry.” The problem is twofold: the theological weakness of our “goal” and the inability to be strategic in pursuit of that goal. Ministry is far less about what we do and much more about where we are going. That’s why goals are the essence of adoptive youth ministry.

    The Point of Adoptive Youth Ministry: A Growing Family

    The point of adoptive youth ministry is to help young people see that by faith in Christ they are part of a new family. Our role in this is to create an environment and employ strategies that will not only introduce adolescents and emerging adults to faith in Jesus Christ but also help them live out that faith as participants and contributors to the family of God.

    I don’t want to see any more young people go through our ministries, with all their activities and decisions for Christ, and graduate feeling disconnected from both Christ and the family of God.

    Again, the gift (or “right” in John 1:12) of the incarnation is to be drawn into a new reality as siblings in God’s household. Certainly we will do activities. Certainly we will lead our students into a deeper connection and commitment to Christ. But adoptive youth ministry calls us to come alongside young people in the name and with the compassion of God so that in Christ they move from being lost to being found. As they encounter and consider the call of the good news, they will see that it is fulfilled in community. No one is created or designed to be alone (Gen. 2:18).

    This is the core message of adoptive youth ministry: God has provided young people not only with an eternal way home but also with a family right here in the world where, by faith in Jesus, they can experience now what it means to be a beloved sibling in God’s household. This is the reason we do everything we do.

    Families thrive in healthy environments. Let’s see how you can create the kind of environment where members of God’s family can thrive.

    Three Keys to Creating an Adoptive Environment

    Being a Christian means more than having fire insurance against hell and the promise of eternal life later on. Knowing Christ means experiencing an intimate and authentic family-like connection with the household of God right now.

    I can hear some of the activity-obsessed doers complaining, “Chap, that sounds so out of touch . . . b-o-r-i-n-g.” Perhaps the doubters have never seen what I’ve witnessed.

    It’s amazing to see the transformation in young people who are jaded by a world where adults don’t really care for them, have been rejected by a world where they don’t fit in, or have been judged by a world where all that matters are performance and conformity. When young people get a chance to experience Christian community through deep intergenerational relationships and shared core values, they latch on to it for all they’re worth.

    I’ve had kids tell me about a lifetime of being shamed while playing sports, or of being forced to embrace an all-pleasing image that they know is not them, or of teachers, neighbors, and parents who never say “I love you” without attaching a demand: “Have you finished your report yet? Have you cleaned up your room yet?”

    Many teenagers and young adults have an innate distrust of adult power and authority. That’s because they’ve witnessed and experienced its abuse throughout their lives. Why should they trust the church, one of the most powerful bastions of adult power? Why must being a Christian require me to submit myself to a bunch of adults I don’t know?

    For the gospel to take root in the lives of young people, we need to start by making them welcome in our midst. I’m not talking about welcome as a passive verb, where you sit back and wait for someone to seek your group. I’m talking about welcome as an active verb, where you invest the energy and effort to invite one and all to Christ’s big family banquet. We need to actively communicate to each and every precious young person God grants us the chance to lead: “We want you here. We will make room for you. We will weave you into this family.”

    We have to be the initiators of welcome and inclusion. We have to take the lead. We take the first step. We must be willing to stretch out and bridge the often uncomfortable chasm between one person and another.

    I believe that if we are to be effective in adoptive ministry, we must let go of any notions that the focus of our youth ministry should be on reaching and celebrating only the top jocks, the elite students, the extreme extroverts, and the key influencers. These students already have their rewards, and while they of course need our care and attention, it must not be at the expense of anyone else.

    I believe authentic ministry must follow the model Jesus set when he was incarnated among us: protecting the vulnerable, embracing the outcast, recognizing the neglected, and healing the broken.

    Youth workers who follow the doer and the disciple-maker models need to follow the practical advice that Dr. Kara Powell, executive director of the Fuller Youth Institute, offered in an interview with Christianity Today: “View your church through the eyes of a young person.”

    When you see church from their vantage point, you can see why a genuine, vibrant community that loves and values them is so precious and unique. Such a community can help them navigate the three development tasks of adolescence and emerging adulthood: the development of identity, owning an internal locus of control and autonomy, and having a place to belong that is bigger than themselves.

