Chapter 13 of 22

6. Implementing Adoptive Youth Ministry

6. Implementing Adoptive Youth Ministry

6

Implementing Adoptive Youth Ministry

I’m sold,” the youth and family pastor of a large church in Canada told me. “So . . . how?”

As I have thought and prayed, studied and written about the idea of adoptive ministry, everywhere I go I try to get people on board. I’m not proposing something that is not already there right in front of us. Throughout the Scriptures the idea of God’s children being part of a family is prominent. When I talk about our goal in youth ministry, adoptive youth ministry fits, conceptually at least, for almost everybody. Whether in an hour seminar at a convention or an all-day denominational gathering, seeing the church as a family and proactively helping kids to make it a family is not a hard intellectual leap. So, inevitably, what everybody wants to know is, “How do I pull it off?”

Pulling It Off

In part 1 we focused on the heartbeat and driving goal of adoptive youth ministry:

To create an environment where young people are encouraged to live into their calling in Christ as agents of the kingdom within the household of God.

To put adoptive youth ministry into practice means that everything we do moves us toward that goal. When it comes to putting on the wheels that lead to that, or any, goal—structure, overall strategy, programs, staffing, calendar, and so on—we need to take several steps. Here is what it takes to develop and implement a ministry that reaches the ministry goal or desired outcomes. It’s called developing a contextually applied structure.

Developing a Contextually Applied Structure

  • Establishing a clear goal: committing to going after the goal together
  • Analyzing context: knowing who you are and where you’ve been
  • Assessing and identifying resources: knowing your ministry options
  • Tweaking (or creating) structure: putting a plan into place
  • Gathering your partners: finding and equipping those who matter
  • Equipping the team: getting partners in the right spot
  • This chapter will explore strategies 1–4, and the following two chapters will go deeply into strategies 5 and 6.

    Establishing a Clear Goal: Committing to Going after the Goal Together

    Organizational theorists Carl Larson and Frank LaFasto spent lots of time working to understand teams. They looked at successful teams and unsuccessful teams. They interviewed cohesive teams and observed fragmented and even contentious teams. What they found is that people who are effective in collectively going after a goal almost always have a set of common characteristics. The most significant marker relates to how clear the end goal is to every team member. When everyone can describe their group’s goal precisely, if not with the exact same wording, they are far more likely to reach their goal than a group that does not share that feature. Regardless of the setting—from professional sports to business to NASA—this prominent characteristic was universally consistent.

    In ministry settings, all too often the goals we have are too generic to meaningfully connect with people as they do their part toward the goal, or ministries do not have a clear goal in the first place. With adoptive youth ministry, however, the goal is always front and center. The trick for us, then, is to make people aware of both its meaning and the implications of its pursuit. This means that a seventh-grade small group leader should know, understand, and be able to articulate the goal of the youth ministry in the same way as the people who flip the burgers for the monthly family ministry gathering of students and adults.

    To make sure that everyone who affects the work of adoptive youth ministry understands the goal (and it’s a very small list of people in a church who do not!), it is up to leadership, however you define that, to make it happen. The two key words for this are communication and training. Communication can be defined as “the art of being understood.” To be strategic communicators of adoptive youth ministry, we must get the word out far and wide, with a consistent and clear message. This includes everything from casual conversations to training materials, from announcements and sermons during services to how we introduce parents to the vision. We need to think macro, bringing along the whole church, and micro, leading individuals who are on the front lines—like parents, church and lay leadership, and youth ministry staff and volunteers—to know what it means for them to move toward adoptive ministry. We must make sure not only that people know what the long-term vision is but also that they see their role in it.

    Related to communication is training. We must train a congregation, including the distant pew sitters as well as those in positions of leadership, so that people know what adoptive ministry means not only for the youth ministry but for them as well. Parents, for example, should be trained and equipped to partner with the church in helping their children enter into deeper relationships within a congregation (with appropriate boundaries for safety). Older congregants should be deliberately equipped to serve the young as older siblings who have the ability to both nurture and empower, and give voice to them when the opportunity arises. Those who preach need to be brought up to speed on their role in sharing content, telling stories, and describing what it means to be part of the household of God.

