Chapter 20 of 22

Appendix Adoptive Church 101

Appendix Adoptive Church 101

Appendix

Adoptive Church 101

You probably have never heard the phrase “adoptive ministry.” It is not a common way to talk about ministry. The word adoption is usually used to refer to an adult or a couple who searches for and adopts a child into their family. At first glance “adoptive ministry,” and especially “adoptive youth ministry,” would imply that our job in the church is to “adopt” kids. Frankly, that’s how I first thought of it. But after sharing the idea with others and spending time thinking about it, I came to see that adoption in the Bible primarily refers to God adopting us as we trust in Jesus (John 1:12). So what you will see throughout this book is a perspective on ministry that begins with God’s gift of adoption to everyone who calls on him by faith. Adoptive ministry, then, is how we learn to live into this reality.

As you read this book, there might be words, phrases, or ideas that you may not remember from a previous section, or that may simply not make sense to you. (That happens to me a lot when I read a book, and I do this for a living!) So keep these pages handy if you get a little lost in key concepts or terms, or run across a word or phrase that throws you. Think of it like the glossary in a technical book from school—as a helpful way to keep things straight.

Three Key Concepts/Characteristics of an Adoptive Church

  • Adoptive ministry is a way of thinking about ministry as encouraging a community of people who have been adopted into God’s household to intentionally live that out together as his children.
  • Adoptive ministry encourages those who feel like they are already included in the local family (usually called “the church”) to be the ones to build bridges of welcome and participation to those who might not feel connected or valued.
  • Adoptive ministry takes seriously two essential commitments: to nurture those who need guidance and care, and to empower those who generally do not participate in and contribute to the life of the whole body.
  • Biblical Foundations of an Adoptive Church

  • “Yet to all who did receive him, to those who believed in his name, he gave the right to become children of God” (John 1:12; notice the move from the singular “to all” to the plural “children”).
  • “For he chose us in him before the creation of the world to be holy and blameless in his sight. In love he predestined us for adoption to sonship through Jesus Christ, in accordance with his pleasure and will” (Eph. 1:4–5; “adoption to sonship” is a technical term including males and females).
  • “But when the set time had fully come, God sent his Son, born of a woman, born under the law, to redeem those under the law, that we might receive adoption to sonship. Because you are his children, God sent the Spirit of his Son into our hearts, the Spirit who calls out, ‘Abba, Father’” (Gal. 4:4–6; notice the plural “you”).
  • Three other texts where Paul uses this same phrase “adopted to sonship” (Greek, huiothesia): Romans 8:15, 23; 9:4.
  • Texts where our life together is described as a family:

    Matthew 12:46–50

    Galatians 6:10

    Ephesians 2:19

    1 Thessalonians 4:10

    1 Timothy 3:15

    Hebrews 2:10–12

    1 Peter 2:27; 5:9

  • The Old Testament is about “God’s people,” and as such living as “children of God” is the theme throughout. There are particular texts, however, that directly point to this idea (this is just a sampling):

    Exodus 4:22

    Deuteronomy 14:1; 27:9; 28:10

    2 Samuel 7:14

    1 Chronicles 22:7–10; 28:6

    Psalm 82:6

    Isaiah 43:6; 63:8, 16

    Jeremiah 3:19; 31:9

    Hosea 1:9–10; 11:1

  • New Testament texts referring to the teachings on “one another” (this is just a sampling):

    Romans 12:10, 16; 13:8; 14:3; 15:7, 14

    1 Corinthians 1:10

    2 Corinthians 3:11

    Galatians 5:13

    Ephesians 4:2, 32; 5:19, 21

    Philippians 2:1–11

    Colossians 3:13–16

    1 Thessalonians 4:9, 18; 5:11

    Hebrews 3:13; 10:24–25; 13:1

    1 Peter (the whole book)

    1 John (the whole book)

  • Why Adoptive Ministry Is an Important Grounding for Youth Ministry

    I believe that youth ministry needs a biblical grounding and trajectory to base our work and practices on. As young people come to faith in Christ, their greatest chance at making the relationship last is ultimately to discover that the church is their home on earth. The Bible is clear that we are alone, or even orphaned, until we turn our lives around and come to sincere faith in Jesus Christ. When we come to faith, we are given the “right to become” God’s children (John 1:12). That means we move from being alone to being in a new family. This family is what God has intended from the beginning. He is our heavenly parent, we now call him “Father” (Abba), and we are also siblings with everybody else who trusts in Christ. Lots of people, especially young people, who come to faith in Christ remain alone. They may give their life to Christ and grow to trust him, but they may never know that the Christian journey is meant to be lived in community. Thus, adoptive ministry is a way to ensure we keep at the forefront the fact that we all belong together and need each other to help us live into that truth.

    Going Deeper

    In Christian circles we use words like body, community, and fellowship. In bringing adopted siblings into the mix of that language, we become more aware of the depth of relationship that God has for us and has called us to. To go deeper in examining ideas related to adoptive ministry, I suggest you read the work of Christian forebears who wrote extensively on Christian community. On the pages of their works, you’ll see glimpses of “adoptive ministry” described long before the term was ever circulated. My favorites are Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Karl Barth, Jean Vanier, Henri J. M. Nouwen, and Dallas Willard.

