10. Beyond Participation
10
Beyond Participation
THE POWER OF EMPOWERMENT
Educational experts say about 6 percent of American children meet this definition for “gifted and talented”: “Students, children, or youth who give evidence of high achievement capability in areas such as intellectual, creative, artistic, or leadership capacity, or in specific academic fields, and who need services and activities not ordinarily provided by the school in order to fully develop those capabilities.” So what about the remaining 94 percent? Don’t they have gifts and talents? And where did this “gifted and talented” lingo come from, anyway?
In 1954 the National Association of Gifted Children was founded on the premise that some children are gifted in ways that most children are not. The concept was given official status with the creation of the US Department of Education’s Office of the Gifted and Talented in 1974. In time the concept percolated through education circles and American culture.
Decades later, our kids are growing up in a world that pretty much embraces the concept that there are very few top-performing students and then there’s everybody else. Many young people I’ve known feel certain they’re in the vast 94 percent, not the elite 6 percent. It is a heavy burden on kids’ shoulders to go through life believing that experts have already determined they don’t have “it,” whatever “it” is. And that applies to those we love to call “normal” kids. What does this say about the 6.7 million young people in the US who are classified as needing “special education services”? Do these not represent another subset of those who are deserving of not only our nurture and welcome but also an intentional commitment from us to empower each one to bring their unique gifts and love to the body of Christ? My friend Miri Sampson, who works with Capernaum Ministries, a branch of Young Life, recently reminded me of the power and profound grace that each of these all-too-often forgotten kids and their families offer to everyone they encounter. When we buy in to how the world only sees the superstar—the athlete, the singer, the “beautiful”—we miss out on that subtle but overwhelming blessing that God gives us through those we deem invisible.
That’s why it breaks my heart when I see church and youth ministries unwittingly slip into this “gifted and talented” mindset. We might not use that lingo, but we make the same kinds of distinctions among our kids, treating our “best” students differently than we treat the others. You may not see it, but your students can.
You may call your approach “student leadership.” You may encourage “those God has blessed with the gift of music” to sing a song for the community. Some kids are blessed and can speak or play guitar. Meanwhile, the other kids wonder, “Why hasn’t God blessed me with any talents?”
One prominent Christian high school in Southern California devoted a special student assembly to one star football player. Faculty and administration didn’t see any problem with the celebration, but one local youth pastor asked a pointed question: “When will we have a special student assembly for the students who build the sets for the school play? Or the students who tutor urban kids?”
“When they get a scholarship to Notre Dame, that’s when!” said one administrator.
Many youth ministries have mindlessly baptized the concept of gifted and talented. We’ve also added on a dangerous theological component by insinuating that gifted and talented kids are uniquely blessed by God. Everybody else? Not blessed quite so much.
Adoptive churches expose this concept for what it is: a heresy that denies the varied gifts and talents God graciously bestows on each and every one of us, regardless of merit or social status. In an adoptive church, we not only recognize that everyone in our group is blessed and gifted; we put that belief into practice by intentionally involving everyone in the life of the community.
Isn’t that what siblings do in their families?
This is the power of empowerment. Let’s see how we can empower everyone in our communities to use and develop their gifts within the loving embrace of God’s big family.
The Journey of Empowerment: Everyone Participating and Contributing
Adult leaders say they want all kids to participate, but what do they mean? Participation means different things to different groups. Most kids realize that some form of participation is the price they must pay to be part of a group. But what’s the fun of being a member of the team if you never get to play in a real game? Minimalist participation is only minimally effective!
Some groups actively encourage kids to participate, but only so far. Kids can help in the sound booth as long as they don’t turn up the drums too loud. They can “teach” second-grade Sunday school if they follow the curriculum to the letter. Many adults believe the best way to help kids realize they are part of the church family is to give them only small, token assignments.
Our students are growing up in a culture where some groups award “participation trophies” to any living and breathing kids who show up. Millennial-bashers love talking about these trophies, blaming this generation’s “entitlement” woes on receiving empty prizes. “These kids only participated. Why do they think they deserve a trophy?”
Adoptive youth ministry seeks more than minimal participation. We want young people to experience what it’s like to live as a part of the family of God. Our hope is that they grow in that family and increasingly contribute their God-given gifts and talents for the building up of the whole family.