    These and many other subsets of the community need to hear how they play a crucial role in creating the environment where adoptive ministry can flourish, as well as providing the presence and commitment to nurturing and empowering the young as they grow. And most of all, everyone should engage the Scriptures to explore what it means when Jesus calls the “least of these” his “brothers and sisters” (Matt. 25:40) and the implications of his command to “love each other” (John 15:17).

    Analyzing Context: Knowing Who You Are and Where You’ve Been

    I was recently asked by an older pastor from a relatively small church, “Who is doing this?”

    “Lots of churches, mostly in bits and pieces, and usually by accident,” I answered.

    “It would be great if you could give us a model so we can see adoptive ministry in action. You know, how it works in context.”

    First, let’s look at the positives of this feedback. Yes, I do see many if not most churches offering some sort of adoptive ministry in what they do. I know of a few that intentionally claim to be a “youth-friendly” or “family-friendly” church, and they work hard to be as intergenerationally welcoming as they can. Another church I know works hard at welcoming the young when they have the opportunity. When they invite teenagers to serve in their music ministry, for example, they make sure all the adults know that the student is not simply another musician or singer—a helpful tool—but a young person who “deserves our care [nurture] and encouragement [in this case almost a pseudonym for empowerment].” These examples—and I’ve encountered many—are, to be sure, signs of an adoptive style of ministry. In this sense there are lots of snapshots out there of churches wanting to draw the young into their community.

    But, if pressed, I would hesitate to call these faith communities models of adoptive youth ministry. When we look at the positives scattered throughout the ecclesial landscape, even those churches that seek to be youth- or family-friendly or that sporadically bring an adolescent into an otherwise adult role are rarely proactive in becoming a family of siblings, which is the basic theological premise of adoptive ministry. It is heartening to see the recent trend of many people and churches sincerely working to reach out to the young. Encouraging young people to use their gifts for ministry and enlisting adults who care about teenagers enough to walk alongside them does provide the conceptual seedbed for adoptive youth ministry. After all, the hardest part of adoptive ministry is getting people over the hump of thinking this means adopting kids (which, as I’ve repeatedly said, it does not). So as of now there are churches that have been intrigued by the idea of adoptive ministry (whether they name it that or not), where a community is committed to living into their mutual adoption in Christ and treating one another, regardless of age or status, as siblings (whether they use that language or not). But are there particular models to point to as prototypes to emulate and copy? To me this is a harder question. Not because people are not going after the basic premises of adoptive ministry, but because the notion of models can be a slippery thing.

    This reveals an even more important issue, and hopefully a comforting one, when it comes to implementing a vision for any form of ministry, and especially something as organic as adoptive ministry. The “fly in the ointment” of models is that your church is unique, and so is everyone else’s! Here is just a sampling of the ways your setting is unique:

  • history: why you are where you are
  • narratives: how you describe your church, even to yourself
  • theological assumptions: beyond faith statement or denomination, the particulars that your church tends to camp out on
  • cultural assumptions: how your community sees the world, both in the big picture and around you
  • Once we have communicated and fostered a conversation that helps people think of their faith in terms of their mutual adoption in Christ, the next step is to expand that into what it means to them as a community. Then, in light of this theological reality, we can begin to examine how we’ve seen ourselves in relation to one another in the past, not just in student ministry but across the community. How have we operated as a community of siblings in the household of God? Have outsiders, or those in various ministry groups (seniors, college students, young adults, middle schoolers, singles), felt connected to the rest of the congregation in a manner anywhere close to something that could be described as siblings in Christ? These are bedrock questions for any church to ask of itself: Who have we been, and who do we think we are . . . together?

