11. Adoptive Youth Ministry and the Challenge of Change
11
Adoptive Youth Ministry and the Challenge of Change
Fundamentally, Christ intends that the pastoral office facilitate the spiritual growth of the community so that all can engage in the common task (Eph. 4:12). To this end, pastors keep up for the people the vision of community life embodied in the biblical narrative.
—Stanley Grenz, Created for Community
When I talk to youth workers and churches about embracing adoptive youth ministry, most seem excited, at least initially. Then come the doubts and reservations.
“Chap,” they say, “you just don’t know what I’m dealing with.” Then follows a litany of complaints about elders, deacons, boards or sessions, parents, older church members, or occasionally the senior pastor.
“We don’t have any power to change things or embrace a new approach without starting World War III,” they say, signaling defeat and sometimes despair.
But you don’t need to overhaul your entire congregation in order to integrate adoptive youth ministry into your work with young people. As Fuller Seminary leadership professor Scott Cormode has shown, even youth workers who are relatively low on the ecclesiastical organizational chart can play an important part in bringing about transformation. “Christian leadership is fundamentally an act of theological interpretation,” writes Cormode. “A Christian leader today leads by shaping the ways that God’s people interpret everything going on in their worlds.”
Do you ever think of yourself as a theologian or a theological interpreter? You may not, but in fact you are! Youth workers not only interpret Scripture to their students, but they also help adults in the church understand how the truths of Scripture connect with young believers.
You can help shape the way that God’s people understand young people and their spiritual needs. To do that, you first need to understand why so many people have so many problems with change of any kind.
Confronting the Challenge of Change
Why are so many people so resistant to change? Scott Cormode says the proposed changes themselves are not the whole problem. “People don’t resist change, they resist loss,” he writes, “and to understand longing and loss is to understand how people are not only wired but how they can change.”
Even when we want the new things change brings, we struggle to resist the stranglehold that old things have us in. Sure, millions of us appreciate Amazon’s discounts and algorithms when it means we can buy a new book for less money. But at the same time, we miss the old bookstore we used to go to and the helpful workers there who always managed to make personal recommendations that we loved.
We tend to fear losing those things we have relied on in the past to bring order, meaning, and comfort to our lives. Our longings for meaning and order often drive our fear, resentment, and need for control. And these powerful longings sometimes play an even stronger role in church settings, where proposals to change anything will be interpreted by some as a declaration of ecclesial war. (Ask me sometime and I will show you my battle scars!)
There are four main reasons change can be a bigger challenge for church folks than for others. The better you understand these reasons, the better you can address them.
Volunteers and Donors Who Feel They “Own” the Church
Most churches are volunteer-run and volunteer-supported organizations that depend on people choosing to stay involved. This means those who devote the time and those who write the checks tend to accumulate power. That power can express itself in emotive ways when someone like you comes along and threatens to upset the applecart.
It’s understandable that believers who have devoted years of their lives and many thousands of their dollars to support the congregation will seek to protect it from harm. Unfortunately, they often see change as harmful, even when it’s desperately needed.
Their position is clear, even though they may not always state it this boldly: “This is our church. We built it and we paid for it. Don’t you dare mess with it!”
I was helping a church develop a strategic plan when a fight broke out over one of the words I used. It wasn’t a swear word, or a heretical word, but a cultural word: video. The offending word was in a report I handed out.
“For years I have put my hard-earned money into this church, and nobody is going to come along and put up screens in my sanctuary!” one elder hollered during a discussion about how the church was dying and needed to reach younger people.
What had I done to incite such possessiveness and anger? I must have evoked some powerful fear of a world out of control. For better or worse, technology has upended our world in unsettling ways. This elder didn’t want to unleash this chaotic force in “his” comfortable sanctuary.
“You raise an important question,” I said. “Whose church is it, anyway?”
Key volunteers and donors deserve respect and praise, but they don’t “own” the church. Christ does.