But many kids may not feel equipped to contribute anything of worth to the family. They’ve been taught they’re part of the nongifted and nontalented masses, and they believe it. That’s why we must empower them.
Inviting only kids’ participation without offering any real empowerment is an empty gesture. But things change when we believe deep down that middle school students do have something of substance to offer, and then we help them offer it.
Would your church trust a trained and qualified twenty-three-year-old college student to chair the missions department and oversee its budget of thousands of dollars from members’ tithes? Could we give voice to a high school student who was willing to be taught and study the Scriptures and as a result felt called to offer critique and advice for a pastor’s sermon series? Behind these nagging questions lies one much larger and more troubling question: Do we really trust our teenage and young adult siblings to contribute alongside us now, even if they are willing and trained, or must they wait until we finally deem them ready to serve God’s family?
Power to the People: Four Keys to Empowering Our Younger Siblings
It’s one thing to talk about empowering young people and another to make it happen. Sometimes it’s not a question of whether students have the ability to serve, but a question of power. Adults have the power, and some don’t want to share it with “those kids.” Empowerment is a major theological issue for some adults. For others it’s a major psychosocial issue.
We need to transcend participation and go all out for contribution. A participant is allowed to be with us. A contributor is a coworker we must listen to and take seriously.
I was a principal researcher for the Fuller Youth Institute’s Churches Engaging Young People (CEYP) project. We looked at which groups preferred participation and which preferred contribution. On the surface these perspectives can look pretty much the same. But look beneath the surface and you can see the difference in the way young people feel about their relationship to the group depending on how included they feel. The authors of Growing Young, the book describing this research, repeatedly noted in their background work (called a literature review) the difference between being a participant and being a contributor. Groups that empower the young to contribute can experience two related benefits:
Adoptive empowerment wants to make sure that when the church, the organization, or the youth group receives young people as siblings, they commit to receiving their contributions to the family. Yes, younger partners may need some level of training and apprenticeship for some forms of ministry. But there’s no training required for them to bring a fresh perspective to any community.
Empowerment is our goal. We want teenagers and emerging adults to be embraced not only as younger siblings but also as valued ministry partners. To reach this goal we need to recognize four keys to empowering the young, summed up in these four words: intergenerational, particular, incremental, and intentional.
Empowerment Is Intergenerational
I assume most readers already know that to be effective, youth ministry should be intergenerational, but putting that into practice is not always easy. Throwing five senior adults and five ninth graders in a van for an ill-conceived service project doesn’t automatically produce lifelong friendships. A slapdash approach may actually make it harder to build intergenerational bridges.
Seniors don’t always know how to talk to kids, and kids aren’t sure how to approach seniors. There may be an outlier or two who are able to break through the generational and cultural barriers. More often it seems students don’t see the need for reaching out, and some of the adults don’t either.
Holly Catterton Allen, a child and family studies professor, says that within intergenerational congregations all age groups “grow each other up into Christ.” Every fifteen-year-old needs older siblings in order to grow in Christ and experience a long-term faith. Likewise, every sixty-five-year-old needs a fifteen-year-old sibling to keep things real!
We need each other. If you want that to be the reality in your community, the adults must commit to embracing the following attitudes and actions:
Churches that want to create a community where every voice is heard and every person is valued need to foster the kind of environment where intergenerational relationships flourish.
Some people love humanity but hate individual people. Likewise, many churches say they value young people, but few actually open up church power structures to young people’s contributions.
Empowering an individual does not happen without a carefully designed and executed ministry plan that makes including each student the end goal of ministry. As I’ve said throughout this book, the goal of adoptive youth ministry is to create an environment where young people are encouraged to live into their calling in Christ as agents of the kingdom within the household of God.
To achieve that goal, we need to drop macro-platitudes, roll up our sleeves, and create a micro-growth plan for each individual young person at every stage in their ministry journey. Adoptive empowerment isn’t some kind of pixie dust we sprinkle on a group of kids. It requires a laser-like focus on welcoming, including, nurturing, and repeatedly empowering youth to contribute to this community in a way that will enhance the body while encouraging their growth.
Adoptive ministry may use the traditional tools of youth ministry (youth groups, small groups), but the long-term goal is creating a plan to lead young people toward ever-greater levels of maturity and contribution within God’s family.