    Questions That Have Come Up regarding Adoptive Ministry

    As I finalized this work on adoptive youth ministry, I sent the draft manuscript to a select group of people I know and trust to get their take. Did it make sense? Was my logic clear? And most important, is this book a helpful resource to move the church to reflect on how it thinks about and treats the young?

    Of all the comments (and there were many), one person in particular took the time to dig in to the heart of the matter. In our back-and-forth, I came to see how his impressions of the book were perhaps what others, maybe many others, might see as they read. So, after adding a few thoughts and with this friend’s agreement, I include this conversation here to make as clear as possible my ideas for adoptive ministry. While this is not our verbatim conversation, this represents what my friend was interested in talking about.

    Adoption as a Grounding Concept

    Friend: Thanks for sending the manuscript. I do believe that it has potential for making a significant impact on youth ministry and on the church. But I do have some questions, more perhaps “wonderings,” that I’d like to discuss with you.

    My biggest wondering is about your adoption metaphor. I wonder if you have been as clear as you want to be. I ask this for three reasons: (1) it will help the reader know exactly what you mean; (2) it will help the reader understand how this is a call for a philosophical shift (otherwise they’ll keep saying, “Oh, I do that already”); and (3) it’ll also clarify your applications in the later chapters.

    Chap: Thanks for this. First, it is not my metaphor, it’s Paul’s. The idea of who we are as adopted siblings just hasn’t been applied in the church regarding those on the outside of the dominant center of a church community (which is one major reason I believe he used the metaphor, to bring unity to a fracturing church).

    Also, adoptive ministry is less of a shift and more of a trajectory, or target. When we pursue what we call “intergenerational” ministry, often we are talking more about a program or strategy than a theological outcome or even reason for it. In contrast, that is what adoptive youth ministry is. To me youth ministry has seemed to not be as concerned with the outcome of our ministry as inclusion in, and being embedded within, the body of Christ. Even if we are working to make sure adults take kids more seriously and include them in ministry opportunities, if we don’t have a driving theological rationale that leads us to seek that for every young person, we will invite the young to Christ without offering them inclusion in the family that God has for them. That’s what adoptive youth ministry is about.

    Adoption as a Metaphor

    Friend: What is the opposite of “adopted”? You suggest that it is “orphaned.” Is that true? If so, who has been “orphaned”? And how have we/they been orphaned?

    Chap: Theologically, we have all been orphaned by and through the fall and in our own participation in it. It is, as James Dunn puts it, “the decisive and universal character of man’s fall.” Thus, as a consequence, sin results in what Dietrich Bonhoeffer called “a concept of separation.”

    Friend: Can we adopt each other if we’re siblings? Don’t parents adopt?

    Chap: “Adoptive ministry” does not replace the family, but it describes the family and household of God. So yes, parents adopt. In the church we don’t theologically adopt each other. Rather, we encourage one another as adopted siblings (John 1:12).

    Friend: Does adoption have any definition beyond a relational one? Is there a legal one? What is the difference between God adopting, a parent adopting, or a community adopting?

    Chap: God adopting us is the gift of the incarnation. Parents adopting a child is bringing them into a social family unit, which is a different application of the notion of adoption. Again, communities of faith don’t adopt; they encourage those who are adopted by God. In addition, adoptive ministry has implications for evangelism, for we also see all human beings as those whom God loves but are yet to be given the right to be God’s adopted children.

    Friend: What are the limitations to this metaphor that you want to name so that people don’t discredit it (as all metaphors have limits)?

    Chap: I honestly do not see any limitations at all, so long as we use the term adopted the way the Scriptures do. The fact is that moving from orphan to adopted child among other children is who we are in Christ (Matt. 12:48–50; John 1:12—two significant texts for this).

    Jesus

    Friend: Did Jesus use adoptive language? If so, how did he demonstrate it? I think of the moment at the cross where he gives John to his mother and his mother to John. Is that adoptive?

    Chap: I like that reference to John. And yes, in Matthew 12:48–50 when Mary and Jesus’s brothers came to speak to him, he said, “Who is my mother?” Also, in the passage on the sheep and goats in Matthew 25:40, where Jesus identifies with the vulnerable and those in need, he calls them his “brothers and sisters.” (Throughout most of church history it was taught that these had to be Christians because nonbelievers could not be his brothers and sisters. Dale Bruner in his Matthew commentary points out that the majority of current scholars affirm the universality of the sibling label; I agree, but mostly because the text is eschatological, so I refer to them as “imminent siblings,” like an acorn is an imminent oak tree.)

    Intergenerational versus Adoptive

    Friend: Is intergenerational . . . adoptive? And if not, what’s the difference?

    Chap: Intergenerational is a word we use programmatically, and maybe strategically (or perhaps missionally, although I don’t recall seeing it used that way). Adoptive encompasses intergenerational connectedness, but it goes way deeper and also reduces, if not removes, the generational hierarchy that can remain. A powerful force against adoptive ministry is generational, or positional, hierarchy. As siblings we are called to demonstrate respect and nurturing love toward one another, but our general rule of life together can be summed up in Philippians 2:3–4: “Do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit. Rather, in humility value others above yourselves, not looking to your own interests but each of you to the interests of the others.”

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