Members Who Want the Church to Honor Their Longings
Some people invest their time and treasure in churches out of a sense of service or calling. Other people connect with churches because they need the warm feelings it gives them. They want “to belong, find a place to share one’s gifts, and be valued,” writes Christine Pohl, professor of Christian social ethics at Asbury Seminary.
Churches are challenging environments for change because people go to church so they can satisfy their deep human longings for community and connection. This may mean they feel “closer to God” when they hear handbells, but don’t you dare play a guitar. Even though it has been over half a century since Larry Norman first strummed his six-string, the worship wars over music styles continue in many congregations. Why? Because people come to church hoping to relieve their fears and struggles from the outside world. Many members may be considered “part of the community,” but in their minds they may feel more connection to a tight-knit, like-minded subgroup that shares their perspectives and values. They feel safe within the relational walls of “their” church, which is the one place that shouldn’t challenge or interfere with their longings.
One important note here: Young people are not the only ones who often feel like outsiders in a congregation. Senior adults, single and divorced people, ethnic minorities, people with disabilities, even those who do not live in the neighborhood may feel like the church is being taken or kept from them. Adoptive ministry is the call to include any people who feel displaced or disenfranchised. This adds an additional challenge to adoptive youth ministry. It is not just young people who deserve our nurture, empowerment, and inclusion. It is everybody.
Bondage to History
Institutions are shaped by their history. Therefore, history—including everything from informal use of power to programmatic structure and style of operation, and everything that goes on in making a given church community unique to itself—is a powerful force to be reckoned with. Harvard’s Robert Putnam explains, “Whatever other factors may affect their form, institutions have inertia and ‘robustness.’ They therefore embody historical trajectories and turning points. History matters because it is ‘path dependent’: what comes first (even if it was in some sense ‘accidental’) conditions what comes later. Individuals may ‘choose’ their institutions, but they do not choose them under circumstances of their own making, and their choices in turn influence the rules within which their successors choose.”
Tradition is important, but you can tell history plays a crippling role in a congregation if you regularly hear comments like these:
The first uses history to discount new thinking or approaches. The second appeals to a church’s supposed corporate narrative to close discussion on any approach that hasn’t already been confirmed. Either way, the goal is to stop any change that threatens the community’s historical narrative.
It Takes Work!
Churches are, after all, volunteer organizations. Typically, volunteer organizations try to fulfill their calling by doing what needs to be done when it needs to be done—then they want to be done with it! Phrases like “We’ve always done it this way” are not only indicators of fear of losing what people hold dear but also express a fear of changing what we already have figured out and know. To change is to wrestle, to explore, to risk. And this takes work: emotional work, physical work, and even spiritual work. Most people come to church to receive comfort and solace, not to be challenged to roll up their sleeves.
But the world has changed. And in many ways, for many of us, the church has not—at least not in the ways that matter, such as theologically and strategically. Ministries and programs traditionally have been fostered by creative, energetic people who genuinely care. But over time these programs control who we are and how we operate, even if they do not actually help us to achieve our calling to become God’s adoptive household! In a changing context, with generations being increasingly marginalized and ignored, the church must change. If we intend to even somewhat reflect the kind of family that the Bible describes, we have no choice but to reflect more carefully on what it means for us to be and live into our calling as God’s children together.
As an old illustration reminds us, laying bricks takes work, but building a cathedral takes calling. Creating an adoptive church, where every disconnected and marginalized person has the opportunity to be embraced, nurtured, and empowered by those at the center, is our charge. Yes, it takes time and conversation and careful biblical reflection. It also, then, takes baby steps to retool strategies and programs that align with our calling. Yet it is our privilege, and ultimately our joy, when we find ourselves growing more closely together, with greater appreciation for and understanding of one another. In the long run the work of ministry is not work at all; it is a life-giving gift of God when we allow ourselves to be careful and supportive of all members of our family.