    This is what it means to objectively and honestly examine our context. To move toward an adoptive community of intimately and interconnected siblings—the kind that Jesus exhibits with his disciples and followers throughout his ministry, and Paul and the other New Testament writers implicitly and even explicitly remind us about on almost every page—we need to be clear about where we have been, where we are now, and why we are who we are. This is our context.

    Take your history, for example. If you are a twenty-five-year-old church that was started in the heyday of the “seeker” movement, then likely that will tell you not only where you’ve been but also where you are currently headed. In the early years the seeker movement, to many at least, was about church growth, bringing in either people who were overtly described as “unchurched” or those lukewarm regarding faith. The hurdle for you might have been, and probably currently is, taking people deeper in their faith than an initial, “Hey, I like this. This is church? I’m in!” Your congregation, then, might not even realize how the Scriptures call us through faith into a new family. This history will affect not how adoptive youth ministry needs to be communicated but how it will need to be strategically implemented.

    Let’s take this same example further. Your congregation, and maybe even some staff, may not have a very rich understanding of what it means to be adopted into God’s family. So a careful read on that history and resultant current setting might instruct you to be more deliberate in guiding the community to a place of recognizing what it actually means to live “in Christ” together. To be given the right to become children of God by receiving and believing in Jesus Christ (John 1:12) implicitly means that before we believe and receive Christ, we are orphaned, at least as far as our relationship to God is concerned. Once we come to faith, then, we not only have the right (or privilege) to become children of God with other children, but we have an explicit responsibility to live according to that truth. In many congregations this is news to people. That, then, is a contextual issue that is part and parcel of the implementation of an adoptive youth ministry.

    Context, as I’ve said, is anything and everything you can think of that would affect your ability to establish a welcoming community that sees itself, by God’s grace and declaration, as a family of siblings. Knowing where you have been and who you are, in every way you can imagine, provides the data that will help you define what is likely to be confusing or missed in your community and emphasize what needs to be strengthened.

    Assessing and Identifying Resources: Knowing Your Ministry Options

    Implementing a strategy committed to adoptive youth ministry begins with knowing where you’ve been, where you are, and where you believe that you are headed. That is the context. The next step is to assess and identify the resources you have available to enter into that context with adoptive youth ministry as the driving goal.

    Resources can be defined as anything that affects your ability to achieve your goal, although the term is rarely used this way. What this means is that resources can be either positive or negative, depending on how you understand and make use of them. Resources are, in fact, neutral. They are neither good nor bad. This understanding is important because we tend to consider resources as what we have and what we don’t have but think we need, or at least want. This is where we get into trouble in ministry, because it is easy for us to be held back from freely engaging our call as a result of what we perceive is a lack of the resources we need to do our jobs. “We could really make an impact, but we don’t have enough male leaders to do what we want to do.” In this example, while you might have identified what you envision doing to move forward, currently the staff you have makes that untenable. So, yes, “pray to the Lord of the harvest” for people to serve alongside you (Matt. 9:36–38), but don’t let your perception of these kinds of deficits hold you back. Instead, find creative ways to adjust your plans and even your expectations to match your resources. Our job is to do what we can with what God has given us, and to pray for whatever else the Lord may want to give us to enable us to follow the vision he has for us.

    The following list provides examples of resources that affect your ability—positively or negatively—to create the environment and offer the content and strategy for an adoptive youth ministry:

  • the paid staff and volunteers you have currently (including but not limited to their age, gender, personal and spiritual maturity, time availability, etc.)
  • your programmatic history and current momentum (beware of tossing programs that have momentum, and be honest about those that do not)
  • facilities (don’t limit this to the church building(s), but think outside the box; what are some other options right in front of you that you hadn’t considered before, like a park, a community center, homes, a school)
  • the way you have structured your ministry—how you serve middle school, high school, post–high school, and emerging adults in your community (whatever structure you have had is simply the way you have divided people, so allow this history to inform what has been good and not so good, especially as it pertains to the implementation of an adoptive ministry)
  • attitudes of parents, staff, and other adults in the congregation
  • In ministry, it is important to remember that whatever God has given us is sufficient to do and be what God is asking of us. We can and should pray for the resources we think we need to serve him well. But all the while, the Lord only asks of us to be faithful with what he has given us.