Empowerment Is Incremental
Wouldn’t it be easy if everyone was the same and grew at the same rate? Such assumptions have supported massive public education programs that impose standardized learning outcomes on all the different age groups of kids.
Such standardized outcomes weren’t ideal for me. If you could go back to the time when I was a gangly sixteen-year-old and ask my parents, my siblings, or my high school friends where they thought I would end up in life, none would have predicted graduate school professor. I wasn’t much of a student. I only ended up at Fuller Seminary as a master’s student in theology because of my passion to be on Young Life staff. Young Life made me go to Fuller (like they did all their staff for over three decades).
Who knew I would end up not only loving theological study but also loving to pass that passion on to others? Before that, my road was a winding, up-and-down journey for the first twenty-five years of my life.
That’s the case for many young people in today’s disrupted economy. The activities they’re interested in and good at as teenagers may have little to do with what they end up devoting their lives to. Along the way we all go through fits and starts, detours and U-turns. Growth is incremental.
While schools impose standardized learning outcomes, churches often do something similar by trying to fit people into a series of standardized measures of spiritual growth. But often spiritual growth occurs in baby steps that can’t be measured. Chuck Swindoll understood this, titling his classic book on discipleship Three Steps Forward, Two Steps Back.
To empower our young to contribute to the community of siblings, we need to allow them and assist them to move at their own pace. The Growing Young authors describe this as “keychain leadership.”
Adoptive empowerment does not mean handing over the keys to someone who doesn’t know what keys are, or what they unlock. We don’t simply hand keys to young people and walk away. We walk alongside them as they take baby steps, grow, and learn how to use keys. Empowerment means we assume a high view of each person’s abilities and giftedness in Christ and help create baby steps that allow them to move toward greater maturity.
For example, if a sophomore in high school, or even an eighth grader, shows interest and promise in what missions can do for people in your congregation, an appropriate baby step could be inviting her to observe the planning team for a trip she would probably be interested in joining. Just by being invited to sit at the table, she has been affirmed and shown that her presence matters.
Granted, this may look like participation rather than contribution, but it is a start. As the meetings progress, adults (or the whole team) who are watching out for her growth and journey may see a unique piece of the planning process where she shows interest or insight. At that point, the student could be invited to join an adult or small subgroup in working on that planning.
In some cases, young people who are given such opportunities rise to the occasion and demonstrate unusual maturity. In other cases, they flake out or disappear. This is consistent with the nature of adolescents in transition, so you need to prepare adults for the occasional flameout. But don’t let these defections lead adults to conclude that all kids lack interest or maturity. Adults need to be the grown-ups, continuing to offer relational support and stability. At the same time, accountability should always be practiced in a nurturing and encouraging environment. Don’t let the “two steps back” stop your church or team from continuing to both believe in and move toward empowering each and every young person.
Empowerment Is Intentional
The final point to make is that adults must take responsibility to be the driving initiators of relationship and interaction. This is one of those realities that few adults get, and even the ones who get it don’t like it!
When students or emerging adults believe that adults perceive them as unreliable or disengaged, surprisingly many will default by living more deeply into that negative perception. Young people may hate being stereotyped, but their attitudes and behavior can easily fulfill the stereotypes. In this way, young people become their own worst enemies, frustrating efforts toward greater participation and contribution.
But there is more to the story. Nearly all young people desperately want to be part of something bigger than themselves, and their intent is to be seen as valuable and committed. Adults who work with adolescents and young adults have to be trained to recognize this vocational paradox, and not to be deterred by it.
Making Empowerment Intentional
If empowerment happened naturally, everyone would be empowered! But it doesn’t, and we often need to believe the best about young people, even when their behavior may not affirm or support it.
That’s why leaders committed to helping empower students need to be intentional in three ways: communication, affirmation, and support.
Intentional Communication
An important marker of maturity is to communicate well with others. When we’re walking with those who are in developmental transition, we are the ones who need to keep lines of communication open.
Early in my ministry I was taught the value of “short accounts” and timely engagement. This means that when I’m leading a group and I become disappointed or confused about the way a student has behaved, it is up to me to move as swiftly as possible to find out what is going on and why.