Being an Effective Change Agent (Even When You’re Not in Charge)
Reader, do not despair! While opposition to change is common, each congregation seems to have a few brave souls who believe new wine calls for new wineskins.
I just showed you how efforts to change things can backfire in some churches. Now let me show you how change can work effectively to bring new life to churches that struggle. Let me show what it might look like to bring change to any congregation, community, or organization in a healthy and theologically sound way.
If you were the chieftain of your own corporate kingdom, you could hire and fire at will. Things are different in Christ’s body. For one thing, all members are created in the image of God and deserve your kindness and empathy, including those who are most resistant to change.
In dealing with hard-core obstructionists, the goal is not to force, coerce, or manipulate. The church belongs to God and God alone, and the veterans are siblings as much as the newcomers are. Adoptive ministry is about the family of Christ, so let’s make sure everything we do is consistent with the kind of committed and selfless love Christ exhibited.
There are two basic ways to change any social system or structure. The most common—and often most painful—is mechanical or technical change, meaning you bring in an expert to “fix” a problem (like you find a mechanic when your car is broken).
That works for some challenges, but other, more complex problems require adaptive change. As Scott Cormode puts it, “Adaptive challenges happen when we ask people to adopt new beliefs, when we hope people will pursue better values, or when we help people see that the ways that they have been doing things in the past will not work for them. Well, that’s the job description for ministry.”
I have found four approaches that promote change in healthy ways. Let’s take a look.
Seek Leadership Buy-In
I was sitting in on one church’s tense monthly staff scheduling meeting when the pastor saw me involuntarily raise my eyebrows.
“Yes, Chap?” he asked.
“I was wondering if it had occurred to anyone what the connection was between Philippians 2:1–4 and the conversation at hand?”
Most of the staff knew their Bibles enough to know the text discussed unity. One person decided to read the passage. Then they looked back to me for interpretation.
“What would it mean for you all if each department decided to fight for the interests of another department?” I asked.
The mood changed as one person after another offered compromise that allowed the task at hand to be finished within minutes.
There are many ways to bring senior leadership into the adoptive conversation. The place to begin is with the theological question of who we are as the body of Christ, not what youth ministry needs to do or how to get senior adults and kids to like each other. Our starting point is God’s intent for all of us.
After all, John 1:12 and Paul’s use of “adoption to sonship” five times (Rom. 8:15, 23; 9:4; Gal. 4:5; Eph. 1:5) become crystal clear once someone sees it. It is impossible to discount the importance of Jesus’s words in John 15, especially verses 1–17: “I am the vine; you [all] are the branches. . . . Apart from me you can do nothing. . . . My command is this: Love each other.”
The only thing really new about adoptive youth ministry is the phrase “adoptive youth ministry”! The basic theological premise of adoptive ministry is thoroughly biblical and ultimately straightforward. The challenge is reenvisioning everything we do and are in the direction of what God has called us to be. That is adoptive ministry.
As staff and lay leaders in your congregation warm up to the goal of God’s people working out their life together in community so as to be fully prepared and free to participate in the mission of God in the world, the next step in designing an adoptive youth ministry is inviting a congregation or community to simply live into that truth with kids. This book encourages those in positions of power to invite, include, nurture, and empower those on the fringes to join them in God’s mission, internally and externally—this is at the core of the adoptive ministry model. Again, the first step of making adoptive youth ministry a reality is to convince congregational leadership that youth ministry, and ultimately every ministry, is grounded in a commitment to the whole church body. Once the team is on that same theological page, the real fun begins.
Create a Shared Lexicon
Words matter. As George Orwell said: “If thought corrupts language, language can also corrupt thought.” Orwell was lamenting poor writing, but his insight reaches far beyond that. When we use words, we connect an idea we have with an idea in someone else’s head. Words are the hooks on which shared ideas, or mental models, hang. Our common use of words is what shapes our shared understanding.