    Tweaking (or Creating) Structure: Putting a Plan into Place

    One of the hallmarks of adoptive youth ministry is that it does not rely on programs but sees them as useful tools. What we do is far less important than how we go about creating an environment where young people believe that they matter and are welcome in the larger body. After a thorough assessment of both your context and resources, you might find that you will only need to make minor adjustments to your programs and structure. In this case, you might find you have to put most of your energies into convincing and training your team and the congregation. Or perhaps you realize that you have historically put so much emphasis on separating your high school students from congregants and the church at large that you now need to think differently and maybe even implement changes. It may take some careful work and time, but you might decide to loosen your grip on having a strict high school ministry identity and to relationally diffuse discipleship strategies, especially for eleventh- and twelfth-grade students, across the broader church (handing off students to the missions committee or a pastoral care team, for example). The point is not to change things for change’s sake but to be realistic and strategic as you move in the direction of adoptive ministry.

    As you begin to put a plan into place, there are two vital components to keep in mind: building consensus and committing to regular evaluations. Building consensus is more than informing or even training people. It is including people in gathering data as you analyze your context and resources. It is inviting others to examine and give input on what you have found and concluded. And perhaps most important, it is moving slowly with great care, especially if you will begin tinkering with established programs, events, retreats, or anything else in which someone may feel like you are taking something they cherish from them. As Harvard’s Ronald Heifitz has said, “What people resist is not change per se, but loss.” Any time you are going to do anything different from what people appreciate or expect, even if they are vocal naysayers about it, the more they are given the opportunity to own the process of change, the greater your chances of systemic success.

    Evaluating Your Ministry

    Finally, as you begin to build a revised or even wholly new ministry to become an adoptive ministry, right from the start you should develop a written, broadly communicated, and clear evaluation plan. This evaluation should not be on how a program is doing on its own merit (as in, “Youth group seems to be going well—our numbers are up, our kids are engaged, and parents are pleased”) but rather on how well it is moving toward the goal of adoptive ministry. Programmatic pieces and individual events may be powerful, growing, and hugely popular on their own, but if they do not lead toward the goal of adoptive youth ministry, then for most students their lasting impact will likely be slim at best.

    The way to create an evaluative tool is to start with your goal. For our purposes let’s use my goal of adoptive youth ministry:

    To create an environment where young people are encouraged to live into their calling in Christ as agents of the kingdom within the household of God.

    Next, break the goal into its key component parts (as we did in chapter 5) and create a series of statements that connect the program or event to your goal. For each of these questions, provide a Likert scale (1–5) and a space for comments.

    Using my goal as an example to evaluate, for instance, a high school small group ministry, here’s what an evaluation sheet could look like:

    An evaluation tool should be created for every ministry program or event. Distribute it as widely as possible (such as students, parents, volunteers, pastoral staff, and so on) both to build a sense of ownership in your community and to discover any issues or patterns that a single leader or a small handful of people might miss. Evaluations like this should be done frequently, and each program or event will dictate its own timetable. Of course, leadership must take seriously what is revealed in the evaluation process and adjust the ministry plan accordingly.

    Implementing adoptive youth ministry in your setting begins with making sure everyone understands and buys into the goal of what it is you are trying to accomplish not only in youth ministry but for the entire faith community. Once you have begun this work, assessing your context, identifying your resources, and building your structure will enable you to strategically move young people into greater inclusion and empowerment in your church. All that’s left is to gather your partners and train your team for the move to adoptive ministry. The fun has just begun.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