In the meantime, while we’re working at the intersection of nurturing young people and empowering them, we must work to ensure that our questions and style of communication are not confrontational or shaming. This is a learned skill that, frankly, many adults have not learned or practiced, so leaders must train the team. This correcting and training is best done face-to-face, or with rare exceptions, on the phone. Email and texting are the worst modes for communicating a perceived failure or misunderstanding. The key is to maintain a relational closeness to a young person so that even when they fail or flake out, they know that their leader/mentor is consistent and trustworthy enough that they can be open and honest about their misstep.
Ministry is important, but people matter more than any task. This is one of those affective aspects of guiding and mentoring that is essential in helping a young person mature to the point of contribution. If a seventeen-year-old knows that he is more important than the duty to pick up the coffee for the parent meeting, he can survive setbacks and continue on with his growth and service.
Intentional Support
Sometimes young people simply need time and space away from ministry or even church for a while. This can be due to a variety of circumstances, and how we handle their distance from church-related things will often determine how or whether the student will reengage in the future.
Our job is to seek the very best for all students, communicate well, and make sure they know that our support for them is absolute. Sometimes that means trying to help them work through the timing and consequences of stepping away from something they agreed to do. Hopefully, we can help them find a way to get the time and space they need without hurting others. Our attitude and spirit in such cases can make all the difference in their long-term growth.
I learned about a relevant case study at a recent pastors’ conference. One pastor lamented an experience that still clearly bugged him. He had “allowed” (his word) a young college student to run a Saturday service project. A week before the event the young man bailed on him via text: “I am so overwhelmed, I just can’t do it. I’m sure you’ll find someone else to take it, but I will not be at the service project.” The pastor tried to “hold him accountable” via text, and he let the young man know how “disappointed” he was in his choice.
I invited the gathered pastors to respond, making suggestions about what the pastor could have done differently. For example, the pastor could have met face-to-face with the young person within hours of the first text. That would have reflected both pastoral concern and programmatic integrity. Others wondered if the pastor had developed a meaningful relationship with the student before this episode.
It’s obvious that we don’t want to encourage irresponsibility when we invite young people to contribute. But we need to be careful how we respond to them when they fail to perform as we wish. Our aim must be to offer young people support.
Making Empowerment Practical: Creating a Youth Advisory Board
Too many leaders still think the goal is participation. But participation is weak when compared with true contribution. If your ministry practices adoptive empowerment, odds are your group will be full of young people who go to bed at night thinking, “I made a difference today, and I was an important part of my church family. Thanks, Jesus!”
There are as many ways to empower young people to contribute as there are churches. But the various approaches have one thing in common. When we offer opportunities with intention, warmth, and consistent nurturing presence, young people will feel like they matter to the family of God.
In closing this chapter, I want to offer one concrete step a church can take. It’s simple, straightforward, and requires no programming. All that’s needed is a bit of courage, some initiative, and leadership consistency to encourage young people to rise to the occasion.
Here’s my suggestion: create an advisory board for the preaching ministry of the church made up entirely of young people.
Let’s face it. Few high school students or recent grads deeply resonate with the sermons they hear on Sundays. But the Fuller Youth Institute’s College Transition Project found that of those young people who held on to faith, a major factor they cited was that they “liked church” when they were in high school.
That’s why I believe every church should invite sixteen- to twenty-year-olds to be a part of a group that helps the preaching pastor or teaching team engage them and hear their concerns. A church can invite a few kids to do this, or enlist a much larger contingent. The number of students doesn’t matter so long as they are willing to do four things:
When I mention this to pastors, some balk, many are nervous, but most are so grateful to have the chance to get to know their students at this level.
I am honest. I tell pastors that if they are really open, young people may occasionally be brutally honest, and even sometimes unfair. But in a very short time, they will grow into a greater appreciation of the role of preaching and teaching in a church. The added benefit? These kids will not only know that their voices are being heard and they are being taken seriously, but they will also likely end up being among the best friends a senior pastor has ever had in a congregant.
Adoptive youth ministry must find ways not only to nurture the young but to intentionally, proactively, and enthusiastically encourage and empower them to contribute to the mission of God. The word empower means “to impart power.” That requires someone who has power to hand off that power. Empowerment is what helps an adolescent build a sense of self and healthy autonomy. Empowerment also encourages a sense of purpose, a necessary aspect to interdependent adulthood. And the most important reason we empower our young to participate and contribute? We need them!