If you want to bring change to a community, introduce new words or phrases to the group’s commonly shared lexicon. (You can also use current words and phrases in a new way, but that’s a subtler change and in some ways more difficult to pull off.) Churches love to say things like “community” on a regular basis—in sermons, during prayer, in a weekly email. Your job is to explore and explain what community really means. This should be your first step in training those who are involved with your ministry, but talk to others about the idea too. Ask them to reflect on and write down words or phrases that come to mind to convey community within every ministry—singles, seniors, children, and so on.
What you will be doing is creating a commonly held lexicon of words and phrases that draw together everyone’s idea about what this means for you. The next step is to make a fairly short list of key words and a phrase or two that everyone agrees will be the way you all describe what adoptive ministry is.
The church where I am currently serving largely shares my commitment to creating a stronger sense of community across a large and generationally separated congregation. For several years many of the leaders have been deeply engaged in my work and the Fuller Youth Institute, especially Hurt 2.0, Sticky Faith, and now Growing Young. The next step we have taken as a staff is to come up with words and phrases that match our aim. Here are some of them:
Now every time we do anything that uses words, we try to throw in at least one of these. A week ago, during a prayer at our midweek dinner, our middle school director mentioned our “adoptive family.” In the announcements last Sunday, an associate pastor said, “This week we’re going to swap name tags so we can pray for our fellow siblings we just met.” As the weeks and months go by, the congregation is not only getting used to hearing these (and other) words and phrases, but they are starting to use them with each other. We have only begun this process, but we can see a shared lexicon emerging just from this one simple strategy.
Share Narratives
Stories are powerful tools for adjusting our mental models of what it means to be God’s people together. Set the example by talking about adoptive community in action. Show how New Testament descriptions of early congregations provide a blueprint for community. Then connect the dots to biblical forms of ministry you see taking place in your own congregation.
Occasionally when someone reads the powerful descriptions of the church in the first four chapters of the book of Acts, you may hear members saying, “People don’t want that kind of community!” But God created us to find our home in his household. Whether people know it or not is a different issue. Our job is not to convince people to begin to move toward something that is foreign to their souls, or even their longings. Often they just don’t know how much they crave familial connection.
And don’t forget: you don’t work alone. The Holy Spirit is in the business of prompting followers of Jesus toward intimate community. It’s what God does. Our job is to simply do our best to respond to that prompting.
Stories are a powerful way to show even the most fearful that the kind of community the Bible talks about is already happening here.
Martha can’t help herself, she just cares for young people. When there is a birthday, she’s the one to bring the cake. When a teenager seems down, Martha’s note arrives the next day (not email or text, mind you—the real deal, and nothing says to a young person I really do care than a handwritten note in the mail!). Her reputation is widespread. In a church of over a thousand people Martha is renowned for knowing almost every middle schooler, teenager, and emerging adult—not only their names, but their stories. When asked about why she does what she does, she scoffs and replies, “You would do the same thing, especially if you got to know them like I do.” And that’s the key. Martha has a heart not to “do ministry” but to know and care for young people. Welcome to the adoptive church.
I recently mentioned Martha from the pulpit so a few thousand people could hear it (I reluctantly got her permission). When I mentioned her, and she received applause, Martha was mostly embarrassed, but later told me she was also a bit saddened. “I’m not special, they belong to me, and I to them, so I just love them. Doesn’t everybody?” Martha’s story, once told, helped others to begin to see themselves, their church, and their young people differently. The church is a long way from the exemplar adoptive church, but at least we’re on the journey to loving the vulnerable, the lost, the young, and the outsider.
Experiment on the Edges
Narratives like Martha’s can help show how an adoptive ministry approach works for one person, but building an adoptive church takes strategy and intentionality. Relational strategies are essential, but strategic and intentionally designed programming must be instituted to bring about lasting change.
The best way to move forward while avoiding the skepticism or criticism from the masses is to experiment on the margins, where there is little ownership (and interference) from those not directly involved or impacted. You can work the margins in two major ways: the invisible and the temporary.
Invisible, off-the-radar programs and events offer some of the most radical, unexpected, and innovative opportunities, all without disrupting normal schedules or budgets. For example, you could encourage an existing small group of high school guys to take on a few shut-in seniors from the church as their own grandparents for a semester as a replacement for their group meetings. This would likely not be on anyone’s radar (except for parents, who should be included in the planning). Such experiments allow you to learn from both the young men’s and the seniors’ experiences. If successful, the experiment can be tweaked, expanded, and gradually embraced by the entire church.
Temporary events or programs have benefits that the off-the-grid programs do not, but they also carry greater risks. The benefits include the opportunity to bring awareness to the intentionality of exploring deeper familial relationships in a community and to broaden the buy-in for the event itself as well as demonstrating the value of trying new things in general. Any public and open experiment should be gently introduced in a way that reassures members that the church they love will not be too radically altered. The key is to make sure to connect the experiment to the intention to strengthen familial ties with one another.
For example, the introduction of “family meals” once a month, with a commitment to doing it well so that all intended participants enjoy it, is a good example of where this strategy works well. In contrast, I have seen church staff use the rationale of intergenerational community to add drums to a “traditional” service, when this kind of experiment has little if anything to do with relationally connecting people.
The risks of a creative or unique event or program should be carefully considered before moving too fast or too far. When an experiment fails or is not well received, the ability to tweak it for a second event is diminished, if not scuttled. Sometimes, public experimental initiatives actually backfire and make things worse for the community. One church, after hearing a speaker share the story of his church, decided to push their congregation into greater intimacy by lengthening services and adding a coffee break between singing and the sermon. They promoted the idea as something they were going to try for a month. After two weeks, so many people in the congregation were upset with the plan that they called a special meeting and threatened to fire the staff person leading the charge.
I suggest you do both: experiment with all-church one-time events and programs that keep the issue of communal, familial integration at the forefront of the congregation’s image of what church is, while also exploring nonthreatening but outside-the-box programmatic options that can eventually be integrated into the church’s regular practice.
As you do all three with care and communication where necessary, continually reinforcing the corporate lexicon and sharing the stories of how people are enjoying walking through life and faith together, you will see the adoptive family begin to emerge. Take baby steps, don’t push too hard, and communicate well what you’re doing and why.
Resources to Convince the Unconvinced
As we move forward with a commitment to live more fully into our adoptive family in Christ, many resources are available to us to help people embrace this move.
Spiritual Discipline of Discernment
While this may seem like a strange use of the term resource, theologically that is what a spiritual discipline is. God has provided for us in our freedom (Gal. 5:1) what are often called “practices” that assist us in placing ourselves into a position to receive the grace, power, and transformation that God has for us. Spiritual disciplines are best understood, then, not as “have tos” but as “get tos.” Spiritual disciplines are “gifts that channel” faith and “rhythms of the Spirit.” Since any effort we make to enter into and embody our mutual adoption in Christ as community is the work of the Spirit, our “discipline” is to see our efforts as a way to channel that faith through prayer, Spirit-led conversation, and Spirit-empowered discernment. This is God’s mission we are aligning with, and therefore as we stay fixed on a careful reading of Scripture and a sincere commitment to listening to the Spirit together, we can move forward with confidence that this is where God is leading our community.
Outside People Who Can Tell Us What We Cannot Say or Hear Ourselves
The idea of adoptive youth ministry did not emerge in a vacuum. Many others are exploring the same basic concept of seeing youth ministry through the lens of the church instead of as a stand-alone commitment of adult believers. The term adoptive ministry, while being used in limited circles, is not yet well known, but the driving idea behind “intergenerational ministry” has taken center stage with many youth ministry and other ecclesial leaders. One of the most important reasons, and strategies, for bringing in outside preachers and seminars is to invite them to speak into issues that a staff person or even senior pastor may not easily be able to. As someone who has done that for years on behalf of youth and family ministry, it is rather interesting to me that people can be deeply moved by an outsider about something their own preacher said only a month before with little response.