    There are three keys to creating an environment of welcome and inclusion:

  • Nurturing young people
  • Empowering young people
  • Including young people
  • Nurturing Young People

    When I am invited to preach or speak, I typically rent a car so that after I’ve given folks everything, I can go somewhere—either to a hotel hot tub or a small gathering with friends—where I don’t have to preach or speak anymore.

    But having access to a car keeps me from encounters like the one I had with a pastor who insisted on taking me to the airport himself.

    “I liked your adoptive ministry talk,” he told me. “Now I get what my sixteen-year-old son needs. I’ve got to get five men to pour into his life.”

    As he drove, he catalogued his many complaints about his son. He was a disappointment. He just needed to grow up and to learn how to be a man for a change.

    “That’s why I need to find five great men who can pour themselves into him and show him what it means to be a man of God.”

    Yellow and red flags started to fly in my mind.

    For one thing, while I believe that young people would appreciate a few adult men and women to gently and organically come alongside and care for them, I’m not sure the way to achieve this is by having a father finding other like-minded guys to “pour into him.”

    As common as it is, the “pouring” language does not reflect what adoptive ministry looks like. I know it’s popular lingo, but doesn’t pouring usually mean one person is a big pitcher full of water and the other person is an empty vessel? Even when lovingly applied, this approach can be one-way and top-down. Adoptive youth ministry is more about providing support and care to a young person than it is about pouring. As Paul puts it to his friends in Thessalonica, “For you know that we dealt with each of you as a father deals with his own children, encouraging, comforting and urging you to live lives worthy of God” (1 Thess. 2:11–12). And even that word, urging, is not with the intensity of “pouring into” but the offering of hope. That’s what the five adults in the life of a young person represent—not a one-way directing, but a mutual and organic friendship that an adult sibling offers.

    The concept of nurture comes from the Latin “to suckle, to nourish” and later “the act of nursing.” In English, to nurture means to “care for and protect (someone or something) while they are growing.” Let’s explore how adoptive ministries can nurture the young by both protecting and caring for them.

    I know many ministries that seek to protect and care for young people. Some are very effective. But what happens when kids graduate and leave your program? Will they continue to live well and engage the world in ways that strengthen their life and their faith? Will they continue to live into their mutual adoption as siblings in the household of God?

    Protection means more than permission slips and health forms and adequate supervision on trips and at lock-ins. These are important, but God’s family can also protect young people’s developing hearts and psyches. We can help young people interpret and filter the world they encounter so they know how to respond. That may mean providing them with resources and experts when it comes to issues of gender discrimination, violence, media, and the like. It also means being present enough with them so that we adults are able to more deeply understand what it is like to be a young person in this culture. This understanding would allow us to engage with them as they move through adolescence.

    How to explain caring? I believe compassion is key. Henri Nouwen said that to show compassion means “to suffer with” another. This is loving with teeth. Instead of building a wall of protection around our young, or hiring the best staff to lead them, an adoptive community comes alongside the young and “suffers with” each one.

    To suffer with others, we must initiate relationships with them. We must seek to know them and know about them. We must do what is not done by anyone else in their world: we must commit to remaining close by every person God brings into our church families. We must embody sacrificial love and compassion to truly nurture these others. Practically, caring with compassion means we must:

  • demonstrate our compassion so we can build bridges of trust;
  • actively show respect for each person instead of waiting for them to show respect to us;
  • listen to them instead of trying to force them to listen to us;
  • initiate relationships without pushing our agenda or timetable on them;
  • seek to empathize with them, meaning we sit on the steps of their world, making sure that they know that we are interested in what their life is like; and
  • advise and share only when asked, knowing that when they are ready and trust us, we are most able to speak in a way that encourages and builds them up.
  • By following these practical principles of caring with compassion, we heed Paul’s admonishment in Colossians 4:5: “Be wise in the way you act toward outsiders; make the most of every opportunity.”

    Empowering Young People

    How many times have you heard someone say, “Young people are the future of the church”? Many times when I’ve heard it, the unsubtle message is that adults get to control things for now, and the young people can take over once we’re all dead.

    When it comes to their faith, every young person needs to know that they have value as siblings in the household of God. All too often, even in youth ministry, we have limited empowerment to serving the internal youth ministry program or succumbed to a church’s plea for warm bodies to “teach” in the children’s ministry. Occasionally, a church may require a special ability, and because there is no one else who can fill that need, a church may seek out (and call it “empower”) a student to serve (like a bass player for the worship band, or someone to help usher or park cars). Under these circumstances, a young person who is given the opportunity to contribute may or may not feel a sense of empowerment in the process. When a task is offered without a commitment to proactively naming that student’s worth and value as a member of the adoptive community, they intuitively know that they are simply filling a need. In these circumstances, they rarely feel a sense of authentic empowerment. Yet when a belief in the contribution of a young person is celebrated and affirmed in the faith community, in recognition of their importance to that body, their sense of self and ability to make a difference strengthens their sense of worth and connection to the broader community. This is empowerment. Here are three ways we can empower young people.

    Involve the Whole Community

    Communicating to students that they are valuable needs to happen outside the walls and networks of the youth ministry. They need to be welcome participants in the whole community.

    An adoptive church looks to avoid a scenario where a high school student may be valued as a third-grade Sunday school teacher, but her value reaches only as far as the children’s ministry staff. Nor would this church be content with a situation where a sound tech played an integral part of the production staff, but no one outside the department even knows what he does or who he is.

    To intentionally empower the young to feel like they are important members of the church family, we must find creative and strategic ways for them to be seen and celebrated as vital to the household of faith. To do that, we need lots of adults to know every young person who calls our church their home.

    Become “Keychain Leaders”

    According to Kara Powell, Jake Mulder, and Brad Griffin, “keychain leaders” are leaders who “are acutely aware of the keys on their keychain and intentional about entrusting and empowering all generations, including teenagers and emerging adults, with their own set of keys.”

    The idea is not to just hand off keys to young people, letting them simply take over a ministry or event. Keychain leaders are strategic, present, and involved. They want to empower young people to discover and use their gifts to contribute to and participate in the life and work of the community, whatever it takes. This can take a myriad of forms, but the common commitment is that, in as many ways and avenues as it takes, every teenager and young adult needs to be able to engage their God-given leadership in a way that embodies their value and place.

    Help Young People Develop Their Gifts and Callings

    One of the more prominent struggles of church ministry is what staff tend to call “recruiting volunteers.” In the body of Christ, the leadership’s job is not to “recruit” anybody to any task. Rather, it is our role to empower the laity to participate in and contribute to the household of faith.

    As Paul puts it, our job is “to equip his people for works of service, so the body of Christ may be built up” (Eph. 4:12). When we recruit people to a specific task, or even label or slot people according to a programmatic need we have identified, loyalty is rarely built.

    When it comes to empowering young people, don’t just use them as a form of plug and play. Don’t automatically squeeze them into your mold, but work with them to see how the Spirit is working in their lives to grow their gifts.

    Ask them what drew them to serve and what they hope to contribute by serving. Using these insights, work together to develop a job description that both contributes to the needs of the community and empowers the young person’s need to know that they matter.

    Including Young People

    How do we include the young in ways that help them feel like they are genuine and necessary parts of the whole community? This is about both attitude and intentionality. Do you truly want to invite young people to participate? How seriously do the leaders and the adults in your community take the contributions of the young in the business of the whole? These are the questions to ask ourselves.

    It is also up to us, as adults and as ministry leaders, to make sure that we are not just talking about inviting the young into the life and work of our Christian body but actually making that happen. This can include everything from their serving in a coleadership role to being on a leadership advisory team. If you offer adult education as well as youth ministry, you can put the normal age-segregated programming on hold maybe two or three times a year and offer elective classes that draw high school students and adults into dialogue. During the Academy Awards season, for example, one Southern California church offers a six-week series on some of the movies up for Best Picture, and everyone (including teenagers) is welcome. They watch assigned films and then gather weekly to discuss the theological and cultural content of the film. The dialogue is livelier than it would be with only adults!

    Adoptive ministry is for all of us—not just the clergy or staff, but the entire community—to commit to creating a church-wide environment where the young know that they matter.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