The only reason to bring in someone from the outside is to reinforce a way of thinking or living that you have already been led to pursue. So obviously, who you bring in is just as important as what they say. The place you insert them—whether it is preaching in a service, offering a seminar to parents and others, or consulting with the lay leadership—also should be strategic and purposeful.
Other Materials That Can Foster Conversation
Lastly, do not discount any other source of input that can be used as a catalyst for further conversation. A ten-minute podcast that a small group of leaders listen to can spark a month-long discussion bringing about creative systemic change. Providing a chapter of a book (but be sure you buy the copies of everything you hand out even in copy form—the law and Christian ethics are very clear on that one!) for a Sunday school class, a group of staff, or a parents’ group can lead to new ways of thinking and greater willingness to ask hard questions.
Strategies to Convince the Unconvinced
Strategy, by definition, is a hierarchical term that implies one person or party seeking to change another person or party. In seeking to be “strategic” in helping others recognize and then respond to the call of the gospel to a community, it is important to understand how much people resist someone treating them like a problem to be fixed or a puzzle to be solved. Our goal in leading a church or organization to change how it thinks about and serves young people is to engage in the process of moving people to the point of being willing to look at something they might otherwise ignore in order to eventually embrace what this might mean for everyone involved. Yet people do not want to be subject to a strategy, and when they feel that they are, they resist and flee.
While we may believe that we are not responsible for someone else’s defensiveness, how we approach people whom we are asking to consider change can make a difference in how they receive not only our message but also us as people. Research into the ways that people receive new and potentially difficult ideas has revealed behaviors and attitudes that generally promote a defensive reaction from a recipient of a message. Researcher Jack Gibb details these in what he labels six behaviors (or attitudes) that create a “Defensive Climate”:
While most people will blame defensiveness on the “other,” more than likely if any one of these behaviors or attitudes is picked up by a person, then, all things being equal, their reaction will be defensive. So, although “strategy” is one of the six behaviors that can elicit a defensive response, our best course is to seek to avoid these by doing the opposite of each behavior.
The Scriptures address this same issue this way: “Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect” (1 Pet. 3:15). It is not our job to convince someone how to think, even in leadership in the church. It is our job to be faithful to the gospel as both Scripture and the Holy Spirit reveal, and to present our thoughts in a way that is neither manipulative nor arrogant. We are called to be gentle and respectful, even with those whom we believe are dead wrong.
These “strategies,” then, are how we present our perspective when given the platform or opportunity to help people see who we all are in Christ and what it means to live as the church as mutually adopted siblings.
The Power of Casual Conversations
Consider a person who you believe may stand in the way of substantive change in how your church looks at and treats teenagers and young adults. Even before speaking with them, you might feel that they would not be open to thinking or behaving differently than how the church has in the past. With anyone who you believe is an important player in making a systemic shift in how we think about and serve the young, the first objective is to seek them out in safe, reflective conversation.
I have come to picture persuasion as sitting with someone with whom I may have a disagreement, and it is my job to convince her of something. Typically, when we get the opportunity to discuss something important with a person we believe is (or even could be) an adversary, we think of a dialogue as a debate where both parties take turns making their case to an unknown crowd from separate podiums. Even if we were to use the imagery of a conversation, we might only change the venue and audience slightly by picturing ourselves and the other on different sides of a picnic table. Still, we might approach the conversation as a back-and-forth, tit-for-tat, two-person debate on the given merits of our positions.
At the end of the day, the worst form of communication and persuasion is the one-way, “I’m right, you’re wrong” approach. So even with your most vocal opponent, your best way to create a productive dialogue—and hopefully bring the opportunity for growth and change for both of you—is to get up from your side of the picnic table and take a seat alongside your friend. Then look at each other as you listen and share, with conviction, what you think matters—especially when Jesus is brought into the middle of the relationship as well as the conversation.
